Latest / Two PhDs on a Pod / Why We Need to Rethink How We Treat Chronic Disease
Transcript
- Guru Banavar: Hey Guru. You know, I've been thinking about how siloed modern medicine is. You want to go to a doctor, you first have to think about is that the right doctor for the specific organ? Like if you have a stomach pain, you go to the stomach doctor. If you have a heart issue, you go to the heart doctor. It's like as a as an IT a computer guy, if I look at the internet. And and if my internet is broken, it's sort of like looking at one laptop and trying to figure out what's going on in the whole internet. Whereas the you know, the internet is really a whole connected network of many, many things. So doctors never think like that. Yep. Yep. Well, that's because that's how they've been trained. So when you say modern medicine, I would say I would call it a conventional medicine. And that's how they've been trained. That's what they do. ⁓ but today we're going to introduce a new concept, which is not new at all. It's actually 40 years old, but we are going to focus today and explain in in deep depths ⁓ the concept of functional medicine. So functional medicine is a personalized, so we're gonna now ⁓ stack up a a bunch of different f ⁓ features of functional medicine that both overlap and are distinct from conventional medicine. So functional medicine is personalized, it is a systems-based approach to chronic disease. It used the body not as a collection of isolated organs, like what you said, but as a network of interacting systems. So that if something is wrong with the heart, you don't just look at the heart, you look at the whole body. So functional medicine not only includes conventional diagnosis and treatment. So functional medicine is not alternative medicine. It does not exclude conventional medicine. It actually includes all of the conventional medicine, ⁓ diagnostic tests, treatments, and so on. But in addition, it also asks. How a person's genetics, environment, nutrition, sleep, stress, medications, microbiome, and all other factors may be contributing to this illness, and which and how those factors can be changed towards cure of that disease, right? So put simply, it asks no not only what condition does this person have, but also why did it develop in this particular person and what can we do about it? Yeah, right. You know, ⁓ agreed. ⁓ functional medicine is a very holistic approach. It looks at all the interconnections across the different organisms. I mean organs in in an organism. And when I think about some of the key aspects of those interconnections, you you think about the circulatory system, the immune system, the nervous system, right? These are all like interconnected pieces. Like, you know, the heart is not on its own, the it reacts to the immune system aspects. It reacts to what's going on in your gut, in your, in your mouth and so on, to the microbiome and all of the other signals that it gets from different parts of the body and so forth. It seems to me that it's it's so important to take all of this network effects into account in medicine. And you know, that's that's basically what our guest today has figured out. Dr. Jeff Bland was one of the founding fathers of this approach called functional medicine and he introduced or reintroduced that topic, even though it it may may have been around before him, he took it to the next level along with Susan Bland and created a ⁓ a functional medicine institute in nineteen eighty one and started a whole movement around it. Yeah. Yeah. So ⁓ I mean, this is this is super exciting for us because as the audience knows, ⁓ Viome is all about functional medicine and understanding the root causes. And ⁓ I'd like to also in this intro give a couple of examples of this network effect because that may sound a little abstract. When people say I have high blood pressure, well, I'm gonna go to a cardiologist and I'm gonna get a high blood pressure medication, right? And that's conventional medicine. But but Check this out. The network effect is blood pressure is regulated genetically by our human genes at birth. And starting at birth, those genes functional perfectly fine. But every decade, our genes lose about 10% of their ability to control blood pressure. So by the time we're 50, half of the blood pressure regulation now falls onto our microbiome. And so if the microbiome is faulty, you're going to have high blood pressure. And here's where this network effect. Kicks in big time as we age. So, with the blood pressure, we need to consume molecules called nitrates. And these nitrates are actually absorbed in the gut into the bloodstream. They circulate via the bloodstream and go to the salivary glands. Salivary glands are genetically encoded to concentrate those nitrates and put them inside saliva to feed specific oral microorganisms, those nitrates. And then those microorganisms convert them into nitrites, which we swallow, and nitrites hit the stomach, and the acid in the stomach converts them to nitrous oxide, ⁓ nitric oxide, sorry, and nitric oxide is the is the molecule that lowers the blood pressure. So now you have a very complex network of specific nutrition, ⁓ specific mechanism of absorption of nitrate in the gut, and then Conversion to specific molecules by oral microorganisms, and then you have to have stomach acid. So for example, if you've used mouthwash and killed those microbes in the oral cavity, that chain breaks, that network breaks. If you have, if you are taking antacids like PPIs and you don't have stomach acid, that chain breaks. If you don't have the right gut microbiome and your absorption is horrible, you may not be processing or absorbing those nitrates correctly. So that's the network effect. And so, yeah. Conventional medicine may give you ⁓ a medication that may or may not work, but functional medicine would look to fix the actual root cause so that you can have normal blood pressure with no medications and then ⁓ that's a better approach. Agreed, Mo Momo, and ⁓ this also Needs emphasis from the biome perspective as well. When we look at systems biology, when we look at our leading tests like the full body intelligence and the precision health protest, this is the underlying philosophy behind these tests, which is that you are looking at all of the different elements of your body. You're looking at the gut microbiome, you're looking at the oral microbiome, you're looking at the blood transcriptome. And then you're connecting the dots across the activities that this the dynamic biology that we are able to detect in each one of these different parts of the body. And as a result of all of that, you're able to get a much better insight into what your health status is today and what you can do about it. So with that, I think it would be great to talk to Dr. Bland and discuss this whole Topic and approach of functional medicine. I'm really excited about it. Super excited. Thank you, Guru. I'm Momo, a biochemist. And I'm Guru, an AI and data scientist. We're two PhDs on a pod. Okay. All right. Next step. Momo, what's on your radar? Okay. So for today, I would like to just give people sort of like ⁓ a hint of what's coming up at VIO. ⁓ because we've ⁓ actually licensed a technology for detecting early stager ⁓ stages of pancreatic cancer and we have now been working in our own laboratory for the last few months to successfully actually overcome all the barriers of translating an academically developed test into a commercial laboratory developed test. And now I can say, hey, we're gonna we're gonna do this. And and so that's a really, really exciting step because pancreatic cancer is one of the deadliest cancers. So Consider this sort of like when a company reveals a new car and they're just showing you sort of the highlights of the little curves and everything else is black and you're like, whoa, that looks exciting, but I I wanna see more. So more to come in the next two months because we're planning to go to market in October. So that's just just over a month from now. So that's exciting. And then I have a couple of sli ⁓ go ahead, Guru. No, I was just gonna say on the pancreatic cancer test, it's so important that we we are able to detect it. early, right? If we don't detect it early, there's not a whole lot you can do because mortality increases quite a bit when you go to the later stage. But if you detect it early, there's probably treatments that will reduce mortality. And ⁓ and that is our goal. Our i this test that we are we are developing is going to be very good. High sensitivity at stage one, which is the most important element of early detection cancer tests. Yep. Yep. All right, ⁓ let's go into some foods. ⁓ I always ⁓ like to talk about foods because I'm just in love with cooking and food. So yeah, I got s I got a couple of pictures. So well, for mushroom lovers, I mean, the how exciting is it that you don't have to go spend days foraging the the forests to look for some mushrooms? I've done that many, many, many, many times in my life and I enjoy it, but it's not practical to do that all the time. How awesome is it that you can go to our local H Mart, which is my favorite mushroom store, and just load up on all kinds. I just just walk down the aisle of the mushrooms and I pick up seven or eight different types, like you can see here in the picture. And then I wash them, chop them up, and make these mixtures. And so every time and I put them in the freezer in these silicone Ziploc bags. And so whenever I want mushrooms, I just pull out a Ziploc bag, this silicone one, and ⁓ it's got a mixture of these seven mushrooms or eight mushrooms. And it's just delicious in all kinds of the meals. It's just so good. And so it's and they're so healthy. Mushrooms are so healthy and tasty and they have great texture. I just love it that we have access to that. That's one of the great improvements in quality of life in in in ⁓ modern food chains. So really excited about that. Yeah, more and let me let me let me add something there. ⁓ it turns out it's an interesting story about my own personal journey with mushrooms. ⁓ I was not a big fan of mushrooms because it's just not part of the South Indian sort of cooking style. Right. But ⁓ not too long ago, I got a result from from our biome test, which says, hey man, you gotta im increase your mushroom intake because all of these mushrooms are your superfoods. Yep. And then I I did a lot of deep diving into that and I saw that the kinds of fibers, the inulins, for example, right? Those fibers are super good for my particular health. And the glucans. And the glucans. Exactly. Yes. So I looked at all of these things and now I've kind of switched my mindset. I look for mushrooms all the time. When I go to a restaurant and I have a choice between a mushroom dish and a non-mushroom dish, I pick the mushroom dish and