Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / The NCUA Central Liquidity Facility and What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:02MARK: Hey everyone.
- 0:03This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:08I hope you enjoy.
- 0:09For this episode, I'm excited.
- 0:11We're gonna have a deep dive on the Central Liquidity Facility,
- 0:15also known as the CLF for short.
- 0:17And I have Steve, far with me here today who's gonna talk through
- 0:22many of the intricacies of the clf.
- 0:24Steve, how you doing?
- 0:26STEVE: I'm doing just fine in the middle of a snowstorm here in Montana.
- 0:30MARK: Snowstorms in Montana, November 7th, and I'm participating from the great state
- 0:35of Virginia and it's in the eighties.
- 0:37But you're in Montana, so you win.
- 0:39STEVE: Yeah.
- 0:41MARK: Very good.
- 0:41All right, so Steve, if you could give a little bit of a background,
- 0:44your background at N C A.
- 0:45I know you, you've been helping me help credit unions over the last
- 0:48two years since I've left N C a.
- 0:50You left a little bit before that.
- 0:51But share with the audience for those who may not have heard any of the
- 0:55previous podcasts that you've done.
- 0:57A little bit of your background at ncu.
- 1:00STEVE: That's great.
- 1:01I did about 30 years with ncaa, working up through the ranks as an
- 1:05examiner, and then spent a great deal of time as a problem case off.
- 1:09US are out on the west coast mainly.
- 1:12Then I went into the central office and served roles, different roles in risk
- 1:16management, and then in my final years at NCAA, I worked heavily on the risk
- 1:23based capital rule and served as the vice president of the central liquidity.
- 1:30MARK: Very good.
- 1:30So you have a very unique view that very few people have ever had having
- 1:35served as the vice president of the clfs a lot of the inner workings and
- 1:40understand the regulation and the how the federal credit unac works.
- 1:44And, there's been a lot of dialogue in different ways from NCAA a recently,
- 1:48and we'll walk through some of that.
- 1:49But, in these times that we're in right now, you hear a lot
- 1:53about credit unions having.
- 1:55A little bit more concerns about liquidity.
- 1:58It, the last several years it was that they had too much liquidity,
- 2:01but liquidity's drying up a little bit and it has people looking at
- 2:04their options relative to liquidity.
- 2:07And part of that goes to what the purpose of the clf.
- 2:09So why don't we start theirs?
- 2:11Steve, could you of walk through the purpose of the central liquidity facility?
- 2:14STEVE: In just simplest term, the CLF serves as a federal liquidity backstop
- 2:19to credit unions and the industry.
- 2:22And that's really what it is it has the ability to borrow from
- 2:27the Federal financing bank in the event when liquidity's really.
- 2:33MARK: And that actually came in quite handy during the 2008, 2009,
- 2:38the great recession when there were liquidity issues all around the planet.
- 2:43Credit unions didn't escape that challenge because of the challenges
- 2:47of the corporate credit unions.
- 2:49And they, the clf was a, again, a wonderful tool for credit unions, which
- 2:54allowed N C a partially allowed the NCO a to hold to maturity those bonds and
- 3:00those assets that had been purchased in the corporate credit unions that
- 3:03were virtually worthless or, pennies on the dollar until liquidity returns.
- 3:07It's.
- 3:08Go ahead, Steve.
- 3:09STEVE: Let me kinda just go over that cuz a lot of people,
- 3:11it's enough time has passed.
- 3:13They probably don't remember what the, what all the CLF did in that and what
- 3:17all of the things that had to take place for the CLF to be able to do that.
- 3:22They had to have Congress remove an appropriations limit on how
- 3:26much borrowing the CLF could do.
- 3:28Cuz at that time while the statute allowed them to borrow more
- 3:31money, the The appropriations rule allowed them to only have 1.5
- 3:35billion, so that had to be changed.
- 3:37And then they did all these lending programs to put liquidity into the system.
- 3:42They, some people might remember 'em as the Credit Union System Investment
- 3:46program, which was a SIP program, and the Credit Union Homeowners Availability
- 3:51Relief program, and those loans that added liquidity in the system.
- 3:56Total date 0.4.
