Latest / Toronto Talks / Can Toronto's Transit Stay on Track When the World Comes to Town?
Transcript
- 0:00The commitment that we want to make is that anybody who chooses to come to the office on a match day is also receiving excellent service.
- 0:08And that's a part of why we're throwing as much service at this as we are.
- 0:13Hello, I'm Giles Gerson, and this is Toronto Talks, the voice of Toronto's business community.
- 0:19What are we talking about?
- 0:20Each episode is a conversation with top business leaders about how they're shaping growth, driving competitiveness, and building up our economy.
- 0:29It's about what they believe it will take to make sure the Toronto region remains one of the world's great global cities.
- 0:35Here's today's conversation.
- 0:37We have literally two of Toronto's biggest names in transit, Mandeep Lally and Michael Lindsay.
- 0:43Michael is president, CEO of Metrolinks, leading the delivery and operations of this historic regional transit expansion that's taking place right now.
- 0:51And Mandeep is CEO of the TTC, which he joined last year after 10 years in the London and New York transit systems.
- 0:58Please welcome Michael and Mindy.
- 1:02Mobility is going to be so important to making these games the success we know they can be.
- 1:07And I know a huge amount of work has already gone into preparation for this on both your parts.
- 1:12And I want to just talk a little bit about that, you know, just kind of give people a flavor of how you've been preparing
- 1:18and how essentially the transit and commuter rail will roll out during this period of intense activity.
- 1:26So, Michael, regional transit will obviously have a significant share of the burden,
- 1:32bringing people in from around the region.
- 1:34And you've got Exhibition Go right next to the Toronto Stadium.
- 1:39Maybe tell us about how Metrolinks is preparing Go and regional transit services to handle surges
- 1:45and what the most important changes or upgrades being prioritized ahead of the games.
- 1:50Can do. And first, let me say good morning. Thank you.
- 1:53It's a privilege to be here on behalf of the agency.
- 1:55And let me give you a few stats that I find arresting.
- 2:01So we move on your typical weekday about 300,000 people in this region on go transit, both rail and bus.
- 2:11By the way, that puts us right next to the MTA and the Long Island Railroad as one of the largest and most used networks anywhere in the world.
- 2:19I think we are the only commuter rail network that has not only recovered, but exceeded its pre-pandemic ridership.
- 2:28That's on a normal weekday.
- 2:31So now think about the incremental volume that we see when we have events.
- 2:36Your typical TFC match contributes about 7,000 people to our network.
- 2:42Your typical Jays match, about 10,000 people.
- 2:46Taylor Swift.
- 2:4917,000 people. Game seven of the World Series, 20,000 people. Anybody care to guess what our
- 2:59ridership projection is for a match day for the World Cup? 44,000 people. Twice game seven,
- 3:08right? More than twice Taylor Swift. So the plan, to answer your question, sir,
- 3:14is a huge increase in service for the entirety of the control period,
- 3:19whether there's a match day or not, from June 10 to July 5.
- 3:233,000 weekly trips, 30% more than we ran through the course of the winter.
- 3:31Focus is on Lakeshore West, obviously, FanFest and Toronto Stadium.
- 3:37For the entirety of that control period, whether there is a match or not,
- 3:41trains will run on Lakeshore West every 15 minutes.
- 3:45on match days the service on lakeshore west goes up even more two hours before the match
- 3:51two hours after the match it'll be six trains now
- 3:56other lines will also see service increases particularly northern corridors barry richmond
- 4:01hill stoville will adjust service times too to make sure that you arrive for the start of the
- 4:06match if you're in niagara falls or anywhere on the niagara peninsula you're going to see a 15 to
- 4:1220% increase in bus trips to get you to matches, as well as sort of changes to the departure time
- 4:20in Niagara Falls to get you here for matches. The OPEX will run late, additional trips till 2am
- 4:29through the entirety of the control period. It is a massive expansion of our service. And for what
- 4:36it's worth, even that would be insufficient without the great work that partners at the TTC are doing
- 4:42to think about how we coordinate this kind of service. Now, there's going to be a little bit
- 4:47of dynamism about this, and I just want to flag it for a minute. There are a couple of match days
- 4:53where you have Jays games, FIFA World Cup, and commuters trying to get home all in the same
- 5:00window, right? So just have patience with us. The service is going to be huge, but we're going to be
- 5:07learning each and every match day about how to run trains to the West. And as a final thought, if you
- 5:11permit me, sir, remember that Exhibition Station is at the heart of that massive capital build that I
- 5:19was talking about, right? Tunnel boring machines chewing their way for the Ontario line heading east
- 5:25from that site, that will continue during the World Cup
- 5:29because we know how important that project is, right?
