Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Whitewash: The Hidden Roots of White Supremacy (with Dr. Robert P. Jones)
Transcript
- 0:05The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting faith,
- 0:15pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth, it's
- 0:20because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a book
- 0:24and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take the
- 0:29risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Beausian wisdom will come
- 0:33to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth Andrews, My very special
- 0:57guest today has a PhD in religion from Emory University. He has a master's
- 1:03of Divinity from Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. He is also a computer guy and
- 1:10a math guy. He's got a bachelor's in computing science and mathematics from Mississippi
- 1:15College. He is president and founder of pr r I, the Public Religion
- 1:23Research Institute. He has had his work and perspectives featured on outlets like Time
- 1:29Magazine, The Atlantic, cnnn PR, The New York Times. He is
- 1:34author of several books, including the one I want to speak about most Today.
- 1:38It is the hidden roots of white supremacy and the path to a shared
- 1:45American future. His name is doctor Robert P. Jones, and I'm so
- 1:49glad you're here. Thanks for coming, thanks for having me. I understand
- 1:53why you didn't go with Bob Jones. Yeah, you know, it's funny
- 1:57like in print, I try to make sure, yes, it is Robert
- 2:00He Now I have to explain that for those who aren't familiar with who Bob
- 2:04Jones is. But he was an evangelist and racist. It's a big sort
- 2:12of a mega preacher in the early twentieth century, and he founded Bob Jones
- 2:17University. He received money from the Klan. I think he supported a racist
- 2:23governor. So Robert Jones seems like a pretty good move. But I'm glad
- 2:27you're here. I'm happy with that. Robbie, just not Bob. Can
- 2:31I call it. I'll just call you. I heard Robbie. But I'm
- 2:35not sure. I mean, you know, I'm just not sure. I
- 2:38want to, like, do I know you well enough? Whether you want
- 2:40people think you know me. I go by Robbie for everybody who knows me.
- 2:45Soon, all right, well, let me just start lay the groundwork.
- 2:47This is not an ambush. I just want to know, are you
- 2:51a religious person? I saw a theologian, but you know, are you
- 2:53a god believer? What's that look like? Etc. Yeah, no,
- 2:59I'm happy to talk about that. So I grew up in the church.
- 3:02I was that kid who was a church like five days a week, even
- 3:06as a teenager, you know, a member of the youth group. I
- 3:09went to a Southern Baptist college where I did study math and computer science,
- 3:14but nonetheless it was a religious institution. I went to a Southern Baptist seminary
- 3:17and was actually going to be a minister, and then did a PhD in
- 3:21religion. Decided that I'd rather study religion than pre triligion. But you know,
- 3:25to this day, yeah, no, I'm still a religious person.
- 3:28I would say I'm Christian. That's about the only descriptor I think I can.
- 3:31You know, I'm not really connected to a denomination. My wife's Jewish.
- 3:36We actually attended an interfaith congregation here in Washington, d C. It's
- 3:39interesting that, like you're not connected with a specific denomination. Do I sense
- 3:46you disenfranchised with the church like formal religion? You know, they really know
- 3:51they'd driven you out. I mean I grew up Southern Baptists, you know,
- 3:54and in that very conservative evangelical world in Mississippi. So was deep,
- 4:00deep in that world. And like I said, it even went to Southern
- 4:02Baptist Seminary, and I think that was the kind of the break, you
- 4:06know, from the denominational world of my youth, was really getting a sense
- 4:11of how entangled our denomination had been in white supremacy. I mean, the
- 4:16very beginning of the Southern Babtist Convention. In fact, what the word Southern
- 4:20means in Southern Babist Convention is essentially support for a slaveholding society. Right.
- 4:27The whole reason they were formed was to make enslaving other people based on the
- 4:30color of their skin compatible with the Gospel as they understood it. That's what
- 4:34the Southern means in Southern Baptists. So you know, that was sort of
- 4:39a shocker to really get the truth about that actually in seminary. Then the
- 4:43seminary and the whole denomination just became so embroiled with the Christian right political movement
- 4:47and continue to move to the right, continue to kind of double down on
- 4:51white supremacy and racism. It just wasn't something I could continue being a part
- 4:56of and I guess there hasn't been any other, you know, formal denominational
- 5:00entity that has really felt like the right place for me. So I'm happy
- 5:04to stay outside of the denominational world. But I am, you know,
- 5:08a member of a congregation here in DC that is the Interfaith Families Project.
