Latest / The Morning Rundown / Typhoon Champi Hits Taiwan, a GOP Split Over an Ohio Ad, and Starshield Questions
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] I'm on my second coffee, and my brain is still buffering.
- 0:18[Maya] David, tell me something that'll wake me up.
- 0:20[David] Three stories, and one of them involves a satellite network and two
- 0:23[David] governments telling different tales.
- 0:25[Maya] Okay, that did it.
- 0:27[Maya] I'm awake, and hey, welcome to the morning rundown.
- 0:29[Maya] I'm Maya, that's David, and we've got a full plate.
- 0:33[David] We do.
- 0:33[David] Quick map of the morning in the order we'll hit it.
- 0:35[David] First, a big storm in East Asia that's upending flights and daily
- 0:39[David] life for a lot of people.
- 0:41[Maya] Serious stuff.
- 0:42[Maya] And after that?
- 0:42[David] A fight inside the Republican Party over an ad in Ohio.
- 0:46[David] Those are always interesting because nobody argues like family.
- 0:50[Maya] Right?
- 0:50[Maya] Holiday dinner, but with campaign money.
- 0:53[David] And the Starshield story.
- 0:54[David] Trump says one thing about Ukraine's access, and Ukrainian officials describe it
- 0:58[David] differently.
- 0:59[Maya] Wait, really?
- 1:00[Maya] Same network, two versions?
- 1:02[David] Two versions, and we'll try to untangle what the reporting does and
- 1:05[David] doesn't tell us.
- 1:06[David] No guessing past the sources.
- 1:08[Maya] Good rule.
- 1:09[Maya] Okay, but the storm comes first, and that one isn't a joke.
- 1:12[David] No, it's not.
- 1:13[David] People are bracing, and flights and daily life are getting upended.
- 1:16[David] So let's start with the storm that's shutting down a big part
- 1:19[David] of East Asia.
- 1:21[Maya] Okay, so the BBC's live coverage has the headline first.
- 1:25[Maya] At least one person has died in Taiwan, and Japan, China, and
- 1:29[Maya] South Korea are all bracing for the same storm.
- 1:32[David] Wait, all four at once?
- 1:34[Maya] Yep.
- 1:35[Maya] Hundreds of flights canceled across East Asia.
- 1:38[Maya] That's how the BBC framed it.
- 1:39[David] Hundreds.
- 1:40[David] Okay, and do we know how bad it is on the ground
- 1:42[David] in Taiwan itself?
- 1:44[Maya] We do.
- 1:45[Maya] ABC News Australia has the latest figures.
- 1:48[Maya] One dead and a hundred and seventy-one injured.
- 1:51[David] A hundred and seventy-one.
- 1:52[David] That's a lot of people hurt for a storm that hasn't even
- 1:55[David] made landfall.
- 1:56[Maya] Right?
- 1:57[Maya] And about twenty-six hundred were evacuated.
- 2:00[Maya] Exactly two thousand six hundred and thirty-nine.
- 2:04[David] And the power?
- 2:05[Maya] More than seventy-seven thousand homes lost electricity.
- 2:08[Maya] Most have it back now, which is the good news.
- 2:11[David] Small mercy.
- 2:11[David] Um, what about flights?
- 2:13[David] Because I'd be losing my mind at an airport.
- 2:16[Maya] Ugh.
- 2:16[Maya] Friday alone, two hundred and sixty-two domestic flights were canceled and seven
- 2:21[Maya] hundred and seventeen international.
- 2:24[David] Seven hundred and seventeen international.
- 2:26[David] That's basically the island saying, "Nobody's coming in, nobody's leaving."
- 2:30[Maya] Pretty much.
- 2:32[Maya] Nearly a thousand total.
- 2:34[David] Here's what jumps out at me.
- 2:35[David] International is way bigger than domestic.
- 2:38[Maya] Nearly three to one going by those two numbers.
- 2:41[Maya] Seven hundred and seventeen against two hundred and sixty-two.
- 2:44[David] For an island, that tells you something.
- 2:46[David] When the planes stop, the outside world just stops arriving.
