Latest / The So What? / Electricity - Green is the New Gold Pt. 2
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Lantman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on JP's website, jplantman.co.za.
- 0:21I am Ruda Lantman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:35Hello and welcome to the second recording, the second part of this recording, which goes
- 0:43with JP's newsletter of the 1st of August 2022, Electricity Green is the New Gold.
- 0:50It is so packed with information and almost double the usual length.
- 0:56So we've broken it up, please listen to the first part as well.
- 1:01And now we're coming to what we've called frequently asked questions about this.
- 1:06What about ESCOM debt?
- 1:08What's going to happen with that?
- 1:09Yep, it looks fairly certain that about 200 billion of the 400 billion that ESCOM owes
- 1:18will be transferred from the ESCOM balance sheet to the Treasury, the National Treasury,
- 1:22in other words, the South Africa as a country's balance sheet.
- 1:26Now that sounds very intimidating, but it's not really.
- 1:30Of that 400 billion debt that ESCOM has, more than 300 billion has been guaranteed by the
- 1:36government anyway.
- 1:38So government or the taxpayer is liable to pay for it if ESCOM can't pay.
- 1:43So whether it sits on the ESCOM balance sheet or sits on the Treasury balance sheet, it's
- 1:47really very much the same thing.
- 1:49How do outsiders like the rating agencies see this?
- 1:53The rating agencies, as a general rule, add these guaranteed debt, what is called contingent
- 2:00liabilities.
- 2:01They add it onto the nominal debt that the government has and they then calculate what
- 2:07the debt is as a percentage of GDP and how that affects the ability of the country to
- 2:11repay.
- 2:13So the economist that has been rated once again as the best economist on the JSE, Elna
- 2:20Moorman, has calculated that if 200 billion of the 400 billion is transferred to Treasury,
- 2:26it will lift the South African debt profile from about 75% of GDP to 78% of GDP.
- 2:35And in her opinion, that is not a game changer.
- 2:37It's not an event that will trigger a rerating of where we are.
- 2:42In fact, it will probably, as it has already done, trigger a rerating of ESCOM's debt,
- 2:47making it easier for ESCOM to borrow, not making much difference on the South African
- 2:51side.
- 2:52So that's likely the way that it will play out.
- 2:55Now, Rudolf, what we must not forget is that since 2018 or 2019, Treasury has been allocating
- 3:04many billions of rands every year to ESCOM as a kind of a direct subsidy to enable ESCOM
- 3:09to survive.
- 3:10I think it's a much better arrangement to just take the debt on.
- 3:14ESCOM can get rid of that interest payments and you've got a much healthier situation.
- 3:20We don't have details yet of precisely what that transfer of debt will look like.
- 3:25We'll get that in October at the time of the so-called mini budget.
- 3:28But we know from reports that have been leaked that Treasury is pushing that after the transfer
- 3:36of debt has taken place, there must be certain follow-up steps that ESCOM has also taken
- 3:41to improve their own balance sheet and own liquidity position.
- 3:45And maybe that includes that they offer to sell Madhupi or Kusila.
- 3:49Once Madhupi or Kusila is up and running properly and has been sorted out, it'll be a fantastic
- 3:54investment.
- 3:55You won't pay what it costs.
- 3:57That you won't do.
- 3:58You will pay it at a much discounted price.
- 4:01But at the right price, Bauer Station is a lovely investment for a pension fund.
- 4:06We've got income for the next 30 years and it's consistent income.
- 4:09So it must be possible to do deals like that.
- 4:12And we will get those details in October.
- 4:14ESCOM is talking about building battery energy storage systems base.
- 4:21Battery energy storage systems base.
- 4:24It's a wonderful, wonderful name.
- 4:27And planning to take on debt, extra new debt for that.
- 4:32Should one be worried?
- 4:33No, I wouldn't be worried because relatively speaking, the amounts are small.
- 4:36The debt is a loan from the World Bank, which André Deraiter has negotiated.
- 4:41It's for 11 billion rand, which will go into the base project, energy battery storage system.
- 4:47Now, if you think about it, 11 billion rand is less than 3% of ESCOM's debt.
- 4:53Whether it's there or not, I think it's not really material.
- 4:58We know ESCOM can't pay the interest and they can't pay the debt.
- 5:00That's why treasury will come in.
- 5:01So in the treasury standing behind this kind of deal.
- 5:05But what 11 billion rand does, it's beginning the process of building a storage infrastructure,
- 5:13energy storage infrastructure in South Africa.
- 5:16We did exactly the same thing at the beginning of renewables.
