Latest / Serves You Right / #47 Camper English: Clear Ice, Toxic Cocktails, and the Science of Booze
Transcript
- 0:00Thank you for listening to Serves You Right.
- 0:02My name is Andrew, and today we're talking to Camper English
- 0:05drink historian, cocktail book, author of two really fantastic
- 0:10books, The Ice Book and also Doctors and Distillers.
- 0:14Camper is really just a fantastic guy, Tons of
- 0:17knowledge, super, super informative.
- 0:20I had a blast talking to him. So without any further ado,
- 0:23here's Camper English. Thank you for listening to
- 0:25Serves You Right and my name is Andrew.
- 0:30Oh, cool Camper English. Thank you for joining us today.
- 0:33Really really a pleasure to talk to you virtually.
- 0:36So thanks, glad to be here. So I thought, I thought I would
- 0:39start. One thing that really strikes me
- 0:42with your work is just how deep down the rabbit hole you will
- 0:47go. You know, some people, you know,
- 0:50they have a nice cocktail, they get a nice clear piece of ice.
- 0:53They call it good. But it seems like you get
- 0:56fascinated by these things that you just dive right in.
- 0:59Is, is that something that's always been true about you or
- 1:02where, where does that come from?
- 1:03I guess I'm a curious person, and part of that is when I think
- 1:07other people are going down the wrong path, then I feel this
- 1:11weird obligation to check and see if they're right or I'm
- 1:16wrong or what the situation is. So some of it is my own curious
- 1:20curiosity and some of it is like, that doesn't sound right
- 1:22to me and I want to figure it out.
- 1:24So with the ice stuff, in particular the stuff that I did,
- 1:28and then there's stuff that other people were saying that I
- 1:32thought like, I don't think that's right, and I wanted to
- 1:34figure it out. So sort of fact checking the
- 1:36work of other people. Sure, sure.
- 1:39And you know, we'll definitely get it to my trials,
- 1:43Tribulations and failures in ice making later too.
- 1:47But for the listener at home that maybe hasn't checked out
- 1:50your book but is interested, what's the deal with clear ice?
- 1:54Why is it so popular? And what are some of those
- 1:57rumors that you disproved and how can you make some at home?
- 2:00Well, you know, clear ice just looks a lot better.
- 2:03That is like 90% of it. And we it does function better
- 2:08or at least more consistently in drinks.
- 2:11But I think that really the aesthetics of it far outweigh
- 2:16every other factor when it comes to clear ice versus cloudy ice.
- 2:21So I always use the analogy that it's like you can drink the same
- 2:25fine champagne out of a Styrofoam cup sitting in a
- 2:28gutter or in a crystal flute at a nice restaurant, and it's
- 2:33ultimately the champagne is the same.
- 2:35However, it's totally different experience and it's going to
- 2:38taste better and more a nicer environment.
- 2:41I think it's the same with ice and that some people are like, I
- 2:45really don't care if my ice is cloudy.
- 2:47The drink tastes the same. Yeah, but it would could taste a
- 2:51little bit better if the ice was clear.
- 2:52So that's the main part of it. And then I think that a lot of
- 2:56people got newly into clear ice. And by people, I mean not
- 3:01bartenders, but regular everyday people at home got more into
- 3:05clear ice during the pandemic when a lot of people started
- 3:08trying to make their own cocktails at home.
- 3:10And of course, everyone's got to record everything they do these
- 3:13days. So as soon as you take a picture
- 3:16of your horrible, horrifically ugly white Crescent refrigerator
- 3:22ice and a cocktail, you realize just how much worse it looks
- 3:26than ice in a cocktail bar. And a lot of people at that
- 3:29point decided that they needed to.
- 3:32They started to appreciate clear ice and then got into making it
- 3:35themselves. Whereas really up until that
- 3:39point, mostly the whole clear ice geekery and stuff that I was
- 3:42doing was an industry knowledge or just the top cocktail geeks
- 3:48and bartenders as well. So there was a big critical
- 3:51mass, I think that happened around 2020.
- 3:54Well, when we as a society elevated drinking from a pastime
- 3:59to a necessity to curb the the spread.
- 4:02So yeah, this we were all, we were all there.
- 4:06We all participated. So, OK, I'm at home and I want
- 4:08to make some clear ice. There really is no way to do it
- 4:11besides directional freezing, is there?
- 4:15Correct. There is not.
- 4:16Yeah. And so, yeah.
- 4:18So the the basics of making clear ice, for those who don't
- 4:22know, is that a typical ice cube freezes from all sides in
- 4:27towards the center. And I kind of say that water
- 4:30wants to freeze clear. So the first part of an ice cube
- 4:33to freeze is the outside, and that is clear.
- 4:36And usually where an ice cube is cloudy is in the center of the
- 4:39cube. And so it took a staggeringly
- 4:42long time for me to figure that out.
- 4:44But once I did, then the solution to the problem or the
- 4:49kluge or the hack, whatever we want to call it, was if we could
- 4:53control the direction that the water freezes into ice, then we
- 4:58can put the clear part of the ice cube where we want it.
- 5:02So we can't get rid of cloudy ice.
- 5:05We can either have it not form or form in this spare part of
- 5:09the cube where we don't want. So Long story short, we use an
- 5:13insulated container like a hard sided cooler, fill that with
- 5:16water, put it in the freezer. And now as the water freezes
- 5:20starting at the top, because it's insulated on all the sides,
- 5:23it will push the trapped air and impurities down towards the
- 5:26bottom of the cooler. And so the first roughly 2/3 or
- 5:3075% of that water in the cooler to freeze will be clear.
- 5:35And if you leave that cooler in the freezer long enough, the
- 5:38bottom part when it starts freezing will be the cloudy
- 5:41part. So you can either let it freeze
- 5:44only for a couple days so that you don't get a cloudy part, or
- 5:47you can chop off the cloudy part at the bottom of the cooler.