- 2:49[Maya] And keep in mind, that's one day, Friday.
- 2:52[Maya] Those numbers say nothing about the days on either side of it.
- 2:55[David] Here's what confuses me, though.
- 2:56[David] I keep seeing that it weakened, so is this a downgrade or
- 3:00[David] not?
- 3:00[Maya] Taiwan's Central Weather Administration says it's now a moderate typhoon, but the
- 3:05[Maya] Taipei Times reports it has a very broad radius.
- 3:09[David] Oh, so weaker but huge.
- 3:12[Maya] Huge.
- 3:13[Maya] The center was projected to pass within about eighty kilometers of the
- 3:17[Maya] coast.
- 3:17[Maya] That's roughly fifty miles.
- 3:19[David] Which is close enough that you still feel all of it.
- 3:21[Maya] Totally, and direct landfall was still possible.
- 3:25[Maya] Schools and work were canceled in nearly every municipality.
- 3:29[David] Nearly every one.
- 3:30[David] That's not a regional shutdown.
- 3:31[David] That's a whole island saying, "Stay home."
- 3:34[Maya] Honestly, hard to argue with.
- 3:36[David] Picture it, though.
- 3:37[David] School shut, offices shut, nearly everywhere, and everybody's home refreshing the forecast
- 3:42[David] and watching the sky.
- 3:43[Maya] And with a storm that wide, that forecast matters to a lot
- 3:47[Maya] of people at once, not just the folks right on the coast.
- 3:50[David] So where does it go from here?
- 3:52[Maya] The forecast track passes just off northeast Taiwan.
- 3:56[Maya] Then it turns toward the Chinese coast and on to southern Japan.
- 4:00[David] Like a bowling ball with a mind of its own.
- 4:02[Maya] Kind of.
- 4:03[Maya] And Taiwan's weather agency says landfall can't be ruled out if the
- 4:07[Maya] storm stalls or wobbles.
- 4:09[David] Hmm, and the Taipei Times says it should slow down and leave
- 4:12[David] Taiwan proper by Saturday evening.
- 4:14[Maya] Slow is the worry, right?
- 4:16[Maya] Slow means more hours of wind and rain sitting on the same
- 4:19[Maya] place.
- 4:20[David] And it doesn't stop at Taiwan.
- 4:22[David] Once that track bends, China and Japan are next in line.
- 4:25[Maya] Which fits with why they're watching so closely.
- 4:28[Maya] So even if Taiwan gets through it, the story keeps moving.
- 4:31[David] Yeah, and tracks change, so this is a moving target.
- 4:34[Maya] It is.
- 4:35[Maya] Everything we've said is as of Friday, October twenty-third, and the situation
- 4:39[Maya] is still changing, so the numbers may be different by the time
- 4:42[Maya] you hear this.
- 4:43[David] Well, weather you can't argue with.
- 4:45[David] Politics, though, is another story.
- 4:47[Maya] And a Republican one is getting messy in Ohio.
- 4:51[Speaker 3] Okay, Ohio.
- 4:53[Speaker 3] Vivek Ramaswamy is the Republican nominee for governor, and his campaign dropped
- 4:57[Speaker 3] an ad that has people from both parties wincing.
- 5:00[David] Wincing how?
- 5:01[Speaker 3] The Washington Post framed it as shock jock politics, the kind Republicans
- 5:05[Speaker 3] have rewarded for about a decade.
- 5:07[Speaker 3] Their take is that this time, the criticism came from both sides.
- 5:10[David] Both sides is the part that jumps out.
- 5:12[David] Usually, these fights split cleanly along party lines.
- 5:15[Speaker 3] Right, and that's why it's worth a closer look.
- 5:18[Speaker 3] The usual script didn't hold.
- 5:19[David] Huh.
- 5:20[David] So what's in the ad?
- 5:21[Speaker 3] It features Donna Arthur, the estranged mother of Democratic opponent Amy Acton.
- 5:26[Speaker 3] She accuses Acton of lying about her past.
- 5:28[David] Okay, and Acton's past is?
- 5:30[Speaker 3] Public.
