Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E007: Cathedral Building in Bitcoin with Alex Leishman
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about the stock, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of darkness.
- 0:131974198792972 thousand, whatever we want to call this, it's all
- 0:19just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we.
- 0:24Sell, hey, I say when we sell. You heard it from Logan.
- 0:31We are rolling. Welcome back to the last trade,
- 0:33Episode 7. Happy 4th of July week,
- 0:36gentlemen. Happy 4th of July week.
- 0:42So we're we well having it on the weekend and then if it's on
- 0:45Tuesday, it's like nobody. There was no like a shelling
- 0:47point on when it was celebrated. I don't know if it's a good
- 0:50thing or a bad thing, how having 4th of July on a Tuesday sort of
- 0:55extends the weekend to a six day weekend.
- 0:59Kind of nice. I threw.
- 1:01I threw a party it. Was fun.
- 1:03I'm tired. Marty's referring to, if you
- 1:05like, the sauce that he's been drinking for six days straight,
- 1:08and so he's trying to figure out if that's an actual problem or
- 1:12or not. Yes, as you can tell I'm I've
- 1:16recorded from down here last week, so I've been down the
- 1:17shore. I got down last Wednesday night,
- 1:21so last week when I recorded was the first day I've been here.
- 1:26And we're in a multi generation home right now.
- 1:29My wife's parents, her sister, my brother-in-law, their kids,
- 1:33and we have all of our kids in one room and since everybody's
- 1:37on vacation at the same time, they just haven't slept in like
- 1:407 days. So that's what I was
- 1:41referencing, Not the sauce. OK, Michael?
- 1:45Hey, I'll throw myself under the bus.
- 1:47It's Episode 7 and the lighting still hasn't been figured out.
- 1:50The the microphone needs to be done, so we gotta get it.
- 1:53Got some work to do on my end. Yeah.
- 1:56But if your freaks weren't aware, we are joined by Alex
- 2:00Leishman. Hey, hey, great to.
- 2:03Be here Andrew River, my favorite Bitcoin exchange out
- 2:06there. It's great to have you here
- 2:09particularly on this week because we've talked about this
- 2:11on TFTC multiple times in the past and I think since it's 4th
- 2:16of July week here in the United States tying Bitcoin what it
- 2:20represents to. The founding fathers of this
- 2:25country and what they fought for, How in line is the Bitcoin
- 2:30protocol with the ideals that the founding fathers tried to
- 2:34set forth in this country? Yeah, you know, we've we've
- 2:39chatted before. And you know, I think what
- 2:41attracted to me, what attracted me to Bitcoin, was how deeply
- 2:44American it is, the the fact that it's money that nobody can
- 2:49tell you what to do with. You can do whatever you want.
- 2:52It's fully self sovereign. And I think that was that that
- 2:56core is what deeply attracted me to to work on this years ago.
- 3:00And and I consider myself and my family are very American at our
- 3:04core. And yeah, it's just like 2
- 3:08pieces of pod in my opinion. Bodies.
- 3:12Everything. Free speech.
- 3:14Property rights. Freedom of association, sound
- 3:17money. Too many people forget.
- 3:19That's like the crazy thing about the time we live in again.
- 3:22Fish swimming in water is the most famous analogy that people
- 3:25use when explaining this. And even though we we discussed
- 3:29it last week. Like, when you're pitching
- 3:31Bitcoin, you probably shouldn't have asked somebody like, what
- 3:33is money? You don't even know what money
- 3:35is. But you do live in this day and
- 3:37age where people really don't understand what money is, nor
- 3:41realize that the founding fathers, like, had a language
- 3:47about sound money. In the documents that they they
- 3:50created and signed. Yeah, absolutely.
- 3:53And you know, the last, you know, since the since the 70s,
- 3:56you know, the American economy has done pretty well.
- 4:00And I think it's distracted people that from the fact that,
- 4:03you know this, this sort of encroaching monstrosity was that
- 4:08has taken more and more control and Bitcoin showed up almost.
- 4:13I mean it's it's almost. Almost too, too coincidental,
- 4:23you know, that showed up at the time it did.
- 4:26There's something about that that I it almost seems like a
- 4:29prophecy was fulfilled. There's something sort of like
- 4:32it feels deeper, deeper to it. But I think it showed up at the
- 4:37perfect time. And I I don't know, it might it
- 4:38might be what saves our Republic.
- 4:44Yeah, we talked, discussed this last week too, but I I do think.
- 4:49Again, people have been thrust into the framework.
- 4:51It is worth reiterating. I don't think you can reiterate
- 4:54this too much, but people have been thrust into the
- 4:57argumentation argument framework of red versus blue, left versus
- 5:02right, and both sides are feeling the pain and they are
- 5:07led to believe that it's the other side causing that pain and
- 5:10leading to the troubles that they they experience in their
- 5:14daytoday lives while never addressing.
- 5:17What is actually causing the pain, which is the fact that we
- 5:19messed up the money, and that has led to a ripple effect of
- 5:23compounding bad decisions. That has got us to a point where
- 5:26the quality of life, despite all the technological advances that
- 5:30we've made over the last many decades, is depreciating in many
- 5:37ways. If you look at obesity, the
- 5:40overall stable health life expectancy in the US is
- 5:43crashing. Drug overdoses, That's the
- 5:47despair. There's no matter what the
- 5:50government wants to what picture they want to paint with the
- 5:54economic data that they put out and make it look rosy.
- 5:57There, I think there's a deep, unspoken understanding that
- 6:01something has gone terribly awry.
- 6:03It's not red side or blue side. It's it's the money.
- 6:08Yeah, there's a beauty in the there's a beauty in independence
- 6:11and sovereignty, sovereignty that I think Bitcoin embodies
- 6:13that people come to America for independence and we found
- 6:16Bitcoin through the sovereignty of, you know, it's the from the
- 6:20native text and like the come and take it, you know, you have
- 6:24this, this asset that cannot be seized, cannot be censored.
- 6:28And at the same time gives you the independence to live your
- 6:30life because that's the universal truth, right?
- 6:32Everybody just wants to be left alone and just do the things
- 6:35that they want to do. And the reality is, if the money
- 6:37is corrupted you, you have that infringed on.
- 6:40And to Alex's point, there's something very interesting
- 6:42about, you know, when free will is taken, how something ends up
- 6:46stepping in, in general over the course of generations.
- 6:49And you have this 08 crisis that was like had been built for
- 6:52probably over 100 years feeding into that and that 08.
- 6:56Bitcoin comes out of it and we've seen the past thirteen
- 6:58years just this kind of like growth in the market and
- 7:02mindshare and so we're very amazing time.
- 7:05I think everybody here, while the world's a little bleak,
- 7:07everybody here and and folks that listen to the pod are
- 7:11extremely excited about the world where Bitcoin is part of
- 7:14it and helps you know. Humanity flourish moving
- 7:16forward. Jessie.
- 7:21You're on mute, Sir. It snuck on.
- 7:26Again, I was reflecting on the 4th about about how it's kind of
- 7:33surprising to me that that there isn't more explicit language
- 7:37about sound money. I guess there's allusions to it,
- 7:43but you know, it's not in, it's not in the Bill of Rights, for
- 7:45example, in our, in our founding documents.
- 7:48And I think it would have been if Fiat money had been a part of
- 7:52the world back then, but it wasn't like the the, the
- 7:55specter. That they were concerned about
- 7:57that Jefferson and Adams were concerned about was nationalized
- 8:02banking and you know we were on a gold standard.
- 8:06It wasn't conceivable really that we would be using monopoly
- 8:09money as currency and and allowing you know the issuance
- 8:14to be controlled by the state. And it's kind of a shame that
- 8:18that it there wasn't an opportunity to put that in the
- 8:22founding documents at the time. But here comes the free market,
- 8:27so many years later, creating that solution and imposing
- 8:31through, you know, capitalistic incentives, free market
- 8:36realities that here's, here's a better currency to store your
- 8:40value and propagate it through time.
- 8:43And you can choose to adopt it or not.
- 8:46And that's the individual choice that everybody is facing.
- 8:49And you know that through that sly roundabout way.
- 8:54Reimposes the the the mandate of having fiscal responsibility and
- 9:01and not being able to print money eventually, like that's
- 9:04where we're headed. And you know I was thinking
- 9:07about how how do we get out of the the quagmire that we've
- 9:12normalized in the US where, you know, we haven't balanced the
- 9:15budget in 22 years. We're on course for a $2.2
- 9:19trillion deficit. You know, and that's excluding
- 9:22interest expense. It's creeping in here on $32
- 9:27trillion of national debt at at now like 5% interest.
- 9:34And you know, there's no political will to restore fiscal
- 9:40responsibility and balance budgets into the future.
- 9:43And so long as you can print debt, print dollars or issue
- 9:49debt. And and control the printer that
- 9:53you know makes it possible to to satisfy those obligations in
- 9:59time. So long as you have that
- 10:01ability, you you can't. You won't.
- 10:04There's no political will to ever restore fiscal
- 10:06responsibility and balance the budget.
- 10:08But when there's sound money, when there's money you can't
- 10:11print, you are forced eventually.
- 10:14To balance a budget because you can't print any more of it in
- 10:17order to to spend beyond your means.
- 10:19And so I think, to Alex's point, that Bitcoin might be coming
- 10:23along at just the right time to save the Republic, because it
- 10:28will eventually impose fiscal responsibility in an era where
- 10:32we've forgotten the importance of it.
- 10:38Yeah, that's another interesting point too.
- 10:41Again, like fish and water if people forget.
- 10:44Often forget. I think in recent years people
- 10:47began to remember that this is a Republic of autonomous states in
- 10:51a union that can make their own decisions.
- 10:54And as it pertains to Bitcoin, I think that's one of the most
- 10:58exciting trends and themes that have begun to pick up over the
- 11:01last three years. Specifically, is states
- 11:04asserting their autonomy and coming out and defending Bitcoin
- 11:09or just signaling like, hey, we're open for business?
- 11:12Anybody wants to work with Bitcoin and obviously they did
- 11:17it with COVID lockdowns in mandates and some other things
- 11:22as well. And that's something that's
- 11:26really important to highlight as well.
- 11:28States beginning to remember that we live in a Republic and
- 11:31really reminding people that hey, we can make our own
- 11:35decisions. Federal government you you've
- 11:38got a bit crazy. We're going to protect our
- 11:39citizens. Within our borders, with laws
- 11:42that that we deem to be reliable and sensible, and Bitcoin as a
- 11:49tool for these autonomous states, fighting back against
- 11:53what we believe is a bloated and increasingly Orwellian federal
- 11:58government like Bitcoin gives them a superpower.
- 12:00It's an incredible tool to have in your belt as an autonomous
- 12:04state looking to sort of tell the federal government they back
- 12:09off a little bit. Yeah.
- 12:13You've talked about the Permanent Fund and that what you
- 12:16just said made me think, is it we talk a lot about a nation
- 12:18state adoption. Do we see states start holding
- 12:22back one on their balance sheet ahead of nation states from that
- 12:26perspective on when it comes to federal taxes and being able to
- 12:29subsidize what's needed? Because that's always a thought,
- 12:31right? Is that there's a check and
- 12:32balance because. Individual states need the
- 12:34government subsidies, but a world where they have and they
- 12:38allocate to BTC based on, you know, whether it's Wyoming and
- 12:42their energy extraction or other states, is that something do you
- 12:47think we see or is it still we're still too far out for
- 12:50something like that? No, Texas got the got their own
- 12:56gold vault. Their own gold treasury.
- 12:59Wouldn't be surprising to see that.
- 13:01Jump into it first and have the the infrastructure set up, I
- 13:04believe from like a legal perspective to do that.
