Latest / Deep Dive / The Value Creation Illusion: Why Customers Never Buy Features
Transcript
- 0:00All right, let's dive right into this explainer and look at how
- 0:02to build things that people actually want to buy.
- 0:05We spend a tremendous amount of time, energy, and money trying
- 0:09to bring new ideas into the world.
- 0:10But have you ever felt that visceral, crushing pain of
- 0:13spending months or maybe even years building a product,
- 0:16pouring your absolute heart into it, only to launch it to
- 0:19absolute crickets? It's devastating.
- 0:22Well, today we're going to unpack exactly why that happens
- 0:25and much more importantly, how you can stop doing it.
- 0:28It's a pretty brutal question, right?
- 0:30But whether you're an academic theorist maing out global
- 0:32markets or a Startu founder trying to just get your very
- 0:35first customer, our economic theories and our everyday
- 0:37conversational habits often set us U to fail from day one.
- 0:41We really think we're doing the right things.
- 0:43We talk to people, we build exactly what they say they want,
- 0:46and we launch. But in reality, we're gathering
- 0:49terrible data and operating on completely faulty logic.
- 0:52You see it all the time. A brilliant founder builds an
- 0:55amazing tech platform because 50 people swore it sounded like a
- 0:57great idea. But when it's time to actually
- 1:00pay, nobody pulls out their wallet.
- 1:02That is the exact trap we're dismantling.
- 1:04Today. We're going to take a Zoom in
- 1:05approach today. We'll start with a macro level
- 1:08academic theory of how economies function and drive all the way
- 1:11down to the micro level of a casual coffee shop conversation.
- 1:14Here's our road map. 1st, the illusion of value.
- 1:17Then rethinking the market paradigm, followed by passing
- 1:20the MOM test, deflecting bad data, and finally finding the
- 1:24real truth. To get started, we need to
- 1:26completely shatter a massive illusion.
- 1:28This idea that businesses fail simply because they don't market
- 1:31their goods hard enough. Let's get into Section 1, the
- 1:34illusion of value and why our paradigms and questions fail us.
- 1:38This illusion actually traces back to a dense but incredibly
- 1:41powerful academic defense of service dominant Logic by Robert
- 1:45Lousch and Steven Vargo. They argue that traditional
- 1:48marketing has historically focused on completely the wrong
- 1:51things. You see, we inherited this
- 1:53mindset from classical economics and the industrial revolution.
- 1:56Back then, it was all about factories pumping out widgets.
- 1:59We got completely obsessed with tangible goods, units of output,
- 2:03and this highly flawed idea that simply manufacturing something
- 2:05on an assembly line inherently creates value.
- 2:08But that view misses the entire point of why people actually buy
- 2:11things. Think of the contrast like this.
- 2:14Traditional goods dominant logic focuses on pushing tangible
- 2:17output out into the world. Basically assuming value is
- 2:20manufactured in a factory, service dominant logic flips the
- 2:24script entirely. It suggests that what we're
- 2:27actually exchanging in an economy isn't stuff, but rather
- 2:30applied knowledge and skills. Think about buying a car.
- 2:33You aren't just buying a hunk of steel and rubber.
- 2:35You're buying the application of decades of automotive
- 2:38engineering to give you the service of mobility.
- 2:41Let's see how this builds into a totally transcending framework
- 2:44in Section 2, Rethinking the Market Paradigm.
- 2:46All economies are service economies, so the crucial point
- 2:50to grasp here is that service isn't just a sector of the
- 2:53economy like hospitality or consulting.
- 2:55According to Lush and Vargo, it is the fundamental basis of all
- 2:58economic exchange. Let's break that down and really
- 3:01let it sink in. Even if you are manufacturing a
- 3:03physical, tangible product, that product is merely a distribution
- 3:07mechanism for service provision. The true exchange taking place
- 3:10is the application of specialized competences, your
- 3:13knowledge and your skills through deeds, processes, and
- 3:16performances, all for the benefit of someone else.
- 3:19What this means is your enterprise can only make value
- 3:21propositions. It's the end customer who
- 3:23actually decides if any value was created based entirely on
- 3:26how it fits into their everyday life.
- 3:28You just do not create value in a vacuum.
- 3:31Value is experiential and uniquely determined by the
- 3:33beneficiary. If they don't see the benefit,
- 3:35the value literally does not exist, no matter how many cool
- 3:38cutting edge features your engineering team crammed into
- 3:41the product. If the whole economy is based on
- 3:44benefiting the customer, how do we actually find out what they
- 3:47need without ruining our data? Let's zoom in for Section 3,
- 3:51Passing the mom test from macro theory to micro reality.
- 3:55Now we transition from high level academia down to Rob
- 3:58Fitzpatrick's highly practical guide.
- 4:01This teaches us that you shouldn't ask anyone if your
- 4:03business is a good idea. Seriously.
- 4:05Not even your own mother? Let's say you have a brilliant
- 4:07idea for a digital cookbook app. If you ask your mom if it's a
- 4:10good idea, she'll tell you it's amazing.