- 5:13As you talk a lot about white supremacy, the focus of your book,
- 5:16there's a course we have to go back to. Probably the most prominent discussions
- 5:21we have about American white supremacy revolve around the Civil War, although we have
- 5:26to go back much further. But I'm reminded of that story by the reverend
- 5:30I want to say. His name is Vero or ver Ohots at the Church
- 5:33of Augustine. This is like eighteen sixty one. He's preaching out of collostions,
- 5:39servants, sobey in all things your masters, and he was using the
- 5:43Bible to defend the owning of slaves by white people. Of course, we
- 5:47jump up to Exodus. You know, we talk a lot about Exodus twenty
- 5:51one. Slaves are beaten by their masters according to God's command. We're seeing
- 5:57a lot throughout our history and even in contempt where we had lines people waving
- 6:00the Bible to excuse the oppression of non whites. You want to speak to
- 6:06that, well, it's you know, unfortunately, been such a part of
- 6:13European you know, Christianity all the way back. And I think it's one
- 6:16of the things I tried to do in the new book, The Hidden Roots
- 6:19of White Supremacy. And the reason why I called it the Hidden Roots of
- 6:23White Supremacy is I really wanted to trace that thread back, you know,
- 6:27at least to the kind of it's proximate cause in the Americas, and you
- 6:31know, it goes way before the Civil War. It is the version of
- 6:34Christianity that lands on these shores, you know, in the America's not just
- 6:39in America, but in the Americas, you know. So in the book,
- 6:44I trace it back to fourteen ninety three, and you could certainly go
- 6:46further back than that, but again trying to get the kind of closest proximate
- 6:50cause to the version of Christianity that landed here with this colonizing white supremacist you
- 6:58know, mindset really is connected to Columbus and the edicts that he was seeking
- 7:02from the Christian Church. These were not taught to me, you know,
- 7:06in seminary. I didn't learn it about it in any religious history classes really
- 7:11that I had, but I think it's so important for how it set the
- 7:15moral compass. These things were called the Doctrine of Discovery, and it was
- 7:17a set of fifteenth century documents that really spelled out in black and white that
- 7:23if European Christians discovered lands and peoples and those people were not Christian, then
- 7:30they had the right and the blessing of the Church to occupy the lands,
- 7:32to take their goods, and the documents even spell out and to submit them
- 7:38their persons to perpetual slavery. Right, this is from the hand of the
- 7:41poop in the fifteenth century. And again this is the attitude, the way
- 7:46that Christianity the dominant really attitude and orientation of European Christianity, that it landed
- 7:53here far before you know, the American project got off the ground. Well,
- 7:57if I can jump in quickly, I mean it sounds like the tribes
- 8:00of Israel in the Old Testament, like they go find those who are the
- 8:03other, the non tribes, and they claim that this is our land,
- 8:07and we are the chosen, and it's our party, and so you either
- 8:11submit or are slaughtered or you know, are oppressed in some way. And
- 8:16so my point is I see a lot of the weaponization of scripture to excuse
- 8:22Christian supremacy, if not white supremacy. I mean, that's not unfair,
- 8:26isn't No. I think that's been really the you know, the temptation has
- 8:31always been, you know, the words you see over and over throughout history,
- 8:35and this is you know, not just in religion, but you see
- 8:37it in American law as well. You know, this idea of the superiority
- 8:43of Christianity and the superiority of European civilization go right together, and you'll see
- 8:48that phrase Christianity and civilization as the legitimizing reason for enslaving people from Africa,
- 8:56for genocide among the indigenous people here, and force removal of indigenous people here.
- 9:03It was based on I mean, the language you'll see is just this
- 9:05overt thing. They'll you know, they'll even say like, based on the
- 9:09superior genius you know of the people of Europe and the Christian faith, that
- 9:13was the reason given for all kinds of domination and violence. But as an
- 9:20egalitarian Christian, you're a humanist Christian, how do you reconcile that with the
- 9:24scriptures. Do you feel like it's a context problem or something else. No,
- 9:28I mean, I think it's important for us to be honest that that
- 9:33these uh these passages are there right that that the Scripture is shot through,
- 9:37both the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament are shot through with you know,
- 9:41these texts that can be used you know, this way, and you've got
- 9:46it's interesting. Like one one artifact I came across, which I think tells
- 9:50part of the story, is that Christians have always wrestled, you know with
- 9:54this that there are liberating texts uh in in in in the Bible, and
- 9:58they are oppressive texts in the Bible. And like one of the starkest recognitions
- 10:03of this, you know, I've ever seen in kind of a physical artifact
- 10:05was a Bible that Fisk University has in its collections, and it was a
- 10:11Bible printed to be used with European slaveholders and in slavers with people in the
- 10:16West Indies. And it says this right up, you know, for use
- 10:20with the slave people in the West Indies by missionaries. And what they had
- 10:24done is they had gone through the text and they had they had left in
- 10:28all the parts like you read about beating slaves, slaves, obey your masters,
- 10:33like those kinds of messages they left in the text, but they actually
- 10:37cut out of the text all the other things that were like you know,
- 10:41in Christ there are no slave nor Greek. That's gone, no male,
- 10:45no female that's gone. The entire story of the liberation of the slaves in
- 10:50the Book of Exodus that's gone. So they literally excised. They kept all
- 10:54the kind of hierarchical, obedient pieces and left out the liberating piece. I
- 11:00think, you know, it's important to be honest that both of those things
- 11:01are there in the text. I'm reminded of that quote by Susan B.
- 11:05Anthony. She said, I distrust those people who know so well what God
- 11:09wants them to do, because I noticed it always coincides with their own desires.
