Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 3rd-A Feast for Odin
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin, we look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar third of December.
- 0:30Third of December. Remember remember remember that it works for like basically every day
- 0:36in the Ember months exactly, which are just the two November, wait,
- 0:42September, September, October, October sort of like takes a turn away from
- 0:46the para rhyme and then it goes back to the embers of the Novembers exactly.
- 0:51So anyway, we're talking about a game. I am very embarrassed to
- 0:55talk about why because I've never played it. You know, you call yourself
- 0:58an Uve Rosenberg thing, isn't it. You are an air zots Uber Rosenberg
- 1:02fan. If you haven't played dare you his his masterpiece? I'm sure it
- 1:07isn't. I mean his masterpieces have. But I think it's like somehow his
- 1:12greatest folly. It could be I was actually thinking the word folly. It
- 1:17could be his greatest folly. It could also be his biggest game. Yes,
- 1:22like the game, like I don't know, it's like the most ub
- 1:25Rosenberg of all Uve Rosenberg games because there's just like so much so much stuff
- 1:30in this game, and you need to play it. I do need to
- 1:34play it. Do you have it? It's a yes, I have it?
- 1:36Do you have it? I've got the German one. I got it
- 1:38up Berlin Bruch Bilkhan this last summer. Can't we play play this Thursday,
- 1:42which would be December or something, rather than that old fucking game you were
- 1:48talking about earlier. I don't know if it's a game I can bring the
- 1:52game night because it's like too big. It's very big. It's a lot
- 1:55of ship to set up. It's like me but you know what, you
- 1:57know, I feel like sometimes I can't get a game too big, you
- 2:00know what I mean? I have to find ye sure, sure, sure,
- 2:07I'll think about it. If I can find time to learn the rules,
- 2:09then yes, I have to relearn them of course. Do you know
- 2:10what we haven't done yet? That's that tell the listeners what the game is.
- 2:15It's in the title of the podcast. They know what the game is.
- 2:17Come on, it's Uve Rosenberg. It's his biggest game. It's famous
- 2:21for giving you a tableau of like one hundred different actions that you can do.
- 2:24But really it's not that hard to make decisions. In this game,
- 2:29you choose a path and you kind of stick to it. We probably could
- 2:31play it on Thursday night. It's really not that hard. You're basically trying
- 2:35to like fit like polyameno pieces onto a board in order to like earn points
- 2:40and prevent yourself from losing points. It's feast Road in Ben with the Norwegians
- 2:46expansion. I got them both at Berlin bresch spiel Khan and the German edition
- 2:50doesn't matter. It's pretty much language independent. And Uve Rosenberg is famous for
- 2:54these polyameno type games, and this is the like polyameno of the polyamino games
- 3:00I've ever played. Do you know why Board game Geeks ratings of games can
- 3:05go fuck itself? Tell me this is the highest rated Ua Rosenberg game on
- 3:10the board Gameless top one hundred. I think it's probably because it's newer than
- 3:14La harv right, and people are tasteless. Well, I mean, Agricola
- 3:19was number one for a long time. Gricola is also in contention to be
- 3:23a masterpieces. I mean a Gricla is amazing. I mean Bonanzo is out
- 3:25there to be a masterpace. I mean, the man can design a game
- 3:28this Fjord is very good. Yes, this field's very good. Also,
- 3:31I mean a Tiva is a lesser work, but good. So explain to
- 3:36me. So I'm gonna past Road. I'm gonna explain to you why I
- 3:40have not played feast THROWDI and why I didn't buy it, And you tell
- 3:45me why. I'm talking out of the bottom bottom all right. So the
- 3:49reason I didn't buy it is because I like Rosenberg's tight designs. Agricola is
- 3:58a brilliantly tight design. Patchwork is brilliantly type design. Lajava is close to
- 4:05being one of the greatest games ever designed. It is almost perfect ross late.
