Latest / No Way Out / Creating Investment Mismatches and Embracing Economic Uncertainties with Taylor Pearson | Ep 30
Transcript
- 0:23Mark McGrath: Taylor, you're the second person I've talked to today.
- 0:25Mark McGrath: That's in Austin.
- 0:26Mark McGrath: Seems like everybody's going to Austin.
- 0:29Taylor Pearson: There you go, just trying to be where all the cool kids are, you know, just following the crowd.
- 0:33Mark McGrath: So I think you're the second guest we've had that lives in Austin too, because I think Michael Strong, if you've listened to that episode yet, he's also in Austin.
- 0:41Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 0:42Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i need to get out of my shell more.
- 0:44Taylor Pearson: I think the COVID.
- 0:45Taylor Pearson: I haven't quite fully emerged and like started meeting up with people, but there's a bunch of interesting people here now, which is pretty cool.
- 0:50Ponch RIvera: Yeah, Austin reminds me of Boulder.
- 0:52Ponch RIvera: You know it's a planet in its own little system.
- 0:54Ponch RIvera: It's got its own little thing going on.
- 0:56Ponch RIvera: Are you seeing the same thing in Austin?
- 0:59Taylor Pearson: Yeah, definitely Austin's gotten really big in the last 20 years.
- 1:04Taylor Pearson: Boulder still feels like kind of it doesn't feel as much like a college town as it used to.
- 1:10Taylor Pearson: I've been here for 10 years and it wasn't even that much of a college town.
- 1:12Taylor Pearson: I moved here by things.
- 1:12Taylor Pearson: like you know, in the 90s it was really UT, was kind of like the only thing in town And now it's kind of got its own tech ecosystem and finance people and just more of a general crew.
- 1:23Taylor Pearson: But it's yeah, it's great.
- 1:25Taylor Pearson: It's attracted a lot of interesting people, which is always nice.
- 1:28Ponch RIvera: I mean, have you seen Elon Musk driving around at all?
- 1:32Taylor Pearson: I have not Lots of Tesla's here, though, so he might be in one of them.
- 1:36Taylor Pearson: I haven't paid that much attention.
- 1:39Mark McGrath: I think even Joe Rogan's in Austin now.
- 1:41Taylor Pearson: So he is.
- 1:41Taylor Pearson: Yeah, his comedy club just opened up.
- 1:44Mark McGrath: Yeah, I saw that That's a new thing.
- 1:49Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i haven't been, but he's kind of trying to revitalize the Austin comedy scene, so that's cool.
- 1:55Mark McGrath: So you find yourself on a podcast with two guys that talk a lot about John Boyd and the Uda Loop, and you've certainly done your contributions in creating awareness about Boyd and Uda and Uda Loop, so why don't you give us a little bit of background on how you how did you stumble into Boyd?
- 2:15Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i was.
- 2:16Taylor Pearson: I was thinking, you know the asset I was thinking about for the company And I don't really remember, to be honest, i was working in an e-commerce company and I didn't have any sort of formal business background or training.
- 2:29Taylor Pearson: I have an undergrad degrees in Latin American history and sort of just stumbled my way into marketing and more general business stuff from there and eventually into finance.
- 2:39Taylor Pearson: But it was kind of just on this like a self-paced NBA kind of thing.
- 2:45Taylor Pearson: I just, like you know, i bought a bunch of business books and it was just kind of like going through and trying to teach myself, you know, business management, marketing, all that kind of stuff.
- 2:56Taylor Pearson: And somewhere in there someone mentioned John Boyd, uda Loop, something.
- 3:01Taylor Pearson: I think I bought the Robert Corum biography.
- 3:03Taylor Pearson: I think I read the whole thing in like three days And I was like this is awesome.
- 3:07Taylor Pearson: And so I bought the Asingha book and I went through that in like a week And so I just had like a six month PA right.
- 3:12Taylor Pearson: I just like basically read everything I could get my hands on That.
- 3:17Taylor Pearson: Anything to do with Boyd and Uda Loop, it's tied together.
- 3:19Taylor Pearson: You know, sometimes you find those things just ties together a bunch of disparate strands in your head And at the time I found it there was, you know, six or eight or a bunch of different things I was thinking about And it kind of tied all those together into this really interesting framework And so, yeah, that's kind of where I got into it and, you know, found Chat, richard stuff and talked with Chat a couple of times And yeah, so it's definitely been, it's been a major influence on me.
- 3:49Taylor Pearson: I think the complexity sort of science, complexity, science complexity, thinking that kind of stuff has always been of interest to me In particular.
- 3:58Taylor Pearson: I think that kind of the GFC and I found sort of machine collabs work around the GFC.
- 4:04Taylor Pearson: I think he got very good with the timing of that book.
- 4:07Taylor Pearson: I think the Black Swan came out in 07, which is very fortuitous book marketing timing.
- 4:12Taylor Pearson: But kind of got into that world through him And obviously Boyd was very cognizant of the developments going on there and sort of lots of parallels and overlaps.
- 4:21Taylor Pearson: So that's the sort of circuitous route.
- 4:25Mark McGrath: And it led you to create a tremendous document that you make available on your website that anybody could download and get a PDF of Your guide to the Uda Loops.
- 4:35Mark McGrath: about 70 pages Is the compendium of your notes in your course of study.
- 4:40Taylor Pearson: Yeah, I went through that like six a month period where I just read everything I could get my hands on And I was like, well, I just spent I don't know 300 hours reading all this stuff.
- 4:48Taylor Pearson: I should just like take some time to put it together until a little book or something.
- 4:53Taylor Pearson: So, yeah, that's kind of my thing.
- 4:54Taylor Pearson: I have on my list to do an update of it.
- 4:57Taylor Pearson: I feel like I've learned a lot since I was probably six or seven years old now, But it's been sort of like an introductory guide, beginner's guide of like someone that's Googling Uda Loop, that has kind of heard of it but doesn't know much.
- 5:10Taylor Pearson: Like how do you sort of introduce that concept to them?
- 5:13Ponch RIvera: Wow, we know some people in France who can use your help in Googling Uda Loop.
- 5:16Ponch RIvera: I'd say there's a lot of lean practitioners over there that have too much wrong information on Boyd Interesting Anything you could do.
- 5:23Ponch RIvera: Yeah, no, it's comedy.
- 5:24Ponch RIvera: They're always attacking us on.
- 5:26Ponch RIvera: You know it's a reductionist approach to like PDCA or PSA.
- 5:30Ponch RIvera: You know it's already figured out in lean.
- 5:32Ponch RIvera: It's just mind blowing how people don't know how to search for anything using the Google box anymore on their own.
- 5:39Ponch RIvera: You know so thanks for setting that up, yeah.
- 5:43Taylor Pearson: Yeah, for sure.
- 5:44Mark McGrath: I was interviewed on a podcast the other day and that was something that came another fellow traveler who asked me to debunk the myths or dispel a lot of the myths of Boyd And at the Pontius point a lot of people have a lot of the wrong ideas about Boyd And he, of course, gets reduced to Uda Loop, just like a lot of people just get reduced to one thing.
- 6:04Mark McGrath: So you mentioned like a revision and an updating.
- 6:07Mark McGrath: What are some of the things that you've learned about Uda?
- 6:10Mark McGrath: you know that you would add to it now, that you didn't know at first or that you've learned over time.
- 6:18Taylor Pearson: I think I got the chance to actually I was lucky a friend of mine's company.
- 6:23Taylor Pearson: They had Chet Richards come in and do the whole patterns of conflict presentation for them, so I got to watch that whole presentation, which was really fun.
- 6:30Taylor Pearson: So I have probably 40 pages of notes from going through that.
- 6:36Taylor Pearson: That was the big thing I was going to integrate, but I think I maybe just have some more like general ideas for how it fits in a different business context, like.
