Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-The 5G4D Awards 2023
Transcript
- 0:03Why from Berlin, the world capital of bullshit. This is the first annual
- 0:07five G for D Awards And here are your hosts, Steven Syrec and Tabb
- 0:14bu leto table. Well, hello Taboletto. He Hello, there's Steve,
- 0:21and hello all of you, and welcome to the second annual five G for
- 0:26the Awards show. Oh it's such a pleasure to be here, and especially
- 0:32I am so gratified Stephen that all of these people in here exist. You've
- 0:41not amazing because there's so much stuff, as we know that doesn't exist.
- 0:45Steve, that's right, Tabuletto. You know, I used to be a
- 0:48Tabuleto skeptic, you might say, But more and more you're starting to make
- 0:53a lot of sense. Well, yeah, because you work from home a
- 1:00lot, You've got a lot of time to watch the youtubes, haven't you.
- 1:03Absolutely, And there's one thing that definitely exists. That's the five G
- 1:07for D Awards. And I'm so glad you've decided to join me today instead
- 1:11of our usual host. Dude you've been saying lately doesn't actually exist. I
- 1:15don't think Ben exists. Yeah, I wouldn't have believed it, but you
- 1:19put forward a very compelling case so thanks for filling in. Actually, I'm
- 1:23very happy if you simply host the show from now on, Tabulai All right,
- 1:26Well, I think the listeners, because they don't find my voice annoying
- 1:30at all. I think the listeners would love for me to just do the
- 1:33entire show like this. Oh I'm totally on board Tabuletto, so sell me.
- 1:38Excuse me? What what are you too bloody doing? Who is this
- 1:44Ben? Yeah? It's bloody Ben? What are you too bloody doing?
- 1:47Tabuletto? Do you see him? Hi? Sees him? Now? Yeah,
- 1:49I feels a bit silly. Actually, Well, Tabuletto is explaining to
- 1:53me that you don't exist, Ben. Yeah, he's been going around spreading
- 1:56bloody roomors. I don't exist you. Well, I didn't think you exist
- 2:00and bullshitter, you're just trying to take over my podcast. Well I think
- 2:02i'd be better on the podcastn't I. Well, he's saying, like,
- 2:05we only hear your voice, we don't actually see you in person ever.
- 2:08Well that's because I'm very shy. That's because I'm very shy. I'm an
- 2:12anchor, write mostly, and then I only come out for shows. Ah,
- 2:15you come out for shows, but then you goes back into your anchor
- 2:20shite, don't you anchor write your little twat? What do you call me
- 2:23a little twat for? Because because you're trying to take over my bloody show,
- 2:27and you you am I hallucinating this right now to you know, fucking
- 2:30you complicit and trying to take over my show. You know what you've been
- 2:35encouraging me to listen to Tabby Leedo I was. I thought he was full
- 2:39of shit for the longest time, and you said give him a chance,
- 2:42and I did, and he had some very compelling and then he tells you
- 2:45I long have we known each other? Well, as far as far as
- 2:47I know, we've never known each other. Oh right, because you believe
- 2:51here you don't twat? Shut you shut up as well. You we've known
- 2:58each other for six years nearly, That's what I thought. And just because
- 3:01fucking Tabuletto tells you don't exist, why you don't exist? Though, I've
- 3:06changed my mind again. You don't fucking exist. What you do in here,
- 3:09you don't exist. Unbelievable, Steve Tabuletto. We're gonna get to work
- 3:15on that YouTube video where we fully go into the bend doesn't exist theory.
- 3:17At another time, but for now, I guess we're gonna have to deal
- 3:21with this phantasm. All right, Well, then Ila, I'll go and
- 3:24I'll learn more Da Vinci results than Steve. So the video couldn't pop.
- 3:29Yeah, you're gonna get twenty thousand views next time. That's twice as many
- 3:31as the first time. What You're getting ten thousand views on it? Oh?
- 3:35Well, I'm quite good at it, and you're get out, get
- 3:38out. This is the awards my bloody podcast, your podcast, You don't
- 3:43exist? Mate, Well that's a rather inauspicious start, next, Steve,
- 3:49I mean you kind of seem like you exist. Yeah, I bloody exist.
- 3:53But that's sort of the counterintuitive nature of Tabuletto's theory. I'm the platonic
- 3:58ideal of the coolest possible dudes. Yeah, this is part of the you
- 4:01don't exist thing. Yeah, what do you mean? Never mind? Anyway,
- 4:05So here we are, Steve. Yeah, after that, after that
- 4:09little ruction, here we are five g for d Awards. Slightly belated.
- 4:15Well, it's we we like the oscars. Like the Oscars are in February,
- 4:18an't they Yeah? March I think, yeah exactly. So we've had
- 4:23we've got to have time to wait if I don't correct you, CD Hunter
- 4:27or Isaac Shalev, famed board game designer will Yeah. Can you imagine if
- 4:31digital ink was a finite resource, they wouldn't be a lot left with their
- 4:35No, they've already used all of it on the discord, which you can
- 4:39join by going to www dot five g for d dot com and clicking the
- 4:43pin post at the top of the page. Oh you're good. This nice
- 4:45to you. And then and then you two can wade into the endless conflict,
- 4:48the Armageddon like struggle between famed board game designer Isaac Shalev and CD Hunter.
- 4:54It's brilliant. It is. It is the fight. It is like
- 4:57Isaac Shalev's Tokyo, CD Hunter's God, and I'm just going at it.
- 5:00Yeah, it's like a pennant versus a hair splitter, and I'm not sure
- 5:03which is which. They're both great anyway. So, Stevie how asked three
- 5:10twenty three, We've probably talked about this, but on a show. I
- 5:13mean, how many topics do we really have? So how strong do you
- 5:16think a year it's been for games in twenty twenty three? Ste Ah?
- 5:19How strong a year for games? You know? I think that there were
- 5:24some extreme outliers, but generally speaking kind of average or maybe slightly below average.
- 5:30Yeah, it didn't feel particularly strong to me, to be honest.
- 5:31Yeah, I mean I wouldn't. I wouldn't say like even like like average
- 5:34would be increased by a few standout like just total successes knocked out of the
- 5:41park, at least for me, But otherwise other than that, I wouldn't
- 5:44say, like in general, there was a lot of noteworthy games coming out,
- 5:46and it felt like to me, all of the silver age euros felt
- 5:50very silver agey EUROI all of the sort of and you know, a change
- 5:57I did see. Maybe I'm behind the times, but it felt like one
- 6:00sort of sea change I think is a good thing. The efficiently designed Ameri
- 6:08trash game such as the Absolute thunder Road thunder Row. So that's going back
- 6:16on Kickstarter with new expansions, so I have another chance to pimp my copy
- 6:20or you can get just get the expansions, don't buy the full game.
- 6:25Well obviously I'm not going to buy the full game. So yeah. The
- 6:27thing is with thunder Road, right is it's just so so, but it's
- 6:30a retro game. It's not like so the board game industry has become mature
- 6:34enough that it is now starting starting to become like self referential, sure and
- 6:39ironic. It's like entering its baroque period, I think. But in many
- 6:43ways, the thing is, I think the eurogame sphere is entering it's I
- 6:46mean for sure that is. But emeritrash games feel to me the ones that
- 6:49I've played. So the thing with ameritrash games is they were often they would
- 6:55thematic meant loads of fiddly little rules. La die to see if you hit
- 7:00the truck, Roller die to see which side of the truck you hit.
- 7:03Roller die to see if it causes its damage. Us die to see if
- 7:06it punctures the armor, all of that sort of shit, right Whereas now
- 7:11I think thunder Road is the poster Charles for this a really efficiently designed game.
- 7:18But that's all of the ameritrash brilliance, right Is there another example?
- 7:23I think Cthulhu Death May Die is along these lines too. An efficiently.
- 7:28It's a bit more fiddly because I think Eric Lang is one of those sort
- 7:31of old fashioned ameritrash designers, and it's a bit more fiddly, but still
- 7:36I think that's an efficient ameritrash game. But they're sort of like turning back
- 7:40to the past and reviving old ideas and putting them in new garb. But
- 7:46I think this is I don't know, some kind of interesting indication of where
- 7:48we are in the history of board games, and thunder Road in particular,
- 7:53and like a lot of these restoration games, I think when they came out,
- 7:56they were like quite sincere, like as sincere as any tipical product of
- 8:01a of a soulless capitalist corporation. Like I don't know who originally published thunder
- 8:07Road, probably Milton Brown, Yeah, yeah, for example. So in
- 8:11this case, the reprint, I think it's like, uh, it's not
- 8:16it's not like, it's not sincere. I mean, it's sort of like
- 8:18this, the funness is sincere, but it's having a bit of a go
- 8:22like it's it's ironic. Like, so the republication of thunder Road is for
- 8:26like the sake of amusement at what thunder Road is. Disagree even though it
- 8:31is a good game. Disagree look at their marketing, but it's hilarious.
- 8:35So I think it's not that simple. So I think it is tonally ironic.
- 8:43Yeah, this is all I'm saying. But the game design is not
- 8:46ironic. The design is ironic. Game design is rigorous and thought through the
- 8:52presentation of it. It's a seriously designed Like like I said in my review,
- 8:56it's a seriously seriously designed game that is big and dumb. It is
- 9:01the biggest, dumbest game you'll play all year, and it's one of the
- 9:05best design games you play all year. Right. But this, this is,
- 9:07this is speaking to its strengths. It's like the Samuel Richardson novel Pamela
- 9:11and then the look at you drop in drop in the Samuel Richardson. Yeah,
- 9:15But then like sometime later, I forget who wrote it. Was it
- 9:18Fielding who wrote Shamela? Yeah, I mean Shemela wouldn't be I mean,
- 9:22it is actually good in its own right, but it wouldn't work in an
- 9:24ironic sense if it weren't also good, if it weren't also well written.
- 9:28Sure, So this this is kind of what I mean. Do you know
- 9:31I was reading about Edgar Allan Bottom the other day because that Edgar Allan Poe
- 9:37Edgar Allan Bottom, because the German words Bottom is posting. Oh okay,
- 9:41that's very good. Yeah, and our German, our German listener, YenS
- 9:46will appreciate. Fucking damn. That is going to be fucking goofforing. And
- 9:50I found out that the guy Griswold who wrote his so basically this idea we
- 9:58have of Poe that he was a drunk lord of the addict, basically comes
- 10:01from Griswold. There was a firm rival of pose and he stole basically the
- 10:09storyline for Poe's life from a novel by Edward bulwer Lytton. Steve, Oh,
- 10:13I know what that is? Who? What was Edgar bulwer Lytton famous
- 10:16for? It was a dark and stormy night. There we go exactly much
- 10:20forgotten what other podcast he was, the Dan Brown of his age, Bull,
- 10:26the best selling author of the Victorian Age, and no one remembers his
- 10:31night because books was s. It's a total shit, all right. So
- 10:33we're going to go into the awards in a minute, and we're also going
- 10:37to get my list. You're also going to get your nominations for the awards.