so on and so forth. So it's it's actually now become a big part of my thinking as well. So this picture is now. Very interesting to me. It didn't used to be ten years ago, but now it is. Yeah. The the the viome results change you. But ⁓ but you also are married to a Slav, which ⁓ I would have thought that, you know, you would have gotten introductions to mushrooms. I guess. That's big that's a big part of the culture. She tried, she tried, but you know, I was resisting it until about ten a few years ago when I got the viome test. So it's it's it's actually changed my behavior in significant ways. So that's that's that's that's that's a good thing, right? That's a good thing. More people need to do that. ⁓ change behavior based on their personalized biology. All right, next slide, please. Okay, here I wanted to show you something that I make that is super, super simple. It's a dish that's super simple. So I think people have heard of rice and beans as sort of a very, very traditional Native American dish. and ⁓ it's it's very high in protein, high in fiber, high in polyphenols, like all kinds of good things. But There there are going to be people who are going to criticize it and say, well, yeah, there there's some protein in there, but really you need to add meat in order to make it, you know, high enough protein. And that turns out not to be the the case. And so here's an example of a dish that has very high protein, it has more than 30 grams of protein in this one serving. ⁓ and so all I've done is I have a bed of rice and I have a bed of beans, but then inside those beans, I added chunks of super firm tofu. This is Just a standard superfruit tofu you can get anywhere. We get it at Trader Joe's, but you can get it anywhere. And so if you if you s look at the nutritional information on this on the tofu and the beans, you can actually figure out how much tofu to add in there. And you can actually cook it with the beans. While you're cooking the beans, you can cook the tofu when you're re frying the beans. And that way, or just frying them with spices. And that way you can have a a delicious meal with 30 grams of protein with all the benefits of tofu and beans. And then you can garnish that with what I did here, long green beans to add a bunch of fiber. And so this is like a completely vegan meal that is super nutritious. And depending on how you spice it, which of course you should spice it with chile, some form of chile. You know, we use chorizo seasoning because we make that stuff by kilograms in our household. And so this is just loaded with chile, and it's just delicious and nutritious. So ⁓ try to get creative beyond just what what people talk about and this is one example that I wanted to share. And and I have also very similar approaches to cooking and preparing food and I have many examples of such dishes. I'll bring some for the future episodes. ⁓ what's on your radar? All right. Couple of interesting things on my radar. ⁓ the first thing I wanted to highlight because we're talking about foods is something that's become a little bit of a tradition in our office It's called the microbiome gathering, which we do on every Wednesday when we have our lunch and learn meeting. Just before that, our team has figured out how to grow some really interesting greens in our hydroponic garden in the in the office, which you see on the right hand side. So we got, you know, we got lots of different types of lettuces, we got lots of different types of s you know, herbs. ⁓ and we pick some of those things and we juice it in the office along with other kinds of vegetables and fruits, like this example from I think a week or two ago, ⁓ there's actually a bunch of you can guess, watermelons, but also some ⁓ cucumbers and and a bunch of leaves that we had put picked up from the garden. And you see the nice mint garnish on top. It's an amazing, you know, my mouth waters every time I see this again. Like it's an amazing little shot that we take just before our lunch and lunch meeting every Wednesday. And we do this in this office. So ⁓ we are very proud of it. And our team is extreme is becoming extremely good at making different combinations of these microbiome shots, which I think is gonna be filled. with all types of micronutrients and all types of other really great microbiome enhancing compounds. So that's one thing I wanted to highlight. That's that looks awesome. Let's just clarify that when you say interesting greens, that no no ⁓ illegal stuff at the federal level falls into the interesting No, look at all the greens we have on the right hand side. It's it's just the naive stuff, but your basil and your mint and your your Different types of lettuces, kale and et cetera, et cetera. You see all the greens on the right hand side. Nice. Amazing. That looks gorgeous. Yeah. Look at all those colors. Wow. Yeah. We're so happy with ⁓ with this garden. The second thing I wanted to highlight was Momo, you and I just celebrated our birthday. So happy birthday again. Happy birthday. And in for my birthday this year, we went to this area around where we live in ⁓ upstate New York called Lake George. It's in the Adirondach region. Very, very impressive area. This area, this lake, by the way, is like thirty-two miles long. It's a huge lake. ⁓ I think it's called the Queen of American Lakes or something like that. And it's got all of these ⁓ ecological environments that have been studied by a number of scientists and they have experimental setups across the lake. You know, just going from the southern tip where it's called the Lake Georgia Village all the way to the northern end of it will take you many hours by even, you know, fast boats because you know it's just it's just a long, very long lake and lots of different environments and stuff. So we were hanging around this whole area. We had a boat with us and and we were d dri riding around and, you know, boating around. But also we were hiking around because the Adirondacks are very nice, you know, not very high, but really nice mountains. Really nice. And there are beautiful beaches, you know, fresh water. ⁓ and and you can, you know, it's warm water and and you can see all the, you know, beautiful ⁓ you know environment around you all the time. And and so we enjoy this this a lot. So if people haven't been aro around this area, I would highly recommend it. This is where I spend my ⁓ birthday weekend. And the last thing I want to mention. Just a second. I mean, this is quite different from the from New York City, of course, but it's not that far from New York City. How far is the drive? It's ⁓ from so I live just north of New York City and from our house to this place is approximately three and a half hours. Yeah, that's so you can make that a weekend trip fairly easily. absolutely. Absolutely. That's amazing. There's a lot there's a lot of people from the New York City environment who come up here, but this area has become a ⁓ a magnet for all the nature lovers and environmental lovers and scientists even who are doing all kinds of n different work. So yes, highly recommend. Looks great. Looks great. You look great, man. Thank you, man. ⁓ so ⁓ the other thing I d I started doing after my birthday, Momo, is as you know, you and I both love table tennis or ping pong, right? And it's been I would say maybe ⁓ a year or so since I went back to table tennis seriously. So just this last week, I decided that I'm gonna get back into it. I went to a a table tennis tournament, which I you know, which I always do when when I'm in you know when I'm in good shape. So I just won in our Pink Pot Club, I just won the silver in a under eleven fifty rated USA T T tournament. And I'm super proud of it. I'm like very sore. All my muscles are super sore because I played like twenty games in a highly intense sort of competitive environment. And this guy ⁓ is a French guy who was super good. He won the gold. I got the silver. But he was like amazing. But I learned a lot. I, you know, as always, had a lot of fun meeting all the people, playing with people and all of that stuff. And I loved this sport and I always try to be on the competitive side just because it motivates me to do better. Well, congratulations first, but also, yeah, I mean so fun and it's so weather independent, like year like it it doesn't matter what time of year it is, doesn't matter anything. You can count on playing it. And it's so creative. There are just infinite number of ways to play it. And it's pretty good exercise. You know, I'd say I'd say it's zone two for sure. So no I I go up to Zo I mean this ⁓ tournament I checked, I went up to zone four, Momo. This it gets really, really intense. I go up to zone four. Zone three is pretty normal in in in these in these tournaments, but this time I went up to zone four because I was like Yeah I have to try my very best. So guys are pretty intense. It's really cool. Amazing sport, yeah. I I mean I encourage everyone to try it and see how they like it. Pickleball seems to be now taking over the world, but Pickleball requires an outdoor court and or a court and booking and all that stuff. It just requires more space and more planning and it is mostly weather dependent, whereas ping pong isn't. So Exactly. All right. Great. All right. Are we are we ready for Dr. Bland? We are ready for Dr. Bland. Let's go. Let's bring him on. Well, here we are. Our special guest for today is Dr. Jeff Bland, a biochemist, nutritional medicine researcher, and one of the founders of the functional medicine movement. Early in his career back in the nineties, he co founded the Institute for Functional Medicine, helping advance the idea that chronic disease should be understood through systems biology and not be organ specific. And it should be intercepted years or decades before the symptoms onset. So welcome, Jeff. We're super excited that you have joined ⁓ two PhDs on a pod, maybe as a third PhD on a pod today. There we go. Well I'm super excited to be the third P in the pod. So thank you. Sounds cool. Awesome. So let's start off with some ⁓ dive right in. So, first of all, I'm very jealous that you worked ⁓ with Linus Pauling. That's he's one of the most extraordinary humans ever. So I can only imagine the kind of memories you have. We'll probably touch upon some of those questions later on. But let's get started, please, with ⁓ I mean, you were way ahead of your time because even today I have I struggle to explain to people what systems biology is and what functional medicine is. And back in nineteen ninety-one, I think, right, you started the Institute for Functional Medicine. That's decades ahead of its time. Please tell us about that and and how and and sort of briefly the the challenges and the ⁓ excitements about it. Yeah, thank you. ⁓ you know, I think my my story is probably similar in in many respects to the two of