Latest / Cyber Crime Podcast / FBI PROFILER DISCUSSES AI , TECHNOLOGY AND CRIME
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to the Cybercrime Podcast, where we discuss the issues, trends, and
- 0:12cases of past and present cyber crimes. Let's get started. We actually got
- 0:26our first sponsor that we've actually accepted a deal, and I'm very excited to
- 0:29announce the new partnership and it's with Titan Nutrition. So a lot of you
- 0:34working out, a lot of you would lift weights, resistance training, aerobic
- 0:38training, whatever it may be. So I highly recommend that you use some
- 0:42supplements for sure to be able to help you with your workouts, to get
- 0:45you stronger, to be able to last longer. Creatine as a given.
- 0:47Protein powers are great because it's a great way to try to get your protein
- 0:50and take up a lot of times we don't have enough protein in our diet
- 0:54and that could be a big problem. So I encourage you to go check
- 0:58out Titan Nutrition Net Titan t I t I N nutrition dot net. Their
- 1:03evidence base which I love a lot. They look at the research to see
- 1:07what power, what products work, and which ones don't work. And by
- 1:10the way, you can also get ten percent off if you use the discount
- 1:12code Doctor Carlos at the checkout and free shipping too, So if you use
- 1:19creatine, if you use protein, powders, branch chain of Meino's, whatever
- 1:23it may be. All those can be helpful and we'll talk about those as
- 1:26well. Another podcast. You can catch my other podcast, the Muscle Gain
- 1:30and Fat Loss podcast. You can check that out. But now to our
- 1:34podcast story about crime, AI and technology. Welcome back everybody, Well,
- 1:44welcome back Andy. Hey, Carlos. Has been a little while since we've
- 1:47had our last podcast. Nice to hear your voice. Yeah, thank you,
- 1:49Mike Wise, my friend. It seems like always a little bit of
- 1:53a pause between those things. But today, you know what's kind of interesting
- 1:59because we're kind of going on almost like on a series. And I know,
- 2:01folks, if you follow us, you're probably going where are they going?
- 2:04Now? It looks like we're sticking with artificial intelligence because Andy did some
- 2:08great research and bumped into a lot of artificial intelligence and its relationship with crime
- 2:14in more ways than what And Andy's going to highlight a lot of those factors
- 2:17for us in a second before we get started. You know what to do?
- 2:21Share subscribe it, I like button. You know, we like it.
- 2:23So let's not waste any more time and let Andy run with us So,
- 2:27Andy, what did you discover Because you were rattling off stuff and I
- 2:30was really I mean, I'm always focused on what you're saying, but I
- 2:35was hyper focused this time. It was a lot of interesting stuff that you
- 2:38discovered. Well, I think what's interesting about artificial intelligence and machine language is
- 2:45that they represent two very useful tools that have improved our lives and will continue
- 2:52to reshape our lives in the future, helping us to predict and overcome some
- 2:59very challenge gene issues. At the same time, they're tools, and we've
- 3:04talked about this as it relates to guns and gun laws or other tools like
- 3:07computers, and it's the operators intent behind the tool that often determines whether it's
- 3:15being used for good or evil. And we're going to talk about that concept
- 3:21today because in the research that we've done, we found that AI and machine
- 3:25language is in fact used for both for helping police detect and predict where crime
- 3:32may occur, as well as by scammers. And we're going to talk about
- 3:38both of those topics today. So why don't we talk about first the good
- 3:42side, the good before the evil. So let me start by talking about
- 3:47a couple products that I've discovered that use AI machine language to better and more
- 3:53efficiently predict and detect where crime is. One is a CCTV operated process.
- 4:02But it's not just a camera and it's not just a sensor. It's the
- 4:06software, the artificial intelligence software and geospatial software that they combine with this technology.
- 4:15It's called a shot spot and it was developed during the Iraqi War.