- 5:32But that's why physically moving people
- 5:35through that station is also something
- 5:37we're going to start practicing this weekend.
- 5:40So that's the thumbnail of what we're doing to the regional.
- 5:42Thank you.
- 5:43That's a huge amount, and that's impressive.
- 5:46And then you're the other part of this, obviously.
- 5:48And, you know, you haven't been here very long,
- 5:50and so you arrive here, and all of a sudden, FIFA,
- 5:53You're a soccer fan, you're a football fan from the UK,
- 5:57so you're probably pretty excited about it.
- 5:59But huge lift also for TTC.
- 6:01So tell us a little bit about Transier first
- 6:03from a TTC perspective during the matches
- 6:05and during the whole control period.
- 6:07Thank you, Giles.
- 6:08So just building on what Michael said
- 6:11and then following on from the words from Peter
- 6:14in terms of this is a whole city perspective,
- 6:17just TTCs, metro links, it's the police, emergency services,
- 6:21in terms of what we're doing collectively.
- 6:24in terms of grounding where we're starting from on average weekday we do about 2.5 million trips
- 6:31so that's our baseline so then we look at the news you can see the map behind me in terms of right
- 6:37how are we going to how are we going to manage the events so very simply and systematically we
- 6:43broke them down in terms of we know near the football stadium i used the word football and
- 6:50not sucking. Thanks, Charles. And FanFest, which is circa one and a half kilometers to
- 6:58the north of the fleet station, is going to be a real center hub of terms of activity.
- 7:05We've actually built, in collaboration with the city, the fleet hub as an interim station
- 7:12to manage the flow of people. So we've got a baseline of 2.5 million trips. We have a
- 7:20of 1.5 million additional trips that will occur between the 10th of June to the 19th of June,
- 7:29of which half a million are orientated around FanFest, around FIFA, and then also not locating
- 7:37the jays matches, the concerts, the Pride, all those additional events which are on top of.
- 7:43In terms of systematically working it through, we've guaranteed to maintain service as we have
- 7:50today for the 2.5 million trips. On top of that you can see how we've broke the system down
- 7:58in respect to north south east and west all orientated around the stadium and fan fest.
- 8:05From from the west you have the streetcars in terms of the 504 King and Dundas as well going
- 8:12through to Distillery Loop and then also Fleet Street as well. So those in itself have been
- 8:21up to four to five minute ratios. Now if you go back to when we looked at this early on in the
- 8:29year, we upped our service to a maximum six minutes or better. Those are now going to occur four to
- 8:35five minutes so that will cut horizontally through the network vertically we've got Dufferin we've got
- 8:43rapid to in Dufferin so that will make a huge difference on top of the normal 92 we've got the
- 8:51929 which is the express post which will get you into the location faster in terms of Dufferin gate
- 8:57look on top of that now we've also from Bathurst got the 511 which will take you again to to the
- 9:05centre of where the action is with rapid TO. On top of that then we've got the 510 from Spadina.
- 9:14So you've got all those additional functionalities in terms of transit and then from Union you have
- 9:22additional service in terms of the harbour front. You then on top of that how we have an overflow
- 9:28from St. Andrew should be required to manage spectators.
- 9:33And all of these working in unison, collectively in tandem with the numbers that we've got from FIFA,
- 9:41from Arcadia, from the Pan Am Games, from the City, from Metrolinx, from the police,
- 9:46to ensure the customer experience is the heart of what we do.
- 9:51Just to give a bit of proportional capacity, in terms of the normal weekday,
- 9:58We've estimated between 3% to 5% additional capacity that we would require.
- 10:04What we're actually providing is 18% more capacity on the subways,
- 10:0911% more capacity on the buses,
- 10:12and 10% capacity on the streetcars for weekdays.
- 10:17When we move on to the weekends and when the actual matches are,
- 10:21bear in mind that police closed the roads five hours prior to.
- 10:25Bear in mind the stadium opens three hours prior to, bearing in mind we're assessing the ingress and egress of the fans being circa two hours prior, two hours post, as well as a normal two hour match.
- 10:42where we've got service that will just exceed what is actually there.
- 10:48So for actual matches, we'll have nearly 40% additional capacity on subways,
- 10:5530% additional on buses, and 11% on streetcars.
- 11:01You may say, well, why this additional capacity?
