Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: BP buybacks, International Energy Week, and AR7a results
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:08the UK energy market. BP in Shetland and then all the
- 0:12way down to London for Energy Week.
- 0:14And then finally we got the results of the onshore
- 0:18allocation round. That's an awful lot to talk
- 0:21about if you're just me. Aberdeen features lead Ryan
- 0:23Duff, but thankfully I'm I'm joined with a crack team of
- 0:26experts, my news editor, Erika Askeland.
- 0:30How are you doing this morning, Erika?
- 0:31Howdy, everything's great, despite the fact we're still no
- 0:36sunshine here in Aberdeen. I mean, I think it's a world
- 0:39record. Yeah, I mean, considering this
- 0:41is the third Aberdeen game that's been called off as my
- 0:45beloved Dons have not played. Do they do they not work in in,
- 0:49in the without? With a?
- 0:50With a lack of. Sunshine.
- 0:51Well, you see, I'd love to say we're solar panel panel powered,
- 0:55but no, it's the fact that the pitches are all waterlogged in
- 0:57the north and northeast of Scotland.
- 0:58So three games in a row without play.
- 1:02And that means that the weather has become our greatest
- 1:04defender. But that's that's enough for
- 1:07that. Ed Reed, E Forward Editor You've
- 1:09been down in London. How are you doing?
- 1:12I'm very well, thank you. Yes, as you say, I've been, I've
- 1:14been out at International Energy Week.
- 1:16Catching up with all the. Tourings and throwings.
- 1:18And finally, but last but not least, I should say, news
- 1:22reporter Matthew Perry. How are you doing today, Matt?
- 1:25I'm doing well. I've got a holiday coming up
- 1:27next week so I'm just skating through to Friday.
- 1:30Apparently, are you are you getting to that point in the
- 1:32week where the everything started to drag because you're
- 1:35getting excited about the holiday?
- 1:37Or are you just that? Point in the week was was Monday
- 1:40at 9:00 AM. Fair enough, fair enough.
- 1:44Well, do you know what we won't delay any further.
- 1:46We'll get you closer to that that holiday by rushing through
- 1:50this action-packed episode. So Erica, you can maybe start us
- 1:53off. Great.
- 1:54BP had its Q4 results this week. It did.
- 1:58Tell me what's happening. Sure.
- 2:00Well, so we're just about coming to the end of Q4 results season.
- 2:06Shell went last week and BP this week and of course we also had
- 2:10total energies. And then I I noticed also ADNOC
- 2:13and Tanka out Thursday morning, which is an interesting
- 2:17comparison in and of itself. But what we saw from BP was
- 2:24interesting, I thought mainly because it, it wasn't really
- 2:31like it was, came in with a slightly lower profitability and
- 2:37income, you know, than it had in 2024 if you'd taken to the full
- 2:42year results. But I think to a certain extent,
- 2:47you know, their long process has been focused on, have they
- 2:52turned a corner? You know, they've been coming
- 2:55under fire for a number of years as a result of, you know,
- 3:00underperformance relative to their peers, Shell in the UK and
- 3:04Europe. And then of course over on the
- 3:07other side of the pond, Exxon and Chevron, the kind of big
- 3:11super multi majors who are killing it.
- 3:14Q4 results saw BP come up with a bit of a surprise, which I think
- 3:21was a bit of a shock to the market in that they decided to
- 3:25suspend buybacks. And as they were going to
- 3:29basically say, you know, they wanted to kind of suspend these
- 3:33because they wanted to start paying down debt, which is 22
- 3:38billion, and they have a target to try to reduce that by 2027.
- 3:43Now, buybacks, I kind of was thinking when I first saw it
- 3:48that, Oh, yeah, you know, they've maybe decided to kind of
- 3:51like, retain some money because, you know what, actually,
- 3:54buybacks are like a process through which large companies
- 3:59tend to just try to kind of shore up their share price.
- 4:04So it's not exactly even something that shareholders kind
- 4:06of get to be able to put in their pocket except for the fact
- 4:09that, you know, maybe the value of their shares either goes up
- 4:13or, you know, it doesn't quit falling.
- 4:15So it was interesting to see the market reaction to BP's decision
- 4:19to cut their plans to do buybacks announced in their Q
- 4:24Fours. So funnily enough, they became
- 4:29the 1st to take such a a major step.
- 4:32Although Total Energies followed up and said that they were also
- 4:37going to be reducing their amount of buybacks as well.
- 4:40So why does this matter? I think to a certain extent, you
- 4:44know, following what was probably a rough day after BP
- 4:48announced their Q Fours in which they lost about 6.5% of their
- 4:53shares value, they did end up recovering pretty much the next
- 4:57day, you know, once the shock ward off.
- 4:59Because it kind of seemed that maybe consensus is suggesting
- 5:04that this is a good idea and you know, gonna maybe it's a good
- 5:08idea to preserve a little cash in order so that you can pay
- 5:12down some debt in order so that also you can invest in what BP
- 5:19kind of has ahead of it. And so it was also interesting
- 5:23to see on Q4D, Gordon Burrell, who's the head of exploration,
- 5:29talking about the boomerangy discovery in Brazil, which is
- 5:34like 800 billion barrels or something like that.
