Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] Nike Is Broken Or Resetting
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Deep Dive. Today we're digging into, well,
- 0:03one of the most iconic names out there, a company that for
- 0:06decades defined market leadership.
- 0:08But right now is trading like it's completely lost its way.
- 0:11Exactly. We were talking about Nike Inc
- 0:14ticker NKE and the market perception.
- 0:18Right now it's just brutal. It really is.
- 0:21I mean, if you look at the stock, it's hovering near 5 year
- 0:24valuation lows. The consensus, you know the main
- 0:28story out there, is that this is a broken compounder.
- 0:30A broken compounder And the argument is what?
- 0:33That they've lost their cool. That's a huge part of it.
- 0:35The idea is they've missed the shift and what people want.
- 0:38They've lost their innovation edge to these nimble upstarts
- 0:41like Hoke Anon. And crucially, that massive,
- 0:44expensive pivot to direct to consumer.
- 0:46That it was a complete blunder, a total misstep.
- 0:49OK, so that consensus is loud, but our job is to test the other
- 0:51side, the variant perception. Is Nike permanently broken or
- 0:57are we just looking at the painful bottom of a classic
- 0:59self-inflicted capital cycle reset?
- 1:02That's the mission for this deep dive.
- 1:04And to do that, we've synthesized a number of Cerensic
- 1:07value investing research reports, the financial
- 1:10statements of course, and the Q2 fiscal 2026 earnings
- 1:14transcripts. We're looking at the hard data,
- 1:17the operational metrics. We want to see if the new
- 1:20management team is truly fixing the foundation or if this is all
- 1:24just, you know, financial engineering.
- 1:26Exactly. And before we get into the
- 1:27weeds, let's just give you the single most important insight
- 1:30right up front. Here's the signal we think the
- 1:32market is misinterpreting. Despite the headline stagnation,
- 1:36Q2 revenue was up a miserable 1% to 12.4 billion.
- 1:41Which looks terrible. It looks awful, but the
- 1:43composition of those sales is changing dramatically.
- 1:46It's like imagine a restaurant that sold the same number of
- 1:49meals as last year, but last year 80% of them were high
- 1:53margin steak and now 80% are low margin burgers.
- 1:56The top line, the total revenue is flat, but the underlying
- 2:00health of the business is completely different.
- 2:02OK, let's unpack that revenue contradiction because it's so
- 2:05important. The flat growth headline is easy
- 2:08to just dismiss as bad news, but when you look under the hood,
- 2:12you see these immediate, drastic changes.
- 2:14Right. So Nike Direct revenues their
- 2:17own stores and website, they fell 8%.
- 2:21Which is bad enough, but the really shocking number is the
- 2:24digital sales, the core of that whole expensive DTC push.
- 2:28They cratered down 14%. 14% Those are the numbers that
- 2:32terrified the market. It suggests people actively
- 2:35dislike buying from Nike's own apps and websites.
- 2:38It. Does.
- 2:40But, and this is the key, at the exact same moment, the legacy
- 2:45wholesale revenues grew and not by a little.
- 2:47They grew robustly by 8%. That's the whole story, right?
- 2:51There. And that's what we're calling
- 2:52the wholesale boomerang. It proves people haven't stopped
- 2:55buying Nike shoes. They've just stopped buying them
- 2:57directly from Nike, right? Precisely.
- 2:59The core insight is the consumers, well they prefer the
- 3:02multi brand environment. Places like Footlocker, Dick's,
- 3:05Sporting Goods, you know, your local running store.
- 3:08So this pivot back to wholesale isn't a sign of desperation.
- 3:12I think it's a sign of abandoning the hubris of that
- 3:15consumer direct acceleration push.
- 3:17That strategy was incredibly capital intensive.
- 3:20It was super sensitive to logistics costs.
- 3:23They're now strategically realigning with where the
- 3:26customer actually wants to chop. But hold on, doesn't reversing
- 3:31course after years of telling everyone that DTC was the
- 3:34future? Doesn't that signal
- 3:36incompetence? They spent billions building out
- 3:39this whole system. Oh, it absolutely signals a
- 3:41failed strategy, no doubt. But the realignment itself is
- 3:44the healthy part. They're absorbing the sunk cost
- 3:47of that failure to build a more sound business for the future.
- 3:50And that brings us to the biggest fear of the market has
- 3:52right now, which is margins. Gross margins contracted 300
- 3:55basis points. They're down to 40.6% and that
- 3:59looks like a permanent loss of pricing power.
