Latest / Ego and Other Things / My Philosophy - A First Pass At What Went Wrong - Part 3
Transcript
- William: Alright, so last time we talked about how the relationship between parent and child sort of innately creates this development of the inauthentic false self within the child that goes on to associate the expression of one's own authentic values with a sort of instinctual death threat. And that throughout the child's development and later on in life, this significantly contributes to the inability for the person to discover who they truly are, discover what they genuinely value, and act for the sake of it in the world. And we talked about how, of course, this is a huge stumbling block in the journey towards personal authenticity. ⁓ just in this attempt to explain what has gone wrong. If we want a world in which everybody can act for the sake of what they genuinely value simultaneously and universally, ⁓ then this conflict that exists between that exists internally for the child that comes about as inherently in the parent child relationship, ⁓ represents a big stumbling block. And of course, later on we'll talk about or late yeah, in a in a different video we'll talk about ways of overcoming this, ways of coming over overcoming the pressures of survival, the psychological pressures of the parent-child relationship that bleed into adulthood and whatnot. But we have still yet to cover everything. We have still yet to cover the significant contributors to ⁓ inauthenticity in the world and therefore meaning and therefore a good life, a a life which is desirable. And the next thing we have to talk about that sort of gets in the way of this entire process is the state. And I want to get into a little bit about how I understand that word state because it's distinct from the word government. And the distinction between a state and between a government is going to be important later on when we're talking about how the structure of the state actually impacts in authenticity. in the way that I understand it and use it, a the term government just refers to any sort of governing body, any group of people that Creates rules and regulations and organizations and hierarchies that help organize the behavior and the decisions of a group of people. And governments can be voluntary or involuntary. An example of a voluntary government would be something like a church, a church body. One becomes a member of the church and so voluntarily submits them to the submits themselves to the church hierarchy and voluntarily submits themselves to the rules ⁓ that are set up by that church or organization. ⁓ businesses, at least actually voluntar at least voluntarily based businesses also operate in the same way. One works or participates in a business or maybe even a non profit and that business typically has in some sort of organizing structure, some sort of hierarchy, some sort of rules of behavior, expectations, stress codes, policies, whatever you whatever have you, right? And it is again a governing body, but it is voluntary in the sense that one can can come and go as as they please and or so long as the the ⁓ governing body wishes them to be there, right? They can sort of come and go as they please. And one's membership you could say it is dependent on whether one follows the rules. So they they sign up for the rules and if they break the rules and they get kicked out. This would be a voluntary organization. But then you have involuntary or force-based governing structures. And these are what I would call the state. But i and so something like the United States would be an example of a state. And it is considered a state because it's involuntary. People are sort of born into it and they don't sign up to the rules of the organization. but they are still subject to ⁓ rules ⁓ the governing body, ⁓ of whether they voluntarily enter into that agreement or not. ⁓ example you could use ⁓ a state would be sort of like a mafia ⁓ ⁓ gang, ⁓ which ⁓ let's say it informally rules over some sort of town or city, right? And the people who are born into that city or the people who lived there before the mafia came, when that mafia comes in and uses force and violence to establish itself and its rules as the way in which that community lives, ⁓ that it would be considered a state in this definition. It would be a a very small and less powerful state compared to something like the United States govern the United States government, but it would still be considered a state under this definition. ⁓ not only that, but when I'm talking about state, I'm not simply talking about the organization in and of itself. ⁓ so I'm not simply talking about Congress and the President and you know, the different b different bodies that make up the state. I'm not simply talking about, you know, I don't know, the the Don and the captains and the capos and the soldiers ⁓ these different ⁓ kinds of organizations, but I'm also talking about ⁓ kinds of organizations ⁓ ⁓ presence of the state ⁓ and perpetuates by its existence. ⁓ in ⁓ ⁓ Mafia example, there might be certain businesses that the mafia props up ⁓ for one reason or other or another in the community, ⁓ because they benefit the mafia organization. Whereas those businesses that mafia wasn't there, they might have folded or they might have not done as well, or they might have existed in a different form or changed or changed owners. While the mafia is there, those businesses exist because the mafia keeps them in place. And I don't really make a distinction in this definition between the businesses that exist because of the mafia and the mafia itself. And in a similar way, when we're talking about something like the United States government. I'm when I talk about the state, I'm not simply talking about the actual organizing body. I'm also talking about ⁓ things like corporations, which