Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage the Employee Who Always Says I Need More Recognition
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've spent the last twenty episodes dealing with employees who say 'I need more time,' 'I need a raise,' 'I need a promotion.' Today, let's talk about the one that's harder to put a price tag on: the employee who keeps saying 'I need more recognition.' Luna: Oof. That one can feel both flattering and exhausting at the same time. You want to appreciate them, but it's never quite enough. Lucas: Exactly. And it's a real challenge because recognition is subjective. A raise has a number. A promotion has a title. Recognition is a feeling, and if you're not careful, you end up in this awkward loop of increasing praise that never satisfies. Luna: I actually had a team member like that a few years ago. She was a solid performer, but every one-on-one ended with, 'I just don't feel like my work is noticed.' And I'd literally just given her a shout-out in the team meeting the day before. Lucas: And that's the puzzle. You're doing the right thing, but it's not landing. So before we get into tactics, let's talk about why that happens. Because sometimes it's not about the praise at all. Luna: What do you mean? Lucas: Well, I think there are three common root causes. The first is a genuine mismatch in love language, if you'll pardon the pop psychology. Some people want public recognition, others want private thank-yous, and some want more autonomy as a sign of trust. Luna: Right. Like, I had another teammate who didn't care about the shout-out at all. He just wanted me to stop checking his work so closely. Lucas: That's a perfect example. The second root cause is a lack of clarity on what 'good' looks like. If the employee doesn't know what specific behaviors or outcomes you value, they'll feel like they're working in the dark, and no amount of praise will feel like it's for the right thing. Luna: So it's not that they want more praise, it's that they want to know you're paying attention to the right things. Lucas: Bingo. And the third root cause is a deeper insecurity. Sometimes the request for recognition is really a request for reassurance that they're not about to be fired, or that they still matter after a reorg or a new hire. I remember a case where an employee's performance dipped after a new star was brought in, and the only way he knew how to ask for help was to ask for recognition. Luna: That's a heavy insight. So when someone says 'I need more recognition,' the worst thing you can do is just pump out more generic praise. Lucas: Right, because that doesn't fix any of the three root causes. In fact, it can make things worse, because now the recognition feels hollow and the employee starts to resent the process. So what I suggest is a simple diagnostic conversation. Luna: Let's hear it. I'm already thinking about how I'd use this. Lucas: So in the next one-on-one, instead of defending yourself or promising to do better, ask three questions. First: 'Can you give me an example of a time recently when you felt truly recognized?' That gets at the type and the context. Luna: And if they can't come up with one? Lucas: Then that's a signal — maybe the praise isn't specific enough, or it's not happening at all. But the second question is the kicker: 'What would recognition look like if it were perfect for you?' This invites them to get concrete. Do they want a note in the company channel? A mention in the performance review? A spot on a high-visibility project? Luna: That's smart because it moves it from a feeling to a spec. Lucas: Exactly. And the third question is about the broader context: 'Is there anything else going on that's making you feel undervalued?' That opens the door to the insecurity or the clarity issues we talked about. Luna: And then what do you do with the answers? Because if they say 'I want a weekly email of all my wins,' that could become a burden. Lucas: That's where you negotiate. The goal isn't to promise a specific frequency or format forever. It's to find something that works for both of you. And a key principle is the recognition ratio. Luna: The recognition ratio — I've heard you mention that before. What is it exactly? Lucas: It's the balance of positive to corrective feedback. Research, and I'm thinking of the work by Emily Heaphy and Marcial Losada, suggests that high-performing teams have a ratio of about five or six positive comments for every negative one. But that's not just about sugar-coating. It's about being specific and genuine. Luna: So it's not 'great job on the report,' it's 'I loved how you structured the executive summary, it made the decision easy.' Lucas: Yes. Specificity is the magic. And for employees who are asking for more recognition, often they're getting a lot of feedback, but it's all in the form of 'here's what went wrong.' They're starved for the positive. Luna: So what does that look like in practice? Say I've got a developer who just shipped a feature on time. What do I say? Lucas: First, don't just say 'nice work.' Say something like, 'The way you handled the edge cases on the login flow saved us from a major bug. I noticed how you tested that early, and it made a real difference.' That's specific, it's timely, and it's tied to a behavior you want to see more of. Luna: So it's not about volume, it's about precision. Lucas: And consistency. Recognition shouldn't be a special event. It should be woven into your regular interactions. If you only praise at the end of a project, the employee feels invisible during the grind. Luna: That reminds me of a study I read about how managers who gave weekly feedback had teams with lower turnover than those who only did annual reviews. But it wasn't just the frequency — it was that the feedback was specific and forward-looking. