Latest / Politics with Paul / How to Promote Pluralism in American Politics w/ Liz Vogel (New Pluralists) | Politics with Paul #70
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08As you can see, we have another guest and for those, I always start off with a disclaimer
- 0:12that I do not take a stance for or against political views or groups they support, but
- 0:18that isn't a concern this episode because today, we are talking about pluralism.
- 0:22A bit more specifically, how do we best promote pluralism in American politics?
- 0:28Our civic life is meant to be a blend of varied cultures, backgrounds, and viewpoints coming
- 0:33together to improve our politics and make us more well informed about what others think and
- 0:38feel.
- 0:39Yet in far too many cases, we see divisiveness and enmity that have threatened that ultimate
- 0:44thread of pluralistic unity.
- 0:47So how do we get back to promoting pluralism?
- 0:49What exactly does that look like?
- 0:51What are some of the biggest challenges to pluralism?
- 0:54These questions and more are what today's guest Liz Vogel is here to talk about today.
- 0:59Liz is the co executive director of New Pluralists, which describes itself as a funder
- 1:04collaborative investing in a growing ecosystem of people, organizations, and ideas working to
- 1:09bring pluralism to life in communities across The US.
- 1:13She also used to be its leader of philanthropic engagement and before that Liz was the founder
- 1:18and principal philanthropy advisor of Liz Vogel Consulting and the Southern California
- 1:23executive director of Facing History and Ourselves.
- 1:27So let's talk a bit more about her work with pluralism and with new pluralists, as well as
- 1:33how to best preserve and bolster pluralism in America as a whole.
- 1:37Please welcome Liz Vogel to the show.
- 1:39Thanks for coming on, Liz.
- 1:40How are you?
- 1:41I'm doing great.
- 1:42Thanks so much for inviting me.
- 1:43Happy to be here.
- 1:45Absolutely.
- 1:46Thank you for being here.
- 1:47So I always like to start off by getting to the genesis of why my guests do what they do, what
- 1:53about our very topic.
- 1:55So how did you first get involved in pluralism in general before getting to New Pluralists?
- 2:00And then how did you become part of New Pluralists?
- 2:03Great.
- 2:04Thanks.
- 2:05My career and in some ways my life has been animated by seeking to understand why we as
- 2:14humans tend to create sort of an other.
- 2:17Right?
- 2:18We and they, us versus them.
- 2:21And, ultimately, like, my work has been, like, with the aim to create a bigger we.
- 2:28So that's really the exploration that sits at the heart of facing history in ourselves, the
- 2:32organization you mentioned where I worked for over two decades, as an educational
- 2:37organization that uses lessons from history to challenge teachers and their students to stand
- 2:42up to bigotry and hate.
- 2:43So that is, you know, my background.
- 2:47And despite sort of decades of working in that space, I've found myself becoming more
- 2:54susceptible and falling into that zero sum trap of, like, we versus they.
- 3:00Right?
- 3:00If they aren't with us, then they must be against us.
- 3:04And what that meant in practical terms for me was that I found myself distancing myself from
- 3:11people that I had known my whole life that I had grown up with, like, the place, you know,
- 3:16where I was raised to, which is very different from where I live now, and just my own sort of
- 3:23sense of intolerance in a way around some things like political views, but, you know,
- 3:29sort of spilling over into other aspects of life.
- 3:32And my own hardening lines is in in many ways what brought me to this work and why I was
- 3:40drawn to the work of pluralism more generally.
- 3:43And then when I found New Pluralists, I wanted to be able to bring the skills that I had built
- 3:48in my career into this work.
- 3:52I think that's something, maybe not to the same extent, but a lot of people, if not everybody,
- 3:58should be able to relate to it in some way because and part of my work that I try to
- 4:04stress is that anybody can be susceptible to polarization.
- 4:08A lot of people think of it as just party or ideology, but in the effect of polarization,
- 4:14the feelings that we have about people, that's where anybody could be tripped up.
- 4:18I never got quite to the point where I cut off people that had different political views than
- 4:23me, but I definitely got into dumb Facebook arguments or got very angry about people I
- 4:29didn't know.
- 4:31And it's I mean, it's it's a very tempting trap to fall into that zero sum game just like you
- 4:37were talking about.
- 4:38And so let's go ahead and get into this more of this work description of what New Pluralist is,
- 4:48but let's obviously now hear it from somebody who's actually part of the organization.
- 4:52So what is New Pluralist exactly about and what are some of the ways it tries to achieve its
- 4:58goals?
- 4:59Great.
- 5:00Thanks for that.
- 5:01And yes, I I could have said when you were talking about Facebook fights that, like,
- 5:06unfriending, you know, has this, like, pull of something like a moment of powerful something,
- 5:11But over time, of realizing that I had, you know, unfriended my way out of relationships
- 5:17that mattered was kind of like that was a wake up moment.
- 5:21So, yes, just to tie tie that knot there.
- 5:23New Pluralist.
- 5:24Okay.
- 5:25New Pluralist is a funder collaborative.
- 5:27And for folks who are not maybe in philanthropy, what that means is a group of
- 5:32foundations that philanthropic foundations that have decided to pool their funds together to
- 5:39provide grants to organizations that are doing work on the ground in communities across The
- 5:45US.
- 5:45So we, as New Pluralists, take in funding from a number of foundations and then together,
- 5:52regrant that funding out to community work.
- 5:55So since New Pluralist was started in 2021, we have made grants totaling about $33,000,000 to
- 6:03about 100 grantees.
- 6:06So in terms of what the work is, pluralism work is often sort of shorthanded as, like, bridge
- 6:13building dialogue work, which is definitely a part of the work that we have funded.
- 6:18However, we have also mapped out about 11 or 12 different fields of work that bring pluralism
- 6:27to life.
- 6:27So for example, even my previous organization, a civic education organization, we never used
- 6:35the word pluralism there.