- 6:48Taylor Pearson: One of the books I've read since then I thought was good was The Design of Everyday Things, which is like a sort of introductory design book.
- 6:54Taylor Pearson: It's great but, like you know, you think about design and like UX and UI and like it very much has to do with orientation.
- 7:03Taylor Pearson: Right, you can think about that context, right, how is the person, the way you're interacting with software, whether that's like external software or internal tooling or something like that's facilitating how you orient with whatever task you're working on with, like the nature of the business or your role or whatever.
- 7:17Taylor Pearson: So, yeah, i think just like a few more things about sort of applications And I think maybe just a broader appreciation for how it could be applied.
- 7:30Taylor Pearson: I really liked that Dave Snowden episode you did.
- 7:32Taylor Pearson: I think Dave sort of had an idea of like moving from this like systems thinking, to complexity thinking, sort of transition, that sort of the system thinking got big and like 50, 60s, 70s And I like a lot of that stuff.
- 7:47Taylor Pearson: But I thought he had some interesting ideas.
- 7:48Taylor Pearson: So I think I've sort of had some parallel thoughts of just like you know, how do you apply this more to management or company building and investing in some extent as well?
- 8:01Ponch RIvera: We like Dave and during that episode he was drinking.
- 8:05Ponch RIvera: So it brings up another point when we did the Kineva Newtoloupe exploratory up at Quantico he was like at 70% brain capacity.
- 8:13Ponch RIvera: He had an injury to his head back then.
- 8:16Ponch RIvera: So even when he's not at his peak level, he's so much better than anybody else's team.
- 9:21Ponch RIvera: So it's always great to have Dave around to talk about things and share insights about complexity, sense making, narrative actually a lot of things that can be applied to the market which I don't think people are really paying attention to right now.
- 9:36Mark McGrath: And tying to what you said about revision and learning.
- 9:39Mark McGrath: You know Dave was very clear on the episode that had Boyd lived longer than the age of 70, which I mean we would think that that's a young person these days It would have been interesting to see how he would have evolved this thinking and how he would have made revisions and updates to UDA, which is that's our mission.
- 9:57Mark McGrath: I mean that's what the three of us are on, that path of developing and advancing these ideas and trying to figure out.
- 10:02Mark McGrath: It's interesting that you brought up complexity sciences.
- 10:05Mark McGrath: I mean that's, i think, panch, wouldn't you agree?
- 10:07Mark McGrath: I mean, that's really where we had seen him, boyd, really transitioning towards late in his life And he was developing this stuff right till he died.
- 10:17Mark McGrath: But I think that that's really really where he was going.
- 10:21Mark McGrath: And then we were talking about that with Jim Rut And we're you know we're big on complexity science as well, in learning that, and I think that that's what Boyd was really ahead of his time there.
- 10:33Ponch RIvera: Yeah, and I think Taylor's point about the Franz Ozinga book is critical, because it wasn't until I read Franz Ozinga's book that I didn't realize that John Boyd was talking about complexity.
- 10:41Ponch RIvera: And it's Franz Ozinga's work which really highlighted that for me and made me open my eyes and go, wait a minute.
- 10:47Ponch RIvera: I need to look at the loop a little bit differently now And then the continuation of that conversation with Dave Snowden and others really expands the understanding of how things work today.
- 11:00Ponch RIvera: And you know we're looking in the we're in the aftermath of SBB, a lot of changes in the markets.
- 11:06Ponch RIvera: You know volatility is through not through the roof.
- 11:08Ponch RIvera: Today it's pretty high, but it's all driven by uncertainty, complexity and everything we do.
- 11:16Ponch RIvera: So at the heart of understanding how to navigate a turbulent world, we have to understand doodaloo, or at least understand complexity science, right?
- 11:26Ponch RIvera: And I think, taylor, you're kind of big into the Kinevan framework as well, right.
- 11:31Taylor Pearson: Yeah, no, i like the Kinevan stuff and a bunch of the work Dave has done.
- 11:35Taylor Pearson: Yet I think that's, you know, like I think one of a formative event for me for sure was sort of the global financial crisis.
- 11:43Taylor Pearson: I was trying to think freshman college, a sophomore in college, in 0708.
- 11:50Taylor Pearson: And that was kind of I think a lot of people like.
- 11:53Taylor Pearson: I think 9-11 was that for some people.
- 11:55Taylor Pearson: I think I had that sort of like the sense of the world around them.
- 11:58Taylor Pearson: Suddenly it sort of comes in kind of thing.
- 12:02Taylor Pearson: The GFC was definitely that for me and I think there was just a sense of like.
- 12:05Taylor Pearson: Like there were no adults in the room.
- 12:07Taylor Pearson: I was like who, how does this work?
- 12:09Taylor Pearson: You know what?
- 12:09Taylor Pearson: I mean?
- 12:09Taylor Pearson: Like no one, clearly no one understands what's going on here, and that was kind of, i think, the event that set me thinking about these things.
- 12:18Taylor Pearson: But yeah, right, i think that the interesting thing there exactly was no one did understand what was going on.
- 12:23Taylor Pearson: And it's not like there weren't reasonably smart people thinking about some of those things.
- 12:28Taylor Pearson: It was just the overall complexity and uncertainty that are sort of inherent in some aspects of the modern system, just how interconnected things are and how complex things have become And actually you get these sort of emergent phenomena.
- 12:45Taylor Pearson: Yeah, we're recording this the week after the Silicon Valley Bank news broke, which is another interesting thing.
- 12:52Taylor Pearson: You have these knock on effects that aren't super obvious for the most part.
- 13:01Mark McGrath: Yeah, jim Rhett was saying there's the unknown and the unknowable, you know, and this could be the pedal that they're, the pebble rather, that sets off the chain of events.
- 13:11Mark McGrath: And who knows, i mean, it might not be For sure it seems like oftentimes there is that whoops, i think we lost them And punch you Yeah.
- 13:32Ponch RIvera: Yeah.
- 13:37Mark McGrath: Oh, here he comes, you're muted again.
- 13:45Taylor Pearson: All right, welcome back.
- 13:46Taylor Pearson: Sorry I have no idea what happened there.
- 13:48Ponch RIvera: I just said, my internet is connected, but everything's fine, i think they heard us talking about the bank.
- 13:52Ponch RIvera: Okay, there you go.
- 13:55Mark McGrath: Someone shut us down, we'll just reorient.
- 13:57Mark McGrath: No, so I can relate.
- 14:01Mark McGrath: I was in asset management for a long time, but I was only during the GFC.
- 14:05Mark McGrath: That's really where a lot of my understanding of Boyd's broader context beyond what I had learned in the Marine Corps because it went from yeah, there was a smart guy, boyd.
- 14:15Mark McGrath: He taught us how to make better decisions and we have this great framework Udalloop.
- 14:20Mark McGrath: When you really started to understand the complexity and see how things were interconnected at a much higher level, i started going back and really digging deep on those things.
- 14:30Mark McGrath: And then when the O'Singh book came out, as you say, that was really an awakening for me that anybody that since then that reduces Boyd to just Udalloop.
- 14:42Mark McGrath: They're missing so much and they're leaving a lot of potential on the table and they're leaving a lot of.
- 14:49Mark McGrath: To me it's almost like that's 1% of And they're forgetting 99 of everything else that he was working on.
- 15:01Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i think it's interesting, like one of my complaints about Boyd that I also respected was he's sort of refusal to write anything down.
- 15:08Taylor Pearson: It's really hard.
- 15:10Taylor Pearson: Part of the reason I wrote that summation and I think the O'Singh book is very good is he was sort of deliberately opaque and challenging about memorializing his work.
- 15:21Taylor Pearson: I totally get, from the perspective of, as Y'all have mentioned, there's this attempt to, i guess, platonify or oversimplify the thing down, which is exactly what he was.