- 4:21It's being used, according to the company, in ninety different cities. And
- 4:28the shot spotter is a machine that has a camera sensor on it and it
- 4:35has an auditory capability that is programmed to listen to different gunshots, the reports
- 4:44of a gun and then it triangulates when it hears the gun shot go off,
- 4:48the camera spins three sixty to the location of where the gun shot went
- 4:53off to and then, based on geospatial software, can triangulate to the very
- 4:59location about ten feet. It has an error span of about ten feet and
- 5:03then automatically contacts the police department and then a responding officer or officers can go
- 5:11to identify where that shot was fired. The company claims that only twenty percent
- 5:16of all gunshots are reported by nine to eleven through a telephone called the nine
- 5:20to eleven, only twenty percent means eighty percent of gunshots go unreported. So
- 5:27you can imagine in cities like Chicago where this is being utilized, the importance
- 5:31of being able to identify very quickly where the gunshot occurred so that the police
- 5:38can report. Now, this is a this is a detection tool. This
- 5:41is not a prevention or prediction tool. Gunshot's already gone off, and so
- 5:46as we've talked in the past, this represents a tool for law enforcement.
- 5:50Right because the crime has already been committed. Gunshot goes off in Chicago,
- 5:55we might be a gang shooting. Police are now off to but more accurately
- 5:59than they have been in the past, and so the response time has been
- 6:02quicker. That's one example. You know, it's interesting if I can hold
- 6:06on jump on that for a second. It's fascinating because you mentioned Chicago.
- 6:12In any cities that have a lot of gang issues, one of the issues
- 6:15they have in criminology, they have that concept of collective efficacy, and you
- 6:19can't have that in some of these cities because of the retribution by that gang
- 6:23member. If they figure out, hey, Andy snitched on me, I'm
- 6:26coming back for that guy. And if they now now you don't. One
- 6:29lest thing to have to worry about is the shot spotter can at least help
- 6:31them. Hey, look, shots went off. This isn't normal. I'm
- 6:34assuming some people are even desensitized, but they're not even going to you know
- 6:38what, it's another gun shot hit the deck and well, once it's over,
- 6:41well get back up. I'm assuming that's part of it too, but
- 6:44a lot of it could be. I don't want to say anything if I
- 6:46look out my window and I see who's shooting who, I want to keep
- 6:48myself quiet. So it's it's psychologically. It's interesting. I wonder how it's
- 6:51changed that the communities a little bit in the sense of providing at least some
- 6:57kind of response answer cured it out. Yeah, I mean I could see
- 7:01where if you're in a high crime area of any city, having a tool
- 7:10like the shot spotter would give me maybe a in some cases, a false
- 7:15sense of security. At the same time, if I'm a criminal and I
- 7:21know where the location of these tools are, right and I don't know how
- 7:25they hide the shot spotter, but it could become a target of the criminal
- 7:30to shoot them so that they can't respond, and any CCTV camera and we're
- 7:36seeing more and more CCTV camera coverage in cities. But the unique aspect of
- 7:43AI and mL and machine language is that they're now combining the technologies. So
- 7:49it's not just a camera or sensor. It's a camera or sensor with an
- 7:55algorithm attached to it. They can identify, in some cases predict human behaviors.
- 8:03That's right. That's yeah. It is kind of close to minority Report.
- 8:09And now let's switch to prediction. You're right. There's a tool called
- 8:13Predpole and this company is out of China. They developed an AI camera but
- 8:20with advanced visual analytics, and so this camera can identify individuals. They can
- 8:28triangulate on your face and do facial recognition, but they also look for anomalies
- 8:33including gate patterns and so the gate analysis and that's your stride of your normal
- 8:41stride when you walk, but then increases if you're agitated or if you're you
- 8:45know, perhaps engaged in criminal behavior and trying to run away. So this
- 8:50particular AI camera looks at facial recognition and gate analysis. It's called cloud walk
- 8:58in this this particular program, and then it looks for anomalies in the behavior
- 9:05of the individual and then reports those anomalies to police. Now, according to
- 9:09the company, they used it in Cpoint, South Africa, and they had
- 9:16a sixty five percent drop in crime where they used That's a lot, Yeah,
- 9:24pretty big. Now, a similar tool was used in Tacoma, Washington,
- 9:28where they saw a twenty two percent drop in crime. That tool was
- 9:33called Predpole, And again it looks for anomalies of behavior, it looks for
- 9:39unattended baggage. These types of tools could be useful at you say, the
- 9:43Boston Marathon, remember the bombing there, Oh yeah, and you had two
- 9:48subjects that were pacing back and forth casing the joint. They had backpacks on.
