Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 129 - Ian Underwood: A New Governance Model for the 21st Century
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities Podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 129 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:36Well, good morning, good afternoon or good evening, wherever you are in the world.
- 0:43And this is your weekly reminder that countrywide power outages are a thing and they're something that's worth contemplating.
- 0:53you may have seen and i mentioned it on last week's show that spain and portugal experienced
- 0:59major power outages recently for me it was a couple of days ago i'm recording this in advance
- 1:05i quote houses offices trains traffic lights and even madrid open tennis tournament were all hit
- 1:12causing chaos for millions of people now you may wonder why this happened i did and the two answers
- 1:21that most easily come to mind are incompetency and of course conspiracy but to be honest either
- 1:28way it doesn't matter which one it was it matters that it happened and if you are the kind of person
- 1:35that would like to insulate yourself from these kinds of problems in life then I would like to
- 1:42introduce you to Veritas Village our most excellent sponsor for this episode. Now Veritas
- 1:51Village are building off-grid energy self-sufficient luxury homes in their freedom-oriented
- 1:58developments. Their very latest project is in Panama which is in the process of being built
- 2:05and you can own a property there a perfect climate for growing your own food too if that's your kind
- 2:12of thing and if that's the kind of lifestyle you want to live if not well every house comes with
- 2:17its own solar or solar and wind system included and their goal is to keep you energy independent
- 2:26whilst maintaining a modern luxury lifestyle which is now a reality you'll be pleased to hear
- 2:33get in touch with them to see working models of their setups and learn how you could own a piece
- 2:39of this project and of course the peace of mind that comes along with owning it www.ecovillages.life
- 2:47forward slash podcast please use that link so they know that we sent you or just jump into the show
- 2:54notes and click on the link in there back to today's show and it's a fascinating one ian underwood
- 3:03My guest has been, well, a planetary scientist, an artificial intelligence researcher for NASA,
- 3:12the director of the renowned Ask Dr. Maths service, the co-founder of Bardo Farm and
- 3:20Shaolin Rifleworks, and a popular speaker at Liberty-related events.
- 3:27he's also written 20 books on liberty related subjects i'll give you some of the names to give
- 3:35you an idea of the way he thinks barefoot learning political conversation in three jokes the lie
- 3:41behind licensing and the libertarian case for public schools now we had a very long and interesting
- 3:51conversations a two-hour one and very i found it pretty hard to sum up what we spoke about so i'm
- 3:57actually quite interested to hear what the AI made of this conversation. We did cover quite a
- 4:03bit of ground. Okay, let's see. Timothy Allen engages in a thought-provoking discussion.
- 4:08Blimey AI, you always say that. Just think up something new. Maybe I should instruct it too.
- 4:13With Ian exploring the multifaceted relationship between individual rights, government authority,
- 4:20and societal norms. The conversation begins with a dive into the nuances of gun ownership across
- 4:27cultures, particularly contrasting American perspectives with European views on self-defense
- 4:34and government power. Ian shares his insights on the philosophical underpinnings of governance,
- 4:40emphasizing the importance of consent and individual rights. The dialogue evolves into
- 4:46a broader examination of how technology reshapes our understanding of governance,
- 4:52community interactions and the potential for new models of societal organisation. As they navigate
- 5:00topics such as the role of education in shaping responsible citizens, the implications of social
- 5:05credit systems and the evolving landscape of political discourse, the conversation challenges
- 5:11listeners to reconsider the foundations of their beliefs about freedom, responsibility
- 5:16and the purpose of government. Now that's actually pretty good for once. AI, well done.
- 5:24It was quite a mind-blowing conversation for me actually because Ian introduced me to
- 5:29a new model of governance that he has come up with himself. The AI didn't really pick up on it
- 5:38too much there but listen out for the part where Ian lays out his new and phenomenally interesting
- 5:45model of governance a sort of version of extreme personal responsibility that uses 21st century
- 5:52technology to create what looks like an extremely equitable system for all. Ian's a really interesting
- 5:59bloke I have to say and I love conversations like this. I was genuinely impressed with this idea
- 6:05and as far as we know we discussed it it's actually a new idea if you don't think so I'd
- 6:10love to hear from you because I've always thought there's no new ideas in the world these days but
- 6:16I'd love to talk about it more with somebody else anyway I very much hope to make another trip
- 6:21back to Ian and his wife's 300 acre off-grid homestead in New Hampshire and record another
- 6:28interview sometime in the meantime many thanks Ian and enjoy this one folks it's a good one as
- 6:35I said last week there will be no Bitcoin strategic reserve and NOSTA comments this week since I'm
- 6:42recording this intro in advance again and we'll be away speaking in Morocco at the Plumia Connect
- 6:50Summit so I'll be bringing back the comments next week along with some very new and obviously
- 6:57stimulating conversations from my trip see you soon and always remember to enjoy these conversations
- 7:02the way they are intended by myself you guessed it just sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with
- 7:11ian underwood
- 7:13that's pretty much it you don't need a permit for an air rifle but you do for a shotgun
- 7:31and there's quite strict rules about it.
- 7:34You have to keep it in a special type of cupboards,
- 7:41a metal cupboard, and you're not allowed to keep the ammo there.
- 7:44You have to keep that somewhere else.
- 7:45And can they come and inspect anytime they want?
- 7:48Probably.
- 7:48I don't know because I only have an air rifle.
- 7:51But they're, yeah, I mean, they're not.
- 7:55It's very difficult to kill someone with an air rifle,
- 7:58But you would never do anything other than shoot small animals, really.
- 8:02I mean, and the American view on it, depending on who you're talking to, it's not necessarily about self-defense, right?
- 8:09It's about defending yourself from your government.
- 8:12I know.
- 8:13Yeah, that is a common misconception amongst Europeans.
- 8:19I've talked a lot about that on this podcast.
- 8:23And that was a big lesson for me, actually.
- 8:27Yeah.
- 8:27Like we aren't forced in Europe to have the debate about a number of things that you do.
- 8:34Guns is one of them.
- 8:35Abortion.
- 8:35Things like this.
- 8:36We just don't have it forced on us.
- 8:38So we don't have to choose a side.
- 8:40But I do enjoy the process of deciding.
- 8:46And with both of those, both guns and abortion, I can see the value of both arguments.
- 8:52and my conclusion is with abortion or no my conclusion with the guns for example is
- 8:59that yes protecting yourself from your government is phenomenal um
- 9:05the and being able to defend yourself of course but if i was given a choice between a very
- 9:15a culture with a huge amount of guns or a culture with no guns currently i'd still go for the no
- 9:22guns one because there's almost no gun crime at all like and there's no accidental deaths by guns
- 9:28etc etc but obviously yeah you would probably look back over us and go well look your government's
- 9:34treating you like pieces of shit and if you had guns you wouldn't be so it's very hard to say
- 9:39because yeah we're all we're living in different scenarios if i was living here i'm almost certain
- 9:44i would own a load of guns and i would be the same as that but there's the option's not there
- 9:50I mean, it's a different culture, certainly.
- 9:53But also, you don't get the choice of a society with no guns because you can make them in your garage.
- 10:01They're not complicated machinery.
- 10:04You can spend thousands of dollars and get a very nice, precise one.
- 10:08But something that will just shoot at this distance and protect you or hurt somebody, it's a tube.
- 10:15It's a metal tube, you know?
- 10:17Right.
- 10:17What about the ammunition, though?
- 10:19I reload my own ammunition.
- 10:21And you can have black powder.
- 10:23You can literally, if you want to, make black powder at home.
- 10:27You can melt lead into balls.
- 10:29You could use whatever technology they had in, say, 1830, you know, out in the western United States.
- 10:35You could do all that yourself, you know, and you can make the parts on any kind of machinery.
- 10:40If you've got a mill and you've got a lathe, you can make a gun.
- 10:44So it's not, it's sort of like saying, let's have a society without arithmetic.
- 10:49You can't because somebody is going to figure it out and then you can do it.
- 10:53So that's sort of the discussion that you have a lot in America is people say, yes, we should have no guns.
- 10:59And it's like, you can't have no guns.
- 11:01You can, because people who want guns are always going to have them.
- 11:04So the question is only whether everybody else can have them.
- 11:06The people who won't do the damage, the people who won't harm anybody, you can take them away from them.
- 11:12because if they're law-abiding, they'll let you and they'll say,
- 11:15well, I guess I have to give up my guns.
- 11:16But the people who really need to use guns as tools are always going to have them.
- 11:20I think that was my conclusion is that the arms race in guns has started
- 11:27and it can't be stopped.
- 11:29So in the U.S., you can't backtrack.
- 11:32So you have to look at where you are and then make a decision based on that.
- 11:35And the decision has to be, if you want to be fair, if you want to be free,
- 11:39is it's up to everyone to do what they want to do right yes but it's almost like we didn't sorry
- 11:45about it it's almost like we didn't really we haven't gone down that route yet and as a result
- 11:51nobody thinks about it no one thinks about guns even it's it's very rare to see a policeman with
- 11:57a gun no no local policeman would would have a gun you have specialist gun units that okay that
- 12:04operate in cities i thought that had changed when i was a kid i knew that you know the london
- 12:08bobbies would just have a nightstick and that was it but i thought that changed and you now see
- 12:13them on street corners in in cities yeah in the middle of westminster where the politicians are
- 12:21and right and they're not handguns and i don't think they're whatever automatic i don't know
- 12:26what they are yeah but um no it's it's it really doesn't exist the whole culture of it and right
- 12:32I think most people would say that's good.
- 12:36And because they would look at a place like America and say,
- 12:39you've had,
- 12:40you have a lot more deaths from due to guns than we do.
