Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 154: Understanding childcare in Paris: the nanny's view with Lise Scott
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. Whether or not you have
- 0:13children, chances are you've heard that France's childcare
- 0:16system is among the best in Europe, both in terms of public
- 0:20and private options. There's the cash subsidized
- 0:24daycare, shared nannies, au pairs, and full time nannies who
- 0:28make, or should anyway, a living commensurate with their
- 0:31experience and hours worked. Since more and more foreigners
- 0:34are moving to Paris with children or with the intention
- 0:36to have children, it's important to understand the landscape.
- 0:40I happen to know someone who works in this world and I
- 0:43thought it was time to get her story, her views on child
- 0:46rearing in Paris specifically, the options that exist, the dark
- 0:50side of the business and how it all compares with the UK and
- 0:53Germany where she has both lived and worked.
- 0:57Meet Liz Scott Liz. Hello.
- 1:01Welcome to the show. Thank you for having me.
- 1:04I have wanted to talk to you about your work for a long time
- 1:08because I'm fascinated a by the world of childcare in Europe and
- 1:16how that compares to what I know in the US from friends.
- 1:21But also we tend to all the all the sort of writing and
- 1:25reporting I've done on, you know, the, the French approach
- 1:29to maternity and motherhood. And all of that comes from
- 1:33mothers themselves and not from the position of a caregiver.
- 1:38And you are in this unique position.
- 1:40I am to be someone who comes from England.
- 1:45Yeah, who has lived in several places doing this work.
- 1:48True. And have you, you have a
- 1:52reference point that is broader than many.
- 1:54So that's Part 1. Also, I think you're wonderful
- 1:59and smart and very funny and we met at a wedding.
- 2:02Thank you so much. And you're wearing a cat dress,
- 2:05which no one can see, which I'm very touched by.
- 2:10So I guess the, the motivation for doing this now is that we're
- 2:15in a period where people are moving to France.
- 2:17I mean, they're always moving to.
- 2:18France, everyone's always moving.
- 2:20It's true. And within Europe that's very
- 2:22easy. But we also have a lot of
- 2:24Americans who are actively trying to get over here, whether
- 2:30it's because, in general, the quality of life is better,
- 2:34because it's, you know, more affordable in terms of childcare
- 2:38and because of the current turmoil.
- 2:41Yes, my client at the moment is actually American, so good
- 2:45point. Good point, right?
- 2:46And she's here for professional reasons.
- 2:48Exactly. But I imagine that she's fully
- 2:51aware. Of the childcare benefits and
- 2:54that was clearly mentioned during my interview and
- 2:58throughout the course of our working together.
- 3:00So yeah. OK.
- 3:01So, so that's a that's a clear factor.
- 3:03And I also think that American families romanticize or glorify
- 3:09a little bit how much better it is over here.
- 3:13And I think there's a little bit of nuance that would be helpful
- 3:17to indeed to illuminate because it's not perfect and the costs
- 3:23vary wildly. True.
- 3:25So before we get into all of that, though, did you start off
- 3:30as a as a nanny because you work as a professional, what I would
- 3:34call a premium nanny? I don't know if that's even an
- 3:36appropriate term The. Correct term is high profile.
- 3:40Really. Yeah, it's a high profile or
- 3:43ultra high net worth nanny. So because you work, you're sort
- 3:49of full time with the same family.
- 3:52It depends actually, so I have one full time family and then I
- 3:56lease myself out to several other people.
- 3:59Like if I have a week or two weeks off, if I work weekends,
- 4:04nights. So you can do other things.
- 4:06Yeah, I work for multiple people simultaneously, but yes I have
- 4:10one current full time job. OK.
- 4:13And that is has always existed, right?
- 4:15This type of. Since the dawn of time, depends
- 4:19on what labels we've put on it, but I think the earliest job
- 4:23people might be more familiar with is the wetness.
- 4:27Ah, yes. Which, yeah, traditionally lots
- 4:29of black women did. Lots of slaves did.
- 4:33Because yeah, it's not very. I mean, if you just have to
- 4:39think about romanticizing breastfeeding, I mean no.
- 4:42But they actually that's illegal.
- 4:44Now, right, it's illegal, right? But you have actually still a
- 4:47huge market in the US of people that still do that, like black
- 4:53market style, like women that just produce lots of milk and
- 4:57have some, there's a name for it.
- 4:59Women that have like an attachment to like the want to
- 5:04nurture a child through, you know, the action of
- 5:07breastfeeding. Even if they're not just out of
- 5:11giving birth themselves, they're just naturally producing milk.
- 5:14They keep feeding other people's babies so that they continue to
- 5:20produce the. Milk.
- 5:21My gosh. Wow.
- 5:22Yeah. And then sometimes they also
- 5:23pump and sell the milk which. Jesus.
- 5:26I could actually be very helpful for neonatal premature babies,
- 5:31that kind of thing. It's helpful, but.
- 5:33But it's still a black market. It's definitely black market.