- 6:37And yet, clearly, like, the work that the organization and other civic ed groups are
- 6:42doing contributes to the culture and the sense of pluralism in this country.
- 6:48So things like civic education, a lot of work in immigration or sort of welcoming work, it's
- 6:54a different field of practice, a lot of traditional democracy building work is, you
- 7:00know, part of pluralism, Some narrative or storytelling work, like the stories we tell
- 7:05ourselves about ourselves and who belongs.
- 7:08And then infrastructure work, like the spaces and places that enable us as Americans to
- 7:16connect with one another, to solve problems together.
- 7:19Like, this is all part of what we know as pluralism work and fund.
- 7:24And then we also, at New Pluralists, are attending to not only work on the ground,
- 7:30although that is the primary way that we have made grants, but also to research.
- 7:36Everyone wants to know, like, what works to help people build stronger ties across
- 7:42difference.
- 7:43And so we have funded a ton of research as well.
- 7:48Nice.
- 7:49I I think you touched on something that is something I try to stress to a lot of people
- 7:56too is this, the people who work in the pluralist and civic health and civic education
- 8:03space, it's not disorganized, but there isn't as much cohesiveness, as much of a structure to
- 8:10it.
- 8:10It's it's a little bit disconnected from each other, whereas the groups that are very
- 8:16polarized that are purposely trying to divide people because it benefits them specifically.
- 8:23Ironically, they the ones that are more isolated have the more robust structure and
- 8:29connection and cohesiveness.
- 8:31And I think that's really great that you guys that's that's a really core part of what you
- 8:36do, having to be involved with a lot of these groups.
- 8:38Now, obviously, don't wanna just control what all these other groups do, but you still wanna
- 8:42have that sense of unity, that that sense of cohesion.
- 8:47And, you know, you were just talking about civic education and not using the word
- 8:53pluralism with one of your previous organizations.
- 8:56And another place I think that's a good segue into is that the word pluralism isn't exactly
- 9:02used, but it's very relevant to civic education is a lot of times when we talk about pluralism,
- 9:08it's talked about similarly to the concept that James Madison had described back in Federalist
- 9:13Paper number 10.
- 9:15This idea of a whole bunch of competing interests duking it out and no single one of
- 9:20them able to overpower everyone else because there's just gonna be too many disparate
- 9:25interests.
- 9:25But what is pluralism about to you?
- 9:28Is it that competitive aspect or is that competitive aspect of particular importance to
- 9:32you?
- 9:32Is it just the simple collaborative aspect of it?
- 9:37What what what exactly is pluralism about to you?
- 9:40Love this question.
- 9:41Thank you.
- 9:42So I define, or we at New Pluralists define pluralism as both a worldview and a practice.
- 9:51And so as a worldview, pluralism is the belief that we are better together.
- 9:59It's the belief that the coexistence of different opinions, worldviews, ways of life,
- 10:06value systems actually enriches all members of our society and that all people deserve respect
- 10:14in a sense of belonging.
- 10:15That's pluralism pluralism as a worldview.
- 10:19As a practice, pluralism is, like, the way that we actually engage, with the diversity that we
- 10:26encounter in our lives.
- 10:27Like, diversity is a fact of our lives.
- 10:29We live in a society that has, you know, people from different walks of life, different
- 10:35backgrounds, different belief systems.
- 10:37So how do we work across our differences such as, religion, gender, race, political,
- 10:45ideology, sexual orientation, socioeconomic status.
- 10:48Right?
- 10:49All of those sort of identifiers and or just, like, differences, rural and urban.
- 10:54All of the ways that we encounter difference, how we do that, how we navigate is the practice
- 10:59of pluralism.
- 11:00So put together, I often say that pluralism is how we want to be together and how we work
- 11:08across difference to get stuff done.
- 11:12Kind of I I see some parallels in in something I learned from grad school, my political
- 11:20campaigning program, which one of the big things that from the more practical side of the
- 11:25program was about campaign strategy versus campaign tactics.
- 11:29Basically, strategy basically being sort of more of the theory like you were talking about,
- 11:34sort of the philosophy, what your campaign is about, and then you have the tactics, which are
- 11:40a lot more like the practice you were talking about, how you exactly achieve those
- 11:43strategies.
- 11:44So I think that's a very good, efficient way to really think about that because obviously the
- 11:50theory is all well and good to have and it's nice to have these ideals that you're striving
- 11:55for, but if you don't have a practical way to get to it, the theory doesn't matter as much.
- 12:01So I can definitely respect and appreciate that.
- 12:05So talking about these more practical ways of making pluralism happen or improving pluralism.
- 12:15What would you say are, let's say, two to three key pieces that are necessary to having a truly
- 12:21pluralistic system, whether that's for the government or for some sort of program or
- 12:26initiative?
- 12:28Sure.
- 12:29Great question.
- 12:30So we can get practical right away, and I would start with the first key piece being dignity as
- 12:42a nonnegotiable.
- 12:44Right?
- 12:44So systems, initiative, program, whatever it is that's aiming to be pluralistic, must uphold
- 12:51the inherent dignity of all people and aim to create genuine experience of belonging.
- 12:57Right?
- 12:57We're it's aspirational often in in in our society, but that means, you know, that that
- 13:05intention and that real impact has to be baseline, number one.
- 13:13Second key piece are to get, you know, even more practical, like shared problem solving
- 13:21mechanisms.
- 13:22So I think the idea that to to ground the pluralism from being just an idea, we have we
- 13:32need structures and initiatives that allow people to address, like, their real challenges
- 13:38in their real lives and communities.
- 13:40Right?
- 13:40And so giving people both individual and collective agency to shape solutions that
- 13:46matter to their lives, like having structures and ways in place to make that possible is a
- 13:54key piece of demonstrating the power of pluralism and being pluralistic.
- 14:00And then the I would also say the sort of what we call, again, relational infrastructure.