- 4:11Then I then I bought Fields of La yep, and Fields of Arla
- 4:16was just baggy. Fields of La played that one. It felt eighty done
- 4:23to me. Okay, right, and hartw I quite enjoyed us great,
- 4:28yeah yeah. And then and then fisa Odin just seemed like a multiplayer version
- 4:35of the Fields of La. That there's no introduction to the game. You
- 4:41don't get led through the game by the designer. They just spat everything on
- 4:45the board and say ooh you go. I think it looks like that,
- 4:47but I don't think it plays like that. No, No, I mean,
- 4:50how do you feel that Tetris all? It's all right? Do you
- 4:54like find Tetris to be a satisfying and doorphin rich experience? I preferred Super
- 4:59Mario Land on my game Boy to be honest. Honestly, if you enjoy
- 5:00playing Tetris, you probably enjoy playing feast Rodin. So there's a lot available
- 5:05to you from the very beginning. But like I said, you you wouldn't
- 5:10do all. I didn't find it that hard to make decisions about what to
- 5:12do. Right. You can find you can pick a path through the game.
- 5:15Yeah, and it plays, and it plays more tightly than it looks.
- 5:17Does it feel like a sandbox game? Because I'm not a fan of
- 5:21sandboxy games? Yhe yes and no, I think it probably comes across that
- 5:29way. But you can't play it like. You can't literally just do like
- 5:32random actions every turn you like, you do have to pick a path,
- 5:36so it gives you a lot of options. But I don't know if I
- 5:39would call it a sandbo Have you played Western Legends? No, Western Legends,
- 5:43We played it once. It rude is is a sandbox game where you
- 5:46can literally just choose any path you want, and it's fine for one game,
- 5:51but it doesn't have that cohesive development. So you played tested my card
- 5:58game last week? Yes, and someone made a comment that I had a
- 6:01feeling was gonna be a comment. Doesn't feel like there's any development. What
- 6:06does that mean that as the game developed? So so Lahava, right,
- 6:12it's like the same game every round. You mean, yeah, so at
- 6:14Laharva. When you play Laharva, when you when you do an action,
- 6:17you think, how the hell am I gonna achieve this ship that comes later
- 6:23on in the game? That is impossible? Level one building? Yeah,
- 6:26you feel weak, and yet by the end of the game you're doing them
- 6:30with ease necessarily, but they are viable according that fish And so the game
- 6:35I gave you there's none of that. You have as much power at the
- 6:40beginning of the game as you do at the end of the game, which
- 6:43I don't think should be the case in games. They should have an arc.
- 6:47It's a good first play test. I think there's something there. Well
- 6:49we're not talking about that anyway, but I'm just using it to illustrate.
- 6:54And so does FSA Roden have that? Yes, I think it does.
- 7:00I mean I haven't like played it loads, so I think I'm like,
- 7:04I'm like searching back in my memory. There are like a lot of little
- 7:09pieces that you can put on your board and you can develop, Like you
- 7:12have your main map, and then there are other maps, and over the
- 7:15course of the game, you get access to like larger pieces to take up
- 7:19more space. And what you're trying to do is like cover up squares that
- 7:23give you like minus one point, but you have to like get to the
- 7:29point where you are eligible to use those large pieces. They're like treasures or
- 7:32something. So I think the game develops in that sense. And at the
- 7:35very beginning, you do have a lot of options, but you you kind
- 7:39of have to choose your strategy, so maybe it leaves a lot of possible
- 7:43strategies open to you. It just doesn't like Railroad you but you know,
- 7:46you'll you'll come to your own conclusion and like my my own thoughts will develop.
- 7:49Because the person I played the game with at Leria Kon he had played
- 7:54it online loads of time, is that he was one of the people playing
- 7:59it. But wasn't him the big chas ks Uh don't you forget his name?