- 5:37So OK, so this, this, the various forms of childcare have
- 5:41existed. Did you start off your career
- 5:44this way? I did not so tell.
- 5:46Me about how you got into this. It's quite a story actually, and
- 5:50it's one that I've been meaning to tell.
- 5:53Wow, how long have I been nannying for now?
- 5:5620 years. So I've been meaning to tell it
- 5:59for certainly the last five years, but I just, I haven't
- 6:03found the correct outlet, Podcast, movie, TV series.
- 6:09Who knows who's listening so. There you go.
- 6:11So basically I studied business and finance.
- 6:14Originally, I worked in a very affluent area of London, which
- 6:19is where I'm from. I was on my lunch break in a
- 6:23park in Chelsea. There was a woman on the
- 6:26telephone and she was with her child.
- 6:29And she was like, oh, darling, you know, stop trying to get my
- 6:36attention. You know, I really need to take
- 6:38this phone call. Mommy will be with you in a
- 6:40second. And the child was just like,
- 6:42mommy, mommy, mommy, please. And it sounds creepy now, but
- 6:48back then it wasn't creepy to be like, hello little girl, what
- 6:51are you doing? Do you need me to entertain you
- 6:54for a minute? I felt.
- 6:55Really sorry for her like she wanted.
- 6:57She was making a Daisy chain. She wanted to play with her mum
- 7:01in the park. The mum was too busy.
- 7:03She took the call. Fine, no judgement.
- 7:06All things need to be done. And so I just went over.
- 7:09She was really opposite me. And I went over and I was like,
- 7:11hello, my name's Lizzie, I'll do it with you.
- 7:14Mummy's busy. And when the mum came off the
- 7:17phone, she was like, Oh my gosh, thank you so much.
- 7:20Like, I really needed to take that call.
- 7:22It was so important. Are you a nanny, by the way?
- 7:26Listen, we don't have much time, but we really need someone for
- 7:29Saturday. Take my card and call me.
- 7:32And I was just like, before I could even explain that, no, I
- 7:37wasn't a nanny and that I was just on my lunch break.
- 7:40I was like, you know what? I'm going to take stock and
- 7:43think about this for a moment because I am at a point in my
- 7:46career where I'm bored of sitting in the office.
- 7:49I never really wanted to do the whole corporate thing.
- 7:53I was working for Red Bull Racing in the finance
- 7:56department. That's.
- 7:57Right. So lots of money, fast pace.
- 8:01I'd been used to seeing celebrities and drivers come in
- 8:04and out of like HQ and offices anyway, and I turned up to the
- 8:09house on Saturday. I was like, I'm just going to go
- 8:12like I've always wanted to go into someone's house in Chelsea
- 8:16in London and have a like nosy around.
- 8:20Like, I've always been into interiors and things like that.
- 8:24So I turn up and then a famous actor opens the door.
- 8:29Oh, boy. So I won't say their name
- 8:31because generally I never say people's names that I work for
- 8:35because of they are always generally people in the public
- 8:40eye. But this famous actor opens the
- 8:42door and he it was a he, he said hello, Lizzie.
- 8:48And I was just like, oh, it's you.
- 8:52And he was like, yes. And you're called Lizzie.
- 8:55Oh my gosh. I have a friend called Lizzie.
- 8:57And then and then it that it just started from there.
- 9:01I was like, yes, I'm going to work for this person.
- 9:04I can do it. I think I can.
- 9:06But it started as like a one off I.
- 9:07Started as a one off. I was very honest with the the
- 9:11clients and I was just like, this is what I do normally, but
- 9:15I have X amount of brothers and sisters.
- 9:19I really like kids, blah, blah, blah.
- 9:22And they were like, well, you're good-natured with her.
- 9:24Let's just give it a go. It's not full time, it's just
- 9:27part time. Tell us if you want to do it or
- 9:30not. And I completely aced it.
- 9:32And then one high profile review to another, to another, work for
- 9:37my friend, work for their friends.
- 9:39And then eventually I went on to study childcare things so.
- 9:44You do have to get at some point sort of a certification.
- 9:47I think if you want to justify why you want a sustainable
- 9:52amount of money, right, not just, you know, the dredges like
- 9:56some pocket change. You know, the thing with my job
- 10:00is that lots of people don't understand the differences
- 10:04between, you know, babysitter, nanny, governess, teacher,
- 10:09tutor. Do we still use the word
- 10:11governess? We do.
- 10:12Yeah, certainly the agencies do. Wow.
- 10:15Yeah, there are so many. Well.
- 10:17What is? What is a governess?
- 10:18Governess is. Generally someone that's older
- 10:22and it is more still the caretaking part of the role, but
- 10:26a nanny is more, it's more listed as like a daily nanny.
- 10:32You have a daily nanny and a night nanny and you're
- 10:34responsible for like the child's milestones and things like that,
- 10:41educational development and as well as having the pedagogical
- 10:45experience. Governess is more of like a
- 10:48child minder, but then you also have one of those.
- 10:51So it just depends. It just depends.