- 12:44And you know that because there's mistake,
- 12:48accidental deaths that if the gun wasn't there would happen.
- 12:52And, but the truth is the answer is it doesn't matter because the arms race has begun and,
- 12:58and it can't stop because if you try and stop it,
- 13:01then you basically let only a certain number of people have guns
- 13:06and they're either criminals or the government.
- 13:09Right.
- 13:10Because everyone else, if you're law abiding, is going to give it up.
- 13:13Right. Yeah.
- 13:14And so that's exactly the why.
- 13:16I mean, people who are for gun ownership will try to bring that argument up
- 13:22as much as they can, that this is not about hunting.
- 13:24It's not about the guy who's trying to rob you.
- 13:28It's about your government saying,
- 13:29we're going to start putting people in jail for saying the wrong things or we're going to start
- 13:33making people you know take this injection or that injection or get this medical procedure
- 13:37or we're going to start saying you can't raise certain animals and at a certain point you just
- 13:42say well you can try you know here's a question then because i i've had this question with a
- 13:49number of people what is the actual reality of somebody you know um combating their government
- 14:00with a weapon like in real in real life because i've when i think it through i think
- 14:06it's going to be very difficult say say right you know the government says right you're not
- 14:11allowed to have i don't know something in your garden here and it really pisses you off and
- 14:16they come around to take it away and you and they're like no i'm gonna i'm gonna confront this
- 14:20at that point it's you and it's them and they're more powerful than you right right so what what's
- 14:27the reality of something like that actually happening like say they start creating femur
- 14:31camps and they start putting dissident minds in camps and stuff like that okay so there there's i
- 14:38have an anecdote and i have a historical thing from just not too recent not too far in the in
- 14:44the past where uh the bureau of land management was trying to take kick ranchers off of land that
- 14:51they'd been using for you know decades and some government agents showed up and said we're gonna
- 14:58kick all your cattle off and kick you off and they brought 100 friends with ars and the government
- 15:03backed down they're just like we can't win this this is uh what's the name of the guy i want to
- 15:10say brody but um just look up bureau land management standoff and you'll find it um so that was an
- 15:20example right yeah go into that a little bit so they the the federal government was it or the
- 15:26federal government backed down from a bunch of guys with guns absolutely some of those guys ended
- 15:31up going to jail but then getting i think the guy who led it got released on it because this trial
- 15:38wasn't conducted properly. We know there's a guy here, I think his name's Jerry Loomis,
- 15:44and he took a plea deal. And so when all the other guys got off, he was stuck in jail.
- 15:48But the government just, they backed down because it's like, well, there's 20 of us,
- 15:53and there's 100 of you, and what are we going to do?
- 15:55And what about the law itself that elicited this? Did that get backtracked?
- 15:59It was, it was, the whole thing was, it wasn't clear what the law was and what their rights were.
- 16:05but they're like, we've been here. Our fathers were here. Our grandfathers were here. We've been
- 16:08grazing this land. There's no reason for the federal government to own in the first place,
- 16:12which was a different issue, but you can't just come and kick us off. So, that's one example.
- 16:18There's a much older historical example, which is Athens, Tennessee, I believe, where there was
- 16:24a lot of local corruption, and they were rigging elections, and a bunch of guys had just come back
- 16:30from the war and they were all armed and they drove that government out of town. So it does
- 16:36happen. The anecdote that I have is, so in America, when you buy more than one gun at a time,
- 16:44there's a special form. The ATF requires the gun dealer to fill out and send to the chief of police,
- 16:50the local chief of police. And we happened to be talking to our local chief of police about this
- 16:55one day. And we said, so what do you do with those forms? He said, I shred them. And we're like,
- 16:59why do you do that? He's like, I don't want to know what anybody has. Because if they ever give
- 17:05me the order to go around and confiscate people's guns, I'm going to resign because I might get them
- 17:10from the first house. And I could get lucky and get them from the second house. But by the time I
- 17:14get to the third house, I'm toast. Right? So, part of it is, it's like a mutually assured destruction,
- 17:23right? Nobody wins if you actually use nuclear weapons. But the thing is to have a credible
- 17:28threat and so the purpose of having an armed citizenry is not it's to not have those fights
- 17:34right it's to make those fights so costly for the government that they will always be looking for
- 17:41some means other than direct force to try to push you around it's the the meme is true the european
- 17:48mind cannot comprehend that it's really interesting because and i think if you if you go into it it
- 17:55must have something to do with your literally your dna and your your your your amendments and
- 18:01your bills that allow you know that your um just the historical nature of the american person you
- 18:11know it is and we're there is a lot of europe envy in america where we look oh they're they're
- 18:17so civilized and so wonderful and we should be more like them and then there's you know the other
- 18:21part saying, no, no, no, we're different and we want to be different. So, one of the books that
- 18:26I have is called Politics and Three Jokes. And there are three jokes that lead to three questions.
- 18:32So, just as an experiment, I'd like to try this. So, my contention in the book is if you're going
- 18:38to get into a serious political discussion with somebody where you're actually trying to solve
- 18:42some problem, there are three questions that you should compare answers on. So, the first question
- 18:48is what's the purpose of government so as a an englishman or a european what would you say it is
- 18:53well i wouldn't say as an englishman necessarily necessarily the purpose of government well i i i
- 19:00know the theories whether or not i really understand whether this is correct or not
- 19:04i mean i would say it's the smallest thing it could be and probably it depends how big your
- 19:10country is if but if your country is too large um then because i think government should be you know
- 19:19local as local as possible but if you're talking about like a an overall government i would say
- 19:24it's probably protecting the kind of perimeter of your place like and protecting the rights of
- 19:30your property so your ownership of things however i would still want that to be done
- 19:37on a smaller level than say in the US.
- 19:40I think the federal government is like,
- 19:43it's too big an area of land to be in charge of, I think.
- 19:47Okay, but those are all mechanisms
- 19:49and how big a government should be.
- 19:51I'm just saying, let's say you didn't have a government
- 19:54and you're suddenly thinking, hey, we need to have one.
- 19:56Why?
- 19:57Why do you have a government?
- 19:58What job is it supposed to do?
- 20:02And so I'll just give you the answer.
- 20:04No, no, no, don't tell me.
- 20:05I want to give you an answer.
- 20:06So the point here is that there are lots of different answers.
- 20:09There is no right answer.
- 20:11But I want to think it through so I can hear, because I want to hear your response to what I say.
- 20:17So we've got no, I mean, right at the moment, we don't have a government.
- 20:21Let's face it.
- 20:22Yeah, we're going to form a government.
- 20:23Why are we going to do that?
- 20:24But we're literally living as, we're anarchists right now, you and me.
- 20:28There's no one telling us what to do.
- 20:29We're sitting here.
- 20:31We don really need one by the looks of it Not in your property and what you doing here and your neighbors and but if we go out far enough there may be a threat from the outside and if your
- 20:44country's large enough if that threat's down you know 700 miles away it may not be of concern to
- 20:51you but in the future it might so you might appreciate someone mind you they'll probably
- 20:58sort it out down there won't they i don't know really so what so what are they doing for me right
- 21:02yeah exactly i don't know so the funny thing is you ask people and there are a lot some people say
- 21:07you know and you'll hear politicians say this the the job of the government is to protect people
- 21:11to protect people's lives or to protect their property you'll hear taught in schools i've heard
- 21:16kids tell me oh the purpose of government is to do things for people that they can't do for
- 21:20themselves or the the purpose is to make things fair or to make things equitable or to keep people
- 21:25happy or whatever. So, I'm just saying there are lots of answers and none of those are specifically
- 21:30wrong. But say I agree with Thomas Jefferson that the point of government is to protect your rights
- 21:36or I agree with Frederick Bastiat that government is nothing more than organized self-defense.
- 21:42If I start from that answer and you start from an answer about we're here to protect people
- 21:48or we're here to do something or you know redistribute wealth or whatever we're really
- 21:55not going to agree on what counts as a valid solution right i think the way my thought process
- 22:00works if i analyze it now is that i always start with myself what can i do and as it gets larger
- 22:09and larger as an issue i ask myself can i do it with my neighbors the people i know as soon as it
- 22:15gets to the point where i need to if i need to include people that have no knowledge of me that's
- 22:22probably where the point that where the government might exist but um in all honesty i could live in
- 22:28like where your guys live and i could live here and never have contact with the government my
- 22:32whole life sure yes you know if i really wanted to so i really don't you know i mean you could but
- 22:37there is a government and it is doing things for you that you don't really notice like here here's
- 22:42one of the things that you would like to have in a civilized place. I should be able to drive away
- 22:47from my house for the day or two days or a week and come back and all my shit will still be here.
- 22:55That's what I want. And that's one of the things that government is in some sort of unorganized,
- 23:00inchoate, not well understood way providing for me. Now, whether you call that protecting my
- 23:05property or protecting my rights, that's a discussion that needs to be had. But the thing
- 23:09is i am agreeing you know that that you have rights and i will not transgress your rights and
- 23:16i have rights and you won't transgress mine and the government is just there that if one of us
- 23:20steps out of line you have a way in an organized way to come in and do something about it so that
- 23:25it is just one way but i'm saying it's just one answer but do you think that in that particular
- 23:30instance is it better to have the government mean intermediate or the people that live around here
- 23:36Like, wouldn't you rather deal with them direct?
- 23:38Well, the people are the government in that case, right?
- 23:41They are.
- 23:42We agree that we have a mutual protection society.
- 23:45So it looks more like NATO than like the English government or the American government where NATO just says, look, you're France, I'm Germany.
- 23:54You be France.
- 23:55I'll be Germany.
- 23:56I'm not going to tell you what to do.
- 23:58You're not going to tell me what to do.
- 23:59But if somebody attacks you, I'll help.