- 4:01Of course it does. If you see a 300 basis point
- 4:03drop, you naturally assume the business model is just
- 4:06structurally broken. So how can we argue this is
- 4:09temporary and healthy? That sounds totally
- 4:11counterintuitive. Because it's largely an optical
- 4:13illusion, it's driven by two very deliberate management
- 4:18actions. First, they are intentionally
- 4:21killing off excess supply to restore brand scarcity.
- 4:24They're clearing the deck. What does that mean in practice?
- 4:27It means they are massively reducing the supply of those
- 4:30classics that they overproduced, like the Air Force Ones and
- 4:33Jordan ones, by over 20%. They have to liquidate that
- 4:37glut, which crushes margins now, but it prevents the brand from
- 4:41being diluted forever. So they're buying back their
- 4:44cool factor. They're buying it back, taking
- 4:46the short term pain for the long term brand equity.
- 4:50And the second factor is just their sheer scale.
- 4:52Nike is absorbing temporary tariffs and cost headwinds that
- 4:55amount to what, an estimated 1 1/2 billion dollars?
- 4:58And their smaller competitors can't do that.
- 5:00Exactly the nimble upstarts like ON or Hoka.
- 5:03A hit like that would cause the massive financial distress.
- 5:06Nike scale lets them just swallow the cost and wait out
- 5:09the cycle. OK.
- 5:10Let's go back to that wholesale boomerang.
- 5:12You said something really interesting that shifting back
- 5:14to the wholesale channel which has a lower gross margin somehow
- 5:18expands long term operating margin, right?
- 5:20Wait, a lower gross margin is better for the operating margin?
- 5:24Can you just quickly remind everyone listening what the
- 5:26difference is here? Absolutely.
- 5:28Think of it this way. Gross margin is super simple.
- 5:31It's the selling price minus what it cost to make the shoe.
- 5:35DTC has a high gross margin, maybe 60% because Nike collects
- 5:39the full retail price. OK, makes sense.
- 5:41But to get that high margin, you have to then pay massive
- 5:44operating expenses. All the store leases, the staff
- 5:47salaries, the shipping, the digital marketing processing,
- 5:50all the returns. It adds up.
- 5:52Right, the SGNA. The SGNA, now the wholesale
- 5:54channel has a low gross margin, maybe 40% because the wholesaler
- 5:57takes their cut. But Nikes operating expenses
- 6:00almost nothing. They ship a pallet of shoes to
- 6:03Footlocker and. They're done, so the dollar they
- 6:07get from wholesale is a cleaner dollar.
- 6:09A much cleaner dollar of revenue, it requires far less
- 6:12overhead. So this strategic shift, it
- 6:14shrinks the whole SG and a base which improves the bottom line
- 6:18operating margin and most importantly return on invested
- 6:21capital. And that ROIC return on invested
- 6:23capital, that metric is everything.
- 6:25When we talk about a company's Moat and Nikes Tri identity,
- 6:29which I think it's lost in all the noise, is that they are
- 6:31fundamentally an intellectual property and marketing firm.
- 6:34They're not a manufacturer. Not at all.
- 6:36It's the definition of an asset light flywheel and the unit
- 6:40economics are, well, spectacular.
- 6:43They leverage low cost contract manufacturing in Asia against
- 6:46this high value Western brand equity.
- 6:49A shoe cost what, 2530 bucks to? Make and it sells for over $100
- 6:53at retail. The nearly $5 billion annual
- 6:56marketing budget that demand creation.
- 6:58It creates this IP barrier that should be almost impossible to
- 7:02overcome. But that failed DTC pivot.
- 7:04It just bloated the entire machine.
- 7:06The collapse in capital efficiencies.
- 7:08It's truly stunning. When you look at the charts
- 7:10historically, you know from 2016 to 2022, Nike was a powerhouse.
- 7:14An ROIC machine generating returns on invested capital in
- 7:18the high 20s, almost 28%. And that is the single most
- 7:21damning chart for the previous management team.
- 7:23Yeah, that aggressive DTC strategy.
- 7:26It demanded massive investment logistics, digital tech building
- 7:31now physical retail stores it. Bloated the SGNA.
- 7:33It bloated the balance sheet. And it just diluted ROIC all the
- 7:37way down to roughly 11 1/2% in 2025.
- 7:40That is a 60% drop in capital efficiency.
- 7:44The entire turn around hinges on getting that number back towards
- 7:4720%. Now let's talk about a quiet
- 7:49little alarm bell from the balance sheet, a critical red
- 7:52flag the forensic reports really honed in on.
- 7:55Yeah, we need a forensic alert on this.
