Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Newton Calculated Stars Not Human Madness
Transcript
- 0:00OK, so if I told you that Sir Isaac Newton, you know, the man
- 0:03who codified the laws of motion and literally invented calculus,
- 0:07was in the stock market, just completely financially ruined, I
- 0:11mean, losing a fortune, would you would you think that was
- 0:14some kind of historical? Joke.
- 0:16It's the ultimate contradiction, isn't it?
- 0:18I mean, the man who could calculate the exact movement of
- 0:21planets, of celestial bodies was just utterly incapable of
- 0:25predicting where his own money was going, right?
- 0:27So today we're diving into one of those famous financial
- 0:30disasters in history, the South Sea Bubble of 17/20, and our
- 0:35central case study is none other than Sir Isaac Newton.
- 0:38That's our mission today. We want to unpack Newton's exact
- 0:41timeline of trades, dissect the the fundamental fraud at the
- 0:44heart of the South Sea Company, and really figure out why.
- 0:47Why does genius fail when it's confronted by, you know, human
- 0:50madness? This story proves that
- 0:52intelligence, no matter how profound it, just hits a wall
- 0:55when it meets market irrationality.
- 0:57And the gravity of this, I think it's best captured by Newton's
- 1:00own words, his famous quote reflecting on this personal
- 1:04catastrophe he went through, He said I can calculate the
- 1:08movement of the celestial bodies, but not the madness of
- 1:11the people. Let's frame the scale of his
- 1:14loss for you, the listener. Newton lost 20,000 lbs in 1720.
- 1:20That was an absolutely staggering sum.
- 1:22It wasn't just, you know, a chunk of his wealth, it was
- 1:25basically every penny he'd saved over decades as the director of
- 1:29the Royal Mint, a very well paid job.
- 1:31We're talking millions of dollars in today's money.
- 1:33It was life altering, a complete disaster.
- 1:35OK. So let's unpack this.
- 1:37I think we have to start with the company itself, the South
- 1:39Sea Company. We do, because the foundation of
- 1:41this entire bubble was built on one of the most audacious, but
- 1:46also simple government maneuvers in history.
- 1:48The South Sea Company or SSC? Looking back, it seems like the
- 1:52original historical meme stock. It wasn't built on earnings or
- 1:55any real business performance. It was just hype.
- 1:57All narrative momentum. But why was it even created?
- 2:00Well, the creation of the SSC, it solved this enormous
- 2:04practical crisis for the British state.
- 2:07After decades of war, the government was just drowning.
- 2:11Drowning in what they called insurmountable public debt.
- 2:14Just a mountain of IOU's they couldn't handle.
- 2:17So the government needed some kind of financial magic trick to
- 2:20make all this debt just go away. Precisely.
- 2:23And they engineered a deal with the Southsea company.
- 2:26The SSC essentially became a debt conversion machine.
- 2:30The company would issue stock to the public, you know, sell
- 2:33shares and then use that cash to pay down the government's debt.
- 2:37So the government hands its debt to the SSC and the SSC pays for
- 2:40it with money from the public buying stock.
- 2:42Exactly. It sounds brilliant for the
- 2:44government, if a little convoluted, but what did the SSC
- 2:47get in return? What was the story they sold to
- 2:49the public? That's the hook they were
- 2:51granted to trade monopoly in the supposedly vast and wealthy
- 2:54territories of South America. This was the narrative that just
- 2:58set the financial world on fire. The company was telling everyone
- 3:01they had the keys to unimaginable wealth.
- 3:04The promise being that this exclusive trade route would
- 3:06generate profits so huge they'd easily pay off the government
- 3:10debt they'd taken on. That was the story.
- 3:12And here's where it gets really interesting and tragic.
- 3:15We know this monopoly was the fatal flaw.
- 3:17But why? What was so fundamentally
- 3:21worthless about this promised trade route?
- 3:24Well, because the majority of South America at the time it was
- 3:28Spanish imperial territory. England and Spain were
- 3:31constantly at war, or at least in conflict.
- 3:33You weren't friendly trading partners.
- 3:35British ships couldn't just sail in instead of shop.
- 3:38So the actual trade rights were tiny.
- 3:40Laughably miniscule, a few limited voyages a year.
- 3:43The supposed profits from this grand monopoly were, for all
- 3:46practical purposes, 0. So the company score asset
- 3:49wasn't profit, it wasn't earnings, it was just an
- 3:52illusion, a government sanctioned story.
