Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / The Geopolitical Chessboard: Israel-Hamas, Biden, Putin, China, India-Canada & More With Irina Tsukerman
Transcript
- 0:20Welcome to the second to the third episode of The World
- 0:24According to Irena Superman, our very special series on global
- 0:28politics on the Kaj Master class Live.
- 0:31Irena Superman is a US based national security and human
- 0:34rights lawyer as well as a renowned geopolitical analyst.
- 0:38Her I Things and commentary have appeared in diverse US and
- 0:41international media and have been translated to over a dozen
- 0:45languages every fortnight in the world according to IRENA
- 0:49Superman, we traverse the geopolitical landscape and delve
- 0:52into pressing international issues and gain insight from
- 0:56Irena's expert perspective. Welcome to the show once again,
- 1:00IRENA. Thank you so much for for coming
- 1:04here. Thank you.
- 1:06Thank you. Welcome to the show once again.
- 1:08Welcome to India once again in this online form and I'm sure
- 1:12because we touch a lot of topics on India, we will be certainly
- 1:15talking about India and Canada today and also about the Bri.
- 1:22So first, but first to understand from you arena, you
- 1:24know what is happening in the world.
- 1:28We are seeing Biden moving, you know amidst the speech he goes
- 1:31back to the situation room. There is the news of of news
- 1:36reports about Putin's health and there is also the news report
- 1:39about China moving warships into that Middle East.
- 1:43So help us understand where are we going?
- 1:46Where is the world going? You know, a lot has happened in
- 1:49the last 15 days that we last talked.
- 1:52Well, I'll tell you, Putin is not going anywhere.
- 1:55The Kremlin already dismissed these rumors, and they've been
- 1:59persistently coming from the same sources, these sources
- 2:03being. Controlled opposition inside the
- 2:05country. Typically, a lot of
- 2:09authoritarian regimes use health issues as a way to kind of
- 2:15distract the West and with with, you know, just keep them busy
- 2:22with speculation, keep them, keep them.
- 2:27Not sure of the of the situation there and also to win out any
- 2:33potential opposition, like any real reaction, anybody trying to
- 2:38grab for power, especially on lower levels, the inner circles,
- 2:42the elites around Putin are loyal because he has already
- 2:46purged anyone who was critical from there.
- 2:51But on the external outer rings of power struggle, there can
- 2:56always be people. Looking to latch on to some
- 3:00rumour that he's not well and maybe make some power moves or
- 3:04try to play some political games.
- 3:06So, so this constant speculation, this is kind of
- 3:10used for for consolidating political control and also it's
- 3:17a distraction for the West. I think people should not take
- 3:20it too seriously. These rumours have been ongoing
- 3:23for years. There's absolutely no sign of
- 3:26flu. Down changing policies.
- 3:29There's no move to appoint a successor or to signal anybody
- 3:33who could potentially be a successor.
- 3:36There's nothing indicating a change in power.
- 3:39So all of these things speak to me much more closely about the
- 3:44stability of the internal situation, at least at the
- 3:47moment. And on the consolidation of
- 3:49power then all these health rumours and all these, you know,
- 3:53gossip stories, I think. I think that's all.
- 3:58No, this should be focused on. OK, so Putin is very much in the
- 4:03picture. What happens suddenly Biden goes
- 4:06back to the Situation Room, goes into the Situation Room, where
- 4:10the world wants to hear about his economic policy by dynamics,
- 4:13but he moves to the Situation Room.
- 4:16What do we read out of this? Is something very major
- 4:19happening? Is that world that does not know
- 4:22what is happening? You know in the in the Israel
- 4:26Hamas crisis, was it related to that?
- 4:28Was it related to something else?
- 4:30What is your understanding? I know it will be too much of
- 4:33any speculation, but just couldn't help asking on that.
- 4:36Well, actually there's multiple crises going on simultaneously.
- 4:41Ukraine, Russia, war is not nearly over, it continues.
- 4:48There's been some major developments in the last few
- 4:51days, major breakthroughs. At the same time, Israel is
- 4:55still looking to move forward with the ground effects in Gaza.
- 5:00the United States has tried to negotiate the release of
- 5:04hostages through Qatar from Gaza.
- 5:07So far it only succeeded in liberating 4 people, two of whom
- 5:12were American dual nationals, and there are all sorts of
- 5:17speculations about this Israel has accused Hamas of using.
- 5:23These hostages is a form of propaganda, propaganda effort to
- 5:28gain to to win time and strengthen their own position
- 5:33and avoid the ground offensive. There's been a major push to try
- 5:37to liberate foreign dual nationals, all fifty of them.
