Latest / The Feminine Manifesto / #7 Women and Work: A Biblical Perspective.
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:05Welcome to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Join us every month as we discuss
- 0:09issues facing women in the 21st century and try to view them through a gospel-centered lens.
- 0:14We are three mums with young children from Australia who are concerned about
- 0:18the lack of truth being spoken in our culture.
- 0:21This podcast was born out of a desire to free women from the lies they are being fed from the world.
- 0:26We are not here to be controversial intentionally, but to seek to point women
- 0:30to the truth that can be found in Christ.
- 0:33We hope you enjoy coming along this journey with us.
- 0:33Music.
- 0:42Welcome back to The Feminine Manifesto. My name is Emma and I am filling in
- 0:46for Heather today while she is off birthing her first child.
- 0:49And any day now as well, so listen out for a newborn in the background of a future episode.
- 0:54You know what they say, whilst the cat's away, the mice will play.
- 0:56And today we will certainly play with a controversial topic,
- 0:59should women be in the workforce? I am joined here today with Anisha,
- 1:03who is going to lend her wisdom to what I hope is an edifying conversation.
- 1:06How are you going today, Anisha?
- 1:08Doing well. Thanks, Emma. I can't believe it's already fair,
- 1:10but I really feel like we're just about getting our lives sorted for the year.
- 1:14I'm really looking forward to this discussion, though. I think it's definitely
- 1:17one that needs to be approached with a bit of gentleness and grace.
- 1:21Awesome. Let's get into it. So we've got plenty to talk about today.
- 1:25I just want to preface this episode, though, before we start by saying that
- 1:28despite not really working myself outside of the home, for about four years now.
- 1:32I am still technically a full-time employee of the Department of Education here in Australia.
- 1:38I've just had a load of kids closely together, so I haven't really been back
- 1:41to work. And I'm honestly not sure if I will return or not. It's not completely off the cards.
- 1:46So the topic of today's podcast is something I'm milling over as much as anyone
- 1:50else. And I actually learned heaps whilst I was researching for this,
- 1:54and it really made me consider my own situation.
- 1:56Another disclaimer I would quickly like to address is that there are always
- 1:59going to be exceptions out there.
- 2:01Single parenting, extreme financial hardship, illness, disability, etc, etc.
- 2:07These are all reasons why a woman would have to enter into the workforce.
- 2:11I'm not going to speak to these cases.
- 2:12I'm also not trying to downplay the very real struggle with inflation and crazy
- 2:18high mortgage rates at the moment.
- 2:19Life is certainly significantly more expensive than it was even five years ago.
- 2:25So with that out of the way, I want to start off by quickly reflecting on our
- 2:28own experiences around the workforce.
- 2:31So Anisha, can you just share about your upbringing? Did both of your parents have careers?
- 2:36Did you have a career? Do you still have a career? Can you fill us in about that?
- 2:40Yeah, so working was definitely the norm in my, is the norm in my family.
- 2:45In fact, not working wasn't really something I considered until recently.
- 2:49So both my grandparents on either side of the family worked.
- 2:53I grew up with both my parents working.
- 2:55They're both doctors and worked long hours before we moved to Australia.
- 2:59So, So I should add that in spite of their crazy work hours,
- 3:03they really put in a lot of effort to spend time with us and take us for trips.
- 3:07And it basically just got to a point where they realized that life was too hectic
- 3:11and they just had to make a change to invest in our lives more,
- 3:15especially spiritually.
- 3:16And that's pretty much how we ended up in Australia.
- 3:19And me, prior to having kids, I worked as a junior project manager on a maternal
- 3:24and child health program in India.
- 3:26I really enjoyed working. I still miss it and.
- 3:30Yeah, I don't know if I'll ever go back anytime soon, maybe once the kids are in school.
- 3:35But I know I would really struggle to divide my time between work and kids,
- 3:39especially while they're young.
- 3:40And this obviously comes from a very privileged position in that I can make
- 3:43this choice of being at home and not having to go to work.