- 9:52Eventually the backpacks were left unattended. These tools are more predictive in the
- 9:58sense that nothing has happened yet. But if they see the bag that's been
- 10:03left unattended for you know whatever, the time set is, maybe fifteen minutes,
- 10:07ten minutes or less. If they see an individual pacing back and forth,
- 10:13if they identify a face and they triangulate that face and then run it
- 10:18against DMV and search for outstanding morts, they might have a person who is
- 10:22a known terrorist who had a backpack dropped the backpack, all of this being
- 10:28done without any human interaction, all through the AI software, and then a
- 10:33phone call goes nine to one one in the police respond and perhaps you talked
- 10:39about minority report. Perhaps in the near future we have these tools helping us
- 10:46prevent crimes from occurring like the Boston marathon bombing. Yeah, it's really fascinating.
- 10:52Go ahead, incredible, incredible, it's just incredible utilization of advanced technicologies
- 11:01by police to help prevent a crime from occurring. Having said that, the
- 11:09bad guys have also looked at using these tools, and particularly tools where there
- 11:18are situations where there's human engagement. So when I was doing this research,
- 11:24there's a lot of different frauds out there, you know, financial frauds,
- 11:26one of which are known as romance scams where AI is being utilized. And
- 11:35what I found in the research is that according to the FTC, the Federal
- 11:39Trade Commission, one point three billion dollars in twenty twenty two was lost through
- 11:45romance scams. It's a lot. That's a lot of money. I'll take
- 11:48one point three billion dollars. The average cost to a victim is four four
- 11:56dollars. Now, when I was it the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit. We
- 12:03actually did some work in study looking at how terrorist organizations could utilize a computer
- 12:11to uh to develop garner trust with a person in the United States, have
- 12:18them convert to Islam, go overseas and blow themselves up yelling out the out
- 12:24part. We were fascinated in the process of developing rapport and trust through what
- 12:31is known as computer mediated communications. So you and I right now as we
- 12:37engage, we're doing it, you know, through this wonderful internet and zoom,
- 12:41of course. But it's this is a form of computer mediated communications.
- 12:46This is different than being engaged live with someone in the presence of that other
- 12:52person and developing rapport and trust through that process. It was thought years ago
- 12:58that it was very difficult to develop trust or even developed rapport, use rapport
- 13:03to build trust using computer mediated communications, and there was a lot of research
- 13:09done on this area. It turns out that the same processes that lead an
- 13:15individual to develop trust in person are found in computer media, communications and liking.
- 13:24And there's a great book called Influence by help me out here. Yeah,
- 13:33Joe Cardigan, you mean Sheldeini that's it, Sheldinie, that's it.
- 13:37And the book talks about seven ways of influencing behavior, one of them which
- 13:43is liking, right, And what artificial intelligence is allowing criminals to do is
- 13:50use technology, one of which is called deep fake. And are you familiar
- 13:54with deep fake? Oh? Yeah, So they use tools such as mirf
- 14:01it's called mirf dot ai and another tool called fotoar fot o r the con
- 14:07victims on online dating scams, right, what they'll do is they'll use deep
- 14:13fake, which is a video that is not real. So if you know,
- 14:20we're on zoom, so you can see my face, our audience can't,
- 14:22but unfortunately you can't, and so but you're not. If if I
- 14:28was using deep fake, I would be talking with this visual, but this
- 14:31wouldn't be me, so my libs would be moving. You'd hear my voice
- 14:37but or maybe another voice, and but the visual that you see would be
- 14:43fake. And so what happens is there's these Nigerian scammers are using fake video.
- 14:50If you go to YouTube, our listeners can go to YouTube and search
- 14:56romance scams or catfishing scams. And there's some videos where these Nigerian scammers have
- 15:03been outed by intrepid amateur sleuths and the thing is they're using artificial intelligence to
- 15:13generate these artificial these fake deep fakes to allow them to develop trust and rapport
- 15:24with potential victims. So that's just one example of this was really crazy because
- 15:33they don't even so I know that I saw Russia doing it with Ukraine.