- 10:39But you know we've got four categories, right, Yes, how difficult
- 10:45was it for you to find things to fill these categories? Because, as
- 10:50we said, I don't think twenty twenty three stood out particularly well, given
- 10:54what the categories are there, they're more about I guess us and our experience
- 10:58than about well I'm an artist, that's right. Yeah, then about games
- 11:01per se. So actually very easy. Oh really, yep, very I
- 11:05did it on the train, on the train ride on the way here.
- 11:07Don't say that, I mean I you've been fucking agonizing over it. Look,
- 11:11look, I'm just going to turn the recording off, Steve. Yeah,
- 11:15Look, don't fucking say that. Shit. Just fucking when I turn
- 11:16them out, like thirty seconds when I yeah, regardless, when I turn
- 11:20the recording back on, Yeah, I want you to say, like,
- 11:22oh, since you put out the first post like a month ago, I've
- 11:26been fucking losing sleep over and it's been so fucking stressful. You're going to
- 11:30cut the last bit out the record has turned off. No, No,
- 11:31that the previous bit where I said I only didn't. Oh yeah, that's
- 11:35cut. That's cut. Okay, cut, Okay, that's a that's a
- 11:35classic. That's a classic Maddocks move. I always Okay, Okay, stick
- 11:39to my cutting promise. Come back in and you ask me the question again,
- 11:43Okay, go all right then, Steve, So you know you've said
- 11:48twenty twenty three is a kind of mediocre year or something. So has that
- 11:54made choosing the things for the categories really difficult? Indeed, it has made
- 11:58it especially difficult, you said the twentieth draft. Yeah, you like send
- 12:03me a message the other day. It's like stressing out saying, like,
- 12:05I didn't sleep last night, yeah, because you haven't been sleeping in that
- 12:07yeah, I mean Sam made me, uh sleep in the guest room.
- 12:13Actually, I just laid up. I just fucking leave with no because I'm
- 12:18trying the fuck are you doing? Sorry? Sorry, I just thought of
- 12:22my good pho make up a story about why it took me so long to
- 12:24come up with. Yes, he's doing a great job. I'll cut this
- 12:26time. Yeah. Yeah, so yeah, I was awake all night,
- 12:30just like you know, turning over the ideas in my mind. You know,
- 12:33like who qualified the windmills of your mind? Exactly what qualifies for which
- 12:37category? I just I can't set I mean I had to in the end
- 12:41settle on something for each one, but it was not easy. I'll tell
- 12:43you what. That's That's one thing I really admire about you, Steve,
- 12:46Like the effort, the effort, the sweat. I mean, there's no
- 12:48way. For instance, you'd be such a slack twat as to just do
- 12:52it on the train on the way over this this is not my understanding understanding
- 12:56of how this partnership works exactly. You know, I bring one hundred and
- 13:01ten percent of Steve every time I'm involved in which one is this? You
- 13:05know, as the years go by, one hundred ten percent is like growing
- 13:09in mass, isn't it. It accumulates exactly. You're getting like a huge
- 13:11rate of return on this investment of Steve. Anyway, Sure, so we
- 13:16go on then, yeah to the first award, Yes, the bloody how
- 13:20was that? It's your surprise of the year. Well, Steve. So
- 13:26the way this is going to work structurally, I know you know this,
- 13:30Yeah, because you've done all this work. Yeah, I've been on top
- 13:31of this for a week. But I'm going to tell the listeners is we're
- 13:35gonna do like a hashtag channel show where we go through the dickheads and the
- 13:39discords comments. Yep, dickheads is meant in a in an affectionate way,
- 13:43by the way, I mean, why do you have to explain that to
- 13:46them? They're dickheads, right, And then we'll come to our picks and
- 13:50then we'll have a little chat about our picks. Okay, so this is
- 13:52the biggest I'm really just gonna kind of mail it in until we get to
- 13:56like the part we get to talk about us and what we think. Yeah,
- 13:58you know, I get it. I totally get it. So this
- 14:01is the gaming support. It's not the game. It's the surprise of twenty
- 14:03twenty three. What is surprise? Everything we talk about is somehow gaming related,
- 14:07right, exactly topic, not the game that was the biggest surprise necessarily,
- 14:13So the biggest surprise that happened to us in our gaming lives exactly.
- 14:18I take by that. But yours isn't a game. I could just very
- 14:22quickly edit this. No, no, you spent months doing this anyway.
- 14:26So the first person to comment was Yen's dehammer Folkman. Yeah, and he
- 14:31said, what's your biggest gaming surprise? And he said, not a twenty
- 14:35twenty three release, but gin Koppolist was my biggest surprise this year and became
- 14:39one of my most favorite games for two or three players. In my family,
- 14:43it's known as Pissnelka after my wife had a brief but intense meltdown in
- 14:48articulate noises groaning. He shouldn't be he shouldn't be revealing his bedtimer mores on
- 14:52the podcast, should he? Car card's thrown on the table and from the
- 14:56depth to rumbling voice doub a whine, a pissnaker. Oh she sounds like
- 15:03you. Yeah. But even though that was a recording, that was actually
- 15:07he sent me the recording it. Yeah, he was recording her. He
- 15:09records her at all times. Apparently that that's a bit that doesn't seem like
- 15:11a very German thing to do. No, seems like an air that seems
- 15:13like a Nixonian thing to do. Isn't it weird? Get a grip?
- 15:18But even though I destroyed two of a huge scoring districts in one tile placement,
- 15:22she won the game. Nevertheless, if you've ever been in a situation
- 15:24where you're playing and your opposing player starts fucking moaning loads about losing and then
- 15:30ends up like a baby child and the ends up winning at the end,
- 15:33I think there's someone that we both know who does that every game we play.
- 15:35Who's that Theresa? Okay, would you would you call very good at
- 15:43games? Yeah? Practically always wins and at some point in the game starts
- 15:48getting upset that she's not gonna win, and then she wins, and then
- 15:50she wins every time. Would you call her so on a pissnek? I
- 15:52don't even know what it means, but sure it's piss clove. I mean
- 15:58it definitely if it sounds angry and therefore it works for me, so you
- 16:03know, you know, and I don't have other emotions at this point.
- 16:04You know what, nel I'm forty five years old. Then you know what
- 16:07is this? This is all I am? You know what Nelkin is in
- 16:11German? No, it's cloves, you know, clothes. I know someone
- 16:14with this last name though, Nelke Nelkin. I know, so Nelkin is
- 16:18clothes. It's the plural, you know, clothes, Yeah, Christmas stick
- 16:22them in oranges. Yeah, Nelka is the singular. And there is some
- 16:26weird it's a weird ejaculation in German expostulation, Yeah, piss nelke apostrophe.
- 16:34A piss clove is a bad thing, A piss clove, yeah, I
- 16:40just must be a figure of speech. It is a figure. I don't
- 16:41know what it's like, something dumb in English, that's equivalent. I mean,
- 16:45that's actually much more creative than what we generally come out with uh,
- 16:48spank me, hank me like U asshole. Uh, that's a nice one.
- 16:53I mean Shakespeare had some good ones, didn't he. Well, I
- 16:56can't think of the you're you're you're good at this stuff whole dog, Horse
- 17:00and dogs, Horse and dog. We can go to like the Shakespeare Insults
- 17:03website. Yeah, come up with a few. Non Why not, because
- 17:07I've got a mechanical keyboard. It's very noisy and it'll pick get picked up
- 17:10by the mic. Thanks for your yes ending anyway, So have you had
- 17:14a game? So He's game Coppolis is an old game relatively speaking, it's
- 17:17ten ten or so years old. Have you had a fragment? Have you
- 17:22had an old game that you've played this year that you're like, Oh,
- 17:26that's a boy, it's exciting. Isn't it like a game that's old or
- 17:30like old? For me? Well, game it's old. Yeah, Okay,
- 17:36let's see. Let's see. Uh. Probably I played quite a few
- 17:38old games. But I should have done to prepare for the show. I
- 17:42mean what I did do to prepare for the show is record all of the
- 17:45games that I played this year so I could look back last year. Yeah,
- 17:49I think I would pick actually Istanbul and Istanbul the Dice game. I
- 17:53like to stumble the dicek. Yeah, I played. I played both.
- 17:56I think they qualify as fairly old at this point. Yeah, classic games,
- 18:00both great and it was someone from the discorder recommended the dice game as
- 18:04possibly being superior to the board game. What do you think is it?
- 18:08Matt Green could be that's his name, right, Yeah, I met him.
- 18:12Yeah he did. Hi, Matt, thanks for the recommendation by that.
- 18:15What do you think is it better than what the fucking normal game?
- 18:21What was the question? He's the dice game better than the normal game?
- 18:23Oh? I thought there was like an original question. No, I don't
- 18:26know. I mean I played each one once. I think they're both good.
- 18:30I can't say better yet. So the one for me was an eternal
- 18:33classic that I played about a month ago. That's that, and it's just
- 18:36again of course, because it's Ryan Kanitzia, it's gonna be brilliant. And
- 18:38that's Through the Desert. Oh when did you play that? About a month
- 18:42ago? It rude is Oh, I wasn't around. No, and it
- 18:45was I got a copy of dershe Dvosta from the same game. I know,
- 18:49I know from Berlin, Bretch bil Khan, flow marked and it is
- 18:52it's classic. So what Kanietzi is really good at. He's good at every
- 18:57genre, but what he's really good at designing multiplayer abstracts? Right, So
- 19:03it's a four player abstract game and brutal and it I was talking about it
- 19:07on the stream the other night. Brutal and unrelenting and from the first moment
- 19:12knives are drawn and it takes forty minutes to play it is it is classic.
- 19:18Can eats here and it's absolutely brilliant. Oh great, you know how
- 19:19to play it? We can play my German copy. Yeah, definitely retained
- 19:22that memory. So CC Runner, what do we decide? His name was?
- 19:26Well, he Plaicero and runner. He claims it's pronounced siss a Runner.
- 19:32I guess ciss Runner, and I'm gonna go I prefer CC Runner.
- 19:34Yeah, I think I prefer CEC Runner. So I'm gonna go a CC
- 19:37runner. A pretty box cover took me telling a story? Okay, is
- 19:41it long? No? Is it interesting? Well? I edited it before
- 19:44in the note A pretty box cover took my eye, Maharaja A quick BGG
- 19:49search reveal. Sorry, I'll do it in a sexier voice, Yes,
- 19:52a CC runner, yeah, ah burks c my mahrazia, Oh quick me.
- 20:03Your juiceage revealed it to be of a karama of kingsling game and I've
- 20:10heard them, so I took something of a oh yeah, speculative pumped.
- 20:17That's a sexy voice. You sound like you're about to die. I love
- 20:21it straight to number five of my revised Top twenty this year. The fact
- 20:26that I effectively, albeit indirectly, traded it for the pretty but eminently uninspiring
- 20:33ah no Veluna was ing on the cock. Sorry and now you know.