- 24:00And if somebody attacks me, you'll help.
- 24:02So in that sense, Germany and France are protecting each other's sort of right to exist and to be who they are and to live the way they want.
- 24:11They're not imposing any values on it.
- 24:14They're just saying, you have certain rights as a country.
- 24:17We have certain rights as a country.
- 24:18If somebody from outside tries to disturb that, we will help each other.
- 24:23And if your government is a government that just protects rights, that's about it.
- 24:27It is a very small government.
- 24:29And all it's doing is saying, if people attack each other, we will make it easy for the other people who would not like to be attacked to protect each other.
- 24:40That's it.
- 24:41So that is, again, that's one version.
- 24:43The point is, if you think that government is about redistributing wealth or making things fair, then like any question that we think about medical care, gun control, education, we're just, we might as well not even talk, right?
- 24:56So the second question then is from where does government get its legitimate power?
- 25:02Well, where does it get its power?
- 25:04Where does it get its power?
- 25:05We allow them, we say, we will allow you to intermediate between us.
- 25:11So when you say we, what do you mean we?
- 25:13Well, me.
- 25:14And you and me.
- 25:15And if we disagree, then what?
- 25:18Well, then you'll be fighting the government and I won't.
- 25:21Or you'll be fighting the government and I won't, or we'll both be fighting the government
- 25:25if we're talking about thousands of people, and the government will take action,
- 25:30what gives it the power to take action?
- 25:33Well, it's a kind of an agreed abstract force, like I say.
- 25:40And if the more, and you know, I'm not a fan of democracy,
- 25:44but in the sense that if enough people agree that this abstract force exists
- 25:49and they can convince other people, then it kind of does.
- 25:52So that's the exact issue then for, in some senses, if enough people agree, okay?
- 26:00So some people will say the source of government power is majority rule.
- 26:06If enough people vote, then it gets to do this.
- 26:08Now, here's an interesting thing.
- 26:10If that's actually true, if majority rule is the source of the power and not just a mechanism for exercising power, then there's no such thing as rights, right?
- 26:20You cannot talk about the right to say no in a situation where enough people can do anything.
- 26:29So, that leads you to a contradiction right away.
- 26:32And so, people who think, oh, well, majority rule, blah, blah, blah, that's how we do things, and I have rights.
- 26:37It's like that's an immovable object and an irresistible force in the same universe.
- 26:41They can't exist.
- 26:42So, you have to make that choice.
- 26:45You have rights, or majority rule is a source of whatever.
- 26:48So, again, I would go back to Jefferson in the Declaration of Independence where he just says, governments get their legitimate power from the consent of the governed.
- 26:58And then people will say, oh, well, consent is majority rule.
- 27:00And then you say, well, here's an interesting thing.
- 27:02Go look at our federal constitution.
- 27:05Sorry, you don't have one.
- 27:06But we have a federal constitution.
- 27:08It has an Article 5 which says, here's how to amend the constitution.
- 27:11If it turns out that we've said the wrong thing or done the wrong thing, you need to do something, here are the steps that you go through.
- 27:16And then it says at the end, except whatever you do, you cannot deprive any state of equal suffrage in the Senate, equal representation in the Senate without its consent.
- 27:29So, 49 states say Hawaii only needs one senator.
- 27:33You know what?
- 27:34Hawaii can say, bite me.
- 27:36That's consent.
- 27:37That's not majority rule.
- 27:38So, you can't make a serious argument that anybody who set up the system confused majority rule of consent.
- 27:45They clearly knew the difference. So, again, if people think, well, you know, where you get
- 27:51government from is majority rule or just whoever is the strongest or whoever's the smartest,
- 27:57there's lots of ways to answer that. And you look around the world, right? In some countries,
- 28:02we get our power from God. In some countries, well, we have a king who got his power from God.
- 28:08In some countries, it's just whoever is the baddest dude is the guy, right?
- 28:14Those are all answers, right?
- 28:18But the American answer, as I think of it, is government operates from consent.
- 28:23So, if I believe that government protects rights and operates from consent, and you think something else,
- 28:29then our chances of deciding how should we have socialized medicine, or how should we run public schools,
- 28:36or who should be able to have what kinds of guns where,
- 28:41we're just not even having the same conversation, right?
- 28:44And then the third question is, when is it okay to violate a principle?
- 28:47Can you say there's absolute freedom of speech unless somebody's feelings are going to be hurt
- 28:53or unless it might hurt us in a war effort or unless, unless, unless?
- 28:58Or do you just say, look, you can say whatever the hell you want?
- 29:01Well, I am that.
- 29:03I don't think if I believe in freedom of speech therefore I believe you should be able to say
- 29:07anything you want and you can I mean you can I can say anything I want right now right uh I believe
- 29:12actually there are people in England right now who are in prison yeah but what I mean is but I still
- 29:17can like I still can I could I could say anything I want right now I might have to deal with the
- 29:23consequences obviously but um yeah the the but in reality I appreciate that I'll probably choose not
- 29:32to say certain things just because it causes hassle that i don't need or that you know you know
- 29:38that would be my response but yeah i i'm an absolutist in that but that's in your personal
- 29:43life as opposed to a bunch of other people getting together and saying that you can't say this you
- 29:47can't say this you can't say that or you must say this you must use these pronouns you must say this
- 29:51oath every day whatever that so these are the three questions though right what what do we have
- 29:57government for in the first place where does it get its power and if you stated something as a
- 30:03principle when is it okay to ignore that and if you don't agree on those then you're going nowhere
- 30:10right and i think this is one of the things that americans many americans would have very different
- 30:16answers than many europeans and that's sort of like they can't get their head around this idea
- 30:20they're like why would i want to fight my government my government's me and it's us all together and
- 30:24oh that's it's i think that's it i think that you've just hit it there that we do see our we're
- 30:31we we don't have the historical dna telling us that it's them and us we we think of the government
- 30:40as being people that help us to yeah you know but here it's much more that you were outlaws in a way
- 30:47you there was you had the freedom and then it was taken away by government rather than the other way
- 30:52around weird you know yeah kind of i mean it's it's it's maybe less about i mean to me it may
- 30:59have more to do with the fact that like there wasn't in america and then suddenly there was
- 31:03and like feeling in england it's like try to think of a time before there was an england it's just
- 31:09it's a weird concept you know or if you're in france or jordan it's like when when was there
- 31:14never this but this thing this america it it didn't exist and then it was created on purpose
- 31:21it was designed in a way that other countries were not they just grew organically and we were like
- 31:29okay screw that stuff we're not going to do any of this where you know and here's our bill of rights
- 31:33all the things that we hated that england did to us we're not going to do them to ourselves
- 31:38and we're going to have this structure and here are the limits and and they wrote all this down
- 31:42we don't follow it but that's the design right so i think that where gun control is concerned or
- 31:51even things like, you know, socialized medicine or education. It's like, so I look at, and this is
- 31:57a sort of a meme, I think that's the right word, but an idea I'm trying to plant in people's heads
- 32:01all the time is, there are two, I think, primary tools that you use to resist a government that's
- 32:10trying to do too much. The first one is arms, and the second one's education. And so, I look at arms
- 32:16And the American idea is like, hands off.
- 32:20We have a Second Amendment, and you are not allowed to tell us what guns we can have, where we can take them, what we can do with them.
- 32:27I mean, we obviously can't commit crimes with them.
- 32:30But beyond that, you just don't – you don't get to tell us what we can have any more than China could tell you what to have, right?
- 32:37We might have to fight you someday, and you don't get to tell us.
- 32:40So that, to me, I look at education exactly the same way.
- 32:43It's like for all the reasons that the government should not be involved in guns, government should not be involved in education, right?
- 32:51I've got a t-shirt over here that I just had made for a friend, which it's got a picture of Linus from the comics for Peanuts.
- 32:59And he's talking to – he's in school and talking to somebody behind him and says, nobody will give you the education you need to overthrow them, which I think sums it up perfectly, right?
- 33:11The government would never give you the guns that you would need to remove it from power.
- 33:16The government is never going to give you the education that you would need to remove
- 33:21it from power or to know that you should remove it from power.
- 33:25So, to me, the idea that government should be involved in either of those things or in
- 33:31religion, right?
- 33:32It's just, there are just certain areas where there just should be no government involvement
- 33:37and education to me is one of them.
- 33:40So that drives my thinking about education in large part, right?
- 33:44Sometimes I'm thinking about, okay, given that everybody's going to ignore that and we're going to have something anyways, here are better and worse ways to do it.
- 33:51But to me, guns and education, I mean, guns and education.
- 33:57I've got a good title for the podcast anyway.
- 34:00That will get a few people watching.
- 34:02Yeah.
- 34:02Guns and education.
- 34:04So, like, what do you think?
- 34:06Go on.
- 34:06What is your answer to those?
- 34:08to those ones i like jeffersons i really if if i could just get rid of the government we have and
- 34:15say i'm going to take one sentence from the declaration of independence that men form
- 34:20governments to protect their rights and those governments derive their legitimate powers
- 34:24from the consent of the people i would start with that and say if you take that sentence seriously
- 34:31it doesn't matter whether you have a congress or a dictator or whether you have a direct democracy
- 34:36or whatever, as long as you don't do anything that isn't directly protecting rights, and
- 34:41as long as you don't take away people's consent, I don't give a crap how you do the mechanics
- 34:47of it.
- 34:48On the other hand, if we say, oh, we have this very nice constitutional republic, blah, blah,
- 34:53blah.
- 34:53But if the representatives in that republic don't acknowledge that there are any limits
- 34:58to what they do, then that's not an improvement over anything.
- 35:01It's not an improvement over a king.
- 35:02It's not an improvement over a dictator.