exist as an extension of the laws created or the rules created by the governing the original governing body. And the businesses and the institutions that exist, like ⁓ much of academia and much of corporate business, certain kinds of industries, for example, weapons manufacturing. ⁓ all exist in this definition as an extension ⁓ the state because they only exist because of the state's ⁓ use of violence or use of force within the country as a whole, you could say. And Both a government, a voluntary government and a state may use force as a part of their laws, you might say. But again, the distinguishment is whether or not I sort of voluntarily participate in the organization or not. Do I voluntarily join the church and submit to its rules and therefore submit to its use of force in the circumstances in which I violate those rules? Or am I forced to participate in an organization that uses force against me when I break their rules, rules to which I've never agreed to in the first place? And that distinctions matter that distinction matters because one can authentically submit oneself to a set of rules which involves force and not violate one's authenticity because one is still voluntarily acting for the sake of that manifestation of structure, organization, whatever. And one believes that there is a sort of benefit to following those rules. And is you know again willing to ⁓ willing to submit ⁓ force in the case ⁓ the violation of those rules. ⁓ ⁓ one is forced to bar p participate ⁓ a governing structure, ⁓ It is inauthentic from the get-go. It's inauthentic from the get-go because one doesn't voluntarily choose, one does not actually actively act for the sake of participating in this organization and following its rules. One doesn't actually value the rules or value the organization because one has been forced into it. So that would be the first distinction between ⁓ government and state. I'm not necessarily anti-government. I'm not anti-hierarchy, I'm not anti-rules, I'm not anti-structure, I'm not even anti- ⁓ punishment for rules, but I am anti-force in a categorical way. If one voluntarily submits to a structure, that is not considered force when ⁓ consequences were a part of that voluntary participation. But When consequences are forced on one by forcing the structure on one, that is a violation of of the of the principle of authenticity that I'm working with here. So I'm not anti-rules, anti-hierarchy, anti-government, but I am anti-state. And the distinction again is really between a voluntary participation and an involuntary participation. And there are two things so transitioning to talking about the state, there are two things about the state that prevent authenticity. ⁓ the major one or the main factor is the use of force or the threat of force in and of itself on the one hand and on the other hand is the culture which forms around the presence of that force as a result and socially and psychologically and in terms of economic incentive reinforces the acceptance, participation in, and perpetuation of the state. The example that to me that often comes to mind is the one that Foucault used when he was talking about the the Penopticon, the Penoptagon, where and he was talking about architecture in this example, but he was talking about how the structure of the building, the fact that you know you had a tower in the middle of this prison that was formed in this circular way. The tower having only one guard was able to keep in control all of the prisoners within this building. simply because of the perception problem. The fact that the one guard could look into each and every single cell around them was able to reinforce the fear that that encouraged the inmates to sort of self-regulate and perpetuate their own imprisonment. And Foucault uses this as an example and maybe even an analogy for how culture works. That The structures that we live in, the structures that have been established around us and the culture that's been established around us often incentivizes us to self-regulate and to self-enslave and to perpetuate the state of something that we don't authentically desire because of the fear of repercussion, even if the actual presence of physical force is not there. And it's always been an interesting example because, you know, I I personally I got a lot of a lot out of reading about this because it explains a lot of why when physical violence is not directly present, people still ⁓ self-regulate and even build into themselves ⁓ confirming beliefs as to why the current state of the current order is legitimate. But at the same time I think Foucault overplays his hands because he I think he relies too heavily on the cultural reinforcement at be as being the primary reason as to why the prisoners stay. And this is where I would sort of disagree with with his analysis of something like that. and the reason I would disagree is or the reason why the cultural structures which reinforce The acceptance of the state to me are not the primary obstacle, but actually the use of physical or the use or the threat of physical force is the actual issue. The reason why I would consider that to be primary is because even in the example of the Penoptagon here, if we were to remove the threat of physical force entirely, or if the prisoners were convinced that no physical force would be used against them. then no amount of architectural design, no amount of self-perpetuating belief would ultimately prevent the prisoners from leaving. Even if many of them, even if they stayed around for a long time because they continued to have this belief in the the fear of the state, or sorry, the fear of of of being perceived and if they at some point somebody is going to take a risk and no punishment is going to come. At some point somebody's going to perceive doing something wrong or trying to leave