- 20:40Now you know why I listened to these at two x oh pele, would
- 20:44you think of my story? Did they go to wed end or to message
- 20:49that was? I added that last little bit. I was a bit of
- 20:52editorializing on my part on the last little bit. Is this going out on
- 20:55the main feed Fox? So the thing is, so I think there's more
- 20:59than one game called my Ja by the way, so I have there's the
- 21:03sequel to britann Yeah, I have that one new and shrink by the way,
- 21:07like from I don't know thirty years ago. I'd love to play it
- 21:08at some point. I've only ever played Britannia, and I don't know that.
- 21:11Probably like divides opinions. I've heard Maharaja is not as good, but
- 21:15I don't think this is the Maharaja. He is likely to be tachd You
- 21:18know what divides opinions? What's that? An idea knife Steve. Anyway,
- 21:30he talks about the reason I put this up, and we're so crestfallen right
- 21:33now. He talks about the uninspiring Nova lunar, and I wanted to have
- 21:40a little chat about my sort of disaffection with Rosenberg. Disaffection. Yeah,
- 21:48this is news. Well, so Uba Rosenberg was one of those answer,
- 21:55Oh no, I am a bit of a nonswrough Virosenberg. But Uba Rosenberg
- 21:56is one of those designers who would once a year, once every two years,
- 22:03bring out a classic. So you had Bonanza, a Gricola, Lajava,
- 22:11Gates of Loyac, you know, what a glass road and what a
- 22:17FD. Yeah. And at the last two or three years, you know,
- 22:21like a tea, No, tea was fine. But the last two
- 22:23or three years he's been spunking out loads of games, right like an Essen.
- 22:29Last year I think he had four or five games out. They're not
- 22:30really lending though, are they no? And so what do you think do
- 22:37you think an artist should because because clearly he's doing it, he's doing it
- 22:42to sort of for a pension. Are you familiar with the concept of an
- 22:45artist having a late period, right, so it could be that, and
- 22:48it's just like cymbolane for him. I get this. I get this feeling
- 22:52though, that if he just focused his ideas a bit more and just brought
- 22:56out one, maybe two games a year rather than five or six games a
- 23:00year, they'd be better, right, Because I've never played no Va Luna,
- 23:03but people don't really talk about it. I suppose at some point people
- 23:07like they must they must switch. I mean, I'm not a designer the
- 23:10designers. Famed board game designer Isaac Shalev no doubt has an opinion about this,
- 23:14which CD Hunter, who is not a disagreement, well, yeah,
- 23:18will refute. But so assume you get into this for the love of the
- 23:21hobby, the love of design, and at some point, maybe when it
- 23:25becomes your livelihood, something else, like the need to keep churning out product
- 23:30takes over. Do you think it's like pulling the pigtails of the girl in
- 23:33the playgrounds with those two. I mean, I definitely want to watch it
- 23:37them have sexual intercourse with each other. Huh what anyway, moving on to
- 23:42ye hate great name, it's right? How would you pronounce this? Is
- 23:48this a patron though? I don't know they're on the discord? Should we
- 23:49actually read the contributions from non patrons? Yeah? Yeah, sure, it's
- 23:53it's a it's a it's a it's a democratic discourse. So would you say
- 24:00this, Steve? Hy h e t e y h et e. Yeah,
- 24:06I've gone with you hate it? Yeah, I don't have a better
- 24:08answer for that one. So you might like this? So he says,
- 24:11General Orders, World War two? It's got So where do you think you
- 24:15hate? He's from? It's probably his name? Like why hate? Maybe?
- 24:19So who knows. I'm trying to look if it's a backwards thing,
- 24:23but that would be et issue. So it's not gonna it's not backwards thing,
- 24:27is it. I've decided he's from Yorkshire. General Orders, World War
- 24:32two. Steve, it's got so much? Or what makes board games great?
- 24:37It's simple enough to teach in ten minutes, simple enough that halfway into
- 24:40your first game you'll start to have little epiphanic moments. What's the how would
- 24:47you say the adjective for epiphany epiphenic? That's what he said here here epiphanic
- 24:52moments. I haven't had a game yet. They didn't have moments where both
- 24:55played suddenly figured out something out and got a little excited by an idea or
- 24:59dismas a suddenly exposed weakness. It's mostly tactical at first, but the more
- 25:03you play, the more you start to perceive strategic ideas. That's when the
- 25:06game starts to get really fun, when you can start to plan ahead and
- 25:10see that plan come together or be thwarted. I found myself thinking about this
- 25:14game a lot in between play sessions, wondering about a previous game, what
- 25:17strategy did or didn't work out, what happens if that area bonus was over
- 25:21there instead, et cetera. I got lost in the performance. I don't
- 25:25even remember what the game was. You're not a listener, though, are
- 25:27you? By nature? Well? I start thinking about other things, you
- 25:30know, do you think that's because you're a narcissist? You know I'm in
- 25:36good company. Do you know that's the German word for crocuses, no,
- 25:41for for daffodils, So What was the game General Orders World War two?
- 25:45Oh? Yes, a good game. What did you What did you think
- 25:48of that of General Orders? Yeah? I thought it was a good game.
- 25:51We should play again, should we? Yeah? We should absolutely.
- 25:53I don't remember how. No, but it takes very simple kind of game
- 25:56where I should The thing is when we play either said of the map.
- 26:00When we played it, I think I won. We were a little tired
- 26:03and emotional, won't we do? I mean, you're always very emotional,
- 26:06so matchi tecchi is how I think you're very at a fucking toucchi. Calm
- 26:11down, a fucking you don't call me fucking toetchi? Sorry, Matt Coates,
- 26:15el fa laffel tetchi cunt. What. As far as surprises from new
- 26:19games, I think the first time designers and publisher behind Distills really knocked it
- 26:25out the park Distilled. It's a year game about booz. I haven't played
- 26:29it, no, but I was very curious about it. I think it
- 26:30came out at Essen, didn't it. Yeah, And it's got good good
- 26:33notices. Yeah, I mean these are these are good picks. I'm like
- 26:37even thinking if I had a game, did I have a gaming surprise?
- 26:41I mean, I mean we'll get to it. I suppose we'll get to
- 26:44ours. Yeah, all right, so let's go on two hours now.
- 26:47Yeah, So your gaming surprise of the year, Steve, I don't think
- 26:51it's a game. Well, I'm doing some quick revisions. So for each
- 26:56of the categories, if if you will indulge me, I have a pin
- 27:00and a runner up. Okay, exciting. So first, one biggest surprise
- 27:03of the year, Uli sticking his head in the live stream at Leria Con.
- 27:06Is that the runner up? No, that's the pick. He's a
- 27:08surprise every time, like, oh, there's Uli. He was very surprised
- 27:12that he kept doing it over and over again. Yeah, that was well
- 27:15knowing Uhlis, it shouldn't be surprised knowing ULI's comic stick. Yeah, it's
- 27:19not hugely surprising. And the the actual pick is getting to meet and spend
- 27:26time with like the godfather of the board game industry and realizing like he's a
- 27:32pimp. What you mean, terrific? Terrific Emo edge Lord Martin Wallace.
- 27:37No Ks, Oh my god, that was the biggest surprise of the year
- 27:41for me. Do you know if you if you dos ks, you'll chop
- 27:45your legs off, I'm not ducking anybody. But we did play an Infamous
- 27:51Traffic there, and I guess that that might be my biggest surprise pick.
- 27:55I'm actually like back and forth between an Infamous Traffic and thunder Road. I
- 27:59don't know if an Infamous Traffic was a surprise per se. It was very
- 28:04interesting and I didn't get to play it the first time because of Uli,
- 28:08and we did play it with Uli. Yeah, and it's a very weird
- 28:12game. It's a very weird game. But I think it's a genuine experience.
- 28:15It's a lot of fun. It's a genuine experience. So I don't
- 28:18know if it qualifies as a surprise. Thunder Road definitely a surprise, that
- 28:22is I think it to be like that good. It's not my number one,
- 28:26but it's it's on the list, and it was in my top five
- 28:29games of the year, and it's absolutely spectacular and loads of fun. And
- 28:33when someone says, oh, but you just fucking just collide in the cars
- 28:37all the time, and it's loads of bloody randomness, and it's like,
- 28:41fucking great, it's the bloody point. It's fun. It's just it's fucking
- 28:45like just shit's fun all over the place. Yeah, absolutely, another one
- 28:48we're gonna get. We're gonna talk about this a bit later, I think
- 28:52in the next for the next award. But uh, what's it called challenges.
- 29:00Well, we'll talk about that. We'll talk about that a bit more.
- 29:02But I was really surprised. But that wasn't twenty twenty three though,
- 29:06No, But it was my surprise, my surprise of last Thursday. It's
- 29:10the first time I played. Yeah, but we're doing biggest surprise of last
- 29:12year. Of course I was twenty twenty four, wasn't it. Yeah.
- 29:15I always get the transition, but my biggest one was the little game that
- 29:21could my pick for the Spielders Rus next year tell me and that's pray another
- 29:26day. Oh yeah yeah. But was it a surprise? Yeah, I
- 29:32was surprising about it. So what was surprising? How badly you do every
- 29:34time you play? Yeah, that's true, but I was speaking to Matt
- 29:37dunstan At it's like we can read your mind. Yeah, it's every single
- 29:41time. It's because I go every time i'm playing it, I'm like,
- 29:42okay, i'll play an owl this time, and I put the owl.
- 29:47Well, you don't say it out loud, but you like mouth of the
- 29:48word at all, because because that's how I read. Yeah. Anyway,
- 29:52So I was speaking to Matt Dunstan because your myths kind of I suppose,
- 29:59yeah, in bretshur bil Khan because he was there because he got nominated for
- 30:02the Sielder Gas and we were talking about next station London, and he just
- 30:06offhand said, oh on, we've got another game here, Schnitzel yaked,
- 30:08right, And I didn't think about it, and it was kind of I
- 30:14could go for Schnitzel right now, I'm hungry. It was kind of under
- 30:17the radar, right, I didn't think about it. There was no sort
- 30:19of fanfare, and not him and Brett. So you only knew about it
- 30:23because he mentioned it because you mentioned yea, and I didn't even think about
- 30:26it after that. And then the what would you call him? The monument,
- 30:34the center the what's that? What's the balance point in geometry? Pivot
- 30:41point? No, the balance point? Uh, center of gravity? No,
- 30:45it's it's it's what the center of a thing where they balance on what's
- 30:49called it's called something yeah of German gaming Meropolis, Peopolis, Yeah, yeah.
- 31:00Brought it to game night as he would do, and I played it
- 31:03and instantly I was just, oh, I fucking love this and this is
- 31:06crux. No I guess not? No, uh you you vamped two seconds.
- 31:11Fucking CD Hunter and themed board game designer Isaac Shallev are losing their minds
- 31:15right now. Too bad. This is not a live podcast or you could
- 31:19tell us live in the chat what this word is? You know, it's
- 31:25one of these words that, like you, you probably haven't heard it or
- 31:26used it in twenty years, but it's like somewhere in your brain and you
- 31:33have to just like surface it or find it out, like I don't.