- 14:08So creating spaces and opportunities for meaningful connection across differences.
- 14:13So how do people in communities actually connect and see one another as neighbors?
- 14:19Right?
- 14:19We've lost a lot of those spaces and ways that people have done that.
- 14:25We've you know, a lot has become privatized, more individualistic, or more isolated, and
- 14:31more more segregated.
- 14:32So but we see really powerfully how, like, where's the town square?
- 14:38Sometimes it exists in, like, faith communities, are places where people are coming
- 14:43together across particular kinds of differences even as they have something that they're
- 14:48holding in common.
- 14:50We're online.
- 14:51You know, we're technically more connected than ever in in history, but also that we have,
- 14:58like, millions of microspaces online.
- 15:00It doesn't actually mean, right, that people are connecting across.
- 15:03So I think, like, that that kind of infrastructure connected with or combined with,
- 15:08like, the structures for actual shared decision making with that foundation of dignity for all
- 15:14people are, like, the three beats I would hit as being, like, the key things.
- 15:19And then I'll add a fourth, which you actually referred to just a few minutes ago, which is,
- 15:24the infrastructure of the ecosystem of, you know, the people who are sort of making all of
- 15:30those things happen.
- 15:32The sort of behind the scenes tools and shared measurement and just coordination.
- 15:39As you said, like, these fields of work can feel very disconnected, and we're not aiming to
- 15:47impose, like, an agenda or sort of, you know, direct it all, but more coordination to able to
- 15:55build on momentum, to be able to share knowledge, to be able to help, you know,
- 16:01improve and grow the kind of work that we're talking about.
- 16:05That critical infrastructure, which is a role that New Pluralist plays, I think is the
- 16:09another, like, key piece to having this move beyond little pockets of success in communities
- 16:16to something that's more widely felt and experienced in our country.
- 16:22Interesting.
- 16:23A couple of the points that you you really hit on that I mean, obviously, I really find all
- 16:29those points intriguing, but there were a couple of points that really stuck out to me.
- 16:33You know, going to the very back of your answer was the that that dignity is non negotiable,
- 16:39and I obviously, I think that's fantastic.
- 16:42But at the same time, I think part the whole issue for a lot of these very polarized people,
- 16:50whether it's by party or by ideology or issue, is that they feel that their dignity has been
- 16:56completely challenged by the other side, and so they think it's okay to challenge the other's
- 17:00dignity, and it just kinda goes back and forth.
- 17:02You know, we can have all these different opinions about various issues like whether it's
- 17:10it's LGBT stuff or transgender participants in sports or guns or abortion or any policy you
- 17:18bring up.
- 17:19It's one thing to have a certain opinion, but you need to respect everybody else as a human
- 17:28being, regardless of what your opinion is.
- 17:32And unfortunately, that has been lost, especially when you talk about how some of
- 17:38these issues that people just automatically assume you're challenging somebody's dignity or
- 17:42their identity.
- 17:44And obviously that's something we need to strive to overcome.
- 17:50And then another point that you talked about was the the individual versus the
- 17:55collaborative, and I think that's that's something that needs to be talked about a
- 17:59little bit more Mhmm.
- 18:01As the whole, obviously or both things are important, but sometimes oh, like over here in
- 18:09America, sometimes we hew too much to the individual and we don't think enough about, you
- 18:15know, what is actually benefiting all of society or more of our individual groups, but
- 18:20we're not looking at the overall community.
- 18:22But then you have some other countries where the individual is basically not even considered
- 18:27and personal thoughts and feelings might not be considered, but it's all about the community.
- 18:32You really need that right balance to be struck, at least that's the way I see it.
- 18:38So what are two to three places or programs that you would point to as prime examples of
- 18:43how pluralism should work, whether or not they are initiatives that new pluralists have been
- 18:48directly involved in?
- 18:50Great question.
- 18:52I will I'll give a maybe an example or two of each.
- 18:56I mean, so I live in Los Angeles.
- 18:59And, you know, at the beginning of 2025, we experienced catastrophic wildfires.
- 19:05And communities across the country have been experiencing catastrophic weather events, you
- 19:14know, for a very long time.
- 19:16That is not new information, but just speaking from experience here, the mutual aid effort
- 19:23that followed.
- 19:24Right?
- 19:24Sort of where wherever and whenever disaster happens, it's really amazing to see who helps
- 19:31out.
- 19:31Right?
- 19:32How neighbors jump in, how people put aside lots of different kinds of differences and
- 19:39really come together.
- 19:40And two, it's really like there's a stat there our people are establishing invisible
- 19:46infrastructure, right, and rising above and rising to the challenge of seeing needs that
- 19:51need to be met and meeting them.
- 19:53And I think, like, outside of the formal or professional sector of, like, just defining and
- 20:00describing what that work is, like, just seeing how people know how to do that and do it
- 20:07everywhere are that to me are is a prime example of how pluralism should work.
- 20:15I think you can look at if we wanna go back in time and look at, like, major pieces of
- 20:24legislation or really critical, yeah, sort of movement moments in our country.
- 20:30For example, like, the Voting Rights Act Act of 1965, or we could name sort of many that
- 20:37required really broad coalition to get passed.
- 20:42Right?
- 20:43It's not necessarily what we learn about as much or what we've emphasized in the
- 20:50accomplishment of the thing, but, like, the work that it took, not just even politically,
- 20:56but across communities and different constituencies to figure out how to advance any
- 21:03one of those kinds of advancements in our country requires pluralism and is sort of an
- 21:09example of pluralism.
- 21:10In in terms of one of our grantees, actually, we we have been so fortunate to partner with a
- 21:17group called Future Caucus.
- 21:19They support the next generation of bipartisan elected leaders through training and networking
- 21:27and coalition building.
- 21:28They're helping young legislators govern effectively and collaboratively.
- 21:33They help them identify by their generation and by their common interests sort of first.