- 35:03the key idea is are there limits and what are those limits so that you know i'm just wondering
- 35:11where the where the anarchists fit into this or or more to the point people have a real issue in
- 35:17the a lot of circles are revolving with the social contract and in a way you're kind of describing
- 35:22there is still a social contract are you saying that there's there's limits to how free you can be
- 35:27like actually naturally you know so so again i think nato is an instructive thing you don't have
- 35:34a country doesn't have to join nato right it could just say you know what screw you guys we're going
- 35:39our own way on the other hand if suddenly they get invaded they can't go to nato and say hey
- 35:45help us because you just told us you didn't need our help so in that sense and that's why like
- 35:52Bastiat very clearly just said, properly done, government is nothing more than organized
- 35:58self-defense.
- 35:59I have the right to defend myself.
- 36:01I will do a better job of defending myself if I can count on other people to help me.
- 36:06And to make that happen, they have to count on me to help them.
- 36:10And that is the extent of the social contract in that sense.
- 36:14It's just mutual self-defense.
- 36:15And beyond that, I don't get to tell you what to think.
- 36:18I don't get to tell you what to say.
- 36:19I don't get to tell you what to eat or drink or smoke or inject.
- 36:22I don't get to tell you how you get sex.
- 36:26I don't get to tell you anything except if you get attacked, I'll help.
- 36:30If I get attacked, you'll help.
- 36:31What makes me think, though, is that countries and governments are formed from individuals.
- 36:38And the problem is that when individuals are allowed to be individuals, they kind of group together in sort of little teams, don't they?
- 36:47And the government are the same.
- 36:49The government's going to have a team, isn't it?
- 36:51But I would actually, I wouldn't really accept that because I think people think of themselves in America.
- 36:58I think this is true.
- 36:59And this is one of the fundamental questions.
- 37:01Does society exist for the benefit of individuals or do individuals exist for the benefit of society?
- 37:08And if you go someplace like communist China and you look at their constitution, they are a constitutional republic too.
- 37:14it actually says right there it's like we're mostly interested in the harmony of the whole
- 37:20and their philosophy is sort of like you're like a cell on a body and if we got to get rid of you
- 37:25because you're causing trouble well that's just too bad you have no rights in that sense right
- 37:31you're you're not important the whole thing is important whereas in America you use things like
- 37:38national security and, you know, defense to try to make people think of themselves that way. But
- 37:45there's a great author named Richard Mitchell, who wrote a wonderful book called The Gift of Fire,
- 37:52and one of the chapters in it is called The Land of We All. And the whole chapter is about the
- 37:57trouble you get into when you misuse the word we. Like we say, hey, we went to the moon. It's like,
- 38:03you know what? I didn't. I had nothing to do with that. Or we gave up slavery. It's like,
- 38:08I never gave up slavery. I never even had the choice of giving up slavery, right? We did this,
- 38:13we will stand with Israel, we will do, you know, we will fight the, we will stand with Ukraine,
- 38:19we will, you know, eradicate whatever. That's just not a proper use of the word we unless
- 38:25you literally think of yourself as some smaller part of a larger organism. But if you think of
- 38:33yourself as an individual, then that's just an abuse of English.
- 38:38What about we the people then?
- 38:41It's a bad use of it. You can't have we the people decide to do something except if each
- 38:48of us needs to supply consent, then there is no we the people. There are some groups
- 38:53of people. And this is like my, I'm in the middle of writing something where it's like,
- 38:57I want, but the idea of something like a foreign policy, the more I think about it seems very
- 39:02strange to me, right? And if you go back to George Washington saying, look, we should just
- 39:06have commerce with everybody and not get entangled. And one of the ways to do that is we constantly
- 39:11think we, the people, America, have to have a tariff against Canada or against China, as opposed
- 39:19to just saying, I'm a person, there's a person in France, there's a person in China, I would like to
- 39:26engage in commerce, I should be able to do it. Or if I think that Israel needs to defeat
- 39:32Hamas, I can go there, or I can send them money, or I can send them ammunition, or I can act as an
- 39:38individual, right? And so, the theme of the thing I'm writing, and I'm going to have hats made up,
- 39:44it's going to make America Americans again, right? Individuals who act as individuals and who can
- 39:51deal with individuals, as opposed to making up this fiction, you know? And so, what Mitchell would
- 39:57say is like you take a statement like, we, you know, we must support Ukraine. And it's like,
- 40:04okay, so first of all, let's actually think about what we say, what we mean by we, what we mean is
- 40:09some part of the American people, but we don't even mean that we actually mean
- 40:13some subset of a group of people who have been elected to represent the American people. And
- 40:21then you look at that, and they have been elected because they had certain views,
- 40:25but they disagree with the people who elected them on other views.
- 40:28And by the time you actually say what's going on,
- 40:31you basically say this group of people who have authority
- 40:34without any real source of legitimate power
- 40:37are acting, using the resources of those other people
- 40:41to screw those people over.
- 40:44And when you look at it that way, it's like nobody wants to be part of that.
- 40:47Whereas we stand with Ukraine, that can make your belly purr
- 40:51and you feel good and you're like, yeah, I'm part of something important.
- 40:54Whereas if everybody just had to act as an individual, I think you would have very different outcomes.
- 40:59Isn't that collective, though, a function of the fact that government needs to pay for itself?
- 41:04And really if you track it back hard enough they need a collective Well what are you paying for That the thing If all you paying for is mutual self that not terribly expensive Yeah I know I saying on the way it runs at the moment you know like it a self disaster We in that sense is a marketing technique
- 41:25You say we, and then you feel either good or at the moment bad about it, right? And politics have
- 41:31become more and more divisive here so that people are starting to say, not my president,
- 41:35not my country doing this. I am not a part of that, which I think is actually a good thing,
- 41:40because if I'm not a part of that, then what I am at. And you hope that they'll actually think
- 41:44about that and say, oh, I'm an individual. And oh, well, they're individuals too. So what if we all
- 41:50just interacted as individuals? Okay, that would be a very different thing. But you can't do that
- 41:57as long as you people think the purpose of government is to redistribute wealth, or to
- 42:02make people feel good or to prevent people from feeling bad or whatever however though individuals
- 42:07sooner or later realize that um they're more powerful in groups sure groups end up becoming
- 42:14you know i mean my i don't know what your theory on the evolution of government is in in general but
- 42:20when i thought it through it's almost if you track it back far enough it's like
- 42:25you know some say we we were hunter gatherers we didn't really need a government at that point
- 42:31We became farmers.
- 42:35And then we had assets that needed protecting, basically.
- 42:39Right.
- 42:39And we've got a choice at that point.
- 42:41We either protect them or we pay someone to protect them.
- 42:45So someone comes in, I'll protect them.
- 42:47You go and do the work.
- 42:48I'll protect the assets.
- 42:50You pay me some of the assets.
- 42:51We're all good.
- 42:52And then that's when it starts at that point.
- 42:54And it will always evolve.
- 42:56And there is an organic growth that comes to that, right?
- 42:58And so some people get thought of as protectors and then their children become the leaders of the protectors and it grows in all different kinds of ways.
- 43:06But at a certain point, you also get enough consciousness as individuals and enough reasoning ability as individuals that you can evaluate things and maybe do things that are counterintuitive.
- 43:18So evolution sort of always does the next thing that seems obvious.
- 43:22and the point of reasoning, the point of learning to be a critical thinker, to use a term that you
- 43:28like, is to say, maybe I don't have to do the obvious thing. Maybe I could do the non-obvious
- 43:34thing. And that's science, right? That's technology. Those are the things where we say,
- 43:40well, this will be the easy, obvious thing to do, but what if I just take that off the table
- 43:44and put it over there and I think of what are the other things I might do? And then you can
- 43:49Maybe find a way, if we're smart and lucky, you can find a way to head off what would be that normal splintering into tribes and incessant fighting.
- 43:59And you say, maybe if we agree to a few simple rules, we'll all leave each other alone.
- 44:04And the energy and effort and money and blood that we put into fighting, we could put into making things and growing things and writing things and creating art, right?
- 44:13That sounds like a utopia to me, though.
- 44:15Okay, but you're always aiming for something, right?
- 44:18A man's reach should exceed his grasp, or what's a heaven for, right?
- 44:21You should always have something that you're going for, and in some sense, you can look
- 44:24at the Declaration of Independence as that.
- 44:26This is what we would like to have.
- 44:28Will we be able to get it?
- 44:30Well, here's the Constitution.
- 44:31Yeah, we're apparently not going to get it yet, but maybe later we can, right?
- 44:35So, I don't think the fact that you can't do something immediately argues against it.
- 44:42It's hard.
- 44:43You know?
- 44:44But, okay, I say that the next evolutionary stage of what's going on in the American experiment is more of an individualization.
- 44:58I mean, is that what it takes?
- 45:00Probably on the grand scale as well, secession of states, making them smaller.
- 45:06I mean, I think when I look at it, I see it as a function.
- 45:09The problems are much, much of the problems are a function of the size of this place.
- 45:14that you're trying to govern.
- 45:16And also, I mean, you think,
- 45:18especially when you think about it in terms of Europe,
- 45:21Europe's a similar idea in many ways now
- 45:24because the European Union
- 45:25has got its own little power center here
- 45:28and blah, blah, blah.
- 45:29And it seems very absurd to me
- 45:32when I think there's Romania over there
- 45:34and there's the UK there when we were in the EU.
- 45:37And it's like, should they really be governed
- 45:39by the same border governors?
- 45:41And I think of the US as the same.
- 45:43I know you have more of a national identity, but, you know, people are very different here than the people I know in California, for example.
- 45:53And actually, it's a long way away.
- 45:56It's a really long way away.
- 45:57It is.