- 31:37I don't know actually how that that works or if we understand this very well,
- 31:40I can't find the word. Doesn't matter anyway, So full Crum,
- 31:41full Crum's talking about it. Hey we are see I just did the thing
- 31:47I was describing. Yeah, how does that happen? How does that work?
- 31:48Your brain hates shit like neurons and shit. Anyway, So the full
- 31:52croom of German games on it and brought it to uh brought it to game
- 31:56night and yeah, just instantly I went, not only do I think this
- 31:59will be nominated for spield as yours? I want it to be to be
- 32:01schpield as yours. I think it is a brilliant game that can be played
- 32:05by all that is tactical, and it brings people together and it's all about
- 32:09reading other people's minds. It's absolutely spectacular. Do you know what the German
- 32:13word for full crum is. It's a very very preventive language. Where'd it
- 32:21come from? Ful chrom? It's probably Latin Latin for sure? Latin?
- 32:24All right? Anyway, So do you not think that yag Schnitzel or pray
- 32:29another Day is a bit too late to be nominated for shield this year?
- 32:30No? Absolutely not no, all right? So I'm pulling for you,
- 32:35Matt, just to get her to come back over here. So the biggest
- 32:37surprise this year for Stevie it was ks he's a broke stroke infamost traffic sure,
- 32:46And for me it was pray another day. So let's go on to
- 32:49the next toward shore we Steve. You know you love to have a good
- 32:53old moan. It's your disappointment of the year, all right, Steve.
- 33:04You love a good moment as much as I do. This is my longest
- 33:06list. Actually, I have quite a few disappointments. So I love my
- 33:09Ben. Yeah, Ben, again, did you do that thing? What
- 33:15ten print ben twenty go to ten? Yeah, so that basically that program
- 33:22prints out a complete list of my disappointment. Yeah, into eternity. Yeah,
- 33:27we'll do it infinitely. I mean until the heat death of the universe
- 33:30I suppose, or your computer breaks. Yeah. Amazing, that's that's the
- 33:35coding I know. Yeah, Pressed, I don't know why you don't do
- 33:37it professionally exactly. So Matt Green is the king of the the take yep,
- 33:45and the efficiently worded take. He likes takes, doesn't He does like
- 33:49takes so all of all temperatures, I would say, yeah, the hottest
- 33:53of all possible. So he said, played Twilight Imperium for the first time
- 33:57this year, and I like this bit. It was like the last thirty
- 34:01years of game design never happened. Discuss Wow, he wants us to discuss
- 34:07it. Well, he didn't put the word discuss. I added the word
- 34:09disc Whilight Imperium. I mean, I guess that's accurate. I mean I
- 34:15think he played. I think he played fourth edition. Though when did that
- 34:17come out five years ago? Did know? Was it only five years ago?
- 34:22Okay, So he's like saying, have you learned nothing not he just
- 34:25slashed from the past. This game is shit. Basically, it's like a
- 34:29nineteen eighties design. Yeah. Well, I'm not a big fan of it
- 34:31either. It's got like I mean, I guess because it's the fourth edition,
- 34:36it's gonna like have very strong resonances with the prior editions. I have
- 34:39no idea what editions one and two were like. And obviously stole its main
- 34:44mechanism from Puerto Rico. And then it's got about a bunch of fucking ships
- 34:47and a stupid political system, and it's long and boring and I never want
- 34:50to play well if we're talking about involved over rules, heavy amritrash games.
- 34:57This is La poster En, isn't it. But it was a surprise for
- 35:00him. I mean, people, really disappointment. This is sorry we moved
- 35:04on different worlds tape, are we? This is a top top top moment.
- 35:07No disappointment, So Ben, remember Ben Ben? Okay, okay,
- 35:13I'm back on down that. I had a rough night last night. I
- 35:16got to bed at two in the morning. I was drunk. I woke
- 35:20up at like five. I thought you stayed up all night thinking about the
- 35:24wards for this child. Really tired because of all of the mental energy I've
- 35:29been expending coming up with awards for this fucking podcast. But it is so
- 35:34so. I don't hate T I four. People love it. Though I
- 35:37hate T I three, people love T I whatever. I don't. I
- 35:39don't really I don't hate T I four. But it is bang fucking average.
- 35:45So why why does it have like a cult following? Because it say
- 35:49that it does, Yeah, it does. Yeah. I think it's it's
- 35:52one of those epic long games that people just love to love, right,
- 35:55and it's it's sort of you know, I spoke to someone I can't remember,
- 36:00it wasn't I, but they told me that when they first got into
- 36:01gaming, they played it once a week. Well, as CD hunter would
- 36:05say, de gustibus known desputandum st what's that mean? There's no accounting for
- 36:10taste, dolce et decorum s propatrimorris day. Do you believe that though?
- 36:15Ben absolutely, especially if your country's Benonia Benonia. So we're going on to
- 36:22Severin. My disappointment was probably flash Points South China Sea. It was just
- 36:27procedural with very little tension, and here I was hoping for a little fix
- 36:30of CDG tension and flavor. I find the subject pretty interesting too, so
- 36:35it didn't have too much to grab so it didn't have to do much to
- 36:38grab me. But no, I think the dickheads are far better at this
- 36:44than we are. Yeah, really get into the weeds of the reasons why
- 36:46they don't like things. Well, I think you should give the reasons.
- 36:49And it's interesting because I get the feeling at the moment because of the mood
- 36:53you're in. Yeah, you could put any CDG down in front of you
- 36:57and you'd love it. Yes, you see, completely obsessed with is an
- 37:00idea? I mean, is that not legit? It's interesting? Is that
- 37:04not legit? I went through this about a year and a half ago.
- 37:07Yeah, so what you're like, what do you like? A more evolved
- 37:08being than Yeah? So I'm like better than you? So you're like so
- 37:12when I look at you, it's like a glimpse at my future of fuck.
- 37:14Yeah, you know, are you going to tell the You're going to
- 37:16tell the audience what happened at game night? Steve on Thursday night? What
- 37:21happened at game night? How I got my night ruined by some fucking idiot
- 37:24lad at game night? I don't remember what happened that he assumed that we
- 37:31have a familial collect I was. I was waiting for the right moment to
- 37:36bring it up, Dad, I told, I told this, Wait a
- 37:39minute, Wait a minute, is that why you cut the beard off?
- 37:42That's why I've cut off? Right, Listens, fucking Santa Claus walks into
- 37:49the game night with me and some brando. First time thought Ben was my
- 37:53dad? He just went, those are those two father and son? What?
- 38:00But like, why would he even ask? Like why would that even
- 38:02be a surprise? Probably plenty of father and son duos like us who go
- 38:07to game night. Well, the point is right, you probably wasn't joking.
- 38:12He was jour he was so So the thing is, you've got less
- 38:15gray hair than me, much much less well on hardly on your face,
- 38:20hardly any on your face. You've got less gray hair than me. My
- 38:22beard is basically white man, but like on my head, it's still normal
- 38:25college and you, I would say, on average, you look younger than
- 38:30me. Right, how old did your girlfriend think? I was, Yeah,
- 38:32I'm not talking about this, And I mean, how fucking stupid is
- 38:37that you look younger than me? But you don't look young enough to be
- 38:42my fucking son. Now I see his point. I mean, I guess
- 38:45the more time I spent hanging out with you, people are like, oh,
- 38:46those are the old guys. But oh no, that's definitely true.
- 38:50That that's what I have been assuming this whole time was happening. Would you
- 38:52reach over there, Steven? Is this why every time we go to a
- 38:54bar together they card me? Yeah? Exactly, that's it. Yeah,
- 38:59So would you reach over there, Stephen? Pull that game out from the
- 39:00shelf, which one Tammany Hall. Ye? Why because I'm going to tell
- 39:05a story about Tammany Hall as well. You've got a Christmas pickle over here
- 39:09I have. I want you to look at Tammany Hall and then look.
- 39:15Bear in mind that image is that Boss Tweed. We were playing a game
- 39:20of that the other week and we were playing. There was a there's a
- 39:22girl, we know, a Bosnian girl who was playing, who was quite
- 39:25young, in her twenties, and do you know what she said to me?
- 39:28What you look like? This guy? We find a top hat and
- 39:30you look exactly like the bloke on the front cover of Tammany Hall's Dude.
- 39:35I bet she thought that was hilarious. Hilarious, But was she joking?
- 39:39Well, I don't know. People joke, didn't they? But she was,
- 39:43which I wasn't in that game? Right? No? No, I
- 39:45did play this with you anyway. So I think this guy is trying to
- 39:50sneak in a cheeky sponsorship without paying the money. Okay, who's that?
- 39:53His username is BJ from Board Game Gumbo. I think Board Game Gumbo might
- 39:59be a podcast. You've never heard of it. They probably did win the
- 40:01Golden Geek Award though. Yeah, yeah, I mean I'm never gonna anyway.
- 40:05So, oh, you're gonna love this. You're gonna love this,
- 40:07Steve BJ. It doesn't stand for that, does it. You know,
- 40:13we have a large sort of like warehouse supermarket chain in the US called BJ's
- 40:17Discount Club. Doesn't stand for that though, does it. No? Anyway,
- 40:21so BJ, I'm just gonna call him BJ because then he doesn't get
- 40:25his cheapest sponsorship. BJ Expeditions was my biggest disappointment. I enjoyed my first
- 40:32play, but liked it less and less with each successive play until I hit
- 40:38the negative like territory. Well, I was thinking about this. The thing
- 40:45is, to me, a disappointment is when you have high expectations and you're
- 40:49let down. Yeah, I did not have high expecting normally, therefore I
- 40:52wasn't let down. I thought it was fucking terrible though. I thought Expeditions
- 40:54was fucking dog shit. So why did you think so? Just because it's
- 40:59a doll g So I like that central mechanism with you where you choose the
- 41:04actions. I think that's quite clever, but it's a very dull game.
- 41:07It's like, just choose actions for the sick of choosing acts? Right,
- 41:08It takes too long. It pretends to be thematic and it's not. That's
- 41:12what I absolutely zero theme. And that those bullshit scoring conditions. If it's
- 41:19a Tuesday, score five points. So it's just you can tell. So
- 41:22this is the problem with stone By Games, I think, is that if
- 41:27you're sad today, score twenty points. Right. And he has this sort
- 41:30of idea that every game, so he said to me, every game has
- 41:35got to play from one to five players every game. Okay, She's like,
- 41:38why five? He's decided on five and five is a terrible player game.
- 41:44And then he wants to cram the box full of shit. And you
- 41:46could see Expeditions really highlighted this that you would have certain score conditions that seem
- 41:51sort of in keeping with the game, and then he'd just run out of
- 41:53ideas and fucking just put anything in. Just put anything in, because you've
- 41:59got to get that much content. And that is that is really I mean,
- 42:05I like I like games that are tightly, brilliantly designed. The point
- 42:10is and it comes from and a sort of American attitude. And I always
- 42:14blame the Americans, but this definitely is. We have to add that to
- 42:16the drinking game rules. Yeah, but it's just the Americans for something.