- 11:15It's a setup. It sounds like a setup. We're going to go
- 11:18out and discover something that has actually already been discovered where there are indigenous people
- 11:22already, but we will say, okay, now that we've discovered it's what
- 11:26we must claim it in the name of God. I mean, it sounds
- 11:30like a setup. Am I reading that wrong? No? I mean,
- 11:33I think it was we think about, like, you know, the story
- 11:35of Christopher Columbus that's taught in American schools, and then the year is usually
- 11:41fourteen ninety two. That's the year he arrives. Now he doesn't know where
- 11:43he is. Of course at the time, he thinks he's in India,
- 11:46but he's not. He's you know, somewhere to the Bahamas. But nonetheless
- 11:52we learn about that. But what we don't learn about is, like,
- 11:54you know, what happens when he goes back that next year. That's why
- 11:56in the book I talk a lot about fourteen ninety three, because that's the
- 12:01year that he asks for this moral mandate, not just more supplies, more
- 12:03ships, but also more missionaries, more soldiers, and this moral mandate.
- 12:09And it's the Christian Church that gives it to him. And that really it's
- 12:13important to realize, I mean, that really is the power that unleashes the
- 12:18violence, is that this kind of moral mandate, right, It's no longer
- 12:22just a pure Machiavelian you know, military conquest. It's something then that is
- 12:26seen to be in line with the will of God, that has been declared
- 12:31to be aligned with European material interests. A friend of mine, another author
- 12:35who writes a lot about Christian nationalism, Catherine Stewart, refers often to the
- 12:41culture wars. That's a term we hear quite a bit. So I'm just
- 12:46going to toss that into your courts. Can you sort of speak to how
- 12:50you would define the culture wars? Yeah, you know, I think it's
- 12:54been shifting a bit. And you know, we used to talk about this,
- 12:56you know, ten twenty years ago as battles around sexuality. It was
- 13:01kind of abortion, same sex marriage. I mean, these were when people
- 13:05use culture wars, those are the next two words It usually came out of
- 13:07their mouths. I think we're seeing a much bigger kind of stage that these
- 13:11kind of debates are being and battles are being carried out on today, and
- 13:16in many ways they're going back to I think the deeper roots. And I
- 13:20think the question today when we talk about culture wars, to me, what
- 13:22it is this fight over in the US anyway? Who is really in American?
- 13:28Who is truly an American? Who gets to be an American? And
- 13:31these are things shot through with race and religion and back to this old,
- 13:35old declaration you know that the country was really intended to be a kind of
- 13:39promised land for European Christians, and that everyone else here is some kind of
- 13:43second or third tier status compared to European Christians. So I think a lot
- 13:48of the things we're seeing today, the fights over what history we're teaching to
- 13:52our kids, what books are in our kids libraries, immigration, these are
- 13:58all really battles and anyways to kind of hold on to this old view of
- 14:03the country, you know, is essentially a white Christian country versus one that's
- 14:07a religiously pluralistic and racially an ethnically pluralistic country. A longtime friend and friend
- 14:15of this show, constitutional attorney Andrew Seidel, has a great line. He
- 14:20says, the minute that America becomes a Christian nation, it will cease to
- 14:24be America. Agreed, disagree, Well, it certainly cease to be democratic.
- 14:31Anything that looks like a democratic country. I think it's worth saying that,
- 14:33Yeah, this vision of America as a Christian nation, which we're hearing
- 14:39more and more of, and we will hear undoubtedly in twenty twenty four,
- 14:43as the presidential campaigns get rebbed up, we will hear about this over and
- 14:46over again from certainly from the Trump campaign. You know, it's important to
- 14:52say that this, this vision of the country as a you know, European
- 14:56Christian country, is fundamentally into that goal to democracy. These two things can't
- 15:03exist together. They are really you know, one is fundamentally opposed to the
- 15:09other. And I think we've just got to be really clear about that.
- 15:11When we start making claims about this country being a Christian country, and by
- 15:15the way, when they say that they almost always inevitably need white Christian country,
- 15:20that's an anti democratic claim and it's a claim that undermines American democracy.
- 15:26Our new speaker at the House, Mike Johnson, he's a piece of work,
- 15:30is I recall? I think he's another fan of pseudo historian David Barton,
- 15:35a guy with no formal training in history, but who has been writing
- 15:39about everything from the Founding Fathers to the Constitution. Have you done any research,
- 15:43any digging into Barton, etc. The history revisionists at least, yeah,
- 15:48you know, even to put the word historian in the same sentence with
- 15:52him, even with the word pseudo in front of it, you know,
- 15:54feel generous. I'm gonna say, I mean it is. You know,
- 16:00this is someone who's had even a Christian publisher have to pull some of his
- 16:03books because he fabricated quotes from the founding fathers to kind of build his case
- 16:08to someone with no credentials through no real historian takes seriously. And yet here
- 16:14we are, we've got the person who is second in line to the presidency
- 16:18now, Mike Johnson, the new Speaker of the House, who you know,
- 16:22has talked about how influential David Barton has been on his life and in
- 16:25his thinking. Barton and has ilk denied the separation of church and state exists.