and no physical force is gonna come. And then once that one person or a few people start doing that, it shows everybody else that there's there's not an actual threat there. There's only the there was only the illusion of threat. So it's not that the culture of violence is what actually perpetuates the structure. It is the the real threat of physical force that is made efficient by a culture of perceived threat, right? The state has become incredibly efficient at ⁓ reducing how much time and energy and resources have to go in in perpetuating their own legitimacy to the point where the vast majority of people in the United States believe that they live within a government that is that is truly free and truly chosen, in which they they they the government rules by consent of the people and ⁓ that in all essence the state is is voluntary. And they've done this through a variety of cultural mechanisms that are all perpetuated or or that are ultimately reinforced by the actual threat of violence underneath the state. The actual threat of force. Now, how does this how does this relate to authenticity? Well, you know, the it it's pretty clear in the sense that to the degree to which there is force being used against you, you cannot act for the sake of what you truly value. In fact, the presence of force is the very opposite of authenticity. It means that you're you are being forced to act for the sake of things that you don't value. Because if you value them, you would simply act for the sake of them voluntarily. I mean if you value them in an ultimate sense, in a way that in a way that actually meant you were moving towards what you desired, ⁓ you wouldn't need somebody to use force against you to go there, right? Like if you want to go get groceries, nobody has to point a gun at your head in order for you to go, because you authentically want the food, right? So you get up and go voluntarily. Nobody has to point a gun at your head if that's what you truly want. Whenever force is used against you, it means you are being you are necessarily acting against what you value. Or you're being forced to choose between two things that you don't value, like we used in the robbery example, where the presence of the gun and the threat of the use of force ⁓ forces you to choose between two authenti inauthentic values, or Forces you to choose between two values, which you don't naturally have to choose between, right? So you're either your life or the wallet. What you really want is your life and the wallet, but now you have to choose between two, and so now you've been forced into an inauthentic choice. and that that's sort of the mechanism of how the threat of force ultimately ends up in the same thing as the actual use of physical force. Now, the state doesn't operate. primarily on the direct use of force. It operates on the ⁓ the threat of force principally. And that's sort of where it wants to get to. That's what the state would like to get to because the actual use of physical force is incredibly costly. If every single time somebody broke a law, a regulation, or a dictate by the state. The state had to actually you you know send a person out to use direct physical violence against somebody to get them to comply, the the the state wouldn't be able to to continue to operate because it would simply be too costly, too many resources. There's not enough people to actually directly regulate ⁓ the entire population of the United States, for example. So the state to operate does not rely on direct physical violence very much. It r relies on the threat of violence in the case of breaking a law or regulation or a dictate against the from the citizen sorry, from the state against the citizen. The state just has to make sure that it actually follows through on those those ⁓ rare situations in which a citizen ⁓ defies the law regardless of the threat, which it does with again, significant enough efficiency to keep everybody else afraid of breaking the rules. And I know what a lot of you are thinking at this point. At least I think I know what you're thinking at this point. which you're thinking, you know, he has not established why it is that a state like the United States is ⁓ not voluntary. ⁓ and most of you I'm I'm I I assume would think, well, you know, we live in a democracy we live in a representative democracy where we get a vote and we get a choice. And therefore the laws reflect in some way the desires of the people under which it rules. And quite frankly, I'm not gonna get into Whether or not the state I'm not getting into the counter arguments as to why the state is actually voluntary and not involuntary. We're gonna deal with that in another section. We're gonna deal with that when we when we come to the the critiques of what I'm talking about. And we're also gonna deal with that we're gonna deal with a lot of the other critiques that come with this entire system. Like why is authenticity an ultimate value? you know, can a murderer be authentic in his murdering, is there not actual value that comes out of the parent child relationship? There are a lot of objections that are a part of or that that come in naturally come in response to the things that I'm talking about here. And I don't want to pretend that the things that I'm saying, especially the controversial things that I'm saying, are just a given. It's it's mostly I don't want to deal with them in in this video as much as deal with them when we when we get to ⁓ The video talking about objections to what I've been talking to up to this point. So I am sort of beginning with the assumption, you could say, and deliberately beginning with the assumption that the that something like the United States is ⁓ an involuntary government in the sense that it is we don't choose to be a part of the system and we don't choose to be a part of its rules, and