- 5:37It's like huge and it's having a real impact on reserves.
- 5:43Now. Of course, the interesting thing
- 5:45too about reserves and particularly if you compare it
- 5:49with Shell, Shell has fewer reserves where as BP is now
- 5:55saying that it's replacement reserves are among sort of the
- 6:01top and among the listed oil majors in the West.
- 6:07And so this is maybe kind of setting themselves up for the
- 6:10future. So having a few Bob in the bank
- 6:12is maybe a good idea, particularly when their new
- 6:16chief executive comes and takes the helm in April.
- 6:19First, However, Ryan, you kind of were looking at something
- 6:25interesting in Shetland and tell us a little bit about that.
- 6:29Yeah, I was going to say that reserves are all well and good
- 6:32and let you know, but they're only you.
- 6:33They only become something if you actually develop the bloody
- 6:36field. And that's something that we're
- 6:39not seeing in Shetland with Claire.
- 6:41We've obviously seen Claire Phase one, which delivered the
- 6:43Claire platform. And then count how many times I
- 6:46say the word Claire in this section actually, because then
- 6:49we've got Claire Ridge from Phase two and now Claire Phase 3
- 6:53is still not happening or it looks like it's there wasn't
- 6:57been any announcement on it and that that we're.
- 7:00Waiting for that though, right? Yeah, we're waiting to see if if
- 7:03they, if they pull the trigger, bite the bullet, whatever you
- 7:05want to say on that. And that led to the University
- 7:10of Strathclyde's Centre for Energy Policy doing a little bit
- 7:15of analysis. I say led to they were doing the
- 7:17analysis already and this kind of just happened to be like come
- 7:21out at the same time and they essentially discovered that if
- 7:26the solemn boat terminal doesn't process the the clear extension
- 7:32if and when it's delivered, over 200 jobs stand to be lost in
- 7:38Shetland. Now the, the the organization
- 7:42did, it's worth mentioning this because I think, you know, it's,
- 7:45it's easy to see big scary number and say oil and gas
- 7:48investment doesn't happen, therefore jobs further down the
- 7:54downstream are lost. But I think the interesting
- 7:57thing for me was actually the opportunity in Shetland for E
- 8:01fuel. So we'll, we'll OK, then square
- 8:03that circle as quickly as I can. Essentially, in the best case
- 8:08scenario quotes from CEP for oil and gas production, it was
- 8:14saying that even if Claire's developed about 340 jobs and
- 8:16Shetland will be lost and about £24 million will be wiped out of
- 8:20the local economy by 2050. Now that's quite interesting
- 8:25because it sort of shows that, you know, clear would provide a
- 8:29momentary uptick in jobs, you know, and then they'll return to
- 8:32about 2024 figures by 2036 if if the field was to go ahead.
- 8:38So to and again quote them to avoid another Grangemouth or
- 8:42Rosebank CEP were backing this clean fuels, low carbon fuels
- 8:49initiative that Barry were discussing previously.
- 8:53And they'd said that if this goes ahead, as well as 55 jobs
- 8:57could be lost or there could be redundancies, could be, quote,
- 9:01entirely mitigated. When I was up at Sullivo last
- 9:04year, you know, kind of mainly it's being operated by Inquest
- 9:09and Inquest, you know, produces a lot of its oil, oil there.
- 9:15They've, you know, been arriving by tankers and that's been in
- 9:20serious declines. So they're kind of ripping out a
- 9:22lot of those old oil chains that they've got and kind of
- 9:26repurposing it for the future. But on the same site of course
- 9:29is BPS Clare Ridge produced facility where all the
- 9:37production from West of Shetland goes in.
- 9:40So I mean, you can see why they're hoping that maybe you
- 9:44know, the the expansion goes ahead because you know, that
- 9:48facility should probably underpin the employment there.
- 9:52It's it's seeing dwindling reserves.
- 9:53There's a lot kind of going. On 100%.
- 9:56What very is doing in terms of biofuels and all that, which is
- 10:00really potentially interesting. Well, that's, and that that that
- 10:03made me think of something that I heard Barry's Donna, Donna
- 10:06Sutherland say last year at the energy exports conference
- 10:08essentially vary for those those not in the know as a subsidiary
- 10:13of INQUEST. And they're, they're essentially
- 10:16looking at the clean, clean energies or lower carbon options
- 10:21for solemn Bow. And one of the things they're
- 10:23thinking about is these E fuels, these little carbon fuels.
- 10:27But Donna pointed out something last year, which was
- 10:29essentially, you know, we all know electricity bills, energy
- 10:33bills in the UK are astronomically high and that has
- 10:37a real impact when it comes to producing these type of fuels
- 10:40here versus in in the continent. It'll be interesting to see that
- 10:45wasn't addressed in the report. And I'd really like to see
- 10:48what's happening with that going forward.
- 10:51For some reason, I feel like Ed Reed has a smashing insight to
- 10:54wrap up the segment, but I'm just going to throw him under
- 10:57the bus and see what he says. Well, I mean, I, I, I had
- 11:00thought, but it kind of throws back to Ericas.
- 11:03Point about BPS kind of growing reserve because?