- 10:53But I think when you work with agencies and high profile
- 10:57clients, the definitions of the job titles are certainly more
- 11:02clear and sometimes they spill into the other and mean the same
- 11:05thing. But you will always see the same
- 11:095-6 type of titles in agencies. And then if you go to nursery
- 11:14schools or private homes, then it's listed differently as well.
- 11:18Yeah. Well, how long were you doing
- 11:20that work once you left your job?
- 11:22Yep. In London before you moved here
- 11:26because you know your trajectory.
- 11:28Yeah, wow, let me see then. God, maybe 5 or 6 years.
- 11:37Come in. Yeah.
- 11:38Five or six years. And then I thought, do you know
- 11:40what? And then that I wasn't really
- 11:43familiar with the term travel nanny.
- 11:45I knew people did it and I knew that the type of people I worked
- 11:49for travelled often on private jets to film premieres, to
- 11:54modelling shoots, depends on what their job is.
- 11:58But I was like, oh, I can't do that.
- 12:00You know, it's not really for me.
- 12:02There's, there's enough business in London.
- 12:04And then I was just like, actually, do you know what?
- 12:06Why not? Like I do want to travel more
- 12:10and I'll just go, you know, not far.
- 12:12Let's try France for baby steps. So you, but you came here
- 12:16without having the family true to bring you over.
- 12:20Exactly, I didn't. I came as an independent person
- 12:24pre Brexit. Pre Brexit.
- 12:27So you could be here. Wasn't yet joined to an agency.
- 12:30So I was again, just asking, looking around myself and I
- 12:35found some clients just through contacts.
- 12:38They weren't so super high profile in the beginning.
- 12:41Because I think before you move to a country, it's also
- 12:45important for a nanny or a Manny, I might add, to research
- 12:52the market. What does celebrity mean in that
- 12:55country that you want to go to? Does it exist?
- 12:58Do they have a reputation for hiring different types of staff
- 13:04for the household? And you know, in the UK,
- 13:09celebrity culture is like up there.
- 13:12You know, which is very different from here, but yeah.
- 13:15But also, I know that you've not always worked for people in
- 13:18that, at that level at all. And you were here and then
- 13:23eventually you moved to Berlin, yes, where you stayed eight
- 13:26years, 7-7 years. And why did you end up leaving
- 13:29Paris? I ended up leaving Paris, so
- 13:33from London moved to Paris, lived here and worked here for 9
- 13:36years and then moved to Berlin because I was dating someone who
- 13:41was German. They always get you that way.
- 13:45So I went to Berlin on the holiday, met someone and I was
- 13:49do you know what? There are agencies here too.
- 13:52I can work anywhere. Obviously in terms of, you know,
- 13:58affluence or purchasing power, very different going from London
- 14:01to Paris to Berlin in terms of what people are conditioned
- 14:06maybe to think is appropriate to spend for their children, right.
- 14:12So how did? How do they all compare?
- 14:14Yeah, this Moving to Berlin from Paris was actually my biggest
- 14:18motivation to earn more money and climb the career ladder.
- 14:23Sounds a bit weird moving to like global fashion city to
- 14:28another one that's more known for like, artistic, artistic,
- 14:32underground living, clubbing culture.
- 14:35I mean, Berlin has changed enormously in the last decade,
- 14:4015 years. And I read up on this and was
- 14:43obviously talking to my boyfriend about this.
- 14:46And in France, you have something that everyone's
- 14:52familiar with called an au pair, right?
- 14:54And it means basically to be on equal terms, au pair.
- 14:59And a lot of people don't actually realize that to work
- 15:04legally in France as an au pair, you need to be under the age of
- 15:0927. You can only work part time,
- 15:13maximum of 20 hours per week. The family that you work for
- 15:18need to provide you with lodgings, whether it's with them
- 15:22or in a chamber de bond, and you're only allowed to have
- 15:27pocket money so you can't earn a salary.
- 15:31Interesting. So this is heavily ingrained in
- 15:35many upper class French families.
- 15:39So they. Assume that if you are a nanny.
- 15:42Yes. That's what you'd be.
- 15:44Doing you must be an au pair or a babysitter, and it's not.
- 15:48I mean, obviously we're just generalizing.
- 15:51Not all French people think that, but a lot of people assume
- 15:55that. So then when you ask for the pay
- 15:57grades that a high profile nanny wants to earn without an agency,
- 16:02people automatically think negatively of that.
- 16:05And they're like, well, what are you bringing to the table?
- 16:08This is how much I want to pay or this is how much I deem
- 16:12feasible. You just have to advocate for
- 16:14yourself. And in Berlin, it's not like
- 16:16that at all, especially with the boom in like tech companies that
- 16:21moved over there, lots of new money, young professionals,
- 16:26people that really understand like the New Berlin and wanting
- 16:30to step out of the past and. Are you suggesting also that the
- 16:35only sort of, well, I guess, that nannies who are not at
- 16:39your, you know, working with families of the same net worth,
- 16:46are they automatically being undervalued?