- 8:05No kill? Sorry? Sorry, sorry, sorry, I thought of
- 8:09Kickstarter at first, and then I realized that you're a big chas, we'll
- 8:11have you moved now. It is our friend Andy, oh okay, okay,
- 8:16so he he played it loads online and basically for me it was just
- 8:20like a learning game because he destroyed me. Yeah, I'm sure and he
- 8:24probably has, uh, like, you know, more right to an opinion
- 8:26about the game than I do. But it's like a puzzle game that you
- 8:33have to solve, but the game doesn't tell you how to solve it,
- 8:35okay, And to me that is like very compelling. And you may look
- 8:39at the like the board, the tableau of available actions and think, oh,
- 8:41this is a sandbox I can do anything. You actually can't do anything
- 8:46right, and you have to pay attention to what other people are doing,
- 8:48and then you have to build your strategy based on what the other players are
- 8:52doing, what you're trying to achieve on your board, the availability of the
- 8:56treasures, trying to fit like these little polyomenal pieces where they I don't know,
- 9:01I mean, I'm not really like talking a lot of coherent sense at
- 9:03this point, but I don't think it's just this like open sandbox game where
- 9:07it's like totally not clear what you need to do. I mean, do
- 9:11you think that? And I think it does develop over time and you do,
- 9:13like figure out your strategy and then the winner is the player who is
- 9:18best able to execute that strategy given the available options. And what's interesting is
- 9:22everybody may have a different approach to doing that. So we have designed a
- 9:24game with Rosenberg, right, that's true. Yeah, we are co designers.
- 9:28So does that give you a different perspective on on a new Rosenberg game?
- 9:35Now we are essentially as game designer is on the same level. Yeah,
- 9:37I mean, would you say that my my opinions have to be qualified
- 9:41by that fact? Sure? Sure? I mean now you're now you're a
- 9:46bold game design legend. Yeah they're not. They're not credible, right,
- 9:48I'm gonna I'm just wanting to be positive toward him. Yeah, exactly,
- 9:52my friend. Plus the publisher of the game, you're an a booger canal.
- 9:58Yeah yeah, yeah, not not feast Road who published that. You're
- 10:05very good at this, you remember it all. I might be wrong on
- 10:07this, but I think it's fouler. I have no idea, so yeah,
- 10:11we should play it. You this is like a hole in your game
- 10:13against it really is it really is? And you know, I might not
- 10:16like it, and that's the reason I've not gone towards it. But I
- 10:20should play it because it's classic Cuba Rosenberg that I should play, all right,
- 10:24So like live on Air, I'm gonna say, why not play it
- 10:26on Thursday? If I if I take it up, Yeah, if I
- 10:30take it out of the box and I feel like I can fit it on
- 10:31the table, yeah, it's fucking feast for odent time. Not in your
- 10:35place though, No, I mean if I could fit it on the table
- 10:37a game night, yeah, exactly defa. Oh well, well if if
- 10:41you listen to this, what what what date in December is that, Steve?
- 10:46Because we're recording this on the I think of December the December November thirty.
- 10:54That would be December the sixth, wasn't it December sixth? December the
- 11:01sixth is a Wednesday? Then seventh seventh is what I meant. I just
- 11:03don't get a date right. So we're gonna play it this week on December
- 11:07the sixth, sixth seventh, December seventh, So this week on December the
- 11:13seventh exactly, not November the thirtieth. No, why would you say about
- 11:18it's a random, random fucking dates to bring up, isn't it? So
- 11:24December the seventh, that's right? If you come to Berlin. Yeah,
- 11:28if anyone here, I mean Yen's de hammer folkman, you you're fucking invited.
- 11:33You're invited, Karthik, if you're listening the Big Ks, you think
- 11:37the Big Ks is going to deign to come to fucking us Berlin. I
- 11:41don't think does he even listen to this? I can't imagine he does.
- 11:45He does he own the podcast yet? I I let's let's move on to
- 11:52Yeah. I'm going to go home now and then we'll come back here same
- 11:54time tomorrow record a new episode. Yeah. Absolutely, I love coming here
- 11:58every day. Lovely. Thank you for listening. You can support the show
- 12:05at Patreon dot com, forward slash five gfi D and join the discord by
- 12:09going to five g fod dot com. Have a very merry Christmas