Latest / The El Paso Matters Podcast / Why El Paso school districts face layoffs, school closures
Transcript
- 0:00El Paso's public school districts are in a tough
- 0:02spot. Administrators throughout the school districts
- 0:05here are dealing with a few challenges. Major
- 0:07student population decline, inadequate state
- 0:09funding, and a push by Governor Greg Abbott and
- 0:11state lawmakers to direct public school funding
- 0:13to private and charter schools. Some districts
- 0:16are dealing with self -inflicted problems like
- 0:17overspending. Meanwhile, most of the major school
- 0:20districts in El Paso are getting ready to hold
- 0:22school board elections next month. which will
- 0:24determine who will make the high level decisions
- 0:26that impact education in El Paso, like how much
- 0:28to pay teachers and what schools to keep open.
- 0:31To put it concisely, the public education system
- 0:33in El Paso is going through a period of turmoil
- 0:35and transition. I'm your host, Diego Mendoza
- 0:39Moyers, and this is another episode of the El
- 0:41Paso Matters podcast. Today, we welcome El Paso
- 0:44Matters education reporter, Claudia Silva, to
- 0:46explain why El Paso school districts are in tight
- 0:48financial situations and what to expect for public
- 0:50education in El Paso going forward. Thanks for
- 0:53joining me, Claudia. Hi, Diego. Thanks for having
- 0:55me. So to start, can you walk us through the
- 0:58main reasons that school districts in El Paso
- 0:59are dealing with financial problems and some
- 1:01districts getting ready to either close schools
- 1:04or lay off employees? Well, there's a lot of
- 1:07factors at play and every district is a little
- 1:10bit different. First, you might want to look
- 1:12at things at the state level. Statewide, Texas
- 1:16has not increased public funding for schools
- 1:19since 2019. Texas schools also recently lost
- 1:24funding under the School and Health Related Services
- 1:28or SHARS program. Essentially this program used
- 1:32Medicaid funds to reimburse school districts
- 1:35for services like counseling, physical therapy,
- 1:39specialized transportation, essentially anything
- 1:42medical related that a student might need while
- 1:44they're in school. So this came after the Office
- 1:47of Inspector General found that the state had
- 1:49incorrectly reported reimbursements. So this
- 1:53basically affects every school in Texas. Now
- 1:56locally, all districts across El Paso County
- 1:58are dealing with declining enrollment. A lot
- 2:01of this is caused by falling birth rates. As
- 2:04we know, people just aren't having as many kids
- 2:07as they used to. And as students graduate, there
- 2:10are less new students coming in. Then we also
- 2:13have the problem with outward migration in El
- 2:16Paso where we have the centralized school districts
- 2:19like EPISD and Isleta ISD who are basically landlocked
- 2:24and people are moving out to the outskirts of
- 2:28the city. So places like Canotillo, Horizon,
- 2:32and for some time people were also moving to
- 2:34Socorro. So declining enrollment is actually
- 2:38the main issue with Canotillo. El Paso and these
- 2:42little school districts. You know, you've probably
- 2:45heard the news that EPISD is planning to close
- 2:47several elementary schools. This is partially
- 2:50because many of these schools are at low capacity
- 2:53and have very few students. Superintendent Diana
- 2:58Saavedra has alluded that there may be layoffs
- 3:01if they don't actually close schools. Notably,
- 3:05both EPISD and Isleta ISD have already closed
- 3:09schools in the past. Collins Elementary and Terrence
- 3:14Hills Elementary became Bobby Joe Hill Pre -K
- 3:17through 8th School. Clardy Elementary and Henderson
- 3:22Middle School are now Dina Hiddle. Beals and
- 3:25Burleson and a few other schools closed a few
- 3:28years back under this really controversial project
- 3:31at EPISD. Ysleta did their own closures. You
- 3:35have, for example, Desert View and Indian Ridge
- 3:38Middle School were consolidated to create Hanks
- 3:41Middle School, and there were a few other closures
- 3:44that happened throughout the years. Now, when
- 3:48we look at Ysleta, they really aren't in as dire
- 3:52of a situation as EPISD are gonna deal, but they
- 3:56are still looking into taking out a $25 million
- 3:59loan. order to cover payroll essentially Texas
- 4:05sends scheduled payments to school districts
- 4:07every month But there are a few months where
- 4:10those payments don't get sent out Normally districts
- 4:13would have enough money in their savings to cover
- 4:16payroll during that time period But because of
- 4:20declining enrollment and certain budget deficits
- 4:23the district may need to actually get a loan
- 4:27this time in order to pay for it and Also Canotillo,
- 4:30we know that they recently announced layoffs.