- 21:40And then together, they figure out in the structure within which they're working, the
- 21:45partisan structure, where can they work together?
- 21:48What bills can they put forward?
- 21:49What work could they advance?
- 21:51And I think that's the one kind of organization that we have supported that I think shows
- 21:58pluralism working in action even in a pretty tough environment sometimes to do that.
- 22:04And then my last example, which is not sort of politics related, but we've seen a lot of
- 22:11pluralism work in sort of transforming conflict and or sort of repairing after harm in a
- 22:19community.
- 22:20And so we have a partner resetting the table that really helps communities move from harm to
- 22:27healing by bringing groups together, you know, to address really, like, local trauma or
- 22:34violence, like the fractured relationships that can pull communities apart.
- 22:40And they've they have a pretty amazing track record of helping communities transform
- 22:45conflict into opportunities for greater understanding and collective action that really
- 22:50then can, like, lay the groundwork for stronger communities moving forward.
- 22:55So those are examples.
- 22:56Sorry.
- 22:57They were a little bit all over the place of, you know, what pluralism looks like in informal
- 23:04or, you know, sort of everyday life all the way up to sort of some big moments, you know, in
- 23:09our in our country's history to kind of like what it looks like on the ground today.
- 23:16I actually think that's really neat that you you took such a wide breadth of different
- 23:21organizations when it comes to pluralism.
- 23:24You basically highlighted it, maybe not directly saying it, but you more or less
- 23:31indicated it with your answer.
- 23:32And this is something that we often, and I'm going to include myself in this, that we often
- 23:37forget that pluralism doesn't necessarily have to be something inherently political.
- 23:42You were just talking about the last one with trying to work in against what fractures
- 23:47communities or your very first example with the mutual aid.
- 23:50None of those have to be specifically political.
- 23:54Now unfortunately, some people make those things political, but pluralism doesn't need to
- 23:59be something that's inherently about a political issue like, Oh, we need to have
- 24:04different viewpoints about or hear different viewpoints about things.
- 24:08It's just that whole coming together aspect that you're talking about.
- 24:12So it's not even about viewpoints.
- 24:13It's just, hey, we're all a community here.
- 24:16We need to band together and help lift everybody up.
- 24:21So I I think that's great that you you took such a wide variety of examples there.
- 24:26But, of course, this isn't all about the positive aspects about pluralism.
- 24:31Unfortunately, there's a lot about politics that isn't positive.
- 24:34But I wanna go into some of the challenges facing it just to really demonstrate what work
- 24:40still needs to be done.
- 24:41Clearly, are some people who don't value pluralism or at least don't place much
- 24:45importance on it, and that's for various reasons.
- 24:49So but for you, why do you think some people don't place proper value on pluralism, and what
- 24:56would you say to these people to demonstrate the value of pluralism?
- 25:01Yeah.
- 25:01This is, yeah, this is a real challenge.
- 25:05I will say that the work of new pluralists is explicitly nonpolitical.
- 25:11Like, we really do understand pluralism as being foundational to our ability to live in a,
- 25:20you know, democracy, like small d democracy, in the and navigate the diversity of the people in
- 25:29our society together well, and actually that we're better off for doing so.
- 25:33So that takes shape in all aspects of life, not just political life.
- 25:38But I think one of the challenges to pluralism well, there there are several.
- 25:45One is the misunderstanding or and or just, like, not familiarity with the word or limited
- 25:52view of what the word even means if if folks do know.
- 25:55But I think I mentioned earlier this this idea that pluralism is often shorthanded for sort of
- 26:02bridge building dialogue work when it actually encompasses all these other kinds of work that
- 26:07we've been talking about.
- 26:08Right?
- 26:09And so I think that's part of why it might be either undervalued or sort of, not prioritized
- 26:19is that it's, pigeonholed or sort of put into a box when essentially it's like a way of working
- 26:27to advance really all the issues that we care about towards the more durable solutions,
- 26:32right, by building bigger coalitions, by enrolling, like, the bigger we on board with
- 26:38the kinds of advancements we wanna make in society.
- 26:41Like, we won't necessarily continue to, like, flip flop back and forth between who's in
- 26:47power, who wins.
- 26:48Right?
- 26:48That's, like, a really tough cycle.
- 26:49It's hard to break out of.
- 26:51I think the other thing or a challenge to pluralism is often that it's seen as kind of
- 26:58weak or ineffective or sort of soft for too soft for addressing the real, quote unquote,
- 27:06real problems or urgent action.
- 27:09And we we see this in even talking about democracy work, pro democracy work.
- 27:16What's really what matters now?
- 27:18Right?
- 27:18There's this idea you were talking about earlier of, like, fighting fire with fire.
- 27:24Right?
- 27:24If if one group is doing this, then then the other group needs to counter it with, a
- 27:28stronger whatever it is.
- 27:31And we really challenge that notion.
- 27:37Number one, that it's a false choice between pluralism and urgent action.
- 27:43Like, those things are not mutually exclusive.
- 27:47We also are you know, think this is some of the hardest work that we'll ever do.
- 27:54It's not soft work.
- 27:55Right?
- 27:55It's sits underneath and at the foundation of us being able to make progress on any of the
- 28:01urgent challenges that we face.
- 28:03And so all that being said, we also know that there's critique of pluralism as, like,
- 28:11papering over real differences.
- 28:13Right?
- 28:13Like, let's just let's just find the common ground and and not address where you really do
- 28:21have profound differences.
- 28:22We don't that's not our understanding or our experience of how pluralism works, but I think
- 28:29that's one of the challenges that can make it hard for folks to come to the table because
- 28:35they feel like they won't we there won't be a real attending to power imbalances or some of
- 28:43the things you were mentioning earlier too where if groups really feel their their
- 28:48identity as being threatened and not upheld in terms of dignity, then, you know, like, how are
- 28:54they gonna really engage, and and how's that gonna work?
- 28:56So I think there's a number of challenges that we are up against.