- 16:49Yes, absolutely. Especially in France actually,
- 16:53which was one of the key reasons I thought let's just leave
- 16:58because even having like the background that I did the
- 17:02reference, there's that I had, people were still always
- 17:06questioning like my salary, why do you need that much?
- 17:10But it's not this much. I can find 10 other girls this
- 17:13much. And actually you have quite a
- 17:15lot of undocumented people. Well, of course, in France,
- 17:19anywhere you have undocumented people.
- 17:21And this is where exploitation comes in short, you know, it's
- 17:25like, why should I pay you with an education with 15 years of
- 17:30work experience when I can just find a lady in the park who has
- 17:35enthusiasm just as good as you? I mean, that's how you started
- 17:39after all. I can pay her like €10 an hour
- 17:43or less, I mean. And, and you're part of chat
- 17:46groups, from what you've told me.
- 17:48Yeah. So not only women who are
- 17:50working for the families that you work for, but sort of across
- 17:54the board. Yeah.
- 17:55And there are some horror. Stories.
- 17:56Yeah, absolutely horrific stories even today in like 2026.
- 18:01Like I really try my best as a person in my 40s to try and
- 18:07advocate for women in their 20s or teens even that are moving
- 18:12here from Indeed America or all over the world that just want a
- 18:17better life or want to experience living in the land of
- 18:21cheese and wine right now and just how to take care of
- 18:25yourself. What are they supposed to do
- 18:27when, you know, I think you've told me a story where someone
- 18:29was like, no, I want to pay you €6.00 an hour.
- 18:32And I mean, how does she, how does a woman like that live?
- 18:35And she doesn't live in Paris, right?
- 18:37You have to say no. It's the moment you think you
- 18:41need to say yes, either to please that person or because
- 18:45you're already living on the breadline.
- 18:47Like there has to be another way.
- 18:49Like you can get more money than that cleaning homes, right?
- 18:54Like there are so many other jobs you can do.
- 18:57You might not think that you want to do it or that you're
- 19:00capable of doing it, but when there's a will, there's a way.
- 19:04And your determination has to be strong because the minute you
- 19:07say yes and let someone exploit you that way, it shows and tells
- 19:14other people that, OK, just do it.
- 19:16It won't be like that forever. But then you meet women that are
- 19:19stuck in these kinds of jobs and with that pay grade for the
- 19:23entire time they're in Paris because they do ask your ex
- 19:27employer how much you earn or what they did or you know.
- 19:32And then there are the horror stories of families, wealthy
- 19:36families often taking their passports and, and sort of
- 19:39locking them into these positions.
- 19:41So, you know, it seems like there's a lot we, we sort of
- 19:45take it take for granted when we see these women in the parks
- 19:50with these children or walking through the, you know, doing
- 19:52school pickup. And, and you know, they, they
- 19:57always seem, I mean, just from my perspective, they seem really
- 20:01warm and wonderful with these kids.
- 20:03It's true. But you just sort of wonder how
- 20:04are they actually being treated? You never know the back story
- 20:07and I think it's just in any job to anyone, just be friendly, be
- 20:13kind, talk to someone if they're in your proximity, you know,
- 20:18it's all just about being friendly.
- 20:20You know it takes 2 minutes to be like, hello, how are you?
- 20:24The opening question, you know, someone might be like I need
- 20:28help, Someone might be like I'm fine, or someone might be like,
- 20:32I'm OK. But you need.
- 20:34To read the signals. And I do this almost every day
- 20:37when I go out with my charge. Like I just talk to people, to
- 20:41women and I'm like, are you really OK?
- 20:44And they're like, yes, yes, actually, I'm fine.
- 20:46Like life is great. And I'm like, good for you.
- 20:49Have a nice day. But one time in like a week
- 20:53someone will be like can you help me?
- 20:57And what do you do in that case? I'll ask them what their
- 20:59background is, how they came here, do they know anyone else
- 21:03here? Are they represented by an
- 21:05agency, or do they know about free legal advice that's
- 21:10available to them to join a women's group?
- 21:14Maybe I already know someone that's looking and they're
- 21:18kinder to people. So yeah, I mean there are lots
- 21:22of ways you can help. Have you been in a situation in
- 21:27any of the places you've worked where it's been limit or where
- 21:32you've been where it could have been a situation?
- 21:39In respect to like how I'm being treated or paid?
- 21:43No. In terms of like maybe a parent
- 21:48trying to hit on me or something.
- 21:50Oh gosh, that's a different kind of.
- 21:52Oh, that's a cinematic story. Isn't it, You know, it happens
- 21:55where you know, you're the trusted person, you're so kind
- 21:59with the children, you're also single.
- 22:02I mean, it happens all the time. And for sure there are movies
- 22:06that have already been written about it.
- 22:08I'm not going to just blame it on the dads.
- 22:11But you've also had, from what I remember, you know, some extra
- 22:15gigs you've taken on where the families haven't paid you what
- 22:19you were owed. Yeah, yeah, actually, yeah.