- 5:41Hamas ultimately rejected the deal and appears to still very
- 5:46much be in control of that situation.
- 5:49The rocket fire continues against Israel, and there's also
- 5:53increasing attempts at infiltration both from Gaza and
- 5:58also attacks from Hezbollah in the north.
- 6:02So I don't think the situation can keep going like that.
- 6:06For a long time, I think Israel will eventually go in in, and I
- 6:08think Hamas knows that. I think it's trying to buy time.
- 6:12I think it has no serious interest in releasing most of
- 6:16the hostages because that would mean losing its only real
- 6:20leverage. And what's to stop Israel from
- 6:22attacking after these hostages are all released?
- 6:25Nothing. So I I don't think Hamas has any
- 6:29incentive to set them free as any goodwill gesture or or
- 6:34anything. I I I don't think.
- 6:36That's going to stop Israel from attacking.
- 6:39So yeah, Biden has a lot on his plate at the moment.
- 6:41I think he's trying to calculate what can be done to avoid major
- 6:47losses, to create the most stable situation possible, to
- 6:52keep Iran out of more direct meddling.
- 6:55One major story that I think may explain his disappearance into
- 7:00the Situation Room is the announcement by the Pentagon
- 7:03that the US. Troops have been attacked at
- 7:05least 10 times since this conflict has started after
- 7:08warnings by various Iraqi militias and other groups in the
- 7:14region. This seems to be also an
- 7:16untenable situation. How long is the US going to let
- 7:19its own forces be attacked and only engage in defensive
- 7:24measures such as Downing of drones before it takes action in
- 7:29self defence? So I think that could be major
- 7:32part of the story here, right, Right.
- 7:36So in the Israel Hamas war, where are we heading?
- 7:42Is the worst behind us or is the worst still yet to come?
- 7:47And how that is a very big worry everywhere especially.
- 7:51And how do you read these reports of, you know, you China
- 7:56moving its warships that side? You, as already said, warned
- 8:00others that do not come into this conflict.
- 8:02Israel at the same time it is speaking in different languages.
- 8:07I am trying to understand for the audience, what does US want?
- 8:11Where does it position itself? It has got worship, It wants to
- 8:15talk. Bidens visit his speech there
- 8:18help us make sense. Even the UK has moved its ships
- 8:22and troops to that region he has visited.
- 8:26You know, Sunak has visited Saudi Arabia.
- 8:28So what is happening? I don't get it.
- 8:31You understand these things very well.
- 8:33Help us understand how should a person sitting far away in India
- 8:38understand what's happening? Well, there is a lot going on,
- 8:43but not all of it is all that mysterious US and UK.
- 8:47Are trying to keep Iran from directly meddling and they're
- 8:50trying to keep Hezbollah from escalating.
- 8:53So bringing in major warships is a is a deterrent sign to keep
- 8:59third parties out of the conflict and to try to mitigate
- 9:03this damage as much as possible. That doesn't mean that the that
- 9:08the situation is over Hezbollah is very much calculating its
- 9:11moves. A lot of will depend on how
- 9:14much. Success Israel encounters in
- 9:17Gaza, whether or not it will suffer heavy losses, and whether
- 9:20or not there'll be a lot of pressure from the international
- 9:23community, including the US, to cut the campaign short,
- 9:28depending on the number of civilian casualties.
- 9:31And since Israel has not even gotten in yet, and already there
- 9:37is a lot of pressure, we can see that Hezbollah will try to
- 9:40calculate how to. Use an opportunity to weaken
- 9:44Israel without also being completely decimated.
- 9:47In return, It may wait until Israel is sufficiently
- 9:51distracted with various infiltrations from Gaza and
- 9:54operations. By the way, not all Gaza Hamas
- 9:59terrorists have been caught or killed.
- 10:01Many of them are still roaming around the South and they could
- 10:04be anywhere at the moment and there are constant security
- 10:07incidents. Not, not, not as bad as before,
- 10:11but that doesn't mean that there isn't something else in the
- 10:14works. In terms of, in terms of the,
- 10:18you know, the Sunak visit, I think it's worth watching the
- 10:23fact that both US and UK supplied Israel with weapons for
- 10:28the first time in a very long time.
- 10:31US is resuming the production of the Iron Dome missiles because
- 10:36there is a very serious concern about.
- 10:38The existing arundoms being overwhelmed by rocket barrage,
- 10:42especially if Hezbollah does choose to get involved and I
- 10:46think UK is seriously concerned as well.
- 10:49The fact that Israel needs assistance from these two
- 10:52countries in receiving all these weapons speaks about the
- 10:56potential seriousness of a conflict.
- 10:59There are multiple other. I think it is involved.
