Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Hamas's Globalized Strategy in Gaza: Irina Tsukerman's Middle East Analysis | KAJ Masterclass
Transcript
- 0:00Right, let's now move on to the Middle East.
- 0:03What's happening at Gaza and from Gaza?
- 0:06Things are happening now in Denmark, Germany.
- 0:09They quoted Hamas attacks in Europe.
- 0:12So what do these operations, globalized operations by Hamas,
- 0:16means? What is happening between US and
- 0:19Israel? There seem to be a lot of
- 0:22different voices coming. Is US now moving away from
- 0:26Israel? How does it all look like?
- 0:29There are lots of visit happening.
- 0:31I want to understand, you know, what is happening at that end in
- 0:34terms of Hamas, in terms of globalized operation, in terms
- 0:38of the relationship between US and Israel?
- 0:43Well, it's been a complicated few weeks, but Hamas is actually
- 0:46carrying out exactly what it promised to do, and it can be
- 0:50trusted to. Once it starts talking publicly,
- 0:54you can you can be sure that what they say is exactly what
- 0:57they mean when they're deceiving.
- 0:59When they're quiet, they may be lying, they may be pretending,
- 1:03But once they start discussing the strategy, they are very
- 1:05clear about their goals and agenda.
- 1:08And they're following exactly what they laid out in the very
- 1:11beginning of the war, which was that they had plans with Iran's
- 1:15backing to attack locations in other countries and European
- 1:21countries where they started targeting Israelis.
- 1:24Where are those countries? They they are going global.
- 1:27They have been global for a while.
- 1:29The financing certainly has been global.
- 1:32We have seen articles coming out on various investment projects
- 1:36in various parts of the world, in in Europe, in Turkey, and now
- 1:41we're seeing that their cells are coming to fruition.
- 1:44Germany has been rounding up some of the Hamas operatives,
- 1:48but other parts of the world have not been as aggressive and
- 1:50even Germany can't necessarily identify every single location
- 1:54and every single cell. So there's been a cross-border
- 1:58cooperation in trying to stage these attacks.
- 2:01For now they're still sticking to Israeli targets and but it
- 2:07But first of all, in a terrorist attack even non Israelis can be
- 2:11harmed. And 2nd, it's only a matter of
- 2:13time when before they start targeting everyone else.
- 2:16As we have seen during during the war, they deliberately took
- 2:21foreign workers hostage, they took Arab Israelis hostage, they
- 2:25have killed Arab Israelis and other foreigners.
- 2:29So there is no ethnic or religious discrimination.
- 2:34There's only a particular strategy, and the strategy is
- 2:37only likely to expand. As far as the US and Israel are
- 2:41concerned, yes, there are differences.
- 2:44The biggest difference is about the future.
- 2:47Who will govern Gaza. Personalizing, it's still too
- 2:50early to count those chickens, and actually it's too early to
- 2:54count on the complete success of the separation.
- 2:57I don't think that the entire military echelon from Hamas is
- 3:03going to be eliminated, eliminated anytime soon.
- 3:06They may take out a few liters and that all of the hostages
- 3:10have been released or rescued yet.
- 3:13And of course in the all of these tunnels that need to be
- 3:16destroyed are very difficult to destroy.
- 3:19Now there may be a shifting strategy in trying to break them
- 3:23up into molds because blowing up of gas is just not feasible.
- 3:29It's creating a lot of outrage, and there's been several
- 3:32incidents of friendly fire and accidents involving civilians,
- 3:38Christians and Gaza and so forth that just created a lot of very
- 3:42bad objects. US has also been trying to get
- 3:45Israel to have a plan for transition to different to a
- 3:52different strategy in the future.
- 3:55The fact is, on the one hand, US is putting some of this pressure
- 3:58too early. On the other hand, Israel
- 4:01doesn't seem to have an actual transition plan.
- 4:03So anything different there they see have a general objection,
- 4:07I'm not entirely sure they know how to quite get to that point.
- 4:12So I think it is wise to start thinking what to do next.
- 4:16But I also agree with John Kirby, who said that it's not
- 4:21wise to put timelines and timestamps on the any phase of
- 4:26the operation because it will simply give Hamas an unfair
- 4:30leverage. It will tell them exactly what
- 4:32to expect and how to restructure their aims.
- 4:35Now, Israel is proposing a new ceasefire for lasting over a
- 4:39week if Hamas releases over three dozen hostages unharmed.
- 4:46Hamas has previously rejected the possibility of such
- 4:49exchanges very recently. I don't know how they will react
- 4:53to this latest development that's been brokered by Qatar,
- 4:57but they have also at various points asked for a ceasefire on
- 5:02terms that Israel could not accept.
- 5:04So. So they clearly do want and need
- 5:06a pause. It's said that Israel is getting
- 5:09closer to Yahir Sinbar. His brother was observed riding
- 5:13through one of the biggest tunnels uncovered so far.
- 5:19So if Yahir Simba is liquidated or captured, that would be a
- 5:24huge PR victory for Israel to build a huge military
- 5:29breakthrough. But until that point, they still
- 5:34have to deal with the reality that Hamas is has been
- 5:39thoroughly entrenched in Gaza, and Hamas also has links outside
- 5:44Gaza, and they're seeing that US, European countries are only
- 5:49starting to sanction a lot of these Hamas players.
- 5:52It's unclear where the sanctions were in the past, given that
- 5:57Hamas is on the terrorist list in all these countries.
- 6:00But I guess they thought that Hamas was not an immediate great
- 6:05danger and did not feel like stirring the hornet's nest by
- 6:10aggressively and publicly going after these actors.
- 6:13Whatever the case may be, they're starting to do that now
- 6:16and it will be a while before these sanctions really take
- 6:19effect on the financing. But the good news is Israel did
- 6:23eliminate one of the top Hamas financiers in Gaza.