- 22:23Do you know what that has happened recently?
- 22:25Yeah, you you probably try to block it.
- 22:27Out. But yeah, you do block out these
- 22:29really crappy things. But yeah, that has happened
- 22:31recently because, you know, rich people also stay rich by not
- 22:35paying for anything, right? You know, they get given 3 free
- 22:40things, they get taken on free trips.
- 22:44Yeah. And I have worked for someone
- 22:46not so not in the distant past where I outlined the job before,
- 22:53asked them what they needed. We agreed the rate, went on the
- 22:56trip, did the work. But then for some reason, their
- 23:01idea of the trip didn't go according to how they thought it
- 23:05would. So they decided to pay me less
- 23:08than what we agreed. And it was like, you're just in
- 23:13shock when that happens because you're like, why are you doing
- 23:16this to me? Like what?
- 23:18And then they're, they always come up with an excuse like,
- 23:21well, you know, we actually ended up looking after our own
- 23:25child for a portion of this trip.
- 23:28Or wasn't that so you could sleep for two seconds?
- 23:31It's like these things happen. I mean think about it, if you
- 23:35have a child, a nanny and a parent on say a flight right,
- 23:43who is the child going to want to be with?
- 23:45This is my first advice to any parent.
- 23:48If you take a nanny on a trip, even if it seems mean to do so,
- 23:53sit the nanny with the child away from you.
- 23:57Have your flight by yourself or with your partner.
- 24:00Have a glass of champagne, read a book.
- 24:02Count it as you time if you want to sit with the nanny and with
- 24:07your child. Just know that your child is
- 24:10always going to choose you first, right?
- 24:12Of course, natural. It's the child.
- 24:14Will choose you before the stranger that has been paid to
- 24:18look after them, right? Of course.
- 24:20So you you will have to do your share of childcare work.
- 24:24It's just, it's just shocking to hear that they, you know, are
- 24:29such in such bad faith. Yeah, right.
- 24:31And going. Back on their agreement.
- 24:33But now, nowadays, you know, it's just more of like the
- 24:36silent retreat. You're like, OK, I've asked you
- 24:39to pay me fairly. You've said no, I'm just going
- 24:43to walk away from this situation and maybe karma will come for
- 24:46you or pretend you didn't realize.
- 24:50And I don't know, and you don't know what these people are
- 24:54thinking at the time of when you do the job or after the job when
- 24:59it comes to paying you. You just don't know.
- 25:02You just have to just sometimes cut your losses.
- 25:06Yeah. So this form of caregiving is
- 25:10obviously one of a zillion, maybe not a zillion, but a slew
- 25:15that exists in in France. And the cash is held up as the,
- 25:20you know, the, the, the wonder system, which is daycare.
- 25:24Well, it's like, yeah, it's like a daycare that started, I read,
- 25:29in the 1800s after Industrial Revolution for women to be able
- 25:36to go to work. Right.
- 25:37OK. And it's subsidized.
- 25:39What's on a sliding scale according to your revenue?
- 25:42It's very hard, though, to get a spot.
- 25:46And I read, and I will put this source in the description of the
- 25:50show description. There are 200,000 spots needed
- 25:56in the whole country that cannot be filled for children because
- 26:01they lack staff. So what do you think?
- 26:05You know that's an option. You've got Gald Partege right?
- 26:08Where you have someone also who can you share kids like a small
- 26:11group? You've done that as well?
- 26:13And how does that work? So the last time I did gald
- 26:17partege, it was for three three-year olds that lived in
- 26:22the same building. Right, OK.
- 26:24So the parents club together and they were like what can we do?
- 26:28We need to work, we need our child, kids to be taken care of.
- 26:32And so they found me and it was all proper with a contract and
- 26:36everything and one family. Yeah, I guess they worked it out
- 26:41between them. Who needs the most care?
- 26:43Who earns the most? And then who hosts, right?
- 26:47Or does it switch? Apartments.
- 26:48Who's Yeah, we switched apartments, which was really
- 26:51quite cool. Because you get different
- 26:52experiences. Different experiences, different
- 26:55toys, different. Yeah, it's, I really liked it.
- 26:59And I'm still in touch with certainly two of the three
- 27:02children that I looked after their parents now, so.
- 27:05And I know that what I found fascinating when I was doing
- 27:10some research on for the new Parisienne, actually, there's a
- 27:14section on motherhood. And I was speaking to some women
- 27:16in Paris who who were like, I only earn enough.
- 27:21You know, I work, I want to be working, but my salary basically
- 27:25goes straight to pay the nanny. And so some of them decide, is
- 27:29it worth it for me to do that? It's a legitimate question.
- 27:32Right. And so this idea that somehow it
- 27:35is like super convenient and affordable for everyone is kind
- 27:39of. It's true, it's intensive, but
- 27:42childcare in general is expensive all across the board.
- 27:47And I think that's where the government comes in.
- 27:50You know, they need to put things into place where it does
- 27:54make it more feasible for parents to go out and work.