your stories because we've decided to walk down our career in a slightly different path, I would imagine, than maybe the standard, usual, and customary. ⁓ I like to think that my training was usual and customary, but maybe the path that I used ⁓ to travel with it was a little bit different. And I think the ⁓ the major reason for that, quite honestly, ⁓ was this two year experience that I had with Dr. Pauling and his wife, Eva Helen, on sabbatical. I was a university professor starting in nineteen seventy at the University of Peterstown in Tacoma, Washington, and and ⁓ I was very fortunate to be invited to come down to the Pauling Institute. ⁓ to take over a research lab, a nutrition research lab in ⁓ nineteen eighty one on my sabbatical year. It turned out to be a sabbatical two years. And I was very fortunate that my office was right next to Dr. Pauling's office. So I had a lot of opportunity to interact with him informally as well as, you know, through the institute activities. I also had quite a bit of ⁓ interaction with his wife, Iva Helen, ⁓ prior to her passing away. And the two of them together were were formidable forces of nature. I mean they were really remarkable people, not only intelligent, but just very humanistically deep in the way that they saw their work in the world and their pr their roles. And, you know, I was very impressed early on that they kept reinforcing the concept that for them, their work was to try to find ways to reduce human suffering. And that was kind of a watchword for their work. And Whether it was free elections in Guatemala or ⁓ exchange of scientists with Russia at the time, or, you know, working on ⁓ equality related issues in Africa. ⁓ you know, he was involved with ⁓ Albert Schweitzer and Einstein and pulling ⁓ together of ⁓ sixty thousand scientists to sign this document they drafted to get nuclear testing, atmospheric testing ⁓ eliminated, ⁓ that won him the Nobel Prize in Peace. So all those activities ⁓ when when I was around him, and of course he was a magnet for people coming from all over the world to visit. And so I had the the vicarious opportunity to meet not only all these scientists, but ⁓ you know, authors and artists and ⁓ polici pol political pundits and people that were from all sorts of different disciplines that were in their own rights really ⁓ extraordinary. So it it when I left there And I had my ⁓ box of things in my hands from my office and my family was in the car with the engine running, waiting for me to join them to drive back to Washington State to rejoin my ⁓ academic position. ⁓ the last thing that he said to me, we had this conversation, he said, So Jeff, it's a pleasure having you the last couple of years. I hope that we'll have a chance to continue to interact and, you know, collaborate. And I said, Well, of course we will. And then the last question he asked me, he says, so ⁓ just one thing, Jeff, do you think your classroom is big enough? And ⁓ so then I got in the car to drive eleven hundred miles home with my family with this idea kind of going around in my head. And, you know, it was obviously a a not too hidden message that I had to be reflecting on what I was gonna go back to teach my students and have my classroom and my research projects in my comfort zone. And ⁓ maybe he was suggesting I needed my comfort zone to be expanded. So that led me to ⁓ to do when I li think back now as a young man with a family and a mortgage and all was kind of crazy. I ⁓ by the time I got home, I'd made the decision to give up my faculty ⁓ position to my to give up my tenure. ⁓ I was actually the highest endowed professor in research monies. So I gave all that up to decide to put together a group that would teach physicians how to do systems biology and their practices. ⁓ my goodness. Yeah, that was my whole business plan. literally. I mean I thi when I say this now I I I even wonder about my stupidity. But th I think the bottom line is I was guided by this energy that I had gotten from being there f ⁓ with the Paulings and recognizing I was ⁓ what was that? I was forty years I'm just turned eighty, so I was forty years of age at the time. And ⁓ maybe this was the time. If I'm gonna do something different, I should do it now. So that's the that's kind of the start of this next minute. Jeff, ⁓ so I mean that's an amazing story. ⁓ thank you for sharing that. And and so now I I wanna ask you forty years later, where functional medicine is, what do you think? Do you think you've really pushed it to the point where you would like it to be? What are the what are the other things that still needs to be done? How do we get it to everybody's ⁓ health journey, right, at the end of the day? Yeah, that's a really great question. And ⁓ I think it's like the evolution of ideas, it's always a good news, bad news story. Because an idea has its own imperative. You no one controls an idea. I think once you put an idea into the unisf universe, it will find its own way if it has any merit. And and so it gets picked up by people and it gets permuted and and modified and matured, but it can also be perverted too. All ideas can be perverted. Yep. And so I think that functional medicine as a term now became a gathering term. I don't know actually the full reasons for that, the sociological reasons, but it's become kind of a a safe place, ⁓ like a safe harbor for lots of different people to say, ⁓ yeah, I'm in functional medicine. And lot now a lot of those people are very highly disciplined, well educated, very dedicated, ⁓ are you know the people that are carrying forward this model and evolving it. And then there are other people that I would call are more parasitic. They're opportunistic. They're using the term because it moves them along in their ability to be either seen as as ⁓ important or make a better living, ⁓ and they don't really care if they've done any heavy lifting or they really contribute to the body politics. It's all about take, not much give. And I think the evolution of ideas depends upon giving as well as taking. You can't just ⁓ you know, k take out of the bank account, you gotta give back. So I think the answer to your question is that there are individuals well, let me let me put it another way. When I started functional medicine, having been an academic, I was told by my colleagues in the medical education universe that my ideas were very idealistic. And would never become scalable because you'll never get doctors to go back and open books that they didn't really like studying the first time. Biochemistry, cell physiology, ⁓ histopathology, and so forth and so on. That they just wanted to get through those courses that they could, you know, become doctors. And what I was gonna ask them to do in indirectly is no, we're gonna go back and we're gonna restudy this from a different lens, but ⁓ And so they said, Jeff, you're being very idealistic. You might feel a few weirdos out there, but you'll never get a large enough body to scale this. Well, I think I've proven that wrong. I think over the years ⁓ that we have found that in in in large or at large in medicine, there are many people that are very interested in going back and relearning if they can see a reason for it, if it makes them better able to do their work, to serve their patients better. that they find solutions to problems that they were not able to have before. If you provide a value system for them, they will work very hard. They're used to working hard. And what they don't want to do is waste their time. So I think that what we've done over the years, now it's what is it, ⁓ thirty-five years, ⁓ we've built out an architecture that people can see the reason for engaging in this relearning process. And they see the value proposition of what it gives them in terms of increased skills to deliver services to these complex chronic illnesses that constitute over 70% of our medical expenses right now. The other side of the coin, however, that's the light side of the coin. The other side are the people who are just ⁓ opportunistically ⁓ trying to harness whatever they can get out of the affiliation to the ⁓ the movement to their own advantage, and they're perverting it. They're not doing the heavy lifting. They're not really understanding what they're talking about. They're skimming ⁓ they're they're voice boxes, they're you know, influencers without substance. and those are the dynamic tensions. Which one is gonna win? Is it the one that is built on authenticity, authenticity and staying power and and built to last, or is it the group that is just taking without giving back and it's opportunistic? So I I think right now I would say ⁓ The jury's still out, although functional medicine as I would envision it is ⁓ as a systems biology operating system. That's what I say. It's not a form people say, give me the therapies. Well, functional medicine isn't a collection of therapies, it's a way of thinking. It's a way of of of of addressing complexity using ⁓ the ability to pull together multiple bodies of information. And ⁓ that's not the kind of thinking that a lot of people were taught. I you know, I I recall when I was in medical school, it was so much memorization. The the people that could really memorize and recite on demand were the ones that were going to get pushed ahead. It was it didn't really warrant or didn't reward inductive or deductive reasoning. That was y you know, that's kind of no. Just learn this stuff and recite it correctly. So I I think that ⁓ where we are right now in in the whole evolution of medicine and now with the in interposition of AI. Which adds a whole new element of ⁓ flux into this. And would like to talk about that ⁓ a little bit later in this conversation. But Jeff, I have I have to ask you a follow-up question here because I have two people in my circle, one of whom is ⁓ just starting medical school here in the New York City area, and the other one is starting her residency at ⁓ Memorial Sloan Catering Cancer Center like this month or next month. If so if you were to meet people young people like that who are just starting off their career in medicine, how would you explain and motivate them to get into functional medicine? Yeah, so th that's a really another really good question. ⁓ so my answer to that ⁓ is a question is an answer that a lot of people kind of scratch their heads, say, really you would say that, yeah? But my answer is this educational system that were provided in the first two years of medical school, this basic sciences curriculum, where there is a lot of memorization, it's not just road learning for no value. The anatomy, physiology, psychology, histology, pathology, ⁓ those are all really valuable tools ⁓ to understand. Even if you're never going to be one of those specialists, the half fabric of understanding you have that builds out of the architecture of