- 29:02And to some extent, doing pluralism work is really asking folks to, like, go against the
- 29:07grain of the environment that we're in, and that can feel risky and that, you know,
- 29:13requires some some fortitude too.
- 29:16And and so that's also a challenge.
- 29:18Like, it's it's not always easy.
- 29:22Yeah.
- 29:22Yeah.
- 29:23Unfortunately, it's not easy.
- 29:25Otherwise, we would have fixed all all our issues.
- 29:27Right?
- 29:28Something you kind of got on was it's something I've been trying to work more with recently.
- 29:36I actually did an episode of this podcast just by myself about it, but I'm trying to do more
- 29:41with it, this concept of efficient versus deliberative government.
- 29:47And you kind of touched on it there with the know, is pluralism gonna, you know, bog down?
- 29:54Or or we sometimes you need swift action so we can't account for everybody's viewpoints, which
- 30:00maybe in some ways you can understand, but then is that the way to go in some cases, but not
- 30:06others?
- 30:08I mean, it's a bit of a different topic, but it just kind of made me think of that.
- 30:12But obviously, yeah, ideally you do wanna have as many different viewpoints as possible, but
- 30:19at some point a decision does need to be made and sometimes people won't be happy, but you at
- 30:24least hopefully hear everybody out or at least hear as many different viewpoints as you can.
- 30:30But that kind of goes into this next question I had.
- 30:34So we talk about how some people just don't want pluralism because they, like you said,
- 30:40need to fight fire with fire or they just they just wanna win and they don't wanna give up any
- 30:45ground to anybody.
- 30:47But on the flip side, in the past, a criticism of pluralism that I've heard has been that it's
- 30:54not that we aren't pluralist enough, but that we are so pluralist that there are so many
- 30:59competing groups that it's bogging down the system and leading to gridlock and policy
- 31:04paralysis or what some people call hyperpluralism.
- 31:07Do you think that there is any merit to those arguments?
- 31:10And whether you do or not, what would you say in response?
- 31:15Thank you for the question.
- 31:16I mean, yes, I hear that critique or that concern.
- 31:21Mean, I I don't think that pluralism is what is bugging us down.
- 31:26I can I recognize that, you know, challenges like polarization might be if they're, you
- 31:33know, actually unable to hear different sides and and actually come together?
- 31:38But I think to your point of trying to build durable solutions to the really intractable
- 31:46some you know, problems that we're facing, pluralism is the way.
- 31:52You know, Rachel Kleinfeld is a political scientist who talks about, you know, there's
- 31:58only sort of a few options for dealing with diversity and difference, and pluralism, you
- 32:04know, is the best for many reasons.
- 32:06But there's there is a recognition that we, in The US now, are the most sort of diverse
- 32:16society trying to do this thing.
- 32:18We've been you know, our the American experiment that has always been imperfect from
- 32:22the beginning continues to be imperfect, but it's coming up on, you know, two hundred fifty
- 32:28year anniversary that, you know, folks are really talking about.
- 32:31And, like, it's it it hasn't, like, been done before in a way.
- 32:38And so I think while there are lots of reasons to be critical of our systems and we have to
- 32:45look at policy paralysis and gridlock to and re rethink or reconfigure, like, how things can
- 32:53work better for people.
- 32:55Right?
- 32:57Not starting with dignity and belonging, you know, for all, not sort of leaning into
- 33:05thinking beyond binary solutions, like not embracing those pieces of pluralism or
- 33:11at least
- 33:11attempting is not a solution that's gonna take us where we wanna go.
- 33:17So, right, in democracy, if there's not an effort, as you said, to bring in representative
- 33:24voices as much as possible, then it's not it really you start to question the, like,
- 33:32democratic legitimacy of the decisions that get made.
- 33:35Right?
- 33:35And so pluralism is not about slowing everything down or sort of contributing to
- 33:40gridlock.
- 33:41It's really about ensuring decisions have enough buy in to stick to work and practice.
- 33:48And we have, you know, research or we've we've we've, supported research that I won't quote
- 33:53well off the top of my head.
- 33:55But, like, when you really survey Americans across all kinds of lines of difference, right,
- 34:01people generally care about and are concerned about similar things.
- 34:06Right?
- 34:06Affordability, can they provide for their family, children, safety, education.
- 34:11Right?
- 34:11There are health care.
- 34:13There are things that matter to people's lives that that are sort of consistent.
- 34:22And I say that to say the idea that needing to hear multiple perspectives will somehow slow us
- 34:29down really goes counter to, like, the core concern.
- 34:34There are core concerns that most folks agree on and most, like, mostly in direct like,
- 34:40directionality wise could get on board with to some extent.
- 34:44Obviously, it's easier said than done.
- 34:46But I think context matters and the alternative, like, non pluralist alternatives
- 34:53are worse.
- 34:53Decisions, like, made without that kind of representative participation could be faster,
- 35:00but come with a whole host of problems and challenges.
- 35:05And not to mention that it might not truly effectively solve the problem you're trying to
- 35:12solve, and it creates other issues that then take longer to solve, which you might have
- 35:16gotten fixed if you actually took a more pluralist route.
- 35:21And there was something else that you had said earlier on in that answer, and it it escaped my
- 35:25head.
- 35:25That that that that happens a lot, I think, or something, and then it just floats away
- 35:29immediately.
- 35:29Yeah.
- 35:31Hopefully, will.
- 35:32But but, yeah, I mean, that's at the very least providing people a voice would go a long way
- 35:41even if they don't automatically win or if they don't win a particular argument.
- 35:46At the very least, most people will feel like, Okay, At least I was heard out.
- 35:52I and and you hear that in even if you just talk about relationships in general between
- 35:58people, whether it's it's spouses or friends or anything like that.
- 36:02They least if they were heard by some by the other person, even if they're still upset about
- 36:09whatever it is that they're upset about, at the very least, they feel like, okay.