we don't choose to be a part of the democratic process, we don't choose the structure of the state that we're born into, rather, the entire structure. is forced on us. And you know, you can you can go through that or make the best devil's arg the you can make the best devil's advocacy that for that case that you want to. But we're not going to get into the objections right now. We're starting with the assumption that the state is an involuntary an involuntary government organization and again because of the nature of its of the fact that it is involuntary means that every single law that it passes, everything will dictate that it passes, carries with it the threat of violence. Carries with it essentially the mantra quite literally comply or die. And I I know that might sound extreme, but if we just even try to work it out here, we can see why something like like that mantra would make sense because you know, I take something like as simple as taxation. the state dictates that if you work ⁓ a certain amount and you make a certain amount of money, then there is a certain percentage of that income which the state is entitled to and is going to take from you. And you don't have a choice as to whether or not the the state actually takes that amount of money away from you. You are you are forced to give that money to them. You can try to evade them by you know working, for instance, I I could work a job or I could try to work a job which has no direct taxation. Most jobs you have to Fill out all this paperwork so that the government can tax you directly, so that it's much more difficult for you to evade being taxed by them. Let's say I work a construction job and I only get paid cash and I make $100,000 a year from this, right? ⁓ so long as I can hide this from the state, you know, I'm not going to be my money's not going to be taken from me. But of course, much of the state infrastructure exists to find out people who are trying to avoid their laws. And so, you know, how does this go about, right? ⁓ is it that you just refuse to pay one single dollar and then the state just comes up to you and ⁓ and and kills you? No, that's not how it works. But there is a progression of compliance or the es escalation of violence. So the state finds out you haven't been paying taxes ⁓ on your construction job or your construction business and you know they're gonna send you a a nice little letter in the mail that says, Hey, you owe this much taxes plus interest plus whatever. or maybe even you have to you have to show yourself in court, ⁓ 'cause we have to you have a trial to see whether or not we're gonna give you jail time for for not paying taxes, right? You get this nice little note letter in the mail and At that point with the letter, you have a choice. You can either comply with what the letter is telling you and say, Okay, I'm gonna go pay this pay these taxes, or okay, I'm gonna go show up to court and let them sentence me and comply with ⁓ letting ⁓ having them lead me off to jail and whatnot, right? Or you can say, No, I'm not going to I'm not gonna come comply with this, right? And then we we brings it to another level. if for some reason the state doesn't catch up with you at that point, then you get away with it, right? ⁓ because the state has failed to really enforce its its dictates, right? But what usually happens is if you ignore a letter like that is eventually you'll get a nice knock at your door from a police officer, or maybe you'll be driving off to your construction job, and there'll be a warrant for your arrest. and The police officer won't knock on your door and and tell you, you know, you've ignored this letter, you haven't shown up to your court date, now I'm here to escort you to your court appointment date, right? And Then you have a choice in that in that moment. You can say, I'm going to comply with this what this officer is telling me, this representative of the state, I'm going to comply with what he tells me. You go along with him, court day, etc., etc. You probably have extra fines or extra jail time because you failed to show up when the letter the letter summoned you, right? Or you can try to resist the officer, right? You can say, I'm not gonna come with you. And one or two things are going to happen, right? He is either going to you are either going to effectively resist him, in which case you ⁓ you get away, right? or he is going to force you to comply and drag you physically off, right? He's going to ⁓ ⁓ he is essentially going to escalate the amount of violence that he uses against you until you are forced to comply with what he is asking you, right? And if you escalate the resistance to this, he is going to escalate his violence. So as you escalate, he'll escalate. And eventually, if you escalate effectively enough, if you resist effectively enough, then he will use least lethal force against you. He will kill you. ⁓ the degree to which you you resist what he's what he is telling you to do, you resist compliance, is the degree to which he'll escalate force against you until he outright kills you. And this for something as small as not paying taxes. and so underneath every single law is this principle. You either comply with the law or we're gonna kill you. We either you either comply or you die. That's the essential principle of it. Now it doesn't always work out in that way, because there are a lot of steps in between. But the essence, the end of the law is always comply or die. it might just escalate to severe bodily harm. It might just escalate to, you know, severe disability. It might just escalate to being ⁓ you know knocked out unconscious, it might be escalate to being tased and dragged off. ⁓ these are all forms of compliance. They're forced forms of compliance, ⁓ they're all forms of compliance. ⁓ this is the principle of law. ⁓ it doesn't matter what