- 45:58I mean, my feeling about that is basically you are more willing to help the people that you actually know and like and trust.
- 46:04Okay.
- 46:04And so the farther you try to extend the reach, and I think this is maybe what you're getting at, I don't really care about a lot of people in California.
- 46:11I certainly don't care about a lot of people in Africa or Belgium.
- 46:14I know one family in Belgium that I care about, which sort of leads me to my next point, which is that up to a certain level in time, everything is geographically defined.
- 46:27And that's largely because of the difficulty of travel and communication, right?
- 46:31So you can't – you divide into states and you divide the states into counties and counties into cities because if you're going to make decisions, you can't all just pick up the phone and call.
- 46:40Well, now you can, actually, okay?
- 46:44And so, here's the thing.
- 46:46So, you ever heard this phrase, ontology recapitulates phylogeny?
- 46:52No.
- 46:53I'd love to hear it explained that.
- 46:55Ontology, what's that?
- 46:57Recapitulates.
- 46:58Ontology recapitulates phylogeny.
- 47:01Even if I think of that, I still don't know what it means.
- 47:04I love it because it's very dense and it packs a lot of things.
- 47:07What does the third word even mean, though?
- 47:09It is the – so, what it says is your evolutionary growth, the stages you went through to become a human are reenacted during your growth as an embryo.
- 47:21So, at a certain point, you have gills, for example, when you're an embryo because somewhere in your evolutionary development, you had gills.
- 47:28You have a tail that then goes away.
- 47:29You have, so it's not true, but it's true enough, okay, that you can use it as a guiding principle, sort of as a way to, it's true enough that you can use it to think about.
- 47:41So I have another phrase similar to that, which I like, which is topology obviates geography.
- 47:48okay if i have people who can connect with anyone anywhere then the fact that they live next to each
- 47:56other becomes less and less important to the point of not being important at all okay so here's an
- 48:01example of this so like people in america will say well we have to have these elections we have to
- 48:07have these states and we have to you know have the electoral college and we need to get people
- 48:11into congress so we can get single-payer health european countries can do it so that's europe
- 48:16envy again, right? Well, England does this. And so, how many people are there in England?
- 48:2260-something million.
- 48:24Right. There are more registered Democrats in America than there are in England. So,
- 48:29if registered Democrats- People in England, you mean.
- 48:31Then there are, sorry, yes, then there are people in England. So, if registered Democrats
- 48:36wanted to have a single-payer health system, they could have it tomorrow. And all they'd
- 48:42have to do is give up this whole idea that you have to do the same thing as the guy who
- 48:46lives next to you, right? You just, you give your bank account information to the Democratic Party,
- 48:52and you go to the doctor, and they send the bill to the Democratic Party, and you pay maybe $5,000
- 48:58a year to help everybody, and George Clooney pays $78 million, right? Warren Buffett, all these guys,
- 49:04they're paying more, but that's your idea, right? That the more you have, the more you should pay.
- 49:08All you have to do is leave everybody else the hell out of it, and you can do that if you give
- 49:13up the idea that the way to do things is through geographically based politics. You connect with
- 49:20the people that you and you could do education that way, you could do healthcare that way,
- 49:24you could do all the all the things where the government redistributes money, you could do it
- 49:28that way, you do it directly, topologically in a network, rather than by fighting to bring people
- 49:36along with you who absolutely hate what you're trying to do.
- 49:39well arguably i mean that as a function of the internet that probably will transpire i mean
- 49:46versions of that already do there are new borders being sort of like you know written across the
- 49:54globe based on what's happening on the internet right i mean in our movement the free cities
- 49:58movement it's a very much there's two two ideas behind the evolution of it one is it's bottom up
- 50:05yeah and the other is it's top down that and the a lot of the times the bottom up stuff is uh online
- 50:12manifesting in real life and i'm i'm an anecdotal evidence of that i mean currently almost everyone
- 50:19i know on a day-to-day basis i know through the internet i don't know from my geographical reason
- 50:24place at all but um and the technology is already there to implement that idea i would have thought
- 50:30But I mean, let's think, why wouldn't it? I mean, obviously, the geographical government wouldn't like it to begin with, because it would put their nose out of shame.
- 50:43It could. And yet, like the Democratic Party should be thrilled about this. They can get what they want, right?
- 50:50At a certain point, you hope, and this is I'm trying to get people with these ideas.
- 50:55Thank you for spreading this virus.
- 50:57I'm trying to get people to get the idea that by letting go of something that no longer serves your purpose, you can get the thing you want, right?
- 51:06And the image I have in my mind is you're like trying to swim across a pond and somebody has a, you know, you're wearing a backpack full of rocks.
- 51:14If you just take the backpack off, you can swim.
- 51:18You can go to where you want.
- 51:20Do you know what, though?
- 51:21The Democrats, well, the modern day Democrats might be worried that no one would pay it.
- 51:27Well, and that would be interesting, wouldn't it?
- 51:30And that would be a very, you know.
- 51:31But no, but we have a similar joke in the free cities movement, which is the idea of free cities are that you have a myriad of competing cities, for example.
- 51:44and the joke is that if you had a left-wing city everyone that would go there would be
- 51:51looking for a free handout and there'd be no one to give the handouts so so like you know the eye
- 51:56is a bit similar with this plan it's like maybe there wouldn't be a lot of democrats prepared to
- 52:01stump up the money because you know i don't know it is but the point i'm just making is it was that
- 52:06that the ideas evolve and the technology evolves right and so the technology actually in some sense
- 52:12liberates you to try ideas that you couldn't have tried in 1600 or 1700 or 1900. Now we're free to
- 52:18try those things. And so in that sense, that actually allows you to scale back government
- 52:23in a system, in a sort of gradual way to say each of these functions, like any function where
- 52:29government's taken money from some people and given it to other people, you can do that
- 52:32with smaller groups than everyone. And they are still big groups. And that's the point of like,
- 52:38the democratic party is bigger than the population of several countries
- 52:42individual countries it's a really good idea actually it would
- 52:45it would it would show what the it would it would be a free market
- 52:50and it would actually show the truth of the human
- 52:53experience yeah really it would be really interesting right and not hard to
- 52:58implement at all you just this technology wouldn't be hard you just
- 53:01have to completely change everyone's mind on a lot of stuff exactly and
- 53:04Well, also, if you think about it, the physical monopoly, the mafia, let's call it what it is, they won't like this because they run the physical world based on geography, don't they?
- 53:19Yes.
- 53:20They'll basically lose a lot of money, presumably.
- 53:23Or they'll just find new ways to do things.
- 53:26I have a friend who jokes that the way that the government grows is they look at whatever the mob is doing.
- 53:31Oh, we're running numbers?
- 53:32Let's have the lottery.
- 53:33We're doing this?
- 53:34Oh, we're doing alcohol.
- 53:36Let's sell alcohol in state stores, right?
- 53:38And so you look for the thing that they're doing next.
- 53:42And you go, oh, well, we could just co-opt that and make it a state function.
- 53:46They'll own the platform that.
- 53:48And they'll take a cut probably.
- 53:50Sure.
- 53:51But you hit it on the head, right?
- 53:52You need to change the way people think about what government is, which is why I like those three questions.
- 53:58If your conception of government is that it's not about redistributing wealth, then okay, let's just cut that part out.
- 54:05And we'll do it some other way.
- 54:07And the beauty of it is, it's like I said, the Democratic Party, if they were serious about this, could have single-payer health next month.
- 54:15They could do it.
- 54:16The technology is there.
- 54:17This is not rocket science.
- 54:20This is not curing a disease.
- 54:22This is not like trying to figure out how do we get rid of malaria.
- 54:24This is just, we know how to move money from some people to other people and then to businesses.
- 54:30That's a known quantity.
- 54:31The only thing that's missing is the idea that maybe we don't have to force that on people who don't want it.
- 54:38Or fight to get other people.
- 54:39Or fight to get it, yes.
- 54:40To get people to believe in it, basically.
- 54:42Yeah.
- 54:43So, you know, so those are the…
- 54:45I mean, yeah.
- 54:47Did you invent that idea or is that…
- 54:48As far as I know, I did, yeah.
- 54:50And I wrote two pieces on it.
- 54:52The second one is about, there's a second component of this, which is sort of the moralistic component, that you want to punish vices and sins, right?
- 55:00And there, again, the technology has brought you along.
- 55:03It used to be, well, we pass a law and everybody in this geographical area can't, you know, buy alcohol or pay for sex or whatever.
- 55:10But it's like, well, or smoke pot.
- 55:13But it's like, okay, what if you could, and I got this idea from, I read about, there's, I think Pennsylvania does this.
- 55:19If you live in Pennsylvania, you can put yourself on a list and you say, I don't want to gamble.
- 55:25And any casino that finds you in it can just throw you out and keep your money.
- 55:29So they're punishing you without making gambling illegal, right?
- 55:34It's sort of a distributed punishment system.
- 55:36It's like, okay, if I think, if I'm very conservative and I think I shouldn't commit adultery and I shouldn't take drugs and I shouldn't do this and this and this,
- 55:44I can put on a body camera and I can have people monitoring me 24-7.
- 55:48and everybody else can do those things but i can't what about this though because there will be
- 55:54instances where say we have that system here you'll be you'll be you'll you'll you know you'll
- 56:02be accepting basically a different bunch of rules to your neighbor over there yes but what about when
- 56:06your i your different rules start encroaching on them say it was you can smoke pot here but they
- 56:12can't and the smell of smoke wafts into there so there are already things in place that the people
- 56:20don't fight that much about which are externalities like i can't i can't open a factory
- 56:24next to my neighbor i can't play noise at all days and that there those are already dealt with
- 56:29but in most cases why should that prevent me from sitting in my house and watching a movie
- 56:33with some friends we're all smoking pot and eating cheetos and laughing who gives a crap
- 56:38So, you mean you would have, if everyone agreed on something, it would be universal.