- 27:58You know, places in like Finland and Sweden where they have even
- 28:02also in Germany. But it's more progressive.
- 28:05Yeah, definitely. I mean, first of all, parents
- 28:07get a year maternity paternity leave, so you can just choose to
- 28:13stop working and look after your own child for a bit.
- 28:17Yeah. And then use the rest of the
- 28:19time to figure it out. I mean, their version of Kresh
- 28:22there is called Kita, and that works exactly the same way.
- 28:26It's mainly free, but you have ones that are more slightly more
- 28:30private than the others. And that also works on the
- 28:34sliding scale of how much you earn, how much can you afford to
- 28:38contribute to the system. Is there, to your knowledge, the
- 28:42same shortage? Yeah, for kids, there are.
- 28:45There are, and actually one of the reasons that I'm most aware
- 28:49of is because as soon as Brexit hit as well for the UK, there
- 28:54was this mass exodus of people leaving for Europe.
- 28:58They were just like well AI want the European passport and B
- 29:03childcare is basically free. So why am I paying 8 or £900 a
- 29:08month to send my kid to nursery or paying minimum of two 3000 a
- 29:14month for my child to be with a nanny right when I can just move
- 29:18to Europe, say goodbye to this whole terrible system of Brexit
- 29:23and right benefit from Europe what European culture has to
- 29:29offer us. So they sort of were inundated.
- 29:32Yeah. The systems were inundated,
- 29:34yeah. And you, you bring up something
- 29:36that's quite interesting because the the rates you've just
- 29:39mentioned about daycare or nursery in the UK sound kind of
- 29:43like what I have heard from my friends with kids in the US.
- 29:46Yeah, what that? Costs.
- 29:48It's wild. But does that mean that's why
- 29:51those cultures are going to they're less shocked about
- 29:57paying more if they are going to get a nanny?
- 30:00Exactly, and it's my preferred type of client because they
- 30:03already understand the value in paying for childcare.
- 30:07I'm not saying it's correct. Right.
- 30:09It is an extortionate amount of money, but if you think of
- 30:13another adult working 40, sometimes 50-60 hours a week,
- 30:21they need to be on the salary that sustains them, right?
- 30:25And that unfortunately is either the same as you or I don't know
- 30:30how you need to figure it out, right?
- 30:32But it's not going to be 6 or £10 an hour.
- 30:35No. And it's also the that that that
- 30:38exists. Yeah.
- 30:39Is akin to the kind of low wage work.
- 30:43Yeah, that has essentially allowed Western economies to
- 30:47function. True.
- 30:48And it doesn't make it right. Yeah, right.
- 30:50So it really. Isn't right at all.
- 30:52Are you concerned by anything thing you see in the French or
- 30:57Paris, let's say, because one in Paris approach to their
- 31:02children. And maybe that's a poorly worded
- 31:06question, but I mean, you know, that they, I, what I always
- 31:09found interesting is that they want to, they, they don't
- 31:13become, they don't lose their identities, not all of them
- 31:17anyway, when they become parents, right?
- 31:18So they want to maintain their, their lifestyles going out.
- 31:23But does that have an impact from your perspective on the
- 31:28relationship with the child? Yeah.
- 31:30I mean, anywhere you go to, I think you definitely get what
- 31:34you pay for in any kind of job really.
- 31:38I mean, you have, I mean, we're talking about childcare not but
- 31:43even you can bring this down to working in McDonald's or a
- 31:47restaurant when you have people that are paid badly, you know,
- 31:50there are rumours that they drop your food on the floor and put
- 31:53it back or, you know, do something not so nice to your
- 31:57burger and then give it back to you.
- 31:59You read these stories all the time.
- 32:01And I'm not saying it's the same for childcare, but I have been
- 32:05in to parks or at birthday parties where where, for
- 32:10example, caregivers are not afraid to like smack a child or
- 32:16shelter a child or it's really awful.
- 32:19And then it just takes a simple conversation to figure out,
- 32:23well, that caregiver's being mistreated, they're not paid
- 32:26fairly. They feel this is wrong and
- 32:29that's wrong and it's not their child anyway.
- 32:31So why does it matter? All we will know and it's not a
- 32:35rare case. This happens all the time.
- 32:38And I often have parents come up to me saying, oh, you know,
- 32:42you're so patient and caring with my child.
- 32:45And you mean, oh, you, you just basically mean I don't shout or
- 32:50hit at your child because that's what you're used to hearing the
- 32:54horror stories, you know, And unfortunately, especially with
- 32:58like Black and Latina nannies as well, there's a stigma that
- 33:02we're more aggressive and more strict with our caregiving,
- 33:07which is why you have the whole Norland system where which
- 33:12actually, I mean, I'm not sure if we have time to.
- 33:15Go into this what is. That Norland is an establishment
- 33:18in the UK where you can go and train to be a nanny.
- 33:22OK, so I applied for Norland, I got in and I quit quite quickly
- 33:28afterwards actually. It just wasn't for me.