- 7:57It's a potential working capital trap.
- 7:59The metric to watch is days sales outstanding or DSO.
- 8:03Which is what exactly? It's the average time it takes
- 8:05for Nike to get paid by wholesalers after they send an
- 8:08invoice. Historically, Nike collected
- 8:11cash really fast, around 30 to 33 days.
- 8:15Recently, that has ballooned to about 43 days.
- 8:18So what does that mean in practical terms?
- 8:20Why should you care if it takes them 10 days longer to get paid?
- 8:23It's a classic, subtle sign of stress.
- 8:26If your revenue is flat but it's taking you longer to collect
- 8:29cash, it suggests your customers, the wholesalers, are
- 8:33struggling to sell the inventory you just sent them.
- 8:36The real danger here is something called channel
- 8:38stuffing. Channel stuffing.
- 8:41So that's when. That's when Nike, the
- 8:43manufacturer, pushes a ton of inventory out the door to their
- 8:46wholesalers right at the end of 1/4 just to hit that quarterly
- 8:50revenue target. They might offer easier payment
- 8:53terms to convince the wholesaler to take the product.
- 8:55So that 8% rise in wholesale revenue might not be real
- 8:59consumer demand. It might be a temporary loan of
- 9:02inventory to the channel, and if that's the case, if retailers
- 9:05are now choked with unsold Nike product, the company's going to
- 9:08have a very, very painful hangover in the coming quarters.
- 9:11And that ties right into this inefficiency tax.
- 9:13We identified in Q2 their marketing spend demand creation,
- 9:18it's spiked 13% to $1.3 billion. Well, revenue only grew 1%.
- 9:24You're spending aggressively just to stand still.
- 9:26It's exactly management calls it a necessary investment, but
- 9:30fundamentally what it tells you is that the cost to stay
- 9:32relevant has structurally increased.
- 9:35The brand just needs more fuel to maintain cruising altitude.
- 9:39So if the problem was operational inefficiency and a
- 9:42failed strategy, the solution really has to be management.
- 9:46And let's look at the catalyst here, the leadership pivot.
- 9:50It really feels like they're moving from a spreadsheet
- 9:53manager back to someone who actually, you know, leases up
- 9:56the shoes. That's the perfect way to
- 9:58describe it. They're transitioning from John
- 10:00Donahoe, who was the technocrat, the guy optimizing for
- 10:02algorithms and the income statement, to Elliot Hill, to
- 10:05Elliot Hill, the shoe dog, a product focused veteran.
- 10:09His whole job is to restore the culture, to shift the focus back
- 10:13to winning by sport, by category, not just by e-commerce
- 10:17channel. And the tone for management has
- 10:19completely changed. I mean, you read the transcripts
- 10:21and the bravado, the hubris in the last few years, it's gone.
- 10:25It's humility. They are intensely focused on
- 10:29operational blocking and tackling and truthfully they
- 10:32have explicitly said to expect more near term pain.
- 10:36They're forecasting Q3 gross margins to drop even further.
- 10:40Which Wall Street hates. Wall Street hates it, but for a
- 10:43value investor, that willingness to take a big bath right down,
- 10:47to sacrifice short term earnings to get inventory healthy for the
- 10:51long run, that's a huge positive signal.
- 10:53It tells you they're managing for the next 10 years, not the
- 10:56next 90 days. And you can see the shift in how
- 10:58they're spending money. That massive $4 billion plus
- 11:01marketing budget is being reallocated.
- 11:04Exactly. They're moving funds away from
- 11:05that expensive and frankly ineffective digital customer
- 11:08acquisition that fed the DPC machine.
- 11:11And putting it back into. Back into traditional sports
- 11:13marketing, athletes, event sponsorships, high profile
- 11:16collaborations. That hits the income statement
- 11:18immediately as an expense, which creates this temporary earnings
- 11:22depression, and that's what offers the current entry point.
- 11:25And it's amazing that even through this massive reset,
- 11:29their shareholder alignment has remained pretty robust.
- 11:32They have what, 24 straight years of dividend increases?
- 11:36And it's now approaching a 3% yield.
- 11:38And you also have to give them credit for how they manage the
- 11:41share count. Look, stock based COP, which was
- 11:43around $709 million, that's a real economic cost.
- 11:47It dilutes you as a shareholder. But Nike has used massive
- 11:50buybacks to counter this. They've aggressively reduced the
- 11:54share count from 1.69 billion in 2016 down to 1.48 billion in
- 11:592025. They're using capital returns to
- 12:03fight dilution and return value. It shows discipline.