- 11:02We have seen Houthis shoot missiles in the direction of
- 11:04Israel which were intercepted by the United States.
- 11:08It is clear that a multi front war is something that Israel
- 11:13would not necessarily be able to face alone, especially after the
- 11:19the apparent major blow to its military and intelligence
- 11:24services. It doesn't mean that they won't
- 11:27be cool and that they don't have sufficient.
- 11:30Equipment for certain times of operations.
- 11:32But if we are talking about a very long term effort with
- 11:35multiple actors that are very heavily armed, I think US and UK
- 11:40are very concerned about what that could mean, whether Iran
- 11:45will get involved directly and they want to make sure that
- 11:47Israel has everything it needs to withstand such an attack.
- 11:51The visit to Saudi Arabia was actually not particularly
- 11:55meaningful. It did not.
- 11:58In any breakthroughs, nor can we could we really expect anything.
- 12:02It's not like Saudi Arabia controls Hamas or controls
- 12:05Israel, or has any particular input other than pushing for an
- 12:11end to hostilities. At this point, I'm not even
- 12:14entirely sure what kind of reassurances either either the
- 12:18US or UK wants from Saudis at this point, other than them
- 12:24pulling their backing for Hamas. We have seen from the early
- 12:30statements which is which hasn't happened and the the only thing
- 12:35we can, you know, you can expect from them is to not get involved
- 12:39with Hamas which would be already something, something,
- 12:43something positive. At this point I don't think they
- 12:45have any intention of directly going in on either side.
- 12:49But it is concerning that some of the Saudi officials that have
- 12:54come out actually made excuses for.
- 12:57Hamas tried to blame this October 7th attack on on
- 13:03occupation. Gaza has been under complete
- 13:05Hamas control since 2005, and no occupation could justify attacks
- 13:10on civilians regardless. So all of this is not really,
- 13:14you know, looking particularly well.
- 13:16But I don't think Saudi Arabia will have a very significant
- 13:20role to play in the near future at least.
- 13:24With respect to China, that is a much more concerning development
- 13:29than the Riyadh because China can have a major, major role in
- 13:35assisting in in Iran in these operations.
- 13:38It can do so in two ways. First, without even going as far
- 13:43as the Middle East, it could use this opportunity with actually
- 13:49devastating the Strait of Hormuz, disrupting international
- 13:53trade. Meanwhile, China could block the
- 13:58passageway through the South China Sea, so we could be facing
- 14:01a double blockade. We could also be potentially
- 14:04seeing various aggressive incidents involving various.
- 14:09The neighbours, we could potentially see an attack on
- 14:11Taiwan. We have just seen China arrest a
- 14:14Japanese executive under, you know, trumped up charges of
- 14:19espionage, which does not bode well.
- 14:22If China is starting to engage in this political hostage taking
- 14:26of its rivals under various pretext, we could see an
- 14:32escalation occurring that could result in some acts of covert
- 14:36action of aggression of minor. Isymmetrical warfare, more
- 14:41serious incidents, cyber, cyber wars and things like that.
- 14:44So this is a really very concerning sign, the fact that
- 14:48it's moving ships to the Middle East as a counterpoint to the US
- 14:52and the UK. This is escalating tensions and
- 14:55it's actually escalating situation in the Middle East and
- 15:00it's showing China's interest in the situation and it's clearly
- 15:05also back in Hamas. So we are seeing this.
- 15:08That China is looking to turn this into a proxy conflict for
- 15:12its own interest in the Middle East which have been growing.
- 15:15And up until this point, while China has been selling
- 15:18surveillance technology and it's been renting out land in Iran,
- 15:25and it's been doing a lot of projects with various GCC States
- 15:31and. Taking control of some of the
- 15:33infrastructure, it has not yet been openly militant in that
- 15:38area. It has not yet built any
- 15:40significant bases in that particular region.
- 15:43The fact that it's moving ships is the first really very open
- 15:47sign of asserting military interests in a way that's also
- 15:53directly antagonistic to the United States and.
- 15:58It's a hostile move to move the ships there at the time.
- 16:02It's also like it's also outright meddling in this
- 16:05conflict in this way beyond its apologetics and political
- 16:11legitimacy to Hamas, beyond the anti-Semitic and anti Israel
- 16:15propaganda in its newspapers quite open this time.
- 16:19This is a really serious escalation and I do think that
- 16:23we should be very concerned about it.
- 16:27And he's a rational actor. It is not necessarily going to
- 16:30do anything without calculating it very carefully.
- 16:34I don't believe that we should be expecting a kind of very
- 16:38reckless confrontation initially or any sort of provocative
- 16:41incidents. But they even the fact that it's
- 16:44just moving the ships in that area, that in itself is just
- 16:48showcasing how much reach China feels it has and how much in
- 16:53power it thinks it has in the Middle East from.