- 5:19The first renewable contracts were signed at, just hold on to your chair, 4 and 50 kilowatt
- 5:24hour at the stage when ESCOM was selling power for less than around a kilowatt hour.
- 5:30On top of that, it carried a government guarantee.
- 5:33So we've really sweetened the deal a hell of a lot for those first renewable producers
- 5:38to get the wheel rolling.
- 5:40And today, of course, we have the benefits.
- 5:42The price have dropped from 4 and 50 per kilowatt hour to 47 cents.
- 5:47You know, it's a fantastic drop in price and you were able to start a whole new industry,
- 5:52which we couldn't do before that.
- 5:54So I think it's a good investment.
- 5:56If it opens the door to battery storage, it opens the door to battery manufacturing in
- 6:01sub Africa with a big vanadium producer, with the biggest vanadium producer in the world.
- 6:06You use vanadium in manufacturing batteries.
- 6:10So the potential is huge that can all flow.
- 6:13But you need, as you pointed out earlier, you need a client, you need a customer, and
- 6:17that customer will be battery storage systems.
- 6:20And that's why I think it's a good thing that ESCOM has taken the initiative here, although
- 6:24it is still very expensive.
- 6:26Hopefully over time, it will come down.
- 6:29The second question, of course, that everyone asks is, yeah, well, it's all fine.
- 6:35But will it ever happen because this government doesn't seem to be able to implement any of
- 6:41its own plans, I'm quoting.
- 6:44What is your answer to that?
- 6:45Well, I think one must distinguish, you know, there's government and here we've got government
- 6:48but ESCOM.
- 6:50And as the president said in his television address, ESCOM now has a very competent management
- 6:55team and has huge confidence in them.
- 6:58And I think it's right to have confidence.
- 7:00So yes, it will be implemented.
- 7:01And in fact, ESCOM is already of that 11 billion rand loan from the World Bank.
- 7:06They've already made a 4.4 billion rand contract with two companies, a South Korean company
- 7:12and a Chinese company to come and build best systems, battery storage systems here in
- 7:17South Africa with technology developed and tested and used in South Korea and China.
- 7:23So yes, it will happen.
- 7:25And how will it affect us?
- 7:26I must read to you the names of a few places where we're going to see that.
- 7:32We're going to see these best systems, in other words, battery storage systems installed
- 7:38at Skaapvlei, Paleishevel, Graa Water, Pongola, Elanskop and Hexerfeef.
- 7:44These are all rural names.
- 7:46These are all Prattland names where you currently have bigger or smaller solar or wind farms.
- 7:54You put batteries down there when the sun is shining or the wind is blowing, the batteries
- 7:57can be loaded.
- 7:59And tonight when the sun is not shining, you can draw from batteries and feed the grid.
- 8:03That's why ESCOM is doing it.
- 8:04I think it's a very strong development.
- 8:07And to answer your question, it's already happening.
- 8:09Not it will happen.
- 8:10There are the towns with the names where the systems will be installed.
- 8:14So yes, it will happen.
- 8:16And the criticism that the contracts are going to not only foreign companies, but companies
- 8:24from the East who are renowned for bringing in their own workers and using no one locally?
- 8:30Well, they will certainly have to train local people.
- 8:33Otherwise, do you understand Graa Water forever?
- 8:37I don't think so.
- 8:38Now, I'm not too concerned about that.
- 8:41The fact is we don't have the technology.
- 8:43We probably don't have the expertise to build it.
- 8:46And that's part of the thing.
- 8:47You must have your people here trained so that future best storage systems can be built
- 8:53by them.
- 8:54And that's the way that I think it will play out.
- 8:56So what has happened to the IRP from 2019?
- 9:01Is that now has that been ditched or what?
- 9:03No, on the contrary, the IRP of 2019 is being implemented ahead of schedule.
- 9:08I quote some numbers in the in the written text, but essentially the IRP runs up to 2030.
- 9:15And by 2025, by 2025, we were supposed to have procured 9400 megawatts of new solar
- 9:24and wind power in terms of the in terms of the IRP.
- 9:28We are already sitting at 7800 and this is now 2022.
- 9:32So we will easily beat that 2025 target.
- 9:36If you then add to the fact that a lot of the activity has shifted to the private sector
- 9:43with the president's announcement around private sector participation and on the storage side,
- 9:49a lot of the activity has shifted to ESCON, then I think we'll easily beat the IRP targets.
- 9:54As a nation, we will easily beat them because solar plants will be built outside of the
- 9:59IRP and batteries will be put up, battery storage systems will be put up outside the
- 10:04IRP.