- 6:28So. So that should send a message at
- 6:32least. There's also rumors that some of
- 6:34the Hamas leadership left Qatar and Turkey in an unknown
- 6:38direction after Israel's threats to assassinate them.
- 6:44That could be also be a minus because now that you don't know
- 6:47where they are, it took it harder to find it and actually
- 6:50kill them. So I don't know whether that
- 6:52public announcement really was necessary, but I think at the
- 6:57end of the day, US and Israel, despite whatever these
- 7:00differences in strategy, they are kind of stuck together.
- 7:04Whatever Netanyahu may say to the public and whatever US may
- 7:08say in an election year to its very diverse constituents, the
- 7:13security situation is such that neither country can afford to
- 7:17the West from another. You have US is relying on local
- 7:24Israeli contacts, intelligence contacts for Hamas intelligence.
- 7:29the US has not been following that intelligence for the last
- 7:31two years and the US does want Hamas eliminated.
- 7:34With that, Israel let's simply not going to be possible.
- 7:37We'll be back to where we started the 2nd cater The
- 7:41lieutenants will rebuild if if they're left in power, they'll
- 7:45continue holding Palestinians hostage, and they'll simply take
- 7:49over Gaza again as soon as it becomes feasible.
- 7:52If they're not fully destroyed or eliminated in such in some
- 7:58way, in such a way that they cannot easily restructure, it's
- 8:02still a huge job and there still needs to be a lot of political
- 8:05pressure, financial pressure, simply cutting off weapons for
- 8:09financing, creating an international involvement in
- 8:15some way. All of these things are
- 8:17complicated and necessary. But at the end of the day,
- 8:20Israel and the US rely on each other for security reasons, and
- 8:25the situation in the Middle East is becoming far more
- 8:28complicated. We are seeing attacks by the
- 8:30cookies on a daily basis. We are seeing a new coalition of
- 8:35ships trying to take down drones coming to the area and missiles
- 8:41and protecting commercial ships. We're seeing the impact this
- 8:45time on the economy and we're seeing many state visits to the
- 8:49region in parts to convince Israel to take measures to
- 8:54prevent escalation in reported with Simpson Gaza.
- 8:58But again, there's a lot of disagreement on whether those
- 9:01numbers are real and what should actually be done.
- 9:04And there's also other discussions, discussions
- 9:07concerning the Red Sea security. And now the cookies are also
- 9:11directly threatening other countries, including the US,
- 9:15including Bahrain and other members of that coalition.
- 9:19So we there's a lot to discuss, but there is a major difference
- 9:24inside the GCC which is preventing A unified strategy.
- 9:29So your Rebus, specifically as the US to abstain from offensive
- 9:32attack on Hoochie launch sites. They are afraid.
- 9:37They're concerned about direct attacks in their own territory,
- 9:42which have happened before and in some cases just failed to
- 9:45come to the rescue. UE on the other hand, has asked
- 9:49us to do exactly the opposite. They encourage us to intervene.
- 9:53And US has also been in the past attacked and threatened by the
- 9:57Huggies. So this uneven strategy
- 10:00unfortunately is playing right into the hands of Iran, which is
- 10:04masterminding with all of this disruption.
- 10:06It's causing some ships to take the long scenic route around
- 10:10Cape, delaying delivery of oil and gas, raising prices for the
- 10:14Far East countries like Japan and South Korea, heavily
- 10:18dependent on imports, and also causing a gas spike in Europe as
- 10:22well. So we are seeing that cookies
- 10:25are actually achieving their goals and they do not feel at
- 10:28all threatened. And all these visits so far have
- 10:32not resulted in any solution for all of us.
- 10:35Right, right. In terms of, you know, Middle
- 10:38East, US has been, you know, it's almost like every subtle
- 10:42diplomacy at a high level, a lot of visits already made.
- 10:45Now national security adviser, Jake Sullivan, US Secretary of
- 10:49Defence, Lloyd Austin, they have been, they are now travelling to
- 10:52Middle East, meeting not only the Middle East also, but also
- 10:56MBS and others. What does this all indicate?
- 10:59What should we understand? What is it that they can't
- 11:02convey on the phone that they have to visit there?
- 11:05I I I think first of all, I think they're hoping that Saudi
- 11:10Arabia will shift in the direction of some more active
- 11:14role in Gaza because the current scenario is kind of a dead end.
- 11:21It's unclear how long the Israeli operation is going to
- 11:26proceed. It's like we're going to be long
- 11:28term. There needs to be US is looking
- 11:31for investors in Gaza for a rebuilding process.
- 11:34They want some solution for their ID, PS and for the
- 11:38refugees, and they want additional sources of
- 11:42humanitarian aid. But just as important that there
- 11:46is a a concern about the Hoki situation, about the regional
- 11:51security, possible escalation of Hezbollah and what to do about
- 11:55it. And I think the US is not happy
- 11:58that the Saudi Saudis have been preventing US from taking more
- 12:03active measures, which US has threatened to do.
- 12:06And well, to be fair, in the past US has been extremely
- 12:10reluctant to get involved in Yemen on that level and against,
- 12:14which is the fact that the targets have become so
- 12:18persistent and overwhelming and the disruptions to the freedom
- 12:22of navigation has been so significant.
- 12:24I think it has shifted even the Pentagon thinking on this, but
- 12:29the Saudis remain an obstacle and I think that meeting was at
- 12:34least partially geared towards getting some sort of agreement.
- 12:38To that end, it remains to be seen what, if anything, because
- 12:42you know what red line has come out of it.
- 12:45So far it's not clear if there has been any.
- 12:49Right, right, Irina.