- 15:37They actually had one of their they deep faked. They former Ukrainian ambassadors before
- 15:41they started the war, and they joined in on a private zoom meeting between
- 15:48Ukraine and some other countries, and they thought it was him till he called
- 15:50and said I'm running behind, I'll be there in about twenty minutes. They
- 15:54didn't count on that word. But yeah, yeah, it was really Uh
- 15:58that scared me. Well, that's that's a sophisticated form for intelligence gathering,
- 16:04and certainly it can be used for those applications as well. The point being
- 16:08that these these criminals are now using deep fake, they're using chat bots,
- 16:15and these chat bots are trained to act like humans in the conversations online.
- 16:22Now, there are some red flags because chat bots are not yet sophisticated enough
- 16:26to change their verbiage. So if asks the question similar questions, they'll they'll
- 16:32repeat the answers verbatim, right, and a lot of these catfishing scams are
- 16:38doing the same thing. You'll you'll know you're on a bot when they,
- 16:41you know, follow a pattern and usually the pattern is Hi, how are
- 16:45you whatever? Handsome, pretty, whatever? And then where are you from?
- 16:49Is another one that usually start with where are you from? What do
- 16:52you do? And these are very short sentences because that's where the machine language
- 17:00technology is right now. But they it's a way, it's a force multiplier
- 17:04because they can steal somebody's profile and pictures. And by the way, they
- 17:11will ask for your picture. What they're hoping for are pictures that cannot be
- 17:15reverse looked up. You're familiar with reverse lookup, right, There's plenty of
- 17:19sites online where you can take a picture. You put the you know,
- 17:23the picture in the in the browser. It reverse looks throughout the internet to
- 17:30see where the original source is, so it'll come to Twitter, or it'll
- 17:33come to Instagram, it'll come to Facebook, whatever the picture was at.
- 17:37They want virgin pictures, they want clean pictures so that when you a potential
- 17:41victim uses reverse lookup, it doesn't come it doesn't come back, so that
- 17:45gives them more legitimacy. The whole idea in this process is using these technologies
- 17:52to develop rapport and therefore trust. Once you have the trust, then you
- 17:57can try to seek the monetary gain you're looking for. It. Maybe,
- 18:03hey, sweetie, I need three hundred dollars so that I can fix my
- 18:07iPhone, or my grandmother's living with me and she needs thirty dollars for pills.
- 18:12What they really don't they don't care about the thirty dollars or the three
- 18:15hundred dollars. What they're looking for is your financial information, and that's the
- 18:21second piece. Once you're willing to give them the money, then they're going
- 18:22to ask for your bank routing information, They're going to try to get your
- 18:27identifying information. Then they're going to steal everything they can from you. There's
- 18:33all kinds of different variations of these fishing schemes, but one one critical common
- 18:41element in cat fishing schemes is it they're going to use a romance platform,
- 18:47a dating platform, and eventually, within within a week, certainly they're going
- 18:52to ask you for some money in some form. It could be an Apple
- 18:56gift card for their son, be the pills for grandma. It can be
- 19:02to fix the cell phone. It could be can you put some money on
- 19:04my food plan here at college? But whatever, it's going to be.
- 19:08The idea is for you to share your financial information with them. And that's
- 19:14why the Federal Trade Commission says over thirty six thousand people reported being conned by
- 19:21people pretending to be their friends or family using artificial intelligence and AI chat butts
- 19:26in two thousand and twenty two. Man, that's a lot. And you
- 19:33know what happens to me when I look at these things. I was doing
- 19:36this research, I'm like, how can people be that dumb? You know
- 19:40how? But was it? Barnum and Bailey said, A what do you
- 19:45say? A fool is born each every day, and a fool and his
- 19:52money are quickly parted. So there are a lot of suckers. There's a
- 19:56sucker born every day, and there are a lot of suckers out there that
- 20:00become much less wealthy because they are desperate for affection or intimacy or relationship.
