Latest / The Gathering Line / Paper Oil vs Physical Flow: The Real Crude Market Story

Transcript

Paper Oil vs Physical Flow: The Real Crude Market Story · The Gathering Line

• 0:00
  You know, if you look at the screen today, paper crude markets are telling a wild
• 0:05
  story.
• 0:06
  Brent futures spiked up to ninety seven dollars and twenty six cents a barrel.
• 0:11
  And on paper, it looks like a world running completely out of oil.
• 0:15
  But then you step onto a real trading desk, look at actual physical deliveries,
• 0:21
  and a totally different reality emerges.
• 0:24
  Take Abu Dhabi's state oil company, ADNOC.
• 0:27
  While paper buyers were panicking, ADNOC was out there buying physical cargoes of
• 0:32
  Iraqi crude at a massive twenty five dollar per barrel discount to benchmark.
• 0:38
  Twenty five dollars!
• 0:40
  That is not what happens in a market that is physically starving for barrels.
• 0:45
  That is a massive speculative fear premium built into paper contracts while physical
• 0:50
  barrels are actually moving around at a discount.
• 0:53
  And up north in Canada, heavy crude is feeling a totally different kind of pressure.
• 0:59
  Western Canadian Select, or WCS, differentials at Hardisty widened to thirteen
• 1:04
  dollars and fifty cents under WTI.
• 1:08
  Why?
• 1:08
  Because oil sands production is ramping up, pouring tons of volume into the Enbridge
• 1:13
  Mainline right as fall refinery turnarounds are scheduled to start.
• 1:17
  The pipe is full, refineries are slowing down for maintenance,
• 1:21
  and suddenly heavy barrels are trapped.
• 1:24
  Now, here in the U.S., the headline inventory data is...
• 1:28
  well, it is downright contradictory at first glance.
• 1:32
  Nationwide, the U.S.
• 1:33
  reported a massive crude build of seven point one four million barrels in a single
• 1:38
  week.
• 1:39
  Seven point one four million!
• 1:42
  That is huge.
• 1:43
  Yet, at the exact same time, stocks at the Cushing, Oklahoma pricing hub actually
• 1:48
  drew down.
• 1:49
  So how can the country be flooded with seven million barrels while the main pricing
• 1:54
  point gets tighter?
• 1:55
  It comes down to logistics.
• 1:57
  Coastal tank farms and Gulf Coast storage are filling up fast,
• 2:01
  even with U.S.
• 2:02
  refineries running hot at ninety two point four percent capacity.
• 2:06
  But that warehouse stock is not getting pushed into the Cushing checkout counter
• 2:10
  fast enough.
• 2:11
  That geographic split pushed the Brent to WTI spread out to twelve dollars and
• 2:16
  twenty five cents per barrel.
• 2:18
  Looking back over my twenty years as a commodities desk analyst,
• 2:23
  I, I, I have seen this exact paper versus physical squeeze play out before.
• 2:28
  When paper benchmarks shoot up on geopolitical fear, terminal operators focus on
• 2:33
  protecting their netbacks.
• 2:35
  They do not buy the hype.
• 2:37
  They look at physical spot deliveries, keep their storage tanks locked in,
• 2:41
  and wait for the paper fear premium to crash back down to physical reality.
• 2:46
  Now let us move inland to the Rockies, because the physical bottlenecks getting
• 2:51
  squeezed out here are fascinating.
• 2:54
  Start in Utah's Uinta Basin.
• 2:56
  Uinta waxy crude is fantastic oil for refiners, but it has one huge physical quirk.
• 3:03
  It has a high pour point of about one hundred ten degrees Fahrenheit.
• 3:07
  At room temperature, it basically hardens like shoe polish!
• 3:11
  You cannot put it in a standard pipeline or it turns into a hundred mile candle.
• 3:17
  Because of that high pour point, ninety percent of local Uinta production has to be
• 3:21
  heated and carried on insulated trucks, mostly going to five refineries near Salt
• 3:26
  Lake City.
• 3:27
  Operators like Ovintiv and XCL Resources are desperate for bigger outlets.
• 3:33
  They have been backing the proposed eighty five mile Uinta Basin Railway to rail hot
• 3:38
  wax down to the Gulf Coast, but ongoing court litigation keeps stalling progress,
• 3:43
  leaving rail terminal expansion in a high stakes waiting game.
• 3:47
  Over in North Dakota, the Department of Mineral Resources shows Bakken production
• 3:52
  holding steady right around one point two two million barrels per day.
• 3:56
  The Dakota Access Pipeline is running practically at full capacity.
• 4:01
  So producers like Chord Energy and Continental Resources are constantly running the
• 4:05
  math on crude by rail economics, checking if moving barrels by train to East Coast
• 4:10
  refiners makes sense when Clearbrook differentials hover at a dollar fifty under
• 4:14
  WTI.
• 4:16
  Meanwhile, down in Wyoming's Powder River Basin, drilling across Anschutz and Peak
• 4:21
  Energy acreage is humming along nicely.
• 4:24
  Gathering lines are handling the throughput smoothly, with no new takeaway
• 4:28
  constraints or big volume shifts reported over the last twenty four hours.
• 4:32
  But the real fireworks in the Rockies are happening at Guernsey Hub.
• 4:36
  That is pronounced GERN zee.
• 4:41
  Guernsey differentials just tightened big time, flipping to a premium over Cushing!
• 4:46
  Think about why that happens.
• 4:48
  You have three hundred thousand barrels a day coming in from the Bakken via Bridger
• 4:52
  Belle Fourche, plus another two hundred eighty thousand barrels a day of Canadian
• 4:57
  crude flowing in on Express Pipeline.
• 4:59
  All those barrels are pouring into Guernsey tankage, looking for a way south.
• 5:04
  But the main exit pipe, the two hundred thirty thousand barrel per day Pony Express
• 5:08
  Pipeline, hit capacity and went into apportionment.
• 5:12
  Shippers are literally bidding up the price of physical crude at Guernsey just to
• 5:16
  secure space on the line to Cushing.
• 5:18
  It completely flips traditional Rockies versus Midcontinent netbacks on their head.
• 5:24
  So when you look across the whole picture, from ninety seven dollar Brent paper to
• 5:28
  Guernsey pipeline capacity limits, the takeaway is clear.
• 5:32
  Paper headlines grab the attention, but in the end, the physical pipe,
• 5:36
  the tank, and the train always dictate who gets paid.