Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Media mix modeling: why Mastercard and Uber revived it
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:08Host: Today's episode, Media Mix Modeling, why MasterCard and Uber are betting on an old tool
- 0:13Host: in a new era.
- 0:14Host: Media Mix Modeling was supposed to be dead.
- 0:17Host: It's the marketing equivalent of a fax machine.
- 0:19Host: Why are MasterCard and Uber suddenly resurrecting it?
- 0:22Expert: Because it was never dead.
- 0:24Expert: It was inconvenient.
- 0:26Expert: Media Mix Modeling, which is the statistical technique of estimating how each channel drives
- 0:31Expert: sales by looking at aggregate spend and results over time, gives you slow, honest answers.
- 0:38Expert: Digital attribution gave you fast flattering ones.
- 0:41Expert: The industry picked flattering.
- 0:43Host: That's a strong accusation.
- 0:45Host: Are you saying everyone knew attribution was lying and used it anyway?
- 0:48Expert: I'm saying the incentives were rotten.
- 0:51Expert: Last click attribution, the model that credits whichever ad the customer touched right before
- 0:56Expert: buying hands the trophy to the channel standing closest to the finish line.
- 1:01Expert: That's almost always paid search on your own brand name.
- 1:04Expert: You're paying Google to take credit for demand your TV ad created.
- 1:08Host: Come on, search still drove the conversion.
- 1:11Expert: Did it?
- 1:12Expert: If someone Googles Uber and clicks the ad, the ad didn't create that intent.
- 1:17Expert: The brand did.
- 1:18Expert: Uber's own team admitted they were double counting.
- 1:21Expert: Everyone said their channels drove more revenue than the company actually made.
- 1:26Expert: When your math claims 130% of sales came from your ads, the math is the problem, not modesty.
- 1:34Host: So MMM is just the grown up in the room.
- 1:36Host: Why did it fall out of fashion in the first place?
- 1:39Expert: It was genuinely painful.
- 1:41Expert: Old school Media Mix Modeling took a team of statisticians three months to deliver a
- 1:45Expert: report that was already stale.
- 1:48Expert: You'd learn what worked last spring sometime around Christmas.
- 1:51Expert: Digital attribution refreshed every morning.
- 1:54Expert: Speed beat accuracy and for a decade, nobody got fired for it.
- 1:58Host: What changed?
- 1:59Host: Computers were fast in 2022.
- 2:01Expert: Two things.
- 2:02Expert: Cheap cloud computing means a model that took three months now runs overnight and privacy
- 2:07Expert: rules gutted the tracking that attribution depended on.
- 2:11Expert: When Apple let people block the identifier that followed them between apps, roughly a
- 2:15Expert: quarter of iPhone users opted out immediately.
- 2:19Expert: And attribution went partly blind.
- 2:22Expert: Suddenly the precise tool couldn't see and the old tool that never needed to track individuals
- 2:27Expert: looked brilliant.
- 2:28Host: MasterCard's a payments company.
- 2:30Host: What's their angle here?
- 2:32Expert: They sit on aggregate spending data across millions of transactions, anonymized, no individual
- 2:37Expert: tracking.
- 2:39Expert: That's exactly the Fuel Media Mix Modeling wants.
- 2:42Expert: They can feed a model actual purchase behavior instead of clicks.
- 2:46Expert: MasterCard isn't nostalgic for an old tool.
- 2:49Expert: They own the ingredient that finally makes it work.
- 2:52Host: SEMrush data suggests brand search volume is a leading indicator of MMM lift.
- 2:56Host: You buy that?
- 2:57Expert: I'd use it as a hint, not gospel.
- 3:00Expert: SEMrush sells search and analytics software, so their whole business depends on you believing
- 3:05Expert: search metrics predict everything.
- 3:07Expert: Cross-check it against your actual sales curve before you build a budget on it.
- 3:12Expert: Directionally, brand searches rising after a TV flight is real.
- 3:16Expert: The precise coefficient they'd sell you, less so.
- 3:20Host: Here's the uncomfortable one.
- 3:21Host: If MMM is so good, why not fire the attribution team entirely?
- 3:25Expert: Because MMM tells you the what and misses the who.
- 3:29Expert: Media Mix Modeling says TV drove $2 million last quarter.
- 3:33Expert: It can't tell you which specific ad to swap out on Tuesday.
- 3:38Expert: Attribution's terrible at strategy, but fine for tactical tweaks.
- 3:41Expert: You need both.
- 3:43Expert: Firing attribution to worship MMM is just swapping one religion for another, and I've watched
- 3:48Expert: CMOs do exactly that and blow their next quarter.
- 3:51Host: So the honest answer is, it depends, which is what every consultant says to keep the
- 3:56Host: invoice open.
- 3:57Expert: The honest answer is measure the machine, not the moment.
- 4:02Expert: Attribution obsesses over the last touch, because it's easy to see.
- 4:06Expert: That's like judging a football match by who tapped the ball into an empty net and
- 4:10Expert: ignoring everyone who ran it up the pitch.
- 4:12Host: Fine.
- 4:13Host: One thing a listener does Monday morning.
- 4:15Expert: Pull your last-click report and find how much credit goes to search on your own brand name.
- 4:21Expert: If it's over 20%, you're paying to take credit for demand you already created.
- 4:25Expert: Cut that spend 30% for two weeks and watch whether sales actually drop.
- 4:30Expert: If they don't, you just found free money.
- 4:33Host: Sources for today's episode.
- 4:34Host: DigiDay, Adweek, Semrush, Vendor, SEO Analytics Tools.
- 4:40Host: That's it.
- 4:41Host: The CMO Decision Tools are live at MBA-training.com.