- 3:58Then in March of 2019, when the NCO board took the steps to ize the corporate
- 4:04credit union by placing US Central and Westco into conservatorship, the
- 4:08CLF approved a 10 billion advance to the share insurance fund in order
- 4:14for the NNC S F, to extend liquidity stabilization loans to those institutions.
- 4:20So by the end of the year 2019, the CLFS loans totaled 18.3
- 4:26billion.
- 4:28The other thing that took place about that time is then C Board made a change
- 4:31in the CLFS earnings retention policy and that they started to retain earnings.
- 4:36Because even though the clfs operations are very low risk, they're not zero.
- 4:42So they started retaining some equity instead of returning all of it in terms
- 4:47of dividends on the funds, on deposit.
- 4:50So those are all the things that took place then and kinda to go
- 4:54along that, There's a similar thing taking place because the CARES Act
- 4:59allowed the CLF extended some of their authorities temporarily, and those
- 5:04generally expired December 31st, 2021.
- 5:09The NCUA board wrote a letter to Congress in November of 2021, asking
- 5:15if these enhancements be written into permanent statute so they could
- 5:21keep liquidity in the bad times.
- 5:23Those were increasing the CLFs maximum lending borrowing authority statute sets.
- 5:28Its 12% of basically equity.
- 5:31And temporarily that was raised, the 16%, we'll go into this a
- 5:35little bit more in detail later.
- 5:38They want a allowed lending to the corporate credit unions.
- 5:43There was greater flexibility in agent membership and we'll talk about agent
- 5:47membership later and provided the board with a little bit of clarity and allowed
- 5:53loans for more of the extension of.
- 5:57Of loans and kinda loosened up when the CLF can grant loans.
- 6:02So they wanted this, They've asked that those things would be made permanent.
- 6:06Now that's important because there is no guarantee that in the event of a future
- 6:11crisis that the executive branch and the legislative branch will be accommodating.
- 6:20And that is a little bit of a risk that takes place.
- 6:23It's nice to have all these backstops well in place and not have to rely on "we sure
- 6:28hope that Congress does this or we sure hope the Secretary of the Treasury allows
- 6:33these things" because we did have Mark, you remember back then we were in a lot of
- 6:38offices in the Treasury during that time.
- 6:41So
- 6:42A reminder.
- 6:43MARK: No, we were, you and I you're bringing back some you're shaking
- 6:46some cobwebs off some memories.
- 6:47Some good, some exciting some scary back in that crisis.
- 6:51And you and I were involved in many different ways.
- 6:53And, you point out the fact that first, some of the things in the
- 6:56language and the change you that NCUA was able to get, even though it was
- 6:59only for a year or two as tied to the CARES Act, was from lessons learned
- 7:04as you said creating a little bit more flexibilities on the loans they could do.
- 7:07And that would've been from lessons learned on how liquidity was utilized
- 7:10in the last crisis and how it might be able to have more clarity around
- 7:14how it could be used moving forward.
- 7:15But if that all evaporates, you of go back to ground zero.
- 7:19As you said, do it when you have the opportunity potentially to get the votes.
- 7:23Don't let it evaporate or you might not ever get it again.
- 7:26And that's something that NCUA has obviously been very cognizant of.
- 7:29The board's been talking about it.
- 7:31Now, whether or not they'll be able to get the votes to make
- 7:33it permanent or extend again
- 7:35your guess is good as mine cuz as they say, that takes an act to Congress.
- 7:38But all great points.
- 7:39Steve, one other thing that popped into my head is that 10 billion in liquidity
- 7:43that you mentioned that, that juncture of the role that I had I was the
- 7:47regional director in Albany there the corporate credit union program who was
- 7:52the person in charge of that was retired.
- 7:54They asked me to serve as the acting director of the
- 7:56corporate credit union program.
- 7:58And I was actually, Making that request.
- 8:01We put, $5 billion into one institution and had the ability to put $5 billion
- 8:06into one in US Central, one in West Corp.
- 8:09And before that, the biggest ask from the CLF was a credit union
- 8:13that I had a few years earlier.
- 8:15So in, in one year's time, I went to, I went from having to ask for 300
- 8:20million in liquidity from the N C A board and explaining they had not seen
- 8:24it yet, that happen either, right?