knowledge around the human body is irreplaceable. I mean, it's really important stuff to have. Now where you take it from there, that's the real question. And so then you go into your clinical years, your third and fourth year and maybe your residency and internship, and now you get unfortunately confronted with the didactic of the system that's all focused on disease. And so the people that are rewarded are going to the people that are the best diagnostiagnosticians. And even in TV and and on media you see that That's what they call the really smart doctors, the really great diagnosticians. Well, diagnosing a disease does not necessarily mean you understand its etiology or where it's come from. but it may lead you into therapeutic to treat the symptoms, but it may not actually lead you to understand how to treat the cause. So I think there is where the real issue starts to come. If you got a really good grounding in the first two or three years, now you need to keep your slit width open of your learning curve. To say, what on the edges do I also need to be aware of beyond that of just driving for an ICD code that I can prescribe a name to that condition? That that's kind of my suggested path. And and my my case in medical school, just honest up, was it I was very young when I went to medical school, probably too young in terms of social maturity, and I was always questioning. I was kind of a heretic as a young person. And I think I really frustrated a lot of the medical school professors saying, you know, you'll have a lifetime to ask questions right now, just learn what you're supposed to learn. And so I think that there is a kind of a balance between the insatiable thirst to know more, but also making sure you learn what you need to know, ⁓ so you can take that next step that you're gonna decide in your life. Got it. I I I would say that ⁓ b just a comment on your previous ⁓ description of the functional medicine community. ⁓ Viome is definitely doing working 24-7 at a maximum, maximum power to add value to the functional medicine community. So we're very proud of that. And ⁓ second comment I'd like to make is that I I'm not sure that ⁓ it's super important for ⁓ doctors to choose functional medicine over traditional medicine. I think combining the two is great. And I think that many doctors today are choosing to leave the traditional medicine where the goal is to diagnose and then treat with traditional approaches. ⁓ they're leaving that those positions and starting their own private clinics and joining concierge clinics and and and giving themselves more flexibility. And in that case, functional medicine knowledge and approaches are going to be making a huge difference in how they're able to help people. So I think that's a that's that's all all options are on the table. I absolutely agree with you. In fact at our most recent ⁓ Institute for functional medicine annual meeting ⁓ in that was in San Diego just a couple of months ago, ⁓ of the twelve or thirteen hundred practitioners that were there, I think it was sixty, let's say more than fifty percent. More than fifty percent of them were first timers, and most of them were coming from very traditional medical institutional ⁓ engagements. So they weren't out there trying to seek out how to be, you know, alternative healthcare providers. They were trying to say, how do I augment my skills to manage these complex Chronic conditions that ⁓ the tools that I've had don't seem to be sufficient to give answers to my patients. Great. ⁓ okay, so ⁓ next topic is medicine still largely treats people according to population averages. I think that that's probably a a ⁓ correct statement, but we'd like your comment on that. And what does it actually mean to practice medicine for the individual? Ooh boy. Those are two really good ⁓ questions. What if in a deep dive we'd have to go to the core of the earth. But ⁓ let's let's start. ⁓ I go back to to the asking a question, how would medicine start? Let's say that we're way back when, pre pre Greek, pre-Egyptian, pre traditional Chinese medicine. How would medicine start? ⁓ and it would start by people observing certain things in individuals that were associated with them not being totally functional. So it could be a limp, it could be bleeding, it could be a lump, it could be ⁓ any number of behavior issues that made them unusual. Sweet urine. Yes. That's a great example. That's a really yeah, being a clinical biochemist back at the turn of the of the nineteenth or twentieth century, tasting urine is not my desire. So ⁓ the ⁓ the concept then is medicine starts kind of as a triage by the most observable thing things that are you know easily able to be recognized that are probably very serious. And then it goes from there to say, okay, then how do we go a little earlier in understanding what are the presaging events that lead that person? If it's an accident, you know, maybe we get into accident prevention and falls and things like that. But if it's if it's other like bumps in the body, like it could be in ⁓ oncology related to event, then we start to try to explore in greater detail where did that come from. That leads then into the next in next tier of medicine, which is really, I believe, the ⁓ the tier that we've been in for a hundred years, which is the diagnostic tier. And we as we went through the International Code of D Classification of Disease, ICD 8, 9, 10, and now into 11, we got more and more ways of of dicing and slicing individual signs and symptoms into these coding things that we call diseases. So now we have, you know, I don't I don't remember the number, but I think it's over 35,000 different ICD 11 codes. And so now we we have this second tier of medicine. But then none of those, well, no, that's an exaggeration. The majority of them really dealt with the outcome that we call the disease. They didn't deal with the the the tr the path that led to the disease. So now we started saying, well, what are the major dominant conditions we have today? Do they fall very nicely into these clean diagnostic codes? like ⁓ chronic fatigue syndrome or like postmyalgic syndrome or long COVID or post CMV infection or EBV or the the list goes on, environmental toxicity, desert storm. Do they fall into nice tidy ⁓ ICD classifications? And the answer is no, they don't. So then we scratch her head and said, well hold up, then this second system we have doesn't seem sufficient to meet all the needs. And then we say, well how big is this? issue that w that I'm describing is it is it big enough to warrant us having a a an expanded view of medicine beyond that of of the phase one, which is the triage one and the and battlefield concern and phase two, the diagnostic concern? And my answer is, well it constitutes these conditions constitute maybe as much as seventy percent of healthcare expenditures. Yep. ⁓ jeez. That's pretty big. That's in actually three point one trillion dollars of expense annually. Wow. That should get our attention, shouldn't it? But the system we have doesn't address that well. So there's the third tier. That's the tier we're talking about, which is a presaging ⁓ trajectory towards these conditions that's rooted somehow in a complex distortion of systems biology. And you need different tools and different interrogation to get different answers. You can't keep asking the same question. Questions with the same tools and different questions with the same tools and expect to get different answers. So that's why I think what you do at VIOM is so important because it's pioneering a different lens to interrogate at a different level to get a different set of answers to the dominant questions that we have today. Yeah. I have a super, super i important question that I think is going to be important to the audience. So ⁓ functional medicine as a field is sometimes criticized for getting ahead of the evidence, meaning the evidence is not like super strong, you know, phase three clinical trials, yada, yada, yada, right? So given that, ⁓ can you give an example? Do you have like a favorite example where a patient went to the traditional route and was either not diagnosed or misdiagnosed or mistreated? And then they went to the functional medicine side. And with these sort of not super proven methods, they actually identified what was the root cause and And either reversed or treated successfully the patient. Do you have such examples? ⁓ yeah. Hun hundreds. Yes. ⁓ Any favorites that people can understand power of functional Yeah, go ahead. Before I give an example, let me give a thought for consideration. So a question that I've had asked to me, and as you know, I've I've done a lot of medical education over the years. I travel over six million miles. And so I've had a lot of opportunities to get feedback from many different disciplines and different individuals in different places around the world. And one of the most common questions slash criticisms I've had bears on what you just asked me. And that is the question I'm going to reframe it kind of to make it simple. ⁓ Jeff, you're very persuasive in the way you present information. You've got a lot of practice in presenting. And you can be very ⁓ you can tell a good story, but I as a practitioner only practice scientific medicine. And y the science that you're describing is descriptive and ⁓ interrogative and interesting, but scientific medicine, as I define it, is placebo-controlled randomized clinical trials that have proven the efficacy and safety of specific interventions with new to nature molecules. So I really can't, other than enjoy your your story, I can't really support it because it doesn't fulfill my criteria of scientific medicine. So my response is the following. My response is so let's assume, just for the sake of discussion, if we're having an intellectual discussion here to try to find truth, let's assume that we start with a basic standard that everything needs to be placebo controlled, randomized, and clinically ⁓ proven to the standard that you're describing. ⁓ so do you ever have a patient in your practice in which you're recommending more than one drug at a time and you're going to have them on on that combination of drugs for some long duration of time? That has never been tested in an RCT probably, right? Well there's where we're going. Yeah okay. Because the question the answer is well if they're being truthful, the cancer is of course I did that. And I said, so then can you cite me the placebo controlled randomized clinical trial that demonstrates that combination of drugs over that period of time leads to safe and effective outcome? And they'll say, Well, no, I I I have individual studies on each of these drugs. I said, No, that's not what I've asked you. I've asked you the therapy that you've chosen that you call scientifically based, fulfilling your criteria, does it fulfill what you've just said, that you have Only done things with your patients that are double blind, randomized, placebo-controlled when you give them for years a prescription with multiple medications. And if they're truthful, they'll say, Well, no, but I'm I'm supported because it's standards of evidence from my guilt, my medical society, or my medical education. I say, ⁓ good. Well then let's both agree that we both have a form of non scientific medicine that we're practicing. The difference is mine is safe. Okay, the difference is we're using molecules of very low toxicity, low binding efficiency, that have the ability to service agonists and antagonists, and that's the way the body actually works. The body doesn't work on eating drugs. The body works on bioactive components from food that modulate complex pleiotrophic effects across ⁓ systems that ultimately then control outcome called the phenotype. Yeah. I think that's a major takeaway from this whole episode, really. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there's actually a I've met ⁓ I met several doctors who also have a similar perspective on this, you know, sort of a f ⁓ a forced view of evidence based medicine where you only do things that are ⁓ That are in the Lancet or something like that. You know, and and you don't do anything else that other people have tried in in in other contexts, in other ⁓ combinations and so forth. So I I want to tie that back into what we do at VIOM, just to come back to it for a minute. I think it's very highly connected, is that number one, rather than focus on diseases, we look at the pathways, the biological functional pathways that are in your body, in your gut, in your mouth, in your blood. And then we connect the dots across all of these different parts of your body. So that's the systems view of the of the world rather than just an organ view of the world or a or a sort of a reductionist view of the world. You connect the dots. And then we sort of ask the question: what are the foods that can impact those pathways to take them in the right direction? Right? Eat well before diseases show up. So My question to you is if ⁓ We do need to turn some of this personalization, right? Which is what you we do in Vyome, by the way, right? We we look at we look at an individual's pathways and we we essentially recommend. I don't want to say prescribe, we recommend foods that are appropriate for those pathways. So when someone takes all the foods that are appropriate for their not optimal pathways, the hypothesis that we have is that. They will improve their overall health. And we can also go into individual domains of health. And by the way, Jeff, ⁓ we have done some randomized clinical trials with this personalized ⁓ placebo-controlled regimen. ⁓ so I mean the studies were placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trials, but it's with this personalization ⁓ philosophy. We've done the randomized clinical trials and we've seen. very good positive results. So do you think so my question to you is this, I mean it's a long-winded question, but I had to give the background for the for the same doctor that you talk to, if you were to show the randomized clinical trials that we do in VIOM for this personalization approach, do you think doctors will accept that? Well ⁓ yes, they certainly they will, but I I believe it is the context of of how we ⁓ think of trial design these days. Because of the ability we have now with informatic processing that we didn't have before, we can do large data set analysis. It was not able to be done when I was a student or a a faculty. So we get into this concept of are we doing this in bulk? And this goes back to your population based versus individual-based. Are we measuring the person against themselves? That's the N of one hypothesis, and then collecting N of one data and then looking a compilation of N of one data to get group data? Or are we looking at group data as a composite? Of averages around a mean. And that's the way of research was originally done, because it was the simplest informatic and statistically to do is to take these Gaussian curves and to look at however many deviations from standard we want, see if they were ⁓ symmetric or non-symmetric distribution curves, and then do ⁓ analysis and come up with a rule of the average. The difference now is that we can take a thousand or ten thousand N of one experiments, a person against him or herself. And we can then put them through different informatics systems. It's a different way of doing randomized trials. And but it gives us much more interrogation about individual cores that we can stratify than we had in our original data limited ⁓ system that we grew up the whole pharma industry around. So I think we're at a fair paradigm shifting period in which the old methods, which were the limitation for making intelligent decisions about the individual, are being supplied supplied. ⁓ replaced now with these new informatic models that allow us to individualize understanding. So yes, VIOM is right at the cutting edge, but it's you know your data is only good is the way that you've established its ⁓ specificity. And the way that dru you know, it's it's let me give an example of a drug. ⁓ this could be one of many, many examples probably. But there's a drug that is used now, it's approved to treat ⁓ fibromyalgia syndrome. And ⁓ the history of that drug, which I followed very carefully, it's a Pfizer product, ⁓ which has actually sold quite well, it has limited efficacy actually in improvement. If you look at a number needed to treat, ⁓ you need to treat, you know, something like sixty people to get a very effective outcome. ⁓ so it but it's yet ⁓ approved and it's not inexpensive. So how does that happen if we're using double blind randomly control? Because The way the study was done to get its approval was it put a placebo group and a group with fibromyalgia, these both had fibromyalgia, had put them on either the drug or placebo. At first there was no differential difference between the outcome of the two. They then took the two groups off of the placebo or off the drug, and they saw which then had to return to their symptoms more rapidly. And it turned out that the group that was taken off the drug had the return of their symptoms more rapidly. And so they said this then defines the need for the drug. Whoa. Now see that's an interesting convoluted way of doing a drug trial, isn't it? I've never heard I've never heard of such a thing. Yes, exact exactly. So ⁓ I think that there are many ways of using these methodologies to prove a point. Wow. Okay. I ⁓ I do wanna I do wanna make sure that we cover the question I asked before though. ⁓ Jeff, it's really I think important for a takeaway for people to understand the power of functional medicine, for you to give us one example, let's say where ⁓ A patient basically reached a dead end with traditional medical approach, went to the functional medicine side and actually found relief. Yeah. So let me ⁓ again, as I said, I could I could create or I could give you many examples, but one that's recent that I think ⁓ is a good testimony to the to ⁓ to the value proposition of the system's approach. So I was asked to speak ⁓ actually two years in a row. It's kind of surprising. To the annual meeting of the ⁓ International Rheumatology Society. So these are rheumatologists, basically, dealing with autoimmune diseases. And I was kind of surprised when I was asked to speak the first time, but then to be invited back a second year really surprised me. And ⁓ I think the reason that I was asked to speak was that I was speaking about the gut microbiome and its connection to autoimmune disease. And they were hearing a little bit about that, particularly from their patients. It wasn't necessarily in their literature, but it was coming from their patients. So they said, Well, let's see if we can find someone out there that might be semi credible that we could bring in to to introduce this concept. Only semi credible? Well, it depends on your definition. So so I I went in and ⁓ gave my my sh my spiel and ⁓ After the meeting, one of the rheumatologists came up to me, he said, ⁓ my word, ⁓ Jeff, that was really interesting. That was, you know, a a story that we need to know more about in rheumatology. I d I didn't realize there was that much science that was already present because we don't follow that literature. We just kind of follow the catechism of the rheumatology association. So ⁓ this this was really interesting to hear. And he said, So, you know, my wife has pretty severe ⁓ SLE and we've we've really had no real success in in getting her under control. And I I just wonder do you think she would be a candidate for what you're talking about? And I said, Well, I obviously I I don't know ⁓ specifically, but I do know that the the that we've done st studies over the years ⁓ in our clinical research center. ⁓ at that time it was in Gig Harbor, we saw over a thousand patients a year, and we have seen some pretty remarkable positive ⁓ turnarounds with various autoimmune diseases, including SLE. So SLE is lupus for the audience. Right, systemic lupus erythematosis. Yeah, thank you. ⁓ so I think the nice thing about it is it is there is a common theme here. Every person has to eat something. So when a doctor then asks me, Am I doing something unusual, what I say is, what is your patient eating? And they would say, Well, I never asked that question. It didn't seem relevant. And I said, Well, I I think it is relevant, and we'll help you to answer that question because we're going to help you to guide that patient to eat the right things. So if everybody eats, wouldn't you want to control that as a variable? If that variable has impact on the outcome of your very expensive $24,000 a year drug? And they would say, Yeah, yeah, that makes good sense. So that would be the way I kind of back myself into that conversation. So he then elected to talk to his wife and get her on the program. She he then had her talk to some of our clinical people in my research group. So I came back the next year And this woman who I had met the previous year, who was pretty physically disabled when I saw her, she was not able to ⁓ she was on a walker basically. ⁓ so the next year when I came back, here she was, chipper, bright eyed, and on no walker, and saying, You know, this stuff really works. And I said, Well, I ⁓ it's not a hundred percent, but it really does make a difference in reducing drug need it it improves efficacy and and improves performance and in your case it ⁓ obviously led to a remission. She said yeah I'm pretty much off drugs entirely now. Amazing. So let me let me let me give you one other one. So after that I can get on a run on here so I apologize but I'll just do one. No no this is I think this is really super