- 3:46Because like you said, cost of living is just it's just ridiculous right now. What about you, Emma?
- 3:53Oh, well, yeah, I feel pretty blessed as well. My mom was around for most of my childhood.
- 3:58And I'm one of five kids and even though
- 4:01she was there it did mean that we struggled a lot financially
- 4:05but it would have made even less financial sense I think to put us all in child
- 4:08care so that's why mom stayed home and dad went to work it was pretty stressful
- 4:12and with money I don't know how my parents did it but I am still really really
- 4:16grateful that we did have a parent at home with us I didn't like leaving my
- 4:20mom I really took a while to get used to even going to school.
- 4:24But then for myself, when I became an adult, I never dreamed of not having a career.
- 4:29I was definitely affected by us growing up with so much money related stress.
- 4:35And I really just wanted to ensure that that wouldn't be the case for my own kids.
- 4:39So even when I got pregnant with my eldest, I assumed that I would just go back
- 4:43to work full time after my maternity leave ended.
- 4:45But now three kids in and I'm not really sure what I'm going to do.
- 4:51So yeah, on that note, let's get into today's topic.
- 4:55And so we can start kind of thinking about this and discuss this a bit further in a biblical sense.
- 4:59I've just summarized a quick history of the workforce and women's participation
- 5:04in it. I got all this data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics.
- 5:07This is really easy to check out yourself if you want to just with a quick Google search.
- 5:12At the end of, sorry, at the turn of the 20th century here in Australia,
- 5:16men made up about 80% of the workforce and women made up 20%.
- 5:21Overwhelmingly, men worked in agriculture and women in domestic services if
- 5:27they were working at all. So things like housekeeping.
- 5:30I also thought that it was really interesting when I was looking at this data,
- 5:33how there was not a single male midwife in the early 1900s.
- 5:39And out of over 9,000 nurses in Australia, only 40 of them were men,
- 5:44which is very different to today.
- 5:45There were no women at all in the military or the police, there were no female
- 5:49train drivers, and there were no female chimney sweeps either.
- 5:52And work definitely seemed more segregated, and it was divided along the lines.
- 5:58Gender, and it seemed to mirror each of the sex's kind of God-given attributes.
- 6:06So for example, women's work seemed to largely kind of fall into the camp of
- 6:11caring for people or caring for a home,
- 6:14whereas men's work seemed to align more along protecting others from physical
- 6:21threats, as well as looking after and managing land for farming,
- 6:26which obviously isn't the case anymore.
- 6:27Everyone kind of just does every job nowadays, right?
- 6:30And I think that the sheer number of men who were employed in the agricultural
- 6:34sector suggests something 100 years ago that doesn't really exist now in 2025.
- 6:40And that is that lots and lots of families lived on farms.
- 6:44And this kind of allowed for a dynamic where men and women within a family were
- 6:49actually working together, kind of just to provide for their families and to
- 6:55run a household properly.
- 6:56That was, I think a lot more common 100 years ago in that women would actually
- 7:01have been working even though they weren't necessarily getting individually paid for that work.
- 7:06But physically, I think the labor would have been very, very,
- 7:10very intense for women as well as men when they were living in this sort of
- 7:14situation where they were kind of having to provide their own food from the land.
- 7:18And when I reflect on the data that the majority of women quotations didn't
- 7:23work historically, I'm wondering how many women actually did,
- 7:26not only just looking after their home and their kids like we do nowadays,
- 7:30but also looking after livestock and crops.
- 7:33And I'm sure that women have always worked, but just not in the way that we
- 7:36view it and have viewed it for about the last 60 years or so.
- 7:41The model that we see in Australia today, that being that two adults in a household
- 7:47leave their home and they commute to a place of work eight hours a day, five days a week.
- 7:51This really took flight in the 1960s and it coincided with the rise of the feminine
- 7:56movement here in Australia and it just continued to grow exponentially until the present day.
- 8:01In 2020 here in Australia the workforce was
- 8:04split pretty much evenly 50-50 between men and women so it's fair to say that
- 8:10women being out of the house participating in the workforce in an almost identical
- 8:14way to men is considered to be the norm here in Australia and I imagine in many
- 8:20other parts of the world as well.