- 11:07As as as mentioned. I was at a week earlier this
- 11:10week. And Wales Sawan Head.
- 11:12Of shell was there and. Was also asked about buybacks.
- 11:15Obviously Shell having as Erica pointed out, gone, gone, gone
- 11:19much more into the about something like 3 1/2 billion I
- 11:22think in, in, in Q4. But I think he but he was also
- 11:26asked. About as they, as they.
- 11:28As they describe it, inorganic. Growth, which means acquiring
- 11:31other companies. Shell, of course, having run the
- 11:34slide. Rule over over BP last year.
- 11:38And, you know, obviously Russell Wan.
- 11:40Spoke about, you know, the the importance of growing
- 11:43organically. He was talking about LNG,
- 11:45obviously that that being a particular focus for Shell.
- 11:48He was talking about trading. That's kind of another area of
- 11:50growth for them. But he.
- 11:52Acknowledged that also that essentially the company's
- 11:55liquids production is going to be flat to 2030.
- 11:59Which obviously is one of those things where you're like, oh,
- 12:01that's. Like an interesting problem and
- 12:03you know, maybe. Maybe there's another big oil
- 12:06company out there. Maybe that's.
- 12:08That's also headquartered in the UK.
- 12:10Should we say that's that's maybe going through some
- 12:11challenges of its own? That that might be.
- 12:13Open to, to to to some sort of a deal.
- 12:17Just going to throw it in there. Well, we'll hear more about
- 12:19Energy Week just after this break and I'm going to be asking
- 12:22you think about this over the break was Will Sarwan caught in
- 12:26last season's clothes with this our buybacks scheme that he's
- 12:30still going for and every other super major looks like they're
- 12:33backing out of. Find out what Ed Reid has to say
- 12:36on that after this short break. Hello, I'm Ed Reid.
- 12:40The. Editor of E Forward E Forward is
- 12:42a membership community that brings together the entire UK
- 12:46energy supply chain. Every hub, Every.
- 12:48Sector Every stage Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy
- 12:52sector, working with industry and policy makers to unlock the
- 12:55UK's opportunities and advantages.
- 12:58This is the movement to secure increased investment, improved
- 13:02policy making and better collaboration by providing our
- 13:05members with visibility, influence and access.
- 13:07Join me forward today. So Ed, we're going to go very
- 13:13Mean Girls and start bitching about whale Salon and his look
- 13:17what's happening with the share buybacks.
- 13:19Is he, is he kind of so last season or is he on a finger on
- 13:23the pulse with this scheme? Well, I mean, yeah, it's very
- 13:27much the, the, the big question is I feel like obviously Shell
- 13:30and BP. Very much moving in different
- 13:32sort of directions, right, I think.
- 13:33I think so on coming in to take over at Shell.
- 13:38Yeah, gave him that opportunity to essentially.
- 13:40Move away from the low carbon solutions as as as Shell calls
- 13:44it. The BP has now sort of followed
- 13:45suit with. And obviously that we expect.
- 13:48To see more of under under Meg O'Neal when she comes in in
- 13:51April I think. So yeah, it, it feels like
- 13:54obviously they are, you know, they're, they're.
- 13:56Moving in in different ways, obviously Shell is kind of
- 13:59leaning and it's it's kind of areas of expertise, LNG in
- 14:03particular. I think they're going to grow.
- 14:04I think they grew something. Like 11% last year and they got
- 14:07a plan to grow something like 5% every year for the next 5 years
- 14:10so. It's a really sort of.
- 14:12Significant move into into gas volumes, but yeah.
- 14:16I mean, I think you know, so so obviously, you know, he, he, he
- 14:19stood out there and. Spoke very strongly about about
- 14:22about how well the company had been doing.
- 14:24You know, he was saying that they'll continue buying.
- 14:26Back shares right down to $50 a barrel, which I thought was
- 14:31quite, quite striking. And obviously oil prices now
- 14:33sort of 6869 given sort of geopolitical tensions.
- 14:37So obviously it feels like. Sort of, you know, Shell feels a
- 14:40lot stronger and that's that's quite a sort of striking
- 14:42difference, isn't it against Equinor Total, who are sort of
- 14:46all sort of, you know, you know, moving away from that sort of
- 14:48buyback opportunity somewhat. But I mean, he, he, he also
- 14:51spoke about about. Sort of, you know, the sort of
- 14:54the, the, the broader sort of macro challenges.
- 14:56I mean, I think, you know, he's, he set up this sort of tension
- 14:58between the. US is sort of the.
- 15:00World's leading Petro state, obviously now the the the
- 15:03biggest producer of liquids in the world and.
- 15:06China is the sort of the world's leading.
- 15:08Electro state, right. So obviously they've they've
- 15:10kind of moved into essentially coal and renewables in a big way
- 15:12that didn't really, you know, burn gas that.
- 15:15And that's really kind. Of focused on energy.
- 15:17Security and both of. Those countries, you know, kind
- 15:18of really looking into the energy security in that way.
- 15:21And and sort of Europe's kind of in the middle and, and he was
- 15:24quite critical. About the ways in which I
- 15:26suppose European plans have sort of, you know, driven this kind
- 15:30of move to decarbonisation, whilst kind of taking the eye
- 15:33off the ball a little bit in the near term.