important for people to understand the power of functional medicine. Yeah so the the other one ⁓ which I actually ⁓ wrote about in my last book was a ⁓ was a woman who was on the front page of our local newspaper in Tacoma, Washington. And the way she was on the front page was a photograph of only her hands and wrists and hands holding two handfuls of medications. And then the byline was around this remarkably serious autoimmune disease she had, erythromyalgia, and being Unable to get treatment of it and how serious these autoimmune conditions could be. She was in her middle thirties, had three children, and was Even with that handful of medications was still disabled. So my colleague, ⁓ Dr. Jack Kornberg, who is one of our clinical ⁓ studies ⁓ directors, he walks into my office with a newspaper and he throws it down on my desk and says, This is disgusting. I said, What do you mean, Jack, disgusting? He said, We can help this woman. I said, Well how how do you know we we've never We've never had an erythromyalgia patient in any of our studies. How do you know? He says, I just know, because there's common themes here that you connect together for these autoimmune diseases, that we could help her. So I'd like to reach out and contact her. And I said, Well, you know, there's kind of like a lot of medical legal stuff there that I think we have to be mindful of. And he said, Well, how about if I work through her physician? And I said, well, that would be the only way I think probably we would undertake this if she was willing to do it. So to make a long story short, ⁓ her physician, who is a head rheumatologist actually in the Pacific Northwest, he ⁓ he agreed that this because it was going to be kind of a diet lifestyle intervention program, not we're not taking her way off from drugs or not giving her any other drugs. ⁓ she started into it. And I because my office ⁓ was right up near the parking lot, I could see people that we had pa special parking for patients. I could see her parking and on our first couple of visits she was helped in by her husband and could barely walk into the office, literally, she had to be assisted. And over the course of a few months she would park in the same spot and I would see her now starting to walk unencumbered into the office. So a year went by And then ⁓ she kind of graduated out of the program. By that time, she was on virtually no medications. She was doing doing incredibly well. And by the way, she had her her her request when she started into this, she said, if you can help me achieve the three wishes, because we have what we call the magic wand rule. What are the three wishes if you had a magic wand that you would like to have resolved? And her three magic wand wishes were one that she could sit at the kitchen counter and prepare or stand and make a meal for her family, which she couldn't do. Number two, that she could go out into her garden in the spring and plant her garden, which she couldn't do. And three, that she could go to the mall with her kids and go f for a walk and get some running shoes, get some walking shoes. Those were her three three wishes. Pretty pretty normal stuff. Yeah. Pretty basic stuff actually. And she ⁓ was able to achieve those three things within six months. She was so then then this is this is the t cop topper of the story. So we didn't see her for several months. So the summer came and towards the end of the summer she called to make an appointment because she wanted to just visit us. And I thought, well, that's kind of cool. So she came back with her husband. And she had a big something wrapped up in paper with a gift card to the doc and our head of ⁓ nutrition services, in which it was opened. It was a picture, a photograph of her at the top of Mount Psy, where she had walked, holding a sign saying, Thank you, Doctor Jack and Deanna. That's And Mount Mount Psy is a burly hike. That's a serious hike. It's yeah, it's twenty four hundred ⁓ vertical feet of a pretty challenging trail. Amazing above Seattle. So yeah. Amazing. Super, super cool. I just wanna close this topic up on on functional medicine. Is functional medicine mostly or solely relying on nutritional lifestyle? Does it include any non natural pharmaceuticals, for example? Well, I think the way that I and my colleagues define functional medicine it's to use the best things For the right purpose for the right reason. Okay. And so it it you know, people have asked me, are GLP ones disallowed in functional medicine? I would say under the appropriate use, maybe GLP ones are what you need. So but it's using them appropriately with the right context of what you're actually trying to achieve. It's not just one stop shopping. Okay, perfect. Excellent. So let me Guru, your turn now. My turn. My turn so ⁓ I think the idea of root cause medicine is ⁓ very, very interesting and appropriate, especially for the audience of this podcast, because we talk about it all the time. So ⁓ I've heard you speak about ⁓ inflammation ⁓ quite a bit, Jeff. And as you know, I mean you you brought up two autoimmune cases and the immune system is sort of the the mediator for sort of chronic inflammation that can be the root cause of many diseases, right? ⁓ I want to ask you whether there are other such processes in the body that are also potentially underlying many chronic diseases. And and please explain to us what they may be if there are others. And then the second question I have follow on is how do you measure the basic underlying root causes? In your mind, what is the approach you would use to to ⁓ measure these and track these over time. So the question you asked, the first question is, are there processes that are fundamental to the upstream or root cause of downstream problems? That was the actually the principal question that we asked the founding members of the functional medicine community in nineteen eighty-nine, nineteen ninety, when we started to actually develop this concept. And so we sat down, I'm I'm very privileged about this because ⁓ when I threw out the invitation that we could have bi weekly meetings. ⁓ I guess no hold it's it's be semi weekly meetings every other week. ⁓ with a group of individuals that would give their time to this. Now this is before we had Zoom. This is back in the late eighties, early nineties. So it would require often people if they if they couldn't come they'd get on the telephone, but we'd mostly do it with ⁓ people bodies g meeting ⁓ every other week. And ⁓ The question we asked one another is what are the based on our understanding of systems biology and cell biology and histopathology and all these different things, what do we think is emerging at the frontier of the root cause? Could we package things into buckets? And we ended up with seven buckets at that time we c we called the fundamental processes. And I actually talked about that in my book, Disease Delusion, I d which was more for the consumer to to give to inform them as to what are these seven fundamental processes. And that's those are the the processes that we we took a bet on would be modifiable. You could execute and change them ⁓ through appropriate intervention. And they were they were forming a matrix. It's almost like now we see the hallmarks of aging and we have this list of these different variables that contribute to cell and biological aging. Well these fundamental physiological processes, one of which was gut function, ⁓ became then the h the I I guess you would call them now the hallmarks of functional medicine. And we've we developed a whole curriculum around it. And that curriculum is what is our ECCME approved, the American College of King Medical Education approved curriculum that we teach doctors for certification in functional medicine. So we we brought up things like detoxification. was one of those. ⁓ gut ⁓ immune function was another. ⁓ intracellular signaling through modulation through hormones. bioenergetics through mitochondrial bioc bioenergetic processes. ⁓ structural integrity ⁓ that relates to muscles, in integaments and bone working together. ⁓ let's see, what am I missing in my seven? ⁓ elimination. That was right. ⁓ we So it's not only intake, but getting rid of things. So we get to the you know, the urea cycle and all the various factors that r help the body to get rid of stuff. ⁓ so those seven core fundamental processes became the the teaching tenets that allowed us to explore at root cause the downstream effects that we see as these ⁓ diseases that end up being called different things. ⁓ now the thing I'm very proud of, some now what is it, thirty Well, yeah. I guess thirty six years ago when we did this, that we weren't a hundred percent on target. I I don't want to overblow it, but we were greater than eighty percent on target. That group of individuals that sat and we this was multi ⁓ disciplinary group of people that were from different disciplines. And ⁓ I think we did a pretty good job of of forecasting where the where the future might take us. Mm-hmm. And so we haven't had, or the the present IFM people, the Institute for Functional Medicine ⁓ educational people, have not had to modify very much those core physiological processes. Now that the teaching to each one of those has changed because we have much more depth of understanding. So then that leads to your question of how do you assess these? Yep. And that is a really fundamental point that I still do not believe is well understood even within the functional medicine community. This is one of my stalking interest points, because I still hear people talking about diagnosis. Well, what are the diagnostic tests that we should be using? And that is the inappropriate word. Nothing we're talking about here is related to diagnosis. It's really to prognosis. These are prognostic tests. So how do you prognostically evaluate? Because if you're a diagnosis, you're already downstream into a set of histopathology. That's those are useful. I mean, I'm not saying that they're not useful. They are. But that's a level of ⁓ in integ interrogation that leads to a different set of outcomes than being able to prognose, to understand trajectory, to understand phenomically how that person is performing at what I call the four quadrants of function. And those four quadrants are ⁓ physical function, metabolic function, cognitive function, and behavioral function. And when you weave those four co ⁓ cohorts together, those four quadrants, now you have total body function. To understand that, you have to have to understand prognostic markers, not diagnostic markers. Yep. Like the difference between a resting EKG and a and an exercise EKG, or a fasting blood sugar and an oral glucose tolerance test. Two different kinds of information. So do you do you do you feel like for each one of those seven areas, there are these prognostic markers that are pretty