- 16:30That isn't anywhere you know that we can find as a legitimate idea and
- 16:34just do assert that the founders had in mind this idea that the country should
- 16:38be a Christian country and try to lay claim to that today. And that's
- 16:41you know, the new Speaker of the House is really, you know,
- 16:45supporting those ideas that should be deeply troubling to everyone in the country again,
- 16:48anyone who cares about the country as being a democracy. More to come with
- 16:56doctor Robert P. Jones, author of the book The Hidden Roots of White
- 17:00Supremacy. We continue next talking here with author doctor Robert P. Jones.
- 17:17By the way, do you use the P when you're introed, like Robert
- 17:19P. Jones, Robert Jones, what do you like use the P that
- 17:22my name is so common? I usually do use the P in induty Robert
- 17:27P. Jones. The book The Hidden Roots of White Supremacy in the Path
- 17:32Too was shared American Future. In the book, you reference a twenty sixteen
- 17:36opinion survey, and I think this is fascinating. The question was do you
- 17:41think the American culture and way of life has changed for the better or for
- 17:45worse since the nineteen fifties. I guess this sort of relates to the old,
- 17:51the good old days, you know, simpler times, back when people
- 17:56had a work ethic, they worked hard, and children said yes, sir
- 17:59and no, and respected their elders, and there wasn't any of that filth
- 18:03on the radio and television, you know, sort of this wholesome Norman Rockwell
- 18:07painting of our past. In the survey, who answered with what America better
- 18:14or worse? What did your findings say? Yeah? You know, well
- 18:18we wrote that question precisely to try to get at, you know, this
- 18:21sensibility you often hear people talk about, yeah, you know, we didn't
- 18:23lock our doors and you know, all those things that you just mentioned,
- 18:26this kind of nostalgist, rose colored view of the past, and for many
- 18:32white Americans, you know, that nineteen fifties era is it. So we
- 18:36actually put that in the question to kind of see how that might divide the
- 18:38country. So it turns out the country is fairly evenly divided on that question,
- 18:42but it is divided along lines of race and religion and party, so
- 18:48you know, the two parties looked like mirror images of each other on that
- 18:52question. Overwhelming majorities of Democrats say that things have changed for the better since
- 18:56the nineteen fifties. Overwhelming majorities of Republicans say the opposite, that things have
- 19:00changed for the worst. When you look at religious groups, it's notable that
- 19:04it's white Christian groups that stand out as saying that things have changed for the
- 19:08worst since the nineteen fifties, and no group more than white Evangelical Protestants.
- 19:12Who are you know, somewhere Depending on the survey of seven to ten,
- 19:15three quarters likely to say that things have changed for the worst since the nineteen
- 19:21fifties. I think that tells you, you know, quite a lot.
- 19:23Their numbers were up mid twentieth century it was kind of the kind of height
- 19:27of the you know, of churches being full after the war, church is
- 19:32being built everywhere, And of course it was pre the Civil rights era,
- 19:37you know, and this was still segregation. And I think that's that's notable.
- 19:41That's what many white Christians are looking back to and saying, yeah.
- 19:45And I think a lot of this is because of the dwindling numbers of white
- 19:48Christians. To make sure I say that this kind of aging and graying phenomenon
- 19:52of white Christians in the country. Twenty years ago, white Christians were a
- 19:56majority of the country. Today they're only forty two percent of the country.
- 20:00And if we would look at white evangelicals again, twenty years ago, they
- 20:03were about a quarter of the country. Today they're about half that, thirteen
- 20:07point six percent of the country, and their median age is now fifty six.
- 20:11So they're aging and graying, and I think that is also setting off
- 20:15these fits of nostalgia, these kind of acts of desperation to try to hold
- 20:19on to their place, you know, at the top of the pyramid that
- 20:23they feel like they deserve. In fact, many of them feel like it's
- 20:26divinely ordained that that's where they'll be, but see the country shifting all around
- 20:32them. I'm struck by how we often romanticize the past anyway, you know,
- 20:37we sort of soft focused. I think there have been studies about how
- 20:41we often will view the merits of the past, the good things, and
- 20:45we sort of brushed aside all of the other. You refer in the book
- 20:49to a democratic society built on a foundation of mass racial violence. Europeans arrive,
- 20:56we kick the hell out of the Native Americans. Before we talk about
- 21:00that, let's deal with this idea that democratic society grown out of toxic roots.
- 21:06So what would you say if someone accused you of being an enemy of
- 21:10American democracy? Right, doctor Jones hates American democracy? What would you say?