- 16:57And mediated to now actually intervening in 3rd party
- 17:01conflicts. So that's a that's a really big,
- 17:03big change in in a very short period of time.
- 17:06Absolutely, absolutely. One thing I wanted to understand
- 17:09for the audience is that, you know, US is a, as we said, US is
- 17:15always under the thinking that somebody, someone may attack its
- 17:19troops down in the Middle East or in that region.
- 17:22Who will attack U.S. troops in that region?
- 17:26What is the fear that they have got because they are there for
- 17:29some deterrence. And so do you think is it it is
- 17:33a realistic scene? Who could be the players here?
- 17:36Secondly, you know, Putin recently visited China.
- 17:40Apart from the what what they have said in public, what do you
- 17:43think they would have talked behind the scenes?
- 17:46What is it that they want from each other?
- 17:48What is it that they want to gather from the world?
- 17:53In terms of attacks, well, US has already been attacked by
- 17:58Iraqi militias and multiple times and it has taken no
- 18:01measures to defendants of in the past, Iran.
- 18:04Iran has actually attacked US drones and US has faced
- 18:10harassment by RGC boats. U.S.
- 18:13Navy is no match for Iran. I do not expect a very serious
- 18:18attack. I do.
- 18:18Can we can expect electronic jamming?
- 18:22You can expect maybe drone related incidents, things like
- 18:25that, not anything serious, but but even incidental provocative
- 18:33actions can get out of control. So we can have an accidental
- 18:37incidental escalation, with Iran and China weighing in IS also.
- 18:43This is also most definitely not a good sign.
- 18:47Anytime you have an aggressive confrontation, there's always a
- 18:50chance that something could go wrong if there's no even if
- 18:53there's no deliberate effort to escalate.
- 18:56I don't think China is looking for direct confrontation with
- 19:00the US, but do think they want to limit what US can do and how
- 19:04much defence it can offer Israel.
- 19:06In fact, China is openly siding with Hamas and with Iran by
- 19:10doing so. I think it's a very clear sign.
- 19:13I think it's very concerning. I don't think we necessarily are
- 19:16facing a major conflagration in the near future.
- 19:20But I do think that if Iran directly attacks the USUS or
- 19:27Iran directly attacks Israel, US will be forced to fire back.
- 19:31And then there's no no telling what can happen in terms of
- 19:36Putin's visits to China. I think they have a lot to talk
- 19:42about actually managing their spheres of interest in the
- 19:45Middle East and in Africa, for instance.
- 19:48On the one hand, they're quite complementary to each other.
- 19:51They play different roles in both spheres.
- 19:55They're not necessarily in conflict, despite both having
- 20:01significant ambitions. But they do need to figure out
- 20:05how to manage some of these. Developments because there is no
- 20:10clear end game. China has aspirations of
- 20:14building additional bases. Russia would access and control
- 20:19to whispers and there than else. That's not going to happen
- 20:22anytime in the near future. It cannot.
- 20:26It does not. It just can't fight with with
- 20:30Turkey over that. It has no power to do that.
- 20:33There is the situation with Syria that I think is of utmost
- 20:36interest to both countries. They're looking to capitalize on
- 20:41the current chaos. We have seen Russia engage in
- 20:45serious defence maneuvers with the Syrian military.
- 20:49China has been holding talks insides about reconstruction,
- 20:54about control economy, sanctions, all sorts of things.
- 20:59Possible possible talks of a future military base somewhere
- 21:04near Syria. If that is the case, then Russia
- 21:07and China do have to negotiate that because Russia has also
- 21:11been viewing the same area for potential Navy bases.
- 21:14It's looking to build a base in the Black Sea as well, which
- 21:20would mean a permanent infringed Russian maritime presence in the
- 21:24Black Sea. A few things things are going on
- 21:28with that, of course. The war in Ukraine remains a
- 21:31factor. There is still not a significant
- 21:34enough move for either side to prevail.
- 21:38Russia is looking to circumvent sanctions.
- 21:41Russia and China involved in many joint projects.
- 21:44Bricks is one of them. Of course, the Shanghai
- 21:48Cooperation Organization And generally bilateral activities
- 21:54to circumvent sanctions to sell oil, energy, trade chips, the
- 22:01chips war with the United States.
- 22:03The IBM has just made a major, major breakthrough that puts the
- 22:08US and its allies far ahead in the AI chips game.