- 36:12Well, at least they heard me out as long as you're genuinely trying to hear them out.
- 36:16Sometimes, you know, there could be that token like, oh, yeah.
- 36:19We're we're yeah.
- 36:20Give us your feedback, but they don't really try to incorporate it.
- 36:22Hopefully, they actually do try to incorporate that feedback.
- 36:27So I know we just kinda talked about them already, but maybe just make it more concrete,
- 36:32very specific.
- 36:33What do you think are two to three of the largest threats to pluralism in America today?
- 36:40Sure.
- 36:40So I think there are three interconnected threats that we talk about at Newplora that are
- 36:49central to our work.
- 36:50The first is dehumanization.
- 36:52So we've been talking about this all throughout our conversation, but when people groups of
- 36:56people are stripped of their dignity and othered and seen as less than human with
- 37:03behaviors that follow.
- 37:06This it makes it hard to impossible to work across differences by, you know, not affording
- 37:15others, like, basic respect.
- 37:18So that's one.
- 37:20Disconnection would be the second.
- 37:22So this is a breakdown of the relationships, the norms and habits and relationships that
- 37:29really hold people together and connect people together across difference.
- 37:33There's sort of the isolation pieces of this, that, you know, crisis of isolation and
- 37:39loneliness and things that we hear about, which makes it harder than to see others' humanity,
- 37:44and find common ground.
- 37:45And then there's also structural segregation and the ways that our lives are just really
- 37:49separate from one another.
- 37:51And I would say within that, we are really attending to class divides at New Pluralist as
- 38:00being you know, I think about, like, sort of two Americas that people live in and where some
- 38:04of those dividing lines are.
- 38:06And I think across socioeconomic status or just, you know, whether that's a formal
- 38:10indicator or just a sense of, like, our people feel like they're thriving in their life.
- 38:17You know, there's, like, dividing lines there that are really keep us disconnected.
- 38:22And then the third piece that of the threat is distrust.
- 38:27Right?
- 38:27This is the erosion of confidence in others, like, goodwill and and and, like, also, of
- 38:35course, institutional distrust, which we see a lot of but as well, like, interpersonal
- 38:42suspicion.
- 38:43Right?
- 38:43This makes cooperation nearly impossible if we don't trust that the the other side has some
- 38:51good faith, you know, willingness to come to the table, it's really, really hard to engage.
- 38:56So we're when we're talking about plur cultivating pluralism, we're talking about
- 39:01cultivating a greater sense of belonging, greater sense of social trust, trust in one
- 39:07another and in our institutions, and then a greater sense of cooperation, like willingness
- 39:12to come together to solve problems.
- 39:14And I think the intersection of the of dehumanization, disconnection, and distrust
- 39:20undermines our ability to to do that.
- 39:23Those, I think, are the three biggest threats.
- 39:25And then for given that we're in philanthropy, I'll add that this work is also deeply
- 39:30underfunded sort of across philanthropy, but also, like, where we would see this work at
- 39:38scale, the infrastructure that's required to really hold communities together, all of that
- 39:43needs attending to as well.
- 39:47Yeah.
- 39:48Actually, the point about distress actually reminded me of something I was gonna say little
- 39:52bit ago.
- 39:53You you you talked about needing to obviously, other people, but you need to trust our
- 40:00political institutions.
- 40:02Yes.
- 40:03You can can critique things, and you should.
- 40:07And I I actually talked a little bit about that in my episode last week, but nothing is above
- 40:16criticism, whether it's people or institutions, but if you don't come at it from a good faith
- 40:24perspective, if you don't at least trust in the fact that these people are here to they want
- 40:31the same things you do or if you're talking about institutions that it's here to make the
- 40:34country better, but we can still critique these things.
- 40:38But if you're distrustful of them, that is going to just further erode our civic culture.
- 40:43And it's a very important part that you bring up there.
- 40:49And then on the disconnection part, that is something I think at least is getting talked
- 40:53more about.
- 40:54You talk about these we see a lot of these stories about people being radicalized, whether
- 41:02it's for terrorism or for some other sort of extreme ideology.
- 41:08How many times have we heard the person who was capable of that violence was disconnected from
- 41:14everybody else?
- 41:16And it's it's That's right.
- 41:18Sometimes we, you know, we do this to ourselves where we segment ourselves and isolate
- 41:23ourselves, but then, of course, you have a problem with social media algorithms also doing
- 41:27it and the fragmentation of media in general where there is a whatever it is you believe in,
- 41:34there's a very specific channel for you whereas like back in maybe twenty, thirty, forty, fifty
- 41:40years ago, even sixty years ago, you had relatively few channels, but more people from
- 41:48varying political views had to go to those channels.
- 41:53Now you can find anything to cater to what you want.
- 41:56And as long as we're if we can be more cognizant of it, it'll really go a long way to
- 42:03to fighting back against this disconnected feeling that a lot of us have.
- 42:07A lot of times in politics, there needs to be incentives for people to act upon something.
- 42:13So do you think we need to find a way to incentivize pluralism so that more people buy
- 42:19into it, or is it a simply a matter of education, or is it something else or some
- 42:24combination of the above?
- 42:27Yes.
- 42:27I love this question.
- 42:29I don't have the answer, but I do think it's a combination.
- 42:33I think I'll I'd spend a lot of time thinking about incentive structure.
- 42:37I think that there some of it is education, and some of it is, like, getting back to things
- 42:43that we've always known about being human and what connects us and and how to how to do that
- 42:50even as, like, we need to recreate or create new opportunities and things like that.
- 42:55But, I mean, I'm very concerned about the algorithm, for example, and the incentive
- 43:02structure that is it really incentivizes, like, contempt.
- 43:07And and so that's totally counter to what we're talking about.
- 43:13This you know?
- 43:14And so how exactly to you know, that can feel really overwhelming and then sort of
- 43:20disempowering.