- 15:34Taylor Pearson: That was exactly the point.
- 15:36Taylor Pearson: You don't do that.
- 15:36Taylor Pearson: That's missing the whole purpose of the whole thing or whatever.
- 15:42Taylor Pearson: But I think it just.
- 15:43Taylor Pearson: I think it seems inevitable.
- 15:44Taylor Pearson: Udalloop was a term and everyone knows It's easier to talk about the term, whereas I haven't really done this.
- 15:52Taylor Pearson: But some of the stuff just needs to be renamed.
- 15:53Taylor Pearson: I think I talk I can't pronounce it in German but fingerspitschengefühl, fingerspitschengefühl, fingerspitschengefühl.
- 16:01Taylor Pearson: Yeah, thank you, i think it's such an interesting idea.
- 16:04Taylor Pearson: I talk about that with people all the time or whatever, but it's just not very.
- 16:07Taylor Pearson: The medical quality is not very good.
- 16:09Taylor Pearson: It's never going to spread.
- 16:11Taylor Pearson: It's like this long, complex German word.
- 16:14Taylor Pearson: But I think some of that his work on the Blitzkrieg and that sort of stuff I think is kind of more interesting than Udalloop or more informative for me, but just kind of like hard.
- 16:26Taylor Pearson: It's not neatly packaged up in a sort of succinct way like the other term, udalloop, is Interesting.
- 16:36Mark McGrath: Well, it's interesting you mentioned talking about Blitzkrieg when your Mutiny Fund webpage.
- 16:41Mark McGrath: One of the articles that caught my attention was the Maginot Line problem, and Maginot Line is something for years I've talked about with people how we build these things up and we get a lot of false comfort and false security in them And our competitors usually go right over them or right around them.
- 17:01Mark McGrath: Was that a Boyd-informed article when you wrote that?
- 17:09Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i think.
- 17:09Taylor Pearson: Then there's a great book.
- 17:10Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i probably wrote it.
- 17:11Taylor Pearson: It's called Systematics.
- 17:12Taylor Pearson: I think I retitled the systems Bible.
- 17:16Taylor Pearson: I think the author's name is John Gull.
- 17:16Taylor Pearson: I want to say it's from like the 80s.
- 17:18Taylor Pearson: One of his.
- 17:19Taylor Pearson: He has just a bunch of clever phrases in there, but one of them is the army is fully prepared to fight the previous war.
- 17:23Taylor Pearson: Right, which you see in military history, but also like in financial history.
- 17:28Taylor Pearson: Right, the asset managers are fully prepared for the previous crisis And you know, inevitably that means the next crisis will not be like.
- 17:35Taylor Pearson: You know everyone's.
- 17:38Taylor Pearson: It's interesting right now, like people talking about real estate and real estate crash or whatever, and I have no idea what's going to happen, but like it's probably not going to be.
- 17:45Taylor Pearson: Just a recap of the GFC right, like everyone lived through that.
- 17:49Taylor Pearson: Everyone remembers that, everyone knows, like, how that worked out.
- 17:53Taylor Pearson: Right, if there is a crisis, it's likely to evolve in some other way, and I guess the Silicon Valley Bank is actually an interesting example.
- 17:59Taylor Pearson: Right, like sort of post GFC, a lot of the focus on banks was on their loan books.
- 18:05Taylor Pearson: Right, the credit is that was what happened in GFC.
- 18:06Taylor Pearson: They made all these bad loans and the loans went bad And that was what caused the begging issue.
- 18:10Taylor Pearson: And like Silicon, from my understanding, i haven't read a ton of other Silicon Valley's loan book.
- 18:15Taylor Pearson: I think it's fine Like there was nothing bad about.
- 18:18Taylor Pearson: The credit quality is that they bought a bunch of long duration treasuries and they had duration mismatch, sort of, between their assets and their liabilities.
- 18:25Taylor Pearson: But I guess you know that makes sense, right, it's not?
- 18:29Taylor Pearson: They didn't repeat the same error they did 12 years ago.
- 18:31Taylor Pearson: But what's?
- 18:32Taylor Pearson: everyone remembers the error they made 12 years ago or 15 years ago.
- 18:34Taylor Pearson: They made a new sort of different one.
- 18:38Ponch RIvera: Yeah.
- 18:38Ponch RIvera: So on this, i want to connect the patterns of corruption that you saw, chet brief, financial crisis and what's happening today and, i think, and complexity theory.
- 18:47Ponch RIvera: So systems try behaviors right.
- 18:48Ponch RIvera: And if we go back to the GFC and we look at who was held to account or accountable for what happened, very few people were right.
- 18:57Ponch RIvera: In fact, the system bailed them out.
- 18:59Ponch RIvera: The lesson learned from that is to take more risk, potentially, and to tie this into a story that takes us to the Northwest part of LA several years ago, i was coaching a bank out there that was deeply involved in the GFC and I saw this.
- 19:18Ponch RIvera: We were doing the spaghetti challenge.
- 19:19Ponch RIvera: I don't know if you know what that is, but it's just like taking our marshmallow and spaghetti sticks and trying to stack them up as high as you can go.
- 19:26Ponch RIvera: What I noticed was these people in this organization were trying to cheat the system already and they were trying to get the game right, and that just told me a lot about the quality of people in there.
- 19:36Ponch RIvera: And maybe it's not the quality of people.
- 19:38Ponch RIvera: It's the system that drove the behavior, that drives the behavior, their daily behaviors.
- 19:42Ponch RIvera: You fast forward to today with SVB and you think about complexity theory, people taking risk.
- 19:47Ponch RIvera: We saw that some of the C-suite selling stock in the last couple weeks, or options in the last couple weeks, maybe a bonus going out to some employees.
- 19:58Ponch RIvera: There's what Mark and I call not patterns of conflict but patterns of corruption happening all around us.
- 20:04Ponch RIvera: Right, there's conflict, is natural.
- 20:06Ponch RIvera: It's happening in our brains, happening in our body, all around us.
- 20:09Ponch RIvera: Now we get into the moral aspect of things, which I think is what which actually I think drove a lot of your book.
- 20:16Ponch RIvera: If you go back several years on entrepreneurship, can you talk about what you view as happening from the lens of the ootlip or complexity theory and apply it to what you're seeing today and what you saw in the GFC and how that connects back to your book?
- 20:35Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i think to the point of sort of the moral thing.
- 20:37Taylor Pearson: I think there was kind of this shift historically in management.
- 20:40Taylor Pearson: I'm not sure sort of when it happened, but like it became very mechanical.
- 20:46Taylor Pearson: There's a great book, the Images of Organization, by Gareth Morgan, and it gives a it's eight different metaphors for thinking about an organization.
- 20:55Taylor Pearson: So one is like mechanical, one is biological, one is sort of like a complexity thing, one is a psychic prison, one is like a Marxist interpretation.
- 21:06Taylor Pearson: I can't remember all the other ones, but I think it's a book board would have liked, right, because it's like we can look at the same thing in eight different ways and all of these eight different interpretations are, you know, valid in their own way and that's sort of a meta-rational, meta-tognative aspect to it.
- 21:24Taylor Pearson: But I think the first two I just said are like mechanical and biological.
- 21:27Taylor Pearson: Right, there seems to have been this sort of big at some point sort of shifted management thinking to this very mechanical view that sort of took all the moral element or took a lot of the sort of like moral softer side and sort of just like set.
- 21:42Taylor Pearson: That that's not management, that's like mushy, that's something like we put over here on the side.
- 21:47Taylor Pearson: It's not sort of part of business administration And I think the term I like is like legibility, which is from, i think, james Scott, james G Scott, from Yale.
- 22:01Taylor Pearson: He has a book where he coined that term, but the idea is like there was this movement and he actually gives a really great example, which was the German Forest Service.
- 22:11Taylor Pearson: This was like 19th century.