- 13:08But no, yeah, I mean the Permanent Fund makes a lot of
- 13:10sense to me. I don't know how it would work
- 13:14exactly, but I've always had this idea using the Alaska Oil
- 13:17Permanent Fund as an example, where they're able to pay
- 13:22Alaskan citizens dividends every year from the profits they make
- 13:25from the oil industry via this permanent Fund.
- 13:29And it's always. We don't know how it would work
- 13:31exactly from like a funding perspective.
- 13:32But I do think there's an opportunity for a state
- 13:35government or a local municipality to issue a bond, to
- 13:39raise cash to buy a six and then partner with a private minor to
- 13:45build on infrastructure, plug the a six and maintain the
- 13:49operation, pay back the bondholders plus the interest.
- 13:52Then once those bonds are paid off, just roll those revenues
- 13:56into a permanent fund that builds up overtime.
- 14:00Who's gonna be the first to do it?
- 14:01I don't know. I think Wyoming.
- 14:03Texas would make a lot of sense, but.
- 14:05I think we know who would be the last two states, the New York
- 14:08and California, will both fight. To.
- 14:12Hey, Alex is in. Alex is in New York.
- 14:14Now let's take it easy. Yeah, that was my subtle, my
- 14:16subtle dig. Because we're gonna, we're gonna
- 14:18do it here in Texas and then we can have Alex come.
- 14:20Sure. Park Park would love the world.
- 14:21The red carpet get a river HQ down in Austin and and I think
- 14:25that the world would be ready to heal.
- 14:28Yeah, you know, I like being around.
- 14:30I like being surrounded by people.
- 14:31I need to convince so. It's.
- 14:38Actually, it's fun having you, Alex, in New York, because
- 14:44there's very few of our friends that are still there.
- 14:46So we get to see your tweets in real time about some of the
- 14:50craziness that happens on a daily occurrence that we don't
- 14:54get to the insight anymore because generally everybody else
- 14:57is oblivious to it. Yeah, you know, I'm like, you
- 15:00know, surfacing it all and bringing it to the and I'm I'm
- 15:03sacrificing, you know, to bring you guys like a good taste, like
- 15:07on the inside. The latest was was the whole
- 15:11situation. The latest was the whole
- 15:12situation in the Northeast with the smoke or whatever was
- 15:14happening. I was actually up near Canada
- 15:17and upstate New York and I was like having my wife and and son
- 15:21inside. I was like, I just don't know
- 15:23what's happening, but doesn't make sense.
- 15:24Everybody else stayed outside. I was like, am I crazy?
- 15:26Are they crazy? And then I was scrolling and saw
- 15:28your tweet about people running and like, it seems a little
- 15:31strange. It's like, OK, we're all right.
- 15:32It's gonna be all right. Yeah yeah so.
- 15:36But hey, there's a good bit devs community here though it.
- 15:40Really is. There's one thing I missed about
- 15:42New York is the bit devs started going in 2015 and I think I've
- 15:47missed like four or five over the many years that it was
- 15:51there. It's shout out to Jay.
- 15:55Max at New York at this for put on a great show, but Alex,
- 16:02really excited to have you on the show this week.
- 16:05Especially considering everything that's been going on
- 16:08in the space with Prime Trust and the fallout from Nat debacle
- 16:13and subsequent transition to Fortress Trust, which is founded
- 16:17by Scott Purcell who founded Prime Trust, which seems to be.
- 16:23Or seems to have been embroiled with some fraud and the way you
- 16:28built River has been intentionally done in a way to
- 16:33eliminate single points of failure or third party
- 16:36dependencies like Prime trust. So I think let's just assume
- 16:42that anybody listening to this podcast is ignorant to what
- 16:46you've built at River, what River is.
- 16:48Explain what River is and why you guys have built your
- 16:51company. And your technical architecture
- 16:54and infrastructure the way you did using Bitcoin's native
- 16:59properties. Yeah, I do believe in this
- 17:04Bitcoin mantra of not your keys, not your coins.
- 17:07And I also think that applies to companies and especially if
- 17:12you're selling Bitcoin or doing Bitcoin custody for people.
- 17:15And so at River, what we do is we offer Bitcoin brokerage
- 17:20custody. Wallet and hosted mining
- 17:23services for both consumers businesses in the United States
- 17:28and then we also have an international payments
- 17:30infrastructure business. So we and and that's mostly
- 17:35focused on the Lightning Network and we make it really easy for
- 17:39for exchanges apps while it's globally to plug into the
- 17:42Lightning Network. And we have some prequel
- 17:45customers, the government of El Salvador is one of our customers
- 17:48for that product. It powers the Chivo Wallet.
- 17:52And then we also have an international, we also serve
- 17:54higher end international customers for our brokerage
- 17:57services. So like high net worth
- 17:59individuals and and businesses who are looking to buy Bitcoin
- 18:01for their treasury. And and you know the way we
- 18:05built the company was sort of a slow kind of do the hard work
- 18:09upfront to save headaches later. So we started the company by you
- 18:19know building our own custody system.
- 18:21And you know, building our own full stack and the software was
- 18:25part of that. But actually like a lot of the
- 18:27work was regulatory. We had in order to be a company
- 18:33that touches people's money and facilitates the movement of that
- 18:37money, we we have to be registered in or we have to be
- 18:41licensed in a lot of different states as a money transmitter
- 18:45and that's an expensive and cumbersome process.
- 18:49It's a lot of work, but it's the only way for us to operate and
- 18:54have you know, control of of our systems and our keys and our
- 18:58infrastructure. The alternative would have been
- 19:02to, you know, outsource all of that to something like a I mean
- 19:06there weren't many places you could do that and the the most
- 19:09popular one was Prime Trust where basically they're the
- 19:12financial institution, they have all the licenses and you're
- 19:14building like a wrapper on top of.
- 19:17Their systems. But you can't touch the money
- 19:19and if you can't touch the money, it means you can't know
- 19:22that the money's there and you can't have any sort of you don't
- 19:25get as much insight into, you know, how how the custody is
- 19:28being handled and how the how the operations are.
- 19:31So yeah, so so that's that that that's how we approach our
- 19:35business is kind of doing it the the hard way, the Bitcoin way
- 19:38proof of work. And it's turned out to be the
- 19:41right decision because these third parties that a lot of
- 19:44people are outsourcing to turned out to be.
- 19:47Frankly, clown shows. And you know, it was pretty
- 19:51obvious in my opinion, but everyone learned the hard way I
- 19:57guess. Why?
- 19:59Why do you say you think it was obvious?
- 20:02Well, look, I don't want to. I don't want to, like, throw.
- 20:05I don't want to sling too much, you know, Shit, I guess.
- 20:11But look, I've interfaced with, you know, a lot of these.
- 20:15Firms who, you know claim to be qualified custodians and you
- 20:21know, like, you know, I want to be sure okay like Okay.
- 20:28If your qualified custodian is based in like Las Vegas and
- 20:31doesn't have anyone who's ever built key management systems or
- 20:36like worked on like crypto custody systems, like, you kind
- 20:40of have to wonder like. Is that a place that I really
- 20:43wanna be storing assets? Right.
- 20:46That's all I'll say. And yeah, I think people really
- 20:54over indexed on just like they basically outsourced their due
- 20:59diligence to regulators who also don't know what the hell is
- 21:02going on, right, and really. And really the question should
- 21:08have been like, well, how are they doing custody, right?
- 21:10Does anyone on this team know how to build high quality
- 21:13custody systems? Because if you don't have that,
- 21:16it doesn't matter how many licenses you have or how you
- 21:19know how many regulatory check boxes you check.
- 21:23And so you know that's there was a six.
- 21:25There's a very sort of, you know, massive gap in people's
- 21:29due diligence in my opinion. Yeah, just to add a few few
- 21:33things there. One really commend you Alex for
- 21:35what you built. It's increasingly as Marty said,
- 21:37I think it's the most frictionless entry point for
- 21:40somebody trying to get access to Bitcoin for larger like you
- 21:44mentioned institutions or nation states looking to leverage some
- 21:46of your products. You know have been building a
- 21:49alongside in the Bitcoin only ecosystem, you know at Unchained
- 21:54with river now on ramp. And I've always respected
- 21:58because of what Alex just references.
- 22:00It takes a lot of work and foresight to understand that you
- 22:04want to own the infrastructure from custody, Mt L's compliance
- 22:07and everything in between. And I actually fully also
- 22:11understand where somebody would use an intermediary because you
- 22:13can help jumpstart that liquidity process of being able
- 22:16to offer certain services. Where I think and I'd be curious
- 22:19like Alex and everybody else's thoughts is you want to if you
- 22:22if that's your. Route, that's Okay.
- 22:25But the problem is to not be complacent on that because
- 22:28there's a lot of counterparty risk for you as an individual
- 22:31business owner, but then also for your clients.
- 22:35You're the individuals that are relying on you as a trusted
- 22:38party to get access to these financial products.
- 22:41And so you're basically kind of kneecapping your own potential
- 22:44business by leveraging these intermediaries, whether it's the
- 22:47custody of U.S. dollars, custody of the BTC and everything in
- 22:52between. Because again when we talk about
- 22:54these intermediaries Nevada state charter, it's questionable
- 22:58what the rest of the state charters look at from a trust
- 23:01entity. So South Dakota, Wyoming, it's
- 23:03my understanding that Nevada is like its own little kind of
- 23:06bubble on like the requirements and that's always been known.
- 23:09The Nevada state charter was questionable to be offering
- 23:12these services in the way that they leverage them for all 50
- 23:14states or however many they they let the Mt L's.
- 23:18But then the the other part is really.
- 23:20The the status of hiding or or leveraging behind the qualified
- 23:24custodian status because as we've discussed here and it's
- 23:26been shown point blank, it's like qualified custodian
- 23:29segregated all the buzzwords you can throw from a legal
- 23:32perspective. Yes, you might need it from an
- 23:34RIA or to offer services in the United States and that's
- 23:38perfectly fine. But from a pure game theoretical
- 23:41understanding Bitcoin and the architecture and just.
- 23:45What can happen to the asset if it's not custody?
- 23:47So you can have the qualified custodian and still have
- 23:50completely unqualified custody if it's not secured properly.
- 23:53And that's effectively what just happened the past, you know, 6
- 23:57to 12 months, but the past month what we saw with Prime Trust and
- 24:01so again just to to tie it all back in, it's very important
- 24:04from the business owner to understand the layers of
- 24:06counterparty risk as you as you build a business because you
- 24:08have to think about the different ways a flow of funds
- 24:10can potentially be. Lost or just not structured in
- 24:14the right way, but then also from a client perspective,
- 24:17understanding where you're depositing dollars, where the
- 24:20BTC sits, where you're taking possession and everything in
- 24:23between because those are all points.
- 24:25We're dealing with a different world here versus like
- 24:27traditional securities. And so there's a bunch of points
- 24:30where you can ultimately get rugged and we just continue to
- 24:33see this and this is the course of bitcoins.
- 24:35We'll be over the course of, you know, the past 10 years,
- 24:37probably the next 10 years until the market gets educated and
- 24:40we've talked to blank. Previously with the ETF and so
- 24:43there's just different financial products that will be structured
- 24:46and they ultimately won't adhere to Bitcoin's native properties.
- 24:49And over time those generally have shown to not end up faring
- 24:53well for the company and the end user.
- 24:55Which is the saddest because that person stored their hard
- 24:57earned capital in in that company and in the unit and they
- 25:01thought they were OK and it end up being you know a trending or
- 25:05it went to 0. Yeah, exactly.
- 25:09And. You know, if you look at and and
- 25:13The thing is, if you really need a qualified custodian, you
- 25:16typically know that, right? Like you're an RIA, you're
- 25:21starting an ETF, you are a big pension fund, you're a public
- 25:25company and there's already products for those people like
- 25:28go to Coinbase custody, go to Nitig, right?