- 5:50And then pretty much every variation of making clear eyes
- 5:53without moving parts involves a version of that.
- 5:57So you might use a thermos, you might set an ice cube tray in
- 6:03the top of the cooler and have the ice cubes freeze within the
- 6:07trays and be clear on the top and cloudy just on the bottom.
- 6:10There's a lot of commercial products that are just like that
- 6:13system, but there's a hole in the bottom of each compartment
- 6:16of the ice cube tray so that the water goes out the bottom of the
- 6:20tray into the reservoir beneath it.
- 6:22And you only have clear ice in the cube tray.
- 6:25And even just if you put a big container into your freezer
- 6:29that's not insulated and only let it freeze for a day or so,
- 6:33probably what's going to have frozen at that point will only
- 6:36be clear. So it's it's all directional
- 6:39freezing, just the how it manifests or how you manifest it
- 6:43is different and very adaptable. Yeah.
- 6:47And I think what really got me to graphs that it was all
- 6:51directional freezing, just depends on what direction is
- 6:55when you talked about making cocktails in ice spheres.
- 7:00So where it's like, you don't have to be careful because if it
- 7:02doesn't freeze solid, you're freezing the outside, that's
- 7:05going to be clear. Hollow it out, put the cocktail
- 7:08in there. And it's like, because I, you
- 7:11know, there was a point in my life that I tried to do that and
- 7:14I never did. I was never patient enough to
- 7:17work it out because you got to be careful about timing and you
- 7:20can't take it out when it's too thin too.
- 7:22Yeah, there's there's a lot of you have to do there.
- 7:25I know I'm I'm complaining about how much work you have to do to
- 7:28the Iceman. Yeah, I've done, you know, 18
- 7:31years of it so far. You're stopping me now, I guess.
- 7:36You know what? So sorry you got.
- 7:39When I was doing the photos for the Ice Book, we did those all
- 7:43the photos over the course of three or four days, very long,
- 7:47intense days. But I had to make the ice over
- 7:49the course of basically almost two months, store it in the my
- 7:54freezer once it was done and then a little side freezer.
- 7:57And then I borrowed a bar space in the bars freezer.
- 8:00But the ice balls were the hardest one because they're very
- 8:03fragile. And as mentioned, the the timing
- 8:06is specific. So I froze a whole bunch of ice
- 8:10balls, but I would crack them open to see how good they were
- 8:13going and till I had enough remaining in the freezer while
- 8:20the right thickness. And that I had to do get up at
- 8:224:00 in the morning the night before shooting after freezing
- 8:25for a certain number of hours and and keep testing them
- 8:28throughout the night. So yeah, you can turn making ice
- 8:31cubes into a lot of work for yourself.
- 8:33A full time profession. Yeah, no.
- 8:36And I, I can tell that you're someone who's made a lot of ice
- 8:39and has a lot of ice on hand. If you actually specifically
- 8:42have to experience sublimation as a problem in the freezer,
- 8:46then then you've definitely made enough ice.
- 8:48So I was not aware. I'm sure at some point, maybe
- 8:51even in like high school, I've come across this, but I did not
- 8:54know that ice in the freezer would, as you put a sublimate.
- 8:58So just kind of evaporates without becoming water.
- 9:01So how quickly does this happen? It takes quite a while, and
- 9:07usually that's a number of weeks before you'll really notice.
- 9:11One time a friend of mine I was staying with in New York had ice
- 9:17cube trays in his freezer, and they were all like, less than
- 9:20half full. And I was like, OK, I refilled
- 9:24your ice cube trays for you. He's like, oh, yeah, I never
- 9:27used those. And I was like, oh, like it took
- 9:29me a long time to figure out. It's because they had sublimated
- 9:32so far that he orders ice from the deli when he wants ice,
- 9:36bring it upstairs for me. But the ice cube trays after
- 9:40months had reduced each the size of each cube in the ice cube
- 9:44tray down to 1/3 of what they originally were.
- 9:47So that's, that's pretty wild. You'll, you notice it when you
- 9:51have certain shapes of ice where it's sublimating off the, the
- 9:56top of the sides or whatever. I've done a lot of experiments
- 9:59when I like I, I store my ice generally in like zip lock bags
- 10:02or something like that in the freezer so that they don't
- 10:06sublimate. And you know, I keep all the
- 10:08smells out of the freezer so they don't pick up absorb odors
- 10:12in the 1st place. But I did an experiment with
- 10:15putting ice in a bag and keeping it for like 6 months to see what
- 10:19would happen if it would start to come apart at all.
- 10:22And yeah it got real frosty I think.
- 10:24I think it's probably been a year now.
- 10:25I have this one sandwich zip lock with size sphere in my
- 10:30freezer. I did that experiment and I keep
- 10:32forgetting to end of the experiment and measure it, but
- 10:35it's definitely fuzzy with a frost now that evaporated off
- 10:39the sphere but then had nowhere to go.
- 10:43Yeah, I guess if it's a closed system, it has to stay in there,
- 10:46right? That's, that's how science
- 10:48works. Yeah.
- 10:49Hopefully. So, you know, I followed along
- 10:53in your footsteps enough to make the clear ice.
- 10:55But what I never did, and what I was really fascinated by how
- 10:58much you did, was putting things into the ice.
- 11:01So I, I just got to the clear spheres because that was my
- 11:04goal. I had a sphere making device and
- 11:07I wanted one that was perfectly clear for whatever reason when I
- 11:09was 24. But So what led you to put so
- 11:14many things into ice? And what are some of the
- 11:17craziest things you have put into ice?
- 11:19I saw sharks that I've seen coins in your book.
- 11:22But yeah, like. Yeah, I mean everything what
- 11:26what I do, I don't think we have a Spirit Halloween anymore in
- 11:30San Francisco. For some reason.