- 11:05So when we look at this event, it's a once-in-a-lifetime event.
- 11:10it's not a question of just moving people from left to right up and down northeast south and west
- 11:15it's the experience are they going to come back here again are they going to visit this city and
- 11:20spend their money are they going to contribute to the economy will their kids want to come here
- 11:25based on their experience so it's the customer experience on top of that we've taken on
- 11:31the comments and feedback from everyone in respect to cleanliness we were up now in terms of each of
- 11:38terminals. We've taken on comments on security, and the reliability perspective. We've actually
- 11:45broken the network down into zones in terms of criticality of who is where to fix what part of
- 11:53our assets, and also what the top three failures are with the parts to that. And we've stress tested
- 11:59that to prove that we can, within zone one, get there in five minutes, fix it, and move on. So all
- 12:05of these contributing factors, coupled with working with our partners on a weekly basis,
- 12:10will ensure that we collectively contribute to make sure this experience really is, as
- 12:16Peter touched upon, a world-class experience for Toronto.
- 12:22Well, again, I think I'm a little gobsmacked at the sheer amount of increase in service
- 12:29that you're both going to be providing.
- 12:31One of the things I'm so curious about is just how you do that in terms of the rolling stock, for example, when you're adding that much, whether it's on the subways, whether it's the go system.
- 12:43Do you have to bring new cars into service or do you have cars that were parked in a rolling stock that was parked and you have to bring back into service now?
- 12:54That's a huge increase in just capacity.
- 12:56Yeah, yeah. It's drawing down the spare board of the locomotives and the coaches that are available to us.
- 13:01But for what it's worth, we weren't satisfied merely with that.
- 13:05What we've done is a blitz on all of our infrastructure, right?
- 13:09Not only rolling stock, but also signals and systems and track to try to make sure that the things that happen on a railroad happen less during this control period.
- 13:17And we've worked with our partners at CN and CPKC. Full credit to them.
- 13:21Shout out to do the same because so much of our rolling stock still moves on freight rail lines.
- 13:27But to a point that Peter made, the real surge in assets is the surge in human assets.
- 13:34Well, I was going to ask you about that.
- 13:35That we're going to deploy, right?
- 13:36Hundreds of people, Peter, they're proud in the way that you are, right?
- 13:41To be on the front lines at every station from Mimico to Allendale, helping people who have come to this region to have fun, not only get where they need to go, but also to solve problems for them.
- 13:55And they love, I can tell you, they love that they can see, in many cases, the communities that they came from culturally coming here.
- 14:04And I can tell you to the tips of their toes, they are really excited to show the best of Canada.
- 14:10That's the biggest surge in asset and complement that we've had.
- 14:13So the redeployment of personnel is obviously quite considerable.
- 14:17Yeah, and frankly, people who typically wouldn't be station attendants or wearing a high-vis vest and helping with security and the movement of people, volunteering.
- 14:27Folks from accounting and marketing and everywhere, right, that are really excited to put on a high-vis vest and to help out at their local station.
- 14:38It was so easy to open up that call for volunteers and to just watch the roles fill up.
- 14:45There's an incredible amount of excitement.
- 14:46And you're both talking, obviously, about this very considerable increase in capacity in the service. How about how it comes together, the integration, essentially, of the GO system and the TTC?
- 15:02because obviously coordination, you know,
- 15:04as you're getting people seamlessly from A to B
- 15:07down to the Panfest or the football stadium
- 15:13and then back to wherever they're coming from,
- 15:15that's got to be quite an important factor here.
- 15:19What's the coordination look like?
- 15:21So, again, this isn't something that just happened today, last week.
- 15:26You're kidding.
- 15:28Well, people do have an advantage.
- 15:30They've had four years of playing.
- 15:31We squeak. Michael's been, I think, less than a year.
- 15:34500 days.
- 15:35500 days.
- 15:36How many hours, though?
- 15:37Yeah, it's a factor.
- 15:38Ten months for myself.
- 15:39So in respect to the detailed plan that we've been working through,
- 15:44the teams have been liaising in terms of the numbers that we've shared with each other.
- 15:49They've looked at the services coming into expedition, leaving unions,
- 15:52what a harbour front passenger number looks like.
- 15:55They've also built it, as I said earlier, the fleet hub station as a new station
- 16:00for this event.
- 16:02And I'll just also highlight that I talked about the fleet hub,
- 16:07and I talked about the 1.5 additional visitors
- 16:11that's coming to the country.