the law is, in the d to the degree that it is enforceable or to the degree that the state cares about enforcing it, ⁓ principle and the end of the law is always the same. Comply or die. There is always, no matter what law it is, so long as the state cares about ⁓ it, ⁓ is always the threat ⁓ death. ⁓ Underneath every single enforcement of law. And this makes sense. ⁓ this is practical in from the state's perspective. Why? Because if there wasn't the threat of physical harm or death against you, then you wouldn't comply. ⁓ the state wouldn't be able to follow through on enforcement. Nobody would pay their taxes if the state couldn't force you to pay your taxes or force you to comply with its punishments or else kill you. so this entire setup is designed to ⁓ incentivize you in a number of ways to follow along with the law even though you have no voluntary desire, because underneath it all ⁓ the threat of death. ⁓ we don't experience this on a day-to-day basis, right? Like going back to the taxation example, ⁓ the state kind of just takes the money out of your out of your wallet, and most people, ⁓ generation after generation, just they pay their taxes, they tell their kids it's important to pay the taxes, we come up with all ⁓ all kinds of excuses like it funds all these kinds of things and ⁓ it actually really benefits us. but at the end of the day it's just the people within the state saying, give me this money or I'm gonna harm you. And so we create sort of these ideological justifications for it and the day-to-day basis looks peaceful because the government is not f is not required to use physical violin in order to get people to do it. They just have to threaten people or have the the subtlety of threat be present within the enforcement of any law to actually incentivize people to comply with it, whatever whatever it is they're talking about. Or whatever it is they want you to do. And again, you know, many of you are gonna say, ⁓ this is justified because of X, Y, and Z. And we'll get into all that in a later video. I'm just sort of talking about the dynamics here. I'm not even necessarily morally morally critiquing it necessarily I mean, I'm connecting it to inauthenticity because it is directly connected with inauthenticity, in a structural way, but I'm not necessarily giving it moral critique here. of course it does interfere with inauthenticity or authenticity. And the reason it interferes with authenticity is ⁓ pretty direct. ⁓ degree to which the state uses force against me ⁓ threatens me is the degree to which now I must shape ⁓ and my behavior, my desires, what I'm acting for, ⁓ what my career is going to be, ⁓ ⁓ ability to survive and essentially my entire life, depending on how pervasive the presence of the state is, I have now have to direct myself and conform myself around what the state demands from me. And from state to state there are differences in in what the state demands, but the same principle applies. I can't simply act for the sake of what I value. I have to act for the sake of what I value in conformity to whatever the state demands from me. And so naturally this produces categorical inauthenticity in oneself. It prevents one from acting for the sake of what one genuinely values and instead funnels it all through a state-approved category or system. And I think in the last video I talked about how there is a connection between the parent-child relationship and the state-citizen relationship. And in fact, I think in some ways the parent-child relationship actually prepares us for the state-citizen relationship. And this is part of the reason as to why people accept that relationship so readily. Break it down very simply, the parent is an authority in a child in the child's life, not because the child has chosen them or finds innate value in them, ⁓ but because the the parent has power over life and death. They have ⁓ a huge amount of power over the child, and the child's not only their life, but their capacity to survive in the future and their capacity to learn and understand, their capacity to achieve values in the future, is hugely dependent on their parents and whether the parents help them, teach them, and keep them alive. And the child knows this at an instinctual level. And so becomes what it has to become, ignores its own authentic interest to a large degree, and becomes whatever it has to become in order to satisfy whatever dictates whatever culture, whatever values, whatever ideas the parent has and wants the the child to conform to. The child has to conform themselves to the to the parents, and then loses touch with their own authentic nature to a large degree, and then struggles with connecting back to that authentic nature in the future, which leads to meaninglessness and depression and pain and suffering and many other kinds of things. The relationship between the citizen and the state is pretty darn similar. the individual, because of the modern context of the state, depends heavily on the state ⁓ for all kinds of things. ⁓ the state has made itself the The state has made us dependent on it. It's a little bit different from the parent-child relationship because the child is just quite literally dependent on the parent in a very sort of natural way. but it's unnatural when it comes to the state, because the state has made its ⁓ made us dependent on it, and it's made us dependent on it by monopolizing through the use of violence all different kinds of areas of the state, right? So the state has a massive influence on. the economy in general, through interest rates and subsidies and economic regulations and ⁓ know, picking winners and losers and the kind of a col economic structure that it promotes and protects. ⁓ it's made us completely dependent on the state for our own personal safety ⁓ through both to the police state and the ⁓ the It's not