- 8:26So it was a 300 million.
- 8:28Ask, and it was a huge ask and it was not a controversial ask, but it a lot
- 8:32of heavy lifting to get that done.
- 8:34And then 15 months later we were asking for 10 billion.
- 8:37And I just remember pausing when I was doing that, the irony of
- 8:40the difference in all those zeros.
- 8:41But by having all those zeros, you have the ability to help
- 8:44more credit unions ultimately.
- 8:46That's a good kind of primer to get the conversation going.
- 8:49And so Steve, the last, over the last year, the NCO board has done
- 8:53two briefings two credit unions.
- 8:55The nco a board meets the third Thursday generally of
- 8:59every month other than August.
- 9:00And so far they've had two briefings on this topic.
- 9:03Could you of walk through if there's anything you'd like to add relative
- 9:06to why they did that or what was discussed at those briefings?
- 9:10STEVE: Yeah it is interesting and a commentary on the importance that they're
- 9:14placing on the CLF at this point in time.
- 9:17The first briefing was in January of 2020, and the one was just recently in
- 9:22October of 2020, and there's a slides that you can look at that were presented to.
- 9:27To the board at that time and they would provide a lot of details.
- 9:31I'm just not gonna go through cuz time won't allow it.
- 9:34Some of the finer details about the CLF and those are a useful source.
- 9:39So keep that in mind as you go forward.
- 9:41The other thing that they have changed and commented on there is they've
- 9:46made the CLF now a permanent office.
- 9:49When I was there, I was the vice president and there was a president, and we did
- 9:54that job as and other duties as assigned.
- 9:57And now they've made the full-time position for the CLF president, and
- 10:02I do believe that the vice president will be a full-time position and the
- 10:06CLF has one other just excellent staff accountant that's just wonderful.
- 10:11So they've changed the emphasis that the staff is now.
- 10:15Dedicated to the clf, which has allowed things that I can see already
- 10:19when I look just at the website.
- 10:21They've improved all of the forms that you would go to for membership and loans and
- 10:27all that, and it made them PDF combines that you can do the inputs on 'em.
- 10:31And added a lot to the website that would, has frequently asked questions
- 10:38that would help you as you're considering the CF and want more information.
- 10:43The other thing I always tell people that I would look at is the audited financial
- 10:48statements of the share insurance fund.
- 10:52And all those includes state a statement from the clf and the footnotes
- 10:56really tell a tremendous story.
- 10:59And help fill in any questions that you might have.
- 11:01So I really tell people that's very useful and something I reviewed in
- 11:05preparing for this presentation.
- 11:08The the other thing I commented on is back in 2009, the CLF started
- 11:13retaining capital for its own losses.
- 11:15And they don't just retain Will Nelly.
- 11:18We do study how much.
- 11:21Equity, the CLF should hold the same as a credit union does.
- 11:25And looking at our risk probability of default and loss given default
- 11:29analysis was performed, and that's what determines how much retained earnings
- 11:36that the CLF has from the investments and covering operating expenses.
- 11:39And then the rest is paid out in dividends.
- 11:42So that in a nutshell is really just the the operations of the c.
- 11:47MARK: Got it.
- 11:48Got it.
- 11:49And you mentioned a lot of documents there.
- 11:51I'll try and remember to put those into the show notes.
- 11:54But you may be smiled when you referenced footnotes.
- 11:56You were.
- 11:56At the, you were the guy way back in the beginning of my career
- 11:59at N C A that turned me on to looking at those footnotes.
- 12:02There's treasure in those footnotes, is what I learned
- 12:04from you way back when, Steve.
- 12:06And that always tends to ring true.
- 12:08And as you said, there's things there in the clf.
- 12:10If you really wanna become a student of the clf, check out those footnotes.
- 12:14So that's great.
- 12:15So we've walked through the briefing.
- 12:17So we've walked through the general operations of the CLF and things
- 12:20that are going on because of what you've seen in those briefings.
- 12:23You mentioned the November, 2021 letter to Congress.
- 12:26Is there anything else relative to that letter that you think
- 12:29we should highlight here today?