- 33:31You have to wear a brown and beige uniform with matching
- 33:35shoes. You have to wear a little hat.
- 33:39You get taught great things, how to swim in the ocean, how to
- 33:42drive a car, how to sew, how to cook, all the pedagogical
- 33:47skills. You learn absolutely everything.
- 33:49I mean, it's a brilliant system, but it's also very white.
- 33:54It's very, very white. Now, if you go on their
- 33:57Instagram, you will see black nannies that have graduated.
- 34:01They do have a program for nannies, which is a male nanny,
- 34:05right? It is becoming more progressive,
- 34:07but since its creation, it has always just been a very white
- 34:12system. And the royal family in the UK,
- 34:15only Higher Norland nannies. And there are always these very
- 34:19prim and proper white ladies with their hair tied in a bow,
- 34:24very akin to like an air stewardess or sorry, cabin crew.
- 34:30And you know, the polished look. And I'm, I just wasn't like
- 34:33that. I can do the job, but I don't
- 34:36want to dress like that. I don't want to wear a brown
- 34:39uniform and have everybody know that I work in someone's home as
- 34:44a caregiver. You lose your identity, as you
- 34:46know. Put a.
- 34:47Label on me, right? So I was like, this isn't for
- 34:50me, you know, sod this. And I just found my own way and
- 34:55then explain to people, quite frankly like this, you know,
- 35:00give me a month. I can do the job.
- 35:02You'll see the turn around in your child.
- 35:04But I'm not going to wear a buttoned up shirt.
- 35:06And I do like to wear bows in my hair, actually.
- 35:10But that's your decision. Right, that's my decision.
- 35:12So I wanted to get your thought also on.
- 35:17I have a friend who just had a baby and she went through a
- 35:20number in Paris, sorry and and went through a number of night
- 35:23nurses before she found someone who could help her.
- 35:25And she knows she is privileged enough to afford this.
- 35:29But she also was desperate. And one of the things she said
- 35:32that really struck me, this is someone who was sort of on the
- 35:35fence about having kids initially and is very, very
- 35:39career minded. And she said the thing that has
- 35:42really rocked her is how isolated she has felt.
- 35:45Oh. Bless.
- 35:46Her in the middle of the night, you know, she's the one that has
- 35:48to breastfeed before they got, you know, help at some point.
- 35:53And just the moments where like, you're not sleeping, you're
- 35:57dealing with this, you know, human, you have to keep alive
- 35:59and, and feeling like there's a lot that other people just can't
- 36:03do. Do you find that again?
- 36:07We sort of gloss over when we talk about the childcare
- 36:10experience. We gloss over those moments.
- 36:12Yeah. To our detriment.
- 36:15Yeah, I mean, women don't really help each other.
- 36:18We're the biggest, you know, the the ones that RIP us down the
- 36:22most, you know, and you either have women on the Internet that
- 36:26like, I love being a mother. It's amazing.
- 36:30You don't know how it feels until you do it yourself.
- 36:33But no one ever really talks about post Natal depression,
- 36:37being alone, not having enough money to afford the help, but
- 36:41you want the help and then feeling guilty for taking the
- 36:44help because you feel like you're being a bad mother.
- 36:47Yeah, because someone else is doing it.
- 36:49But actually, this is my favorite type of work.
- 36:52The night nannying. Yeah.
- 36:53Yeah, I love it because I've done it several times.
- 36:57I mean. On a right like for how long do
- 36:59you do that? Just like the first month.
- 37:00No, it depends. And I always take the night
- 37:04nanny and jobs through an agency and never do it by myself
- 37:08because this is where you need the contract.
- 37:10To be clear, you need to be paid either by the hour or per night
- 37:15you need to. Yeah.
- 37:17I mean, typically you start from about 6:00 or 7:00 PM and you
- 37:21work the whole night until the same time again in the morning.
- 37:27So like a. 12 hour shift, yeah. But I love it because you get to
- 37:32meet the baby when they just come home and I really like to
- 37:36support the parents. You know, I had the most
- 37:39wonderful family once in Frankfurt.
- 37:41I'll never forget them. Both CEOs working top jobs
- 37:45really good like and but they don't want to lose the place in
- 37:50their career, right? You need the help and so you
- 37:54teach the mum how to be OK with breastfeeding if she wants to do
- 37:58it. If not, I take the baby, I
- 38:01bottle feed, show them how to pump, show them how to bathe.
- 38:05I mean basically all the things a midwife shows you right?
- 38:08Except she stays right you. Stay and you allow them to
- 38:12sleep. Yeah, basically.
- 38:14I mean, how does your sleep though?
- 38:15Get, I mean, dreadful. But you know, it's not forever.
- 38:18You, you can't be a night nanny for a family forever.
- 38:21You can do it for like a year tops, but I've generally have
- 38:27done it for like 3 to four months in a row and then you
- 38:31stop or sometimes even just a few weeks.
- 38:34Depends what the family is, if they're travelling in for
- 38:37business, if they're just getting settled before they hire
- 38:40their daily nanny. So then what do you recommend
- 38:44for anybody listening who is about to have a kid here?