- 11:31They they don't put them here, but the, the start of Halloween
- 11:34season, I'm like in line at the at the Spirit Halloween store.
- 11:38They're like, what can I put into ice cubes?
- 11:40That's how I move about the world is like looking for
- 11:43objects that I can freeze inside ice.
- 11:45So I've done, you know, for Halloween, I've done skulls and
- 11:50like, Bony hands sticking up out of an ice block and giant rats,
- 11:54bats and, and eyeballs and things like that.
- 11:57Just anything for fun. Because ultimately I'm not
- 12:00running a bar program. I'm just a nerd who takes
- 12:04pictures of ice cubes and I don't need them to, you know,
- 12:09there was also need to go anywhere other than Instagram.
- 12:12So I frozen, yeah, a handful of coins once.
- 12:16I was like, I don't know, let's let's throw those in there.
- 12:20Some of the dumbest stuff like other office supplies.
- 12:24The stapler from Office Space. I yeah, just freeze your whole
- 12:27desk set. That's what I should do.
- 12:30If I had office mates, certainly that I would have subjected them
- 12:33to that by now. One thing I do really appreciate
- 12:36about your writing and just kind of your style and some of the
- 12:39things you've done in the past too, is even though you do these
- 12:42things, though, you're very transparent about your warnings
- 12:46of fun. If you put these things into
- 12:48alcohol, that can be dangerous because a lot of these products
- 12:52aren't designed to be consumed or at least to enter into our
- 12:56mouths or products. Alcohol is a solvent and it can
- 12:59pick up a lot of things we wouldn't expect.
- 13:02I think I forget the way you put it exactly, but it was something
- 13:05along the lines of if you freeze things in ice and give it to
- 13:09children or drunk people, they will drink it at some point.
- 13:12Like sometime it will end up in their mouth.
- 13:15So just be cognizant to that. You're going to try to swallow
- 13:19it. At some point, yes.
- 13:21So. Yeah, I'm always, yeah.
- 13:26I want to just make people aware of when you put something into
- 13:29ice, then you got to think about it going in their mouth or down
- 13:33the throat and in the system and you hope that you have
- 13:36responsible enough people. But if you're making ice with
- 13:38stuff in it for a bachelor party, then you like, you know
- 13:43that people are going to get wild and be a little
- 13:47irresponsible with things. So it's just a, what I warn to
- 13:51people who are making the ice for these events is just be
- 13:53aware of your audience and there's stuff you could do for
- 13:56the beginning of the night versus the end of the night or,
- 13:59you know, if you have to think about who you're serving it to.
- 14:02I don't think everything needs to be so precious in that, like
- 14:06plastic monkeys from a barrel of monkeys or something like that.
- 14:09You could freeze into ice cubes. And I think you should have a
- 14:12reasonable expectation that people won't swallow something
- 14:15that they wouldn't pick up off the ground and put in their
- 14:17mouth. But add alcohol to that
- 14:19equation, Asian, and things can go differently.
- 14:23Yeah. I mean, it looks like it's
- 14:24candy. What are you going to do?
- 14:25Yeah. I would like to know.
- 14:29Yeah, exactly. I do.
- 14:31I do want to dig into that, though.
- 14:33What, what got you involved into the world of cocktail safety?
- 14:36Because that's also where I often think about, like you and
- 14:40your work. So is it just looking around and
- 14:43seeing some slightly dangerous, uninformed things pop up in the
- 14:47marketplace? Or was there a story, a
- 14:49cautionary tale? Yeah, we were having some
- 14:53conversations with other industry people, largely on
- 14:57Facebook at the time, and other sites where people were getting
- 15:01very creative but not being all that smart about it and using
- 15:06some problematic ingredients. The first two that really kicked
- 15:08off the need for me to, or what I felt was the need for me to
- 15:12build a website about it were tobacco and then activated
- 15:17charcoal. And with tobacco, it's in the
- 15:20spirits world, you know, always saying notes of tobacco XYZ and
- 15:25that's a familiar word and that things pair with it.
- 15:27And there are cigar malt whiskeys and cigar cognacs that
- 15:32are meant to pair with things and and have familiar notes.
- 15:34But putting tobacco into a beverage is a horrible idea and
- 15:41extremely dangerous as people were coming out with all sorts
- 15:45of different and original bidders and selling them locally
- 15:49in particular or making them at the bar to serve to customers
- 15:53without going through any kind of FDATTD approval process.
- 15:58People were making tobacco bitters, which are super
- 16:02dangerous even in the drops and dashes that people use in
- 16:05drinks. And some commercial bitters were
- 16:08coming out that were tobacco bitters that were containing no
- 16:11tobacco. And but being labeled as tobacco
- 16:14bitters could put into the mind of the person using them that
- 16:18you can make tobacco bitters rather than tobacco flavored in
- 16:22a big letters bitters, which would have been a more safer
- 16:25option to sort of let people know no actual tobacco is here.
- 16:29So there's a couple. Things about what is it is
- 16:32specifically about tobacco that makes it so dangerous because I
- 16:35know they they used tobacco to flavor whiskey back in the day
- 16:39and along with a lot of other unsafe things.
- 16:43Right. Yeah.
- 16:43So it's, you know, it's the nicotine it gives you.
- 16:47If you don't smoke cigarettes and then have one really fast,
- 16:50you're going to definitely feel impacts of it.
- 16:52And part of that can be heart palpitations, which get worse,
- 16:56you know, the less used to it you are.
- 16:58And in a cigarette, the amount of nicotine that's in it is you
- 17:03get some certain small percentage of it into your
- 17:06bloodstream. But putting that into alcohol,
- 17:09which is at extracting the active properties of any kind of
- 17:14herb and herbal medicine, etcetera, you're getting 100% of
- 17:18that nicotine. And so the impact is going to be
- 17:21much, much, much, much, much larger.