- 43:21So I think I think about it or we think about it on sort of the daily practice, daily
- 43:28interactions, like, the really human side of life.
- 43:33And also that incentives would need to be about, like, how we act in, you know, it's sort
- 43:40of experiential.
- 43:41Like, you can't, like, think our way out of these things.
- 43:44We can talk more about that.
- 43:46But and that's, I think, the combination of what you're seeing in terms of education.
- 43:50I think education is super important.
- 43:52I also think, you know, how people learn is you know, there's formal education structures, yes,
- 43:59and then there's culture.
- 44:00And, you know, New Pluralist is entirely focused on culture change, not sort of policy,
- 44:05as we said, not in that realm, but what takes shape in culture, the norms, and habits, and
- 44:11ways of being together that we wanna promote, like, our forms of education.
- 44:16Like, how do we bring people in and bring people along and sort of and show how
- 44:22pluralistic ways of being are enriching and sort of can support people to improve improving
- 44:29lives.
- 44:29Like, that's, I think, the challenge that we are facing when it comes to how to incentivize
- 44:36this when sort of lots of forces are incentivizing the opposite.
- 44:42Yeah.
- 44:42And, of course, I strongly I'm a strong proponent of the civic education aspect, but
- 44:49there it is also a good idea to not necessarily totally separate, but to supplement alongside
- 44:56of the changing of the culture because even if you provide people an education, and I've
- 45:03talked about this with a previous guest of mine, some people just, you know, even if you
- 45:07teach them, they're like, okay, but why should I care?
- 45:10And in some ways, having it through fixing the culture is actually what's gonna teach them to
- 45:18care.
- 45:19Obviously, you know, some reforming of how we teach civics can go a long way, but in some
- 45:26ways the culture is really what needs to change for people to realize, oh, okay, I see why
- 45:32pluralism is so important.
- 45:34This is why pluralism helps to fix our communities is how we find these solutions.
- 45:39So definitely a good, not necessarily dichotomy, but a side by side kind of deal
- 45:46there.
- 45:47So obviously, we've talked a lot about the practical, actionable information about
- 45:54pluralism, and I especially like to end or come towards the end of podcast episodes with more
- 46:01practical tips.
- 46:02So, what are two to three practical ways that we as individuals can uphold and promote
- 46:09pluralism in our communities?
- 46:12Oh, I love this.
- 46:13Okay.
- 46:14First practical tip, we talked about this at the very beginning, but do the work to identify
- 46:20your own blind spots first.
- 46:22Where do you exist in an eco echo chamber?
- 46:25Sorry.
- 46:27An echo chamber.
- 46:29That awareness, I think, is both, like, really practical and grounded and then can lead to the
- 46:34next sort of steps or practical things that I might suggest.
- 46:38So the next one might be, like, do things across difference.
- 46:42Like, don't, you know, just think about wanting to be pluralistic, but, like, where can you
- 46:49connect with folks who you might not otherwise normally connect with?
- 46:54And, again, this doesn't have to be across political lines, but there's so many examples
- 46:58in communities of, like, community suppers where you know, that are meant to just help
- 47:04people know each other better or, you know, neighborhood block parties.
- 47:08I think somebody was telling me last night about, like, this block party tree lighting,
- 47:14you know, sort of thing that was happening in a neighborhood, you know, not far from me.
- 47:19I thought, right.
- 47:20Like, I could you could go show up somewhere different that it you'll find people that you
- 47:25haven't connected with.
- 47:26There's also, like, lots of collaborative problem solving, opportunities on very local
- 47:32issues, like, sort of happening all over.
- 47:34That's a little bit of investigative work to find where those things are happening in your
- 47:39community and show up.
- 47:40Doesn't mean you have to take take it all on, but, like, see what that's like to be in a
- 47:45space that's different than than where you typically spend your time and and the people
- 47:50you typically spend time with.
- 47:53I think there's also similarly opportunities or find an opportunity to just put yourself in a
- 48:00space where meaningful connection can happen.
- 48:02So we have another a grantee called warm cookies of the revolution.
- 48:07Right?
- 48:08And they use, like, really creative public events that invite people in to share stories,
- 48:14build trust, sort of co create futures.
- 48:16It's it's, like, fun too.
- 48:19And, you know, that goes to the point that I was making earlier.
- 48:22Like, some of this is hard.
- 48:23It's not always easy, and that is disincentivizing.
- 48:26Right?
- 48:26If you, like, know something's gonna be hard, it kinda makes it hard to show up.
- 48:30But there are plenty of spaces or there could be if you seek them out that that are meant for
- 48:36just building connection and are sort of low stakes in terms of, like, what the outcome
- 48:40needs to be.
- 48:41So I think practicing those kinds of things in our daily lives are ways to be pluralistic.
- 48:47And then the last one I would say really practically is to uphold dignity in our own
- 48:56everyday interactions.
- 48:57So, again, some of the dehumanization that we're seeing, it seeps in even when we don't
- 49:05intend to.
- 49:05Like, we're good people.
- 49:06We have right intentions.
- 49:07We, you know, learn the golden rule or we think we treat people well.
- 49:11Like, just that extra intention to treat others that we encounter with curiosity, with care,
- 49:18like, assuming things about people we interact with, just, like, disagreeing nonviolently or
- 49:25not escalating, like, just that that mindfulness, which I know, you know, can feel
- 49:31like a a big word to bring in here, but really, like, making the commitment to uphold dignity
- 49:37in our own interactions to me feels both practical and super important.
- 49:44The dignity part and inter interpersonal acts interaction or the echo chambers part, it's
- 49:51something I try to stress to other people and also to myself is when we talk about something
- 50:00like the freedom of speech in general, it's not just about if we really believe in the freedom
- 50:05of speech and other people's dignity, it's not just about government's actions, it's about
- 50:10what we also do.
- 50:11If we really want people to be free to express their opinions, be able to put forth their
- 50:18ideas, we need to actually practice being okay with those in our individual lives too.
