Latest / Her Legacy: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / The Lie I Told on First Dates: Why We Fabricate Our Histories | Her Legacy
Transcript
- I told three different men I went to a university in Vermont, even though I spent four years in a dorm room that smelled like stale coffee and regret in Ohio. It wasn’t about the school; it was about who I thought I needed to be before they saw who I actually was. Let’s sit with that for a second. The lie started small, almost accidentally. I was twenty-two, standing in a dimly lit bar in downtown Chicago, nursing a gin and tonic that tasted like medicine. The man across from me was wearing a tweed jacket that probably cost more than my monthly rent. He asked, casually, where I had gone to college. And in that moment, panic didn’t just visit; it moved in. I didn’t want to say Ohio State. I didn’t want to say state school. I wanted to sound like someone who drank espresso on stone steps while discussing post-structuralism. So I said, "Bard." Or maybe it was Vassar. Honestly, I can’t remember which one I chose that night, but I remember the relief that washed over me when he nodded and said, "Oh, lovely. I’ve always wanted to go there." Here’s the thing about lying on first dates. It rarely feels like a moral failing in the moment. It feels like strategy. It feels like armor. We are so terrified of being seen as ordinary, or worse, insufficient, that we curate our histories until they look like something worth reading about. I wasn’t trying to trick him into loving me. I was trying to trick myself into believing I belonged in that space. That bar. That conversation. That life. But the truth is, I felt like an imposter in my own skin long before I ever invented a fake alma mater. Did you feel that too? That sudden tightening in your chest when you realize you’ve painted yourself into a corner? Because that’s what happens when we start building relationships on foundations of fiction. You have to keep adding bricks. If you said you went to a liberal arts college in New England, you can’t suddenly mention your junior year study abroad in Madrid if you never left the Midwest. So you start remembering things that didn’t happen. You start adopting opinions you don’t hold because they fit the character you’re playing. You become a ghost in your own narrative. I think we do this because we believe love requires perfection. Or at least, competence. We think that if we show them the messy, unpolished, confused version of ourselves—the one who cried in the library bathroom because she failed Organic Chemistry—they won’t stay. They’ll leave. They’ll find someone who sounds smarter, who looks sharper, who has a clearer path. So we edit. We highlight reel our lives before the camera even starts rolling. But in doing so, we rob ourselves of the chance to be loved for our actual struggles. We deny them the privilege of knowing us. And we deny ourselves the freedom of being known. As someone who has spent years listening to women’s stories, I’ve realized that this isn’t just about dating. It’s about how we view our own worth. When I worked as an editor, I used to review resumes. And I could always tell when someone was embellishing. Not because their skills were fake, but because their confidence rang hollow. There’s a specific cadence to insecurity disguised as arrogance. It doesn’t quite land. It floats. And people notice. Even if they don’t say anything, even if they smile and nod, they feel the dissonance. I’m thinking now about my mother. She never lied about her past. She was a nurse in the seventies, working double shifts to pay for tuition. She told every man she dated exactly that. No glamour. No prestige. Just hard work and tired feet. And yet, she attracted men who respected her deeply. Why? Because she wasn’t performing. She was present. She gave them the real story, and she trusted that the story was enough. I envy that simplicity. I envy that trust. I spent my twenties trying to add chapters to my biography that weren’t there, hoping the plot would improve. But the plot only improves when you’re telling the truth. There was always a breaking point. For me, it usually came around the third date. That’s when the veneer cracks. The third date is intimate enough that questions get deeper, but early enough that the lie hasn’t been fully integrated into the mythos. One evening, a man named David asked me why I hadn’t mentioned my hometown. I froze. My heart hammered against my ribs like a bird trapped in a chimney. I looked at him, really looked at him, and I saw kindness in his eyes. Not judgment. Kindness. And in that moment, I realized I was exhausted. I was so tired of holding up the sky. I was tired of monitoring my voice, my posture, my memories. I just wanted to put the burden down. So I told him. I told him I went to Ohio. I told him I drove two hours home every weekend because I missed my dog. I told him I hated the pretension I had projected onto myself. I waited for him to recoil. I waited for him to laugh or to walk out. But he just leaned back, exhaled, and smiled. He said, "Well, that explains why you hate cheese so much. I thought it was some East Coast elitist thing." And then we laughed. We talked about real things. We talked about bad movies and childhood pets and the weather. And I felt lighter than I had in years. The lie hadn’t protected me; it had imprisoned me. Let’s dig into why we do this. Why is the ordinary so terrifying? Why do we equate authenticity with risk? In a culture that glorifies hustle, achievement, and aesthetic perfection, admitting to mediocrity feels like surrender. We’re taught that we must be exceptional to be worthy. If we’re not special, we’re invisible. So we fabricate specialness. We invent credentials, experiences, and backgrounds that align with the cultural script of success. But here’s the quiet truth: most people are just figuring it out. Most people are scared. Most people are wondering if they’re faking it too. When we drop the mask, we give others permission to do the same. We create space for connection that isn’t based on performance. I think about the women I interview for this show. They talk about the pressure to have it all together by thirty. By forty. By fifty. They talk about the fear that if they stop performing, they will cease to exist. But existence isn’t about performance. It’s about presence. It’s about showing up as you are, with all your contradictions and confusions intact. It’s about trusting that you are enough, not despite your flaws, but including them. Your history is yours. It’s not a marketing pitch. It’s not a resume. It’s the soil from which you grew. And it’s beautiful, exactly as it is. So, what do we do with this urge to embellish? How do we untangle ourselves from the webs we’ve spun? First, we acknowledge the fear. We admit that we’re scared of being rejected for who we are. That’s okay. That’s human. Then, we practice radical honesty in small doses. Tell the truth about where you’re from. Tell the truth about what you’re afraid of. Tell the truth about how you’re feeling today. Start small. See who stays. See who leaves. You might be surprised by who stays. You might be devastated by who leaves. But both outcomes are valuable. They bring you closer to the truth of who you are and who deserves your time. I stopped lying about my university years years ago. I don’t need to pretend anymore. I know who I am. I know what I’ve overcome. I know that my education wasn’t defined by the name on my diploma, but by the late nights I studied, the friends I made, and the resilience I built. Those things are real. They are tangible. They are mine. And they are enough. More than enough. They are everything. So next time you feel the urge to curate, to embellish, to perform—pause. Take a breath. Ask yourself: who am I trying to impress? And more importantly, do I like the person I’m pretending to be? Thank you for letting me into your headspace today. Be gentle with yourselves. You are doing better than you think. Until next time, I’m Michelle White. Keep listening.