- 38:48Maybe moving with kids that are not yet school age and let's say
- 38:53they can't afford unfortunately a Lizzie.
- 38:59What should they be looking out for though?
- 39:01And what would still be a good Ave. to pursue for their kids?
- 39:08And if they can, you should absolutely hire Lizzie.
- 39:10Yeah. I mean, assuming you absolutely
- 39:13can't afford a Lizzie, which isn't that expensive in
- 39:16relation, but I mean Sikh community, you know, there are
- 39:22also a game, Sorry to keep reference in Berlin when we're
- 39:27in Paris, but there were two mothers.
- 39:29It must exist here. They set up their own company,
- 39:33both a doula and a mother that set up their own company and
- 39:38they made like a food portions for for new parents.
- 39:45So like bulk buy things, get things to help you.
- 39:48OK. But so bulk buy.
- 39:51Prepare yourself, OK? You can't afford the Lizzie.
- 39:55Tap into your community. Ask your bestest friends.
- 39:59Can you help me? I need a month's worth of food
- 40:04in the freezer. I need.
- 40:08You know the care packages like when you have a new instead of
- 40:12people just offering you a gift or something cute, come up with
- 40:16a list. I've contacted a nanny and this
- 40:19is what she says I need. So disperse it amongst your
- 40:22community and have this, this, this, this just to get you
- 40:27through that period of where you know you're going to have lack
- 40:29of sleep. And what about where to put?
- 40:32So what if someone can't get into crush, Right?
- 40:35And that was their initial goal, Yeah.
- 40:36Should they look for a gal? A gal?
- 40:38Battagier? Is that a good solution?
- 40:40Absolutely, so more the more cheapest solutions instead of a
- 40:44daily Danny is either Gal Partagier or childminder.
- 40:49Actually, a childminder is still an accredited person.
- 40:53You have to have applied for your license properly and it's
- 40:59way the the child minder their home has been adapted to
- 41:05accommodate right, say three or four children, right.
- 41:09So they have it checked as well. You have to have like the safety
- 41:13plugs, you have to have an area of play, an area of change, like
- 41:17it can't just be anyone's home, OK, has to be adapted so that
- 41:21the children can come over. So that's much cheaper and girl
- 41:26partege, yeah, I loved it. I mean, not everyone is a two
- 41:30parent family, right? But if you think about having
- 41:34like 6 or 7 salaries to look after a few children, right?
- 41:39I mean you can already do the maths, it's way cheaper, right?
- 41:43Yeah. So any concluding words about
- 41:47your, your world in Paris because you see a different side
- 41:50of things than I do, For example, is there anything that
- 41:53gives you, I guess, hope for families setting up in Paris?
- 42:00I mean, I love Paris, right? I know it came back.
- 42:03I absolutely love France. What's it going to take to get a
- 42:08passport? Oh, I know.
- 42:11Nightmare. I don't know.
- 42:14I mean, I've also forgotten the question.
- 42:19I love it. I love it.
- 42:21Well, I guess just like, do you see kindness when you're out?
- 42:25I do in the parks and stuff. Like, I'm just, I guess I just
- 42:27want to feel that there's humanity even in the little
- 42:30people that, you know, you might be raising, helping to raise
- 42:33like. 100%. Does that give you hope?
- 42:36There's kindness everywhere, especially in Paris.
- 42:39You just have to look for it. And if you really aren't sure
- 42:43about your childcare options, the easiest thing to do is
- 42:47contact an agency via phone or e-mail.
- 42:52Ask them all of your questions. Of course they will try to
- 42:55onboard you and get you to hire a nanny, but kind of use that as
- 43:01like your troubleshooting and then get as much information for
- 43:05yourself as you can before you go out and do the research
- 43:09yourself. That's excellent advice Be.
- 43:11Like, I mean, the agents won't love it, they'll hate me for
- 43:14saying it, but they're there to advise you.
- 43:17They're there to try and get you to take a nanny from their
- 43:22company. And if you can't afford that for
- 43:25whatever reason, try and take as much of that advice and find
- 43:29your own. Great advice, Liz.
- 43:32Yeah, well, I wish I new offhand of other people who could help
- 43:37you get that passport and. Will hire you forever from this
- 43:42autumn so. OK, All right, you heard it here
- 43:44first. Books will open soon.
- 43:46Liz, thank you so much and thank you SO.
- 43:48Much for having me. I just love how you fell into
- 43:51this also. Me too.
- 43:55I mean, and you're and you're really, I mean, I've seen it
- 43:57first hand, obviously. You're so wonderful.
- 44:00With kids so. Everyone should be so lucky.
- 44:04Thank you so much. And next time we'll have you on
- 44:06to talk about wine because that's your other passion.
- 44:08So to be continued. Yes, all the food, all the wine.
- 44:14That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 44:16be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 44:19scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 44:22conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 44:24subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 44:27what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 44:31from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 44:34Sub Stack at Treviento.