- 25:31Those are New York trust companies.
- 25:32If you're looking for like if you really want to make sure all
- 25:35the legal stuff is going to be exactly like you expect.
- 25:40The New York Trust Company is the gold standard, but you have
- 25:43to pay for that, right. You're going to have to pay a UM
- 25:45fees on for that qualified custody because those qualified
- 25:49custodians in New York have to lock up that capital with
- 25:51regulators. So the cost structures are built
- 25:54for like financial and financial products that have a UM revenue
- 25:59models like funds like investment management and and
- 26:05the like. So you know this sort of like
- 26:08outsourced like. Compliant custodian as a service
- 26:13it tends to basically attract like I mean if you look at prime
- 26:17trust customer roster like it was Celsius finance us Abra
- 26:25which turns out seems which they're saying wasn't solvent on
- 26:29top of prime trust insolvency. I mean, it's not exactly like,
- 26:33you know, a great roster of companies using these kinds of
- 26:36services. So.
- 26:38And there's a reason and there's a reason for that.
- 26:40So, so yeah. Yeah, that's my, I think one
- 26:46also thing to point out is it is not required for an entity to
- 26:52hold Bitcoin in a qualified custodian.
- 26:54It is required for registered investment advisors to hold
- 26:58securities. On behalf of clients and a
- 27:00qualified custodian. Ra's do it because it's a form
- 27:03of CYA, hey? But it is nowhere written that
- 27:06you can. You need to hold a commodity
- 27:07with a qualified custodian. They decide to do that because
- 27:11they are not IS again. Information asymmetry, they just
- 27:14want to check the box and be fine with it.
- 27:17But it is not required and it's being rumored or discussed that
- 27:21there's this discussion on the federal and state levels on what
- 27:24qualified custodians will be required to hold.
- 27:27And they're trying to encroach on other assets, alternative
- 27:30assets, commodities, real estate, and also what states are
- 27:33recognized i.e. federal versus like honoring the South Dakota
- 27:37charter as it is today. But that is all speculative and
- 27:41it's still years more than likely.
- 27:43Because that would require changes across the United
- 27:45States. So it's just there's a lot of
- 27:48discussion out that happens about this.
- 27:50And and again, I didn't know about any of this stuff, right.
- 27:53It's like you go into this world, you have to understand
- 27:55it. And when you go and look and
- 27:56educate is the reality is very different than what people will
- 28:00propagate out in the market. And it's important to know
- 28:03because at the margins, if you choose a qualified custodian
- 28:06that ends up in Nevada, you may lose all your Bitcoin.
- 28:09Yeah, and you know, an interesting data point here is
- 28:12the only. As as far as I know in in recent
- 28:15history, the only American custodian that went bust due to
- 28:23something other than financial leverage was Prime Trust, which
- 28:28was a qualified custodian. I mean, I can't think of any
- 28:32other examples like all the other ones that went bust like
- 28:35Celsius block by it was all yield and leverage, it was all
- 28:38financialization risk. The one custodian that screwed
- 28:43up key management was a qualified custodian, and I think
- 28:47there's a correlation there. People running qualified
- 28:49custodians tend to be traditional financial people who
- 28:53know absolutely nothing about key management.
- 28:58Yeah, absolutely. And so there's this world where
- 29:01you can combine the two. You need the Bitcoin custody
- 29:05skill set. To marry with the qualified
- 29:09custodian procedures and policies and practices.
- 29:12And through that fusion you can create something better that you
- 29:17might not get by just handing over your keys to a quote UN
- 29:20quote qualified custodian. Yeah.
- 29:25And I mean, so like what is a qualified custodian?
- 29:30Why do they exist, ideally by the litter of the law to protect
- 29:34consumers. By ensuring that their assets
- 29:37are custody by somebody qualified to actually control
- 29:41and secure those assets. But again like Michael
- 29:45mentioned, Bitcoin's completely different.
- 29:47Like the way to consumer protection on a grand scale in
- 29:51the era of Bitcoin is to have like a distribution of private
- 29:56keys amongst many businesses. Like that would be the worst
- 29:59case scenarios if this qualified custodian.
- 30:04Encroachment into alternative assets turns out to be true, and
- 30:08you force a bunch of Bitcoin into very few players hands.
- 30:12That's overall bad for the vast majority of consumers because
- 30:19that's concentrated third party risk in the hands of a select
- 30:22few, which is not what you want. You want a million flowers to
- 30:26bloom? Distribute the private keys
- 30:29amongst many different businesses, many different
- 30:32individuals. And yes, some may fail, but that
- 30:34failure will be isolated to a relatively small group of people
- 30:38compared to the potential failure of a massive qualified
- 30:42custodian. Yeah, exactly.
- 30:47And you know, also sort of like part of the purpose of the
- 30:51qualified custodian thing was, you know, you have these
- 30:53financial institutions, they're like moving all sorts of assets
- 30:56around doing like trading over here, doing all sorts of stuff
- 30:59over here. Like you want to make sure that
- 31:02if you say you have a. Clients, assets, they're like,
- 31:06there's no funny business happening with them.
- 31:07They're all right there. If you're just running a simple
- 31:11Bitcoin brokerage, you know where you're holding.
- 31:15Someone buys Bitcoin, you put it in your cold storage.
- 31:18When they would draw it, it leaves your cold storage.
- 31:21It's not like there's this, all this other stuff going on,
- 31:25right. It's not like customers, assets
- 31:28might be over here, might be over here.
- 31:30It's a very like. Simple business and we're
- 31:32already legally required to not use our clients assets for
- 31:36anything else. We make those representations to
- 31:38regulators and our auditors check that.
- 31:41So it's you know like it's it's not really designed for this,
- 31:48it's like it was designed for a very different sort of financial
- 31:52institution. Right.
- 31:54And because there's because fundamentally there's never been
- 31:56an asset like this where you can.
- 31:59You can point to the Ledger real time and say here's the proof
- 32:03it's sitting right here. There's nowhere else it could
- 32:06possibly be right now. It's not like these books are
- 32:08out of date. It is there that this is you
- 32:11know my real time Bitcoin audit in action, you know, and of
- 32:15course the auditors have their other policies that they're
- 32:18checking boxes on. But that gets you a a great deal
- 32:22of the way to the assurances that are that you're seeking
- 32:27with any kind of. Audit trail and and custody in
- 32:31general. You want to know that the assets
- 32:32are there, that control is maintained by the entity that is
- 32:38supposed to be controlling it and nobody else.
- 32:40And that's what Bitcoin provides.
- 32:44Exactly. It's a brave new world.
- 32:49And that's, I mean as a Bitcoin or as an investor in the space,
- 32:54if somebody wants to see freedom.
- 32:57Went out in the long run. That's like the biggest threat
- 33:00right now is like the regulators in the United States just really
- 33:04dropping the ball by infringing on the market for figuring
- 33:09things out and putting some overburdensome regulations on
- 33:14smaller companies. And then creating risk for
- 33:18individual consumers at the end of the day by applying this
- 33:21anachronistic view of securities custody onto Bitcoin.
- 33:28Yeah, I think, I think that's the thing that we like.
- 33:31It's been talked about. I was actually initially
- 33:33concerned you did what you just referenced Marty of like the
- 33:36centralization qualified custodian federal.
- 33:39But the reality is like bitcoins such a tiny asset compared to
- 33:41other things that would be fall under this.
- 33:43Like gold's a good example of this.
- 33:45So you require all these different entities to figure out
- 33:47if they need to move the gold or go get this charter like that
- 33:50would cause an uproar across other industries, let alone
- 33:53Bitcoin. Like I don't see this happening.
- 33:56You know in that like in that scheme of having to like move
- 33:59assets or not recognizing state charters where the dynamic would
- 34:06change for custodians to move forward with how they custody
- 34:09all these assets because again think about trillions and assets
- 34:12being held in these different custom arrangements.
- 34:14I think before we jumped on we talked or maybe it was on the we
- 34:16talked about the Texas. Bullion depository like I think
- 34:19this would effectively have them have to move the assets out of
- 34:23that or get some kind of state charter to to custody those
- 34:25assets because they're holding it.
- 34:27I think still for the largest endowment in the country which
- 34:32is UTEMCO, the University of Texas and A and M Endowment and
- 34:38I think it's over a billion dollars held at the Texas
- 34:40Bullion Depository. I don't believe they're a
- 34:42qualified custodian and because they're not those assets.
- 34:46We potentially have to move and actually probably should check
- 34:48that. But yeah, and I think there's
- 34:54like we talked about this I think in the last episode and I
- 34:59think my thoughts have crystallized a little bit more
- 35:01on what I see is a likely outcome over the next 10 years
- 35:06is some Wall Street firm, a lot of Wall Street firms are going
- 35:09to get exposed to Bitcoin and and and launch Bitcoin products
- 35:13like the BlackRock product. The ones that are very
- 35:15successful can accumulate large amounts of Bitcoin.
- 35:20Meanwhile, I think the price of Bitcoin runs such that these
- 35:24funds become very large. And you know, a bedrock normal
- 35:30practice for Wall Street is to rehypothecate assets and funds
- 35:34to lend them out to get additional yield.
- 35:36And you know, thinking about it more, I think that there is, I'm
- 35:42going to go out on a limb here and say.
- 35:44That some very large Wall Street firms that have been around for
- 35:48a century are going to die in the next 10 years because they
- 35:53rehypothecate Bitcoin and the tide goes out and they're the
- 35:57hole on their balance sheet is larger than their enterprise
- 36:00value. And I think that's going to be
- 36:04that's the better scenario because the world Wall Street,
- 36:10everyone touching the hot stove and burning themselves.
- 36:14Is better than the alternative which was would be the over
- 36:17regulation and of of how Bitcoin custody is done forcing all of
- 36:25the Bitcoin out there into a small number of custodian honey
- 36:30pots that can then be more easily confiscated or controlled
- 36:35or have stipulations applied to them about.
- 36:38You know, OFAC compliance or KYCAML or ESG compliance or
- 36:42whatever the flavor of the month is at that point.
- 36:45So you know, I think, I think we're going to see Bitcoin
- 36:49custody be a extremely big topic in the world of finance over the
- 36:54coming decade. And people don't know it yet.
- 36:57And I think it's going to be the reason that some venerable old
- 37:01Wall Street established names die in this in this decade.
- 37:07Yeah, Sue text bowling depository not qualified
- 37:10custodian. And Alex, I don't know if we
- 37:12we've chatted or we haven't chatted about this, but part of
- 37:14what Jesse said was Q3Q4 of last year before really the end like
- 37:19fallout of FTX, we started having conversations with folks
- 37:23that were sitting close or at. Citadel, BlackRock and hearing
- 37:27about all these plans, EDX, not really the ETF, but recognizing
- 37:31at the time the, the, and I think this was even in writing
- 37:34that the EDX, Schwab, Citadel and Fidelity, we're going to use
- 37:37Paxos as their back end. I think it just came out today
- 37:40or yesterday. Now they're potentially using
- 37:42Anchorage custody, but just seeing what we witnessed with
- 37:46Block 5, right. You know before that in this
- 37:48state the status of the market was like, Oh my God, we're going
- 37:51to see orders of magnitude. Like what we just saw, what we
- 37:55just witnessed three to five years from now at that scale
- 37:59with Wall Street, it's like there has to be people that step
- 38:02in and at the time like looking at the market and I'd be curious
- 38:05like your thoughts like building the space, you kind of thought a
- 38:08lot of the market players have been built.