- 42:21So it's this, it's this fatuous idea that the amount of content equals the
- 42:25replay I mean, that's the problem with this game. It's like a bunch
- 42:29of content disguised as a game. Yeah, exactly, run around and collect
- 42:32points for some reason, more content, and you not use Giant minis to
- 42:36do it for some reason, for some reason, more content does not equal
- 42:40more replayability. It just does not. And Expositions is the great example of
- 42:45this. And the thing it's pointless as well, because it's so baggy and
- 42:50poorly designed. It's got no replayability. You're not gonna fucking replay It's it's
- 42:53a really awful game. I mean, I think more and more because of
- 42:57the market and uh, the way just business works, Like more and more
- 43:02games are being published that or not like we're looking for masterpieces. I mean,
- 43:06you know, we're we're very picky people in the gaming world. So
- 43:08it's fine, though, I think I think there are there are so many
- 43:12like game products, right, and I think Jamie Stegmeier is probably the best
- 43:17in the world at producing game products, right, Like, he is really
- 43:21good at this. And they're not games though, are they? You know,
- 43:24people will argue that they are games. But but to me, like
- 43:28the point of the game is like I want to design a great game.
- 43:30It's like I want to design a product that will sell. So here's some
- 43:34mechanisms that sort of work, and I'll paste a theme on it to sell
- 43:37it, and then I'll have really posh components. Yeah, exactly. And
- 43:40he is the he really is the archetype of this. And we have a
- 43:45person in our game group who is in some sort of cults around Jamie Steen.
- 43:50He's a subscriber to the cult. Yeah, and it's so weird that.
- 43:52So we played a Pury the other night and it's fine. I enjoyed
- 43:57a Pury. It's not a bad game, right, he didn't design it.
- 44:00No, but it's it's nothing more than an average work replacement game.
- 44:04I mean, I gave it seven to be nice, but it's a bang
- 44:07average workplace. You need to play it again? Absolutely not, No,
- 44:10I would. So it's one of those games, right, Like like I
- 44:13have no desires to play Expeditions again, right zero, And I will never
- 44:16fucking go near Tapestry again. But aperiod I play it again, and so
- 44:21it's good, it's good. I would even go so far as to say
- 44:22it's good, but good is not? I mean, really, I don't
- 44:29want to sit down and do like yet another iteration of like action selection card
- 44:34collection. I don't know what Aperry is about. That's like Expeditions to me,
- 44:37and like it's like I have to learn these fucking games and it better
- 44:40be like novel and unique if I have to go to that much trouble to
- 44:44learn it and then have to learn it again every time I play it.
- 44:45Otherwise, what's the point. It's like a bunch of should have seen before
- 44:50and not not even like well honed and done in a better way. No,
- 44:53I mean, this is the big fucking drawback with stigmaias games right well
- 44:59honed. I have never come across games for the less honed in my life.
- 45:05And our mutual friend is defending this practice. Oh it's and that's what.
- 45:08It would have been impossible to properly balanced tapestry, and it had to
- 45:12go out into the world and like get play tested after being published post publication,
- 45:17play testing to show that it was broken. And it's unconscionable. Unconscionable,
- 45:22so I don't cunsion that shit. This one from Dingbat, which is
- 45:27fascinating, great great moniker. By the way, this is because I have
- 45:31never disagreed with a statement more than this, and I was singularly unqualified to
- 45:37comment on it until Thursday night. M no contest. Biggest disappointment was Challengers,
- 45:45and that's an achievement considering I didn't really have any expectations. I know
- 45:49I'm not the target audience for SDJ and in recent years even the Kennishpiel,
- 45:52but Challenges is such a poor offering. I felt get this. I felt
- 45:58vicarious embarrassment for the people involved in the SDJ. The twenty twenty three Kennish
- 46:02Beer Winner is possibly the worst game of the year. Wow, controversial,
- 46:07scuss. I don't think he is completely wrong, and I think you and
- 46:14I probably well we disagree. That's out of my mind. I mean we
- 46:19don't. We don't have to have the same preferences all the time carry on.
- 46:22So I think I would probably have to play it again to have a
- 46:25proper judgment when you are going to yeah, well, I'm ext I'm looking
- 46:29forward to playing it in this kind of format, like we have eight people
- 46:32and it actually feels like a bit of a tournament, so it is like
- 46:36what is special about it? I think the dynamics that it creates are very
- 46:38interesting. You don't see that kind of thing like ever. We have like
- 46:42pairs of people facing off against each other and you switch seats and then there's
- 46:47a final at the end. I mean, I don't know if the novelty
- 46:51will last that long, Like maybe after one play I'll be satisfied. So
- 46:54to me, it felt like a kind of average deck building game with a
- 47:00bit of like like like wrote playing, Like you get your deck together and
- 47:05then you just kind of play through it. There aren't like loads of decisions
- 47:07to make, and once the deck is set, there might be cards that
- 47:09change things around a bit. It didn't strike me as brilliant or anything.
- 47:14It is fun, but as far as being a design, not like that
- 47:20great. So to put this in context for the listeners, last Thursday night
- 47:23game night, we played a couple of games and then the guy who we
- 47:28were with said, oh, why don't we play challenges? Yeah, I'm
- 47:30glad we did. I was like, Okay, let's play challenges because we
- 47:32should. We should in one, the Kennishpiel, right, and I've never
- 47:35got around to playing it. And he had to learn the game, which
- 47:39is always frustrating, right because you have to sit around doing nothing while they're
- 47:43learning the game. And then I almost fell asleep reading from the rule book
- 47:45and stuff, and he explained the game and I was fuming. I was
- 47:50like, what the fuck is this shit? Right? Then we started playing
- 47:54it, and I haven't been as excited about a game as this one since
- 48:02since since my Game of the Year. That's why, that's why you're so
- 48:07protective of your opinion this game. I love that there is decisions. Those
- 48:14cards you choose and those cards you jettison are real decisions that you have to
- 48:19make. And then I love that idea, but culling cards from decks.
- 48:23It's not like it's not original, but the way it's done is so clever
- 48:28and I love and the fundamental thing that I adore at this game that is
- 48:34just that is just I don't know, without going over the top. Is
- 48:37a is a analogy for life? Oh my god? Is the Because we
- 48:43don't I want to see if you still feel this way after playing it again.
- 48:45Because we don't have free will. This is a this is a fact.
- 48:47And the way you just shuffle the cards and then you just put them
- 48:52down and you just hope the decisions you've made previously will bear out and sometimes
- 48:59they do and sometimes don't, and it is just down to skill and chance
- 49:06and it is so invigorating. It is so exciting. I find the game
- 49:10hugely original. I love the way that you swap partners. I was genuinely
- 49:16so excited that I went home that night and arranged a full player meet up
- 49:22for this for the next game night. Well, I was, honestly,
- 49:23you and Dingbat are night and day here. So excited. I sent a
- 49:28Facebook message to the designer saying, this game is fucking brilliant. Wow.
- 49:31I mean I don't just I don't agree with any of that. I don't
- 49:35think it's that special, but like I need to, I honestly don't understand
- 49:38why you were so taken with it. I mean, I really take him.
- 49:42I need I need to wait and see. So I think that if
- 49:44you're a dickhead like Dingbat, I completely understand where he's coming from, because
- 49:49surely this game isn't for him or the kind of audience who tends not to
- 49:53go for spield CRS games. Now it fits very well in that category.
- 49:58Right. It's a it's a light game. It's simple, it's an event.
- 50:00It's like simplicity. I guess is as genius in some way, Like
- 50:04if you look at it as a kind of fun activity, I have nothing
- 50:07to say against it, Like I don't think it's imbalanced or something or poorly.
- 50:13I just didn't find it particularly exciting. Don't think it's an activity.
- 50:15I think it is very much. I don't find it exciting to flip over
- 50:19cards until someone wins. I think it's very It's replete with very important decisions.
- 50:25It is hugely exciting that the simple things clearly an occasion for loads of
- 50:30trash talking games are events and the idea that you have that card which tells
- 50:36you who your opponent's going to be and swap opponents is just I was.
- 50:39I was genuinely blown away by it. I was really surprised because I expected
- 50:43to hate it, and I was genuinely blown away. I absolutely I think.
- 50:46I think the dynamics with it will be very interesting. So I'm looking
- 50:49forward to that. And I think it's perfectly fine to have a game that
- 50:52creates a sense of occasion, right, and you can judge it on that
- 50:55basis, and not simply like mechanistically or as a design like going in with
- 50:59your two wheezers and dissecting it until it's dead. But I do think that
- 51:04your opinion is exaggerated, but we'll see I disagree anyway. So Steve,
- 51:09what is I'm gonna do a drum roll on the table there. I'll just
- 51:13stick one in, Steve, what is your gaming disappointment? The biggest,
- 51:19biggest disappointment of the year is fucking OOLI sticking his head in front of the
- 51:23fucking cam, ruining the live stream. You didn't see. You were trying
- 51:28to have a serious conversation and he could stick in his head so much so
- 51:30someone on the someone on the stream just said who's this dickhead putting their heads?
- 51:35Yeah, yeah, exactly. I thought that was extremely rude, disappointed
- 51:37ouly couldn't even like leave you alone for five mins to do a live stream.
- 51:42So that's the pick the runner up. I wonder if you and I
- 51:45are gonna have the same one. I bet we do, And if we
- 51:47don't, you're gonna change your answer. Okay, you're gonna fucking fall all
- 51:51over yourself to agree with me if you didn't pick this. And it happened
- 51:54almost exactly a year ago. Oh god, and that is when you and
- 51:59I sat down very much looking forward to playing a little game called weather Machine.
- 52:05Oh it's not it's not my You were more disappointed by something than weather
- 52:09Machine. Yes, and when I say it, you will completely You'll go,
- 52:15oh yeah, yeah that man. I still haven't listened to the Darwin's
- 52:16Journey episode. I'm afraid, but weather Machine is. So it's not just
- 52:21weather Machine for me. It was basically I think I changed my entire opinion
- 52:27about vital ASERTA. Yeah, like in the past, I would sight unseen
- 52:30by any game he put on Kickstarter. And they're fucking expensive and they're getting
- 52:36more expensive every every year. Every every release, and I just found this
- 52:40game to be I'll use a word you like to use a lot. It
- 52:44was a fucking palaver. A great writer once I sold it, A great
- 52:49writer. Steve once said. The reason games are said to be designed,
- 52:52rather composed, written, or created is that they have an intrinsic utility.
- 52:57Mcgreet's compaint The Son of Man with no thigh orders to whether the poor bloke
- 53:00can see with that apple in front of his face. Games are different.