- 20:08And that's what these people pray on. And that's the sad thing, and
- 20:12it hasn't gone away. I think one of the most common actors that people
- 20:17tend to use who they say they they are representing that actor or that they
- 20:22are. That actor is Keanu Reeves. It's kind of surprisingly he has the
- 20:26most imposters of anybody else, and it's kind of funny. Is I actually
- 20:30know someone who fell for that? She went, she went out with the
- 20:34guy. The guy he kind of had a different mo than when I've heard
- 20:38before and maybe you've heard before as well. He kind of actually bought her
- 20:42dinner. He took her out, and about two or three dates later is
- 20:48when he started saying things like, have you ever seen such such movies?
- 20:52And she said no. She goes, well, this is me. I
- 20:56wanted to tell you now And she's like oh, because he knew she wasn't
- 21:02up to speed in the movie. Was it just wasn't that that kind of
- 21:03person. So, but he looked like him, So he showed her a
- 21:08picture of himself in the movie and she said, he really looked like him,
- 21:12and he did. He looked like him. And eventually we kept warning
- 21:19her that, you know what, this it's probably not going to be him.
- 21:22The odds are really high that it's not going to be Yea. And
- 21:27eventually we found out she wasn't because he supposedly had a heart condition and he
- 21:32had to fly to Washington, d C. To do the operation, and
- 21:34then but he has to keep it quiet because he doesn't want the paparazzi all
- 21:38over it. And then now he had to fly to India because they're the
- 21:41only ones who could do this special operation. Oddly enough, he never went
- 21:45for the money, so we don't know if he just maybe he thought there
- 21:48wasn't enough money there to bother with, so he kind of ended it and
- 21:51moved along. Right. Well again, it's I come back to the P.
- 21:56T. Barnum quote about a suck are born every day or a fool
- 22:00is born every day. Some of these scams that I've read about, it's
- 22:07so obvious to me, right that these are scams, But when you're that
- 22:11desperate and that close to it, it's it's certainly less obvious. There are
- 22:17some red flags, and one of those red flags is if some you know,
- 22:22first and foremost, if somebody's asking for money that you just met on
- 22:25the internet less than a week ago, probably a scam. If somebody is
- 22:32unwilling to video and this has gotten a little more sophisticated, a little harder
- 22:36because of the deep fakes, but in most cases they won't video chat with
- 22:40you because it's a scam and you know they're they're Nigerian male pretending to be
- 22:45you know, a thirty five year old female. So then that's that's a
- 22:49good way to determine it. Just you know, you don't ever give your
- 22:56social Security number or your routing number, or your account number to anyone that
- 23:00you don't know. I mean, those are they're clearly common sensical things.
- 23:04But one point three billion dollars tells me that there are a lot of fools
- 23:08out there that that don't really care about their personal security or information security.
- 23:17You know, this company that was talking about how they use the software to
- 23:21prevent crime, they talk about the development of deep neural networks, and that's
- 23:30really the basis of these sophisticated AI software programs is that they create new knowledge.
- 23:40They're not human, certainly, but these deep neural networks learn from the
- 23:45information of the past. And so these computers are becoming more and more sophisticated
- 23:52to understand the patterns of behavior. And you've heard of routine activities theory of
- 23:56course, right where you have a motivated offender and you have a potential victim
- 24:04without a capable guardian, and so if you can see where patterns of crime
- 24:11have occurred in a particular town over the course of the last five years.
- 24:18Crime can become predictable in the future. And using these security cameras and deep
- 24:23neural networks, combining the the optics with the algorithm not only takes away the
- 24:32bias that you might have as a police officer, but gives a predictive process
- 24:38to the department so that they can create and define a hotspot, put police
- 24:44in that area, and basically prevent crime by creating a presence of threat to
- 24:49the perpetrator. And that's the future. I think in a lot of policing
- 24:55in prevention right now that here's the thing to find I find it. How
- 25:00do you prevent or how do you how do you measure the negative? How
- 25:06do you prove that negative? How do you say that the deep neural network
- 25:10and the cameras prevented crime because this has been a drop of you know,
- 25:15dropping the crime rate. Because there's a lot of factors that play into crime
- 25:21rates or crime in general. Right so inecdotally you can say that the presidence
- 25:27of the police officer, now you have a capable guardian over the potential victim.