like we have a choice ⁓ in our security. We don't get to sort of choose ⁓ or not the state ⁓ ⁓ for us or whether or not ⁓ state provides the military for us. They ⁓ do that and they they they push out any other sort of I guess you could say competition when it comes to security needs. ⁓ have massive control ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ over health care, ⁓ education, ⁓ agriculture and just day to day living in general, the power of the state is present everywhere. I mean it it it's everywhere you look the state has its hands in ⁓ Our day-to-day lives. And again, some of you might say this is great, some of you might say it's it's not, but the point is to say that the individual depends on the state in an enormous capacity. And not because that is natural. But because the state has used its monopoly of violence to create that dependence. It has systematically pushed out competition from the police, from the military, from utilities, from economic domains, from banking, from from agriculture. It's systematically pushed out competing. in these ⁓ these various domain domains through its use of force, ⁓ us dependent on ⁓ state for these things. Because now without state violence society would just fall apart. I mean with ⁓ we didn't have the police, ⁓ would be chaos, right? But not because ⁓ state is necessary to maintain order, but because the state has crowded out any alternative ⁓ for something like ⁓ security. ⁓ Agriculture would we would all starve to death without the without the state. Not because the state is necessary to for agriculture, but because the state has crowded out all competition around alternatives for ⁓ agricultural production. And it's done this with across a myriad of of domains. And so now the citizen is dependent on the state. And this is where I think a lot of defense of the state comes in. ⁓ Where we think we are dependent, we are sort of naturally dependent on the state for all these good things, and we say we need the state to provide us all this kind of stuff. because if we didn't, then it would be we would be you know useless. We wouldn't have all this kind of stuff. But it's kinda similar to s to this is an example I've heard before, it's not unique to me, but it's kinda similar to something somebody saying You know, if there was only one grocery store, if we were all forced to shop at one grocery store, right? And we didn't ha we couldn't compare that grocery store to anything else because we had no other options and there had never ever been any other options. and somebody came along and said, you know, we should we should really we should really get rid of this grocery store, right? Everybody around them would go, Well, what do you mean? Without this grocery store we would all starve to death. But that's because there's no other options to choose from. And it's sort of the same thing with the state. within the state, and because of the state's influence in so many domains, without the state, society would would collapse. But that's not because the state is necessary for society, but that because the state has made itself necessary for society. and so going back to to the the whole authenticity thing, this radically limits what I'm actually allowed to sort of do with my life because again, everything has to be channeled through not simply what the state demands from me, but all the monopolies and the monopolistic powers that the state has imposed on my life. And of course you get all these other bad actors as well. And you get these people that come in and they they commandeer the power of the state for their own interests and then ⁓ you know, even if you believe that somehow the state is the representative of the people, all of these oligarchs and and And special interest groups ultimately gain control over the power of the state and push it towards their own interests, and now I have to act for the sake of somebody else's values instead of mine. It's kinda like how older generations have used the state to secure the the housing market and make it beneficial for themselves, ⁓ when they were younger. And now that same generation is trying to protect their own financial assets, ⁓ through using the power of the state to prevent ⁓ building building new housing and through zoning laws and through interest rates and all this other kind of junk. And politicians are incentivized to protect the housing market for people who have ⁓ put their entire retirement into the value of their house. And now that's creating a problem for new generations who, you know, they want to be able to to buy new houses, but older generations, ⁓ that are more populous have commandeered the power of the state for the for their own interests. And now the rest of us are prevented from acting for the sake of what we actually value because the you know older generations have come near the power of the state. And some of you are gonna say, well the real power is not the state, it's ⁓ it's the capitalists or it's the capital class and there's there's a lot of legitimate criticism there. ⁓ but we'll we'll get into the economic side of this, you know, some other time because that's that's a whole other issue. ⁓ and also it's kinda getting close to where I want to end this recording today. But back to the relationship between the power between ⁓ parent and the child and the state and the citizen, ⁓ is that ⁓ is that psychological dependency. ⁓ child must change and conform themselves sort of intuitively ⁓ to become what it needs to become in order to satisfy ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ by the parents. And in the same way the citizen has to conform themselves ⁓ explicitly with more wisdom, but They still have to conform and change who they are and what they actually want out of life and even in the in the very direction of their life, ⁓ in