- 15:35And, and he was, you know, sort of saying about essentially the
- 15:39that kind of mounting reliance that we're seeing on, on, on, on
- 15:43gas imports, LNG imports in particular following the, the
- 15:47Russia's invasion of Ukraine. And it was, it was a very
- 15:50interesting sort of tension. And obviously, you know, he, he
- 15:52had some comments for the UK as well.
- 15:54I mean, it really has put the part of, of, of the of, of the
- 15:57kind of the broader European picture, but.
- 16:00He was, you know, essentially. Saying, you know, de
- 16:01industrialization is a choice which, you know, was it was
- 16:05quite, quite a punchy thing to come out with in, in in London.
- 16:10But I think that's that's the thing about.
- 16:11International Energy Week is that there's this kind of
- 16:13interesting tension at the event between.
- 16:16You know companies. Come from around the world.
- 16:19On the one hand, there is this kind of.
- 16:20Broader global energy trading kind of an outlook.
- 16:24And then on the other hand, there is this kind of very kind
- 16:26of localized, you know, sort of power plants, you know,
- 16:29electricity prices and there is. This kind of tension.
- 16:31In, in, in, in, in the room. And I think, you know, where's
- 16:33the one kind of embodied it quite.
- 16:35How's the feeling of the general mood there?
- 16:39Because, you know, it always kind of feels maybe that, you
- 16:43know, U KS like the slow kid in the corner when it comes to kind
- 16:47of its energy policy. Whereas, I mean, you know, as I
- 16:51was reading today, you know, ADNOC and Tak are absolutely
- 16:56minting it. You know, they're not ashamed at
- 16:59all of their oil production and reserves.
- 17:03And as you say, interesting to see that China, of course, is
- 17:07the electrification, you know, kind of big wig.
- 17:11But of course, you know, they're probably getting a lot of their
- 17:13electrification from coal, which kind of makes you go really
- 17:16like, is that where we should really be doing?
- 17:18But tell us, how does it feel on that floor?
- 17:21What is it? What does it look?
- 17:22Like, yeah, I mean, I think I think yeah, the China.
- 17:25Discussion is always very interesting and there were some
- 17:27really interesting points raised and I'm going to.
- 17:29Kind of off the top of my. Head so you've kind of.
- 17:31Put up, but it's something like, but I mean that's the yeah,
- 17:33yeah, yeah, I'm going to roll the dice and and obviously feel
- 17:36free to Fact Check me. Right in.
- 17:37With your with your comments and complaints, but it was something
- 17:40like so. So China last year added.
- 17:42Something like 7080 GW. Lots of coal last year alone,
- 17:47right? Which is more than India has
- 17:49added, I think, in the last decade.
- 17:51So as you say right there there is that kind of question around.
- 17:53Actually, you know what? Does that mean?
- 17:56And obviously that's not. Great.
- 17:58In terms of sort of, you know, net zero, in terms of, you know,
- 18:00tackling emissions, those sorts of problems.
- 18:02But at the same time, they are running that coal.
- 18:06At lower and lower utility rates, utilization rates, sorry.
- 18:09So actually. The amount of time.
- 18:10That they're burning coal is falling.
- 18:13So there's. Quite an interesting kind of a
- 18:14question there around, you know, how they're kind of square in
- 18:17that circle around, you know, kind of building out kind of
- 18:21industrial capacity and not just in coal obviously in other other
- 18:23other areas as well. I mean, I think looking at
- 18:26Chinese industry, you know, the construction of batteries, solar
- 18:29panels. It's kind of obviously off the
- 18:32chart. I mean the, you know, an
- 18:33extraordinary. Move into into renewable energy.
- 18:36Well, they're still not. They're certainly not de
- 18:38industrializing, are they? Whereas it kind of feels like
- 18:41that's EU KS only choice. But it I suppose the the it's
- 18:44that interesting thing, isn't it?
- 18:45Where? Because for.
- 18:47China moving into that sort of electrification stack is very
- 18:51much industrialization and that's.
- 18:53Obviously, I mean, I think there are, there are clearly.
- 18:55Questions raised about, you know, the sort of the financing
- 18:59for those questions, right? Like obviously is it
- 19:01sustainable? Is it, you know, like obviously
- 19:03the European Union is investigating China on a number
- 19:06of grounds, EVs, turbines around is the government giving
- 19:10government and local governments giving unfair support to
- 19:13manufacturing? And obviously, you know, that's.
- 19:16That's a good question, but actually, what?
- 19:18The the sort of the plus side of.
- 19:19That is clearly building out an extraordinary local capacity to
- 19:24manufacture things. And there's a point to which
- 19:27it's quite hard to stop. Isn't there?
- 19:28Because actually, when you're China and you've got more than a
- 19:31billion people living there, you need to create jobs and how are
- 19:35you going to do it? You're going to throw money into
- 19:37building more capacity, whether that's coal-fired power plants
- 19:40that don't get used or factories that are making solar panels
- 19:45that you then have to dump on the world market.
- 19:47There's kind of a question there about about local stability.