- 25:33And because most criminals are reasonable or reason Now the routine activity theory that
- 25:40the perpetrator decides not to act in a criminal manner or at least not in
- 25:44that location, right, And that's the theory. So that's and then you
- 25:49know, inclosing on this topic, because I find this whole topic when we
- 25:52could talk about this, you know, for three or four podcasts. But
- 25:56by putting these cameras in place, and you were talking about LA and some
- 26:02of the cessation of these activities. By putting these cameras in place, particularly
- 26:07in areas that are high crime areas, which coincidentally, many of these high
- 26:12crime areas are in areas of people of color. People of color, you
- 26:21have serious civil liberty issues that are advanced because they're like, wait a second,
- 26:26you're putting these surveillance cameras and the sophisticated software in my neighborhood but not
- 26:33in you know, Beverly Hills, and so you know, you're you're,
- 26:41you know, playing big brother because I can't afford to live in a fancy
- 26:45house. And I don't know what your thoughts are on that, but it
- 26:48is it is an issue, and so many communities have backed off on the
- 26:52use of these technologies that could be used to prevent crime because of the civil
- 26:57liberty issues. I think it's a mixed bag. I can see both sides
- 27:02of the story. There's the side of hey, you're picking on us because
- 27:04we don't have the ability to move into another area, or because we're a
- 27:07particular ethnicity or dominanting this ethnicity. But the other side of the coin is,
- 27:11no, we're trying to help you because you have a high crime problem
- 27:15and we're trying to reduce the crime. So I don't know if there's even
- 27:18a halfway point there. It depends on how those arguments reconciled. I get
- 27:25both sides of the argument. How do you quantify that? I don't even
- 27:27know if you can. How do you able to define it clearly enough to
- 27:32show that all sides are have good intentions? I guess would be another one,
- 27:37Well, that's difficult. It's funny how a lot of our conversations,
- 27:41you and I in these podcasts come back to the original point. And you
- 27:45know, we talked about our opening comments that we're going to talk about a
- 27:51tool. You know, the combination of these computer you know, these cameras
- 27:56and these sensors coupled with the outlgorithms to help predict or detect where crime is
- 28:02occurring. But ultimately these tools have humans behind them, and it's the intent
- 28:08that the human introduces that determines whether it's being used for good or evil.
- 28:14And even when it's being used for good by police departments to help prevent crime,
- 28:18it can be interpreted as evil by those that live in that community and
- 28:22feel oppressed by these technologies that are intended to help them. Sure, and
- 28:27that's a much deeper philosophical conversation that you may warrant a future podcast, but
- 28:36I don't have any answers for I've often said that crime is a relational issue
- 28:42of unpredictable behavior. You've heard me talk about all relationships are predicated on trust
- 28:48and control. When trust goes down, controls go up. So if your
- 28:52relationship in your community is between the people and the police that serve them,
- 28:57but there's a high light level of unpredictable behavior in that community, namely there's
- 29:02a high level of crime, public trust will go down, and the only
- 29:07way to stabilize that environment is to increase social control. More. Police presence
- 29:12has very little to do with the race of the people or the ethnicity of
- 29:18the people or the religion of the people, and you see this demonstrated throughout
- 29:22the world. And so where there's high crime, you're going to have higher
- 29:26presence of police because you need social controls, because there's a lower level of
- 29:33public trust because there is a lack of predictability of behavior as it relates to
- 29:38the baseline or laws. Now the question becomes, what's the intent behind the
- 29:45police. Is it to maintain quote unquote security or law and order, And
- 29:52if that's the case, then you have a buy in in the community.
- 29:55And where that's where that's the case, you don't really have a whot and
- 30:00holler from the people because they're cooperating and partnering with the police themselves. So
- 30:07ultimately, in my opinion, whether it's these sophisticated tools or just the cop
- 30:12on the beat, it comes down to managing public trust against social control and
- 30:18that's the heart and base of relational policing. So it's not the tool or
- 30:25the use of the tools, how they sell it to the community in my
- 30:26opinion, Yeah, I think that's the exactly I was going to get through.