- 8:22So the crucial question for today is, what does the Bible say about this?
- 8:25Is it God's will for women to be in the workforce?
- 8:29Now I think that one of the most important bits of scripture for instructing
- 8:33women and the part that I personally come back to again and again when I'm thinking
- 8:36about this topic is Titus 2, 4-5.
- 8:39I'll just read it out. And so train the young women to love their husbands and
- 8:44children, to be self-controlled, pure, working at home, kind,
- 8:48submissive to their own husbands, that the word of God may not be reviled.
- 8:53So this is the Apostle Paul, and he's instructing the older women in the church
- 8:57in how they can help out and teach the younger women in the church.
- 9:04From this passage, Anisha, what would you personally deduce is to be the main
- 9:09focus area for Christian women, if there is one at all. What do you think?
- 9:15So the focus for a Christian woman is definitely on the family,
- 9:20loving and caring for her husbands and kids, and also just being a good witness at home.
- 9:25If we look at that passage specifically, it says we're called to be self-controlled,
- 9:29or some other translations say to be sensible or of sound mind.
- 9:34We are to be pure, hard workers, kind. that's
- 9:37a that's a pretty high and weighty calling and anything
- 9:40that steals our attention from that being a priority whether
- 9:44it's work or hobbies or socializing or whatever it
- 9:47might be really needs re-evaluation I
- 9:50mean I think our hearts and our efforts really should be focused on
- 9:53building a home where God is glorified and we
- 9:56are fulfilling our God-given responsibilities like you
- 9:58said earlier yeah definitely that's a really yeah
- 10:01that's a good pinpoint I think of what Paul is
- 10:04getting at here and from this passage personally I
- 10:08take away that women have really been
- 10:11given the unique role of caring for
- 10:14a home by God because men are not instructed in
- 10:17the same way to be workers at home and that's not to kind of take value away
- 10:23from that because it's an absolutely huge job and we know looking after our
- 10:27kids alone is just so time consuming even in 2025 where we have a whole manner
- 10:32of modern day conveniences and tools to help us out.
- 10:37And when you throw into that mix a husband who, you know, you want to have a
- 10:40decent relationship with, you want to invest into your marriage.
- 10:44You don't just want to be kind of ships passing in the night.
- 10:47That certainly takes a lot of time as well. And then on top of that,
- 10:51creating a home, which is peaceful and enjoyable to live in and has some semblance of order.
- 10:57All of that is just, Yeah, it's endless hours, it's more than a full-time job.
- 11:01But we as women are uniquely equipped for it.
- 11:04And this is gonna get me into trouble, I'm sure, for saying it,
- 11:07but I really don't think that there is any man out there who could do a better
- 11:11job of looking after a home and all that that entails than a woman could.
- 11:16It's just not a strength of men.
- 11:18That's just my observation, I think, just from being alive for 36 years.
- 11:21And I think that God gifted women specifically.
- 11:25In the areas of nurturing and caring for others.
- 11:29I think he gifted us in creating a calm and a peaceful and an enjoyable home.
- 11:36I think that he gifted us in being able to plan healthy and delicious meals
- 11:41to cater for various palates in our homes and also just to look out for the
- 11:46well-being of the members of our family.
- 11:48And these are strengths of women which lead us, I think, just to naturally thrive
- 11:52in the domain of the home. And men just don't have the same skill set.
- 11:56Therefore, it makes sense for me anyway, for men to go out into the marketplace,
- 12:01to leave the home and to generate income.
- 12:04And it makes more sense for women to stay at home and kind of take care of the
- 12:10many, many, many jobs within that space.
- 12:14Now, is that to say that there can be absolutely no crossover at all.
- 12:18Can women not work outside of the home in any way?
- 12:22I don't think that there is any part of God's word that condemns women having
- 12:26a job outside of the home.
- 12:27I did a fair bit of research into this and I tried to pull the most conservative
- 12:32pastors that I could find.