- 12:33STEVE: No I don't think so.
- 12:34And then that letter is on the website and can be pulled down, but
- 12:37it's a very short letter so that Congress can read it quickly and
- 12:40get the sense of what they want.
- 12:45MARK: So clf borrowing ability, we talk, we've talked through the fact
- 12:50that there, the CLF has the ability to borrow that we utilize that.
- 12:54Quite heavily during the last crisis that led to when the CARES Act came out, NCO
- 13:01A wisely going to try and get some things put in place so they could have broader
- 13:06authorities on the borrowing authority.
- 13:08And that's about to expire.
- 13:09Anything else you'd like to add relative to that particular topic?
- 13:14STEVE: Yeah, and they're in the.
- 13:19that the board members made at the October session.
- 13:22You can read those and it provides a little more on this, but I'll cover a bit
- 13:26of it to really should take care of that.
- 13:28The CLS borrowing authority is based on the capital stock in its surplus.
- 13:33It's a statutory limit that's 12 times the, that, that amount.
- 13:39So temporarily the CARES Act raised that to 16 times, but that expired.
- 13:47On December 31st, 2021.
- 13:50So now you look at what the capital position of the CLF is now, and
- 13:58to take that times to 12 times.
- 14:00And so they have the borrowing authority of 29.3
- 14:04billion.
- 14:06So can't you kinda look at that and go, Wow.
- 14:08During that corporate crisis it had loans outstanding of 18 billion.
- 14:13And, inflation and all that.
- 14:14And so that's one that tells you that there's not a lot of margin
- 14:17for error now because of an item that'll cover in more detail, but I
- 14:23can cover it how it affects capital.
- 14:25Now, the corporate credit unions we're allowed to do agent memberships, and
- 14:31we'll cover that in detail, but those agent memberships came about because
- 14:37of the CARES Act and that added.
- 14:39About 400 million in on book capital and a borrowing authority of about 9
- 14:45million or in other words, has that increased the amount of CLF capital stock?
- 14:52And you take it times the 12 times that generated an additional
- 14:5610 billion in borrowing a.
- 15:00So now when that expires and those funds have to be returned on December
- 15:0531st, 2022, the CLS borrowing authority will be reduced to 19.6
- 15:15billion, which puts it pretty close to where it was in the crisis.
- 15:21The source of funds that the CLF has is from its own funds, and it can
- 15:25borrow from the federal financing.
- 15:28We have an agreement with the Federal Financing Bank.
- 15:31It works pretty well to renewed every year, but that really
- 15:35is briefly a description of the CLFS borrowing authority.
- 15:39MARK: Got it.
- 15:39And so there's two variables there, right?
- 15:41The Cares Act allowed gave a 33% increase instead of a
- 15:46multiplier being 12, it was 16.
- 15:49And it also allowed for.
- 15:52For lack of a better word, the creation of some capital,
- 15:55which increased the multiplier.
- 15:56So the result is 10, when this expires, 10 billion of borrowing authority
- 16:02available to the credit union system goes away if it's allowed to expire.
- 16:07Got it.
- 16:07The, so let's go in a little bit more detail to the let's on.
- 16:13Agent membership concept, what that means, how that works and any other, just
- 16:19general thoughts or comments on that.
- 16:22STEVE: Yeah that, that's a good one to go into.
- 16:24Now, as I said, The Cares Act temporary allowed the corporate credit unions.
- 16:29To become what's called an agent member of the CLF to a subset of
- 16:34their members, and that was with the uniqueness of the CARES Act.
- 16:38So they, what happened in May of 2020, because of this act, all of
- 16:43the corporates joined and purchased capital stock for their members
- 16:47with assets less than 250 million.
- 16:51that is, is what contributed to the increase in the capital stock of
- 16:56the 403 million that's on deposit.
- 17:00And that provided the federal backstop and liquidity for 300.
- 17:063,641 is the latest number of the smaller credit unions that now
- 17:12had access to a federal backstop.
- 17:14It's about to end if no, no changes in the regulation.
- 17:17And as we talked about before, is the reduction of that capital being
- 17:22paid back out and the reduction it has in terms of how the multipliers
- 17:27determine and the borrowing authority.