- 22:13Taylor Pearson: It was sort of Germany was coming together and maybe it was Prussia sort of starting to, starting to centralize and have a centralized state and part of the state needs were lumber right, they had to build ships, they had to build homes, and so they wanted to sort of quantify or be able to predict how much lumber they were going to be able to get right.
- 22:37Taylor Pearson: So they went out and they surveyed all the forest And it was really hard to survey the forest right because you had different types of trees.
- 22:45Taylor Pearson: Growing in groves typically was the way most oak with forster go, and so it's really hard to estimate how much lumber there was.
- 22:50Taylor Pearson: There's also really hard to harvest right because, like, if you needed oak, there wasn't just like all the oak was lined up like corn in the farm, it was in different groves throughout the forest.
- 22:59Taylor Pearson: You had to get it out.
- 23:02Taylor Pearson: And so, over the process of decades, they started cutting down all these forests and building what they called scientific forests, which were just it looked like corn crops, right, it was just a row of trees, you know, in a grid pattern.
- 23:13Taylor Pearson: You planted them all at the same time.
- 23:16Taylor Pearson: It took 25 years.
- 23:17Taylor Pearson: Whatever it was for the needs of the point where they were harvested, you cut them all down.
- 23:21Taylor Pearson: It was very smooth to cut them all down And the feedback loop was so interesting because the feedback loop was like 100 years, like for the first 70 years.
- 23:31Taylor Pearson: This worked great, like lumber production went up, the cost of harvesting the lumber went way down, they were able to forecast the lumber much more accurately, and what they realized is, at some point, it turns out, all the stuff they stripped out of the forest was actually really valuable, which is the reason trees often growing groves is because then, if disease spreads among one species, it's limited to a grove, right?
- 23:55Taylor Pearson: so you have a grove of oaks.
- 23:56Taylor Pearson: Those all get wiped out by bacteria, paracetamol, whatever it is, but it doesn't spread over to the next growth, right?
- 24:02Taylor Pearson: so you get you don't get systemic forest death.
- 24:06Taylor Pearson: You get sort of this, i sort of groves and then the bacteria and the moss and sort of all the underbrush actually turns out to have been really important in preserving the health and the ability of the trees to grow right, and so you clear that out and all the good stuff was still in the soil.
- 24:23Taylor Pearson: But eventually you ran through all that stuff And so they had a like Walderstab and it was like forest death, just mass death of all these forests across all of Germany, because they, oh they, legible eyes.
- 24:36Taylor Pearson: Right, they tried to make this thing fit into a spreadsheet so that they could track this and they sort of gotten rid of all the parts that they couldn't measure and that's, you know, outside of, you know what was the role of the forest and the social system of the village, right, it was the place where the teenagers ran off and was sort of a semi independent spot where they could mature, right, like all these sorts of secondary effects that aren't obvious and sort of don't fit into an Excel sheet.
- 25:01Taylor Pearson: So I think that's, i think that's a really interesting idea And you can see that in a lot of different domains, that sort of desire to legible eyes, because I think you know you get talking about like the moral and mental domains and it's hard to do.
- 25:14Taylor Pearson: It's hard to do it in a concrete way, right like it's not.
- 25:17Taylor Pearson: It's not math, it's not physics, it's, you know, it's metaphysics, it's moral.
- 25:21Taylor Pearson: But that doesn't mean it's not important.
- 25:24Mark McGrath: Hmm, It's like.
- 25:26Mark McGrath: so it sounds like they put a very linear solution to a very nonlinear thing a very yeah, very symmetric versus the asymmetric.
- 25:36Mark McGrath: Yeah, it's interesting, a lot of those unintended consequences never get realized until until long after the fact.
- 25:44Ponch RIvera: Yeah.
- 25:45Ponch RIvera: I think just back to what Jim, jim Rut was saying is the short termness of everything.
- 25:48Ponch RIvera: Yeah, everybody's worried about next quarter, next year, you know, making their bonus doing all these things.
- 25:55Ponch RIvera: And this is what is wrong with organizations today, with businesses today They're short-sighted on things.
- 26:00Ponch RIvera: There's no accountability, right.
- 26:02Ponch RIvera: So in a complex system, i believe that we need to.
- 26:05Ponch RIvera: You know, if you make decisions in it, you need to own the consequences of it, too, right?
- 26:09Ponch RIvera: Which isn't happening today, right?
- 26:12Ponch RIvera: And then, taylor, is that aligned with your thinking too?
- 26:15Ponch RIvera: Or as far as ownership and decision making in complex systems, For sure.
- 26:22Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i think the challenge is just it's often hard to assign ownership, right Like you have who's the person that started the German force thing, and just the challenging of these, like measuring these feedback loops and seeing where it is.
- 26:37Taylor Pearson: But certainly, like you know, in sort of a healthy business culture, right Like someone is overseeing the sort of total output or total productivity, and that includes not just you know how many wages you're getting produced, right, but what are the sort of moral, emotional, what are you know, the other domains that are that are affected there And how does that impact the business in the future?
- 26:55Taylor Pearson: right, like you know you can increase which a production for six months and maybe that's great.
- 26:59Taylor Pearson: But if it makes it impossible to recruit people and you have high turnover, right Like you have to be able to think through those secondary and tertiary effects.
- 27:09Mark McGrath: Accountability is an interesting question.
- 27:11Mark McGrath: I did.
- 27:12Mark McGrath: I think it's correct, but it is going around the internet that the some guy with a very senior role at SVB was the CFO at Lehman Brothers.
- 27:25Ponch RIvera: I saw that.
- 27:26Ponch RIvera: I think they run them.
- 27:27Ponch RIvera: I think they run a somebody who was on the Fed board too.
- 27:29Ponch RIvera: We have to look that up before we print this, but are you guys tracking that?
- 27:34Ponch RIvera: That somebody is on the board?
- 27:35Mark McGrath: I hadn't seen that one.
- 27:36Mark McGrath: Yeah, we'll have to look it up.
- 27:39Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i saw that.
- 27:39Taylor Pearson: I want to say that I thought that I was right.
- 27:40Taylor Pearson: The CFO of SVB was something at Lehman previously.
- 27:45Taylor Pearson: I get my intuition about a lot of this stuff, though, is like there's definitely like moral hazard, there's definitely conflicts.
- 27:54Taylor Pearson: I think a lot of times, like complex systems just do things people don't expect, and I think it's interesting like there's obviously the in the sort of financial world like the Fed is always like the 800 pound gorilla in the room, right, and I don't have a good answer to this question, but I just always want to say like is the Fed important and powerful in financial markets?
- 28:16Taylor Pearson: Certainly, like there's no doubt, but your party thinks it's a bit over-sated, right, it's just like the market is very complex and you have these emerging things and people want to ascribe some agency to that.
- 28:29Taylor Pearson: They want to say the Fed raised rates and that caused this and this caused that, and there's some examples where you can probably say that, but I think a lot of times, it's just like we're not quite sure why it played out this way And so let's just, but that's an uncomfortable situation to be in, right, like we want to have someone to blame.
- 28:46Taylor Pearson: There's a strong, like you know, feel the sort of renaissance or hard idea of escape right, that you want to have a sacrificial lamb to say, oh well, it was this person's fault And so we'll sort of destroy this person.
- 28:59Taylor Pearson: And you know, that makes everyone feel better about the situation, whether or not it was that person's fault or not.
- 29:05Ponch RIvera: So we can potentially add this to our patterns of corruption.
- 29:07Ponch RIvera: Just pulled up here, the chief executive officer of failed Silicon Valley Bank, greg Becker, is no longer on the board of directors at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.
- 29:16Ponch RIvera: This is two days ago, all right, so there we go.
- 29:22Mark McGrath: Well, the one meme I did see going around Twitter about the Lehman Brothers guy was you can't make this stuff up.