- 16:13But what I actually overlooked was we also are up in our night network.
- 16:19So when our extended service ends in six instances post-2.30,
- 16:25we've got a plethora of streetcar services that will go beyond.
- 16:29So if you want to, when Canada wins, and you want to keep celebrating through the night.
- 16:35So 24 hours, basically.
- 16:37So we're a world-class city.
- 16:39So we're providing world-class service.
- 16:41So if you want to get from Harbourfront to Bathurst, or you want to go to someone else's house party to celebrate, we're providing you the facility to do that.
- 16:50Again, that's come from coordination planning to ensure the customer experience is at the heart.
- 16:56And if I could build on that.
- 16:57Yeah.
- 16:58Peter, you talk about what people know about Canada.
- 17:00I have a pet peeve, and that is the meme that the algorithm feeds me all the time
- 17:06of Toronto's transit system being two lines.
- 17:10Compared to Dubai, Shanghai, Berlin.
- 17:13Exactly.
- 17:14Take a look at the maps that our organizations are putting into new stations like Mount Dennis right now
- 17:21that overlay the GO network and the expanding TTC network.
- 17:26By the way, nothing conceptual about any of the lines that you see.
- 17:29They're all either in service or under construction.
- 17:32That's the story to tell about Toronto Transit.
- 17:35And it's as simple as saying that if we run into problems with the Union Pearson Express south of Mount Dennis,
- 17:43because I don't know, there's a freight infra issue or our work crew at St. Clair Old West and requires it.
- 17:50For the first time in a long time, people have optionality at this region.
- 17:54They get off at Mount Dennis.
- 17:55They get on the Eglinton Crosstown.
- 17:58They get down a year ago.
- 17:59Happens every day, right?
- 18:01So the network coming into being,
- 18:05and full credit to Mandeep and his team at the TTC,
- 18:07who have been excellent partners in doing this,
- 18:09has now provided pathways that create redundancy and resilience
- 18:13for an event like this.
- 18:14We have the ability to direct people different ways, different places.
- 18:20Just, you know, Mandeep talked about,
- 18:22and you both have the world-class service and, you know,
- 18:24the image of Toronto and Mandeep talking about it,
- 18:26as I said in my opening remarks, we hope people come back.
- 18:30There's a huge opportunity to bring people to Toronto
- 18:32who haven't been here before, and we want them to return.
- 18:35And so, as Mandeep said, first-class service,
- 18:38great customer experience.
- 18:40I talked about in my opening remarks some of the things
- 18:42that I've noticed, I mean, certainly from the Metrolinx,
- 18:45I think you're responsible for that, sort of the connector,
- 18:49So the covered walkway on the west side of Bay, you know, running from Union Station down to Scotia Arena,
- 18:57which has really suddenly undertaken, sort of undergone this sort of metamorphosis in terms of, I think, cleanliness, brightness.
- 19:04It's a real change.
- 19:05So congrats to you on that.
- 19:06And then I was saying to Mandy, some of the stations I've noticed, because I take the TTC every day,
- 19:12really, really, you suddenly notice this surge in, you know, cleanliness, and it just feels differently.
- 19:18So congratulations on that.
- 19:21What about, you know, are there more you can tell us about, you know, look, feel, just customer experience at the stations, on the trains themselves, on the streetcars, what you're trying to do to kind of give people that great customer feeling?
- 19:37How do you, sir?
- 19:39So in terms of the customer experience, so we've got reliable, stable service that will give them the customer experience from perspective.
- 19:48Michael touched upon ambassadors.
- 19:50We thus far have about 615 still counting for customer experience and ambassadors.
- 19:59On top of that, we're also deploying iPads for ambassadors and station folks
- 20:06with multi-linguistic skills on there because we appreciate that we'll be having linguistic challenges.
- 20:14So that would help with the customer experience.
- 20:17And coupled with all of that, we've also now got wayfinding,
- 20:22which was coming through very strongly in terms of we need to improve on,
- 20:26which we've just started to try this week, actually, at Bathurst.
- 20:31So making it very simple.
- 20:32And then on top of that, in terms of one of the most important things is communications.
- 20:39How are we communicating to the customers that have got the app?
- 20:42And we've got the GTS, GTFS feeds now that allow us via specific FIFA routing per matches via systems to get them there and back the most effective and best way possible.