- 17:29That's where the $10 billion reduction in the borrowing authority comes about.
- 17:34MARK: Got it.
- 17:35Go ahead.
- 17:36STEVE: Yeah, that, and I when those corporate credit unions funded that amount
- 17:41of capital and they'll get it back and then they were paid a dividend on that.
- 17:45And I'll go through that dividend process in a little more detail
- 17:49with natural person credit unions.
- 17:51So this is a, an important issue for the smaller credit unions in that
- 17:55they, they've lost that federal backs.
- 17:59MARK: Got it.
- 18:00No, that's, that.
- 18:01This is a big loss, for the small credit unions.
- 18:03If it does evaporate, that's for sure.
- 18:05Yeah.
- 18:05So that's a good segue into the natural person membership.
- 18:08Why don't you kinda walk through.
- 18:09You and I know what natural person credit union means, and if you kinda look at
- 18:12the words, you might be able to figure it out or suss it out as they say.
- 18:16But in N c a nomenclature, what's a natural person?
- 18:20Credit union.
- 18:21And then what's a natural person membership of the clf.
- 18:25STEVE: So the natural person credit unions, are those credit
- 18:28unions serving credit union members versus the corporate credit unions?
- 18:33The that, that is the important difference between an agent
- 18:36member and the natural person one.
- 18:38So what happens now is credit unions who now lost that packs up, that feel like
- 18:42they need something in terms of liquidity.
- 18:46They all have the ability to become a natural person member, and you become a
- 18:51natural person member by filling out the application that's on the website, which
- 18:55I recently said has been much improved.
- 18:58And then you subscribe to the capital stock of one half of 1% of paid in
- 19:04and unpaired capital and surplus.
- 19:07Now you have to put on deposit with the clf.
- 19:11One half of that.
- 19:14And then the remainder is on call.
- 19:18The amount that you have on deposit is adjusted after the
- 19:23year end call report is in.
- 19:26And that provides a couple of things.
- 19:28It, it helps.
- 19:29It maintains the right capital base based on the membership of the clf, and it
- 19:35makes n so a go back through working with the wiring instructions that we have.
- 19:40So we keep those more up to date so that has a, an extra benefit.
- 19:46So now on that amount that you have on deposit at the cf, a dividend is
- 19:51paid on that, and it's pretty close to generally, almost actually the same
- 19:55as the Fed pays on excess deposit.
- 19:57For example, in the third quarter of 2022, it was 2.24%,
- 20:06and prior to that it was always, it was less than 1%.
- 20:10So that shows the, it does keep pace with the increase in
- 20:14general interest rates to clf.
- 20:17The dividend has increased that amount too.
- 20:20And, but the CLF of course, invests.
- 20:24Very short term, number one, because now it's facing the payout of so much of the
- 20:29agent memberships, but generally it does invest rather short to keep its purpose
- 20:36as being a liquidity source and the earnings that it has allows it to be able
- 20:41to pay the dividends that are paid out.
- 20:44There are 352 regular members.
- 20:48And the there used to be a waiting period for getting a loan on
- 20:51that thing that's been waived.
- 20:54But the website does a wonderful guy job of guiding you through
- 20:58and including all the calculations that would go into determining how
- 21:03much you'd have to have on deposit.
- 21:05And then the the agreements are fairly lengthy but easy to understand.
- 21:09MARK: Steve, that's about, if I did my rough numbers, that's about
- 21:127% of credit unions belong and probably the bigger ones do it.
- 21:17As you said, the smaller ones are currently covered through this
- 21:19other arrangement, but there's benefits no matter what size you are.
- 21:22You could argue that maybe a smaller credit union, it might make more sense
- 21:26because it gives, because of some of the advantages that it gives you.
- 21:30And yeah, I know we're gonna talk about, borrowing from the clf, but other
- 21:34than for the good of the order and, making a deposit that makes a decent
- 21:39return compared to other options, and the fact that you have this deposit
- 21:43and you buy this cert, this stock I guess it's a stock deposit, unless
- 21:47I'm mixing up my definitions here.
- 21:49Th that helps the multiplier.
- 21:51Do I have that?
