Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.43 🎙️ Public Inquiry Legal challenges – Day 1
Transcript
- 0:05Hello there. Day one
- 0:07of the public inquiry.
- 0:09It felt a little like Groundhog Day repeat, repeating our
- 0:12performance from January 2025 so to set the scene, there was a
- 0:18fair amount of press outside the stroll Arts where we were
- 0:21interviewed, and there wasn't much clicking of cameras. And of
- 0:24course, the yellow umbrellas with no toxic mining on them
- 0:27were very much in evidence. They started at 10am everyone
- 0:32dutifully taking up their positions.
- 0:34And as usual, we're referred to as the third party,
- 0:39musing quietly to myself, as I'm waiting for things to start.
- 0:43Wondering, why do the public get designated the third party at a
- 0:47public inquiry? It feels a little derogatory. Anyways,
- 0:52we're kicked off with an explanation of the role of the
- 0:54commission and sundry housekeeping. A statutory
- 0:59objection was quickly lodged by one of the third parties as to
- 1:03the confirmation that the public inquiry is run in line within
- 1:09statutory framework
- 1:10legislation, and this was duly noted.
- 1:14This was followed quickly by an inquiry
- 1:17if state bodies were invited from the Republic of Ireland,
- 1:20and the answer was a resounding no. Another third party
- 1:25representative want to know if it was a reconvened inquiry or a
- 1:30new inquiry. And this was quickly pointed out that it was
- 1:33a reconvened inquiry.
- 1:35And then we start to get into the nitty gritty.
- 1:41The barrister for fodc for mana Noma District Council referred
- 1:46to a series of files, 95 in total, which were released as
- 1:50recently as March 2026, on the planning portal as to what their
- 1:56status was, questioning whether they were admissible, and
- 2:01further asking how they will be dealt with in the context of the
- 2:05inquiry,
- 2:07he said the new information
- 2:09meant people had not been given
- 2:11the reasonable time to respond that they should be allowed
- 2:14under law. Northern Ireland
- 2:16environmental agency stated
- 2:18that the significant volume of new information was submitted as
- 2:23part of the trans boundary consultation undertaken by the
- 2:27distortment department for infrastructure, GFI. Last year,
- 2:33the agency said it
- 2:35was assessing, but
- 2:36given the volume of new information,
- 2:40NIA would not now prepare a draft habitats regulation,
- 2:45appropriate assessment, hraa in advance of the inquiry,
- 2:50suggesting that it could be bolted on at the end after The
- 2:55planning appeals commission had made their decision. Mr. Fagan
- 3:03then made two salient points. One, has a decision been made on
- 3:10the acceptability of this evidence? And two, is this
- 3:13process fair? I know over the last month, with everything else
- 3:19going on, that savers burns were only able to give
- 3:23cursory attention to these new
- 3:24documents in the final rundown to
- 3:27the public inquiry.
- 3:29In my mind, it does not
- 3:30feel fair, but what do I know?
- 3:34Well, this conversation was battered forward
- 3:36and back and continued on and off up until lunchtime after
- 3:43lunch, the planning appeals commission came back with the
- 3:45decision. They would let us know on Tuesday what the outcome of
- 3:49this would be, saying that DFI were responsible for trans
- 3:54boundary consultation submissions. The rest of the
- 3:57afternoon proceeded with questions around processings and
- 4:00parameters, as in mine processes. That is, there was a
- 4:04question about the different figures in the application given
- 4:08for the amount of tonnage coming out of the mine over a given
- 4:11period, the barrister for delrayden managed to get this
- 4:15kicked up the road to later in the public inquiry proceedings,
- 4:18muttering something about there was no intention to exceed the
- 4:21limits. Another question was reasonable to ask as to why some
- 4:25of the assessments of EIA was based on 20 years, and others
- 4:29over 25 years. There was a whole discussion about a P, 1b, form,
- 4:35and that it was out of date. This form is an outline used to
- 4:40establish what has been mined for and what has been granted as
- 4:46the original form makes no mention of tellurium.
- 4:50Fidel McCain said it should be a new application.
- 4:55Dr Amy Strecker made the point that if it's not known
- 4:59yet which. Or will be extracted
- 5:01or used. How will that affect the economic argument? How do we
- 5:06determine what this is based on? There were questions around
- 5:11drawings showing where exploratory tunnel will be on
- 5:16the plan, and it was explained to us that the exploratory
- 5:21tunnels were in the area outlined in blue, and
- 5:25it was further explained that
- 5:26this blue area stretched all the way from Greencastle to Ruski
- 5:30with the understanding that mining could take place under
- 5:33people's houses and folk would not necessarily know about it or
- 5:37be able to do anything about it. The afternoon finished with a
- 5:41whole conversation around who's responsible for monitoring and
- 5:44enforcement of the mine, basically, who foots that?
- 5:47Bill Fermanagh district council made
- 5:51it very clear that they were not going to do it. We were told it
- 5:54was to be a shared responsibility of the DFI and
- 5:58the NIA. This caused a few raised eyebrows around the
- 6:02place,
- 6:03because we all know
- 6:04what happens to a shared responsibility. Somebody can
- 6:08always blame the other. The day was busy. There was a lot
- 6:12covered. It was actually quite exhausting, when I think back
- 6:16about it, trying to follow the whole conversation. It was
- 6:19interesting to note that there were that there were five tables
- 6:23of people representing communities from around the
- 6:27sperms. And given that the proceedings are not available
- 6:31online, we are not allowed to record them, nor is there a
- 6:35transcript, it is hugely important that we are able to be
- 6:40there. Unfortunately, some of us are, but others had to come and
- 6:45go. One mum left with her three children because she couldn't
- 6:50attend online.
- 6:51And at that point, the children had had enough,
- 6:56and she made that very clear, the fact that there isn't a
- 6:59transcript available of proceedings. Just make it feels
- 7:04odd.
- 7:06Why wouldn't there be a transcript?
- 7:10And it just doesn't feel right, and there's nothing we can
- 7:12do about it. Yeah, I think that's
- 7:15all I've got to say about it for now. You you.