- 21:15Yeah, so they don't understand patriotism. You know, I think if
- 21:18we really love our country and love the place we live, we're going to
- 21:23want to be honest about it, and we're going to want to build a
- 21:26future that's not based on a lie. So I think that's really what's motivating
- 21:30a lot of my writing is to try to tell the truth about and to
- 21:34get a better understanding of how we got here, and particularly for people who
- 21:37look like me, you who come from kind of white Christian background. We've
- 21:42never told the truth. We've always told these kind of impossible miss of innocence
- 21:47where we're always the heroes, we're always generous, you know, We've never
- 21:51told the truth about Indigenous people, about enslavement, always tried to kind of
- 21:55candy coat and all of that. And I think it's really important if we're
- 21:57going to live into again, multi ethnic, multi religious democracy, we can't
- 22:03do that with this foundation built on a lie, particularly about ourselves. We're
- 22:07gonna have to tell the truth and use that as the basis for coming into
- 22:11a more honest relationship with our fellow Americans. The Boders are not going to
- 22:15be happy with you. There are people who were there who are trying to
- 22:18get rid of the books that inconvenience them, right, that aren't I mean,
- 22:22because they say, well, if you acknowledge the atrocities of our past,
- 22:27the mistakes of this country and our history books, well we need to
- 22:30either use wide out and I just gave away my age, or you ban
- 22:36the book. This is another example of bardon Esque revisionist history. You've been
- 22:41watching the book bans what's your take? Yeah? You know again, I
- 22:44think when you ask why now, right, why in twenty twenty three,
- 22:48twenty twenty two, Why are we seeing this now? And I think it
- 22:52is this combination of a racial reckoning that we've been having in this country.
- 22:56You know, with the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement, it has
- 23:00been asking difficult questions at the country, and we've been reckoning with this history.
- 23:04Statues are coming down stood for a century after this, you know,
- 23:08that were put up actually in the early nineteen early twentieth century, but to
- 23:12valorize the Confederacy and white supremacy. Those statues are finally coming down, and
- 23:17we're reevaluating our history, and we're doing at a time again when white Christians
- 23:22are no longer the majority in the country, so longer really have just outright
- 23:26sheer numbers to prevent this kind of reckoning from happening in the country. So
- 23:30where they do have the numbers, sometimes at the local level, and I
- 23:33think that's where we're seeing this real attempt to like literally whitewash history, to
- 23:40kind of hold on to these myths and to prevent you know, their kids
- 23:44from asking challenging questions. Mistakes us back to Charlottesville. Chris the twenty seventeen
- 23:49white supremacist rally, and they're screaming that you as will not replace us.
- 23:55People are talking about the removal of the Roberty Lee statue. I think they
- 23:57melted it down for this year. Yeah, yeah, I don't know if
- 24:03they decided what they're going to do with it yet. I haven't seen that
- 24:06they didn't, you know that what I believe what they said. They've melted
- 24:08it down into these ingots, so they held onto it. They didn't just
- 24:12outright destroy it, but they melted it down. And there's a process going
- 24:17on. They're working with the city, and there's a process going on.
- 24:22An African American history museum and the city or go through a process of what
- 24:26to make out of this new out of the same material, but make something
- 24:30new that's more inclusive, and that speaks to all of the local residents here.
- 24:34But you know, like the Marjorie Taylor Greens, et cetera, who
- 24:37were like, they're trying to erase our heritage or you know, our part
- 24:41of our history. And somebody said once that you know, Germany outlawed all
- 24:47Nazi symbols on display, which is why no one remembers who Hitler was right
- 24:52I never understood that we have to remember our heritage, if nothing else.
- 24:56Put it in a museum that teaches America history in context of white supremacy.
- 25:02But why do we have to celebrate the oppressors of other people? Don't let
- 25:06me trespass, doctor Jones. But you mentioned that your wife is Jewish.
- 25:10I want to talk about Hamas, Palestine, Israel. Zionists, especially in
- 25:15the Christian context, believe that Israel is a kind of Jewish holy mountaintop.
- 25:21Right, this is a sovereign Jewish states. It is fulfilled prophecy, but
- 25:26also a precursor to the end times. Here in the States, I'm seeing
- 25:30a split. I see some Christians who are absolutely without caveat pro Israel.
- 25:37I will have no discussion Israel, Israel, Israel. But I'm also seeing
- 25:42a divide with other Christians who are I mean anti Jewish hate has exploded in
- 25:49the United States. I know these are conversations you've had. You want to
- 25:53speak to this rise of anti Jewish sentiment in this country. Well, there's
- 25:59no out about it. I mean, you mentioned Charlottesville, right, it's
- 26:03twenty seventeen that we heard. I mean, I remember hearing that for the
- 26:06first time, I remember thinking like, wait, what did did I hear
- 26:10that? Right? What did they just say? And they were literally chanting
- 26:12Jews will not replace us in Charlottesville as they're marching around the statue of Robert
- 26:18E. Lee, and I just remember that being a real marker for me
- 26:22and for many people. I've interviewed a lot of people since then, and
- 26:26they will often mention Charlottesville as a kind of wake up moment for them.
- 26:30We're realizing, Okay, I can't just kind of pretend it's the same,
- 26:33same old, Something different is arising here, and so yeah, there's no
- 26:36doubt. I mean, you've seen from government reports, ADL other places all
- 26:41reporting hate crimes are up against Jews in the country, vandalism of synagogues.
- 26:47I mean, all of that is arising, and it's really connected. It's
- 26:51funny, there's kind of the two things going on here at the same time.
