Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #58 🎙️ | Public Inquiry - Commonwealth Mining Feasibility Guidelines Week Beginning 12th May 2026 | Day 2
Transcript
- 0:04Hello again. The panic is always on every evening as I sit down
- 0:08to write about the day's proceedings. What will I write
- 0:12about this now I know I have a copy book full of notes, and I
- 0:16only have one job to do, and that is to tell the story of the
- 0:21day's events. I never really have a plan, or indeed, know
- 0:25what is going to come out of my fingertips as they chop away on
- 0:29the keyboard, and even as I type this, watching the words appear
- 0:34like magic. It always seems like a kind of miracle. On the days
- 0:39when I'm really tired, it's much harder. The words and ideas do
- 0:43not flow so far. Luckily, I haven't been yet stuck for
- 0:47words, writing in a way that informs without boring people to
- 0:52death, becomes even more challenging when complex legal
- 0:55and technical issues also need to be explained. I keep hoping I
- 1:00get a little bit quicker at it. For the writing is the slowest
- 1:04part of the podcast. Once I begin, it's like a stream of
- 1:07consciousness. And before I know it, two or three hours have gone
- 1:11by, and lo and behold, suddenly, there are three or four pages of
- 1:15content ready to record. I tried to keep these episodes about the
- 1:22public inquiry to under 10 minutes, making them
- 1:26sustainable, both for you, the listener and for me the writer,
- 1:31whilst at the same time avoiding writing like I'm recording
- 1:35minutes at some board meeting. Have to say it's hard to make
- 1:40exciting at times. It's not exactly a rip roaring yarn.
- 1:45Anyways, off we go. The first business of the day was
- 1:51conversation around the possibility of attendance at the
- 1:53public inquiry by some of the expert witnesses. Their
- 1:58attendance has been severely compromised by the constant
- 2:01timetable changes, which was aptly described by one of our
- 2:06expert witnesses as a Moveable Feast. Once again, various
- 2:11parties promised to up to date the commission after lunch as to
- 2:15whether their experts could attend. We will wait and see we
- 2:20return then to the submission of documents. Mr. Alvin, counsel
- 2:23for dfi, said that Commonwealth model mining feasibility study
- 2:28guideline, cfsg, that we spoke about in yesterday's podcast,
- 2:34was non binding guidance that had been adapted by the
- 2:38executive and that was therefore not a material consideration.
- 2:45This phrase, I might add, material consideration has been
- 2:49appearing more and more during the discussions over the last
- 2:52few days. I could pretend I know all about it, but I won't, so I
- 2:57looked it up and perhaps also saved you the trouble. This is
- 3:02what Google says in UK, planning law, a material consideration is
- 3:07any factor that a local planning authority is legally allowed to
- 3:11take into account when deciding a planning action. So returning
- 3:17to our Mr. Alvin, this is an interesting stance from one who
- 3:22is representing a government department that purports the
- 3:25Commonwealth led government guidelines cfsg are not relevant
- 3:31to an inquiry where questions are being raised about the
- 3:34absence of a feasibility study. I'm still scratching my head
- 3:37about this one. To quote one of the third party folk, not sure
- 3:44if the king would be too happy that his guidelines be ignored
- 3:48given his eco credentials. Needless to say, Mr. Beatty,
- 3:54counsel for dalradian, was, unsurprisingly, in full
- 3:57agreement with Mr. Elvin stance. Funny that as del radian have
- 4:02been presenting themselves in the marketing blurb as an
- 4:05example of best practice mining for the last god knows how long
- 4:10one would imagine they would be jumping at the opportunity to
- 4:13adopt this best practice framework. And it was long story
- 4:18short, the Commission agreed to accept the cfsg Despite the
- 4:23rejection of it by the applicants and DFI the second
- 4:28document proposed by third parties is about guidance
- 4:31principles for social impact assessment. To backtrack a
- 4:35little if you've been listening to this podcast for the last
- 4:39while, you may have heard me talking just the odd time about
- 4:42the lack of a feasibility study. Well, surprise, surprise, guess
- 4:47what else is missing or has not been done, or at least we, the
- 4:51third parties, have not seen one, and that is a social impact
- 4:55study by the applicant for the planning application. The DFI
- 5:00answer to the query, if they had any objections to it been
- 5:04included that they would leave that up to the commission to
- 5:07decide. Mary Brawley remarked that dfis response, re it stands
- 5:14for neutrality, was somewhat tiresome, and asked the DFI to
- 5:17try to make a decision for themselves, the commission made
- 5:23a request that the third parties provide a copy by Friday
- 5:26afternoon. Eventually we got to tourism, Orbison council for
- 5:33Northern Ireland electricity network, the company providing
- 5:36the power lines for the mine, waffled on about some desk
- 5:40research where he was basically trying to prove that was no
- 5:44evidence of any significant use of tourism assets or related
- 5:47spend, or indeed any significant reduction as a result of either
- 5:51of the two elements. Conor Fagan, counsel for fodc,
- 5:56described the report as a parasitic report that in that
- 6:00all other reports say no effect, ergo, no impact on tourism.
- 6:06There was then a succession of speakers from the community
- 6:09speaking about tourism accommodation providers such as
- 6:13Michael Keenan and Peggy McGurk sent in a letter to be read out
- 6:17about the miles cottage. Sean Warnock spoke about the local
- 6:21football club and how young people were coming back to the
- 6:24area from abroad and that there was full employment in the area.
- 6:29Emma McAleer said the proposed gold mine would industrialise
- 6:33the sparing landscape, threaten tourism, undermine the area's
- 6:37identity as a place of nature, heritage and outdoor recreation.
- 6:43She argued that regenerative and community led tourism plans for
- 6:47the region are incompatible with large industrial mines, and
- 6:51warned it could deter future funding and investment in
- 6:55tourism heritage and environmental projects. She
- 6:58urged government departments to fully scrutinise the application
- 7:02before making a decision that will affect local communities
- 7:06for generations. Other speakers from the community included
- 7:11Kevin McAleer, Mark Turney, who spoke on behalf of Ulster
- 7:15angling Federation about how angling was a sustainable
- 7:19industry and that the risk of mining to river quality was well
- 7:23documented across the world, and how the foil system was a jewel
- 7:26in the crown for the fishermen from as far away as Canada, that
- 7:30fishing brings in 2 million a year to local communities, and
- 7:33778 jobs are associated with the fishing. I suppose what will
- 7:39stay with me from this conversation about tourism, is a
- 7:42comment from one of the third parties, which was, tourism
- 7:45invests in people, places and communities here at home, mining
- 7:49extracts wealth and exports it elsewhere. The rest of the
- 7:54afternoon was mainly focused on planning conditions, which means
- 7:59what may be needed in the event of an approval of the planning
- 8:02application. This was neatly summed up by Billy Donnelly, 30
- 8:06year campaigner against the Kavanagh call mine, just outside
- 8:09OMA he said, in his experience that planning conditions are
- 8:14reinterpreted, ignored, exploited, circumvented, and
- 8:19gradually eroded over time, rendering them meaningless. They
- 8:23are not worth the paper they are written on and on that note I
- 8:28leave you.