- 4:33So unlike other school districts which are landlocked,
- 4:37Canotillo ISD is actually in an area with a growing
- 4:40population. A lot of people are moving out to
- 4:43Canotillo ISD and you've probably noticed that
- 4:45there's been a lot of construction in the area.
- 4:48The voters in the district recently approved
- 4:51a bond and now the district is hoping to make
- 4:54improvements. that will bring in more students
- 4:57and ideally fix, you know, some of their financial
- 5:00situation. Now, some of the issues that districts
- 5:03are facing were made at the actual district itself.
- 5:09So a lot of them were decisions made by the board.
- 5:11A lot of it had to do with overspending and that's
- 5:14essentially where SISD is right now. So Coral
- 5:18ISD recently announced that it was going to be
- 5:21laying off 300 employees. And a lot of that was
- 5:26the result of overspending. Some of the purchases
- 5:31that were approved that were outside of their
- 5:33budget or outside of the revenue that they were
- 5:38making included developing some specialized academies,
- 5:41replacing turf in some of its athletic fields,
- 5:47paving a new parking lot in Montwood High School.
- 5:50And I think one of the biggest things was giving
- 5:53pay raises to teachers. Now, the legislature
- 5:56was looking to increase school funding in 2023.
- 6:02And before the legislative session ended, Socorro
- 6:08ISD, the school board, approved pay raises for
- 6:10all of its teachers. And a lot of that was in
- 6:13the hope that there would be more money coming
- 6:14into the district. Now, those raises and funding
- 6:18didn't happen back in 2023. But those pay raises
- 6:22still need to continue. So that's kind of what
- 6:25brings the district to where it is right now.
- 6:29Now for a time, the district was able to use
- 6:32its savings to cover a lot of its expenses. It
- 6:35had growing enrollment, so it had a lot of extra
- 6:38money coming in. But now that enrollment is declining,
- 6:43the district is dealing with a budget deficit.
- 6:46and its savings have dwindled. So it's no longer
- 6:49able to continue spending and now is having to
- 6:52make some really severe budget cuts in order
- 6:55to stay afloat. And whose decision was it to
- 6:57give out pay raises and so forth to teachers
- 7:00and do some of that additional spending? So it
- 7:03was actually the board's decision. The school
- 7:06administration had come forward and recommended
- 7:09pay raises at the time. And the board actually
- 7:13decided to give pay raises that were higher than
- 7:15was recommended. And their goal was to try to
- 7:19retain and attract more teachers. There have
- 7:23been issues in recent years where teachers have
- 7:26been leaving the job. And many districts are
- 7:29having a hard time keeping good experienced teachers.
- 7:34Yeah, and we see there's a lot going on right
- 7:36now in the Texas legislature that probably will
- 7:38affect education in Texas going forward Can you
- 7:40talk about some of the education related policies
- 7:42that state lawmakers are looking at and how they
- 7:44might impact education in El Paso? Yeah, definitely.
- 7:49So one of the issues that we talked about before
- 7:51was the fact that Texas hasn't increased school
- 7:55funding since 2019 The way school funding works
- 7:59is it's based on average daily attendance and
- 8:02there is a student allotment which is basically
- 8:05the amount of money that the state sends a district
- 8:09for every student that it has and it's all plugged
- 8:11into this formula. Now the student allotment
- 8:17has been $6 ,160 per student since 2019. Right
- 8:24now, the House's omnibus school finance proposal
- 8:27would raise the allotment by $220. Now, one of
- 8:33the issues with that is that a lot of lawmakers
- 8:35and education advocates say that this is not
- 8:38enough to keep up with inflation. Many lawmakers
- 8:42that I've spoken to, district leaders and other
- 8:46educators, say that they would need closer to
- 8:49about $1 ,000 to $1 ,500. to keep up with inflation.