- 26:53One of them is the kind of open white supremacy that I think it's
- 26:57fair to say that President Trump really helped unleash. It's not that he created
- 27:02it, it was certainly there, but unleashed into the public by I think
- 27:06wink nod nods saying things like, well, there were fine people on both
- 27:08sides after Charlottesville. Not being willing to clearly denounce white supremacy. That I
- 27:15think gave open space for it to kind of come out into the open,
- 27:18for people to be more bold. If I may jump in, doctor Jones,
- 27:22I know Trump used the word vermin. I think it's Hitler who had
- 27:26called the Jews rodents or vermin and mind com face talking about the contamination,
- 27:32the poisoning of the national blood or bloodline, very Nazi esque language. No.
- 27:37I wrote a piece on my subsec newsletter last week about this, and
- 27:41again I think this is another time when we have to kind of pause and
- 27:45realize, Okay, this is just this is not the same old, same
- 27:48old, even from Trump or even as many outlandish things as he said on
- 27:53an almost a weekly basis. This is something different. And I actually went
- 27:57in that piece and I looked at mine comp and you're exactly right. I
- 28:00mean this echoes his language. He talked about poisoning the blood of this metaphorical
- 28:07as if the blood the country has blood that needs to remain pure, and
- 28:11that immigrants are poisoning the blood of the country. He called leftists Marxist communists,
- 28:17Vermin, which is a mindcomp uses that or rats in a number of
- 28:21ways to talk about Jews in Europe at the time, and it echoes the
- 28:25language of mind comp in very disturbing ways and not just kind of vague ways,
- 28:29and in very close ways. And that piece I actually go in and
- 28:33show you the tight connections there. It's I mean, I just titled,
- 28:37you know, with Vermin Trump, you know, ventures fully into Nazi territory.
- 28:41Talking here with author and extremely smart person, doctor Robert P. Jones,
- 28:48as I continue to monopolize your time, I want to talk about something,
- 28:52and you spend a lot of time in the book speaking to the murder
- 28:55of Emmett Till. Now. I'm not asking you to read the book for
- 28:59everybody, but can you kind of frame that for me? Talk to me
- 29:03about Emmett till So. Emmett Till, you know, was a fourteen year
- 29:07old boy from Chicago visited the Mississippi Delta so as my home state, and
- 29:11this was nineteen fifty five, and he was murdered for allegedly whistling at a
- 29:17white woman and a store, a kind of local general store, by two
- 29:21white men who later confessed to the crime. They were acquitted before they confess.
- 29:25The jury met for all of sixty seven minutes, acquitted them, and
- 29:29then they later confessed to the crime. And you know, no justice was
- 29:33ever done there. And it's a story that well, it sparked, really
- 29:37in many ways, the modern civil rights movement. Rosa Parks said she had
- 29:41Emmett Till on her mind when she was doing the kind of bus boycott work
- 29:45in Montgomery. Martin Luther King referenced him in speeches, and as a matter
- 29:49of fact, the early the first version of the I have a dream speech
- 29:52mentions Till Emmett Till in that speech. And yet, you know, when
- 29:56I grew up in Mississippi, it wasn't a story I really knew and wasn't
- 30:00taught. So even though people all over the world knew the story, there
- 30:03really wasn't anything going on in Mississippi. So in the book, I tell
- 30:07the story of this group of people, kind of a group of black and
- 30:10white citizens that came together in the Mississippi Delta to try to make sure his
- 30:15story was told at the local level in the Mississippi Delta. As again a
- 30:18way of kind of reckoning with this past, telling the truth, apologizing to
- 30:23the Till family that justice wasn't done and trying to tell the truth to a
- 30:26new generation. This is a near parallel to an experience that I had.
- 30:32I'm born and raised in Tulsa, Oklahoma. I was thirty nine before I
- 30:38ever heard of the Tulsa race massacre. Was never taught in a history class,
- 30:44the media never referenced. It was like revision by omission. Let's talk
- 30:49about Greenwood and the Tulsa race massacre. Right, Well, like you said,
- 30:55it's there, you could tell the story. And virtually every well really
- 31:00every state, these stories of white racial violence against either indigenous people or African
- 31:06Americans are both that then gets erased and written out of history. So you
- 31:11know in Tulsa, Yeah, there was this thriving kind of middle class area
- 31:15that was dubbed Black Wall Street, and a whole part of town that was
- 31:18essentially burned to the ground and upwards of three hundred African Americans lost their lives
- 31:23over a period of a couple of days when there was just widespread writing it
- 31:27was essentially black Tulsan's killed by their white neighbors over a couple of days.
- 31:33It was built on a lie, right, the story was there was a
- 31:34young black man in an elevator who had a costed a white woman and there
- 31:40was no proof for any of that, and that story catches fire, and
- 31:44before you know what, he's arrested. People are circling the jail wanting to
- 31:48lynch the guy. I mean, it's just insane. And so it was
- 31:52like they were looking for an excuse to go and he's later released. So
- 31:56it was essentially incited by the newspapers and local leaders and exactly it was kind
- 32:01of a you know, it was a tinder box and it's worth doing.