order to appease whatever the arbitrary rules or values that are being pushed by the state are. And, you know, even if you can't, even if you're a person who lives in the United States and think and thinks, you know, well, the values that my government is representing are actually good, then just take a look at all the states that you don't agree with, someone like China or Russia or anywhere else, and you can see more objectively the same power dynamic happening in a state that you're not directly dependent on. And that'll help you give give your give yourself more objectivity into how the state can you know, really controls people's destinies in a very fundamental way that often goes hidden because there is no direct violence. But the state drastically hinders the authenticity of the individual and really sets their life on a course which is of course not chosen. And so you know connecting the bridge here, even if you're a person who has become aware of The inauthenticity that's produced out of the parent-child relationship. You wake up to that. You dig yourself out of that, right? You come to an understanding of who you are. You start to become ⁓ more self-knowledgeable. You start to be able to act more in line with what you truly value rather than what you were forced to become as a child. What you wake up to is just another layer of problem. And the n the other layout problem is now you have a state and a culture which reinforces that state, which blocks your ability To actually act for the sake of what you value. There is a direct threat to your freedom to be able to even act on what you authentically value in the first place. It has to now be in conformance with the broader culture that exists to defend the state and the violence and the threat of the state itself. And that can kind of just ruin an entire person's life in in some ways, or it can drastically reduce the quality of a person's. life because now they are not all these options for authenticity are sort of artificially cut off from from for them for their ability to actually act on ⁓ for the sake of what they value. So it adds this extra layer to inauthenticity and makes authenticity an even greater challenge than it was beforehand. You have to deal with the internal psychological issue. Well, now you have to deal with three things, really, right? You have to deal with just the existential limits and survival limits that come with that are a natural barrier. One's authentic values, then you have to deal with the intrinsic power relationships that created ⁓ inauthentic self-image. But then even if you overcome that, now you have to deal with the state and the violence of the state and what it forces you to conform to in order to act for the sake of. And again, the parent-child relationship actually prepares you for the state-citizen relationship. And so There's an a furtherance of the same inauthentic dynamic throughout one's entire life. And, you know, with all of this force and violence being used against us, we wonder why even in the West we're so unhappy. But anyway, I wanted to lay out that that sort of dynamic, that that extra layer layer that gets in the way of authenticity. Which is the state? talk a little bit about the cultural dynamics, though there's more to be said there. And I really think that brings brings us to the end of the major things that get into the way. The the the false self-image that's created in the parent-child relationship, ⁓ survival, and the existential limits that are placed sort of naturally on one's on one's ability to be authentic, and the state and cultural elements that get in the way of authenticity as as an adult. And again, just for emphasis here, underneath all of these all three of these layers, the existential limits, existential and natural limits, the parent-child relationship which creates the false self image and the state citizen relationship which causes both cultural and and physical limit and and ⁓ violence based limitations on the expression of authenticity. Underneath what unifies all three of these elements is force. These are all different variations of force with different moral culpabilities and different different causal extents of underlying force, but they are all examples of the same kind of force. And so you can see this tension between force on the one hand, or this and ta really a fundamental antagonism between force on the one hand and authenticity on the other hand that sort of unifies the question of what's gone wrong. And these are the three major elements. There there are other elements that are significantly involved in here, but they're not as major as these three. And I just really wanted to lay out the major ones, right? ⁓ so in the next episode what we're gonna talk about is How do we overcome this, right? And it'll probably also be three episodes explaining how do we overcome it. Like how do we overcome the existential limits? How do we overcome the parent-child inauthentic dynamics? And how do we overcome the state citizen dynamics? And then lastly, we're gonna talk about Again, does this hold up to scrutiny? And that's the episode where I'm gonna talk more about common objections, right? Because there are very there are some very common and natural objections that come up to this almost from the get-go that we're gonna talk about deeper in the last episode. And that'll be the summation of this sort of first pass at the philosophy. But again, if you made it this far, thank you so much for listening. ⁓ I hope that today's episode was a little bit more clear than the other ones. have been. I've been aiming to be try be better and and and trying to to practice this over each episode and I just hope that that progress of articulation is coming across. If you like what you hear please you know like this video and subscribe and we'll talk to later.