- 56:46And if they didn't, then it would be very specific.
- 56:49So, yeah, okay.
- 56:50I mean, I would just get rid of the first part and say everybody agrees to what they will be punished for.
- 56:55And if you're not on that list, then you don't get punished for it.
- 56:58But what about like criminal law and stuff?
- 57:00So, criminal law, that has more to do with, so this gets into government by consent.
- 57:07because people you say well i'd like to have government by consent people like what would
- 57:10that look like and here's how it looks like to me everybody sits down and you make a list and the
- 57:16looks like this i don't want anyone else to do x to me i don't want them to kill me i don't want
- 57:22them to rape me assault me destroy my property steal my property uh pollute my land right and
- 57:31the funny thing is you do this with groups and you run out of things after like 15 things. You're
- 57:37just like, okay, that's about it. If nobody does those things to me, I'm pretty happy.
- 57:42And so that is government by consent. You essentially are just saying,
- 57:46I don't want anybody to do these to me. So if I do them to somebody else, I consent to be punished.
- 57:52And that's it. And anything that doesn't fit on that framework, like I don't think those two
- 57:57people should be able to trade money for sex. Well, screw you. That's not part of government
- 58:01by consent. Your consent is not needed there, right? Or these people should have to give money
- 58:07to this or not have to give money or educate these kids or do whatever. You've got all the things
- 58:12that you're worried about, right? Well, what if somebody steals from me? What if somebody breaks
- 58:17into my house? What if somebody assaults me? Those are all taken care of through a consent mechanism.
- 58:22And what you're then doing is layering something on top of that to say, but some people want to be
- 58:26punished for things that don't fit in that framework, great, they could hire people to do it.
- 58:31The Republican Party could set up a thing where they have AI monitoring body cams,
- 58:35and if they catch you in a hotel room with somebody who's not your wife, they punish you.
- 58:39If they catch you snorting cocaine or injecting a drug or gambling or whatever,
- 58:44they punish you, but they leave everybody else the hell alone.
- 58:48It's like a digitization of the golden rule, basically, isn't it?
- 58:52It is, yeah. And so that's one of the things when I think about libertarianism,
- 58:56And one of my formulations of it is the Hillel version of the golden rule, right?
- 59:00Which I like better than the standard one, which is do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
- 59:05Because that opens things like, well, I would like people to give me free dental care.
- 59:09It's like, okay.
- 59:11Hillel's version is what's hateful to you, don't do to anybody else.
- 59:17Hateful is a contentious word though, isn't it?
- 59:19And this is what I would say.
- 59:21What you don't want people to do to you, don't do to them.
- 59:23But it's a completely negative formulation.
- 59:26It doesn't allow for anybody forcing anybody to do anything.
- 59:30It's just these are things I don't want to do.
- 59:32I don't want them done to me.
- 59:34Therefore, I won't do them to other people.
- 59:36It's really interesting.
- 59:37So I like that model.
- 59:39You write down everything that you don't want people to do to you,
- 59:44and that forms the basis of governance.
- 59:47Yeah.
- 59:48And it's, yeah.
- 59:50And anything else is like that's up to you.
- 59:52Did you say you've written that and put it in a book?
- 59:53I, those two things, those are in Granite Rock, and I can give you the, they will be in a book called The Proper Use of Political Parties, because you have these giant political parties that could do all this stuff and not drag anybody else along.
- 1:00:06Instead of fighting over temporary control so we can steer the bus this way and then they steer it back the other way, you know, oh, now I'm in office.
- 1:00:15I will repeal.
- 1:00:16I mean, I don't know if you saw this.
- 1:00:17Trump is signing things.
- 1:00:19I'm repealing Joe Biden's repeal of my previous order.
- 1:00:23And it's just like, this is such a…
- 1:00:25Well, it's better than in a lot of countries.
- 1:00:27They just kill the people that could.
- 1:00:30Yeah.
- 1:00:30And so, yes, it's all being done on paper and that's good.
- 1:00:32But the idea is that, yeah, you have these political parties that are just trying to get these small majorities and eke this out so I can have two years of control and try to shove things through against people who hate it and are using every parliamentary and legal procedure to get in my way.
- 1:00:50They're the bag of rocks on my back swimming across the pond.
- 1:00:53What if I just let go of them?
- 1:00:55Just boop.
- 1:00:56That sinks to the bottom and I swim on.
- 1:00:59now i see why you were going on about the individual though because what it takes for that
- 1:01:04to become a reality is to completely switch your perspective on governance you absolutely do has to
- 1:01:13reside totally in you yes but it but it's a really good idea because and i can't even imagine it in
- 1:01:21real life but i just know it's a good idea it's like because um the technology is really simple you
- 1:01:26I mean, to digitize that is a piece of piss, as we would say.
- 1:01:31It's like, you know, here are 20 questions, probably,
- 1:01:35or whatever you think that you might be.
- 1:01:37And now an algorithm just pairs all those up together.
- 1:01:40And every time you interact with someone,
- 1:01:42the only problem is that you have to monitor it And then someone knows all that information which makes me feel a little bit unsettled so these are technical questions but i photography could sort actually cryptography could could actually sort that and it solves like the counterfeiting problem right
- 1:01:58maybe maybe i get a badge and it just says i have not signed up for any vice or sin control well if
- 1:02:04i really did but i temporarily want to do something bad i could put that badge on if it's just a badge
- 1:02:09i mean anybody can have badges made i have badges that were made you know they they're the same
- 1:02:14But the blockchain, right? Gosh, if only we had a technology that you couldn't fake. Oh, we have one. So again, the technology actually makes – I did a thing called the age of consent, which is not what you think.
- 1:02:30But it has to do with through history, you always have to get somebody's consent to act, right?
- 1:02:37And for a while, it's like you have to get the consent of the king.
- 1:02:40And then you have to get consent of the legislature or in Canada, you have to get essentially the consent of your neighbors.
- 1:02:47And at a certain point, you would like to move towards you just need your own consent.
- 1:02:51And the technology at each age has enabled the change, right?
- 1:02:55So when the king has the army, that's how it works.
- 1:03:00But suddenly you get to America and the people have more guns than the king.
- 1:03:05Now they can have a different kind of consent, right?
- 1:03:08Do you know what?
- 1:03:08That, your idea should become a computer game first.
- 1:03:14It would be so easy to do that, like a Sims type game.
- 1:03:18But it would be interesting because I would like to see it modeled.
- 1:03:21I would like to see what would happen.
- 1:03:23Because at the moment, I'm trying to grasp it in its entirety.
- 1:03:26And that's quite difficult because who knows how humans will interact.
- 1:03:30Like human action is a creep.
- 1:03:32But I want to see what happens when people adopt that.
- 1:03:38It's like extreme ownership of themselves.
- 1:03:42It is.
- 1:03:43Extreme responsibility for yourself too.
- 1:03:45Yeah, it is.
- 1:03:46But which is kind of anarchism, right?
- 1:03:49I mean, really?
- 1:03:50It is.
- 1:03:50And the only thing that keeps it from being anarchism and that, again, is Jefferson's conception of government or Bastiat's conception of government is you recruit some people to help you with your anarchism.
- 1:04:02I want to do what I want to do, but sometimes what I want to do requires me to go away for three days.
- 1:04:07And when I come back, I want my shit to be here.
- 1:04:09Right.
- 1:04:10So I recruit, we recruit each other for what you might call it.
- 1:04:14And so I guess I tend to call it minarchism.
- 1:04:16like what's the smallest thing you need to to actually do the things that you do need
- 1:04:23which is self-defense extended in your self-defense should exist in your absence for
- 1:04:29some period of time in that in your model who um who implements the rules like say i am someone who
- 1:04:39doesn't want to ever rob from someone and then someone robs from me or i rob from someone so
- 1:04:46Right. What happens to me? Who does it?
- 1:04:49So this is the same way that you have police forces now, except they do a lot less. So that is, in fact, you do create institutions to carry this out. Right. And if you look at, say, the Bill of Rights, I mean, you have things like, okay, I have a right not to be searched, but it's not an absolute right.
- 1:05:07Because in order to protect my other rights, I say, look, if you've got enough evidence that I did something wrong and you can convince a judge to search and you know what you're looking for, you don't just get to search everywhere and take everything.
- 1:05:22You know there's a specific thing, there's a murder weapon or something.
- 1:05:26Then I consent to that.
- 1:05:28I say, look, because if somebody steals from me or hurts me, I want you to have that power to find the evidence so that we can prosecute, so we don't have feuds. Great, so I consent to that. And that's what something like the Fourth Amendment actually is doing. It's placing a limit on your absolute right to privacy. It's like, well, in order to protect my right to privacy in a much bigger sphere, I will give it up in a much smaller sphere, right?
- 1:05:52And so that's the same thing that would happen.
- 1:05:54All these ideas have been sitting around.
- 1:05:57What's missing is sort of the, there's always this idea, well, we need government to do all this stuff.
- 1:06:02And I'm saying you don't.
- 1:06:03You don't need government to enforce, to punish people for sins and vices that don't involve anybody else.
- 1:06:09You don't need government to redistribute money.
- 1:06:13And if you take those things away, what's left is very, very small.
- 1:06:17The dystopian version of that as well is that you don't even often really need any of that. I mean, the social credit score system is exactly that.