- 32:04It was after soldiers were returning from World War One, many black soldiers who
- 32:09had served in the war, and this was the truth in the twenties across
- 32:13the country. That wasn't just Tulsa, Chicago, Washington, many many other
- 32:17towns erupted in these really white racial violence attacking African Americans who really came back
- 32:22from serving their country. And that was part of the mail you and also
- 32:27expecting jobs and whites were expecting to kind of recreate Jim Crow. Even after
- 32:32this experience of African Americans risking their lives and giving their lives for the country,
- 32:37and it created these conflicts. Many when many African Americans were refusing to
- 32:44go back to this kind of white supremacist status quo. And I think that
- 32:49was kind of the tinder box and Tulsa as well. But yeah, the
- 32:51white citizens took full advantage of it. I'm struck by Tulsa because you know,
- 32:54it's one thing to have kind of people lose their minds and it kind
- 32:59of be one burst of mindless violence. But over Tulsa, it took place
- 33:04over a couple of days, which means that like people were on the streets,
- 33:07killing people, maiming people, burning down things, went home to their
- 33:12families, got dinner, put their kids to bed, went to sleep,
- 33:16and got up the next morning and did it again, right, And I
- 33:20think that's something quite different, that it was a very willful, deliberate effort
- 33:25to really eradicate the African American presence in Tulsa. If anybody ever passes through,
- 33:31there's a really compelling museums called Greenwood Rising that tells the story of the
- 33:37Tulsa race massacre. When I continue with doctor Robert Jones, I'm going to
- 33:44talk about this sort of redrawing of the district lines to lock out specific voters
- 33:51often voters of color. Jerry mandering is next. Hang on. Thank you
- 34:04so much for listening to the broadcast. Today. I'm talking with doctor Robert
- 34:08Jones, who has a PhD and religion a Master of Divinity from Southwestern Baptist
- 34:15Theological Seminary. He is a mathematician and he's author of a book which is
- 34:20called The Hidden Roots of White Supremacy in the Path to a Shared American Future.
- 34:25So we talk about how history is often written by the ruling class.
- 34:30You're a numbers guy, you're a math guy. I'll call you a math
- 34:34geek, doctor Jones. So you're watching the jerrymandering. You're watching how people
- 34:38are redistricting to try to lock out people of color, first of all,
- 34:42to find jerry mandering for those who may not know. And then what your
- 34:45perception is on that. Yeah, if you look at it on a map,
- 34:47you can see a jerrymandered district because it looks like, you know,
- 34:52it was drawn by somebody with a blindfold. It doesn't look like you know.
- 34:55You think of a district in your mind as something coherent, cohesive that
- 35:00you could maybe draw a circle around, or at least a square around.
- 35:02And these are like these weird elongated, kind of geographically nonsensical things. They're
- 35:07basically designed to dilute the power of minority votes and to kind of load all
- 35:14the minority votes into one district so only get one representative instead of maybe controlling
- 35:17two. That's basically what jerrymandering is, as an attempt to kind of dilute
- 35:22the vote, particularly voters of color. And I think we're going to see
- 35:24more and more of this, and again, I think the reason is because
- 35:29of the shifting demographics in the country. Again, you know, white Christians
- 35:31who used to just have super majorities everywhere pretty much now are forty two percent
- 35:37of the country and can't rely on sheer numbers to control the political outcomes anymore.
- 35:43And so we're going to see more things like voter suppression, just outright
- 35:46trying to prohibit voters of color from voting. I mean, part if you
- 35:51really pay attention to you know the way the kind of big line was constructed,
- 35:54or you know that Trump was this kind of false assertions that the twenty
- 35:59twenty election was olin from him, was all built around minority districts. Almost
- 36:02all the districts he was challenging, we're black and brown voters and asserting that
- 36:07they were illegitimate voters in those places. So it's all kind of around.
- 36:10Really, white supremacy is the most straightforward way, and preserving white supremacy white
- 36:16supremacist results when there aren't enough white voters to actually do it by democratic means.