- 38:10You know, you looked at grayscale, you looked at Block
- 38:12Fi and while we knew that they were kind of on shaky grounds,
- 38:15like maybe they get themselves out of it, but it's like the
- 38:17whole. Landscape got like the table got
- 38:21knocked upside down is like the opportunity is still there and
- 38:24now you have the benefit of hindsight of like how not to do
- 38:27things, the risk not to take. So to Jesse's point, it's like
- 38:30this is a big reason by like where on ramp exists is really
- 38:33thinking through like how do enterprises, institutions
- 38:36actually get to a way where or how do we build the right
- 38:39structure. So we don't see what happened
- 38:41just recently with FTX Block 5 and the like happened five years
- 38:44from now, but orders of magnitude larger.
- 38:49Yeah, it's a I mean it's been, it's honestly like I, you know
- 38:54it's it's been really sad to see how many people lose money and
- 38:57get hurt by this. But selfishly it's been great
- 39:00for our business and I and I've said this on other podcasts, but
- 39:05you know during the bull market, you know I never understood how
- 39:10the lending worked. If I'm being honest like I'm I I
- 39:16never understood it. I never really understood where
- 39:20the yield was coming from and how they did all this stuff and
- 39:24there was a point in time where I was almost kind of wondering
- 39:27if I'm just dumb like am I just retarded that like I don't get
- 39:30this and and block five was soaring and all these guys were
- 39:33soaring and I was like I don't I don't know how this is working
- 39:35like this is just doesn't make me feel comfortable.
- 39:37We're just not going to do it but we're also going to be
- 39:39missing out on a lot of growth and and revenue and and it turns
- 39:44out like those instincts were just right.
- 39:47And and so you know since then our growth has been great
- 39:50because you know, now everyone's learned well, well yield isn't
- 39:55actually a great thing for Bitcoin.
- 39:56So now I'm going to go to the company that doesn't offer any
- 39:58yield because that's much safer. But and and so like that's a
- 40:02lesson that you know, I think that the industry learned what I
- 40:06what I don't know is, you know Wall Street was built on all of
- 40:11this stuff like all these finance people, all these firms.
- 40:16They all made all their money. Not all of it, but a lot of it,
- 40:19just doing all these funny games.
- 40:20And when they get into Bitcoin, like like Jesse said, like, is
- 40:27this actually going to help Bitcoin or is this Bitcoin just
- 40:30just going to kill all these guys because they can't do the
- 40:34same game and it's like, what's the point of them getting into
- 40:39it, right, so. Yeah.
- 40:43Yeah, I I think there's there's so much hubris right now because
- 40:45that that's Wall Street. They think they know money.
- 40:47They they've got the playbook from 150 years of doing this,
- 40:51that, and now the big boys are here to show us how it's done.
- 40:54But The thing is, is that Bitcoin is uncompromising and
- 40:59Bitcoin humbles everyone because it is uncompromising and you
- 41:03have to play Bitcoin's game on its terms.
- 41:07You can't dictate the terms of the game to Bitcoin.
- 41:10And so there's this, like this juggernaut of hubris coming up
- 41:15against this completely inflexible Bitcoin.
- 41:20And we're going to see fireworks from some, you know, disastrous
- 41:25outcome of Wall Street playing the games that it is accustomed
- 41:30to getting away with in the Fiat world.
- 41:33Yeah, you know and sorry, you. Got.
- 41:37Well, and I was just going to say like I think what you know,
- 41:39my realization has been, you know, like Bitcoin is like kind
- 41:44of the great definancialization. We our company, like our company
- 41:48name officially legally is River Financial.
- 41:50We just did a brand refresh. We now just say River because
- 41:53what I've, you know, what I wanted to sort of internalize in
- 41:57the company is we're not a finance company.
- 42:00The innovation here is, is, is software, it's user experience,
- 42:04it's brand, it's service. We're not going to be building
- 42:07new you know finance things. We're not going to be offering
- 42:12new sorts of ways to you know like do leverage or lend or
- 42:16anything like this because that stuff will just kill you.
- 42:22You know everything we're going to be building at River is like
- 42:24is like software basis. How do we help people secure,
- 42:28move and buy Bitcoin, better people in institutions and.
- 42:34That's our focus. There's no source like there's
- 42:37nothing on our roadmap that leads to like I just can't sleep
- 42:43at night offering any financial products that involve risk
- 42:48beyond software risk and and so yeah, so that's why we're just
- 42:52river now because I'm like you don't want to be doing finance
- 42:57with Bitcoin. It's really funny to hear you
- 43:00say that, Alex, cuz me and Marty talk a lot about just the status
- 43:03of the market. And it's like if you look hard
- 43:05and long, it's like the only way you get to what you just said is
- 43:06looking long enough at this problem that you're like, it's
- 43:10like the killer app is just buying and holding at least for
- 43:13another like 10 to 100 X. And so I've been coming to this
- 43:17realization too. And I look at the status of just
- 43:20venture in itself. It's like how much a lot of
- 43:22these firms that are Bitcoin only don't actually monetize
- 43:26because there's only so many people willing to spend the
- 43:28asset. If you think about like
- 43:29lightning and liquidity, like the orders of magnitude is on
- 43:32chain versus through it. And to your point, I think like
- 43:35there will be a financialization of it just by definition of it
- 43:38being money in the same way that there will be very incredible
- 43:43businesses built in top line, But the core from an order of
- 43:46operations and where the money will accrue and the value added
- 43:50services right now is literally to get exposure and to hold it
- 43:54safely and securely. And then everything else is
- 43:57downstream of that and they'll be test and innovation just
- 44:00similar to early Internet days. But right now in my mind it's
- 44:03still like similar to like web van where you're gonna like see
- 44:07the inkling if you squint. But we're still probably years
- 44:09out from all the different crazy stuff because the perimeters
- 44:12haven't been built that like mimic what the software layer
- 44:18will allow. And the example I always think
- 44:20of is. Like we tried a lot of stuff in
- 44:22the early 90s and early 2000s, but it really was the mobile
- 44:25phone that allowed for the real applications to be delivered.
- 44:29Because you had GPS, you had Geo location, you had the phone that
- 44:32set your thing and then you got the Ubers and Airbnb's of the
- 44:34world. And so to your point, I think,
- 44:36yeah, like the killer app is not the lend against it or get yield
- 44:39or you know these other like even merchant services like it
- 44:43makes sense that any of you worked on, but we're still so
- 44:45far from people using Bitcoin as money that it's just something
- 44:49I've been thinking about. So to hear you saying out loud
- 44:51it, it really is kind of like crystallizing my mind the past
- 44:55few months. Well.
- 44:58Go ahead, Marty. Well, I was gonna like in
- 45:00harkening back to your comment Alex about.
- 45:04Sitting there watching a lot of these Defy Yield products blow
- 45:08or like have temporary great success, like I have that same
- 45:13that same feeling too. Like am I wrong like already,
- 45:16like I had that same intuition like I don't think this is right
- 45:18but they're making so much money that maybe I am wrong if I have
- 45:21to check my priors. Like remember 3 Hours Capital
- 45:25Suzu and Kyle Davies were vaunted as these Wonderkins FTX
- 45:30SDF. Was a Wonderkin.
- 45:32Like, yeah, they were all the smartest guys in the room.
- 45:35They could influence people on Twitter, They can go on podcasts
- 45:40and sound extremely smart. But they were doing some of the
- 45:43dumbest stuff they could ever do with Bitcoin, which was borrow
- 45:49it from a company like block fire Celsius and then go
- 45:51leverage trade it with shit coins.
- 45:54And that's what's going to be interesting, tying this back
- 45:57like Wall Street getting in. And something we probably have
- 46:00to mentally prepare for is a a temporary period of time where
- 46:04it seems like they're having massive success doing their
- 46:08financial gains with Bitcoin, their their marketing like
- 46:13massive returns and showing all these profits.
- 46:17But like Jesse said, the tide will eventually recede and that
- 46:21will get all laid to bear. And like like Michael said, it's
- 46:26gonna be pretty epic. But that's like.
- 46:28Psychologically, the point I'm trying to make here is having
- 46:31been in the space for 10 years, I've had these self doubt
- 46:34questioning moments many times throughout the many bull and
- 46:38bear cycles that I've been a part of over the last decade.
- 46:42And it's something as I get older, as I get more experienced
- 46:46than beginning to internalize much better is like, hey, it's
- 46:49all noise, come back to the fundamentals, we have some
- 46:52money, you cannot print more of this.
- 46:54So taking obscene risk with it does not make any sense.
- 46:58Especially if you're a business acting on behalf of clients.
- 47:02Absolutely. And for me, you know, like the
- 47:05last year really hammered home this idea that it I'd always
- 47:11kind of intuitively unknown, which is like sounding smart and
- 47:14being smart or two very different things and you know,
- 47:20if you add unnecessary. Risk and complexity to things
- 47:27and you create this, you you create this sort of like complex
- 47:33world of of complexity and little things that you need to
- 47:37know and understand. And you create all these words
- 47:38like rehypothecation and and swaps and perpetuals and you
- 47:42know and you create that. You can sound very smart, right?
- 47:46And somebody like who who, who's like, you know what?
- 47:50I just don't. I just think all that stuff
- 47:51introduces unnecessary risk. They're not.
- 47:54They're not going to bother understanding all of those.
- 47:57All that complexity just created.
- 47:58So they're not going to sound as learned and intelligent as the
- 48:00person who is into it, right? They just intuitively know to
- 48:05stay away from it. The smarter person actually
- 48:08intuitively knows to stay away from complexity, But because of
- 48:11that, they sound Dumber, right? Because there's there's fewer
- 48:15words, they know, there's fewer concepts for them to explain to
- 48:18you, and it's that you're constantly on the defensive
- 48:22like. You know you don't want to spend
- 48:24all your time. Now you have to go research what
- 48:27a perp swap is so that you can explain to somebody why it's a
- 48:30bad idea, right? It's an endless sort of like
- 48:33struggle to constantly try and debunk new crap that gets
- 48:37invented for you to lose your Bitcoin.
- 48:38So I think that's what ends up getting people is like that sort
- 48:43of dynamic. Yeah, we talked about this a bit
- 48:46with with Parker, Lewis and and Michael and Parker had a.
- 48:52They rift on how Bitcoin is a common sense test.
- 48:55And you know, it boils down to like, if you just have
- 48:58internalized the common sense mantra at some point.
- 49:02The money doesn't grow on trees, There's no such thing as a free
- 49:05lunch. You're going to avoid the the
- 49:10fancy talk that is designed to be the siren call that lures you
- 49:15into risk. And if you just stay the course
- 49:18and and and know that you've got sound money.
- 49:21You've got the best savings technology ever that appreciates
- 49:23in value over time because of its increasing scarcity, and
- 49:26that's good enough for you. You're gonna come out on top.
- 49:31What's interesting though is there's almost like if you were
- 49:37like that from a previous generation, you avoid Bitcoin.
- 49:43And that's the irony of that, right?
- 49:45Because like you hear about a blockchain and a you know you
- 49:48learned your lessons the hard way in like the pre Bitcoin
- 49:51world and you hear these guys going on about all this stuff.
- 49:54You're like I learned to stay away from the complicated stuff.
- 49:57So there's. Yeah, absolutely.
- 50:02You throw out the baby with the bathwater because you're like,
- 50:06there's no way that any of this blockchain mumbo jumbo is worth
- 50:09my time when it turns out that. We've reinvented sound money.
- 50:13It's. A fascinating 90. 5%, right?
- 50:1899% of the blockchain mumbo isn't worth your time, but 1%
- 50:22is. That's a really important 1% and
- 50:25not this. Well that reminds me of the
- 50:27Bitcoins is a get rich slow scheme disguised as a get rich
- 50:31quick scheme. So if you will look at it, they
- 50:33think of it as a Ponzi. Marty, your comment really like
- 50:37made a lot of sense about you know the pattern recognition and
- 50:40I think this happened in 17 with the alt coins and everybody
- 50:42thinking they're crazy about not getting the Icos.