well defined right now? And and and and Viome has been a leader in in taking this transcriptomic ⁓ knowledge base and and mapping it against these seven areas. Yep. That's that's one way of getting to some answers, right? That's actually ⁓ that that is that is inspiring me to go back and look at all the pathways that we measure and, you know, kind of map it back into your seven areas. So which which I will which I will do or our team will do and And maybe get back to you about and and have you kind of evaluate that and review that, you know, if it if it makes sense. No, I would love that. I Yeah. I think I think these are the tools that because even within the functional medicine community, you you've seen this. People are it's like test de jure. Okay, well let's see, what's the latest test that I might put on my patients to get them to be able to diagnose their chronic illness? Right. That whole formalism is wrong for for me. Okay. Yeah. So you want prognostic tests. That's I think that's a key takeaway here. Another tests before before any disease onset. Exactly. Exactly. So so so Jeff, just one other follow up on that same, you know, thought process is once you understand the, you know, some subset of the seven factors that are impacting a person's life and health, ⁓ the interventions that you you get into for those areas, are those again looking at the individual markers, or are they looking at things sort of more holistically across across all of them, you know, in different combinations? Yeah, I think it's a topology. It's, you know, the landscape of health is a ⁓ irregular surface. If I can use a geographical kind of analogy. So if we run our hand over the topology of health, it's going to be very interested. Some things are high, some things are low. And they can vary ⁓ depending on the inputs, because our body is constantly exposed to signals. And and we are primed as a as an organism to respond to those signals, which becomes our physiological control system. If those signals that c ⁓ we're taking in are one of alarm, our body is extraordinary ability to protect against the ultimate thing which is death. It will do anything to protect against death. It'll it'll give away so many functions in order to protect us against death. That's an interesting way to look at it. So that's that's the end point. That's like when you're in the acute care sys ⁓ setting of a hospital And there's only a couple of biomarkers that are still preserved. Your electrolytes are out of whack, your glucose is out of whack, your proteins are out of whack, everything. And so you've you're just held together by one wire. And if that becomes jeopardized, then you lose the battle to entropy. Entropy takes over and you die. So the key is to maintain this metabolic redundancy, the ability to have multiple paths of execution, which then has to do with fitness and resilience. And that then comes back to all these various channels of this ⁓ topology of how our body has multiple ways of navigating. Because maybe tomorrow a ketogenic diet is the best way to navigate. But maybe most days it's a Mediterranean diet based upon the signals the body is getting. I have a quick question. ⁓ how many grams of vitamin C do you take per day? I'm a thousand milligram guy. Okay, same here. So you're you're you're not ⁓ following Linus's recommendation for ten grams per day. No, I'm I'm not ⁓ as much as I love him and believe in the ascorbic acid model, I I'm not the ten gram per day. I used to be actually in my younger years, but I've decided no. Yeah, ⁓ because I think you end up ⁓ getting a lot of ⁓ drive of dehydroscorbate, which is ⁓ probably not so good. You want a proper balance between the two. Agreed. Agreed. Okay. I'll stop with my questions. Guru, go ahead. Let's ⁓ Well, I I have I have another ⁓ very ⁓ relevant topic I wanted to cover before we we ⁓ let you go, Jeff. And that is ⁓ the AI topic. ⁓ and and I was actually pretty fascinated to hear that you recently launched ⁓ some kind of an AI clone of of yourself that was trained with all of your our few of your life's work or something like that. I'm not sure exactly what it is, but I'd love to hear from you. And also Most importantly, I was wondering what are the applications you were envisioning for that? Is it is it just education or are you actually thinking of of providing care? Yeah, thank you. No, I'm not thinking of providing care. You know, I I'm I'm not a doctor ⁓ that really is licensed to do therapeutics, but I I'd like to think of myself as an information modulator, information source, a provocateur, so to speak. ⁓ and so this was a big decision that ⁓ I made in consultation with my family. My my family was not so much in support of Jeff Plan being cloned, ⁓ intellectually cloned. ⁓ but I felt that I had this body of work that went back now nearly fifty years that had a legacy value that would never a be available if we didn't find some tool, some repository. And probably neither of you know, but I've been told that I was the first podcaster. I didn't I didn't know that. But I started a journal club, an electronic journal club, that I did every month for 32 years with I never missed a month, ⁓ starting in the late 70s. I had several tens of thousands of subscribers. We started off on celluloid tapes. And then we went to CDs and then we went to STICS and then we went virtual. ⁓ and I interviewed over every month I would have an interview with what I called a functional medicine leader of the month. And then I would review their work and then we would talk about ancillary topics. So I did that for 32 straight years monthly. So that's 32 times 12 issues. ⁓ and believe it or not, for twenty-eight of those years. I had a woman working with me, Trish Urey, who is so diligent that she and before the technology we have today, she transcribed all those tapes. My goodness. She made them wow. Wow. Yeah. And when I think back to where this started, in ⁓ starting with cassette tapes and to to today, she's still working with me. So when we started talking about this, I said, Well, we there is a Many of the people that I interviewed are n deceased now. And they were the ⁓ some of the fundamental people, Linus Pauling being one, Abram Hoffer being one. I mean, I could go down the list, so many of these people were the founding members of our community. And I thought this will all get lost if we don't have some way of codifying it. So I made the decision against my family's recommendation of of putting together a Jeff Plan clone that that took all this digital work, everything I've ever written or talked about that it's in digital form and putting it together. And I have to say now when my family reviews it as as ⁓ maybe still apprehensive they are as to how it might be misused, they can't help but be impressed with the quality because the voice similar simulate simulation of me and the quality of the way that it puts the ideas together is scary. I mean it's it remembers better than I do. It remembers all these things that I When I hear myself say that, I say, ⁓ yes, I do remember that. That's right. So Jeff, I I I have to I have to just make a make a small observation there. I ⁓ I I I tried to take my dad's work. My dad passed away just about six months ago. But he is he's had a prolific career with a lot of writings. I think he's written like twenty five or thirty books and he was a justice of the high court of ⁓ Karnataka in India and so forth. So he's got all these judgments and everything. You know, he's got his entire thing. And I wanted to take all of those things and turn that into exactly what you just did. Uh-huh. ⁓ however, I ran into a problem, which you probably did not run into, which is that my language, Kannada, is not spoken very well right now with ⁓ with an AI. So I tried so many different tools in the last few years. And we're not there yet, you know, but we will get there soon enough, I hope. And then I I can take all of his work, which is in a completely different language, not English, and and and turn that into into a clone of my dad, which my family, by the way, does not like, but I think I'm gonna do it anyway. So I completely identify with what what you're saying. But I I wanna know where do you so is this is this an educational tool at in the end of the day? It's available on my website, ⁓ Jeff Leblan dot com. It's also available in Personalized Lifestyle Medicine Institute. it's a ask Dr. Bland. And so I don't do any any diagnosing and and prescribing. But if if if you want information, I I give citations. I can cite all the journal articles I've read over the last It's pretty funny because at our last ⁓ meeting for the Personalized Lifestyle Medicine Institute, my ⁓ the director of the institute, ⁓ Nicole Fox Did a very cute thing. She got me up on stage at the beginning of the meeting. She says, So, Jeff, ⁓ so we're going to have this meeting. It's going to be on the following topic. And ⁓ I just wondered what you think about this meeting. So I thought she was going to have me do an narrative. She's but no, she asked my clone. And so my clone then spoke to the audience about well, this meeting I think should be the following, and it should go and it was hilarious. Everyone got a big by the way, it was very good. I said better than I could have said what this meeting was gonna be about. Amazing. I'm I'm really happy that you've done this, by the way, and I will definitely check that out and also recommend it for other people who wanna hear about all the stuff that's happened in the I mean I didn't know that it was for the last twenty eight years, including with Linus Pauling, everyone else. Beautiful. ⁓ we definitely we definitely love that. So I ⁓ so on from my side, Momo, I have one last question and then I'll I'll leave you to ask you your last question. I think we have plenty of topics to discuss in another episode. So I think we should wrap this one up. Yeah, maybe we should, yes. We should with this final top with this final question, I think we should wrap this up. Yeah. Which is you said that you would ask your patients what if you had a magic wand, what are your three wishes? So I want to ask you this question. If you had a magic wand, what would you want to do? Three three wishes for what you would want to do with functional medicine. Well, I think my my wish number one is that I would be able to have people of your background intelligence and level of inquiry increasingly engaged in this concept. And ⁓ I think that's how you I wish granted. Well, thank you. When I think back to Linus Pauling of how he got sixty thousand scientists to sign this ⁓ document with ⁓ Schweitzer and Einstein, the contribution that made to humanity was was significant. So how how can this idea I call it a virus that gets in your nervous system. I always tell people, be cautious now as you're being