- 8:54On top of the current allotment? Yes. Another
- 8:58big issue that is being looked at at the legislature
- 9:01is vouchers or an education savings account.
- 9:07This has actually been a top priority for Governor
- 9:10Abbott since 2023 and it's one of the reasons
- 9:14that there was no increase in public school funding.
- 9:19So what this voucher program or this student
- 9:22savings account program does is it allows parents
- 9:27to take their children to private schools using
- 9:30taxpayer funds. In 2023, lawmakers attempted
- 9:35to include vouchers in the school funding bill.
- 9:38And that's one of the reasons that funding never
- 9:41got approved. The bill got voted down in order
- 9:44to try to prevent vouchers from passing. So the
- 9:48purpose of these voucher programs is to help
- 9:52low -income families access private schools.
- 9:54But a lot of opponents feel that the selective
- 9:57nature, you know, transportation barriers and
- 10:01other things may actually keep these low -income
- 10:04families from accessing private schools. A lot
- 10:07of them feel that it will only actually benefit
- 10:10wealthier families who already have their kids
- 10:12enrolled in these schools. Many also feel that
- 10:16this legislation is going to be siphoning money
- 10:19from public education. This year the bill would
- 10:24allocate one billion dollars to these private
- 10:27school vouchers. Some feel that that money should
- 10:30be actually allocated to public schools and others
- 10:33worry that parents may be incentivized to take
- 10:37their kids out of public schools and move them
- 10:39to private schools. What that would have essentially
- 10:42do is move that funding into a private school.
- 10:47Now, there actually aren't very many private
- 10:51schools in El Paso. The largest was Laredo Academy
- 10:55and only takes in about 600 students. So, even
- 11:00if every private school in El Paso took in 600
- 11:03students, that actually wouldn't be enough seats
- 11:06to take, it would only be a fraction of the students
- 11:11in El Paso. But there is a concern that these
- 11:15vouchers may actually incentivize more private
- 11:18schools to open in the area and a big concern
- 11:21is that private schools don't have as much oversight
- 11:24as public schools do They don't have to you know
- 11:29Do standardized testing and follow a lot of the
- 11:32you know strict regulations that are set by the
- 11:34TEA and the Department of Education Yeah, and
- 11:38is it looking that likely that vouchers will
- 11:40pass this legislative session? So it's a little
- 11:42bit hard to say, but Abbott has said that he
- 11:47has enough votes in the House to pass vouchers.
- 11:51I know a lot of lawmakers here in El Paso are
- 11:54going to attempt to vote the bill down. Some
- 11:58of them may try to add requirements to the voucher
- 12:01program that would make private schools have
- 12:04to follow a lot of the same regulations that
- 12:06private schools do, but a lot of that is, we'll
- 12:09have to see. Yeah, so back at the local level,
- 12:12we have school board elections coming next month
- 12:14for almost every school district in El Paso other
- 12:16than Isleta, which I believe all of the candidates
- 12:18in Isleta are unopposed. But I wonder if you
- 12:20can talk about what school board members do and
- 12:22why people should vote in this election. Yeah.
- 12:26Yeah. So as you mentioned, two of the largest
- 12:28districts in the county are having elections.