- 22:13That's a major blow to China and Russia, who have been struggling
- 22:16to keep up with that. China has been making some
- 22:19progress, but not yet sufficiently not sufficient to
- 22:23prevail in that battle. So I'm sure all of these things
- 22:28are on the table. Economic incentives, cooperation
- 22:33and China's only interest. China has announced the pressure
- 22:37would be its partner in any future action against Japan and
- 22:42South Korea, possibly Taiwan. So we can expect that these sort
- 22:46of conversations are happening and certainly the Israel Hamas
- 22:51war and its impact on the Middle East, on the economic reality in
- 22:55the Middle East are of major interest and concern to both
- 22:59countries. They have shown no secret of
- 23:02having interest in Israel, economic, social, political, but
- 23:07also actually hedging their bets more towards Hamas for various
- 23:11reasons and of course aligning with Iran and other countries.
- 23:14So I think that would very much be a subject of discussion,
- 23:20general anti Western positioning, possible
- 23:24cooperation on other fronts, increasing intelligence,
- 23:28increasing cybersecurity cooperation which have been
- 23:31rising, but perhaps there's always room for more.
- 23:34There's still a lot of distrust on a tactical level between the
- 23:39two countries. So they have to balance this
- 23:41historic and tactical distrust with the strategic strategic
- 23:46interest in opposing the West as much as possible and
- 23:50infiltrating politically in different countries as much as
- 23:53possible. Right, Rena, I want to
- 23:57understand the Middle East crisis, has it come?
- 24:01No crisis is good, but is it a very bad time for the crisis to
- 24:08happen? Or it could have happened
- 24:09another time? The reason is that a lot of
- 24:12countries are they have elections coming up in the US,
- 24:16Russia, Egypt. You know, and and even in
- 24:20Poland, so a lot of countries which are part of this whole
- 24:25dealing, China is dealing with its own own economic problems.
- 24:29So will they be looking at it purely from, you know, taking
- 24:35care of their domestic problems, domestic issues, trying to, you
- 24:40know, address the audience back home and rather not looking at
- 24:45things on the ground? From trying to solve the
- 24:47problem, I want to understand, will politics override all the
- 24:52concerns, humanitarian concerns and everything?
- 24:55Or is it? Is it that it will still be a
- 24:59good politics that we will be seeing?
- 25:02Well, I don't believe, I don't believe in coincidences.
- 25:05I don't believe that these things are planned just randomly
- 25:09or without a reason. I do think that all these
- 25:13elections and all these things are taken into consideration.
- 25:17I think it's also beneficial to Russia because it distracts from
- 25:21the war in Ukraine and it splits.
- 25:25It splits interest and support for the war in Ukraine,
- 25:30especially among Republicans who were already skeptical providing
- 25:35for the funding for weapons to begin with.
- 25:38Now there's an effort to connect Ukraine aid bill to Israel,
- 25:42which is facing opposition. Some of the Republicans want
- 25:45separate bills. The Democrats obviously opposed,
- 25:49so there's no telling what's going to happen with that,
- 25:52especially without the speaker. We We've got a fourth nominee
- 25:56from the GOP in in three weeks who he's very unlikely to get
- 26:02the majority needed to become the speakers.
- 26:05There's no telling what will happen after that and he's
- 26:09pretty anti Ukraine. Mike Johnson.
- 26:13So, so so yeah in Poland we have seen a very fragile coalition
- 26:18emerge as a result of the tasks party come into power.
- 26:23They are known to have been very on very good terms with the
- 26:29European Union, which on the surface would position the
- 26:32European Union to further strengthen its alliance against
- 26:35Russia. But in reality the party is
- 26:37actually has significant Russian connections.
- 26:40It has been smearing the previous law, ruling Law and
- 26:44Justice Party and coming up with all sorts of active, very active
- 26:53positions against it in this evidence of Russian the measures
- 26:58being involved in all of that. So Poland is becoming, you know,
- 27:02an unstable political situation in Poland.
- 27:06Even if Task party does not prevail on most of its
- 27:09initiatives, it benefits Russia. And this kind of situation also
- 27:16creates a great deal of uncertainty on the policy level.
- 27:20Regarding Ukraine, Poland has been one of the chief
- 27:24contributors to to Ukraine, and though its capacity is currently
- 27:30limited by its own security needs, it still has shown a lot
- 27:34of a great deal of support. What happens if it transitions
- 27:40to some something else or it doesn't?
- 27:44If the coalition is so is too weak to actually be of any
- 27:52significant leadership on this issue?
- 27:54What happens if Russia starts pushing more aggressively
- 27:59against Polish borders with the refugees and various
- 28:03destabilizing activities and there's a lot of infighting in
- 28:06the government. There's no telling it.