- 29:29Mark McGrath: Like you couldn't make this stuff up if you tried.
- 29:32Mark McGrath: I know the long term capital management guy.
- 29:35Taylor Pearson: I'm blanking on his name, but he had another fund that had basically the same thing.
- 29:39Taylor Pearson: that blew up like 10 years later, And I think he had a third fund that blew up in COVID And it's an interesting example, you know but it's not.
- 29:49Taylor Pearson: Sometimes you don't learn.
- 29:51Ponch RIvera: The thing is, they're managing other people's money, right?
- 29:53Ponch RIvera: It's easy to lose other people's money.
- 29:55Ponch RIvera: It's hard to lose your own money, right Well?
- 29:57Taylor Pearson: the long term capital management thing was interesting because they kicked most of the investors.
- 30:00Taylor Pearson: In long term, capital management made money and they kicked them all out of the fund because they were at capacity, so they put more of their own money in there.
- 30:06Taylor Pearson: So they actually mostly just blew up their own In a lot of cases.
- 30:10Taylor Pearson: That's true, right, people manage other people's money and they're not good about it.
- 30:13Taylor Pearson: But long term capital management is interesting because I think almost all the external investors made a net positive return over the three or four years they were invested.
- 30:20Taylor Pearson: It was actually the people it was that they had kicked.
- 30:23Taylor Pearson: I had kicked out almost all the investors so they could put more of their own money to work because they thought the strategy was so great right, which is interesting.
- 30:30Taylor Pearson: It's like there was no, yeah, they weren't, it wasn't a principal agent problem.
- 30:35Taylor Pearson: They were just wrong and they lost a bunch of their own money.
- 30:39Ponch RIvera: So, taylor, how do we communicate this to my mom and dad, who may have a high school diploma, maybe some college, maybe a little bit of college?
- 30:50Ponch RIvera: How do we explain what's happening to folks that I mean, we're not special by any means, i'm just trying the average American that shopping on Walmart, trying to get by day by day?
- 31:03Ponch RIvera: how do we explain what's going on to them using these big words like finger spitting of fuel and the beautiful language that we get from Germany, where we call things like a butterfly schvittling or you know, and Einheit is one of this?
- 31:16Ponch RIvera: How do we communicate to them what they need to be aware of in this environment?
- 31:22Ponch RIvera: Not the stuff that we're seeing on the news, but how do we talk to the average American about complexity, science and Oudelübs and what you do with entrepreneurship?
- 31:33Taylor Pearson: I think there's probably some coming up with new terms and some stuff like that, but it's like pretty intuitive at a certain level.
- 31:41Taylor Pearson: If you work at a company and your boss is a dick and everyone hates him and everyone quits and you get that's not a good idea.
- 31:48Taylor Pearson: It's not that complex of a concept to understand that.
- 31:51Taylor Pearson: If you work at a company and everyone trusts each other and it's clear what the goals are and your people are allowed to make decisions about their domain, where they have the fingertip feeling, I think anyone that's worked in either of those environments it's not like a super, It's like yeah, of course, this is clearly working better than this other thing.
- 32:16Taylor Pearson: In some ways there's a bit of just a common sense element to it that I think has gotten like kind of we have to have this management science of exactly how the thing works, and sort of overcomplicated is my sense.
- 32:35Mark McGrath: Another book that you have on your Mutiny Fund page which hit me was The Organization Man by William White.
- 32:43Mark McGrath: What compelled you to include that classic?
- 32:51Taylor Pearson: I can't remember exactly the context from which I was writing right there, but it's a good.
- 32:56Taylor Pearson: You're asking about my book.
- 32:59Taylor Pearson: I have a book called The End of Jobs and sort of about I think it was called El DeY the changing economy and sort of more and more kind of gig work, freelance, entrepreneurial Stuff happening in that in that world.
- 33:11Taylor Pearson: So I was, i went back and I read that It looks.
- 33:16Taylor Pearson: It looks at the second.
- 33:18Taylor Pearson: I think it's 1950s, 1960s, when you're sort of the peak of this sort of like I, you know I kind of these iconic American corporations, you know the auto manufacturers and G and all that kind of stuff, and it was just an interesting example of how you have sort of the social system is in large part determined by sort of the What Carlotta Perez would collect, the techno economic paradigm right.
- 33:47Taylor Pearson: That, like the nature of Sort of the technology system we had at that time and the economics that grew out of that technology system, was the most efficient way to organize labor, wasn't these very large Companies, is very large conglomerates, right?
- 34:02Taylor Pearson: And so the way to get ahead Was to basically mold yourself into the organization right, to become the organization man sort of, to play by these politics and these rules, and that was sort of like how you, how you got ahead And the sort of interesting tradition like once you sort of had the microchip.
- 34:18Taylor Pearson: Right, once computers started to become Sort of the more dominant force in the time economic paradigm, that wasn't as much the case anymore.
- 34:27Taylor Pearson: Right, i can we think about sort of like the, the new rich, or right like we think of these sort of Silicon Valley Tech people that have gone on a different script and startups and all that kind of stuff.
- 34:35Taylor Pearson: But that didn't used to be like it was very hard, you know, comparatively, to do a Sort of global scale startup 50 years ago versus now.
- 34:46Taylor Pearson: Right, the the internet really changed that in terms of Opening up the distribution.
- 34:52Taylor Pearson: Right Like podcasting is a great example, blogging, all these things, right like you really are, reach Customers.
- 34:58Taylor Pearson: And then Just the cost right like the, the cost of starting most software businesses is Relatively nominal at this point.
- 35:09Taylor Pearson: Right, like it's a it's person with a laptop and an AWS instance and You're off to the races hmm, so the organization may, might be something of a dwindling species or endangered species.
- 35:24Taylor Pearson: Yeah, that's my sense, right?
- 35:25Taylor Pearson: I think there's a new sort of.
- 35:28Taylor Pearson: Article a few years ago called the blockchain man.
- 35:31Taylor Pearson: It was sort of a speculative sociology of our blockchain future.
- 35:36Taylor Pearson: But, right, this idea that you know that that's sort of a new paradigm like that.
- 35:41Taylor Pearson: The idea of public blockchains Is that they have, you know, you have these smart contracts which you're interacting with right and so it's, and the ways like Sort of sort of the organization man, you're the blockchain man, you're molding yourself to the needs of the blockchain.
- 35:56Taylor Pearson: And I want one of my friends coin this term, the, the selfless coin, like the selfless gene for mature dock ins, right, but in a way that the coin is sort of Determining all this behavior.
- 36:07Taylor Pearson: Right, people are reacting to the protocol and what the protocol needs, based on the price signals coming out of these Particular coins.
- 36:17Taylor Pearson: Right, but it's just yeah, like how to?
- 36:19Taylor Pearson: how to sort of society reorganize in that sort of world, right, and it I think it looks more sort of Freelancer, micro multinational has a term I like, right, i can you see that now.
- 36:29Taylor Pearson: Right, that's people to have an eight-person company spread, a you know distributed goal, you know people in four different continents and Customers and you know 50 different countries.
- 36:39Taylor Pearson: Right, that's not that weird of a thing to see now, nope we know exactly what you're talking about.
- 36:44Mark McGrath: Yeah, we know exactly what you're talking about To a tee.
- 36:49Mark McGrath: But you know, it's that contrast, that to say, my grandfather that worked for Exxon for 35 years And even as a retired pensioner he would he would run his car out of gas until he found an Exxon station, you know, like, like that kind of, that kind of take, i think is, you know, probably gone.
- 37:09Mark McGrath: There's probably less now than That's funny.
- 37:12Ponch RIvera: My, my grandparents would drive 50 miles to Cheyenne, wyoming, to save five cents on gas.
- 37:17Ponch RIvera: You know to come back in the 1970s, 1980s, kind of funny.
- 37:21Ponch RIvera: Things have changed right now.