introduced to functional medicine, because once it's in there, you can't get away from it. Yep. And so that's that would be my first magic wand wish to infect people with this concept to see if it sticks. Number two would be to make sure that ⁓ the formalism And the scientific underpinning of functional medicine was secure enough that it would be able to be ⁓ scrutinized by individual who had an open mind. There are some people that no matter what you do, they will n never be interested. But for people with open minds, I would like it to be able to fulfill the criteria of of serious ⁓ proof of concept. And and then number three I'd like ultimately this to in whatever form, it doesn't have to be called function months to SWIP, to slip into the healthcare system so that people can be reimbursed for services that are delivering prospective care, not just on terminal disease. Yeah. Or make them inexpensive enough to where ⁓ money is ⁓ the the cost is basically not. Exactly. That's not the barrier. Yes. Right. So so Jeff, on your second wish, maybe ⁓ just a follow up is ⁓ if if we have good scientific evidence. ⁓ for example, in Vyom, we generate a lot of scientific evidence for various things. What would you recommend to be a great forum, maybe a set of journals or whatever it is, to expose those so that the functional medicine community can ⁓ can can can evaluate it and and you know hopefully pursue it? Well, you know, in this kind of attention disorder society in which we're now living, that's all kind of driven by the idea of the moment. It would seem that ⁓ that we need to find a way to attach these ideas to ⁓ What do I want to say? I don't want to call it glamour, but to produce a buzz. We w we want it we we want it to be an authentic buzz. We want it to rival the excitement that people have when they hear about this new melanoma treatment technology that just has come out that you know is really remarkable and there's no question it's it's ⁓ extraordinary. But if you look at the number of people that that affects, it's far smaller than if we were to produce the same kind of buzz around prospective health care. So How do we do that? How do we get that kind of excitement, energy into transforming health, not just treating terminal disease? Agreed. Agreed. I think with that ⁓ we should probably ⁓ call this particular episode ⁓ an end. And ⁓ I you know I we would I mean we have a long list of other questions that we would have to talk to you about, but it's great. It's really great talking to you, Jeff, and ⁓ hope to see you back here in the not too distant future. Well I just wanna I wanna Just ⁓ commend both of you. I think that this ⁓ activity you're engaged in here is extraordinarily important. Society rises and falls on ideas and the communication of those ideas and ⁓ your idea mongers. You are promoting ideas that make a difference. So so thank you. Thank you. We're we're loving it. Thank you for being a wonderful guest and we'll talk soon. Have a good day. Look forward to it. Thanks so much. Be well. Bye bye. Bye-bye. ⁓ Jeff Bland, Dr. Jeff Bland. ⁓ I feel like we could go on for hours and hours with him and we'll bring him back. We'll definitely bring him back. There's so I I'm I'm particularly excited about ⁓ presenting to people many, many different examples of of how functional medicine works in practice, but also as a scientist, to go down deeper into molecular mechanisms and show, for example, how is it that A specific molecule made by gut microbiome can travel to the central nervous system and stimulate neuro regeneration, right? Such things are not known to conventional medicine and no one's going to be paying attention to your gut microbiome and conventional medicine. And these are the things that you can, as a person, actually learn about and take the right probiotics and right prebiotics and actually help yourself. Absolutely. ⁓ so yes, lots lots more to discuss ⁓ on this topic and we'll we'll have more episodes on this, I'm sure. Let's move on to the next segment of our of our show today, which is ⁓ in the news, right? ⁓ I'm sure a lot of people have seen in the news that there's a lot of talk about cancer vaccines. It turns out that ⁓ Moderna had some success with their cancer vaccine, and that's now in the news ⁓ in all the news outlets. So, Momo, I think we should talk about it both from the perspective of You know, what difference will it make? But first let's talk about the molecular mechanism that's going on. So can you explain to us briefly, please? Yeah. Well, so I just want to give a bit of context that I've been I've been super excited about this approach for more than a decade. And in fact, Viome has a pending patent application ⁓ that describes this same approach but for anti aging. So what if you can have an anti aging vaccine? And that's that's this is kind of a similar thing. So first of all, ⁓ Vaccine is now sort of a bad term for many people. So maybe we shouldn't even consider this to be a vaccine. It's like a training tool for your immune system. So let's talk about how this works. So naturally, the way that cancer is actually not is actually defended against is something called immune surveillance. So we have cells in our body, immune cells called T cells, and these T cells literally patrol the entire body. And when they find a cell that's not normal, they kill it. That that's literally how it works. It's called immune surveillance. However, the reason that cancer comes around is because it is able to evade those cells in many, many, many different ways. And that's literally could be we could spend hours in ways that it can evade. But what this Modernus program does is two things. First, it sequences the cancer cells in that person. Keyword in that person because every cancer is different. So in this person, they sequence the cancer and identify what is different between the cells, the cancer cells, and the normal cells. What is the difference? And then they create those differences and basically present those differences in the form of an mRNA vaccine, but it's actually just mRNA to the immune system of the person. So they train the immune system and say, hey, These are these are new things that are presented in your body that you didn't know about or you couldn't see. Now, here, here it is. I'm telling you clearly, here are the differences. Go find them and go kill them. So you're basically training soldiers to go kill cancer. It's a phenomenal approach that is highly personalized, which is important, and it's highly effective because you're basically unblinding the immune system. So I think we should definitely at some point in time have. A bit more about this, especially when our patent is awarded, to talk about the mechanism in pictures, how this works. Makes sense, Momo. Thank you for explaining that. And you know, stepping back, right, melanoma is the specific type of cancer that they they ⁓ targeted in this particular experiment, ⁓ in the news. And ⁓ it turns out that A lot of people with melanoma, especially with stage higher stage melanomas, like stage three or stage four melanoma, a lot of people have a recurrence risk for melanoma. So for example, a stage three person has approximately fifty percent chance of recurrence of the cancer even after they go through the first round of therapy. And if they take a standard drug in the market, which is Kitruda, they can reduce that recurrence risk by about fifty percent. Now turns out this particular cancer, let's call it an intervention, vaccine, whatever you want to call it, this particular method reduces the risk by an additional 50%. So the the ⁓ risk of you recurring, getting a recurrence of melanoma becomes very, very small given all the methods that. you know, the the pharma companies have developed in the last several years. So if you have melanoma, please take advantage of this. It's very, very important. And and Momo, do you have a sense of, you know, what the cost of these kinds of vaccines could be? Is it like very high? Well, no. I mean the no, the the the manufacturing of the vaccine will be very low, but the manufacturing cost has nothing to do with the market cost, right? Of course. So I mean, we know now with GLP ones and quitruda, for example, quitruda is one of the most expensive drugs ever and it's it's the the the the most profitable drug to make it costs very little. But ⁓ of course the pharmaceutical companies are going to market or or price their products what the market will bear. So it'll really depend on what the market will bear. But I think as more and more companies develop this, just like what we've seen with GLP1 drugs, you know, GLP1 drugs just went down by 75% in cost in the last year. I think that over time this will become more and more affordable to everyone because the actual process of Detecting these lesions and then manufacturing this mRNA training tool is actually not not a lot of money. Got it. Got it. Okay. Moving on to the next topic. ⁓ the Vi Monthly Challenge. Last time we had an announcement of the winner of the monthly challenge for the last time. We're gonna continue the same monthly challenge this month as well, which is that everyone is encouraged to go down below this video if you're watching a video. To provide your comments and questions. And we, Momo and I will look at all the comments and questions and we will pick one that is very insightful, very educational, really good questions and comments. You know, we pick one of those and we award the monthly ⁓ challenge award, which is a free full body intelligence from VIOM, which is the leading test in the market right now. And you will get all the benefits off all the insights and the recommendations that you get from that test. Yeah. Awesome. And then ⁓ what's in the next episode? So we are going to have a very special guest in the next episode. This is Dr. Ed Zuckerberg. He's spent 40 years educating dentists and dental community about the importance of oral health in systemic health. And that's what the focus is going to be. So definitely tune in because oral health is not just limited to the mouth. Oral health has deep impacts on systemic health and very serious diseases such as Cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer's, type two diabetes, and several others. So we're gonna dive deeper into those topics. So exciting topic and look forward to that. Yeah. That's all we have for today. I'm Momo, a biochemist. And I'm Guru, an AI scientist. Wear two PhDs on a paw. Yes. See you next time, Momo. Bye bye. See you next time. Two PhDs on a pod is a Viome Health Science Podcast production, written and hosted by Viome CTO Guru Banavar and Viome CSO Momo Vuisich. Produced and edited by Lisa Shomo. Podcast Art by Kevin Wu. If you enjoyed today's episode, like and subscribe for new episodes every other week. We'll see you next time.