- 36:22Before we put a punctuation mark on this and sort of hit the book,
- 36:27here's a hot button, I'll just toss it up. Some might accuse
- 36:31us of participating in what they would call white guilt. This is a common
- 36:36MAGA complaint. I hear it. You know, I didn't oppress the Native
- 36:38Americans. I never owned slaves. I rebuke bigotry. I don't think you
- 36:45know. I'm not. I didn't do the things that my ancestors did,
- 36:49And to a degree, I get that. I understand. Yeah, you
- 36:51know, I'm not going to apologize for the accident of my birth anymore that
- 36:55I would condemn anybody else for who they are. I see us all this
- 36:59the human condition. But as part of the white privileged demographic, do you
- 37:04and I bear some kind of responsibility for the sins of the fathers? What
- 37:08do you think? Well, the Bible would say so. The first thing
- 37:13I would say, most often those objections come from you know, white Christian
- 37:16people. But I think this idea of systemic oppression, how it goes down
- 37:22from generation and generation, even seven generations down right, is clearly in the
- 37:27text. But you know it's also common sense. And I can just give
- 37:30you, I'll give you straight examples from my family. And my family's not
- 37:34wealthy. Both of my parents were the first ones to go to college,
- 37:37my dad after fifteen years of night school. And they're you know, my
- 37:40entire extended family. So we don't come from a lot of money. But
- 37:44yet if I kind of go back, so how did my dad go to
- 37:47school? He went on the GI Bill, which was not available to many
- 37:52veterans of color, explicitly excluded from them. They got FAHA loans to buy
- 37:58a house early on, and again through practices of redlining, where the federal
- 38:02government explicitly supported not giving loans to non white people and what were deemed to
- 38:07be white neighborhoods. This is something my family benefited from. If we go
- 38:13all the way back to the first property my family owned in Georgia back in
- 38:15the eighteen early eighteen hundreds, we got free land two hundred acres of free
- 38:22land. My most direct ancestor back in eighteen fifteen gets free land from the
- 38:28State of Georgia, who's handing out two hundred acre plots to people of European
- 38:31descent who are willing to come in homestead. So where does that land come
- 38:35from? Come from the Cherokee, right, It was after the State of
- 38:37Georgia forcibly removed Cherokee Indians from the State of Georgia and forced them to Oklahoma
- 38:43on the Trail of Tears, and then they just handed it out for free
- 38:45to white people. So in all these kind of I can name a ton
- 38:49of other things, but in all of these ways, the society got built
- 38:52for the benefit of whites. Better schools, access to libraries, access to
- 38:58public amenities like parks and pools, all these things in our Jim Crow were
- 39:01kind of segregated. The best we're kind of allocated for white people. I
- 39:06think it's just no way we can be honest about our own you know,
- 39:09just the plain history in front of us, much less the history we dig
- 39:13for, but just the plain history in front of us to say we haven't
- 39:15benefited. And if that's been the case, then what's our responsibility? So
- 39:20I think even if you can't say, well, you know it wasn't me,
- 39:22nonetheless, those benefits flow up through us. And then the question is
- 39:27it's really about responsibility and justice? I think are the questions that we have
- 39:31to face honestly, and you know, how do we make amends? How
- 39:35do we repair the damage? I mean, that's the kind of plainest way
- 39:37to speak about it. For these blatantly racist and unfair policies. I think
- 39:43too, some of it speaks to our desire to have collective ast values.
- 39:46Right, what helps others helps us all as part of the human condition.
- 39:50How do we, even though we weren't personally responsible, how do we work
- 39:53to try to undo or heal some of the injustices of the past. I
- 40:00think that's white guilt. I think it's acknowledging the privileges that we have had
- 40:04and trying to do the right thing. Forgive my daytime television question. To
- 40:09finish us off here, But in the book, What's Surprised You? You
- 40:14are? You're going You're doing a deep dive into American history, the white
- 40:21supremacist attitudes that have brought us to the modern day. I know your research
- 40:25had some high Eureeka moments. Give me one or two, I'll give you
- 40:30one. I start the book off with, there's a story. I think
- 40:34the stories in many cases were what stuck with me. So it's a compelling
- 40:37story. I begin the book with by a guy named Robert Hickman, who's
- 40:40an enslaved man in Missouri, and he gets wind of the Emancipation Proclamation.
- 40:45He's literate and he can read, so he's probably read a newspaper account about
- 40:50it. And even though it doesn't apply to Missouri because it was not a
- 40:54state technically in rebellion during the Civil War, and that's the only states that
- 40:59the emancipation population applied to, he says, well, nonetheless, we're going
- 41:02to make a break for it, and he and his family set off on
- 41:06a raft to get picked up by a Union steamboat and towed up to Minnesota,
- 41:10and so he finds freedom. But what he finds there, too,
- 41:14is another story. His story kind of intersects with this other story of the
- 41:17Dakota people, indigenous people in Minnesota who are being forcibly removed from their land.
- 41:22So like at the same time he and his group of friends and family
- 41:27are finding liberty in Missouri, they are literally stepping off the boat and the
- 41:31next load that the boat is taking on. Are these the remnants really of
- 41:37about sixteen hundred or start off as sixteen hundred, but half of them die
- 41:43Dakota people who are being herded on like cattle and forcibly shipped out of the
- 41:46state as a kind of part of Indian removal policies in Minnesota. And so
- 41:52like, when you see these two things coming together, I think in kind
- 41:55of highlighting the contradictions that we have in the country. Those things have kind
- 42:00of stayed with me. I'm a big fan. I loved the book.
- 42:05It was a little overwhelming. I found myself like, there's so much here
- 42:08that I did not realize. I mean, I thought i'd know. I
- 42:12thought I knew something. After the last fifteen years, I sort of emerged
- 42:15from a cocoon, and I, you know, I started to sponge things
- 42:19up. But you've covered some things that I had no idea, and I
- 42:22appreciate that. I appreciate the fact that you are working to try to on
- 42:27a no level of playing field, and part of that I think stems into
- 42:30understanding our past. Doctor Robert P. Jones, I will link to you
- 42:36and the book in the description box of the show. You've been very generous
- 42:39with your time. Thanks so much. Oh, thanks so much, and
- 42:43it's great to see you in Tulsa. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and
- 42:46Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t
- 42:52shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and
- 42:57details on upcoming free thought events and inventions. Log onto our website, The
- 43:01Thinkingatheist dot com.