- 17:23So despite if you took one cigarette's worth of tobacco for
- 17:27a whole bottle of bitter, it's still problematically high
- 17:32quantity of that. It's like chewing on a cocoa
- 17:35leaf versus doing tons of lines of cocaine or something like
- 17:39that. A step change in difference.
- 17:41OK, that makes sense. Sorry I cut you off there.
- 17:44Yeah, so I, I mean, I know people who have, I had a friend
- 17:48who is a very small person, probably weighs 100 lbs and was
- 17:52saying like, I don't know what it is, but every time I have a
- 17:55tobacco old fashioned, I feel really sick afterwards.
- 17:58Like, well, I know what it is. It's the tobacco.
- 18:01Even though. Nicotine poisoning, Yes.
- 18:03Yes. And you know, it's an
- 18:05insecticide. It's really, it can be really
- 18:08quite bad for you or or even deadly.
- 18:10It's just an absolute. That one is an absolute no go
- 18:13and no form. I don't even really believe in,
- 18:16you know, smoking for this, using the smoking guns and the
- 18:19smoke cocktails with it. I don't know how dangerous that
- 18:22is, but I'm just sort of, I think we could do without it,
- 18:26use wood. Instead, Yeah, why tempt fate
- 18:28there? If you're enjoying this so far,
- 18:33please take a moment hit like subscribe, leave a comment or
- 18:37share with a friend that you know would get value from this
- 18:40as well. All right, back to the podcast.
- 18:45Yeah, and I think that. So one factor is it being toxic
- 18:50itself if you serve to a person or drink it yourself.
- 18:53A second factor is the labeling of it.
- 18:56If your menu says whiskey, simple syrup, tobacco, that
- 18:59might inspire someone to go home and do it.
- 19:01So that's a question of whose responsibility is that versus,
- 19:06You know, they're using safe tobacco bitters that are tobacco
- 19:08flavored, but the person goes home and makes tobacco bitters.
- 19:13It's, you know, I think that's it's worth discussing that
- 19:16that's can be problematic. And I don't know that it's
- 19:18always the the bar and the bartender's fault of that.
- 19:22But we can do better for our customers.
- 19:23Hospitality means not inspiring people to go home and poison
- 19:27themselves. Sure, sure.
- 19:28Yeah, I guess there's no other. Like there wouldn't be a
- 19:32activated charcoal brand vodka you would put on a menu.
- 19:35Like tobacco is a very specific thing that could lead people to
- 19:39think that. Yeah, that's like of of
- 19:42everything, the most dangerous is, is tobacco by far.
- 19:47Some of the techniques. So I don't know if you stated it
- 19:51yet, but the website iscocktailsafe.org, which is a
- 19:55website I put together with a list of techniques as well as
- 19:59ingredients and whether they're generally safe or not or some
- 20:02rules to be aware of about them and.
- 20:07Legality of them. So those are often different
- 20:10issues like the legality versus the safety of things like
- 20:13sassafras and cocktails and known.
- 20:16Carsogen, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 20:18Well, with 1950s technology, yes.
- 20:21Yeah, yeah. Not before then, I don't.
- 20:23Know because no one has spent the money to test for the actual
- 20:28safety of it since then. Those are those are some of the
- 20:32issues addressed. And you know, I think the first
- 20:35thing is just to be aware. And the real goal of cocktail
- 20:39safe is like, hey, if you're using something that you haven't
- 20:41seen before, put it into the search bar or even on Google.
- 20:46Put word of ingredient and then safe word of ingredient danger.
- 20:51I feel like, and this has been long enough that it may not have
- 20:55been you, but I feel like I did end up reading something you
- 20:59wrote when we were talking, like me and another bartender were
- 21:03talking about making your own tonic syrup.
- 21:05I feel like we came into some info from you and we're like,
- 21:09let's not do that. That's good.
- 21:11Yeah. It's been probably 10 years
- 21:13though, but yeah. Yeah, there was a big trend a
- 21:17while back of making your own tonic syrup because, you know,
- 21:20bartender is like, oh, let's try to make everything that we can
- 21:22in house. It's going to be the the least
- 21:24processed, the most natural. The larger problem for me is
- 21:27that tonic syrup is brown and tastes like dirt.
- 21:32You think that you get a much better experience by just
- 21:35drinking the stuff from the bottle.
- 21:37But yeah, people did run into problems with quinine, excess
- 21:41quinine in there, homemade syrups.
- 21:44And the people who ran into the most problems were the
- 21:46bartenders experimenting with it and testing the recipes over and
- 21:50over and over again, building up in your system and then
- 21:54experiencing some of the impacts of that.
- 21:57Yes, things that we probably haven't seen in the Western
- 22:01world since we had all the problems with malaria.
- 22:04Right. So we've been dancing around it.
- 22:07Let's, let's dig into it. So doctors and Distillers, what,
- 22:10where did you come up with the idea that with that book?
- 22:13That's such a cool, such a cool work.
- 22:18Yeah. Well, I am always kind of making
- 22:22lists and categorizing things. And so in the history, when we
- 22:26look at cocktails and spirits and you study them in any depth,
- 22:29you run into medicine in a lot of places, even if you're not
- 22:32looking for it. So citrus and scurvy, quinine
- 22:36and malaria, even whiskey to cleanse the wounds on the
- 22:40battlefield and things like that.
- 22:41You you keep running into alcohol if you're looking at
- 22:44medicine. You keep running into medicine
- 22:46if you look at alcohol. And so I would start putting
- 22:50those on the list somewhere. And the list kept getting longer
- 22:53and longer. I wrote a little self published
- 22:56book on the history of the gin and tonic, mostly the tonic.
- 23:01And that became basically a chapter of Doctors and
- 23:04Distillers later on after I gave some talks about it.