- 20:57not overlooking that as I said I'll go back to just to ground the discussion the 2.5 million
- 21:05core customers we have removed during the day so there'll be a primary route to the stadiums
- 21:11and then we have a secondary route because we'll have the flexibility within the system to allow
- 21:18everyone to get to work and come home as well so all of those little small incremental elements
- 21:25will contribute towards the customer experience
- 21:29enhancing the city and the World Cup at the same time.
- 21:32Just on wayfinding, for example,
- 21:34one of the things that the board we've been sort of pushing
- 21:36is integrated wayfinding for the entire transit system in the region.
- 21:40So that would be all the local, the municipal services plus go.
- 21:46Are you going to have integrated wayfinding?
- 21:49Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 21:49I often worry that wayfinding is more exciting to transit CEOs
- 21:53than anybody else in the room,
- 21:54But the answer is yes.
- 21:55Go to Mount Dentist Station and observe a digital display that for the first time shows you the schedule not only of TTC vehicles, but also of vehicle vehicles.
- 22:05Expect more of that.
- 22:06But if I could go back to excitement and enthusiasm, you should have every expectation of train wraps and activations on trains and enthusiasm at various station locations that go around this incredible event.
- 22:19I can't miss the opportunity to say that one of the things we are also really fixated on is ensuring the safety of our neighbors and patrons.
- 22:30So, yes, at Union Station, consistent with what you've been seeing over the past couple of weeks, there will be more of a security presence at that station.
- 22:39And by the way, I think that that's something that the World Cup prompts to a certain extent, but is as amongst the things that probably then never goes away in respect to standard operating procedures.
- 22:50And again, just a shout out to partners who aren't on the stage with us, but deserve to be.
- 22:55To the Chief and Toronto Police Services, just a fantastic partnership to think about union as a node and exhibition as a node and how we're going to make sure that people are safe.
- 23:06That more than anything.
- 23:08I think the city and its amenities speak for themselves.
- 23:11You just put people in this town and they love it.
- 23:14It doesn't matter if they're an athlete or a tourist or a longtime resident.
- 23:18But making sure that people know that this is a safe location to come to is something that's really on our mind.
- 23:23Terrific.
- 23:23We've run out of time, but I have one last question that I think employers in the room will be interested in,
- 23:28which is what's your advice to employers in the downtown core?
- 23:32should I mean is your best advice to have folks work from home on match days for example listen
- 23:40attentively to what the Toronto Regional Board of Trade tells you to do well but we're going to take
- 23:44our advice from you in this instance so so far we're giving all the flex we're giving you the
- 23:51opportunity and everyone here today the flexibility flexibility to make that decision so the options
- 23:58is there. It's not for
- 24:00me, and Michael can speak,
- 24:02it's not for me to say yes or no.
- 24:05We've demonstrated the
- 24:06capacity, we've demonstrated
- 24:08the resilience, we've demonstrated
- 24:11how we went about it
- 24:12and the rigour in terms of reliability,
- 24:15customer experience. I think
- 24:17then the decision is
- 24:18the options are there
- 24:20for you to decide. I have to praise your
- 24:22political acuity, so the terrific answer.
- 24:25I suppose
- 24:26I would say, you know,
- 24:28to amplify that point,
- 24:30the commitment that we want to make
- 24:32is that anybody who chooses
- 24:33to come to the office on a match day
- 24:36is also receiving excellent service.
- 24:38And that's a part of why
- 24:40we're throwing as much service at this
- 24:42as we are, right?
- 24:44But the message that I would say
- 24:46is we will try to,
- 24:47through the board,
- 24:48which has been fantastic,
- 24:49provide more information
- 24:50about the dynamic elements of this.
- 24:52Like, that's the one thing
- 24:53that I hope everybody takes out of this room.
- 24:55We will change a little bit
- 24:57what our plans are after Match Day 1 happens.
- 25:00For sure we will.
- 25:02100% we will.
- 25:04And by the way, when Canada wins
- 25:07and we figure out that people stay downtown
- 25:11for four more hours celebrating,
- 25:13that'll change things too.
- 25:14So we've done as much planning as we can.
- 25:17No battle plan, as they say, survives first contact.
- 25:20So then a big communicationist effort after that, right?
- 25:22Because the dynamic takes hold.
- 25:25Thank you very much.
- 25:27Pleasure.
- 25:27Nadineke and Michael, thank you.
- 25:28Terrific conversation.
- 25:30Thank you.
- 25:31Thank you, Michael.
- 25:34Thanks for listening to Toronto Talks,
- 25:36conversations with the leaders shaping the region's economy.
- 25:40Follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
- 26:11ご視聴ありがとうございました