- 12:30EPISD and Socorro. Isleta, they didn't have any
- 12:35opponents. So this is actually This is actually
- 12:38not the first time that the the school board
- 12:40hasn't had any opposition So a lot of these board
- 12:44members have been in place for quite some time
- 12:47Now what board members do is they essentially
- 12:51represent voters in different areas of a school
- 12:53district? usually they'll a school district will
- 12:57get divided into into seven regions and Every
- 13:01board member is essentially expected to represent
- 13:04their constituents Board members are in charge
- 13:08of hiring and firing the superintendent. They
- 13:11are basically the superintendent's boss. They
- 13:14also make a lot of major policy decisions. So
- 13:17they're the ones that decide what kind of police
- 13:20officers may be in the school, what kind of curriculum,
- 13:25the punishments and policies for behavioral issues
- 13:31and things of that nature. They also make purchasing
- 13:35decisions and are the ones that have a lot of
- 13:38final say in a lot of things that school districts
- 13:42do. So one thing to keep in mind is that board
- 13:44members are unpaid. A lot of them, especially
- 13:47right now that they're making budget cuts and
- 13:49cutting teacher salaries or laying off employees,
- 13:53are asking to cut the board member's salary,
- 13:56but they actually don't make any money and are
- 13:58actually volunteering a lot of their time to
- 14:01do this job. Now the election is going to be
- 14:04on May 3rd early voting starts on April 22nd
- 14:08and ends on April 29th Yeah, and we Already have
- 14:12low voter turnout in El Paso, especially so for
- 14:15school board elections So hopefully we'll see
- 14:17a higher turnout this year. Well then on this
- 14:20Claudia What do you think would be the consequences
- 14:22for our school districts here if some of these
- 14:23financial issues aren't fixed? Yeah, well there
- 14:26are several consequences now when we look at
- 14:29what could happen to the school district You
- 14:33know a school district can be taken over by the
- 14:35TA that's something that we did see happen in
- 14:38Houston recently and If school districts, you
- 14:42know continue to have financial issues. They
- 14:44could actually risk their accreditation Every
- 14:47year districts are required to submit reports
- 14:50You know regarding their finances and a part
- 14:53of that is, you know districts are supposed to
- 14:56have savings Right now a big issue is that a
- 14:59lot of district savings their savings accounts
- 15:01have been depleted and That could actually cause
- 15:05them to fail some of these reports if they continuously
- 15:09get bad financial reports that could Lead to
- 15:13a you know a takeover from the state Another
- 15:16issue that could happen which is probably the
- 15:19most extreme thing. It would be a loss of accreditation
- 15:24Now when a school district loses accreditation
- 15:27generally this means that they are going to close
- 15:29down and can no longer You know offer classes
- 15:33We have seen charter schools and smaller districts
- 15:37lose accreditation So it'd be difficult to say
- 15:41if such a large school like the ones here in
- 15:45El Paso would face similar consequences Now when
- 15:49we talk about the students, we've already seen
- 15:51some of the consequences of these budget issues.
- 15:56Districts have had to make budget cuts, and with
- 15:58a lot of those budget cuts, we're seeing students
- 16:02losing schools in their neighborhoods and now
- 16:05having to travel farther away. We're also gonna
- 16:08be seeing larger class sizes. A lot of parents
- 16:12really enjoyed having neighborhood schools with
- 16:14these smaller class sizes. And even though the
- 16:18state does have a regulation and a requirement
- 16:22saying that class sizes can't go over a certain
- 16:24amount, districts can ask for exceptions, and
- 16:28many parents still feel that these class sizes
- 16:31are a little bit too large. Another issue is
- 16:35students may start losing programs. We've seen
- 16:38at SISD that They're going to be cutting the
- 16:42elementary school fine arts program. So that
- 16:44means that elementary school students are no
- 16:47longer going to have a dedicated music and art
- 16:51teacher that they would go to to learn about
- 16:53these subjects. Kind of DOISD is also going to
- 16:57be cutting its elementary school music program.
- 17:01So this is all things that have already happened
- 17:05and there may be more programs that could be
- 17:08affected by this. Yeah, so there's a real risk
- 17:10presented by some of these financial issues the
- 17:12district are facing. Well, thanks for joining
- 17:16us, Claudia. We'll leave it there. Appreciate
- 17:17your insight on this and listeners can read all
- 17:19of your reporting on El Paso's education system
- 17:21at ElPasoMatters .org. Thanks so much for joining
- 17:23me. Thank you.