- 50:45And it's like there's something to the like downstream effect of
- 50:48who gets in the early adopter and similar with like this ETF
- 50:52and all this all this like financialization with the
- 50:54different fund structures and who custody's you're going to
- 50:57start seeing the downstream ruggings happen.
- 50:59At a certain point cuz some ETF is gonna do, maybe it isn't
- 51:02BlackRock, but it's another one that does decide to lend out.
- 51:04The volatility happens. They're not used to seeing it go
- 51:07from 300 to 150 over whatever the numbers are and it's just
- 51:11gonna be like it's just we're just gonna see it happen again.
- 51:13There was like, I could have never figured this out.
- 51:14I don't understand. And then five years from there
- 51:16we'll see the nation state do the same thing.
- 51:18It's just like all the way ruggings until until the end.
- 51:24Rugging is until people relearn the lessons of a free market
- 51:29economy with sound money like there's there are no bailouts in
- 51:32Bitcoin and we have to relearn that hard lesson the only way
- 51:36that hard lessons are ever learned, which is through
- 51:39disaster. Yeah.
- 51:42And that's like actually since you brought up the BlackRock
- 51:46ETF, like I was observing a thread that a bunch of the ETF
- 51:52into it, people. Were engaged in earlier today
- 51:56and it's really funny to see how they view Bitcoin and
- 51:59particularly black rocks entrance into the space.
- 52:02I'm gonna put a tweet in here look and pull it up.
- 52:05We talked about a rabbit hole recap too but I think it's
- 52:07important to discuss it here on the last trade as well because
- 52:12especially for our audience because I do think.
- 52:18Wall Street views the BlackRock ETF in a particular way that is
- 52:22going to get them burned or severely limits their
- 52:26understanding what Bitcoin can do.
- 52:28And so this is Eric Val Kunis, who I believe is Bloomberg's ETF
- 52:33expert. The big irony in all of this is
- 52:36most crypto people see the ETF is boomer mainstream trad 5 when
- 52:39in fact the ETF is the real disruptor and disintermediator
- 52:44mediator. This was the point we made.
- 52:47After the dumb Matt Damon commercial and he references an
- 52:50article with the title of Spot Bitcoin ETF could make this the
- 52:53last crypto Super Bowl commercial.
- 52:55And essentially his argument is since people will be able to
- 52:59access Bitcoin via the ETF and only pay 10 bips and fees like
- 53:04that is the distance mediator in the space so far as like cheaper
- 53:08access to Bitcoin failing to acknowledge that that Bitcoin
- 53:13will just sit in a coin based wallet.
- 53:16That individuals won't have access to and therefore won't be
- 53:19able to the reap the benefits of the digital bearer assets and
- 53:22the many things that you could do with that.
- 53:24So I need artwork in this cave I have at the house or whatever
- 53:28and I think that needs to be framed like is there more
- 53:30perfect Wall Street like just version of understanding what's
- 53:33happening here? It's like I think where I saw
- 53:36that was your comment about 12 words or the he responded or you
- 53:39responded about 12 words being a lot easier than understanding
- 53:41this. And it's just like all personal
- 53:43responsibility esolving of all risks.
- 53:45It's just like here, ETF 10 Bips handle this.
- 53:49It's incredible because the 10 bips actually isn't 10 bips.
- 53:51It's a 0. Ultimately, what's on the table
- 53:55is if you lose all your funds because they decided to do
- 53:57something. Yeah, the point Michael's making
- 54:00here is for anyone out there who is less versed in what exactly
- 54:06BlackRock has created here is. They're going to try to have
- 54:10very low fees and that sticker price will look great in terms
- 54:17of you know here's your your AUM fees or your trading fees too.
- 54:23But they're going to get, they could get their yield,
- 54:26additional yield by rehypothecating that Bitcoin.
- 54:30That's the standard practice and then that's the scenario where
- 54:34you could end up with the zero, so.
- 54:37Buyer beware. You know when Wall Street is
- 54:41saying we've got this figured out and it's going to be really,
- 54:45really, really cheap? So cheap you can't believe it.
- 54:49It's for a reason and there's hidden risk.
- 54:52Is there any indication that BlackRock is in the current
- 54:56filing is allowed to do any rehab, any rehab application?
- 55:07That's what I was just going to say.
- 55:08I don't think there is like, I don't think like I talked with
- 55:11Townsend Lansing from Coin Shares who's created a lot of
- 55:14these exchange traded products in Europe around Bitcoin and
- 55:18other crypto currencies. I mean he helped spun out the
- 55:21GLD and the Palladium and Platinum Grantor Trust, which is
- 55:27the model obviously the black rocks using for the Bitcoin ETF
- 55:31and he's seemingly like now there's no way that they can
- 55:33rehypothecate it. I think, I think that the
- 55:37question is like the grantor trust has a direct unit exposure
- 55:40and then what they're supposed to do.
- 55:42I think we're it gets mucky as between the authorized
- 55:45participants, the redemption creation and what all the things
- 55:49that happened in in between on having the actual Bitcoin versus
- 55:54what the claims on it from like shareholders are an issue.
- 55:59Yeah, I think. I think people should more worry
- 56:01about like Coinbase, Like if they ever get in a sticky
- 56:03situation, like they're the ones custody.
- 56:07Yeah, in in my view, there's. So I I spent a weekend really
- 56:12diving deep into the S1 and there's a lot of little mucky
- 56:16details that you know about like standard practices that Wall
- 56:19Street's bringing that add a little little bits of risk here
- 56:24and there and and you could have a disaster at any one of these.
- 56:29Points of of small risk, Coinbase being one of the the
- 56:35additional, you know single points of failure effectively
- 56:39that is in place in this model. There's nothing in the S1 that
- 56:44prohibits them from rehypothecating and there's and
- 56:48I've I've heard both sides from from folks about whether or not
- 56:51they would they would dare to rehypothecate to lend out the
- 56:56Bitcoin in the fund. But there's nothing explicitly
- 57:00that that says they can't. And and that is a standard
- 57:03practice with ETF. So they could tiny risk.
- 57:06But it's there among many other little mucky points that that
- 57:12are, you know Wall Street trying to force their structure of how
- 57:16they do things to to make Bitcoin fit in it.
- 57:23Interesting. And even if they're not now.
- 57:27There's nothing, you know, things change down the road,
- 57:30yeah. Right and and for for example
- 57:33for that like you know the in kind redemptions are allowed for
- 57:37the for the Ap's, the authorized participants that means broker
- 57:42dealer firms and it it specifically says that they have
- 57:47those broker dealer firms have to enter into a separate
- 57:49contract with with BlackRock and basically be in the good graces
- 57:55of BlackRock so. That's the that's the limited
- 57:58list of who can do in kind redemptions.
- 58:00And at any point in time, BlackRock could revoke those
- 58:04permissions for for some or all of them, depending on it.
- 58:08And there's a little angle, a little point of risk where it it
- 58:13could be you know it starts to become a a bit of a honey pot
- 58:16where if the government wanted to 6102 the, let's say it ends
- 58:23up being a million Bitcoin in this vastly successful
- 58:26BlackRock. Fund.
- 58:29Very, very, very doable. That's actually my biggest
- 58:33concern and like let's put the 6102 off the table, just the
- 58:37honey pot. If it gets a million Bitcoin, it
- 58:39really means Coinbase. And by the way, BlackRock
- 58:41probably has four or five million Bitcoin because of what
- 58:44they already hold. Cuz like if they're probably if
- 58:46they get a million Bitcoin, that means the price is whatever.
- 58:48And at the same time that means Coinbase is holding more GBTC if
- 58:51they're so custody with Coinbase.
- 58:54And you get to 3 to 4,000,000 bitcoins sitting on Coinbase.
- 58:59I'm curious, Alex, have you thought about that?
- 59:00Is that like concerning you cuz that's like my like my that was
- 59:04the first thing that's been I thought about.
- 59:06I mean, it's a real concern. I mean, the good news is
- 59:11BlackRock could diversify their custody if they wanted to, but.
- 59:19It's weird because like with custody, you almost want to go
- 59:21with the big one because they have the most to lose and
- 59:23probably have the most resources to secure it.
- 59:27But it's a constant concern. But I don't think it's really
- 59:30avoidable because wealth distribution in terms of just
- 59:34like, you know, where it will land, like the institutional
- 59:38stuff will just be the like vastly, you know, outweigh any
- 59:43sort of individual holders who are selfcustoding and so.
- 59:48You're just going to end up with a dynamic like this, whether
- 59:50it's Coinbase or somebody else. So I don't really know if it's
- 59:53avoidable, just given how institutions, given how just
- 59:57human civilization works, frankly.
- 1:00:00And so because of that, yeah, better hope Coinbase doesn't
- 1:00:06mess up, Yeah. But I think it's like a
- 1:00:11civilizational sort of like reality.
- 1:00:13I don't know that it's actually ever avoided like.
- 1:00:15Any like the wealthiest civilizations or like the
- 1:00:18wealthiest countries will have the highest institutional trust,
- 1:00:22right? And we'll like trend towards
- 1:00:25like wanting to outsource this core competency.
- 1:00:28Like BlackRock knows that Coinbase can custody their
- 1:00:31Bitcoin lots more than BlackRock can.
- 1:00:33Like. Like the alternative is
- 1:00:35BlackRock custodying it themselves And like, well,
- 1:00:37what's what's safer, Coinbase doing or BlackRock doing it?
- 1:00:39I mean, probably Coinbase doing it almost certainly right and
- 1:00:44so. Yeah, I don't know.
- 1:00:46These are sort of just like foundational issues, and I don't
- 1:00:48know that there's a good answer. I think the one, the counter
- 1:00:52that is like that, this is the first asset.
- 1:00:53They can have multiple people participate in the custody
- 1:00:57model, right? Like you can't split the Bitcoin
- 1:01:00or the, I mean the gold or the silver or the dollars, but the
- 1:01:04asset can have multiple. Jurisdictions, multiple entities
- 1:01:07and I think that's, I think that I mean that's where we're taking
- 1:01:10our bet is like that's how this all ends up playing out is the
- 1:01:12keys end up further out versus like Coinbase holding it all.
- 1:01:15That's. A great point and that is the
- 1:01:18one of the pieces of learning that is outside of the paradigm
- 1:01:22of Wall Street of corporate America, frankly, like Alex
- 1:01:25nailed it, you tend to trust the expert firm and because there's
- 1:01:30one. Person that one firm to hold
- 1:01:33accountable and and put all your eggs in one basket.
- 1:01:36That's how the world has worked. But this crazy asset has this
- 1:01:40property that can mitigate your risk by distributing across
- 1:01:44multiple entities. There's a game theoretical
- 1:01:46aspect too about just like being able to move the assets if
- 1:01:50you're coerced like in the sense and I always thought this was
- 1:01:52interesting, like Unchained costs of holding one key in a
- 1:01:55world where worst case scenario happens, server sees government,
- 1:01:59whatever it is, they can't move the funds and that always kind
- 1:02:01of keeps a check and balance on what can happen.
- 1:02:03And I think in a world that we are concerned about a 6102, the
- 1:02:06best position for a large entity holding the asset is actually
- 1:02:09not able to give up the Bitcoin or be course because they don't
- 1:02:11have unilateral control. I think we're a long way from
- 1:02:14that, but I think that's ultimately if Bitcoin becomes
- 1:02:16money, it will face that in whether it's the US or another
- 1:02:20jurisdiction that will be a problem where it could just be a
- 1:02:23government that wants the Bitcoin for themselves and not
- 1:02:26even outlawing it. Yeah.