- 53:04The machines and machines must function to have value. Therefore they're designed. Good
- 53:08games, though, not only have a machine that works, but the user's
- 53:12interaction with that machine is mediated by an interface, an interface that ameliorates the
- 53:16raw complexity of the machine and allows our limited cognition to manipulate it, like
- 53:22a key that starts a car. Most people, when confronted with a naked
- 53:25componentry of an engine, will have no idea what to do. It's the
- 53:29same with games without a simplifying user interface, most players will come bogged down
- 53:35in simply making the machine run, rather than having fun with it. Games
- 53:38are not an engineering degree, So if this is true about the game,
- 53:43it fails. Whether machine fails. Yeah, yeah, yeah, well I
- 53:50agree. I mean, you know, you put a lot of like heart
- 53:53and soul into your fandom, right, and then a big new box shows
- 53:58up and you're fucking excited and you punch all of it out. And I
- 54:00have to say, like the size of it, like the deluxification of it,
- 54:05the expense of it, it kind of makes it more exciting. And
- 54:08we sat down and we played it and was just like absolutely awful, absolutely
- 54:13awful. So my big disappointment. You won't be surprised after I tell you.
- 54:17So. I went to Essen this year looking forward to two games,
- 54:21really looking forward to two games. One was Match of the Century, great
- 54:25game. That was not my disappointment. I think that game is fabulous.
- 54:29We have to do a battle report for that, I certainly do. But
- 54:31there was another game. It was an abstract game. I was hugely excited
- 54:36for it. It had a really cool theme, and also it was designed
- 54:40by two of the greatest designers who've ever graced board game design, Matthias Karma
- 54:46Rama and Keisling. Mattias Tyus Keysling is it Karma and Karma and Mikhail Keisling
- 54:54Michelle Keesling. And and this was a megdala. Oh yeah, Migdala was
- 55:04awful. So you were more, Oh, I see disappointed in the sense
- 55:07that you had higher expectations. Really wanted to love this. I don't have
- 55:10to try to play it like twice. Yeah, it's terrible and it doesn't
- 55:15work. It doesn't work, it doesn't make function, it doesn't make sense.
- 55:17It's like it's fucking stupid. It's stupid being mean. No, I
- 55:22thought that this game. I like Weather Machine. I didn't think it was
- 55:25stupid. I had a different reaction to it. This game. I thought
- 55:29like, is this even a game? Right? And the thing is,
- 55:30it's really beautiful. It's by board and have you heard has anyone has anyone
- 55:35like contradicted you on this? So no, oh, you don't get it.
- 55:37I don't think anyone's played it, honestly. And it's from game Brewer
- 55:40that usually do good games. And I was really excited a krama keasling abstract.
- 55:45I want an abstract for me, stee, I haven't discovered an abstract
- 55:50yet that I feel is like my abstract, the abstract I want to play.
- 55:54And I'm looking on your your game shelf here and are there any abstract?
- 56:00No, I don't think, so, you don't tend to gravitate chest.
- 56:02I've got war chest, which is kind of abstract. Definitely, you
- 56:06don't tend to gravitate toward them. But this one, wow, just that
- 56:12was the thing. I thought, fucking krama keasling. Like the last game
- 56:15I played from them was Paris, and I adored Paris. I thought it
- 56:21was brilliant, and I thought this was going to be brilliant and it was
- 56:22an art abject failure. I mean, we were a little tired and emotional
- 56:27when we played it. Did we where? Did we play it? At
- 56:29quin Book? And it's okay? Oh yeah, you had a copy.
- 56:31And it was so hugely disappointing. I was, and I was angry by
- 56:37how bad the game was by two of the masters. You know, hey,
- 56:42how come we're not drinking tea out of your brand new mug with because
- 56:46that is at another location. Oh I see I drink it from there.
- 56:52I see, I see so so I was hoping to watch you do it.
- 56:55So for the listeners, Steve's biggest disappointment in front of the camera,
- 57:00yep and weather machine and mine a migdala. What a bloody nightmare. Let's
- 57:06move on in and act of craven self indulgence. We find out your five
- 57:13g thre d moment of the year. So here we ask Steve, this
- 57:17was it was a good year this year, wasn't it. Yeah, a
- 57:20lot of great moments. I have a feeling everybody's gonna agree about the top
- 57:23moment though, Oh really, yeah, I think so. I have no
- 57:25bloody idea. I haven't read them. No, I mean I have.
- 57:29They don't agree with each other, they're not all the same. No,
- 57:31Oh the fuck is wrong with the dickheads? There's no idea, there's only
- 57:35one top moment. Well, I don't even know what you're talking about.
- 57:37So all right, Well I've got a few top moments to talk about.
- 57:38But let's get to it. Someone someone you might know, Steve famed board
- 57:43games on Isaac Shane, board game designer Isaac Shalv. What is his top
- 57:46moment? Get this. Larriacon twenty twenty three segments featuring at Uli Blaze Forehead
- 57:53were pretty epic. So if you haven't if you have, check if you
- 58:00haven't seen this, this is one of my live streams that hasn't been removed
- 58:02from my channel. Go back to the Larriacon live stream from last year and
- 58:08Uli was hilarious in just sticking his head in front of the camera the entire
- 58:15time, and it was a good live stream. Steve couldn't do it.
- 58:16We were going to co host it together, but that's another disappointment getting So
- 58:23yeah, Richard Norkle, So he said he's gone my favorite interview route?
- 58:30Which one? Which one? Do you reckon favorite interview? I mean you
- 58:34listened to him on fucking nine x, so you don't remember them. I
- 58:36would have to actually look at remembering to podcasts for you? Is it just
- 58:40about keeping out the on rushing void from mensering your ears? You have to
- 58:46do something. It's very true, all right? So five games for Doomsday?
- 58:52You have two feeds. You have five games for Doomsday. The F,
- 58:55the G, and the D are capitalized as in title case. Then
- 58:59you have disp matches from the cabin period for some reason full stop as you
- 59:02say, I could like a full stop like sentence case. What do you
- 59:07think dispatch you from the cabin is it's not consistent with five games for rooms
- 59:12day? That's the Patreon Yeah, no, Petreon, and I know,
- 59:14I know, but you're not You're not consistent in your titling is what I'm
- 59:16trying to say. I don't know any grammar. Yeah, sure you don't
- 59:20know. You don't try, No, I don't try. Fuck you try.
- 59:22All right, Let's look at your interviews for the past year. Okay,
- 59:27this is really exciting, right, David Thompson, Ryan Courtney, Oh
- 59:30this is twenty twenty two. Excuse me? Oh oh shit, I picked
- 59:36myself. That was twenty twenty four four first one, it's twenty twenty four,
- 59:38Stave. Yeah, I mean I remember there was one in particular that
- 59:43I genuinely thought was a great interview, and I think it dropped relatively recently.
- 59:50And I'm stalling for time so that I can scroll back through the list.
- 59:55And god, there's so many odd think calendar episodes. Yeah, yeah,
- 59:59well twenty five them taking taking me a while to Oh, you know,
- 1:00:05I thought I thought Rodney Smith was Smith was good? Yeah, up
- 1:00:07five G for d classics, Martin Wallace always good. If I can pick
- 1:00:12something that's a classic episode, you know what, Donald x Vaccarino, I
- 1:00:17think I think I had to standout episode. I had to do a lot
- 1:00:21of things in that episode, but he was good a lot of but a
- 1:00:22lot of like a lot of lore, I would say, yeah, a
- 1:00:25lot of law. Yeah, so maybe I'd go with that one actually,
- 1:00:28so Richard decided on ses Al Jazar. There was also a very good one.
- 1:00:35Yeah, talked about being a refugee from bag Dad, talked about failing
- 1:00:37at Cambridge, fascinating stuff. Yeah, I could pick so Jen's Dehammer Foltmann.
- 1:00:45So he says, so I put this in just because it always so.
- 1:00:50You're not someone who experienced his emotions, right, what would you mean
- 1:00:53so you told you before anger? Oh? Sorry, sorry, I experienced
- 1:00:58emotion. And you don't ever think about this. When you produce something that
- 1:01:06people are going to actually value it, you think of it very much,
- 1:01:09even though I put a lot of effort, and you think of it as
- 1:01:13disposable content because that's what the Internet is. And some people really love stuff.
- 1:01:17And YenS wrote, how is a wonderful distraction? On so many days
- 1:01:21in hospital full of dark thoughts and fear. I can hardly put into words
- 1:01:24how much the podcast has helped me cope with the last twelve months. Enough
- 1:01:29of the sentimentality. Now let's get some cursing and swearing, you dickheads.
- 1:01:32That's Patreon dot com slash five games for doomsday. Yeah. So the thing
- 1:01:37is, it's fascinating, isn't it, Because podcasts do do that. Podcasts
- 1:01:43do stop the on rushing void entering your body, just the sound of familiar
- 1:01:47voices. I mean, we are here for the parasocial relationship. And this
- 1:01:52is why podcasts are a different artfulm to radio. They're not radio. Podcasts
- 1:01:55are something uniquely themselves. I mean it's undermanded, right. Well, it's
- 1:02:00not just the it's not just the means of delivery. It's a stylistic thing
- 1:02:04as well. Right, neither the two middle aged men bantering style. Yeah
- 1:02:07exactly. I mean I'm not middle aged. I'm I'm your elderly. I'm
- 1:02:10still young. You know, fucking look like your dad. Bonzo said the
- 1:02:15discussions in hashtag Channel m He liked the hashtag channel and the accompanying podcasts weren't
- 1:02:22too bad either. I mean, hashtag channel has fucking gone off the rails
- 1:02:25in my opinion. And people love a people People love a bathos, don't
- 1:02:29they. Yeah, don't people love a beathos? I mean, certainly the
- 1:02:31last two posts, what the last two posts? They love a beathos?
- 1:02:37The last two posts in hashtag channel right now. No, the last two
- 1:02:39posts I just read, Yeah love a beathos. Yeah, I get the
- 1:02:43point, all right, very pathetic. Oh I hate this one. This
- 1:02:47is my least favorite post. I was thinking of not putting it in,
- 1:02:52but I put it in. Gotta be fair to the dickheads. I really
- 1:02:54hate this post. And I know Ben hates to hear this is from Dingbat.
- 1:02:58I know Ben hates to hear this. But there's been a lot more
- 1:03:01hashtag and there's been a lot hashtag more Steve in the feed this year,
- 1:03:06and it has been glorious. I mean, I think he's right. It's
- 1:03:08not exactly a top moment though, right Well, every every moment you are,
- 1:03:15you're like a fucking You're like a sixties freak character any time you're a
- 1:03:19microphone. The thing is you always take like whatever feedback people give you,
- 1:03:22you always listen to it, like the last thing that you've heard, you
- 1:03:25do it. Yeah, exactly, And because you know you want to give
- 1:03:28the people what they want exactly. And if that's going to be more Stephen
- 1:03:30the feed, so be it. I'm not sure how many people change that
- 1:03:34this year. Matt Green, Matt fucking Murder you, Matt Green. The
- 1:03:38five Year Retrospective was a highlight for me. It walked the line between being
- 1:03:42reflective and melancholy with like a I wasn't in that, and it was a
- 1:03:46feel good, positive piece. You were fucking you featured it. There's a
- 1:03:49whole section about you in it. Oh wait, this isn't about like a
- 1:03:52games retrospective. This is no, it was so this is Yeah, you
- 1:03:55did have a section. I spent I spent weeks. I listened to it
- 1:03:59at three, I went. I spent weeks writing, sourcing, editing the
- 1:04:05five year thank you to the listeners and the retrospective. It was beautiful.