- 28:08Egypt is also at the precarious point as a result of the Gaza
- 28:13situation. They're being, you know, there's
- 28:15a lot of pressure to provide aid.
- 28:18They cannot take any refugees from Gaza, but there is a lot of
- 28:22conflict around this issue and the situation is very, very
- 28:28unstable. There's an economic crisis in
- 28:30Egypt already. The fact that Israel has had to
- 28:34cut off gas exploration, which was a significant economic
- 28:38contributing factor to Egypt, is definitely very bad.
- 28:43This means that there's going to be more pressure on President
- 28:46Sisi by various elements which have already been rebel rousing
- 28:51to begin with and trying to exploit this economic crisis.
- 28:55We are seeing the turn of Islamists all over the region.
- 28:59All of that is quite clear. Russia's elections, I don't
- 29:03expect much to change as a result.
- 29:05It's not really going to be a very democratic election, but
- 29:09there is going to be likely some sort of a crackdown before the
- 29:12elections to avoid controversy and just as an opportunity to
- 29:17consolidate power. So we can expect to see some of
- 29:20that. And of course in the US it's a
- 29:22complete disaster. Trump is still very much a
- 29:27leading nominee among Republicans.
- 29:29What happens if he does not prevail on his legal charges?
- 29:34There's no way of telling whether Republicans will
- 29:38nominate somebody else. And if that.
- 29:40And if that's so, who would that be?
- 29:42Would they go according to the current polls?
- 29:45How would all of that turn out doing primaries?
- 29:47We have yet to understand Biden. On the one hand, his support is
- 29:52rising as a result of his actions on the front.
- 29:58But he is also has a lot of challenges to overcome, such as
- 30:05the economy, inflation, the rising fuel fuel prices and and
- 30:11his age remains a factor that is no less concerning now than it
- 30:16was before the war. We're still seeing the southern
- 30:20border crisis to continue. There's a rising concern about
- 30:23potential terrorist attacks in the US after recent threats, and
- 30:29there's a great deal of political instability at home.
- 30:33So all of that is a very convenient political context for
- 30:37the terrorists and for Hamas, and certainly for the backers
- 30:42that such as Iran, Who benefits from this exploitation of
- 30:47political instability in the stacking of crisis.
- 30:50The more crisis that you have, the less there, less anyone can
- 30:55really manage them, and everyone gets distracted by a
- 31:00proliferation of crisis. So the more crisis you have, the
- 31:04more crisis you can create. Right, right.
- 31:08Amidst all these things, there was this China Belt and Road
- 31:12summit and that is when Putin visited a lot of other
- 31:15countries. Visited India, did not go for
- 31:18the third time 2017, nineteen and this time help us understand
- 31:24what is happening there will which side where is this whole
- 31:28thing going about the Belt Road and India obviously has its own
- 31:32issues, sovereignty issues in terms of you know whether it is
- 31:36a good viable thing for the Chinese to go for that because
- 31:41you know a lot of this is coming through Pakistan occupied.
- 31:44So all those things help us understand how this thing is
- 31:47panning out, whether you know, how should we understand it,
- 31:53this whole thing going on, whether India, how should India
- 31:57engage with the Middle East corridor that that sort also is
- 32:02a big question mark for us. Well, in terms of China, this
- 32:05part is significant and growing economic problems.
- 32:09It's still pushing forward with all these projects because it's
- 32:13going to try to project power no matter what happens.
- 32:16Internal. We have seen the same thing, the
- 32:18Soviet Union, with Iran, with Russia.
- 32:21All these countries have horrible internal economic
- 32:25situations, but they are continuing onwards with
- 32:30projecting global power and spending money elsewhere.
- 32:33That creates even more internal instability.
- 32:36Eventually, with some push, such regimes can collapse, or they
- 32:42can be overtaken by internal cool and end up in some other
- 32:46direction. But unless, But right now, we're
- 32:50not nearly at that point yet, and certainly not not with
- 32:53China, which is actually still the most powerful of all these
- 32:59actors. And as bad as the situation is
- 33:02internally, it still has plenty towards towards such projects
- 33:08and it's still continuing with that, with that path and it's
- 33:11still trying to project influence and a lot of countries
- 33:15are still very dependent on it. So let's not forget that it does
- 33:18have its leverage for now. It hasn't.
- 33:22It's not like it has lost all its fears of influence, all of
- 33:25its our eyes and proxies and so forth.