- 19:50Isn't there? And I think but, but yeah, I
- 19:53mean the the, the, the tension with the.
- 19:54UK is really striking, right? We, we had a number of points
- 19:57about, you know, the incredibly high electricity prices, right?
- 20:01Fenton Sly from Niso was talking about that and, and you know,
- 20:04speaking very strongly about it. Chris O'Shea from Centrica was
- 20:10predicting that power prices, I think he said that, you know, in
- 20:1320-30 would be, you know, sort of higher still.
- 20:18And that's obviously a a point. Of, of, of debate.
- 20:20I mean, I think the was it Martin Pidworth from SSE was
- 20:24saying that he disagreed with that sort of assertion and, and
- 20:27as far as he could see, you know, building into a renewable
- 20:30capacity was cheaper. He raised some very interesting
- 20:33questions around the costs of of of key B2 and actually, you
- 20:37know, what is the real cost of building new gas fired power.
- 20:40But I think, look, everyone sees the.
- 20:42Problem around around UK electricity prices.
- 20:47But I think there there's also a question there about what's the
- 20:49alternative right at this? Point.
- 20:51At this point in our. Trajectory.
- 20:52Where are we going? What?
- 20:53What? What else could we do?
- 20:55Ryan, What do you? Think well, that's, I mean, I
- 20:56think it's it's interesting. I think it's especially the
- 20:59point you made around Will Sawan being sort of piggy in the
- 21:01middle a little bit between the the US and China.
- 21:06So I was listening to Westwood yesterday.
- 21:08So I'm going to I'm going to go to our Nordic neighbors slightly
- 21:12because Westwood were essentially speaking about how
- 21:15Norway are on the brink of a decline in oil and gas as well
- 21:18because of, you know, reserves. There's a finite amount of
- 21:22resource and that's why the government are incentivizing so
- 21:25our bigger projects and started getting big projects going as
- 21:28quickly as possible. That was quite interesting.
- 21:30But on on the UK front, as you say, what, what does the UK do?
- 21:34Because even even though UK says we don't have enough to, to wash
- 21:39your face, we don't have enough to completely cover our own, our
- 21:43own needs. But if, I mean, I've said this
- 21:46before, if it was an easy, it was an easy answer, then I would
- 21:49probably be in charge. But it's, it's not, but no, it's
- 21:56So I think The thing is with, with this, it's, it's about, I'm
- 22:00going to use the most cliched term in the book, but it's about
- 22:02manage, right? It's about managing the
- 22:04transition. I'm going to, I'm going to sound
- 22:05like Dave Whitehouse here, but I think yeah, it's, it's not
- 22:10helpful the, the policy in the UK when it comes to
- 22:13incentivizing investment, oil and gas.
- 22:14But then you've got the other side of things West of Orkney
- 22:17closing down or pausing investment.
- 22:21I'm, I'm, I'm willing to stake a claim that pause just means
- 22:24cancel because I've never seen a project on pause.
- 22:26And, you know, so with that, you know, front runner in Scotland,
- 22:31which was meant to be like, you know, Scotland was meant to be
- 22:34the initiative that really helps us get to 2030 when generation
- 22:38targets. It's it, it feels like the UK is
- 22:42going in the wrong direction for both oil and gas and renewables.
- 22:46So I completely get where those issues are.
- 22:49But I'm, I'm really looking forward to going over to Norway
- 22:52in August for ONS because I'm a really interesting chat with
- 22:57someone from the University of Stavanger.
- 22:59Last time I was out there about our wind capacity and what we're
- 23:02doing. And when that I was like, look
- 23:04at Concord and it had to get shipped over to you guys to get,
- 23:08you know, for maintenance. When it, when it shut there when
- 23:10it needed that, why weren't we doing it?
- 23:13And you know, is the, is the UK sort of not, not this powerhouse
- 23:18that it pretends to be. And he was like, what the hell
- 23:21are you talking about? The UK is a definitely a front
- 23:26runner. Scotland's a front runner.
- 23:27You know, and then you hear people and across Europe
- 23:30speaking about we don't have an allocation round system and we'd
- 23:33love 1. And, you know, we sort of bitch
- 23:35and moan about the CFD process. So I think it's, it's an
- 23:39interesting one. I think it's very easy to sort
- 23:41of point to, to Europe and say, oh, they're not doing things
- 23:45right. But, you know, we've been
- 23:46producing oil and gas for, for a long time and we are sort of
- 23:49facing dwindling reserves. Is the UK government managing it
- 23:52properly? Probably not, but I think it's
- 23:55always the easy target. Yeah, I suppose just on that I
- 23:59know. We're pushed for time, but I.
- 24:00Feel like it's that sort of thing, isn't it?
- 24:02Where actually in an ideal. World we could go.
- 24:04Back sort of 15 years into the past and be like.
- 24:06Actually, you know what? Building more?
- 24:08Grid would be really useful at this point 1. 100%. 100.
- 24:12So more. Great ruling out time travel,
- 24:15What are the options? That I don't.
- 24:17I don't think a flux capacitor is on Kier Starmer's mind.
- 24:20However, I think he would love one right about now.
