Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Give Negative Feedback Without Sounding Like Your Boss
Transcript
- Lucas: Okay, here's a question that came in from a listener named Priya, and I think it's one of those that a lot of people feel but rarely say out loud. Luna: I'm ready. What's she dealing with? Lucas: Priya says: 'I need to give critical feedback to a peer on my team. He's a senior guy, been at the company longer than me. His part of a recent presentation was confusing and kind of rambling. I'm the one who has to tell him, and I'm dreading it. How do I do this without making him defensive or damaging our working relationship?' Luna: Oh, this is hard. Because the power dynamic is off. She's junior in tenure, but she's been asked to deliver the message. That's a tightrope. Lucas: It really is. And I think the instinct most of us have is to soften the message so much that it loses all meaning. Or we avoid it entirely and just hope someone else will say something. But that doesn't help anyone. Luna: Right. So what's the alternative? There has to be a framework that makes it less personal. Lucas: Yeah, there is. And it's one I've seen work across a lot of different workplaces. It's called the SBI model—Situation, Behavior, Impact. You describe the specific situation, the specific behavior you observed, and then the impact it had. No judgment, no character analysis. Luna: Situation, Behavior, Impact. That's clean. Can you walk us through how Priya would use that for her peer? Lucas: Sure. So she might say, 'Hey, in yesterday's client review meeting, when you walked through the Q3 numbers section, I noticed you went into a lot of detail on the methodology behind the forecast. The impact was that we ran over time and the client seemed to lose the thread on the main takeaways.' That's it. She's not saying he's a bad presenter. She's not saying he's disorganized. She's pointing at a specific moment and the consequence. Luna: I like that because it's almost scientific. It's data. It's not 'you were rambling,' which feels like an attack. It's 'here's what happened, here's what happened next.' Lucas: Exactly. And the beauty of it is, it leaves room for the other person to respond without getting defensive. He might say, 'Oh, I didn't realize we were short on time. I thought the client wanted that detail.' And then you can problem-solve together. That's a conversation. That's not a confrontation. Luna: What about the common advice to use a 'feedback sandwich'—positive, negative, positive? Does that work? Lucas: I think the feedback sandwich is well-intentioned, but it often backfires. When someone hears the positive opener, they know the negative is coming. So they're just waiting for the other shoe to drop. And after the negative, that second positive feels hollow. It dilutes the message. Luna: Yeah, I've been on the receiving end of that. It feels like a script. Like, 'Great job on the report. But...' and you just brace yourself. Lucas: Right. So instead of the sandwich, I'd recommend what some people call 'radical candor'—care personally, challenge directly. You can still lead with genuine appreciation if it's real. But don't pad it. Say, 'I really value your deep expertise on the numbers. And for this client, I think we need to stay at a higher level. Can we trim that methodology section next time?' Luna: That's a complete sentence. It's respectful, but it's clear. And it gives him a specific action to take. Lucas: Yes. And that's the other piece: always end with a request or an offer to collaborate. 'Next time, do you want me to give you a five-minute warning if we're running long?' That makes it a partnership. Luna: So for Priya, the script might be: mention the situation, the behavior, the impact, and then a suggestion. That's four moves. Lucas: That's it. And she should practice it out loud first. Even just once. It makes a huge difference. Luna: What about the fear that the senior person will just shut down? Or push back? Lucas: That can happen. And if it does, I think the move is to stay curious. Say, 'I might be wrong about the impact. What was your read on the room?' That opens the door for him to explain his reasoning. And you might learn something—maybe the client actually asked for that detail offline, and he was just being thorough. The feedback still stands, but now you understand the context. Luna: That's a good point. Feedback isn't about being right. It's about aligning on what works best for the team. Lucas: Exactly. And I think a lot of us avoid giving feedback because we're afraid of that pushback. But the cost of not saying anything is often higher. The team's performance suffers, the person never improves, and resentment builds. Luna: So the real skill is learning to deliver it in a way that preserves the relationship while still being honest. Lucas: Yeah. And it's a skill. You get better with practice. Priya is already on the right track by thinking about it carefully instead of just blurting something out. Luna: Let's talk about timing. Should she do it immediately, or wait for the next one-on-one? Lucas: I'd say as soon as possible, but not publicly. Definitely not in front of others. Pull him aside for a quick chat. And frame it as a 'here's something I noticed that I think could help us next time.' That makes it about the future, not the past. Luna: So the message is forward-looking. Not 'you messed up,' but 'let's do even better next time.' Lucas: Exactly. And if she's really nervous, she can even start by saying, 'I wanted to share some feedback because I think we work well together and I want to keep it that way.' That sets a positive frame. Luna: That's disarming. It says 'I'm on your side.' Lucas: Yeah. And it's true. She is on his side. She just wants the presentation to be better. Luna: Okay, one more thing. What if the person is above you? Like, what if a listener needs to give critical feedback to their manager? Does the same framework apply? Lucas: It applies, but the stakes are higher. When giving feedback upward, I'd add one more step: ask for permission first. Say, 'I have some feedback on how our team meetings are running. Is now a good time to share?' That gives the manager control. And then you use SBI the same way. Luna: That makes sense. You're respecting the hierarchy while still being honest. Lucas: Exactly. And a good manager will appreciate it. Most managers are starved for honest feedback. Luna: You know, before we wrap, I want to mention something real quick. A lot of listeners have asked how we keep this show going without ads. And honestly, it's because of a handful of people who chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. If you've gotten value from episodes like this one—maybe it helped you in a tough conversation or a career decision—that's the kind of support that keeps the lights on. No pressure, just gratitude. Lucas: Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up. It's humbling that people are willing to support what we do here. And it allows us to stay completely listener-funded, no sponsors to answer to. So thank you to those who do. Luna: Absolutely. And now back to feedback scripts. Lucas, what about a scenario where the feedback is about something the person can't easily change—like their communication style? Lucas: That's where you have to be careful. You can't ask someone to fundamentally change their personality. But you can ask for a specific adjustment in a specific context. Like, 'In our team meetings, when you interrupt someone, it can make people hesitant to share ideas. Could you try letting them finish before jumping in?' That's behavioral. It's actionable. Luna: And it's about the impact on the team, not about them as a person. Lucas: Right. And if they push back, you can always say, 'I might be wrong. Let's check in with the team and see how they feel.' That takes the pressure off you as the sole judge. Luna: I love that. It makes feedback a hypothesis, not a verdict. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a mindset shift that can make all the difference. Luna: So let's quickly recap for Priya and anyone else in her shoes: use the SBI model—Situation, Behavior, Impact. End with a request or an offer to help. Keep it private. And frame it as a way to improve together. Lucas: And practice it. Seriously. It's like a muscle. The first time is the hardest. It gets easier. Luna: Thanks for the question, Priya. And if you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, you can send it to us at fexingo dot com. We might use it in a future episode. Lucas: That's it for today. Good luck with that conversation. You've got this.