- 21:52STEVE: Yeah.
- 21:52Yeah, it does.
- 21:53The more members that the CLF has, the greater its borrowing authority becomes.
- 21:59MARK: Back to that multiplier of 12 or 16, depending on which
- 22:03operating rule you're under now.
- 22:06The other thing is what, so what, let's speak a little bit
- 22:10to the borrowing from the clf.
- 22:15If the credit union.
- 22:16Was going to want to work with the clf.
- 22:18They find themselves in a liquidity crunch.
- 22:22What can you, what do you have to say about how that works?
- 22:24And then as a follow up question to that, or maybe you'll deal with that.
- 22:28Are there advantages, And I think there are, from having listened to the
- 22:32webinar, are there advantages to being a a CLF member before you find out that
- 22:38you need the liquidity as opposed to thinking you might need it later as
- 22:41far as timing and things like that?
- 22:42That was a mouthful.
- 22:43So let's talk about borrowing from the clf.
- 22:46STEVE: Yeah.
- 22:46And in terms of the natural person, credit unions would really be looking.
- 22:52Or the CLF members.
- 22:54It's real dependent.
- 22:55Some credit unions operate tighter liquidity than others.
- 22:58I So certainly if you're a credit union and you earn tighter liquidity
- 23:02the federal backstop that you need to comply with, the regulation, the CLF is
- 23:07certainly a great serves that purpose.
- 23:10Now here, somebody that does is, has a lot of liquidities, don't have a lot of loan.
- 23:16You may not have as much need to be on the clf.
- 23:19Now what happens is if you have a low liquidity, suddenly an event
- 23:22happens and now you're faced with a liquidity problem that can't really be
- 23:27resolved for general market sources.
- 23:30Then you have to look to the clf.
- 23:32The CLF lending authority is limited a little bit by not a
- 23:37little limited by the statute.
- 23:40And it we're back to that they can't make loans to expand a credit
- 23:44union's loan portfolio, but the CLF can grant short term adjustments
- 23:50and those are 90 day ones.
- 23:51And those are generally from credit unions that are affected from
- 23:55a short term outflow of funds.
- 23:57And these generally occur in terms of like the hurricanes
- 24:02and those types of disaster.
- 24:04And those ones could come into play because when an area is
- 24:08affected by a hurricane, there's an initial flood out of liquidity.
- 24:15As everybody has a lots of stuff to buy and stuff.
- 24:17Then as insurance payments come back in, it quickly becomes a great amount that
- 24:23comes back into the institution, and it can be difficult for everybody to start
- 24:27putting those funds to use because there's just limited resources in the area.
- 24:31But that's one.
- 24:33Potential use of it.
- 24:35There is a seasonal loans that can be done for those institutions like
- 24:39agriculture, ones that have a big outflow of funds at certain times of the year.
- 24:43Those are generally limited to a 270 day maturity.
- 24:48There are protracted credit adjustments of longer term ones that, that can be done.
- 24:55The important thing to remember is if you're borrowing from the c.
- 24:59You have to be creditworthy, so it's not a source of funds
- 25:03for a troubled institution.
- 25:06It will require approval of the supervisory authorities,
- 25:09CWA and the state.
- 25:12The rate assigned to those loans is the higher prime or the federal
- 25:16financing's rate on the advance, and they have to be fully collateralized.
- 25:22The by the change has been made.
- 25:25It used to be that we required would not lend no more than 90% on even a treasury.
- 25:31And the n c board did change that, and that is listed in the
- 25:36CLF collateral margin table.
- 25:38So if you're gonna look at borrowing from them and you can pull up the
- 25:41CF margin table and look at, these are the instruments that we would
- 25:45have believe we would have available to post as collateral for that.
- 25:50And you would be able to see how much you would be able to borrow
- 25:54based on that available collateral.
- 25:56And they do require, of course, that first lean interest on that.
- 25:59Yeah, that's really quickly.
- 26:01Borrowing from the C.
- 26:03MARK: That's good information.
- 26:04And if I find myself, so let's say four years ago I was, I was CEO of a
- 26:08credit union four or five years ago.
- 26:10I decided I wanted to be a member of the clf and I.