- 23:07Because I just realized that the history of alcohol and medicine
- 23:11are in part that, you know, a major overlapping history, if
- 23:16not the same history for a lot of a lot of time, particularly
- 23:20as distilled spirits were developed.
- 23:23That was developed as medicine specifically and used as such
- 23:28for 100 years or so before recreational consumption was
- 23:34more of a factor. But yeah, really just like
- 23:36looking at all the different ways alcohol and medicine
- 23:39overlapped and realizing, one, it was enough material for a
- 23:43book on that, and two, surprisingly, I couldn't find a
- 23:47book that hadn't been written on that topic yet in any kind of
- 23:51long way. You know, more like fun facts
- 23:53you can find Did you know scurvy was cured by you and etcetera.
- 23:59Different books kind of hint at it, but nothing that dug into
- 24:02that connection deep like you did.
- 24:04Yeah, it's it is wild. Like, you know, I'd forgotten.
- 24:07I knew a little bit of the history of some of the like past
- 24:11Physiology, like the the Galens of the world, so like the humors
- 24:15and you hear some references to that.
- 24:17I had never heard What was this probably butchering this para
- 24:22celsus. I don't know if he's a name
- 24:26that. Is honestly, I do, yeah, but
- 24:29I've already learned it from books.
- 24:31Yeah. Do you do you mind talking about
- 24:33this guy? Because I've never heard his
- 24:35name and he sounded like the funnest, Well, no, the least fun
- 24:40guy in history, but such a cool spot.
- 24:42Yeah. Yeah.
- 24:44So I had also never heard of Paracelsus before doing the
- 24:48research for this book. And he becomes this important
- 24:51person in the history of medicine, less so with alcohol,
- 24:55but it did change how people viewed the theories of medicine,
- 24:59which would impact the treatments of them.
- 25:01So Paracelsus was a wandering physician who traveled around
- 25:07Europe and was very big blustery jerk who like was all about
- 25:14being anti establishment as far as the medicine.
- 25:17And the medicine for the last thousand years or so was Greek
- 25:22and Roman medicine of Galen and the four humors.
- 25:25And to reject that long established medicine was a big
- 25:29deal. He was reported to have burned
- 25:32the books of Galen on the steps of a university or something
- 25:35like that and proposed his own theories of medicine, which were
- 25:39so the four humors is first of all, it's it's garbage.
- 25:42It's not true. And it's based on this
- 25:43completely bad understanding of human anatomy, which.
- 25:47Still shows up in some of our words, surprisingly, but yeah.
- 25:51It sure does. And the whole thing about
- 25:53leeches and bleeding and stuff like that, that like in the mid
- 25:57to later 1800s, people were still doing that sort of thing,
- 26:00all goes back to that Greek and Roman medicine of like, you've
- 26:04got to rebalance the fluids in the body.
- 26:07And what Paracelsus did was reject that theory and espouse
- 26:11some of his own. Almost none of this.
- 26:13His ideas were effective themselves.
- 26:16They were all wacky medicinal cures, a lot of them using
- 26:19minerals and sort of chemistry ish, more like mineralogy in
- 26:24medicine. And none of them worked.
- 26:26But they were so ineffective that people healed on their own
- 26:29rather than you. Like keep bleeding the person
- 26:33until they get better. Yeah, and I mean.
- 26:37In a. Day and age, yeah, When there's
- 26:39no sanitation, nothing. So like you were continually
- 26:42reopening a person who's suffering versus giving them
- 26:46something ineffective and letting them chill for a minute.
- 26:50So we get from Galen the the dose makes the poison of that
- 26:53which which is true and that less to give someone less
- 26:57medicine effective or not, and that person has a chance to heal
- 27:01themselves. And that ended up working, but
- 27:03it changed how people viewed it helps people switch from
- 27:06believing in the for humor system to a more modern theory,
- 27:10also helped by modern understandings of human anatomy.
- 27:13But the thing about Paracelsus was that he talked a lot of
- 27:15smack, and that's what makes him so much fun.
- 27:18Yeah, pretty much everyone hated the guy except for his own fans,
- 27:22and they cleaned up the nonsense in his work afterwards.
- 27:25But that's what made him kind of a fun character.
- 27:27I would love for there to be like a, you know, a two season
- 27:31series about the life of Paracelsus going through the
- 27:36world and just talking smack and like, getting out of trouble
- 27:39because someone just healed on their own.
- 27:42Heck yeah. OK, continuing from the past to
- 27:46the present, we've got ancient views of the body and health.
- 27:51Tell me about alchemy. Because alchemy has a big
- 27:54overarching influence from the beginning.
- 27:57Everything from like the quintessence all the way to the
- 28:01distillation itself. Like how did alchemy get all
- 28:04tied up in booze? Yeah, I was really surprised.
- 28:08And it took me, it took me the longest time of any concept in
- 28:11the book to figure out how when distilled alcohol is created by
- 28:16Western alchemists, why they thought it was the perfect
- 28:20medicine and why they thought it was the philosopher's stone, why
- 28:25they thought it would make you live forever.
- 28:27Like what medicinal theory of sorts was it?
- 28:30And so it took me like a few months and a few books to sort
- 28:34of put it together. And that is basically the
- 28:38alchemists were sort of proto chemists that they were trying
- 28:41to understand the world through any kind of science as it was in
- 28:45that era, and science as it wasn't that era was just mixed
- 28:48up with religion and astronomy and astrology and all that
- 28:52together. And by trying to figure out most
- 28:57of the world it was about taking things apart and separating
- 29:00things to a chemical chemistry tool for that is distillation.
- 29:05So the alchemists were always using distillation from probably
- 29:10the year 300 till, you know, it's 1000 years later.