- 30:30Was the part of it's really the communication, like you mentioned earlier,
- 30:33between the community and the police department, the mayor whoever is going to agree
- 30:37with it, they should probably present it before they implement it, and then
- 30:41maybe even have a vote on it. I guess you can have some kind
- 30:44of weird vote to be able to see if the community is willing to try
- 30:48it. And if they sell it and they give it a try, then
- 30:52it's a whole different ballgame, right because I think if you just do it,
- 30:55then it scares a little bit of the community. They had no say
- 30:57in it, and something's being implemented where and I'm really sure how it works,
- 31:03and all this other stuff. I think. I think that's a very
- 31:07valid point. I think that the way I've often been told, and this
- 31:14is just me Andy, it's not what you say, it's how you say
- 31:18it. And and that's very true. I think with a lot of police
- 31:23departments, right, you said, maybe if they introduced it through a community
- 31:27uh you know, response, community outreach before they implemented the tools, then
- 31:36the community would see that it's being used to help them and prevent crime,
- 31:41as opposed to oppress them and and unfairly watch them. And I don't know
- 31:49if it's a situation where law enforcement says, you know what, but if
- 31:52we say too much, then the bad guys are going to figure this out.
- 31:56I don't know if this is one of those situations or not, because
- 31:59I know something's yeah, you want to kind of keep quiet. I get
- 32:01it, Like the shot spotters. You're not going to start showing oh look
- 32:04it's over there in that corner the thing, right, So I get that.
- 32:08I'm just kind of I don't I haven't really thought about it whether or
- 32:10not this system would actually be something that they would want to keep on the
- 32:15downlow as they say, yeah. I think that it depends on the culture
- 32:20of the community. And in some communities where you have a very good relationship
- 32:24with the police department, I think that these types of technologies are welcomed and
- 32:30embraced, and I think where there's a lack of public trust in other communities,
- 32:36then they're much more hesitant to have these and they're more likely to cry
- 32:38out, you know, a civil liberty issue. One final note from my
- 32:45side, at least not really related to it to the AI world, but
- 32:50related to a tactic that was implemented to get a lot of controversy. But
- 32:54I was stunned on the dropage of homicide per capita. For the last I
- 33:01don't know how many years. Now, El Salvador has had a huge homicide
- 33:06percapitoary with one of the top five in the world. Usually it's like one
- 33:09hundred for every hundred thousand people. And just to give you comparison, folks,
- 33:14I think like some of our most violent cities in the US is about
- 33:16twenty five to thirty five per one hundred thousand. So this was like triple
- 33:20the most violent that we have in the US. And it was almost country
- 33:24wide. And you look at those hotspot maps and everything that was read was
- 33:28a big crime area. Almost the whole country was read. It was insane
- 33:31to look at some of these things. And this was about twenty sixteen,
- 33:34Yeah, twenty sixteen or seventeen. And then I made the mistake, and
- 33:38I admit my mistakes. I made a mistake a few months ago in a
- 33:42lecture saying, you know the homicide rate in El Salvador, but you know
- 33:45they're implementing this new thing. In the last year, they put into like
- 33:49over forty thousand people in jail or prison. So then I said, you
- 33:53know what, I wonder if this thing is doing anything. So in the
- 33:57middle of the class. I had a breakout for a second. I decided
- 33:59to look at myself, and I'll be damned that was wrong. It dropped
- 34:02about twelve or fifteen for every one hundred thousand. It went from one hundred
- 34:07down to about twelve to fifteen. It's like an eighty percent drop. Yeah,
- 34:10right, I get the civil liberty issue. I understand that. But
- 34:15then of course they do the anecdotes where they go around asking people and they
- 34:17say, it's the first time I can walk at night, it's the first
- 34:21time I can do this, the first time I can open a business and
- 34:22not worry about somebody strong arming me for money, and are they using these
- 34:27technologies? And is that I have nothing related to that. But it was
- 34:30related to an intervention that was controversial. I guess that was my point about
- 34:34it. It was an intervention that a lot of people said, oh,
- 34:37you can't do that, And I get it. I understand it. Yeah,
- 34:39we board. It didn't drop a lot. I mean, how much
- 34:42wasn't do you know? What was the intervention? What was it? Targeting
- 34:45these individuals and putting them away. So they were just rabbing everybody who was
- 34:47part of these groups and just boom, poom poom. And I don't know
- 34:51if it was a lack of corruption at this point compared to other past administrations.