- 37:24Mark McGrath: Well, my grandmother would tell me, though, the only time, he would ever not use Exxon as if they had a free car wash.
- 37:29Mark McGrath: So, but, yeah, different, different thinking.
- 37:35Mark McGrath: No, i like that book, you know, because if anybody that's ever worked in corporate, they've encountered the organization man, you know, yeah, or the organization, i guess, woman in person now, and They'll stop at nothing to preserve their Position and they generally don't take risks and the things that we're talking about, you know that are more Dealing with people, ideas and things in that order, you know, like leadership and trust, and that sort of thing is, i find it often punished or, you know, not, not practice.
- 38:12Mark McGrath: Well, so That's, that's good.
- 38:18Mark McGrath: So what's, what's?
- 38:19Mark McGrath: what's next for Amy?
- 38:21Mark McGrath: You have, you know, you're involved in a lot of things, including mutiny, fun and others.
- 38:24Mark McGrath: I mean, what's the, what's the big agenda there for the, you know, growth of that and how's that going?
- 38:34Taylor Pearson: Yup.
- 38:34Taylor Pearson: So Mutiny is a fund I started four years ago with my business partner Jason.
- 38:43Taylor Pearson: I'll do it actually give the general.
- 38:45Taylor Pearson: This is not investment advice.
- 38:46Taylor Pearson: Nothing I say here.
- 38:48Taylor Pearson: This is entertainment purposes only.
- 38:49Taylor Pearson: Past performance is not indicative of future results, et cetera et cetera.
- 38:55Taylor Pearson: But, yeah, we do that started in, we started working on it in 2019.
- 38:59Taylor Pearson: We also in 2020, our first strategy was a long volatility strategy.
- 39:06Taylor Pearson: So I mentioned to him it seemed to him earlier he had done some stuff with that historically.
- 39:11Taylor Pearson: Sort of like buying options is sort of the most simple vanilla version of that strategy.
- 39:17Taylor Pearson: There's many, many other ways to sort of implement it, but the basic idea being that when you have sort of big liquidity events in markets, like sort of March 2020, COVID scenarios that you're able to do well in that scenario.
- 39:31Taylor Pearson: And then we launched our second fund in 2021 that was called the cockroach fund, but it does that sort of some of the volatility stuff we were already doing.
- 39:43Taylor Pearson: And then also sort of broadly diversified portfolio So stocks, bombs, commodities, trend following strategies, some various other things in there.
- 39:56Taylor Pearson: So our kind of interest in that really we started it mostly for ourselves.
- 40:00Taylor Pearson: That was kind of how we wanted to invest And you know, over time sort of brought more people into it and it became a became more of a business than just sort of a personal investment strategy.
- 40:20Taylor Pearson: But I think you know a lot of the way we think about things that I think that the cockroach fund in particular, sort of our thesis.
- 40:28Taylor Pearson: There is just that we don't believe we have any ability to predict macroeconomic events or regimes, right, and once you start from that perspective, how do you work your way backwards into some sort of portfolio construction?
- 40:44Taylor Pearson: So I think the basic things that implies are just some very high level of diversification, right, like you know, ultimately diversification.
- 40:52Taylor Pearson: So I think Warren Buffett has a quote.
- 40:53Taylor Pearson: It's like diversification implies you're ignorant or something It's not.
- 40:58Taylor Pearson: It's something.
- 40:59Taylor Pearson: To that extent I think I'm like exactly, like, exactly, i'm ignorant and that's how I'm diversifying.
- 41:05Taylor Pearson: And so, yeah, i think that's that's sort of the core of the philosophy.
- 41:11Taylor Pearson: You know we named it Newtony because that's a bit of an untraditional approach.
- 41:17Taylor Pearson: I think most sort of asset management is very focused on sort of stock bond portfolios.
- 41:23Taylor Pearson: You know that's a fairly typical thing.
- 41:25Taylor Pearson: You'll see sort of whatever 60% stock, 40% bonds, maybe you have 5% and something like alternatives or commodities.
- 41:32Taylor Pearson: But you know, we really felt that if you look at sort of the longer stretch of history, not just the last 30 or 40 years in the US, that that doesn't really constitute sufficient diversification, that there's lots of periods and lots of countries.
- 41:47Taylor Pearson: You know in the US sort of late 60s to early 80s, where stocks and bonds did pretty poorly at the same time for 15 or 20 years, and so, yeah, that's kind of what we're working on there and I think it's.
- 42:01Taylor Pearson: For me it's been fun, it's sort of an interesting expression of a lot of the ideas I've been thinking about for a long time.
- 42:07Taylor Pearson: That's like, you know, how do we, how do we start from this position of you know I can't predict the future and work our way backwards to, ok, well, how do I sort of prepare or put myself in a situation that, no matter what the future unfolds, i've kind of done my best to manage that.
- 42:22Taylor Pearson: So we talk a lot about stuff like, you know, path dependency right that you have all these different paths, and how do you account for those?
- 42:30Ponch RIvera: This is awesome.
- 42:31Ponch RIvera: So you mentioned the seem to labor layer.
- 42:33Ponch RIvera: You know his background is derivatives trader, options trader and then came up with the concept of anti fragile and all his great work.
- 42:40Ponch RIvera: Not a lot of people know that.
- 42:42Ponch RIvera: You know, not a lot of people know his background and the derivatives market Brilliant, brilliant human being right Looking around the landscape today.
- 42:51Ponch RIvera: Who do you follow, who do you trust in asset management?
- 42:54Ponch RIvera: Who's who are the thought leaders that you're really paying attention to right now?
- 42:59Taylor Pearson: That's a good question.
- 43:01Ponch RIvera: Or maybe they're outside of the market too.
- 43:03Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i don't.
- 43:04Taylor Pearson: I think broadly the asset sort of you know the stuff we're talking about, the sort of more complexity, i think broadly the asset management industry doesn't get that And that hasn't really sunk in yet.
- 43:19Taylor Pearson: That's sort of my impression And I think we can talk about a lot of reasons for that.
- 43:24Taylor Pearson: As an asset manager it's often hard to go against the crowd, right, because you know it's often the same.
- 43:32Taylor Pearson: You know sort of copying everyone else's.
- 43:33Taylor Pearson: You know you lose money when everyone else loses money.
- 43:35Taylor Pearson: So you can always say like well, we lost money, but look, everyone else lost money too, whereas doing something different means you can lose money when other people are making money, and you know that can be hard to explain unless your clients sort of really understand why it is.
- 43:49Ponch RIvera: So what are the tools that allow you to use complexity thinking in the Udalloop right now?
- 43:52Ponch RIvera: I mean, you brought up some trend following.
- 43:54Ponch RIvera: You brought up some path dependency things.
- 43:56Ponch RIvera: What else are you using Or you think that need to be used to really understand how to be a maverick?
- 44:03Ponch RIvera: I hate to say maverick, but how do you be a maverick in a market environment?
- 44:07Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i think at a high level, like I think, just thinking a lot more broadly about diversification, right, like I think typically people say, oh, i sort of own the S&P 500.
- 44:16Taylor Pearson: And so that's a sort of diversified portfolio And everything's in degrees, right, you know it's earning that more diversified than earning you know all your assets in Apple stock?
- 44:24Taylor Pearson: No, i think so.
- 44:27Taylor Pearson: But I think there's a lot of changes in the financial landscape in the last 20 years, like you know, just the emergence of ETFs and mutual funds, that there's a lot of access to products and strategies.
- 44:38Taylor Pearson: Now that just didn't exist.
- 44:40Taylor Pearson: My partner and I were both kind of inspired or we came together by the work of Harry Brown, who's a financial advisor in Tennessee, in the 70s and 80s I believe.
- 44:50Taylor Pearson: But he came up with this idea called the permanent portfolio And it's beautiful and it's simplicity.