- 1:04:10I went, I went back through all of it. I remember every word.
- 1:04:13God barely fucking listened to it, got almost no downloads, and no
- 1:04:17one spoke about it. How does it feel to be unappreciated, unfucking believed,
- 1:04:21and even your appreciation is appreciated, Matt Green? Matt Green, there,
- 1:04:25and Jim crim says, the Jason Matthews interview is an excellent discussion.
- 1:04:29Yep, you know that's another good pick. We talked about child trafficking.
- 1:04:31Yeah, very few board game shows talk about that. You know, that's
- 1:04:34one I might have picked if I had remembered the full list. All right,
- 1:04:36So come on on, Steve, let's talk about your five g F
- 1:04:40D that you think everyone. No one's mentioned it yet, I assume h
- 1:04:44Nope. In fact, I guess I was wrong that everybody wouldn't pick the
- 1:04:47same one. But I think you and I probably did, so I'm gonna
- 1:04:49have to agree with famed board game designer Isaac Shaalev, who is sticking his
- 1:04:54head in the live stream at Laria Khan was fucking great. Top moment of
- 1:04:58the moment, top moment. Run her up. I have to say,
- 1:05:01the birth of Tabuletto. Oh, that's royal loose, Steve. I got
- 1:05:05born this year, didn't I? Yes, well, last year Tabuletto,
- 1:05:08Oh last year, that's try. It's new year this year. Yeah,
- 1:05:11you're not quite one year old yet. But it depends on what calendar you
- 1:05:14go by, don't it. Yeah? But fortunately go by the Obarma calendar,
- 1:05:17don't you? So do you do? You go by the Obama calendar?
- 1:05:21Steve? What's that Tabuletto? Well he changed the calendar, didn't he,
- 1:05:26when he was President Obama? How did he change it? Ah?
- 1:05:29Well, if you don't know, you're still in the matrix, aren't you.
- 1:05:31You know, the more time I spend with you, the more I
- 1:05:33feel like I'm coming out of it. Do you take the red pill,
- 1:05:35Steve? Or will you stay with Obama in the blue Land? Steve?
- 1:05:42I'm fully red pilled tabuletto. Oh you look it. Does that mean that
- 1:05:46you're gonna come with me to my meeting tomorrow to throw down the deep state?
- 1:05:51Yep? Yep? Ready to go? Why don't you go pack?
- 1:05:55Are you gonna piss off? Now? All right? All right? So
- 1:05:57top five g for D moment of the year the birth of ten. I
- 1:06:00think it's a wonderful moment. I would also like to point out Terresa running
- 1:06:03into us at the Christmas market and CC Runner not believing it was also great.
- 1:06:09Yeah, it was also great. So I had a load of great
- 1:06:13moments. So this podcast took me to America for the first time in my
- 1:06:15life, Yes, which was fascinating. America's a fascinating place, the best
- 1:06:20country. Luria con was great. But you know what I think my highlight
- 1:06:26was this year. I think that I kind of felt wow, And it
- 1:06:30wasn't just the free booze that I felt that this is kind of the purpose
- 1:06:33of this podcast. Ah, yeah, the spield CRS. It was so
- 1:06:36good this year. I felt like I really did some great work. I
- 1:06:40really felt like it was it was just nobody's doing it, and I really
- 1:06:46every year, well, no, because I did it twenty nineteen. Yeah,
- 1:06:51then twenty twenty two I was suffering from the COVID as you remember,
- 1:06:58Yes, I remember a Berlin con. Yes, and I snuck someone my
- 1:07:02press pass ye. And then they put it up on Instagram and tagged not
- 1:07:06only me in the post but also Berlin Retchbury or co holding up the tag.
- 1:07:14Don't remember who that was. So yeah. And last year the SDJ
- 1:07:16was great. The coverage was great. Yep. We got to talk to
- 1:07:19really interesting everyone really doing it, I think, and there was another guy
- 1:07:24there. Yeah, but I said, really doing and I really enjoyed it.
- 1:07:30And this year is gonna I'm gonna do it the same. You're gonna
- 1:07:31do whatever a year now, Yeah, but this year you're gonna actually have
- 1:07:35some work to do, like what's that carry stuff around? Operate the camerah.
- 1:07:40Oh yeah, no problem, Ben, I'm here for you anyway.
- 1:07:43So yeah, good top moment. My top moment is the SDJ, all
- 1:07:45right, shall we go on to our final award of the night. Steve,
- 1:07:48oh nervous about this is five G f d's Game of the Year.
- 1:07:50I'm not sure what your pick is gonna be. Yes, you are here.
- 1:07:57It is the greatest piece of ludologe. Who are to have greased your
- 1:08:00table this year? It's five G for these game all the year? All
- 1:08:08right? So here we ask Steve the big awards. We're gonna go through
- 1:08:13the other people. So Ambi, right, I don't really care what they
- 1:08:15picked. I want to talk about my pick. Yeah, but you know,
- 1:08:18come on, these people aren't even paying. Some of them are like
- 1:08:21which ones I'm blood? You know? All right? Fine, so Ambi
- 1:08:26Majong for me. We finally learned scoring from Majong and started getting into Richie
- 1:08:31Majong and it's been great. It's a lifestyle game that you can play again
- 1:08:34and again, which works well with the group who's all at a similar level
- 1:08:38of learning together. Is what our group is. So basically, the journey
- 1:08:41has been more than just the game, which is why it's my game of
- 1:08:43the year. You have played, Marjon. That's cute. Yeah, I
- 1:08:45guess it's like tile matching and you know, it's fine. It's quite dismissive.
- 1:08:50Like there's no sheep, there's no like bricks. You're not converting sheep
- 1:08:55into into pelt. Yeah exactly, You're not like building up an engine and
- 1:09:00and an economy with your head down while you don't talk to anyone else around
- 1:09:02the table. So I don't get it, but you do. You an
- 1:09:08mb amb and I really want to. I want even want to try and
- 1:09:11try go in twenty twenty four. All right, we can make that happen.
- 1:09:14Oh yeah, but you're gonna fucking destroy men't you like he destroyed me
- 1:09:15at every game. That's just the way it goes. The battle report is
- 1:09:18going to be amazing. Oh yeah, we gotta do that. We gotta
- 1:09:21make that happen. Resolution, resolution corollary. You're gonna love this. Matt
- 1:09:26GREENO two publish this year. He questions, m Pirates of Maracaiboah, yeah,
- 1:09:32you haven't played it. I haven't played it. I think it's very
- 1:09:34good. Is it better than fucking Shitakaibo? I think that you will agree
- 1:09:39that it is the superior game and actually subsumes the original Maracaibo. I don't
- 1:09:45necessarily agree with that it does title. Shut up carry on. It does
- 1:09:50capture the essence of the sort of well like shit, the essence of ship.
- 1:09:56I think he's very good at designing games that really Deck of Card,
- 1:10:00no the deck of cards. So Boon Lake has this, Mark has Mac
- 1:10:05takes too long, got loads of I think has this, and UH based
- 1:10:12on the Western Trail has it, and Powers of Maracaivo is entirely focused on
- 1:10:16the cards. So it does capture, like I think, the essence of
- 1:10:19you know, you can't say that Alexander Fister isn't good at anything. It's
- 1:10:25games rules solid, but just like I do in this case, I think
- 1:10:28it's actually much tighter than you typically experienced playing his games. And there's like
- 1:10:32some essence of what he's good at as a designer that this game captures.
- 1:10:35So you should give it a shot. I definitely will give it a shot.
- 1:10:39I wonder if I like it, though, so BJ and I'm not
- 1:10:42going to read the rest of his name can't stand for that. Just someone
- 1:10:45who's using their nickname as a way to promote something. Yeah that podcast,
- 1:10:47Yeah, I mean, you know, fucking write a check right exactly check
- 1:10:53novel, the unbearable likeness of being Maybe who is that Milan kundera. Ye,
- 1:10:59did you read that? Yeah? Is it good? Yeah, it's
- 1:11:00good. Like is it worth it? Oh? Yeah, really good?
- 1:11:02Yeah, Like I have a copy. I don't remember anything of it,
- 1:11:04but it's really good. I remembers the problem with reading all these great books.
- 1:11:06You don't really remember them. You remember the feeling that you hadn't you
- 1:11:10read it, But that's about it. Did you see that great meme?
- 1:11:12I think I sent it you, that great meme where Gregor Sampson's lay on
- 1:11:15his bed. Yeah. Yeah, the phone is saying, yeah, I
- 1:11:18know that sounds bad, dude, but you've really got to come in today
- 1:11:21because we're on the staff. Yeah. Very fun. He's spent a lot
- 1:11:25of your time looking at memes, and I do. I love memes,
- 1:11:27So BJ says, at the risk of riding Ben's coattails, I got a
- 1:11:31very shortcoat, so you'd be like climbing on me. I've got Last Light,
- 1:11:35great Game, Rats of Wistar, and Tales to Amaze as my three
- 1:11:40favorite published this year. It is Last Light, that science fiction game you've
- 1:11:43been playing lately, is that? Yeah? First Late that's the last true
- 1:11:45Last Light down here, So I need to play that one. Yeah,
- 1:11:47Last Light and what else? Rats of Wistar. Yeah you play this,
- 1:11:51don't you. Yeah? We have a mutual friend, the same one who
- 1:11:56loves Jamie. Yeah, exactly, he's got a copy. So we've got
- 1:11:58to play that. And tails to a man and I don't know what that
- 1:12:00is, Scott Hill says, Oh, you're gonna love this. I love
- 1:12:05it. Game of the Year for me has to be Darwin's Journey. While
- 1:12:10none of the design elements present in this game are particularly unique or innovative,
- 1:12:14no shit, Luciani and Manjoe have expertly pulled them together in ways I've never
- 1:12:19seen before to provide the players with all the tools they need to navigate the
- 1:12:23ever shifting landscape of it at times brute brutally restrictive decision space. I think
- 1:12:29you overreacted to this game, which absolutely I did. We should we should
- 1:12:31play again and the other side of the board. We should definitely play again,
- 1:12:34and I should see whether it's any good And YenS to hammer fold Man,
- 1:12:39who seems to be cropping up a lot. My game of the year.
- 1:12:43This is a surprising one, but I like it is. That's not
- 1:12:46a hat by Casper Lap. We played that, we did played that with
- 1:12:49a verfial Alex and indeed and family compared to my wife and our children.
- 1:12:55I suck at memory games, but the design of That's Not a Hat makes
- 1:12:58up for that. If you play it with four people, there are only
- 1:13:00five cards in the game which show simply drawn objects. All you have to
- 1:13:02do is remember which card shows which picture. But the cars are constantly being
- 1:13:05passed to the right or left, back or forth. It often only takes
- 1:13:09three or four rounds for the game turns into something like cockroach poker and you
- 1:13:12start passing misinformation around the table. Yeah. I didn't do that well at
- 1:13:15this game. I enjoyed it. We played with verfal Alex's daughter, and
- 1:13:19I don't I don't remember how old she is at the time, thirteen or
- 1:13:21something at the time, and she's very good at it. Yeah, I
- 1:13:24mean, but she was giving us so much shit, so much shit.
