Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Philosophical Test Drive
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, and welcome to Today's Explainer.
- 0:03We're doing something absolutely fascinating today.
- 0:05We're blending the bleeding edge of modern automotive tech with
- 0:09the deepest roots of human thought.
- 0:11I want you to imagine, just for a second, taking a brand new
- 0:14electric vehicle, pulling right up to the ancient academies of
- 0:17the past, and just tossing the keys to some of history's
- 0:20greatest thinkers. How would they react?
- 0:22Would they love it? Hate it?
- 0:23Well, by looking at this incredible modern marvel through
- 0:26the lens of classical philosophy, we can actually
- 0:28uncover a ton about why we make the everyday choices we do right
- 0:31now. O, let's take a quick jum in
- 0:34time, we're firing up our mental time machine to ask one
- 0:38beautifully weird question. What if the great philosophers
- 0:41actually drove an electric car? It's a brilliant mental
- 0:44exercise, really. And spoiler alert, out of the
- 0:47four brilliant minds we're looking at today, three of them
- 0:50wouldn't just appreciate an EV, they would absolutely fall in
- 0:53love with it. And it's all for reasons
- 0:55intimately tied to their specific core world views.
- 0:59Let's start things off with Epicurus and this whole idea of
- 1:02perfect silence. Now when you hear the word
- 1:05Epicurean, you probably picture, you know, decadent feasts,
- 1:08massive banquets, just total wild luxury.
- 1:11But actually, scratch that. Historically, Epicurus was after
- 1:14something much, much quieter. His entire philosophy revolved
- 1:18around this concept called ataraxia.
- 1:20Basically, it's the pursuit of pleasure achieved by completely
- 1:23eliminating disturbance, pain, and stress in the soul.
- 1:26To Epicurus, anything that caused unnecessary friction or
- 1:29annoyance was literally the enemy of a good life.
- 1:32So applying that to cars, think about a traditional internal
- 1:35combustion engine from an Epicurean perspective, a gas car
- 1:39is essentially a machine made of micro stresses.
- 1:42It's constantly vibrating, it's loud, and you've got continuous
- 1:45mechanical interruptions like gear shifts.
- 1:47But then you look at an electric motor, it is perfectly silent.
- 1:50It's fluid. It delivers the smooth, linear,
- 1:53uninterrupted power. And that brings us to another
- 1:56huge concept from Epicurus catastomatic pleasure.
- 1:59Think of this as a stable kind of pleasure, entirely free from
- 2:02anxiety spikes or sudden jolts. And EV is practically the
- 2:06ultimate physical manifestation of this exact idea.
- 2:10Epicurus would absolutely adore traveling in a vehicle that just
- 2:13glides in total silence, completely free from mechanical
- 2:17jolts. It would let him peacefully chat
- 2:19with his friends in his famous garden.
- 2:21Really, for him, the EV is the ultimate car of inner peace.
- 2:25All right, let's shift gears to our second passenger, Diogenes
- 2:28the Cynic. We're talking wild charging.
- 2:32Diogenes famously lived in a literal barrel on the streets of
- 2:35ancient Athens. He completely despised societal
- 2:38rules, wealth, the whole shebang.
- 2:40He lived strictly by the principle of autarkia, meaning
- 2:43absolute self-sufficiency and total independence from societal
- 2:46systems. So you kind of have to ask
- 2:48yourself, why on earth would a guy who aggressively rejected
- 2:51society ever embrace a highly complex modern technological
- 2:55object like an electric car? Well, it's actually pretty
- 2:58simple when you break it down. For Diogenes, driving a
- 3:01traditional gas car means you are completely tethered to the
- 3:04system. You're relying on global
- 3:06petroleum supply chains, messy geopolitics, and constant trips
- 3:10to the gas station. To him, that is flat out oil
- 3:13slavery. But an EV?