- 10:05So in a sense, the IRP thing is academic, but we certainly will beat the numbers, which
- 10:09is an IRP.
- 10:10No question about that.
- 10:11What about what shall I call it?
- 10:14murmurings about a second ESCON?
- 10:16I think it's exactly that murmurings.
- 10:18Yeah, a second ESCON doesn't fit into the long term picture, which we've been discussing
- 10:22here today.
- 10:23Absolutely not.
- 10:24And, you know, you must always see things in context.
- 10:27I watched the speech that the president made in which he made this comment about the second
- 10:32ESCON at the South African Communist Party summit or meeting.
- 10:37It was one hour and seven minutes.
- 10:38It was really, if you watch the whole thing, it was really a throwaway comment.
- 10:43The throwaway comment was then picked up by the media and taken further and so on and
- 10:48so forth.
- 10:49But it was really a throwaway comment.
- 10:51I would be very surprised if that becomes part of ANC policy and then even more surprised
- 10:57if it becomes part of government policy.
- 10:59There's a hell of a difference between talking at the SSCP conference, having an official
- 11:04ANC policy and then having government policy.
- 11:07Those are three very different positions.
- 11:09So now I don't think we'll see it.
- 11:11What we I think we'll see is a gas company, a government owned gas company to build the
- 11:17infrastructure that we need to use gas in the country.
- 11:21We don't really have a gas infrastructure, only in a very small and limited way.
- 11:25If we want to reach a point of having 3000 or 6000 megawatts of gas supply available
- 11:32to the economy, we will have to put a few pipes in the ground.
- 11:35To put it that way, we'll have to build infrastructure.
- 11:39That could possibly be done by a government company, a state owned enterprise.
- 11:46So in that sense, there could be, but that's a second ESCON, but let's be very clear, a
- 11:50gas company is not a second ESCON.
- 11:52It's like saying a zebra is the same as a kudu.
- 11:55No, no, no, no, no.
- 11:57That's not the case at all.
- 11:58I first want to see in any case who's going to finance it.
- 12:01I don't think there's money in the budget for it.
- 12:04And I very much doubt whether private financiers would be willing to step in unless their government
- 12:09guarantees and so on.
- 12:11So let's see how that space develops.
- 12:13I'm very much in favor of gas supply and I don't see a second ESCON as part of the long
- 12:20term plans.
- 12:22We've talked a lot about procurement for generation, but what about transmission?
- 12:28Because the transmission lines need to be upgraded enormously.
- 12:31Absolutely.
- 12:32Transmission will remain a government monopoly.
- 12:36That's the case in the Netherlands, it's the case in China, it's the case in several countries.
- 12:41And that would be the case here as well.
- 12:42The president made that clear.
- 12:44ESCOM itself is working with an upgrade of the transmission lines of about 130 billion
- 12:50rand.
- 12:51They're talking about 8000 kilometers of transmission lines and they're talking about 100 new substations
- 12:57to be built.
- 12:59And the price tag of that is 130 billion and more.
- 13:03So yes, that'll have to be done and the transmission company that will be formed will have to take
- 13:08that on.
- 13:09A portion of the money that we are getting or hope to get from the COP26 conference,
- 13:16that 8.3 billion dollars, it's about 140 billion rand.
- 13:21A portion of that 140 billion will go for transmission lines for ESCOM because that's
- 13:25really the heart of energy transition.
- 13:28If you can get your transmission lines and your substations right, the rest follows.
- 13:34So I think that's how ESCOM will finance it.
- 13:36Thank you.
- 13:37Do you want to just have a look at what you yourself have listed as so what at the end
- 13:42of this two part series?
- 13:44Yeah, and we must apologize that it's so long, but the topic is just big and complex and
- 13:49one has to see it in its whole.
- 13:52When we talk electricity, we normally stop with load shedding, but there is just so much
- 13:55more to it.
- 13:56And that really is the only point I want to highlight.
- 13:59The Chinese word for crisis consists of two characters and the one character indicates
- 14:05danger and the other character indicates opportunity.
- 14:09And I think that's exactly electricity in South Africa.
- 14:12It's the biggest single danger facing this country at the moment.
- 14:14It's the biggest single constraint holding us back.
- 14:18But by the same token, it's the biggest single opportunity.
- 14:21There's nothing else in this economy, agriculture, tourism, you name it.
- 14:28There's no other industry where we have the possibility of the investment and the jobs
- 14:33and the growth that we can have with electricity, switching from coal to renewables.
- 14:40And in that sense, it really is a case of green is the new gold.