- 5:31[Speaker 3] Newsweek notes she's spoken openly about childhood abuse and homelessness, so the
- 5:36[Speaker 3] ad is a mother attacking a daughter over a story the daughter
- 5:38[Speaker 3] already tells herself.
- 5:40[David] Wow.
- 5:40[Speaker 3] Yeah.
- 5:41[David] It's a heavy thing to hear in a political ad, honestly.
- 5:44[David] Family stuff always lands differently than a policy fight.
- 5:46[Speaker 3] It does, and it's why people react to this kind of ad
- 5:49[Speaker 3] in a gut way, whatever their party.
- 5:51[David] Now, I mean-
- 5:52[Speaker 4] Come on.
- 5:53[Speaker 4] Hard-hitting campaigning is normal.
- 5:54[Speaker 4] Nobody expects a governor's race to be a church picnic, and Republicans
- 5:58[Speaker 4] have watched Democrats go after them plenty.
- 5:59[Maya] Totally.
- 6:00[Maya] Except look at who objected.
- 6:02[Maya] Newsweek reported that Governor Mike DeWine, a Republican who endorsed Ramaswamy, urged
- 6:07[Maya] the campaign to take it down.
- 6:09[Maya] He called it wrong.
- 6:10[Speaker 4] Wait, really?
- 6:11[Speaker 4] Wrong flat out?
- 6:12[Maya] Wrong.
- 6:12[Maya] And CNN reported that some other leading Ohio Republicans distanced themselves too.
- 6:17[Speaker 4] That matters.
- 6:17[Speaker 4] That's not the usual critics.
- 6:19[Speaker 4] That's his own side.
- 6:20[Maya] And he's not a backbencher.
- 6:21[Maya] He's the governor, and he endorsed the guy.
- 6:23[Speaker 4] Right.
- 6:24[Speaker 4] Anyway, the party has defenders.
- 6:26[Speaker 4] CNN says Vance told Republicans to stop whining, and he said the
- 6:29[Speaker 4] ad calls Acton a liar.
- 6:30[Maya] So his defense is basically it's about honesty, not her family.
- 6:34[Speaker 4] Right.
- 6:34[Speaker 4] And Trump said he didn't know about the ad, but he did
- 6:37[Speaker 4] say the mother went very rogue.
- 6:38[Maya] Which is a funny way to describe somebody's mom.
- 6:41[Speaker 4] Rogue mom.
- 6:42[Speaker 4] Sounds like a streaming series.
- 6:44[Maya] Fair enough.
- 6:45[Maya] But there's a serious version of the Vance argument, right?
- 6:47[Maya] If a candidate's biography is part of the pitch, it's fair game
- 6:50[Maya] to challenge it.
- 6:51[Speaker 4] Sure.
- 6:51[Speaker 4] I'd say that's legit.
- 6:53[Speaker 4] Voters get to test what candidates say about themselves.
- 6:55[Maya] But, but...
- 6:57[Speaker 4] But the messenger is her mother, and the topic is abuse.
- 7:00[Speaker 4] DeWine isn't some cable pundit looking for a fight.
- 7:02[Speaker 4] He backed this guy.
- 7:04[Speaker 4] If he sees a line, a lot of ordinary Republican voters might
- 7:06[Speaker 4] see one too.
- 7:07[Maya] Mm.
- 7:08[Maya] And those voters are the whole ballgame in a statewide race.
- 7:11[Speaker 4] Exactly.
- 7:12[Speaker 4] You can be a tough campaigner and still ask whether this particular
- 7:15[Speaker 4] tool is worth what it costs.
- 7:16[Maya] And that's the line I keep landing on.
- 7:19[Maya] Nobody's saying you can't challenge a candidate's story.
- 7:22[Maya] The question is whether this particular way of doing it helps.
- 7:25[Speaker 4] Right.
- 7:26[Speaker 4] And the Post piece makes that point about limits.
- 7:28[Speaker 4] The shock jock approach has been rewarded for a decade, but that
- 7:31[Speaker 4] doesn't mean it works every time.