- 33:29In fact, in some areas, it's actually growing and succeeding
- 33:33quite a lot and its industrial espionage machinery is also
- 33:38quite functional. So I think that is not going to
- 33:41be resolved anytime soon. I do think that India is in an
- 33:45increasingly beneficial position with China, simply because China
- 33:50is mismanaging so much of its own internal affairs and because
- 33:55some countries are becoming concerned of being dependent on
- 33:59China. If it cannot carry through its
- 34:01promises of investments. I think that's where India and
- 34:05some of its allies can have a positive long term impact on
- 34:09networking, but military operations, but simply economic
- 34:12investments being seen as a more stable place, a place for doing
- 34:17business, investing in other countries and having just you
- 34:21know other options besides China, I think that alone could
- 34:26could very positive. With regards to the Middle East
- 34:30corridor, I don't really see any movement.
- 34:33The corridor itself was not clearly defined to begin with,
- 34:36which was a major mistake similar to what happened with
- 34:39Abraham Accords. Abraham Accords was at least
- 34:42temporarily beneficial as a trade value, but as soon as
- 34:46things went awry, we saw Middle Eastern countries rollback their
- 34:50products from Israel. We've seen a lot of things
- 34:53collapse very quickly. So I think unless there's a very
- 34:57clear definition of mutual obligations towards this Middle
- 35:02Eastern corridor, I don't think it's going to go very far and
- 35:05certainly not if some of the parties end up being subsumed
- 35:09with other problems. And right now we are facing this
- 35:13very immediate test to the situation, the exact sort of
- 35:17thing I was worried about before all of that happened.
- 35:20If you recall that this this exact thing happened just now,
- 35:25this Hamas got operation is really going to challenge this
- 35:32commitment because this corridor was supposed to be partially
- 35:36tied to Israel. There's no telling where it's
- 35:40all going to go now that Israel is occupied with the war.
- 35:45Other Middle Eastern states are withdrawing from Israel.
- 35:50Saudi Arabia is, I don't know, dealing with Qatar and Iran,
- 35:55which is not something that India necessarily is positive
- 36:00for it. I think Iran's been causing some
- 36:03level of problems even in India and Qatar has been finding all
- 36:07sorts of Islamist movements. So I think all of these things,
- 36:10these political issues need to be discussed and resolved before
- 36:14moving forward with significant financial commitments towards
- 36:18projects. Because otherwise it's going to
- 36:20be huge waste of money that's, you know, at best going to be
- 36:24either a cheap PR effort or, you know, if there is a significant
- 36:29financial commitment, it can go to waste and be easily disrupted
- 36:33by all these political factors. I think this is a good time to
- 36:37kind of try to figure out what is going on, sit down and have
- 36:41adult conversations with substance and not just something
- 36:45that's done to show that, you know, there's diplomatic
- 36:49breakthroughs in election years for various countries.
- 36:53Absolutely, absolutely. And talking of India.
- 36:56Why? Why we not talk about India,
- 36:58Canada issue? Where do you think this is
- 37:01going? There the opposition is saying
- 37:04that you know to do has made Canada or himself a laughing
- 37:08stock among Indians. Obviously a lot of Indians try
- 37:11to understand what was the reason of all that allegation.
- 37:15Now the situation stands, you know, at a difficult situation.
- 37:18How do you see it? Where will it end?
- 37:21Will it end soon or it will take a long time?
- 37:24Where I and to be, I mean, on the one hand, India has ended up
- 37:29expelling a lot of Canadian diplomats, which is a major,
- 37:33major diplomatic escalation. On the other hand, nobody is
- 37:37particularly happy with Trudeau about this, not even people who
- 37:40actually thought he he had the points to begin with or who
- 37:43agreed with his assessment over the situation.
- 37:47Even they think that the escalation should be avoided,
- 37:50even if Trudeau was initially right.
- 37:53And I tend to agree with that, because I really don't think
- 37:56this having a huge political fight over that one guy right
- 38:01now is in in anyone's best interest.
- 38:03I think absolutely everyone, including Canada, has much
- 38:06bigger problems at the moment and I think this is, this is a
- 38:10big distraction from resolving those issues.
- 38:12Now. What opportunity there is to
- 38:16move forward, I think probably be best handled behind the
- 38:19scenes. Just have a discussion agreed to
- 38:24have some framework for resolving security related
- 38:28issues going moving forward, put this incident aside and just
- 38:33kind of just move on. I mean this diplomats have been
- 38:36expelled. I'm not entirely sure who wants
- 38:39what from anyone at this point. And I think it's just at this
- 38:43point there's no real resolution.
- 38:46It's just, you know, you need to, everyone needs to move on if
- 38:51they want to resolve it at all. I think the best thing that's
- 38:54come out of it is some framework for cooperation.
- 38:58Maybe some specific agreements to do certain things, goodwill
- 39:03gestures with the results to with regards to priority issues
- 39:07for such for both countries to to to have some positive outcome
- 39:14out of all of this. That's what I would do if I were
- 39:16in in that position. But of course I'm not Trudeau
- 39:19and I cannot advise him on. I don't think he would listen.