- 12:06All right, now we have to apply Charlie Munger's favorite trick
- 12:09inversion, the pre mortem. Let's assume Nike fails five
- 12:13years from now. The turn around is a bust.
- 12:15What happened? The cause would be one of the
- 12:17big structural risks, the ones that the current pivot was just
- 12:20too little, too late to fix. OK, Risk number one has to be
- 12:23the innovation trap. We're calling this the Nokia
- 12:25moment. Nike's whole identity is
- 12:27performance innovation. And they missed the biggest
- 12:31running trend of the last decade.
- 12:32The Max cushion trend, Hoka and on basically ate their lunch.
- 12:37Nike was late to that party. And that is the most lethal
- 12:39risk, a permanent structural loss of the Innovation Edge.
- 12:44If the new updates to the core running shoes like the Pegasus
- 12:47or the Vapor Fly, if they failed to stop the slide, the brand
- 12:51risks becoming just a lifestyle company.
- 12:53And that's a much lower multiple business.
- 12:55A much, much lower multiple than a performance IP house that
- 12:59drives the cutting edge of sport.
- 13:01OK. Risk number 2 is geopolitical,
- 13:04the China decoupling. China is about 15% of revenue
- 13:07for Nike, but in Q2, revenue there fell 16%.
- 13:11Digital was even worse. Digital was down a staggering
- 13:1436%. The failure mode here is the
- 13:17structural rise of guachao. You know that nationalist
- 13:20consumption trend that favors local champions like anti and
- 13:23lining? So Nike becomes a political
- 13:25football. It becomes a political pawn and
- 13:28a massive historical growth engine for them just evaporates.
- 13:31You can't just replace 15% of your global revenue overnight.
- 13:34So we've laid out the risks, we've laid out the turn around
- 13:37case. Let's bring it back to the
- 13:38money. Is this stock actually a
- 13:41bargain? Today we have to run the
- 13:43valuation reality check. OK.
- 13:45So if we use an owner earnings calculation, which you know
- 13:49strips out accounting noise to show the true cash profit, Nikes
- 13:53trailing 12 month owner earnings are about $2.79 billion.
- 14:00And at the current market cap, that implies an owner earnings
- 14:02yield of only what, 3.3%? About that, yeah, only about
- 14:063.3%. And that is, well, that's rich
- 14:09compared to the risk free rate. The 10 year treasury is sitting
- 14:11around 4.2% right now. Correct.
- 14:13So on its current depressed earnings, the stock is fairly
- 14:18priced for a turn around. It is not a screaming bargain.
- 14:21The market is already pricing in some expectation of recovery.
- 14:24So the bet you're making? The bet you are making is that
- 14:27this strategic realignment works, that owner earnings
- 14:30recover and that 33% yield effectively double S overtime,
- 14:35giving you a much more attractive yield, closer to 7%.
- 14:38So to synthesize this whole thing for you, Nike is not a
- 14:42deep value stock, not in the classic Ben Graham sense.
- 14:46Trading it, you know, roughly 24 times depressed earnings is just
- 14:49too high for that. So what is it?
- 14:51It is fundamentally quality turn around play.
- 14:54The safety here doesn't come from a rock bottom valuation
- 14:57multiple, it comes from the sheer proven durability of the
- 15:01brand, their scale advantage and the fact that the balance sheet
- 15:04is net cash strong. The numbers are fascinating
- 15:07though. If the new CEO Hill, if he does
- 15:09pull this off, if they restore normalized earnings and they
- 15:12only achieve A conservative 5% free cash flow growth annually.
- 15:16Which is very conservative compared to their history,
- 15:18right? Then the intrinsic value based
- 15:21on that model, it jumps to over $104.00 per share and that shows
- 15:24some significant upside from where the stock is trading
- 15:27today. The whole setup is clear.
- 15:29You're buying short term pain, the margin pressure, the
- 15:32strategic pivots for the potential of the long term
- 15:35compounding power of this iconic brand.
- 15:38So here is the provocative thought we want to leave you
- 15:40with. The core question isn't really
- 15:42about PE ratios or logistics. It's whether Elliott Hill the
- 15:46shoe dog can make a 50 year old brand cool and innovative again.
- 15:50You are essentially buying a call option on his ability to
- 15:53fix the operations and restore that cultural magic.
- 15:57Can he reignite the innovation cycle, the next Air, the next
- 15:59Zoom X to fight off these nimble upstarts?
- 16:01Or is a Nike just the world's largest, best market retirement
- 16:04home for classic sneaker franchises?