- 26:13Find myself, today, potentially wanting to borrow short term, compare and
- 26:18contrast that to someone who today is starting to have that liquidity
- 26:24problem, but they wanna sign up.
- 26:26Is there an advantage to having been a member for four years?
- 26:30And having all the paperwork done, the wiring instructions
- 26:34all done as the approvals.
- 26:36Because if, the other thing is, I guess if I'm going through some liquidity
- 26:40challenge challenges in wanting to join, I might not be the only person
- 26:43in line and that might slow things down at NCU a or my state regulator or not.
- 26:48Compare or contrast those two.
- 26:49Is there an advantage to being a member as far as the speed of getting the.
- 26:52STEVE: Probably just a marginal reach.
- 26:54Now that the CLF has a full-time staff, I would believe that applications
- 27:00would be able to be processed very quickly, and like we did in 2008 and
- 27:052009, we deputized a lot of people to be loan officers for the clf.
- 27:11That was, another one of my duties during the corporate crisis.
- 27:15N c.
- 27:15MARK: your name.
- 27:16You are deputized to make loans.
- 27:17Got it.
- 27:18Yeah.
- 27:18STEVE: Yeah.
- 27:19And so they, it has the ability to staff up in the event's,
- 27:24got a bunch of application.
- 27:26The other thing that's keeping important is if you're doing it now, it kinda
- 27:29reaction to a liquidity outflow.
- 27:32It's really hard to look at I'm gonna require, I'm gonna acquire this
- 27:35liquidity source, but now I gotta put this money on deposit with them.
- 27:39MARK: right?
- 27:39STEVE: It kinda seems a.
- 27:41MARK: Defeats the purpose.
- 27:42And it might be you're putting more on deposit than the ability to
- 27:44STEVE: On the short term it, it looks like it doesn't help your situation if
- 27:48you look at it in a really short run.
- 27:50So those people, of course, they've been members for a while, that money
- 27:53is a sunk into the clf and they are receiving a reasonable return on
- 27:57that, and they wouldn't have to come up with that at the worst of times.
- 28:02MARK: It.
- 28:02Got it.
- 28:02This has been very informative.
- 28:04When I think of liquidity, some, somebody once said, liquidity
- 28:07doesn't matter until it matters.
- 28:09And then it's the only thing that matters.
- 28:11You and I have been involved in institutions like the corporates
- 28:14we mentioned like some other.
- 28:16Troubled institutions that had long term assets on one side, and
- 28:20it went from an asset issue to a liquidity issue real quickly.
- 28:24And when your liquidity dries up and you have monumental issues
- 28:26there, it can be a challenge.
- 28:28And now that's not.
- 28:29That's not exactly what the CLF is for because it's there for other purposes and
- 28:34not the longer term, et cetera, et cetera.
- 28:36But it is a great tool for credit unions to consider.
- 28:39And there's a lot of good information out there.
- 28:41And, before, before I wrap up the, this episode, Steve, is there anything
- 28:46else that we should mention to our listeners relative to the clf?
- 28:51STEVE: I would say if you're have any questions at all, I would reach out to
- 28:54clf, Does have a phone number and I'm sure it has an email address that I believe you
- 28:59would receive a ver a very quick response and they would be able to answer any
- 29:05detailed questions that you might have.
- 29:06Anthony who did the presentations is a very knowledge Anthony capta.
- 29:13He's a very smart person, and I got to work with him before I'd left n c a.
- 29:17So I anticipate that you would be pleased with your interactions with the CLF staff.
- 29:23MARK: Yeah, he's a smart guy.
- 29:24He's the president now.
- 29:25They're looking to fill the vice president and again, more.
- 29:29Resources there.
- 29:29More professional website, because they've got more resources to donate it to it.
- 29:34Steve, I wanna thank you for your time today and sharing the
- 29:37knowledge you have again, that very few have relative to the clf.
- 29:41STEVE: Thank you.
- 29:42MARK: You bet.
- 29:43And listeners, I wanna thank you for joining me for this
- 29:46episode with Flying Colors.
- 29:47I hope you enjoyed it.
- 29:48They'll and I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 29:50This is Mark Tri, signing off with flying color.