- 1:02:30And that's the other thing too, like when it comes to like 6102,
- 1:02:37like. Bitcoin is a push system, it's
- 1:02:39not a pull system. So like if the government wanted
- 1:02:42to confiscate Bitcoin whether it be from individuals, coin bases
- 1:02:47or a multi sig, multi institution setup like somebody
- 1:02:51has to sign the transactions. At the end of the day when they
- 1:02:55did the 6102 gold confiscation it really showed up.
- 1:03:00We just took the gold, especially if you have like a
- 1:03:02multi institution, multi sig or even just a geographically
- 1:03:06dispersed. Multi CIG as an individual
- 1:03:08company it's much harder to do that like in person coercion if
- 1:03:13you have the right processes and policies in place and let's hope
- 1:03:17to God it never gets to that point or government never gets
- 1:03:19so despotic and overrun with power.
- 1:03:22They tried to do this but that's the beauty of bitcoins native
- 1:03:26multi cig properties it is it is sort of a hedge to that like hey
- 1:03:32you can't move that imagine that the government went and tried to
- 1:03:36get like. 3 institutions to collaborate, to move user funds
- 1:03:41and instead of moving them, they came out publicly and be like,
- 1:03:44hey, the government's trying to take your Bitcoin.
- 1:03:46We don't want to let that happen.
- 1:03:47You get like a social movement behind that.
- 1:03:51It's true. But I think at the end of the
- 1:03:52day, like, you know, if you want to, if the US government is
- 1:03:57going, is willing to go after your money, I mean like you kind
- 1:04:02of have two options, right? Keep your keys in.
- 1:04:07Jurisdictions like yourself, right, Like keep using
- 1:04:11jurisdictions that the US government has no influence
- 1:04:13over, which are typically very low trust jurisdictions, right?
- 1:04:18And maybe there's like a few, there's maybe like Dubai or
- 1:04:21something, but or keeper keys in high trust jurisdictions.
- 1:04:26But the US just like they did to Switzerland at some point gets
- 1:04:30the power to just be like, no, you're going to do this because.
- 1:04:33You will, right. Like, I don't know.
- 1:04:36I don't know how that stuff plays out.
- 1:04:38Yeah, I think Marty to your point like the counter is just
- 1:04:41as easy. It is to take the person's goal
- 1:04:44to take the person or the entity that can sign, you can force
- 1:04:47them to sign. So I think to Alex's point, it's
- 1:04:49like this hybrid of jurisdictions along with the US
- 1:04:53and it's not necessarily that, it's more of to make the.
- 1:04:57It's the asymmetry of violence, basically.
- 1:04:59It's like the reason about like, you know, firearms in the US.
- 1:05:01It's like it's just the thought that you have to go door to door
- 1:05:03that makes it untenable or like very hard.
- 1:05:06That's like the game. So we're all trying to play.
- 1:05:08It's not like you're gonna, you know, completely solve it
- 1:05:10because reality is you can put pressure on anybody or one
- 1:05:13entity. It's just about leveraging the.
- 1:05:15Tools as they are, Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:05:20Again, it's brave new world exploring the unknown here.
- 1:05:25That's sort of known. We know what the government is
- 1:05:27willing to do. What?
- 1:05:30Are you guys bets? Does the BlackRock ETF even get
- 1:05:32approved this year? Let's say this year.
- 1:05:34Does it get approved this year? I think right after Labor Day,
- 1:05:38Labor Day, right after Labor Day, yeah.
- 1:05:41Yeah, I'm kind of 5050 on it actually, though I'm sort of
- 1:05:45bracing for it does happen, which is good and and bad at the
- 1:05:50same time. It's a better question is what
- 1:05:53gets approved first to our core BlackRock.
- 1:05:56Because that's been in the headlines this week is that ARC
- 1:05:59Invest, headed by Kathy Woods, is technically frontline and has
- 1:06:05refiled to be very similar to BlackRock.
- 1:06:11Yeah, you know, maybe maybe ARC gets approved 1st and then
- 1:06:16BlackRock a few weeks later and BlackRock Day 2 has surpassed
- 1:06:21ARC and AUM. Yeah, obviously a better
- 1:06:26distribution. I don't know.
- 1:06:27I'm going to be controlling here.
- 1:06:29I don't think it's approved. Everybody, everybody again,
- 1:06:32pattern recognition and Bitcoin, everybody thought the ETF was
- 1:06:37going to get approved in 2020. What do you think the.
- 1:06:39Motive is for that, Marty. Like, do you think the SEC is
- 1:06:43trying to stop it for a particular reason or do you
- 1:06:47think that they have like legitimate justification for
- 1:06:51wanting a better version of an ETF?
- 1:06:54I mean, the way Townsend from Coin Shares explained it to me
- 1:06:59and it used to be like a securities lawyer here in the US
- 1:07:01was that you're really worried about price manipulation and not
- 1:07:07particularly at Coinbase, but like other offshore exchanges
- 1:07:10manipulating the price, which I think we do have some examples
- 1:07:15of that in recent history like FTX, you could argue that they
- 1:07:18actually manipulated the price lower than otherwise would have
- 1:07:21gone because they were just dumping.
- 1:07:23People's bitcoins on the market and I don't think the way towns
- 1:07:29and I'm not a securities lawyer, I don't know, frankly don't care
- 1:07:32whether it does or doesn't like. The signal in and of itself is
- 1:07:37big enough for my opinion. The signal is that black rocks
- 1:07:41customers have been demanding Bitcoin so much that they were
- 1:07:43forced to bend the knee and file for the CTF.
- 1:07:47I don't think they came to the decision to file a Bitcoin ETF
- 1:07:50by themselves. I think their hands were forced.
- 1:07:53My clients were saying give this to us, you're going to take our
- 1:07:55business somewhere else. But going back to the price
- 1:08:00manipulation, like even if Coinbase does really good
- 1:08:04custody, they run a good shop that doesn't manipulate price,
- 1:08:09which looking like the history, like B cash and like coin and
- 1:08:12stuff like that. Like who knows if you can
- 1:08:15actually say that with any degree of certainty.
- 1:08:19Even if they had that surveillance sharing agreement
- 1:08:21with NASDAQ the way Townsend framed it to me, I believe I was
- 1:08:25understanding them correctly is they don't have any assurances
- 1:08:28with offshore shops manipulating the price.
- 1:08:32And even if you have your buttons buttoned up between
- 1:08:35Queen Base and NASDAQ doesn't doesn't matter to them.
- 1:08:38Marty, what happened? You're Marty Jones.
- 1:08:40You're you're thinking in the lens of the world being logical.
- 1:08:43Like Townsend came at it from a logical fair playing game.
- 1:08:46Like this is BlackRock, this is the US government.
- 1:08:48Like, they're gonna just slap there's they're they're gonna
- 1:08:52slap everybody around. They're gonna slap Kathy Wood
- 1:08:54and arc and say, hey, yeah, you were first.
- 1:08:56Whatever. You play by the rules.
- 1:08:57This is our ETF. Like there.
- 1:08:59It's a it's a humiliation ritual.
- 1:09:01Like they're gonna, they're gonna get it.
- 1:09:03It's gonna go to BlackRock. What he referenced it's like.
- 1:09:06It doesn't even actually make sense because it's even
- 1:09:09inconsistent like they did the futures ETF already and it's a
- 1:09:12global like traded asset. The it's already trading like
- 1:09:17the price manipulation has always been just their version
- 1:09:19of. Hiding behind getting the ETF
- 1:09:22actually launched it wasn't actually real like we know that
- 1:09:25it's a free trade asset. They're gonna do like you know
- 1:09:29the USD, USD to BTC pair with like Coinbase.
- 1:09:33They're gonna have an isolated so they can show it and they're
- 1:09:35gonna make up all these reasons when reality they could have
- 1:09:37done it three years ago like I get what towns it was coming
- 1:09:40from and in a free like fair you know whatever world that that
- 1:09:43all makes sense but that's not what we're living in and so.
- 1:09:46Yeah, they're just gonna, I agree, just gonna.
- 1:09:49I was trying to play the contrarian on the panel, but I
- 1:09:52agree. I mean black rocks gonna get the
- 1:09:54red carpet rolled out. Probably the question, the
- 1:09:57better question, I'm curious is what is going on, like what is
- 1:10:01going on with them launching it, Larry Fink coming about about
- 1:10:03it, playing in gold, that's like what I'm curious about.
- 1:10:06Well, that's that's a good segue into the newsletter you wrote
- 1:10:09over the weekend, Jesse. Like we had pretty big spasms in
- 1:10:13bond markets today. Like maybe it's a signal that
- 1:10:16they're like a. Things are not all well in the
- 1:10:20markets that we've been playing. In yeah, it's funny timing that
- 1:10:26today the UK gilt market had a steep bond sell off and this
- 1:10:34last weekend and I put together a piece the the bondholders
- 1:10:40burning platform and and tried to lay out in simple terms why
- 1:10:43the math is really not on the side of.
- 1:10:46Bond holders over the coming decades, and it's a pretty
- 1:10:50simple argument. Ultimately, it's that you know
- 1:10:53the amount of debt in the system at the sovereign level at every
- 1:10:57level necessitates that we're going to print a lot of money in
- 1:11:03order to inflate away the debt. Because you you, you know if you
- 1:11:082X the money supply, you let inflation run hot such that.
- 1:11:14The dollar today is worth half as much in the future.
- 1:11:18Suddenly your your nominal national debt burden is 2 times
- 1:11:22easier to pay off because GDP adjusts upwards and and becomes
- 1:11:29easier service at that. But the bondholders are left
- 1:11:33with the bill and so it's it's a way to to get out from under the
- 1:11:39debt burdens that the US and every.
- 1:11:44G7 Nation has at this point, you have to print a bunch of money
- 1:11:49and then confiscate wealth from the bondholders in doing so.
- 1:11:55Like, that's that's the math. That's the path forward is to
- 1:11:59cause the $32 trillion of U.S. National debt that is held by
- 1:12:05individuals and institutions and you know whether or not you even
- 1:12:09know it because. People have in their pensions or
- 1:12:13in their four O1 KS. You know the standard 4O1K is
- 1:12:16the 6040 portfolio. 40% of that is bonds.
- 1:12:20A lot of that is U.S. Treasuries, and the math says
- 1:12:24that that has to be devalued. You have to to earn a negative
- 1:12:28real return on that portion of your portfolio in order for the
- 1:12:33US to to get out from under its national debt burden.
- 1:12:40Without defaulting. Without hard defaulting.
- 1:12:42So at this point, we've kind of crossed the Rubicon and we have
- 1:12:45to default in one way. There's soft default.
- 1:12:47Print a bunch of money. There's hard default.
- 1:12:49Just say you're not going to pay people back.
- 1:12:52And we have a printing press. So of course we're going to soft
- 1:12:56default and print as much money as we need to nominally service
- 1:12:59our debts. That's the that's the
- 1:13:02circumstances, that's what we're looking at.
- 1:13:05And that means that over the next decade or two.
- 1:13:10Bonds will deliver negative real returns for their holders and
- 1:13:15then you know today we have a massive sell off of of UK
- 1:13:21sovereign debt, meaning that people who are holding these
- 1:13:27bonds are realizing I don't want to be holding this because I'm
- 1:13:30going to end up getting a negative real return.
- 1:13:32So get this out of My Portfolio. Let's sell it and and reallocate
- 1:13:38to a different asset, of course. My view is that people will
- 1:13:43learn over each successive having Bitcoin.
- 1:13:46Having that Bitcoin fulfills the function that bonds are supposed
- 1:13:50to provide to your portfolio at this point in time going
- 1:13:53forward, that reliable return over time, in Bitcoin's case,
- 1:14:00delivered by increasing scarcity with the havings causing value
- 1:14:04appreciation over time. Rather than the nominal promises
- 1:14:07of yield that bonds offer, but then can't deliver in real terms
- 1:14:12given the amount of national debt that that we all that we
- 1:14:16face and every G7 country faces at this point.