- 29:15They figure out how to make alcohol with that same tool,
- 29:20which is pretty fascinating itself, but that there are like,
- 29:25take a, let's say a metal and corrode it with vinegar and then
- 29:29distill it and then look at the different parts because you've
- 29:32done a separation now. And that sort of chemistry over
- 29:34and over again to break things down and to try to extract the
- 29:38active essence of a material. So a person you could think of
- 29:43as, you know, the physical body, but also their soul or their
- 29:47spirit or their human energy, and The Alchemist, what they
- 29:50would want to do according to their philosophy was separate
- 29:54those two things. And so you have just their
- 29:56spirit captured without being attached to a body.
- 30:00OK, so now take that same philosophy and apply it to wine.
- 30:04That's what distilled spirits were as the active energy of
- 30:08wine was the Brandy that you got out out of the end of it because
- 30:13you had separated it from the red fermented wine.
- 30:17And now you have something very intense and powerful and active
- 30:22and useful in medicine. And pretty quickly they figured
- 30:26out all of the physiological impacts of it that oh, it makes
- 30:30you, gives you more energy, it will kill lice on your head.
- 30:36You know, it changes how your eyes work when you throw Brandy
- 30:40in them. And all of all of this stuff
- 30:42that was very impactful and very strong compared to any other
- 30:46medicine or alcoholic beverages at the time.
- 30:49So they're like, we've done it, we figured it out.
- 30:51We've separated the active energy of the universe from its
- 30:55corporal form. We did it, fam.
- 30:58And that's why they thought that distilled alcohol was sort of
- 31:01the the active energy of the entire universe.
- 31:04It was a really, really big deal.
- 31:07The Alchemist of its age and. I actually I want to add a
- 31:12couple of points there. When you distill anything
- 31:16alcoholic and you get a stronger product, it also often is shelf
- 31:20stable, which is something that would have been quite shocking
- 31:24back in the day to have a substance that doesn't decay but
- 31:27just sticks around. And if it's high enough and
- 31:29proof it, it's flammable too. And I'm sure that's something
- 31:33that really shocked a lot of people.
- 31:35It's the strong, indestructible, concentrated.
- 31:39Yeah. It's.
- 31:40Yeah, both of those factors were, those are like the two
- 31:43most important things that that people comment on.
- 31:45First of all, all the names for it were burning water or flaming
- 31:48water, that you could dunk a cloth in it and the cloth
- 31:52wouldn't burn, but yet the cloth was burning because of the
- 31:55alcohol burning off. That was magic basically.
- 31:57There's nothing else that did that that existed in the natural
- 32:01world. So that's a big deal.
- 32:02And then for millennia, people were using an infusion of herbs
- 32:07into wine or beer as medicine because people long understood
- 32:12not only does that make it drinkable as medicine, but also
- 32:15that it extracts the active properties of plants.
- 32:18And so, you know, you take your rose petals and put them in wine
- 32:23for a long time and then you filter out the Rose petals and
- 32:27you have rose wine for as long as it lasts, which can be a long
- 32:30time. But into high proof alcohol, as
- 32:34you said, like now, that's really the the pure essence of
- 32:38your rose puzzles that will last essentially indefinitely, A big
- 32:43step forward in technology and in medicine as they saw at the
- 32:46time. And then tell me, tell me about
- 32:49how you know this is alchemy. It's all tied up in religion and
- 32:54science. Talk to me about the monks.
- 32:58When the monks come in and the monks start making their own
- 33:02herbal liqueurs, is that itself a continuation of this
- 33:07alchemical journey or is that its own like journey up to
- 33:12itself well. There's a few things happening
- 33:15with the monks and that they were kind of closed off from the
- 33:20rest of society, although they were often supported by royalty
- 33:23somewhere. And they, I think that we
- 33:25forget, or at least I didn't even know it at all, that they
- 33:27were landlords. And so they had serfs working
- 33:30the land that would provide them with materials.
- 33:33But if we think of like a monastery environment, they're
- 33:37going to have their own doctors, herbalist, you know, slash
- 33:41pharmacist people there. They would often treat the the
- 33:44people who worked the land there.
- 33:47So they were the hospital for the community as well as there
- 33:51were the people who could read and write.
- 33:53They copied books from one to another.
- 33:56They were the nodes on the information highway, such as it
- 33:59was with people taking pilgrimages across Europe and
- 34:04would stop in from one monastery to the next and often, you know,
- 34:09take this book to the pharmacy to the to the monastery, you
- 34:13know, down the road or whatever. So because they were these
- 34:18enclosed environments that they had to make their own medicine
- 34:21and they had the books to learn about it and pass that along.
- 34:25So in a way they were, they were a parallel to the universities
- 34:30and even before universities, they were performing that
- 34:33function. They were the centers of
- 34:35knowledge when even the royalty couldn't read along with 90% of
- 34:39the populace. So because the centers of
- 34:42learning, that's where medicine was pushed forward, alchemy was
- 34:45pushed forward at monasteries. So that's kind of the reason.
- 34:50And then because they would tend to have their own herbal gardens
- 34:55and apothecaries and distillation on site, they often
- 34:59took those preparations forward. Now getting into let's say 1600,
- 35:05those eras, each one is developing more complicated
- 35:08all-purpose medicines. And that's where we get what
- 35:11becomes things like Chartreuse later on, is that this has every
- 35:16healthy herb and plant and root that we think it's good for
- 35:20digestion and healing and insect bites and everything else all in
- 35:25one medicine to treat people as well as to sell to people to
- 35:30raise money for their actions. And in the case of Chartreuse,
- 35:34specifically the the monastery in Grenoble, which became the
- 35:39home of the Chartreuse liqueurs, they used to trade in lumber and
- 35:45in iron works. But then a lot of deforestation
- 35:49was prevented by the king at the time dating the new industry,
- 35:52and thus pushed forward sales of their liqueurs, particularly
- 35:57after the French Revolution as well.
- 35:59They needed money and they sold medicine.
- 36:02And that medicine is something that we put in our cocktails to
- 36:06this day. Yeah, and I believe you put it
- 36:09how much they sell on it. It was a large number.