- 1:06:26exactly and you could i was just trying to go through my mind whether you could implement a
- 1:06:31social credit system in this model without it becoming dystopian because really it would be
- 1:06:38it would work it would actually work but you would still need some things to be adjudicated in real
- 1:06:44life but because you would have something would have to say that that actually happened yes you
- 1:06:50actually did steal from that person or you did you know yes but really the the the the you know
- 1:06:57can't believe i'm advocating for social credit scores but i don't think i am i don't think i am
- 1:07:03i'm just like thinking about how the technology could work right because it's a good idea it's a
- 1:07:08really good idea it's like it's the kind of thing i imagine in a thousand years time when we're all
- 1:07:13flying around in in anti-gravity technology that's probably how we might live actually yeah you know
- 1:07:19I wouldn't be surprised if there are advanced alien civilizations living like that already.
- 1:07:24Yeah, there could be.
- 1:07:25And that would be sort of what it would mean to be advanced is they don't have to keep a chain around each other's neck all the time.
- 1:07:30Yeah.
- 1:07:30Well, it's a much more efficient way of working because you don't have to convince anyone of your ideas.
- 1:07:37And you don't have.
- 1:07:39And yeah, and it's location unspecific.
- 1:07:42So it's.
- 1:07:43Right.
- 1:07:43If you and I want to pay each other's medical bills, I don't care where you are.
- 1:07:48it just doesn't matter but like it would defund it would defund the the the there it would i mean
- 1:07:56it's like a trojan horse to sort out what is the right way to live your life because really it would
- 1:08:02show the true colors of of right of people except i would think of it as more like a
- 1:08:08a trojan horse where it starts inside the city and you load in all the crap you don't want and
- 1:08:13you shove it out the gates right you're not bringing anything in no the idea is the trojan
- 1:08:18horse yeah no but i think you know the idea is the trojan horse it's like do you want a fairer
- 1:08:22system yeah of course well you know and the democrats love fairness right okay right so you
- 1:08:29do all the stuff you want to do and we do all the stuff we want to do cool and then suddenly you
- 1:08:34realize no one's going to do that their stuff because actually it costs them a lot more yeah
- 1:08:39And there are lots of people over there trying to get their stuff.
- 1:08:43And then you have to admit to yourself like, yeah, this was a bad idea and I needed to steal from people to fund it.
- 1:08:49Whereas if it was a good idea, people would be joining the Democratic Party in droves.
- 1:08:53Oh, my God.
- 1:08:54They'll pay for my medical care?
- 1:08:56Sign me up.
- 1:08:56I want to be a Democrat.
- 1:08:57They'll pay for my kid's school and his football and his trombone lessons.
- 1:09:00Sign me up.
- 1:09:01And then you'll see.
- 1:09:02And then you'll watch like the people going, oh, my God.
- 1:09:05Wait, I paid how much?
- 1:09:07this is too and then you see but it's now contained in sort of an experimental lab and you watch that
- 1:09:13and maybe at the end of it you end up with something that's really cool and then other
- 1:09:17people go well we'd like that too with some you know modifications and then you get sort of the
- 1:09:24equivalent of federalism except it's topological federalism rather than geographical federalism
- 1:09:29you don't it doesn't depend on where you live you know there are certain things that do depend on
- 1:09:34where you live like pollution you know i mean that is actually a local thing so yes you you need to
- 1:09:41where you live isn't completely irrelevant but more and more the things that people turn to
- 1:09:48government to do it is irrelevant because mainly what they want is somebody else to pay for my shit
- 1:09:55you know yes the solution to democracy isn't it maybe that maybe maybe maybe it is a next i mean
- 1:10:03And democracy is, I know at the moment, it's untouchable, isn't it?
- 1:10:09It's the thing you can't, it's the pinnacle of governance.
- 1:10:12And if you say anything bad against democracy, you're a heretic.
- 1:10:16But it's the word.
- 1:10:18So, you know, and this is the thing, like one of my favorite, maybe my favorite saying ever comes from Confucius, who said the first step towards wisdom is to call things by the right names.
- 1:10:28And what we call democracy is not democracy.
- 1:10:31And what we want when we say we want democracy is not democracy.
- 1:10:34We should say what we want and use the right words.
- 1:10:38Well, what would you call democracy then?
- 1:10:41Well, I don't even think you can start at that level because it's power from the people, but which people?
- 1:10:50And is it power over other people or power over yourself?
- 1:10:53Right. Nobody's even had this discussion.
- 1:10:56They just say. So it's funny.
- 1:10:57We have these bonus granddaughters.
- 1:10:59right they're not our kids they're neil and emily's kids but we're basically their grandparents
- 1:11:05it's it's great so we're bonus grandparents and they will do things like i gave a talk at you know
- 1:11:11this club the quill which you may have been at and it was it was called fuck fairness right and i just
- 1:11:16went through like what do we mean by fair and it turns out we don't mean anything by fair all fair
- 1:11:20is is a trigger it's just if i say you're being unfair you're supposed to feel bad and that's all
- 1:11:25it means. So, what's funny is one of the granddaughters heard this and she was probably
- 1:11:30like five. And now every time since then that I use the word fair, she's like, fair isn't even a
- 1:11:36word. It's great. You know, she got it. She was five years old and she got it. It's like, right,
- 1:11:43that every, you come up with different models of fairness and they're all incompatible and there's
- 1:11:48nothing that they all have in common. You only use the word fair when you want somebody to feel bad.
- 1:11:54that is it that is the point of fair you know so i'm just trying to get there must be examples
- 1:12:01like i i think i'm quite a fair father on my kids and for example i would say when when they're any
- 1:12:09of my kids i've got three of them when it whenever they're arguing about something and they will
- 1:12:13eventually come to me if they can't and i will say that the fair thing to do is to hear everyone's
- 1:12:18argument so so it's okay but then when you go to make the decision how do you make a fair decision
- 1:12:24well great you say whatever you want there's normally a right decision right i don't know
- 1:12:30that that's the case there's a right decision for each of those kids yes but there's normally in
- 1:12:35their case and then there's normally one decision for you there's normally one where when everyone
- 1:12:39thinks about it it makes i don't know that that's the case i mean i think that that is that may
- 1:12:46sometimes be the case, and those are the fond ones that you remember. But the ones where nobody's
- 1:12:53happy, and maybe that's one definition of fairness. Nobody's happy. One definition of fairness is
- 1:12:57everybody's happy. In terms of education, I have a book about this where people think fairness means
- 1:13:02we spend the same amount on every kid. And other people would say, I would say,
- 1:13:06fairness is when every kid learns the same thing. And those are just not even close,
- 1:13:11right? And if you pursue one model, you basically tank the other one.
- 1:13:15Well, aren't we just trying to distill our philosophy down to the building blocks of it?
- 1:13:21And, you know, it becomes many times when I've done this, I end up with either collectivism or individualism.
- 1:13:29That's one of the places I end up.
- 1:13:30It's not definitely the right one.
- 1:13:32There are other ways to sort of subdivide ideas, I think.
- 1:13:37But that is definitely one of them.
- 1:13:38And the problem is they're just these words like democracy, like rights.
- 1:13:42nobody has any idea what it means that i have a right well i have a right to be left alone that's
- 1:13:47like as brandyves would say that is the source of all other rights but i have a right to free wi-fi
- 1:13:51i have a right to safe spaces i have a right to not ever hear anything that i disagree with and
- 1:13:56it's just the word the word no longer means anything right and so i think fairness is like
- 1:14:03that people have used fairness and they have used it as a way to beat each other over the head
- 1:14:07I grab this word fairness and democracy is like that.
- 1:14:11Oh, you need democracy.
- 1:14:12It's like, what do we mean by that?
- 1:14:14Exactly.
- 1:14:15We have no idea.
- 1:14:16What do you think the real way to use fairness is then?
- 1:14:21I don't think there is one.
- 1:14:23I think we're past that.
- 1:14:25I would just use different words.
- 1:14:27I would talk about equitable distribution of something rather than fair.
- 1:14:31I would say even distribution or preferred distribution.
- 1:14:33or i mean i would always say the first thing before you can say something's fair it's like
- 1:14:38what's your goal what are you trying to accomplish right because it might be all you're trying to
- 1:14:42accomplish is peace and quiet in which case fairness isn't even an issue right well it's
- 1:14:47half and half is it two people but you've got three daughters and two parents i mean that's
- 1:14:54a good example is often it's like they got more than me and i i wouldn't go straight to 50 50 i
- 1:15:00I would start with ownership.
- 1:15:02I would say, well, who's were they?
- 1:15:04And who's put the most time and effort into maintaining those things?
- 1:15:07Did they buy them with their own money?
- 1:15:09But also, how is this going to affect what happens in the future?
- 1:15:12How does it make up for what may have happened in the past?
- 1:15:15So without the context of those things, what's fair in a relationship where we're going to meet one time and do something and we'll never see each other again is very different than we're going to see each other every day for the next 30 years.
- 1:15:27It just, it's not a useful word.
- 1:15:30That's all I'm saying is in almost any context,
- 1:15:33there are so many ways to understand it that you can both be saying,
- 1:15:37I'm being fair and you both mean that you're being fair,
- 1:15:40but you're not having the same discussion.
- 1:15:42I look forward to having some more discussions.
- 1:15:45My kids are normally, they're happy and content kids.
- 1:15:50And I think I've thought that part of that reason is because whenever we do
- 1:15:56discuss things we we we want to find a consensus on anything like critically analyze something and
- 1:16:05go well you know some people think this some people think that um you know here's the pros
- 1:16:11and cons of this idea and that one and what do we think right and and consensus is a great word
- 1:16:17yes consensus is a fine thing and we understand what we mean by consensus but it's not necessarily
- 1:16:23the same thing as fairness. You're teaching them a process by which you can resolve disputes,
- 1:16:28which takes into account the fact that different people want different things at different times
- 1:16:34for different reasons, right? So, yeah, I'm like Confucius. I'm saying, great,
- 1:16:39use the word consensus. My claim here, and it'd be funny for you to test it,
- 1:16:43is you could go the rest of your life and never use the word fair and you wouldn't lose anything.