- 1:14:21The counter that just to play the devil's advocate, it's like,
- 1:14:24hasn't it been the past 5-10 years like bonds have had
- 1:14:28negative real returns? Like the common thought is like,
- 1:14:32yeah, So what, What is that? Like, how is that?
- 1:14:33Is it at the margins that we're going to get the like grandma
- 1:14:37and the family offices to start or like how does that work?
- 1:14:40Because I think that's what everybody's waiting for, right,
- 1:14:42The like. Yeah, well, it's already, it's
- 1:14:44already in process like it the the platform is burning a little
- 1:14:49bit right now and it's up to bondholders to realize that the
- 1:14:53the platform they've placed their value on is is on fire and
- 1:14:57it's made of wood. Since micro Strategy has Michael
- 1:15:03Saylor has been keeping track of this and and proudly proclaiming
- 1:15:07how micro strategy adopting the Bitcoin standard has has done
- 1:15:13very well for them in comparison to the risk free asset of U.S.
- 1:15:17Treasuries. So since Micro strategy adopted
- 1:15:20that in gosh was that was 2020. The bonds are down 19%.
- 1:15:26So you if you were to store your value since 2020 in bonds you
- 1:15:30lost 19% of your purchasing power, whereas Bitcoin is is up
- 1:15:35like 160% or whatever and more I'm not actually sure.
- 1:15:42So there's there's your it's already in process and we we
- 1:15:45talked with dines about 25% down since 2021.
- 1:15:52I'm not sure exactly which. Point in time or what type of
- 1:15:55bonds he was referring to. But this wealth destruction,
- 1:15:58this wealth confiscation is already happening It what's
- 1:16:01what's wild about it is that for this to work, policymakers have
- 1:16:09to convince the bond market that high inflation will not continue
- 1:16:14because they need somebody holding the bonds to confiscate
- 1:16:18wealth from. So you know you really can't
- 1:16:21trust. What you're being told by the
- 1:16:24Fed when it comes to to inflation because they need
- 1:16:28somebody to get stuck with the bill.
- 1:16:32You hear that, Alex, You're 30% personal account allocation to
- 1:16:37bonds is is on fire, is that what you're well?
- 1:16:42No, I think this is actually, I mean, Jesse and Michael,
- 1:16:45obviously you guys are talking to a lot of people.
- 1:16:49We're curious about Bitcoin, but Alex, I know that's a point that
- 1:16:52you make at River too, if they actually speak with your
- 1:16:54customers, really new customers. Like are you seeing any growing
- 1:16:58trends and common themes that is turning people on to Bitcoin?
- 1:17:05Yeah, I mean, so we're seeing record transacting users month
- 1:17:10over month for a while now. You know, I think it's really
- 1:17:17mixed I think. I I think all these factors are
- 1:17:23basically pushing the crowds slow like more quickly and
- 1:17:27quickly into Bitcoin. But the way that like everyone
- 1:17:31perceives it is maybe from a different perspective every
- 1:17:34every individual in that crowd as as to the why they're doing
- 1:17:37what they're doing. For some of it's it's inflation.
- 1:17:41For some of it they've gone down the rabbit hole and they they
- 1:17:44they've like really sort of understood the theory.
- 1:17:46A lot of people frankly, their friends like you know, I
- 1:17:49actually think like the the majority of people are convinced
- 1:17:54by a minority of people, right. Guys like you guys, you know
- 1:17:58you're you're spreading the message or getting the word out
- 1:18:00there. People listen to your show and
- 1:18:04and those people then tell their friends and it gets people going
- 1:18:08further and further down the rabbit hole.
- 1:18:09So I think it and then I think lastly I think.
- 1:18:16It's a it's it's the decline of institutional trust in the
- 1:18:19United States. You know, before, if you trusted
- 1:18:24the US government, you trusted the US dollar.
- 1:18:27Fewer and fewer people trust the government.
- 1:18:29And I think that's also at a like unlocked a lot of people's
- 1:18:34minds and given them permission to actually look at this thing.
- 1:18:41Yeah, it's a very. A very good point.
- 1:18:44It seems very obvious, but something I never connected like
- 1:18:47the collapsing confidence in the US government particularly
- 1:18:53should lead to a collapsing confidence in the dollar.
- 1:18:56Yeah, I mean, if it's because like, you know, you know, I
- 1:18:59mean, when I was in, when I was in undergrad in college, I was
- 1:19:02really into this monetary stuff. I graduated undergrad in 2012
- 1:19:05and you know, I was talking to my parents and like, I would
- 1:19:08talk to other people about central banking and.
- 1:19:11You know why it's bad. And you know, most people just
- 1:19:14kind of like thought it was kooky, right?
- 1:19:16Like and but now when you talk to people about it, you get it's
- 1:19:21different. Like you're allowed to talk
- 1:19:24about that stuff now without looking like a nutty professor.
- 1:19:29Like Ron Paul was right about a lot of things he said.
- 1:19:33But like the mainstream saw him as like sort of this kooky
- 1:19:36quirky like Professor Guy and now.
- 1:19:41If you ask a lot of people now, you know, like do they have the
- 1:19:44opinions he had? They're they're kind of, yeah,
- 1:19:46you know, we shouldn't have been in Iraq, right?
- 1:19:48We should be watching out for central banking.
- 1:19:51Like that's a these are mainstream conversations to have
- 1:19:55now, not just sort of fringe or libertarian weirdos.
- 1:20:00So I think that's all a result of people realizing the US
- 1:20:03government is an absolute mess. Our institutions have been
- 1:20:05coopted by people who don't share our American values and.
- 1:20:11It's leading people down this path.
- 1:20:14Yeah, the I think it incredible anecdote I came across recently
- 1:20:19was that we had this debt ceiling fight a month ago and it
- 1:20:25was, you know, they both sides pretended to fight over whether
- 1:20:29or not we would allow more debt and of course ended up rubber
- 1:20:33stamping it. And and that was one month ago
- 1:20:35we went, we raised the debt ceiling from 31.4 trillion a
- 1:20:39month ago. And we have now added almost a
- 1:20:43trillion dollars of national debt in one month and that is
- 1:20:48the same amount roughly as all of the fighting about bank
- 1:20:53bailouts in in 2008. That was the scale of of what
- 1:20:56those bailouts were and we've just added that to the national
- 1:21:00debt in one month and and nobody made a peep.
- 1:21:03That's how much things have progressed since 2008 in terms
- 1:21:07of the the erosion of. Of fiscal responsibility and and
- 1:21:13trust comes from that. Yeah, Marty, your tweet, your
- 1:21:17tweet from the weekend, so I just thought I was talking to
- 1:21:19Jesse about it. I think today or yesterday is
- 1:21:21like 150 billion I think has been funneled to Ukraine from
- 1:21:25the government the past two years and they're like the 4.5
- 1:21:28billion. I think that was paying off some
- 1:21:30of their debt that's owned by BlackRock.
- 1:21:32Like it's it's literally insane if you just look at it, it's
- 1:21:35just it's all out there. Yeah, it's lazing.
- 1:21:38Corrupt. It's oh nice.
- 1:21:42It really is brazing corruption. That's like.
- 1:21:46But that's power, right? So that, like, that's true
- 1:21:48power, right? You know, the people in charge
- 1:21:52have true power that they can just do this in front of you and
- 1:21:57nothing happens to them, so. Yeah, Hunter Body can do cocaine
- 1:22:03on the White House balcony on the 4th of July.
- 1:22:07Found any clear retribution because they have true power.
- 1:22:12Yeah. It's so I'm, I'm short.
- 1:22:16I'm, I'm, I'm long American values.
- 1:22:19I'm short United States federal government institutions.
- 1:22:24Same, yeah. And that's and bringing like
- 1:22:26tying it back. I think that's one thing we have
- 1:22:28to recognize too. We touched on it earlier, but
- 1:22:30like the. Beauty of When Satoshi launched
- 1:22:34Bitcoin, obviously in the wake of the great financial crisis,
- 1:22:37you had Ron Paul really drumming up some support, but not quite
- 1:22:42enough in during that election. And then at the same time you
- 1:22:46have like the bubbling and the emergence of the social media
- 1:22:49wave which has played a big part in propagating Ron Paul's
- 1:22:53message and message to Bitcoin on top of that.
- 1:22:55So you have like all these factors, Toshi.
- 1:22:58The great financial crisis, Ron Paul exceeding some ideas and
- 1:23:02the people in our generation. I was 17 at the time and really
- 1:23:06connected with me. And then we have social media.
- 1:23:08We go on, we mean into those ideas, discover Bitcoin, like,
- 1:23:12hey, this is a perfect implementation of these ideas
- 1:23:15that they can't corrupt and we don't have to ask permission.
- 1:23:18Then we're able to go on social media, begin propagating the
- 1:23:21message. It really is like a crazy
- 1:23:24serendipitous coalition of events that happen.
- 1:23:28When I when I was first raising investment money for forever,
- 1:23:32people would ask me who's your biggest competitor?
- 1:23:35And I would tongue in cheek but also like kind of half meaning
- 1:23:39it, say the Federal Reserve and and you know, as this goes on,
- 1:23:47like it's almost like like meming this is getting us closer
- 1:23:51to the reality of it. I feel like this is going to be
- 1:23:54one of those like Trump moments where like it's a meme.
- 1:23:57That he's going to be president. It's like a it's like this like
- 1:24:00kind of meme. We joke about like bitcoin's
- 1:24:03going to like take out the Federal Reserve and we it's
- 1:24:07still kind of a meme. Like we still kind of are meming
- 1:24:10it, but also like someday it happens and we're like, holy
- 1:24:14shit, I can't believe that it's happened.
- 1:24:18Yeah, yeah. I do think it's incredible that
- 1:24:20for most people they will experience Bitcoin.
- 1:24:25As something that that that was just a joke that turned out to
- 1:24:29be real. Like like a joke that everybody
- 1:24:32decided was real, that it was always a joke and just became
- 1:24:35real. You know, like for most people
- 1:24:38they will not put two and two together, that Bitcoin was real
- 1:24:40the whole time and not a joke the whole time.
- 1:24:43But we'll, you know, we're living in this weird breakdown
- 1:24:47of reality where Elon is meming all sorts of stuff.
- 1:24:53And you know, the Internet is crazy and meme stocks take off
- 1:24:56and we're going to end up with meme money and people.
- 1:24:59And most people will just be like, I guess this is what's
- 1:25:02happening. But if you, if you actually look
- 1:25:06at the evidence and dig into it, now you can frontrun those
- 1:25:09people because you understand it's not a joke, it's it's real.
- 1:25:13Yeah, and I mean, well, that's the thing too.
- 1:25:16Memes aren't jokes. They're they're truths that are
- 1:25:20distilled into. Very like like a JPEG, like a
- 1:25:26like a digestible form of information.
- 1:25:29Logan, pull up, don't play the video but just pull up the
- 1:25:32YouTube. So anybody watching this and
- 1:25:34link to this in the show, that's after.
- 1:25:36I think honestly this is one of the most important speeches ever
- 1:25:39giving at a Bitcoin conference. It's Michael Goldstein's The Art
- 1:25:43of Bitcoin Rhetoric, how to mean Bitcoin to the moon and it is so
- 1:25:49incredibly well done. Start a lot of controversy when
- 1:25:53when he when he first when it first got released in 2019.
- 1:25:57But if you dig into it like the memes around Bitcoin number go
- 1:26:00up. That three three word meme
- 1:26:04basically highlights the bitcoins extremely scarce.
- 1:26:07More people are going to want it.
- 1:26:08So number's going to go up. Like fix the money, Fix the
- 1:26:11world is another one. Stay humble.
- 1:26:12Stack sets like the memes are are riddled with truth at the
- 1:26:17end of the truth embedded in and once.