- 3:14Think about it, If Diogenes could just mount a solar panel
- 3:17right on top of his barrel, he could charge his vehicle using
- 3:20the pure free energy of the sun. He wouldn't owe a single dime to
- 3:24the system. It takes the electric vehicle
- 3:26and strips it right down to its ultimate expression of
- 3:29self-reliance. I mean, you can almost picture
- 3:31him right now sitting next to his solar powered barrel car,
- 3:34looking incredibly smug as traditional cars line up at a
- 3:36gas station just shouting. Look at them, slaves to the
- 3:40price per barrel. For Diogenes, the EV definitely
- 3:42isn't a luxury item. It's the ultimate tool of
- 3:45rebellion. Moving on to the 18th century,
- 3:48we have Immanuel Kant, the logical choice.
- 3:52Let's scale things up to the macro level here.
- 3:54Kant is the strict man of duty, cold logic and pure rationality.
- 3:59The absolute cornerstone of his ethics is the categorical
- 4:02imperative. In simple terms, before you do
- 4:04anything, you have to ask yourself, would the world still
- 4:07function logically if everyone on earth did exactly what I'm
- 4:10about to do? As Kant famously put it, act
- 4:14only according to that maxim, whereby you can at the same time
- 4:18will that it should become a universal law.
- 4:21So how does this 18th century logic apply to your daily
- 4:24commute? Well, Kant wouldn't approach the
- 4:27environmental impact of driving as some emotional plea.
- 4:30No, he'd view it as a strict, cold mathematical equation.
- 4:34First off, if everyone drives cars that pump toxic gas into
- 4:38crowded cities, the air eventually becomes unbreathable.
- 4:41For Kant, that's a blatant logical contradiction.
- 4:44You are literally destroying the very environment you need to
- 4:47survive. Therefore, the action is
- 4:48immoral. Period.
- 4:50Second, moving around while actively reducing your local
- 4:53impact that can be safely universalized.
- 4:55And finally, an electric motors incredible thermodynamic
- 4:58efficiency means it waste very little heat compared to a piston
- 5:01engine. To Kant, this isn't just good
- 5:03engineering, it is the literal triumph of practical reason.
- 5:06Kant chooses the EV because logically and morally it's the
- 5:09only universalizable choice. OK, but here comes our dramatic
- 5:13twist. Friedrich Nietzsche, the greatly
- 5:17disappointed. Right when we think we've got a
- 5:20complete philosophical consensus going, we hit a massive speed
- 5:23bump. Because Nietzsche.
- 5:25He would absolutely hate the electric vehicle.
- 5:27Seriously. Everything the other
- 5:29philosophers loved about it, he despises.
- 5:31To him, the silent, perfectly smooth ride of an EV is a weak,
- 5:35too human attempt to anesthetize life and strip away all the
- 5:39danger. He doesn't want peace and quiet.
- 5:41No way. He wants the visceral, brutal
- 5:44and almost threatening roar of a massive V8 gasoline engine, and
- 5:48this perfectly aligns with his core concept, the will to power.
- 5:52This is all about embracing raw power, danger, and what he
- 5:55called the untamed Dionysian spirit.
- 5:58AV8 engine roaring to life is aggressive, it's chaotic.
- 6:02It violently demands to be heard and felt.
- 6:05The extreme safety and calculated efficiency of an
- 6:07electric motor would feel to Nietzsche like a total
- 6:10suppression of humanity's rawest, most dominant instincts.
- 6:13He wants the fire, the noise and the fury.
- 6:16O what does this all mean for us?
- 6:19This brings us to the end of our test drive and leaves us with a
- 6:22really important question for you to ponder.
- 6:24Because this exlainer isn't just about history, it's about the
- 6:26mindset we carry with us today. When you look at the cars on the
- 6:30road, or even the ones sitting in your driveway right now,
- 6:32what's really guiding your preference?
- 6:35Are you seeking the peaceful, stress free autoraxia of
- 6:37Epicurus, the fierce off the grid rebellion of Diogenes, the
- 6:41strict universal logic of Kant? Or does the Dionysian roar of
- 6:45Nietzsche's will to power still call out to you?
- 6:47Think about it the next time you turn the key or you know, press
- 6:50the start button. Which philosopher is actually
- 6:52driving your choices? Thanks so much for joining me on
- 6:55this incredible journey through the mind, and I'll catch you on
- 6:57the next explainer.