- 7:32[Maya] Which is the whole idea behind that headline about owning the libs
- 7:35[Maya] having limits, especially when the target's own family is in the frame.
- 7:39[Speaker 4] And I'd call that campaign craft more than a moral lecture.
- 7:42[Speaker 4] Allies like DeWine are telling you the tactic may cost more than
- 7:45[Speaker 4] it earns.
- 7:46[Maya] We'll see whether the campaign hears that or whether it simply keeps
- 7:49[Maya] the ad exactly as it is.
- 7:51[Maya] Now, from a fight over an ad to a fight over a
- 7:54[Maya] switch, there's a dispute over satellite internet in Ukraine.
- 7:58[Speaker 4] Starshield.
- 7:59[Maya] Right.
- 7:59[Maya] Who actually gets to decide whether Ukraine has access to it?
- 8:03[Maya] Okay, Starshield.
- 8:04[Maya] David, you've been waiting to explain this one.
- 8:07[David] I have.
- 8:08[David] The New York Times reported that Trump asked Elon Musk to reverse
- 8:12[David] limits on Ukraine's military internet use.
- 8:15[David] That's the starting point.
- 8:16[Maya] Wait, so the president is phoning a private company about a war?
- 8:20[David] According to The Times, yes.
- 8:23[David] That was reported October twenty-second into the twenty-third.
- 8:26[Maya] Just to be clear on the setup, this is about Ukraine's military
- 8:29[Maya] internet use and the limits on it.
- 8:31[David] Right.
- 8:32[David] The Times reported that limits existed and that Trump asked Musk to
- 8:35[David] reverse them.
- 8:36[David] What those limits are exactly, I'm not gonna guess at.
- 8:39[Maya] Huh.
- 8:40[Maya] And then what?
- 8:41[Maya] Did Musk just flip a switch?
- 8:43[David] Trump says so.
- 8:44[David] He said Thursday that Musk had restored Ukraine's access.
- 8:47[Maya] Great.
- 8:48[Maya] Done.
- 8:48[Maya] Everybody go home.
- 8:50[David] Not so fast.
- 8:52[David] Ukrainian officials say restrictions remain, and they say those restrictions complicate Kyiv's
- 8:56[David] war effort.
- 8:57[Maya] Hold on.
- 8:58[Maya] Same service, same day, two completely different stories?
- 9:01[David] Right.
- 9:02[David] Per CNN's update on The Times and Wall Street Journal reporting, that's
- 9:06[David] exactly where things sit as of Thursday.
- 9:08[Maya] Okay, so which is it?
- 9:09[Maya] Because, I mean, come on, somebody knows whether it's on or off.
- 9:13[David] You'd think, and it gets more tangled.
- 9:15[David] A source told CNN that Trump asked Musk by phone to restore
- 9:19[David] full access.
- 9:21[Maya] A source.
- 9:22[Maya] One unnamed source.
- 9:24[David] Fair flag.
- 9:25[David] That account leans on someone CNN didn't name, so hold it a
- 9:28[David] little loosely.
- 9:29[Maya] But it doesn't line up with what Trump said before, does it?
- 9:32[David] No.
- 9:33[David] Trump had earlier said he wasn't involved.
- 9:36[Maya] Wait, really?
- 9:36[Maya] So he wasn't involved, and then he's announcing the fix?
- 9:40[David] Tunky, both can be reported.
- 9:42[David] I'm not going to tell you which is right because the sources
- 9:44[David] don't settle it.
- 9:45[Maya] And Musk, has he said anything about who runs this?
- 9:48[David] He had.
- 9:49[David] Musk said limits on speed or usage are decided by the military
- 9:53[David] and ultimately the president.
- 9:55[Maya] Huh.
- 9:55[Maya] So he was pointing up the chain.
- 9:57[David] That's what he said, and it complicates the picture of one man
- 10:01[David] flipping a switch.
- 10:02[David] If the military and the president set the limits, a request from
- 10:05[David] the president to Musk at least fits that, but that's me reading
- 10:09[David] between the lines, and the reporting doesn't spell it out.
- 10:12[Maya] Which leaves the question you can't shake.