- 24:23I'm sure that would really help him, but surely that's anyway
- 24:25nuclear? Program that we've so yeah.
- 24:30Just what we need. Just read too many Isaac Asimov
- 24:32novels and things that nuclear unlock time travel for him.
- 24:36Who knows, maybe that's the case, but that I think that
- 24:39wraps up Energy Week. I'm sure we could talk about
- 24:42this, but it's own full 30 minute episode.
- 24:44So we might end up having more from you next weekend, who
- 24:47knows. But after this break we are
- 24:50going to be speaking about the UK.
- 24:51We are going to be speaking about renewables and how there
- 24:55are yet more delays. We'll find out more with from
- 24:58after this break. Be a part of the conversation
- 25:02shaping Scotland's investment future.
- 25:05The Scottish National Investment Bank Conference 2026, in
- 25:09association with Energy, Voice and the Press and Journal,
- 25:12brings together investors, business leaders and policy
- 25:16makers who are driving economics, social and
- 25:19environmental impact across Scotland.
- 25:22This is your opportunity to hear directly from those deploying
- 25:26mission LED capital. If you're serious about
- 25:29investing with purpose, whether you're raising capital,
- 25:32allocating it, or shaping policy, this is the room you
- 25:36need to be in. Get your tickets online today
- 25:43Map AR 7 finally delivered well as AR 7 finally delivered the
- 25:49onshore wind, solar title, all of that, the not offshore wind.
- 25:53But it was a day late, right? It was.
- 25:55A day late. I think you know, there's
- 25:56potentially a bit of COM started there because GB energy local
- 26:00power plan came out. So maybe they're trying to give
- 26:02some add to to that, but you know the Winter Olympians over
- 26:07in Milan, they're breaking records and the UK government is
- 26:10breaking their own records on allocation rounds for onshore
- 26:14wind and solar. And I guess you wouldn't really
- 26:17think of the UK as a country and we don't really talk about solar
- 26:20all that much, but it is quietly growing in in the background.
- 26:24So we for AR7A as they were calling it solar kind of for the
- 26:27largest share of new capacity, it had 4.9 gigawatts across 157
- 26:33projects of your various sizes, the biggest of which was the
- 26:37West Burton Solar Farms 480 megawatts is on the site of the
- 26:41former W Burton Power Station. That's also where the UK
- 26:43government is pursuing their fusion energy project, the
- 26:47spherical tokamak for something something that's step.
- 26:50I know the. Isn't W Burton W Burton also
- 26:54where they're kind of spectacularly demolishing the
- 26:58existing coal power station and sending us these fabulous videos
- 27:02of things? Just getting great explosion
- 27:04videos out of West Burton recently.
- 27:06So yeah, some big solar projects going on.
- 27:09Also a lot of onshore wind. There was 1.3 gigawatts of
- 27:13onshore wind capacity awarded across 28 schemes, the bulk of
- 27:17that being in Scotland with 21 projects.
- 27:19We also saw five in Wales. And interestingly we saw two,
- 27:23admittedly quite small, but two projects in England securing
- 27:26CFDS. And those are the first I think
- 27:28in just over a decade that have secured contracts for difference
- 27:31in England. And that gum slow start.
- 27:34Well, it comes after the Labour Government obviously last year
- 27:37removed that de facto ban on onshore wind.
- 27:39So we're potentially starting to see the first buds of new growth
- 27:43of the UK onshore wind sector spurting back into life.
- 27:49Also interestingly for our Scottish listeners, you would
- 27:52know the Scottish Government has made a lot of the potential for
- 27:55tidal energy, a lot of projects going on up in Orkney and in
- 27:59Shetland and the Pentland Firth over the years.
- 28:02But there's a, a new kid on the block as of the latest
- 28:06allocation around. So I guess you know, we saw a
- 28:08record, you know, new highs in, in solar and onshore wind for
- 28:12tidal stream. They did come in lower than
- 28:15previous allocation around. So we had 20.9 megawatts awarded
- 28:20across 4 projects. That's down from 28 megawatts in
- 28:25AR-6 and you know, going back to AR5 and AR-4, we saw 53
- 28:30megawatts in AR540, megawatts in AR-4.
- 28:33So it's been trending downwards in the last few years.
- 28:36And but the CF diesels came in a strike price of £265 per MW
- 28:42hour. So, you know, quite expensive
- 28:44compared to solar and onshore wind, which were about 60 and 70
- 28:47lbs roughly respectively. But we've seen in this round a
- 28:53bit of a shift towards Wales in, in away from Scotland.
- 28:57So there's one product awarded in Scotland and three in Wales.
- 29:00And they're mainly at the Morley title scheme off the coast of
- 29:05Anglesey. So we've seen the Welsh
- 29:08government talking a lot about the, and we're discussing
- 29:11industrialisation and, and you know, the title sector.
- 29:14They they really because of EU KS massive title result, I think
- 29:17it's got the largest title resource capacity in the in the
- 29:21world. There's a lot that has been made
- 29:23out of the potential for tidal stream energy to be an
- 29:26industrialization opportunity for the UK at, you know, prices
- 29:30of 260 pounds, 265 lbs per MW hour that might, you know, might
- 29:36need to significantly industrialize to bring those
- 29:39prices down. It's, you know, big question as
- 29:41to whether that's going to realistically happen.