- 36:12It surprised me. It's something like a million
- 36:14models a year or something crazy like.
- 36:18Yeah, it's it's extraordinarily large and has been for a long
- 36:23time. I was surprised looking back in
- 36:26archives of newspapers, like how the monks were in the news all
- 36:30the time around 1800 and the the French Revolution years and
- 36:36people followed the saga of Chartreuse even then, much like
- 36:40we do today. OK.
- 36:42It's kind of always been popular.
- 36:45In my head I was kind of thinking of it as a reaction to
- 36:49alchemy, but it seems like it was more a continuation and just
- 36:53a place where knowledge and ability could flourish.
- 36:57And so they just kind of carried the torch forward.
- 37:00Maybe would have been a better way to have thought about the
- 37:02monks. So OK.
- 37:04Yeah, I think that's that's pretty accurate.
- 37:05They they practice their own sort of alchemy, but alchemy had
- 37:09kind of changed because as science became its own
- 37:13discipline, we start separating the religious aspects of it from
- 37:17the medicinal and scientific aspects of it, which doesn't
- 37:21really, I don't think, interfere with each other and doesn't in
- 37:24their eyes invalidate a religion by treating science as science.
- 37:29But it's just sort of as time progressive.
- 37:33They become separate disciplines, I think.
- 37:35So we get chemistry and physics and math and all of that stuff.
- 37:39Whereas when at the time at which alcohol was developed,
- 37:42those were not disciplines and we didn't have the scientific
- 37:46revolution yet. So there was no understanding
- 37:48that there's a difference between, you know, the moon is
- 37:52in Jupiter and distillation and evaporation like that was they
- 37:55were like part of the same system.
- 37:57Later we. Came it was all new and exciting
- 37:59and we'll just kind of see what happens.
- 38:01Yeah We. We probably would be remiss if
- 38:04we didn't touch at least a little bit on the whole plight
- 38:08of scurvy and malaria kind of towards the end of the the early
- 38:14air and bringing us into the modern air.
- 38:16Just how much how much effort and how much human work has gone
- 38:20into preventing those two things is it's kind of wild.
- 38:26Pretty much every booze combination you could have
- 38:28mentioned said good for scurvy, good for malaria.
- 38:32Like, yeah. Yeah, Particularly, you know,
- 38:35you know, quinine and as a cure for malaria and then malaria as
- 38:39a disease are two topics that carry through to humanity for
- 38:44millennia. We we think it's, it's possible
- 38:47that malaria impacted the dinosaurs and dinosaurs evolved
- 38:50into birds and birds get malaria.
- 38:53So it kind of makes sense that that impact carried through.
- 38:57And we first were able to understand the mechanisms of
- 39:00malaria through the study of birds, which I think is pretty
- 39:03interesting there. But so people have always
- 39:06suffered from malaria caused by the parasite, which is
- 39:09transmitted by the vector of mosquitoes, rather than the
- 39:12mosquitoes have poison in them, They have plasmodiums in them.
- 39:16But so, yeah, it's a disease that always plagued humanity.
- 39:21It had prevented humans from traveling to certain places like
- 39:25Africa, the continent, and of course there were people living
- 39:28in Africa, but it prevented the colonization for a long time
- 39:31until quinine came into the equation.
- 39:36So in the 1600s, early 1600s, Jesuit monks in Peru and Bolivia
- 39:45learned from the indigenous people there of a bark that was
- 39:48good for fevers and headache. And it turns out that that also
- 39:53cures the underlying disease of malaria, even though they didn't
- 39:56have malaria in the Western Hemisphere at that point, as far
- 40:00as we can tell. So a great medicinal coincidence
- 40:03changed really the whole format of the world and where people
- 40:07were able to go and how long people were able to live and,
- 40:11and things like that. A huge medicinal discovery that
- 40:15ended up into every possible form of medicine that was
- 40:18imaginable, whether that's like an oil with quinine in it or all
- 40:22of. The the wine, the quinine wines,
- 40:24quinine and beer, quinine and whiskey and every patent
- 40:27medicine that you could order through the mail.
- 40:30And it was, I call it like the electrolytes of 1850.
- 40:34I don't know if it's going to do anything for your shampoo, but
- 40:37let's put it in. It can't hurt because you know
- 40:39it's healthy. Yeah.
- 40:42That's how it ended up in in like everything Amaro.
- 40:46We think of quinine being just in tonic water, but quinine is
- 40:49in most amaros, as well as a lot of like from moose and other
- 40:54fortified wines as well. It's still.
- 40:57It's still in everything. Yeah, I mean, most of the amaros
- 41:00that are around have secret or ancient recipes that they've
- 41:04been using forever. So it makes sense if if that was
- 41:07the electrolytes of the day, it's like, throw a little in
- 41:11there. Yeah.
- 41:12Couldn't hurt. Exactly.
- 41:15You know, kudos to you. This is the only book that I
- 41:18think could have the chapter titled Syphilis and Root beer.
- 41:22I thought that was a, a bold move, but I, I, I definitely
- 41:27liked the just interweaving how difficult we've how, how much
- 41:34difficulty we've had with diseases and what all we've done
- 41:37to try and address them. You do that so well throughout
- 41:40the book and it's just, it is amazing.
- 41:42The distillation and the doctor connection.
- 41:45It's it's there, it's it's deep, it's super cool.
- 41:48Yeah, it's it's it's wild how it formed the understanding of
- 41:54things that end up being purely recreational now and just how
- 41:57much medicine, formerly known as medicine that we're like
- 42:00drinking. Like I love root beer and I make
- 42:02a fun party. Guess when I'm telling everyone
- 42:04syphilis stories. Makes for good good good bar
- 42:10banter. I, I had heard once that there
- 42:14was a cure for syphilis and it was injecting people with
- 42:16malaria. And I never like that was like
- 42:19anecdotally, someone said, have you ever heard this?