- 44:57Taylor Pearson: It's equal parts stocks, bonds, cash and gold.
- 45:00Taylor Pearson: So that's the whole portfolio.
- 45:02Taylor Pearson: So you have 25% stocks, 25% bonds, free version, cash and version of gold.
- 45:05Taylor Pearson: And I think he rebalanced it once a year.
- 45:08Taylor Pearson: He had like rebalancing bands, you know.
- 45:10Taylor Pearson: Once one got to more than 30% you rebalanced the whole portfolio.
- 45:15Taylor Pearson: And I want to say he came up with it early 70s, something like that.
- 45:20Mark McGrath: That sounds right.
- 45:21Mark McGrath: Yeah, he's very popular in I'm going down to the Mises Institute this weekend and he's very popular with a lot of the followers of Austrian economics.
- 45:33Taylor Pearson: Okay, yeah, that makes sense.
- 45:34Taylor Pearson: I can see this sort of….
- 45:36Mark McGrath: Because he was a libertarian politician, I think.
- 45:39Taylor Pearson: He also had I think he ran for like libertarian president candidate one year and he had another book that was sort of a libertarian manifesto.
- 45:48Taylor Pearson: But you know, out of sample, you look at the performance of that strategy since he came up with it in 1970s.
- 45:54Taylor Pearson: The risk-adjusted returns are like remarkably good, like it did really well, and so I think in some ways we just kind of thought of what we're doing as a modern version of that.
- 46:05Taylor Pearson: You know, there's just things in his book he's talking about like how you do the portfolio.
- 46:09Taylor Pearson: It's like to buy treasury bonds, right, You have to call up your broker and there's the whole auction.
- 46:16Taylor Pearson: It was like hard to buy treasury bonds And he said like that was like a lot.
- 46:20Taylor Pearson: I was like work, like he had to know what… You kind of know how to system.
- 46:23Taylor Pearson: Now there's mutual funds and ETFs and just access to these sorts of private funds.
- 46:29Taylor Pearson: There's just much broader now.
- 46:32Taylor Pearson: So I think trend following in my experience, trend following is probably the most interesting and accessible strategy that most investors don't know about or ignore.
- 46:44Taylor Pearson: You know, from the data I've seen, it's historically been a very good diversifier for stock bond portfolios.
- 46:51Taylor Pearson: It's available in a lot of private funds, mutual funds, that kind of stuff.
- 46:58Taylor Pearson: So yeah, i think like that's probably.
- 47:00Taylor Pearson: You know, i talk to people that have sort of traditional portfolios.
- 47:03Taylor Pearson: That's usually kind of where I point them.
- 47:04Taylor Pearson: First I'm like, hey, go read some stuff about trend following and think about how that sort of impacts your portfolio, and then I think there's a whole range of….
- 47:11Taylor Pearson: There you go, mr Kavell's book.
- 47:15Mark McGrath: Yeah, i mean to me it's UDA.
- 47:17Mark McGrath: I mean it's a differentiated orientation and it's so radically different from everything else.
- 47:24Mark McGrath: It really does make me think that, as I read it and I study more of the trend followers, i think that Boyd would find them interesting.
- 47:33Taylor Pearson: Yeah, that's interesting when I say it's a differentiated orientation.
- 47:36Taylor Pearson: But yes, that's right, That's what it is Like.
- 47:37Taylor Pearson: You're creating a sort of return profile from these markets based on sort of the nature of how the strategy operates And how that return profile integrates with the rest of your portfolio, And there's very much like a sort of complex aspect to it.
- 47:53Taylor Pearson: I think that's… I generally that's one of my big… Almost all investors are… The vast majority tend to look at their portfolios as individual elements.
- 48:07Taylor Pearson: Right, it's like I like this investment, I like that investment, i like that investment, i like that investment.
- 48:11Taylor Pearson: And very rarely outside of like certain professional quantitative investors do I hear people talk about how those parts interact.
- 48:21Taylor Pearson: So, like trend following, for example, trend following sort of 2010 to 2021 was bad.
- 48:29Taylor Pearson: I think a lot of trend followers did well sort of GFC time period And then trend was basically a lot.
- 48:37Taylor Pearson: You know, a lot of the trend indices were like flat to maybe slightly positive for like the whole decade of the 2010s And like really fell out of favor And I think a lot of people sort of rushed into those strategies after the GFC.
- 48:49Taylor Pearson: They saw this good performance, it was a good diversifier And a bunch of people flooded in and then just sort of had like flat performance for a long time And most people were like oh you know, it's got bad returns.
- 49:05Mark McGrath: It's a good strategy.
- 49:06Mark McGrath: People say, oh it's dead, It's dead.
- 49:09Taylor Pearson: But I kind of look at that and I go, well, it was a really good diversifier, and then you could hold it for a long period and it was just flat, like that's great.
- 49:17Taylor Pearson: So, it's like it's either flat or it's helping you diversify the rest of your portfolio, but you have to look at it as sort of a piece of the broader picture.
- 49:27Taylor Pearson: As a pure standalone, i can understand why people don't think it makes sense, but if you look at it as a part of the broader portfolio, so I think that sort of thinking is sorely lacking in most of the asset management business.
- 49:40Ponch RIvera: So I want to try to connect us to the Udalloop.
- 49:43Ponch RIvera: So when we talk about the Udalloop, it's being right, it's not something.
- 49:48Ponch RIvera: Being connected to the loop means that we have genetics, we have previous experience, we have our culture In that genetic heritage.
- 49:56Ponch RIvera: You could think of our biases right, or heuristics, stunk, cost fallacy resulting you know, there's many, many, many to list.
- 50:06Ponch RIvera: When you put humans in a system where there's money involved, our biases kick in right.
- 50:12Ponch RIvera: A lot of times it's harder to sell a winner than it is a loser.
- 50:15Ponch RIvera: But what trend falling does?
- 50:17Ponch RIvera: it tells you when to do something right.
- 50:20Ponch RIvera: It tells you when to execute, to sell, to buy.
- 50:22Ponch RIvera: It kind of takes the biases out of it, which is absolutely critical.
- 50:27Ponch RIvera: This type of orientation addresses individuals' OODA loop right, the way we're biased towards something.
- 50:35Ponch RIvera: One thing that's emerging right now and we'll make connection here to physics with an episode with Asia and Beijing Talking about going back to UX, ui point why humans like things right.
- 50:46Ponch RIvera: They're visually stimulating to us, they're symmetrical, there's fee involved, there's geometry involved in a lot of things.
- 50:53Ponch RIvera: This is starting to become true in a lot of trend falling too.
- 50:57Ponch RIvera: So you're using harmonics, you're using dates when things are purchased, you're using the distance between planets.
- 51:03Ponch RIvera: I know it sounds weird, but we're starting to move away from the 50-day, 200-day moving averages, away from Fibonacci, so you move more towards Elliott Wave, more towards this geometry, which is absolutely fascinating.
- 51:14Ponch RIvera: Are you seeing any uptake on that in your space or are you still in the legacy trend following area with Fibonacci and 50-day and 200-day moving averages?
- 51:24Taylor Pearson: I guess, from what I see, there's a pretty broad diversification, right, there's some people that are classic trend followers and they're doing it the same way they were doing it in 1970.
- 51:35Taylor Pearson: And there's other people that are yeah, they've come up with lots of updates and modifications.
- 51:40Taylor Pearson: You never know what that's going to look like going forward.
- 51:47Taylor Pearson: So I think again I kind of come from my perspective it's like you probably want to diversify across a variety of those different approaches.
- 51:54Taylor Pearson: Because is the newer stuff just doing some clever curve fitting with some more data, whereas the classic stuff is the performance is all out of sample.
- 52:06Taylor Pearson: I started doing it that way in 1980, and you're still doing it that way today.