- 3:55That is the defining feature of a bubble, whether it's 1720 or
- 3:58today. The valuation, the SSC, was
- 4:01based purely on faith. Faith that the narrative of this
- 4:04untapped South American wealth would keep growing, keep drawing
- 4:07in new money completely detached from reality.
- 4:10And that momentum brings us right back to Sir Isaac Newton.
- 4:14Let's walk through his specific actions in 1720.
- 4:17They perfectly illustrate that painful journey from rational
- 4:22investor to emotional gambler. His first move?
- 4:26It shows that rationality that really defined his whole career.
- 4:29Absolutely. Action #1 The rational trade
- 4:33Newton sees the initial excitement he gets in early in
- 4:351720, but unlike everyone else, he correctly identifies a point
- 4:40where the price has just gone too far, too fast.
- 4:42He had a plan and he exited. He sold his position in April
- 4:46when the stock hit around £300. And he was a massive winner from
- 4:49that. He booked a 7000 LB profit,
- 4:51doubled his money. From a rational point of view,
- 4:53that's a brilliant trade lock in the game.
- 4:56He had some metric that told him OK this is getting overheated.
- 4:58But then comes the classic emotional reversal action to the
- 5:01FOMO trap. He's out, he's sitting on a huge
- 5:03profit and he just has to watch the world around him get richer.
- 5:06It's the ancient tale of financial regret, isn't it?
- 5:09His friends, his colleagues, his neighbors, they didn't sell, and
- 5:13the stock just kept climbing. It shot past 300 to 500, then
- 5:17700 and it just kept soaring towards 8. 100 and suddenly
- 5:20Newton's spectacular 7000 LB profit.
- 5:24But it feels small. It feels foolish compared to the
- 5:26paper gains everyone else is bragging about.
- 5:28It's that moment where a perfectly rational decision
- 5:32feels like a catastrophic mistake simply because you
- 5:35didn't maximize the outcome. You did well, but you didn't do
- 5:38the best. And that intense psychological
- 5:41pressure, that's what we now call fear of missing out, FOMO.
- 5:44It just creates this irrational need to get back in.
- 5:46It completely overrides decades of intellectual discipline.
- 5:49Which leads to action #3 the disaster buy.
- 5:53Newton just couldn't stand being on the sidelines anymore.
- 5:55He dives back into the market near the absolute peak of the
- 5:57bubble. The price is close to 900.
- 6:00And he didn't just reinvest the 7000 lbs.
- 6:02He added gigantic new principle. He threw huge amounts of his
- 6:06accumulated wealth back into the SSC.
- 6:08He shifted from thinking, what is this company worth to I have
- 6:12to be a part of this? Exactly.
- 6:14He was betting on human momentum, not corporate value.
- 6:16And what happens when momentum is the only asset?
- 6:19It vanishes. The bubble burst hard in August
- 6:211720. And the stock price It didn't
- 6:24decline, it just it collapsed. His final tally was that
- 6:28devastating 20,000 LB loss wiped out decades of his savings from
- 6:32the Royal Mint. It's so instructive to look at
- 6:34what was happening in the market.
- 6:35We have his own words on this, his own self analysis.
- 6:38He admitted his fatal error. He said he thought he could find
- 6:41a bigger fool to take the stock off his hands at an even higher
- 6:45price. That admission is the perfect
- 6:47pivot. The mechanics of madness.
- 6:49How could a man dedicated to immutable universal laws base
- 6:53his financial strategy on on finding a Dumber person?
- 6:56I know the SSC was one of the earliest, most massive examples
- 7:01of the greater fool theory in action.
- 7:03It's fascinating because during a bubble, the whole objective of
- 7:06investing completely changes. People stop caring about what
- 7:09the company can earn. That number is irrelevant.
- 7:11Their sole focus becomes timing the exit, just finding a fool
- 7:15tomorrow who will pay a higher price.
- 7:17It's game of musical chairs. Played with incredibly
- 7:19speculative assets and that game is very, very fun until the
- 7:23music stops. And the thing about a bubble
- 7:25collapse is that it's not slow, it's instantaneous, it's
- 7:29catastrophic, and it's driven primarily by a crisis of
- 7:33liquidity. Yes, let's clarify that
- 7:35mechanism for the listener, because that liquidity factor is
- 7:38what turns a slow decline into a complete free fall.