- 50:23And unfortunately, those echo chambers are they're very tempting and they're very easy to
- 50:28fall into and it it does take a lot of work to break yourself out of it and to recognize when
- 50:34you're falling into those echo chambers.
- 50:36So definitely good to stress to stress those points and especially with the, you know,
- 50:43upholding dignity in each other's lives, which is also it's a lot harder to be vicious to
- 50:49people in real life as opposed to being on the computer and getting into, like we said
- 50:53earlier, dumb Facebook arguments or
- 50:55That's right.
- 50:56Or or just or Twitter, I mean, I guess is even worse.
- 50:59But, yeah.
- 51:01It's I I think that's another thing is just having more interpersonal interactions with so
- 51:06much interaction being online now.
- 51:09It it it's that also, I think, contributes a lot to Good point.
- 51:13Dehumanizing everybody.
- 51:14So before I get to the random question of the day, any final thoughts that you'd like to
- 51:19leave us with about pluralism or the work of new pluralists in general?
- 51:25Well, I really appreciate this conversation, and I think a reminder for me as much as for
- 51:32anyone as a sort of a final word who's who's watching or listening is that pluralism, isn't
- 51:39something you can just, like, study or advocate from afar.
- 51:42Right?
- 51:42It really is about this daily practice or daily choices to connect to affirm people's dignity.
- 51:51Like, it's it's it's something that you do you experience in your lived life.
- 51:56Yes.
- 51:56That can be online as well as sort of in the real world, but you we can't think our way to
- 52:04more pluralism.
- 52:05It and and it's it's meant to be lived and experienced, and I think it taps into the
- 52:10things that make us human.
- 52:12And therefore, because we are all human, we can all be pluralists.
- 52:19I think that's a great final point.
- 52:21Yeah.
- 52:21It is that's another thing too is just in general with politics.
- 52:25There's a lot of apathy or not wanting to get involved, which I can understand in respect to
- 52:31some extent because politics can get very nasty very just don't wanna deal with this, but you
- 52:38don't have to get into the mud to promote pluralism.
- 52:42It's the fact that it's the exact opposite, and we do need more people to truly support that
- 52:47regardless of whatever party or ideology is in question here.
- 52:54So that is going to end the pluralism part of our conversation.
- 53:00Now let's get into the random question of the day.
- 53:03So I like to, for those who are new, I like to end guest interviews with a random question of
- 53:08the day.
- 53:09It's fun, it's non political, might be simple, might be wacky, who knows?
- 53:16Well, I do because I'm about to ask it.
- 53:18But today's random question of the day for you, Liz, is should Pluto be upgraded back to full
- 53:26planet status?
- 53:29Wow.
- 53:30Okay.
- 53:30This is easy because I claim very little mastery or knowledge about our planetary world.
- 53:39But what I will say is as someone who believes in a bigger we, I don't like the idea that
- 53:45Pluto has been downgraded or demoted to somehow, like, less or they had a planet.
- 53:50I learned about Pluto as a planet, and so with no scientific this is, like, a totally non
- 53:56scientific answer.
- 53:58But, like, yeah, I want Pluto in the, like, planetary world.
- 54:01I want I want Pluto in our bigger way.
- 54:04So I'm with I'm full yes for no evidence or scientific reason.
- 54:09True true to your pluralist roots.
- 54:11That's right.
- 54:11We're we can't can't exclude Pluto.
- 54:14So That's right.
- 54:14Not quite I I agree, but not quite for the same reason.
- 54:17Georgia, mean, yeah, that's I mean, you had to change so many textbooks, and I remember I was
- 54:23a huge astronomy nerd when I was a kid.
- 54:25So I I just love all things space.
- 54:28Obviously, I can't devote as much time to it as I used to as a kid, but I I love space.
- 54:35But the reason why I think Pluto I mean, just besides the fact that why did we bother wasting
- 54:41our time changing this, is I find the main guy who led the charge to demote it, Neil deGrasse
- 54:51Tyson, which I I think is funny.
- 54:53Like, he's so beloved, but yet people were so pissed when Pluto got demoted from pull from
- 55:00full planet status.
- 55:01But I I personally can't stand Neil deGrasse Tyson.
- 55:04I think he's kinda pretentious and obnoxious.
- 55:07So just despite him, I think Pluto should be back to planet status.
- 55:12Very, very petty, very not pluralist of me.
- 55:16But Not pluralist also not scientific.
- 55:18So just to say, as an astronomer, that wasn't I wasn't expecting that answer.
- 55:24I'll say that one.
- 55:24Yeah.
- 55:25So yeah.
- 55:26No.
- 55:26I I I fully recognize the pettiness of it and yeah.
- 55:30It's but I I but I I do I do like Pluto just because it's so isolated out there, and it
- 55:37feels lonely.
- 55:38Yeah.
- 55:38I agree.
- 55:40But but maybe one day, Pluto.
- 55:42Hopefully, one day, you'll you'll get back to your rightful place.
- 55:45But with this, that's gonna end, today's episode.
- 55:49Of course, thank you so much, Liz, for coming on.
- 55:51Before we go, though, any other links that you wanna share?
- 55:55Obviously, I'll share New Pluralist's website, but is there anything else you wanna put up?
- 55:58That's great.
- 55:59Thank you so much for having me, Paul.
- 56:01Thanks for the conversation.
- 56:02Alright.
- 56:03Yep.
- 56:04That'll do it.
- 56:04So my links, my Facebook, my Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn profile, my medium.com
- 56:10profile I run on from time to time, my website, paulrayder.org, PaulRayderWritesgmail dot com
- 56:15if you wanna email me, and my five day educational email course about how we can all
- 56:21better mitigate polarization.
- 56:23I think it's very relevant to today's topic.
- 56:26So that is going to wrap things up for us.
- 56:30So thank you so much for listening and we'll see you next time.