- 12:34And yeah, none of them could come to that finite conclusion that it's sinful
- 12:40for a woman to work outside of the home.
- 12:42Lots of them referenced certainly Titus 2. There was another piece of scripture
- 12:47that was referenced often as well when considering the topic of whether or not
- 12:51women should be working.
- 12:52And that, of course, is Proverbs 31.
- 12:56It's an absolutely fantastic piece of scripture. I'm going to look at some verses
- 12:59more specifically soon.
- 13:00But Anisha, do you think you could give us a quick summary of it, please?
- 13:04Sure. This is definitely one of those passages I used to just shy away from
- 13:10thinking, oh man, I'm never going to attain this.
- 13:12But I think if you just look at that passage, so I'm looking at verses 10 to
- 13:1731, I think it's just describing a godly woman who is thriving in her God-given role.
- 13:22So if we start from the top, so verse 11, it says her husband trusts her.
- 13:27Verse 13, 15, 16, it says she's hardworking.
- 13:31If you look at verse 18 and 24, it says she's enterprising or resourceful.
- 13:36Verse 20, she cares for those in need. Verse 16 and 26, she's full of wisdom,
- 13:41even in financial matters.
- 13:43Verse 27, she cares well for her household. Verse 28, she's respected and praised
- 13:48by her husband and children.
- 13:50And most importantly, in verse 30, she fears the Lord. Verse 28,
- 13:54she cares well for her household.
- 13:55That's, yeah. That is a lot. That's a brilliant summary. Thank you, Anisha.
- 13:59Yeah, I've heard the argument made that the woman featured in Proverbs 31 is
- 14:06buying and selling land.
- 14:08So I assume this comes from the verse 16. She considers a field and buys it.
- 14:12Out of her earnings, she plants a vineyard. I've also heard further arguments
- 14:16to support her working, such as in verse 18, she sees that her trading is profitable
- 14:21and her lamp does not go out at night.
- 14:23And also in verse 24, she makes linen garments and sells them.
- 14:26I just want to circle back to earlier in the podcast where we were touching
- 14:30on how different the workforce was here in Australia even 100 years ago.
- 14:35I think that the Proverbs 31 woman is actually quite descriptive of what work
- 14:39would have looked like for many women throughout history, probably really to
- 14:45within the last kind of 70 or 80 years.
- 14:47That is skillfully managing a home in a huge variety of ways,
- 14:52in a way that here in 2025, we would certainly be describing what she's doing as work.
- 14:59So she's farming, she is cooking, she is making clothes, she is caring for the
- 15:05poor, and most crucially, she is watching over the affairs of her household,
- 15:09and she does not eat the bread of idleness.
- 15:11This is one busy, organized, resourceful, and highly skilled woman.
- 15:17Even though, let's face it, being today, as at any point in history,
- 15:21is in itself a 24-hour job.
- 15:23Modern day conveniences from dishwashers to cinema mixes to tumble dryers to
- 15:29online grocery shopping has definitely made the rebranding of the working-at-home
- 15:34woman into a woman who doesn't work marginally more convincing.
- 15:38I wonder if the invention of so many useful tools and appliances and apps has
- 15:46actually contributed to women leaving their homes for the workforce just because
- 15:50they don't feel fulfilled at home.
- 15:54They don't feel like they're contributing as much at home because,
- 15:58yeah, we just, as a modern day women, have a whole army of things to help us
- 16:03out with what we need to do, I suppose, because the world has become more and
- 16:07more organized around two people leaving the home and going to work.
- 16:12So we're going to make everything else a little bit more convenient in the meantime.
- 16:15But backstory to the Proverbs 31 woman. Is she making an income?
- 16:19Yes, I do think she is. Is she doing it primarily within the sphere of a home?
- 16:24I also think that yes, she is doing this.
- 16:26So I deduce from this piece of scripture that as a woman, you're not forbidden
- 16:31from making money through a job.
- 16:34And just from a general Bible perspective, I do see a pattern of God giving
- 16:39the role of caring for a home to women.