- 10:14[Maya] Who really holds the switch?
- 10:16[David] Right.
- 10:17[David] Musk's own words put it with the military and the president.
- 10:20[David] Trump's version says Musk restored it.
- 10:22[David] Ukraine's officials say it's still restricted.
- 10:24[David] Those three don't snap together yet.
- 10:26[Maya] And that matters beyond the argument because this is a country at
- 10:30[Maya] war.
- 10:31[Maya] Ukrainian officials say the restrictions complicate Kyiv's war effort.
- 10:34[Maya] So a switch that's on in one telling and off in another
- 10:38[Maya] is not a small thing.
- 10:39[David] Which is why a clear statement from whoever actually controls the limits
- 10:43[David] would settle more than any of us can.
- 10:45[David] Until then, we have the president's word, Ukraine's complaint, and that one
- 10:49[David] unnamed source.
- 10:51[Maya] So what would settle it for you?
- 10:52[Maya] Not an opinion, but something concrete.
- 10:55[David] Something on the record from whoever sets the limits, yes.
- 10:58[David] Short of that, we're weighing a president's remark against what Ukrainian officials
- 11:02[David] say they're living with.
- 11:04[Maya] And weighing those for you isn't our job.
- 11:06[Maya] We'll lay out what each side says and leave it there.
- 11:09[David] That's the honest version, I think.
- 11:11[Maya] Fair enough.
- 11:12[Maya] That's it for the big stories.
- 11:13[David] Let's wrap it up.
- 11:15[Maya] Okay, that was a big morning, and I'm glad you stuck with
- 11:17[Maya] us through all of it.
- 11:19[Maya] Let's do a quick lap before we let you go, and I
- 11:21[Maya] promise to keep each one short.
- 11:23[David] First, the typhoon.
- 11:25[David] Champi shut down much of Taiwan, and its neighbors were bracing too.
- 11:28[Maya] Then Ohio.
- 11:29[Maya] Ramaswamy's ad with Amy Acton's estranged mother split Republicans, and the governor
- 11:34[Maya] was among the critics.
- 11:36[David] And Starshield.
- 11:37[David] Trump says Ukraine's access is restored, and Ukrainian officials say otherwise.
- 11:42[Maya] Two of those are still developing, the storm and the Starshield dispute,
- 11:46[Maya] so keep an ear out for updates.
- 11:48[David] What stuck with me is how different the three felt.
- 11:50[David] The storm is physical.
- 11:51[David] You can't argue with weather.
- 11:53[Maya] Ohio was about judgment.
- 11:54[Maya] Hard-hitting campaigning is normal, and the party has its defenders, but pushback
- 11:59[Maya] from someone like DeWine suggests even allies can see a line.
- 12:03[David] And Starshield is about facts, which should be the easier kind of
- 12:06[David] question, and somehow it's the one that's still tangled.
- 12:09[Maya] Honestly, that's the part that gets me.
- 12:11[Maya] You can argue about taste all day, but facts are supposed to
- 12:15[Maya] settle things.
- 12:16[David] They are, and that's a decent lens for your own news diet,
- 12:18[David] I think.
- 12:19[David] Ask whether the story in front of you is a fact, a
- 12:22[David] judgment call, or a forecast because they deserve different amounts of trust.
- 12:26[Maya] Ooh, I like that.
- 12:28[Maya] Three questions free of charge.
- 12:30[David] Worth every penny.
- 12:31[David] And if you've got family or travel plans touching Taiwan, check local
- 12:35[David] updates and not just US.
- 12:36[Maya] Good advice.
- 12:37[Maya] And for Starshield, watch for who speaks next and how specific they
- 12:41[Maya] get, especially anyone who actually controls the limits.
- 12:45[David] Exactly.
- 12:46[David] Specifics beat slogans every time.
- 12:48[Maya] Well said.
- 12:49[Maya] Thanks for spending part of your morning with us, everybody.
- 12:51[David] Take care of yourselves out there, and stay safe if you're anywhere
- 12:54[David] near that storm.
- 12:55[Maya] Stay dry, and that's The Rundown.