- 1:26:20They're common sense, yes. Yeah, they they become the the
- 1:26:26way that you can most effectively transmit common
- 1:26:29sense wisdom to the maximum number of people.
- 1:26:33Stay humble. Stack Sats is is penny saved,
- 1:26:38Penny earned for a new generation, a new, a new digital
- 1:26:42landscape. And we're part of creating that
- 1:26:46new. Pantheon of common sense
- 1:26:51witticisms. It's so much less absurd than,
- 1:26:55you know, this concept of a dollar is a dollar that the
- 1:26:59government owes you. Like, yeah.
- 1:27:03The Mental gymnastics of What Do You?
- 1:27:05Mean you don't understand it like well you need.
- 1:27:07To go. Get a degree to understand this.
- 1:27:09It's this is the way money should be.
- 1:27:11It's like. What do you mean my money's not
- 1:27:14in the bank? Ohh, you don't know.
- 1:27:18You don't know that we lend it out great new units we only
- 1:27:21actually have. We're required to have 0% of the
- 1:27:23money that we are taking in and reserves at any given point in
- 1:27:26time. Yeah, let's see like we've
- 1:27:31harped on this on this show, many other shows, but again,
- 1:27:35cannot be overstated like the simplicity of Bitcoin from a
- 1:27:41network perspective, from an asset perspective.
- 1:27:45It is incredibly beautiful because we will be able to build
- 1:27:47a complex world just by anchoring into the simplicity of
- 1:27:50the network. Like having that stability of
- 1:27:53its simplicity, its transparency, its tangibility in
- 1:27:57the sense that you can see what's going on at any given
- 1:28:00point in time, you can verify what's going on at a given point
- 1:28:03in time, is extremely powerful, That simple anchoring function
- 1:28:08that Bitcoin will play in society.
- 1:28:11Yeah, I mean, Alex touched on it earlier.
- 1:28:13You know, bitcoin's a great defund financialization.
- 1:28:15It's like the fact that your money just does what it's
- 1:28:17supposed to. Then you don't have to do all
- 1:28:19the other things that everybody's been on this hamster
- 1:28:21wheel and you get to do what God gave you, like as a, you know,
- 1:28:24individual on this earth to, like, go and flourish and
- 1:28:27innovate. And we've been stuck in this
- 1:28:29kind of like perpetual just, you know, tinkering and all the best
- 1:28:32people focus on these apps and all this weird crap when there's
- 1:28:36so many other things that we can be doing and, you know,
- 1:28:38basically innovating as a society.
- 1:28:41And so I think that there's like, you know, I think
- 1:28:43personally, but I think probably every this group is like part of
- 1:28:45the goal or attainment of what we're working towards.
- 1:28:48It's like that end version at Bailey.
- 1:28:50David Bailey says really well, like the party starts when the
- 1:28:52dollar ends. It's like when we're all like
- 1:28:55have that unit, that's when the fun actually begins.
- 1:28:58And until then everybody's just trying to figure out get mean
- 1:29:00and psyop to to figure it out. You mean you guys don't want a
- 1:29:04world where your grandma has to own?
- 1:29:09You know, dozens of different companies securitized and also
- 1:29:14all of their debt securitized so that she can feed herself when
- 1:29:17she's older. CEO's, Cdo's, Derivatives
- 1:29:24leverage. The way it should work, Grandma,
- 1:29:27Grandma needs to throw her no. When it comes to the
- 1:29:30financialization of the world, just suck it up.
- 1:29:35Talk to her financial advisor. Get a.
- 1:29:37Get a nice allocation trying to eat and.
- 1:29:42You'll be able to eat when you're old.
- 1:29:44Then give some more of your money to the government, and
- 1:29:46then they'll give that money to Larry Fink too.
- 1:29:49That's great. I was just thinking like Jesse
- 1:29:51just pulled, this was just pulled up.
- 1:29:53Think about all the financial advisors and wealth managers
- 1:29:56that could build that cathedral physically if we just got, if
- 1:29:59there was just Bitcoin, you don't need one percent, 2%
- 1:30:02paying somebody every year to look at your money.
- 1:30:05Yeah I I saw this come. I saw this at Logan.
- 1:30:07If you put up I I saw this come up yesterday of like it's a
- 1:30:11beautiful quote that it was not in Bitcoin world.
- 1:30:14But it came across as modern man is is in a terrible predicament.
- 1:30:18He is helplessly enamored with the beauty of what the old world
- 1:30:21built yet despises the beliefs that inspired them to build it.
- 1:30:26And I think it's such a it's so close to what I would say is you
- 1:30:31know the sound money and the. Deflationary engine of
- 1:30:37craftsmanship is what built so much of the stuff in the world
- 1:30:41that we, you know, hold on a pedestal and Bitcoin returns
- 1:30:46those mechanics to the world and is how we're going to build a
- 1:30:51better world going forward. People know deep down inside
- 1:30:55what's real and what's true and they've been.
- 1:30:59You have to be taught to not listen to that and.
- 1:31:05I think we're seeing a trend. More and more people are
- 1:31:07listening to what like what's there, but we have a long way to
- 1:31:12go. Yes.
- 1:31:14And that's actually a good segue until the last question I want
- 1:31:17to ask you, Alex, before you wrap up here.
- 1:31:19Somebody's building a company in the space and touching the
- 1:31:25Bitcoin technological stack at the protocol level at Lightning
- 1:31:30in the mining industry. Like what are you most excited?
- 1:31:34To build on the horizon or what's what's what's exciting
- 1:31:37you in the Bitcoin space right now that you can apply to River?
- 1:31:41So the two things technologically that are most
- 1:31:44exciting me are Lightning. I really think sort of we're
- 1:31:48getting to an inflection point and the and the the tech is
- 1:31:51getting there where Lightning truly is going to unlock a whole
- 1:31:58another order of magnitude of international value transfer.
- 1:32:01Because we've removed the delays for payments and the UX, it's a
- 1:32:0710X UX experience for transferring value with Bitcoin
- 1:32:10now and we're working on a lot of stuff there and the
- 1:32:15infrastructure has matured to the point where we're starting
- 1:32:18to be able to get real money, real flows happening with this.
- 1:32:24I'm also very excited about cryptographic advancements.
- 1:32:27There's a lot of investment left.
- 1:32:29I'm thinking about what we might be investing in at River, but
- 1:32:32deep crypto, deep deep crypto investments.
- 1:32:36And by crypto, I mean cryptography.
- 1:32:39I think there's a big opportunity with Frost and in in
- 1:32:44creating Schnorr specific multiparty computation, which I
- 1:32:48think can be a lot more elegant than some of the stuff we've
- 1:32:50seen with ECDSA because of how messy ECDSA is.
- 1:32:53And I think we can. I think there's a world where
- 1:32:58sort of, yeah, I kind of see MPC as as maybe sort of multisig
- 1:33:022.0. It's going to be a little bit
- 1:33:03more complex. There's still going to be
- 1:33:05reasons to use multisig, but this concept of like having a
- 1:33:09single singular wallet, root wallet key split up into shares
- 1:33:13that can be refreshed, rotated, signers moved in and out, I
- 1:33:18think it's really interesting and I want to see Bitcoin
- 1:33:21specific. Versions of this for Schnorr,
- 1:33:25the mature implementations built out, and I have a lot of
- 1:33:28interesting product ideas and thoughts and what kind of things
- 1:33:31that can unlock. So those are two things I'm
- 1:33:34really excited about. Jesse and Michael, anything you
- 1:33:42wanna add before we head into the weekend here?
- 1:33:46You know what, as as Alex was talking there, I was, I was
- 1:33:50thinking about how it really is a testament to the choices you
- 1:33:53made early on and sticking with them that you had the foresight
- 1:33:56to like own your infrastructure and and not, you know, get into
- 1:34:04any situations where you were, you were trusting A custodian
- 1:34:08that wasn't quite up for, you know, the the job.
- 1:34:13And I think that what you're talking about right now and the
- 1:34:16excitement to build out the feature set is such a perfect
- 1:34:20microcosm of how Bitcoin wins. It's through these, through, you
- 1:34:24know, the cumulative efforts of adding valuable features and
- 1:34:30doing it in a, you know, you're building a cathedral, and
- 1:34:33Bitcoin is about building a cathedral and doing it the right
- 1:34:37way. And and yeah, I admire it.
- 1:34:40Thank you. I'm really excited about what
- 1:34:42you guys are doing. Thank you.
- 1:34:46Us too. Yeah, removing central points of
- 1:34:51trust. The more we do that, the better.
- 1:34:55Yeah. And I think just to echo Jesse's
- 1:34:57sentiment, really appreciate you joining Alex.
- 1:35:00Really admire what you guys have built.
- 1:35:01And I think the one thing we didn't focus on, but it's a big
- 1:35:04part of what you guys do in every like business that will
- 1:35:06truly be successful over the next decade is on the education
- 1:35:08and providing you know people are coming to financial.
- 1:35:12You know service, I know you're not calling river financial
- 1:35:14service business, but a partner, a trusted brand, they're looking
- 1:35:18for guidance in this new world. And so part of that is like it's
- 1:35:22the responsibility of that individual and that firm to
- 1:35:25provide their clients with the right guidance because that's
- 1:35:28going to translate to them telling their family and friends
- 1:35:30and that's how these businesses are built by propagating that.
- 1:35:33And so you guys have done a great job of that and and that's
- 1:35:36a big part of all this because of what we talked about early in
- 1:35:39the podcast that. If you you can win early, but
- 1:35:43you can't win long if you don't actually send the right message
- 1:35:46on education and educating the end client.
- 1:35:48So that's a big part of like you can have the right product and
- 1:35:51you also need to have the right education and like motion to to
- 1:35:54go to market and you guys have done both.
- 1:35:56So it's been cool to see. Thank you.
- 1:35:58Yeah, we're investing heavily in that.
- 1:36:00We're we're trying to put out some really indepth research
- 1:36:02reports. We just put out A1A few a few
- 1:36:06few weeks ago on a 60 page research report on Bitcoin and
- 1:36:08international payments. So check that out if you want to
- 1:36:12go deep. Yep, Marty has a pod on it.
- 1:36:15If you, if you if you're not a reader.
- 1:36:17I I thought there was, there was some very interesting data
- 1:36:19points discussed in that pod. They're really interesting.
- 1:36:23You know, with the research analysts at River Sam Booters,
- 1:36:27you dove into it on TFTC. So if you guys want to go over
- 1:36:30to that podcast and check it out, it's great conversation.
- 1:36:34I mean, you've got some killers on your team, Sam being one of
- 1:36:37them. Oh yeah, he's awesome.
- 1:36:40And and my old my old classmate from Stanford, Julia.
- 1:36:43Shout out Julia. Yeah, Julia's a pillar of river
- 1:36:50by my right hand. Woman COO.
- 1:36:54She she she has been an instrumental in river success.
- 1:37:02So you have good friends, Jesse. Julia's very talent.
- 1:37:09All right, gentlemen, that was an incredible conversation.
- 1:37:12Alex, thank you again for joining us.
- 1:37:14We will have to link up in person.
- 1:37:15Since I'm on the East Coast right now.
- 1:37:17At some point in the next few weeks, I'll make sure to make
- 1:37:20that happen. We should.
- 1:37:22Everybody going, everybody go, enjoy your weekend.
- 1:37:26Things are heavy out there. People are losing faith in
- 1:37:29institutions, but we have Bitcoin.
- 1:37:31We have this this giant thing that we can anchor into.
- 1:37:34We hope that conversations like this.
- 1:37:37Give you some more clarity around this credible rounding
- 1:37:41force that we have at Bitcoin. So that is all for this week,
- 1:37:44episode 7. We'll see you guys next week for
- 1:37:47episode eight Faces.