- 7:41When liquidity dries up, it means the system is run out of
- 7:44greater fools. Suddenly everyone wants to sell
- 7:47their hot potato, but no one is willing to buy anymore, at least
- 7:51not at any price close to the peak.
- 7:53The. Pool of buyers just vanishes.
- 7:55But the price doesn't slowly go down.
- 7:57It instantly collapses. The panic to sell meets zero
- 8:00demand and the price free falls toward its actual underlying
- 8:03value. Which for the SSC was basically
- 8:060. Pretty much.
- 8:07This brings us back to the tragedy of Newton's intellect.
- 8:10He was a master of trajectory, of velocity, of change.
- 8:14Why couldn't his own mathematical genius save him
- 8:16from this predictable emotional trap?
- 8:18Because mathematical models, even calculus, they are
- 8:22fundamentally useless when you apply them to a system governed
- 8:25by human emotion. Newton was trying to apply
- 8:28perfect rationality to a chaotic, irrational system.
- 8:32He understood the risks, but the pressure, the pressure of
- 8:36watching others profit, just overwhelmed his logic.
- 8:39It just highlights the limits of pure analysis, doesn't it?
- 8:42If you had to make a mathematical analogy for this,
- 8:44how would you simplify it? Well, you can think of it like
- 8:47it's not about calculating the numbers.
- 8:49It's about recognizing when the denominator in your equation,
- 8:53the fact you're representing market rationality and the
- 8:55supply of new buyers when that denominator approaches 0, when
- 8:59that foundation of rationality disappears, the system tends
- 9:02toward, well, infinite and catastrophic collapse.
- 9:06The rigorous, predictable laws that govern the planets do not,
- 9:09and they never will govern human panic.
- 9:11So what does this centuries old story mean for us today, 300
- 9:15years later? Why should Sir Isaac Newton's
- 9:17failure still matter to you, the modern investor?
- 9:20Because history confirms this pattern is cyclical.
- 9:23It's not a one off event. Newton's story is a financial
- 9:27rhyme that just echoes through time.
- 9:29You see the same pattern in 17th century Tulip mania, in the
- 9:33irrational exuberance of the Internet bubble in late 90s,
- 9:37and. You can see it reflected in
- 9:38modern things too. Certain cryptocurrencies high
- 9:41flying stocks built on nothing but narrative.
- 9:43The underlying asset changes could be a flower bulb, a trade
- 9:47monopoly, a.com promise, a digital Ledger.
- 9:50But the human psychological pattern is always identical.
- 9:53Chasing returns driven by belief, not by value.
- 9:56And the enduring critical take away from Newton's personal
- 9:59tragedy is this. The greatest enemy in investing
- 10:03is not the market. It's not a lack of data.
- 10:06The biggest threat is the enemy within our own internal greed,
- 10:09our susceptibility to the herd, and the profound anxiety of
- 10:12FOMO. Newton made a rational profit
- 10:14and he walked away. But his ambition and regret
- 10:17dragged him back in when the prices have become utterly
- 10:19absurd. Which raises an important
- 10:21question for you, the listener, as you navigate today's markets.
- 10:25Markets saturated with hype. How do you personally identify
- 10:30the crucial difference between a real opportunity based on
- 10:33tangible value and jest, a story built on the hope of finding a
- 10:38bigger fool tomorrow? It requires an intellectual
- 10:41humility that even the greatest genius of the Enlightenment
- 10:44couldn't manage. In that moment, you have to be
- 10:46able to look inward and admit when your emotions, not your
- 10:49analysis, have taken the steering wheel, that
- 10:52self-awareness is the only real protection.
- 10:54So to summarize the core lesson one last time, even the smartest
- 10:58minds in history are susceptible to the human impulse of greed
- 11:01and the fear of missing out. That is why Sir Isaac Newton,
- 11:04the man who mathematically defined the universe, lost
- 11:0720,000 lbs. And it serves as the most
- 11:10powerful reminder there is that while we can calculate the
- 11:13orbits of stars and the trajectories of rockets, if the
- 11:16biggest variable is our own irrationality, is any amount of
- 11:19raw information or intelligence truly enough to protect us from
- 11:22ourselves when everyone else around us is making money?
- 11:25Something profound to think about.
- 11:26Thank you for joining us for this deep dive.