- 1:13:27She fucking insulted me like children these days have good memories and a day fucking
- 1:13:30my day. You know. You can get a clip round of the urol
- 1:13:34talking to your betters like that. Yeah, I do. I do like
- 1:13:36her though, because she's really into our idea that anytime anyone sees verfal Alex
- 1:13:41in public they should throw Yeah, exactly. She's constantly encouraging me to get
- 1:13:45this going, right, So Steve, yep, tell us about your game
- 1:13:51of the year. It's very exciting. So you know, OULEI sticking his
- 1:13:56head in the live stream camera. Yeah, it's not exactly what. It's
- 1:13:59not a game. I mean, it's it's playful. Yeah, it's very
- 1:14:01playful. So that's my official answer. But runner up obviously the Ironian Burger
- 1:14:06Canal promo card. Yep. Yeah, easily, easily game of the year.
- 1:14:11Now I'm gonna give you a serious answer, and I wonder if finally
- 1:14:14we're gonna agree. Maybe we've been talking about it all year long, horseless
- 1:14:19fucking carriage. Explain to us, Wine, this is your game of the
- 1:14:24year, not only my game of the year, but it's the game I
- 1:14:26picked to take to the cabin with me in controversial choice, unexpected, right,
- 1:14:31I don't I don't know, you know what it is for me.
- 1:14:34These guys they create games in which they give you so much freedom. So
- 1:14:39many other eurostyle games. You have to learn these complicated mechanisms and they can
- 1:14:44be fun and they are very stimulated, but you are definitely like railroaded through
- 1:14:47the game. These guys they design games, it's like do whatever you want.
- 1:14:51You have as much rope as you need to hang yourself, And I
- 1:14:55just I love that you you start with your empty factory floor. Every turn
- 1:14:59you get more factory floor for free. You have all the parts that are
- 1:15:02available to you at your current tech level for free, and you can build
- 1:15:06whatever assembly line you want. It doesn't cost anything. I mean, you
- 1:15:11can't like move things around later. But like it is entirely like the onus
- 1:15:15is on you to figure out the puzzle, and it's just it's like it's
- 1:15:17it's it's terrifying, right, but there's something just genius about it. There's
- 1:15:24genius about how you put together your assembly line, how you have to like
- 1:15:28figure out what cars to produce so that you're not competing in the wrong sectors
- 1:15:32because you don't want to compete with other players, or at least you want
- 1:15:36to, like, like player order in their games is so often critical,
- 1:15:40and it's really critical and horseless carriage who gets to sell first, who gets
- 1:15:44to populate the market, and and it's a game that made me want to
- 1:15:49like figure out how to become a better player. That's why I want to
- 1:15:51bring it to the cabin. It really really stimulated me. And I know
- 1:15:57that some people think it's it's somewhat poorly designed aesthetically speaking, and it's got
- 1:16:00some fiddlely components. I do not give a shit. I actually think there's
- 1:16:05something novel about the fiddliness of the components, Like those those windows, little
- 1:16:09plastic windows that you have to put down. They are definitely fidly. But
- 1:16:13I've never seen this kind of thing before. From phase to phase to phase,
- 1:16:17this game just has loads of surprises. It's very dynamic. It's like
- 1:16:20different kinds of game within one game. And I think it's just like,
- 1:16:26I don't know if they never publish another game. This is like the crowning
- 1:16:29achievement of Splotter game design. So my game of the year. People talk
- 1:16:34a lot about originality, and so rare is true originality any good Usually it
- 1:16:43needs to be mediated through some sort of medium. Originality needs to be sort
- 1:16:47of shorn of its sort of harshness and its surprise to be able for us
- 1:16:57to be able to comprehend it. Originality should not be your goal as an
- 1:17:02artist. I don't think if you even believe in such a thing, it
- 1:17:05should be creating something remix that is entertaining or that is profound or whatever.
- 1:17:14But sometimes some people come along who are utterly, completely, unremittingly original and
- 1:17:27manage to transmit that originality in a manner that can engage its consumer. Sometimes
- 1:17:39you play something and you are just blown away by the audacity of that thing
- 1:17:45that you go bloody hell. Not only have I never seen this before,
- 1:17:49but I love it too. And this is a real this is a real,
- 1:17:59rare gift. I think I know what it's going to be. I'm
- 1:18:03not gonna do Beathos here, I'm not in Bathos. You're setting me up
- 1:18:06for Bathos. I'm not doing I think I know what it's gonna be.
- 1:18:09I thought you were gonna pick a horsele's carriage as well, And so now
- 1:18:12I know what it is. I am. I feel privileged to have been
- 1:18:18in a situation where I get to play this game. The world. The
- 1:18:24worlds exists for four billion years. Human beings have existed for the number keeps
- 1:18:30going up, but we think about five hundred thousand years at this point.
- 1:18:33And yet I am fortunate enough to live at the time and place where horseless
- 1:18:40Carriage is exists. It is. I thought you're gonna pick Bonanza. No,
- 1:18:44Bonanza is wonderful, but Horseless Carriage is just so refreshing and original and
- 1:18:50exciting and engrossing and scary and rewarding and tragic and exhilarate. It is everything
- 1:19:00you want a game to be. It is absolutely brilliant and audacious and and
- 1:19:09I don't understand how people don't love it. I think for once, your
- 1:19:14your affusion has topped mind when it comes to a splatter game. But you
- 1:19:17understand why I picked this game over Antiquity to bring to the cabin. Yeah,
- 1:19:21I mean I love Antiquity too. There's a few of their games that
- 1:19:25I really love. But Horses Carriage is just so it's just so startlingly original,
- 1:19:30And you're right, they give you it is. It is that sort
- 1:19:32of You have usual touristics in games, usual design foibles. There is a
- 1:19:39currency and you have to spend that currency to acquire a resource and so on
- 1:19:44and so forth. Right with Horses Carriage, you you've just given everything for
- 1:19:50You're a manager. You're like a procuremance manager who doesn't have to spend any
- 1:19:55money, and you do. It's just you and the game. It is
- 1:19:58you and the game and there into the void. And I think maybe what
- 1:20:01distinguishes it for me from antiquity. Uh, there's some interaction in antiquity.
- 1:20:05And I don't tend to go on and on about interaction and how important it
- 1:20:09is, but I think it does make the difference. For a horseless carriage.
- 1:20:12It is fucking competitive and it's it's like, you know, the there
- 1:20:16like the raw naked evil of capitalism essentially, and these guys do that very
- 1:20:19well. And the fact that it has that more interactive element I think probably
- 1:20:27makes the difference for me. And it has the charm and it has the
- 1:20:30wit of their games. This is what people don't talk about with Splotter is
- 1:20:34how witty their games are. Yeah. I mean I see Nicole and the
- 1:20:38mechanisms themselves, like have a sense of humor. Who can do that?
- 1:20:42Yeah, I mean the Splotter guys, it is it is. It is
- 1:20:47genuinely a brilliant game, and it is a game that is destined because they
- 1:20:55can't sort their fucking production out to save their fucking lives. It is a
- 1:20:59game that's destiny to be derided for reasons that I think with all due respect
- 1:21:03to people use the fact that the colors are a bit weird on some of
- 1:21:08the things. It's completely fatuous. It's completely fatuous. I mean qu qu
- 1:21:13quittl how you will about the like the production values. I just don't care.
- 1:21:16Like the game is there, Yeah it works. Yeah, as long
- 1:21:20as you know that from the beginning, it works right, and it is.
- 1:21:24It is just we played that one game with you and me Avy no
- 1:21:29Ham Maple Pete and it was just so bloody exciting and it was long.
- 1:21:32It was three and a half four hours. Boy does eat up table space,
- 1:21:35and it was so exciting. I absolutely love it. I knew then
- 1:21:40this is my game of the year. I'm not going to play it.
- 1:21:43Yeah, it's completely engrossing and absorbing. Match of the Century comes closer,
- 1:21:46right, Bonanza I discovered this year, which is absolutely brilliant. But yeah,
- 1:21:50it has to be horseless carriage. Yeah, wow, that's a what
- 1:21:55do you call that? When we both have the same pick, it's like
- 1:21:58a reach around. Yep. Well we are, Steve at the end of
- 1:22:02our ceremony, just leaves us to wrap up, all right, Steve,
- 1:22:08you tell him how do they join the discord? Well, tabula that was
- 1:22:12indeed an exciting five G for D award show. Certainly walls. If you
- 1:22:15would like to get in on the action and possibly have your picks read out
- 1:22:18loud next year, head on over to five G for D dot com.
- 1:22:23Click on the pinnpost at the top of the page. Head on over to
- 1:22:26the discord because the pin post is actually an invit to the disc discord stroll.
- 1:22:30It will take you there immediately at the speed of light, or you
- 1:22:32know, as fast as your computer browser, because you know you might have
- 1:22:36a lot of open application. That's right, it's like slows down your machine.
- 1:22:39You probably don't have a high processing kind close close the windows, Like
- 1:22:44if you've got a nine to gen Intel, well you got a bloody do
- 1:22:46you know what I mean? Why do you have to have fifty tabs open?
- 1:22:49If you don't do upgrade your processor, get a thirteenth gen nine nine
- 1:22:54do that? Closing fucking tabs. Go to five G f D dot com,
- 1:22:58click on the link, head to the discord and you're there. You're
- 1:23:00immediately going to be immersed at endless pedantic debates between famed board game designer Isaac
- 1:23:06Shelev and seal to Me on the discords. What Discabuleto is on the discord
- 1:23:11that's true as please join and say hello to Tabo Leto and you know,
- 1:23:15let him know what you think about he's hosting Chops and you can raise the
- 1:23:18podcast five stars on our Chaps stars even your review saying oh that baby table
- 1:23:26is a bit of a sexual dynamo as the tape. That's true, tab
- 1:23:29Letto, how do you support the show, Steve? Would you'd like to
- 1:23:31support five Games for Doomsday and all of the amazing shows that Ben produces and
- 1:23:38and sometimes myself participates in, and of course tab leto Hello. Head on
- 1:23:43over to patreon dot com slash five Games for Doomsday, five G for I
- 1:23:49think it's all five G for Dino. It's pretty not chat yeah Ben Twitter.
- 1:23:55Ben has finally done something consistent in his life and uh five I think
- 1:23:59you own five G for Dinaut Then, and finally, I'd just like to
- 1:24:03say thank you to all the listeners, all the contributors for a great year,
- 1:24:10and thank you for coming to the awards. Thank you for paying me
- 1:24:14three hundred dollars. He wants to get in, I'm gonna spend it all
- 1:24:17on my new political party, Tabyo her talking and say good bye Steve,
- 1:24:23goodbye Steve.