- 34:55I have no idea about that. If it was a coordinated ap with
- 35:00everybody. Did they get money from another country I have? You know,
- 35:02sometimes that helps R Look, I can't do this because they're funding these corrupt
- 35:07politicians. If you help us out, I'll do this, I promise you.
- 35:09And maybe that was the case, because I've never seen a change like
- 35:12that. You can look at those numbers. Maybe we'll talk about it.
- 35:15That was really a surprise how fast that drop was. Well, you know
- 35:17it's funny too that, you know, not funny but ironic that in places
- 35:22like Sun Salvador. And I actually lectured in El Salvador, Sun's back in
- 35:29twenty fifteen, I think, or fourteen or fifteen. That was high problems
- 35:31right then. Yeah, And I flew in when I flew in for this
- 35:36lecture, I came in and then when I got off the airplane, just
- 35:42outside the airport, you're driving and you see these people armed shotguns or M
- 35:49sixteen's, But they weren't in front of like government buildings. They were in
- 35:52front of businesses. Like everyday businesses like be in front of Walmart, there's
- 35:57a guy with a M sixteen. Right. It was very shocking to me
- 36:01the number of guards in front of these houses and businesses. Right. Part
- 36:07of the problem in you know, these these violent cultures, particularly in South
- 36:13America, I think a lot of it has to do with the culture itself,
- 36:16the honor culture. So if you know, and they in the number
- 36:21of gangs and organized criminal groups, right, and if so, if you
- 36:24disrespect somebody in one of these cultures, the response is usually violent. The
- 36:31other thing, too, is you talked about the crackdown and the response.
- 36:36The laws in many of these South American Central American countries, they don't have
- 36:43death penalty. And the reason is because historically most of them are Catholic,
- 36:49and so you know, the Catholic Church has been against the death penalty forever.
- 36:53And so you could kill a cop and you know these some of these
- 36:57South American countries and you're not getting the death penalty. You could have premeditated
- 37:01murder, you're not getting the death penalty. So these individuals go to jail,
- 37:07and oftentimes they're not in jail for the rest of their life either.
- 37:10And so it's just it's creates and breeds I think of violent culture in many
- 37:15of those countries. I was interested to see if, in fact, you're
- 37:22the drop in crime was due to these technologies, because the response from police
- 37:28in these countries is also we talk about the you know, violence of our
- 37:30police departments here in the United States, that they are almost paramilitary in those
- 37:37countries, you know, south of US. So I think it'd be a
- 37:42great discussion to for our next podcast is maybe have an international or somewhat of
- 37:46an international look a crime and policing and seeing the differences, because I'm always
- 37:52bugged when people try to compare it because they're not apples to apples, not
- 37:54even no, not even close. And it's finely because I was and I
- 37:59taught you know, police executives for fifteen years at the National Academy. I
- 38:05had a student believe it's Newfoundland. No, it was Greenland, Greenland,
- 38:10and they don't have guns. They don't carry weapons. If there's an issue
- 38:16on the ISEM, they have to go to the headquarters in the gun vault
- 38:21and they get a gun. So you know, it's there's a broad spectrum,
- 38:27and I think it certainly would be worth a podcast to look at policing
- 38:30around the world and how those processes, how those processes work. I don't
- 38:37so, yeah. I don't think the United States is nearly the most violent
- 38:40policing culture or the most passive. I think he's somewhere in the middle.
- 38:47And well, again, that's hard to compare. It's very hard. We
- 38:51can have an easy part another podcast right now, so be carefully. We
- 38:54can tell already we're digging that rabbit hole pretty fast. Yeah. No,
- 38:58I think that'd be a good, good topic in the teacher. Sounds good
- 39:00to me again, folks. Hey, check out Behavioral Science Unit LLC dot
- 39:05com Behavioral Science Unit LLC dot com to find out what Andy's up to and
- 39:09to learn about his services over there. And by the way, folks,
- 39:13you can also make sure to share, subscribe, and hit that like button
- 39:16if you like our shaw of course hopefully for listening to do. Thank you
- 39:21everyone for listening. Stay safe, watch out for those deep fakes and whatever
- 39:23else they eyes up to. And the deep snow in California, yea,
- 39:28the deep snow. All right, buddy, talk to you later.