- 16:42He's not giving it to men. So another scripture supporting this would be Proverbs
- 16:4614, the wisest of women builds her house, but folly with her own hands tears it down.
- 16:53So I don't see any convincing argument for a woman making her career ambitions the focus long term.
- 17:01And I think that would potentially fall into the tears down her house bit of Proverbs 14.
- 17:08But that being said, I think if there's an agreement there with your husband
- 17:13and, you know, there's kind of a discussion there.
- 17:16I'm going to work for this amount of time or this many hours a week for this particular reason.
- 17:22This is what the money is going to be going towards and
- 17:25you kind of have an agreement there and you know
- 17:28your home is in order the kids are in order no one's being neglected then I
- 17:32don't see it being an issue and for a woman to yeah just go out and take some
- 17:39sort of yeah job outside of the house to earn some money but I do think where
- 17:44your heart is it's crucial there like are you.
- 17:48Going out and you know
- 17:51your whole personality your whole trajectory
- 17:55is your career and the accolades
- 17:59that you gather in your workplace or is
- 18:03you know your children you know your accolade is your relationship with
- 18:06your husband your accolade is you know your your home and the hospitality that
- 18:09you show to people your accolade like where is your heart at truly with that
- 18:13I think that's something that would really need to be considered and reconsidered
- 18:18throughout the time as a woman choosing to go out and work. But what do you think about it, Anisha?
- 18:24I agree with you. I think, like, I don't say anything wrong with it if everything else is in order.
- 18:30But I think the Bible is very clear, like we said earlier, that a woman's focus
- 18:34is on the home and just adding to the different passages. So in Titus 2,
- 18:40they're called to be workers at home.
- 18:42In 1 Timothy 5.14, they're to keep the home.
- 18:45In Proverbs 31.27, it says they're watching over the ways of the house.
- 18:50There's no gray area in this. It's very clear that our focus should be at home
- 18:54and everything else is secondary.
- 18:57But I do, yeah, like I do think it's a very personal decision for each family.
- 19:01I think each family has to consider and assess their own motives,
- 19:05their convictions, circumstances. And I think just they have to prayerfully
- 19:09make whatever decision they make.
- 19:11I don't think it's a one answer fits all for each family, if that makes sense.
- 19:17Yeah, definitely. I think you summed that up really, really well.
- 19:21And yeah, I don't think we can say that women absolutely are forbidden from
- 19:25working outside of the home.
- 19:26Yeah, I don't see the argument for that in the Bible. But yeah,
- 19:29I certainly do see God repeatedly saying to women through a variety of means that they're,
- 19:37you know, their ultimate and their primary goal is making sure their home is in order.
- 19:42So does that give space to work outside of the home? I think in,
- 19:46you know, lots of situations, it does.
- 19:49But yeah, it's just don't let it, I suppose, become the main thing or the thing
- 19:53that you're chasing the most, right?
- 19:55Like, I don't know, you're working, you know, because you have some spare time
- 19:59and you have something to give or you're working,
- 20:01you know, you need to pay bills, you pay your mortgage but yeah so long as it's
- 20:05not kind of the the main thing and you're ascending in a career or getting a
- 20:10particular position at work is where all your focus is going to,
- 20:16oh so many good points and there's a lot to think about there and yeah personally
- 20:20I'm just really in two minds for my own situation here so it helped me a lot
- 20:25to be able to have that opportunity to discuss women working outside of the home.
- 20:31So I hope you enjoyed the episode today, guys. Definitely feel free to leave
- 20:34us a review and add your opinions if you would be so kind. I'm sure there's
- 20:38lots of opinions on this topic.
- 20:40And thank you so much for listening to us. And we will see you in the next episode.
- 20:45Have a great day. Thanks, Emma.
- 20:50Thanks for joining us today. We hope you found this discussion beneficial and
- 20:54it is our prayer that this will cause you to see Christ more clearly within our culture.
- 20:58If you enjoyed this, please like and subscribe as this will really help our
- 21:01podcast to get to more listeners.
- 21:03Music.