- 4:12Why? Because people are nice and she
- 4:14loves you. She will lie to you the most to
- 4:16protect your feelings, but practically everyone else is
- 4:19going to lie to you at least a little bit too.
- 4:21It's not your mom's job to tell you the truth.
- 4:23It's your job to go find it. Fitzpatrick uses this fantastic
- 4:27analogy. The fragile truth of what a
- 4:28customer actually values is buried deep under the surface.
- 4:33If you use the bulldozer of a heavy-handed sales pitch, you'll
- 4:35smash it to pieces. Picture yourself as an
- 4:38archaeologist. If you go in asking do you think
- 4:41my idea is good, you're basically handing the customer
- 4:43dynamite. You're forcing them to say
- 4:45something nice, effectively blowing U the very artifacts.
- 4:48Those real genuine customer pain points you desperately need to
- 4:51uncover. To dig U that truth safely,
- 4:54you've got to follow the three core rules of the MOM test.
- 4:57These force you to objectively study the customer's actual
- 5:00reality rather than seeking ego validation for your grand idea.
- 5:04First, never talk about your idea.
- 5:06Talk about their life. Second, ask about specific
- 5:09things they've done in the past. Why does this matter so much?
- 5:12Because we are famously terrible at predicting our own future
- 5:15behavior. Anything involving the future is
- 5:17an over optimistic lie, but our past actions are concrete facts.
- 5:21And 3rd, talk less and listen more.
- 5:24But hey, even when we try to follow the rules, conversations
- 5:27can go way off track. That brings us to Section 4.
- 5:31Deflecting bad data. Navigating the noise.
- 5:34Bad customer conversations are exceptionally dangerous because
- 5:38they give you false positives. You have to actively watch out
- 5:41for three things. Compliments wrapped like a gift,
- 5:44generic fluff up in the clouds, and unprompted feature ideas
- 5:48that will completely drain your time and budget.
- 5:50False positives convince you that you're on the right path
- 5:52when you are actually miles off course.
- 5:54You have to learn to identify this bad date of the exact
- 5:57second it enters the conversation.
- 6:00Compliments are the most deceitful data of all because
- 6:03people genuinely just want to protect your feelings.
- 6:05When you hear one. Use a quick three-step workflow
- 6:08to deflect it and get back to gathering facts.
- 6:11If someone says oh wow I love it, that sounds amazing, do not
- 6:14take it to the bank. Catch yourself, say whoops I'm
- 6:17sorry I totally slipped into pitch mode there for a second.
- 6:19Let's get back to how you currently handle this task.
- 6:22Boom, you deflect the compliment and anchor them firmly back to
- 6:25their actual everyday workflow. Now let's look at how we
- 6:28actually engineer our questions to strip away these illusions of
- 6:31value in Section 5, Finding the real truth, The anatomy of a
- 6:35question. By breaking down common bad
- 6:38questions, it becomes super clear that fishing for opinions
- 6:41or future promises will only blind you to what the market
- 6:44actually needs. Think about asking, do you think
- 6:46it's a good idea? That's just self indulgent
- 6:49noise. Now compare that to asking would
- 6:51you pay $40.00 for a product that did this?
- 6:54This one is a total trap. It feels like a highly rigorous
- 6:57data point because you included a specific number, right?
- 7:00But it's still just a hypothetical.
- 7:02People don't know what they'll actually do in the future,
- 7:04they're just telling you what they think you want to hear.
- 7:07Instead of asking those hypothetical bad questions, ask
- 7:10a good question about their current workflow, because how
- 7:13they deal with a problem today reveals the exact price, anchor,
- 7:16and effort they are willing to spend.
- 7:19If you ask how are you dealing with it now and they tell you
- 7:21they send three hours every single Friday manually copying
- 7:24data into a sreadsheet, well, you've just found a real
- 7:27validated problem with a high effort cost attached to it.
- 7:31Because at the end of the day, opinions are worthless.
- 7:33Only the market can tell you if your idea is good.
- 7:36Meaning you must gather concrete facts and commitments instead of
- 7:39relying on the biased opinions of the people around you.
- 7:42Remember our macro theory from earlier?
- 7:44The beneficiary is the sole judge of value.
- 7:46You cannot define their problems for them, and they cannot design
- 7:49the ultimate solution for you. Your job is to humbly gather
- 7:52facts about their life and then take a visionary leap to build a
- 7:55solution that actually serves them.
- 7:58You now possess both the macro service dominant mindset of the
- 8:01academic and the micro conversational tools of the
- 8:03street Smart founder to find out what people actually need.
- 8:07So get out there and start excavating.
- 8:10Shift away from pushing products and start seeking to apply your
- 8:13skills for the benefit of others.
- 8:15Ditch the bulldozer, grab your conversational brush and stop
- 8:18accepting compliments. So my final question to you is
- 8:22what fragile truth are you going to dig up tomorrow?