- 52:10Taylor Pearson: There was no curve fitting that went on over that period.
- 52:13Taylor Pearson: So, yeah, definitely if you were doing new things I don't have super strong feelings on, is it better to stick with the classic approach?
- 52:21Taylor Pearson: I think my default thing with all this is I'm not sure.
- 52:26Taylor Pearson: So using a combination of all of them seems prudent.
- 52:31Mark McGrath: It seems like trend following, too, can be kind of a tapestry or a patchwork quilt of a lot of you know.
- 52:37Mark McGrath: I don't know that we can aggregate them as one defined block, because a lot of them do very different things in their own, in their own respects, i guess under the.
- 52:47Mark McGrath: Yet at the same time, i feel like the one thing I do have in common is that it is a very differentiated orientation that you know in the idea of void, using your orientation to shape and adapt and identifying and generating mismatches.
- 53:02Mark McGrath: Trend following traders of any flavor seem to be doing very well and they don't seem to get psychologically as rattled.
- 53:11Mark McGrath: It seems that they have their behavior under control versus, versus others.
- 53:16Ponch RIvera: Yeah, and this comes back to retrospective coherence.
- 53:18Ponch RIvera: When something like SVB happens, we look back and see all the things that could or why it happened right, but we don't see them before it happens.
- 53:26Ponch RIvera: And the thing about complexity you know complex adaptive systems.
- 53:30Ponch RIvera: There's no connection between cause and effect until after the event, when we look backwards at it.
- 53:35Ponch RIvera: What trend following does?
- 53:37Ponch RIvera: and if you, i don't know.
- 53:38Ponch RIvera: If we go back to Thursday or Wednesday of last week, some folks were looking at a down market on Friday, right, it didn't matter why It didn't matter.
- 53:46Ponch RIvera: You know it doesn't matter to them why.
- 53:47Ponch RIvera: They just say the trend shows us we're going down, and then later that afternoon they find out why, which is not as important as the fact that it did go down.
- 53:55Ponch RIvera: Right.
- 53:56Ponch RIvera: So you know, that's what trend following does for us.
- 53:59Ponch RIvera: Is it tells us a direction or gives us a probability of a direction, but it doesn't tell us the why.
- 54:04Ponch RIvera: We don't need to know the why.
- 54:05Ponch RIvera: Is that how you're sharing this with your customers, your investors?
- 54:13Taylor Pearson: Yeah right, It is a systematic strategy, right Then, as you said there are different rules and people do a two-in-a-day moving average, but a three-in-a-day moving average is for an honesty of all these different ways you can set up the rules.
- 54:24Taylor Pearson: I think it's.
- 54:25Taylor Pearson: You know.
- 54:27Taylor Pearson: The truth is no one knows why it works.
- 54:29Taylor Pearson: I think there's a good paper I think AQR put out, called like 100 years of trend following or a century of trend following, and it looked at Yeah, it's excellent.
- 54:37Mark McGrath: That's yes, that's Cliff Asness's group.
- 54:40Ponch RIvera: Yes, that's an excellent paper.
- 54:42Taylor Pearson: Yeah, I've got the link to that The history of basically studying trends, like are there trends?
- 54:48Taylor Pearson: do markets trend?
- 54:50Taylor Pearson: It looks at, i think, a bunch of different stock markets, commodity markets, this very broad thing.
- 54:58Taylor Pearson: It's just like it's sort of a trend in value and sort of the quantitative finance literature, the two most sort of persistent anomalies.
- 55:07Taylor Pearson: But, right, the truth is like no one knows why trend has been a persistent anomaly.
- 55:14Taylor Pearson: There's lots of theories.
- 55:16Taylor Pearson: I think most of the theories are probably some sort of behavioral, economic ones, like hurting and overreaction, right, that people tend to see the market going up and people crowd in and then people panic too much at the bottom and so you get these sort of over and under reactions that show up as persistent trends.
- 55:31Taylor Pearson: But the truth is like no one knows.
- 55:35Taylor Pearson: It's just like, if you look over a long stretch of history across many markets, like it does seem to be evidence that trending is happening And so you know seems like it.
- 55:50Mark McGrath: I always find it more valuable after the fact, like I can explain, if I understand, say, business cycle theory, i can explain something after the fact, but I'm not going to try to use that to anticipate certain moves in the market.
- 56:02Mark McGrath: I'm not going to do what my system tells me to do.
- 56:04Mark McGrath: I'm not going to try to be smarter than it And then I might be able to go back and explain well, fractional reserve banking is X, y and Z and price signals were distorted and there's malinvestments, but I'm not going to try to anticipate what that's going to do going forward, because there's no way, given just uncertainty, there's just no way you could even know that.
- 56:24Mark McGrath: That's what Jim Rutt said in our podcast.
- 56:26Mark McGrath: It's unknowable, like that's absolutely unknowable And that's the best you're guessing.
- 56:34Mark McGrath: So I mean, i find that most of the seasoned trend followers that you read or learn about, they don't do that.
- 56:39Mark McGrath: They're not predicting the future.
- 56:41Mark McGrath: They have systems that they've tested and that they're.
- 56:44Mark McGrath: It's kind of like you know they've got these things set up And then, yeah, again after the fact, yeah, sure, we can go talk about it, but we're never going to try to, you know, include that into an equation, to think what could happen.
- 57:00Mark McGrath: I don't know anything could happen, you know, yeah, but and I find too, you mentioned we've been talking a lot about Taleb, i think the other thing about trend followers I find interesting.
- 57:11Mark McGrath: It seems to me that most of them they do it themselves and they have skin in the game.
- 57:15Mark McGrath: And skin in the game is something that, back to Pontius' point, you know tying it all up, i guess you know, with accountability.
- 57:21Mark McGrath: I think that skin in the game is something that is, it should be in a lot higher demand than it is.
- 57:31Taylor Pearson: Yeah, i mean, i think the systematic nature of it is certainly appealing in some ways.
- 57:38Taylor Pearson: Right, like I think for the most part, most investors would be better.
- 57:41Taylor Pearson: You know doing things.
- 57:43Taylor Pearson: This is what I'm committing to.
- 57:44Taylor Pearson: This is my portfolio.
- 57:44Taylor Pearson: I'm doing this at these times with these rules, then making decisions in real time.
- 57:50Taylor Pearson: I don't have any hard data on that, but I suspect that's probably.
- 57:54Taylor Pearson: You probably get worse outcomes than having a plan and sticking to it.
- 58:02Mark McGrath: Outstanding.
- 58:02Mark McGrath: Yeah, Let's say we could go for hours on that topic.
- 58:06Mark McGrath: I'm sure I know we don't have hours to do it, but Taylor, where could we direct people to?
- 58:12Mark McGrath: So there's TaylorPersonme, there's the book The End of Jobs.
- 58:18Mark McGrath: Like I was saying, you've done a brilliant compendium.
- 58:23Mark McGrath: That sounds like.
- 58:23Mark McGrath: I'll be looking forward to seeing the revision of your Udalloop notes.
- 58:28Mark McGrath: Anywhere else that you would want us to direct people to, No, that's great.
- 58:34Taylor Pearson: Yeah, TaylorPersonme is my personal site.
- 58:35Taylor Pearson: I send out a newsletter every month or so, which is book and article recommendations.
- 58:41Taylor Pearson: That's usually how most people stay in touch.
- 58:46Mark McGrath: Outstanding Well, we thank you for coming and joining the conversation with us on No Way Out.
- 58:52Mark McGrath: Hopefully this won't be the last one.
- 58:54Mark McGrath: We'll have you back at a later date.
- 58:57Taylor Pearson: No, it's a pleasure.
- 58:57Taylor Pearson: As I said, i've really enjoyed the podcast, so I look forward to more of it.
- 59:04Mark McGrath: Awesome.
- 59:04Mark McGrath: Thanks, Taylor.