- 29:43But yeah, it's just interesting that to see Wales sort of
- 29:46getting in on the action there with Tidal Stream.
- 29:48Here's a question. What's Morley got that the
- 29:50Pendulum Firth doesn't in terms of title and all that and
- 29:57they're. Setting themselves up at the
- 29:59moment as kind of a plug and play basically.
- 30:02So they've got the the full scheme, the grid connection,
- 30:05everything set up at Morley and they're opening it up to
- 30:08different developers that want to come and test their
- 30:10technologies. And then basically sort of
- 30:12similar to the emac up in in Orkney.
- 30:15And and maybe it's just easier to get to than than Orkney, but
- 30:19I wonder if that's yeah, we're seeing.
- 30:21A couple like an issue, I think, you know, kind of particularly,
- 30:25you know, with first AR 7 round floating offshore wind, you
- 30:30know, in the Celtic Sea off the coast of Wales.
- 30:34And then of course, now the title.
- 30:36I mean, frankly, Wales is probably a little bit closer to
- 30:39the grid in a way than, you know, areas in the remote north
- 30:44of Scotland ain't. Is this going to be an ongoing
- 30:47problem? And like, I guess maybe that
- 30:49just means that, you know, the Nimbys are going to be delighted
- 30:52in Scotland to see that the rest of the country is going to get
- 30:54plastered with onshore wind. Is this, is this the way that
- 31:00things are shaping up, do you think?
- 31:01Well, I think there's certainly part of it.
- 31:03Obviously you don't have to build a massive subsidy
- 31:05interconnected as if you've got an offshore project in in Wales
- 31:08to get to where all the power demand is in in the South of
- 31:10England. I think another thing that
- 31:13though that could be preventing that is that Wales doesn't have
- 31:17the offshore supply chain that Aberdeen does.
- 31:22And we see this in other industries as well.
- 31:24I remember speaking last year at All Energy to someone from the
- 31:27Cornwall Geothermal, deep geothermal United Downs
- 31:29projects. And they said that they had a
- 31:31supply chain member from Aberdeen that was the only place
- 31:34in the UK basically that they could get this part that they
- 31:36needed. They drove all the way to
- 31:38Aberdeen from Aberdeen down to Cornwall and they'd forgotten
- 31:41something. So basically then had to wait to
- 31:43for this supply chain company to drive all the way back to
- 31:46Aberdeen, pick up what they'd forgotten and come all the way
- 31:48back because there was no one in Wales, there was no one in
- 31:51Cornwall that had that capacity to they just, that was all there
- 31:55was. So, you know, for these Celtic
- 31:57Sea projects, a big part of that will be essentially establishing
- 32:01a supply chain where one doesn't exist.
- 32:03So there are a lot of advantages that the Celtic Sea has,
- 32:06obviously because of its geography, but you know, it
- 32:08certainly doesn't have the oil and gas heritage and and supply
- 32:12chain capabilities that the Scotland does.
- 32:14So, you know, it's, it's one of those things where I think the
- 32:18from the sounds of it at the moment, the UK government just
- 32:20wants more, more, more, you know, wants to develop as many
- 32:23projects as they can. So I think it's, you know,
- 32:25we'll, we'll see for AR-8 and AR9 I think is also potentially
- 32:31where, where Scotland may, may see some more joy based on Chris
- 32:34Stark's comments and then Gillian Martin's comments in
- 32:37Glasgow a couple weeks ago. But yeah, it's, I guess, you
- 32:40know, a good day for the onshore wind and solar sectors in the
- 32:44UK, and a horrible day if you're an MD who hates a sight of wind
- 32:48turbines. I guarantee that Aberdonian
- 32:51contractor you're speaking about was getting paid by the hour.
- 32:54That's that's what I'm thinking. Clever strategy.
- 32:58But you know, it is interesting and you know what I do, I've
- 33:00always had a bit of a soft spot for Tidal.
- 33:02I think it's a really interesting, interesting
- 33:05technology and we speak about the supply chain an awful lot.
- 33:08And you've sort of touched on it and touched on it there as well
- 33:11with I was listening to I believe was or orbital marine
- 33:18couples last year, a couple of years ago and they were speaking
- 33:20about how their O2 TB was like 98% or something mental about
- 33:25was produced right here in the UK.
- 33:27And I always think that's something that Cana flies under
- 33:31the radar a little bit. It's just how much of the
- 33:33content for title can be built domestically, especially when
- 33:38we're speaking about offshore. Wind and it is good at the
- 33:41current scale. That would be the case if we
- 33:44were trying to do GW scale or title string projects.
- 33:46I think there's an argument that maybe that local content number
- 33:50would probably come down a little bit.
- 33:51But yeah. And then you mentioned orbit all
- 33:53day were the project in Scotland that picked up a CFD.
- 33:56We also saw tidal technologies and hydro Wing which is part of
- 34:01Inyanga Marine Energy Group. So some some new tidal
- 34:04technologies. So if you want to head along to
- 34:07read my article Ryan, you can see some lovely pictures of some
- 34:09of the new tidal turbines that will be going into Welsh waters
- 34:13soon. Oh, I do.