- 39:23But I I I do think that continuing this diplomatic
- 39:30standoff, while there's multiple global conflicts, there's likely
- 39:35to be a very significant economic impact from all of
- 39:37this. There is the, the China
- 39:40situation that's assorted other things.
- 39:42I just don't think it's very helpful.
- 39:44It's not productive and it's not really helping anybody.
- 39:48And I do think that there are serious security issues that
- 39:51need to be resolved. Canada has a particular approach
- 39:55towards all of them. You know, some say that India
- 40:01should be more. Open to what happens in other
- 40:04countries, since that doesn't, you know, directly concern.
- 40:07What happens in Canada does not directly concern that.
- 40:10But if those in the future, if, if there are concerns about any
- 40:16particular Canadian extremists or opposition members or
- 40:20whatever, I think extradition demands are probably a good way
- 40:25to prevent, you know, these misunderstandings from
- 40:30occurring. That's my personal opinion.
- 40:33I think. I think having this very clear
- 40:36communication path towards making these demands and putting
- 40:41your concerns on records will eliminate accusations of
- 40:45meddling and so forth in the future.
- 40:48If you say, well, we've tried to do this, this and that, and why
- 40:51don't you listen? You will have a very legitimate
- 40:54and clear case and it will be very how to make an issue out of
- 40:58that in the future. Unfortunately, I think I I think
- 41:03this, I do think that these ongoing global issues are likely
- 41:08to displace the scandal, which I think is best for everybody if
- 41:11it just kind of goes away. I think right now it's just not
- 41:16it's not helpful. Absolutely, Absolutely talking.
- 41:21We just talked about elections. Even in Pakistan, elections are
- 41:24very much around the corner. And at this point, Nawaz Sharif,
- 41:28the former Prime Minister, is back.
- 41:30And as they say in Pakistan, nothing moves, you know
- 41:35anything. Nothing moves without the
- 41:38consent of the army. Nawaz Sharif did not have a
- 41:40great relationship with the army.
- 41:42Now he is back. How does this look like?
- 41:45What will happen? What is going to happen?
- 41:48Will it lead Pakistan out of crisis or is it going to be a
- 41:52much more different affairs that Pakistan will have to deal with?
- 41:57Well, Nawaz Sharif is still dealing with his corruption
- 42:00related investigations and problems.
- 42:03I mean that would not be the first time every single Prime
- 42:07Minister Pakistan has ever had had either gone to prison or had
- 42:11to resign over corruption related allegations.
- 42:14I don't think there are any winners there.
- 42:16I think there will. The entire system is incorrupt.
- 42:20So it's not possible for anyone not corrupt to even come to
- 42:23power. I think.
- 42:27I don't think US particularly thinks the truth would be
- 42:31helpful towards Pakistan's economic issues.
- 42:34I don't think somebody like him has any new vision that would
- 42:38radically change the the current status quo.
- 42:41That said, I think the current set of characters there is not
- 42:45likely to resolve those things either.
- 42:47Nor do I think Imran Khan contributed much.
- 42:50So any of that. I think he only made Pakistan
- 42:53more dependent on China and Russia and distance from the
- 42:57West. So I, I, I really don't think
- 43:00anything is going to change until there is a popular push to
- 43:04minimize military involvement in political affairs and push for
- 43:08the resolution of extremist social and political issues of
- 43:13sort of extremism and involvement of various foreign
- 43:16countries and all sorts of, you know, very controversial
- 43:23security apparatus, involvement in politics until all of that is
- 43:28resolved is going to continue like this.
- 43:31I don't see any reasons for it to change.
- 43:34You cannot have a country with this structure that functions
- 43:37properly. This the entire political
- 43:39structure is deeply flawed and the entire political structure
- 43:43is rife with exploitation, corruption, meddling from
- 43:47security, mishandling various extremist factions, tribal
- 43:53issues. All of that is not is not
- 43:57resolvable one unless you have good leadership, good political
- 44:00structure in the system that promotes problem solving and not
- 44:04these endless cycles of mismanagement.
- 44:08Absolutely. There is so much happening in
- 44:11the world, isn't it, Irena? And you have summed up all these
- 44:16things very, very well. Help us.
- 44:18Understand what is going behind the scenes in all that is
- 44:22happening or all that we see happening in the world.
- 44:25We'll thank you very much for that.
- 44:27And we'll soon be back again with another episode of The
- 44:31World According to Irina Superman.
- 44:33Thank you once again. So thank you so much.
- 44:36Appreciate this opportunity. And.