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the thing about the recognition request. It's a signal that the feedback system isn't working. And as a manager, your job is to fix the system, not just hand out more gold stars. Luna: But what about the flip side? What if you have an employee who's clearly fishing for praise but their performance is just average? You don't want to inflate their ego or set a bad precedent. Lucas: That's a really good point. You can't just give recognition for the sake of it. The key is to find something that is genuinely worthy of recognition. If the performance is average, maybe the recognition is for their consistency, or for their attitude, or for a specific improvement they've made. But if you can't find anything, that's a performance issue that needs addressing, not a recognition issue. Luna: So you're saying the 'I need more recognition' might be a smoke screen for 'I'm not sure I'm doing well.' Lucas: Sometimes. And that's why the diagnostic conversation is so important. You might discover that the real issue is they don't know what the team goals are, or they feel like they're not getting the right projects to shine. Luna: That actually dovetails with something I've been thinking about. We've been talking about individual recognition, but what about the team level? There are teams that just don't have a culture of appreciation. And that's a manager's job to model, right? Lucas: Absolutely. And a great way to do that is to create a 'recognition ritual' — like a few minutes at the end of a weekly team meeting where anyone can shout out a colleague for something specific. It doesn't have to be a big production, just a regular, safe space for appreciation. Luna: I love that. And it takes the pressure off you as the manager to be the sole source of validation. Lucas: Right. And it encourages peer to peer recognition, which can be more meaningful than a manager's praise in some cases. Because colleagues see the day-to-day effort that you might miss. Luna: So we've got the diagnostic, the ratio, the specificity, and the ritual. That's a solid toolkit. But there's one more thing I want to touch on — what if you have an employee who just can't seem to get enough? You've done all this and they still come back asking for more. Lucas: That's when you need to have a different kind of conversation. You say, 'Look, we've been working on making recognition more specific and more frequent. I want to make sure we're on the same page. What's still missing for you?' Luna: And if they still can't articulate it? Lucas: Then you might be dealing with a deeper issue, like a mismatch between their expectations and the reality of the role. Some people come from environments where they got constant applause, and they expect that everywhere. It's okay to say, 'I appreciate you wanting to feel valued, but I can't give you praise every day for doing your job. That's the baseline.' Luna: That's a hard conversation, but it's fair. We're not running a participation trophy factory. Lucas: Exactly. And that clarity can actually be a relief for the employee. They know the rules of the game. And you can work together to find other ways to feel fulfilled — like taking on a mentorship role or leading a project. Luna: I think we've given our listeners a lot to chew on. And before we wrap up, I want to take a beat to talk about something that's close to both of our hearts. We keep this show free of ads, and that's a choice we're proud of. It means you get unfiltered, practical advice without any corporate sponsorship. If you've ever gotten value from these episodes, and you want to support that ad-free mission, you can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep this going. Lucas: Yeah, it's not about perks or anything. It's just about keeping this resource open to anyone who needs it, whether you're a first-time manager or a seasoned leader. And we're grateful for any support that comes our way. Luna: So, back to recognition. One thing I want to leave you with is this: the next time an employee tells you they need more recognition, don't panic. Don't feel like you have to launch a praise campaign. Instead, get curious. Ask the diagnostic questions, and you might be surprised by what you uncover. Lucas: And remember, recognition is a tool, not a treat. Use it deliberately, and it will build a team that feels valued and motivated. That's the real win. Luna: Thanks for joining us on Manager Mondays. We'll see you next week.