- 42:22And it, this is the first time I encountered it in a book like,
- 42:25oh, this is a real thing. This this is not just like some
- 42:28random party story. Yeah, it was actually true.
- 42:33I heard that it was something like that was on an episode of
- 42:36the show House, someone told me. I haven't.
- 42:38I haven't seen. It that's where they heard it
- 42:40too, Yeah. Are there any crazy stories that
- 42:46you couldn't find enough backing to put in the story, but you're
- 42:50like, oh, I've only had it validated that one.
- 42:52That would have been perfect for this book.
- 42:54I there were none that I can think of off hand.
- 42:58The moment I know there's a lot of stuff that I was like, is
- 43:01that true or how much is it true?
- 43:03The one thing that is probably true, but I've never found the
- 43:07smoking gun is that Catherine de Medici brought liqueurs to
- 43:12France from Italy. Like that's that's something
- 43:16that's always repeat it. I don't think I put it in the
- 43:19book, but it's possible that I did a lot of.
- 43:22Things say that. According to the brand, like
- 43:24everything about Benedictine is according to the brand, meaning
- 43:27like maybe not true at all. Sure, yeah.
- 43:32That so that's, I've always been interested in that sort of fun
- 43:36factor, which I've seen repeated 1000 times and never seen a
- 43:40document for it. But it could be like that was
- 43:43when Italy was civilized and France was, according to some
- 43:46people, considered uncivilized in that era and bringing all of
- 43:50the delicious liqueurs that we more associate with France than
- 43:53Italy today there. So that's like one thing that
- 43:57like, because I wasn't able to dig into it any deeper, I left
- 44:00that on the cutting room floor. I've always wanted to look
- 44:03through. I have for every chapter in the
- 44:05book, I have like pages and pages, pages of stuff that I
- 44:09didn't use. So for each chapter, I have
- 44:10unused material Chapter 1 and I haven't yet gone back to look
- 44:14through them because one, it's a lot of stuff, but I thought it
- 44:17would be fun to do like, you know, fun fact and stuff for
- 44:21Instagram that may not have fit and sort of mind that extra data
- 44:25that I have. Yeah, all all the stuff that was
- 44:29just not on topic but still interesting almost made it.
- 44:32Right. Yeah, maybe like a little bit
- 44:33too gross. There's there's a lot.
- 44:36I mean you you reference. What is it?
- 44:41Fizz Fizz Donovan, his work and his story.
- 44:47The lady Mae Donahue. She finds a decomposing snail in
- 44:51her ginger beer. And it's like some of the
- 44:54beginning of like, legislations against bottlers and like, no,
- 44:58you have a care of duty to protect your consumers.
- 45:01Like. But like, I I can never not
- 45:04picture a decomposing snail and a bottle of ginger beer after
- 45:08hearing that story. It's just, yeah.
- 45:09But that's funny. Yeah, that's a that's a great,
- 45:12great book for anyone who hasn't seen it yet.
- 45:14It's called Fizz and it's the history of sodas and carbonation
- 45:17in general. Yeah, he's a he's a cool guy.
- 45:20He's he's been on too. So we got to talk a lot about
- 45:22that. Well, that's great, yeah.
- 45:25For the listener at home, where should someone go to find out
- 45:28more about you and the work you do?
- 45:31My website, isalkademics.com, I have everything kind of stems
- 45:37from there. If you are listening to this in
- 45:40September, I have to change my host and it's going to be a mess
- 45:43for a bit. So check back later if it's not
- 45:46currently. Up well, but this is going up
- 45:49right right before Halloween, so you've got a little bit of time
- 45:52to get it. Right.
- 45:53I'm trying to fix it in the next week or so, but also my other
- 45:57website, cocktailsafe.org has the safety information that is
- 46:03hopefully a great resource for people to check before engaging
- 46:07in both using unusual ingredients, but also some
- 46:11techniques like using liquid nitrogen.
- 46:13And if you're worried a dry ice, if you're worried about safety,
- 46:17maybe give it a look. Sure.
- 46:19Yeah, That is a Coyote Cafe when we were playing around with
- 46:22liquid nitrogen. That is if I remember where we
- 46:25went to make sure we we knew what we were doing before we
- 46:29started having too much fun, which which was probably smart
- 46:33I'm. A I'm a little afraid of it
- 46:36myself. You know, if you have someone
- 46:39who is experienced and confident like Quinn Stevenson, donor was
- 46:45like it, you do become used to it.
- 46:48But it's just you have it's like playing with fire behind the
- 46:51bar. It's doable if you know what
- 46:53you're doing and if you're not reckless.
- 46:55If you're reckless, it's stupid and I wouldn't recommend it to
- 46:57anyone. And then for those of you who
- 47:02are listening, I will have links to those websites in the show
- 47:06notes in case you didn't get to write that down.
- 47:08If you're in your car or anything like that.
- 47:10If you are listening to, please go pick up the ice book, Doctors
- 47:13and Distillers. Ice book is a nice short, easy,
- 47:17quick read. Doctors and Distillers is a
- 47:19little bit longer actually. I read it re read it on the
- 47:22flight, which is really is a good one.
- 47:24It kept me companies. Yeah.
- 47:26Well, camper English. Thank you for coming on tonight.
- 47:29It was awesome. I really appreciate it.
- 47:32Thanks a lot. It was great.
- 47:34Great doing this and talking to you.
- 47:38Thank you again for listening. If you have not, please like
- 47:42subscribe and also leave a comment on the show.
- 47:45Every interaction is really, really appreciated.
- 47:48I respond personally to every message comment I get.
- 47:52Episodes of this show come out every Tuesday, every week.
- 47:56If you have any questions, please feel free to reach out
- 47:58and I'm looking forward to you talking to you again soon.
- 48:02Thank you.