- 34:14I do love that. I'll need to look at the
- 34:16pictures. I was, I was just too fascinated
- 34:18with your words, Matt, to take any, take any of the pictures
- 34:21and that's what it was. You look like you want to wrap
- 34:24things up. I feel like you're itching to
- 34:26jump in to say something here, No?
- 34:28No, no, I was just going to say, you know, does your does your
- 34:32love for Tidal? Technology also extends to 240
- 34:38lbs a MW. Hour Are you also in love with
- 34:40High Power? Prices.
- 34:41No, definitely not. But I think, I think The thing
- 34:44is, I mean, I guess if, if I were a title industry, a
- 34:48representative, which I'm not, but I mean before someone says
- 34:51I've been paid off by big title, which doesn't exist, there's no
- 34:54such thing as big title. And I, I would say that you
- 34:58know, as, as we're also seeing in that debate that we had
- 35:01earlier about energy prices with the sort of energy transition
- 35:05and so on and so forth, you know, we, you need to develop
- 35:09the sort of economies of scale to make these things cheaper,
- 35:11right? So right now it is very
- 35:13expensive. Does it have the potential to
- 35:15get cheap enough to, to sort of compete with us, you know, with
- 35:19the likes of onshore wind and solar?
- 35:21Definitely not solar. I don't think that'll ever
- 35:23happen. But it's an interesting,
- 35:25interesting talking point. To be fair as well, it's not far
- 35:29because the floating wind strike price in AI7 was 216 lbs per MW
- 35:34hour and a lot's been made of the floating winds potential.
- 35:36You know, tidal is it's only about £15 per MW hour only as we
- 35:41say behind floating wind. But you know, as everyone said,
- 35:45you've got to got to start somewhere to start bringing
- 35:47those prices down. And I guess the question is
- 35:49whether Tidal can can reduce those costs?
- 35:51I guess it's, I think the, the the striking thing for me is
- 35:54that I suppose it looks like so soda and onshore wind, those
- 35:56prices are still looking. You know, pretty really
- 35:58competitive, aren't they? Whereas.
- 36:00Offshore wind is. Kind of, you know.
- 36:02Kind of, it felt like it's kind of bottomed out and it's kind of
- 36:04gone back. Up hasn't it?
- 36:06Right. So that was that was the result
- 36:07in the AR 7 that we saw. And it just feels like maybe
- 36:10that's, you know, the sort of. Dividing line and if we are
- 36:13thinking about, you know how we get more power cost effectively,
- 36:17you know it feels like onshore is going to have to be the
- 36:20answer, right? So there's massive, sort of
- 36:22enormous sort of solar. Pi mean I think the UK got
- 36:25something like 20. Gigawatts of of solar PV
- 36:28capacity there. And that is already.
- 36:30Enough to annoy people I whenever I drive around, I see,
- 36:33you know, big signs complaining about and it feels like
- 36:36actually, you know, we're. Going to need more of.
- 36:38This and you know, to to to bring prices down and I feel.
- 36:42Like there is possibly a. Lack of coordination or planning
- 36:49around how these pieces all fit together.
- 36:52But I feel that's probably a a debate for another day.
- 36:55If only we had NISO or something like that to coordinate.
- 36:58You know how there's elephanting together?
- 37:02Yeah, I feel like there's also a communications problem around
- 37:05solar because I see a lot is made and I think the, you know,
- 37:08there was some talk this week about concerns about food
- 37:12security and, and farm lovely farmland being taken up by solar
- 37:16panels. I'm just not sure if people are
- 37:17aware that sheep can graze underneath solar panels.
- 37:20And, and, and at least in, in hotter climates like Australia,
- 37:23they're a lot happier underneath solar panels.
- 37:25And they, you know, they produce bigger wool yields.
- 37:27So, you know, there's, there's, it's not all doom and gloom
- 37:31destroying precious farmland in some, you know, areas, solar
- 37:35panels can actually improve. I I didn't realize you were so
- 37:37into agriculture. Bring on the solar panels and
- 37:40the lamb biryani. You know I'm I'm not all for
- 37:43that, right? I'm I'm a former ABC.
- 37:45I'm former ABC country and regional reporter Ryan.
- 37:48Of course, I love my. Agriculture.
- 37:50Oh well, there we are. We will need to, we'll need to
- 37:52rethink your job title here then, you know, start Speaking
- 37:54of speaking to those nimbies more often.
- 37:56But that I think that does it, does it for this week's episode.
- 38:00We really have run the gauntlet, haven't we?
- 38:02I don't think there's an area of the UK energy sector that we
- 38:05haven't probably offended and upset in some capacity, but
- 38:10maybe, maybe, maybe you know, also our champion, I guess
- 38:14nuclear didn't get much. It's still.
- 38:16Time. Tell us what you think about
- 38:18nuclear on LinkedIn. Why don't you?
- 38:20But anyway, that'll do it for this this week's episode.
- 38:23So thank you very much, Ed, Erica and Matt for joining me
- 38:26and thank you very much for listening.
- 38:28If you want to hear more from us, well, we'll be back same
- 38:31time, same place next week.