- 1:16:48You could just, we could hypnotize you and say, you know what, from now on the word fair doesn't
- 1:16:52almost the only time i ever use it is in the context of my kids and um i don't think i use
- 1:17:00it to make them feel bad put it that way maybe i am but i'm missing something but i tend for me
- 1:17:05fairness is a function of of um what we just said what was the word um consensus consensus so that
- 1:17:17would be that they would be almost the same word in all the the examples that i use we can we have
- 1:17:25there is a consensus that this is the right way to do things therefore that's fair because everyone
- 1:17:30can said yeah okay that that makes sense you know like sure but then you look at extreme examples
- 1:17:37the mob comes to you and says you're going to give us 10 of everything you make and you say okay we've
- 1:17:43reached a consensus was it no i no but i might not be giving there might not be a convinced okay
- 1:17:47and they'll say here's the thing if you don't agree we'll kill you yeah it still won't be a
- 1:17:51consensus i'll be forced to do it it will but your reasons will not be about fairness you will still
- 1:17:57go okay you're forcing me to do it and i'll do it because i value all these other things like
- 1:18:01staying alive and raising my family and doing the job that i like but we we have a meeting of the
- 1:18:07minds i'm not happy it's not fair fairness has nothing to do with it but it's a consensus right
- 1:18:12And I have my own reasons and they have their own reasons and they have force that they can bring to bear and I don't.
- 1:18:18Whereas if I have thousands of friends, then we could just shoot all them and then we're fine, right?
- 1:18:22I thought a consensus was an agreement, though.
- 1:18:25It is an agreement.
- 1:18:25Am I agreeing, really, with the mob?
- 1:18:28I'm under duress.
- 1:18:29It's like signing a contract, right?
- 1:18:31I mean, you have agreed on the terms of the contract, whether you like them or not.
- 1:18:35Yeah, but did you?
- 1:18:36Like, I could sign a contract without agreeing with it.
- 1:18:39Like, I could.
- 1:18:40And you could.
- 1:18:41and you have achieved consensus with the other people involved in the contract,
- 1:18:44but it's not fair and you don't approve of it and you don't like it,
- 1:18:47consensus just means you agreed to stop talking.
- 1:18:51That's what it means.
- 1:18:52Okay?
- 1:18:53So if I'm in a Quaker meeting, right, and they only do things by consensus,
- 1:18:59if anybody's complaining, we're not done talking yet.
- 1:19:02All consensus eventually means is we're done talking.
- 1:19:05We're done talking.
- 1:19:07I'm not happy.
- 1:19:08Maybe that's where I am with my kids as well,
- 1:19:10and they bring me problems.
- 1:19:11It's like,
- 1:19:12it's a function of staying quiet.
- 1:19:14But no,
- 1:19:15I enjoy,
- 1:19:15I enjoy the critical thought process
- 1:19:18and I love watching my kids
- 1:19:19learn about it
- 1:19:21because it's,
- 1:19:22I don't think a lot of,
- 1:19:23they don't teach it at school,
- 1:19:24put it that way.
- 1:19:25No,
- 1:19:25because,
- 1:19:25because why would they?
- 1:19:26They will never give you the education
- 1:19:28you need to overthrow them.
- 1:19:29I would have thought
- 1:19:30if I was a teacher,
- 1:19:31I'd be teaching that.
- 1:19:31In fact,
- 1:19:32actually,
- 1:19:32that's not strictly true.
- 1:19:34My,
- 1:19:34my daughter,
- 1:19:35my youngest that go,
- 1:19:36still go to what we would call
- 1:19:38primary school
- 1:19:38up to the age of 10 they have excellent teeth one particular teacher there who's brilliant i really
- 1:19:45love him and he does teach them things like that he does point out the two sides of an argument and
- 1:19:52he does or the three or the four or the five yes correct but it's mostly the two obvious ones you
- 1:19:59know but um yeah right and so every once in a while yes you get great teachers who are fantastic
- 1:20:05human beings and who are very thoughtful and whatever but as an institution that's not going
- 1:20:12to be encouraged by the people who are running it from the top because it actually works against
- 1:20:17them so and it's not even you know it sounds like that's a conspiracy theory but it doesn't require
- 1:20:23a an actual conspiracy it just requires people sort of acting in their own best interests rather
- 1:20:30than in the interest the stated interest of the institution do they make that connection though
- 1:20:34You don't have to. That's the beauty of it. You're just acting in self-interest and the institution and the government, the funds it, have set up the incentives in the wrong direction. Right? So, if I'm, say, you've read Catch-22, right?
- 1:20:48I haven't read it.
- 1:20:49Oh, fantastic book.
- 1:20:52There's this great part in there where you have these army officers, and they're basically trying to steal each other's officers because like, well, if I get another colonel, then I get two captains and four lieutenants, blah, blah, blah.
- 1:21:06And they're not really interested in fighting the war.
- 1:21:09They're interested in having the largest command, right?
- 1:21:13The incentives go in the wrong way there.
- 1:21:15It's just, and this is, Thomas Sowell will often say, look, people don't respond to goals.
- 1:21:20You can set up goals, but people respond to incentives.
- 1:21:24And if an incentive is, if I do more of this, I get more of something I want, then I'm going
- 1:21:29to do that thing.
- 1:21:30I have no interest if I am running a school system where I get paid for the kid being
- 1:21:36there, I have no interest in getting him out faster.
- 1:21:40If I could get this kid to learn everything he needs to know about age 12, that hurts
- 1:21:43me because that's like five, six years of money that I don't get for him. So my incentive is to
- 1:21:51string him along, right? And to teach classes where I don't really care if any of the kids are
- 1:21:56getting it. Maybe there's three kids in the middle of the bell hook curve are getting and five of them
- 1:22:00are bored and eight of them are just like, what the hell's going on? But that has nothing to do
- 1:22:05with my incentive, which is to get paid for providing instruction, whether anybody learns
- 1:22:10anything or not. So this is, you know, just paying attention to incentives is incredibly important.
- 1:22:20Bad segue, but you've written 16 books.
- 1:22:26and I wrote down a few of the titles because there's some love brilliant interesting unusual
- 1:22:33titles um I'm just going to read one two three how many have I written down there six of them
- 1:22:38okay tell me I think it looks like no five pick one and tell me what the hell it is because I
- 1:22:45couldn't work out just from the title okay uh losing the religion of liberty political conversion
- 1:22:52in three jokes have we done that conversation we talked about that one conversation yeah political
- 1:22:57conversation in three jokes we talked about that one three boxes a cure for government overreach
- 1:23:02okay right that's not the same thing as the first one is it three no they're not three boxes you
- 1:23:07have so that talks about the cartridge box the jury box the ballot box barefoot learning what
- 1:23:11shoes can teach us about schools that one sounds really interesting what barefoot learning what
- 1:23:17shoes can teach us about schools okay so very briefly i was having a problem with my feet
- 1:23:21and I was looking into, I was buying all different kinds of shoes and stuff and, you know, trying to fix this problem.
- 1:23:27And I finally came across these people who talked about going barefoot, barefoot shoes, you know, the soles.
- 1:23:33And I tried this and it cleared everything up.
- 1:23:36Okay.
- 1:23:37And so I started thinking about this.
- 1:23:38It's like.
- 1:23:39No, sorry.
- 1:23:40You wear shoes, but they're the shape of your feet.
- 1:23:42I wear shoes, but like these are a boxy toe.
- 1:23:46So my toe isn't being pushed over and the soles are like nothing.
- 1:23:50So this is protecting me from sharp objects, and that's about it.
- 1:23:54Okay, and my boots are like that, the muck-lucks I have.
- 1:23:57And so I try not to have anything under my feet except to protect me from getting cut.
- 1:24:04So the idea is you start looking at this thing, and you find, so what these people were explaining is your foot is designed to work a certain way.
- 1:24:12And by design, I mean designed by evolution, not teleologically.
- 1:24:15But your foot is supposed to do a certain thing, and it turns out that the way people shape shoes prevents it from doing that.
- 1:24:23And so you start adding things, arch supports, pronation, supination.
- 1:24:27You do this, you do that.
- 1:24:28Here's different materials.
- 1:24:29We'll put air in them, whatever.
- 1:24:31And none of those fix the problem, which is basically you've prevented your foot from being a foot.
- 1:24:38And so I was reading this, and I was like, holy crap, this reminds me of something.
- 1:24:41What is it?
- 1:24:42And it occurred to me, schools.
- 1:24:44Schools are like this.
- 1:24:45Okay? In that to make your feet work properly, you need to let a foot be a foot and do what a foot is, which is something comes down, you actually, the arch compresses and then releases the energy in a certain way. And that's how it's supposed to work. And if you don't do that, no matter what else you do, your feet are going to have problems unless you're lucky.
- 1:25:07so in schools it's like so you start and you go you start there with what's the function of a foot
- 1:25:14the function of a foot is to absorb this energy of your body coming down and then re-release it
- 1:25:18what's the function of a kid a child the function of a child is to imitate adults using who are
- 1:25:27doing interesting and important things that's what kids do and everything about school prevents them
- 1:25:34from doing it okay you are not with interesting people who are doing anything that matters
- 1:25:40right and so they do not get to be kids so that was what you can learn about schools from shoes
- 1:25:48and so it's just you do all these things you put all this technology and you put all these
- 1:25:51pedagogical things in and it's just like adding all this stuff to shoes but if you don't address
- 1:25:56the problem it doesn't work but you have to be in consensus that the the point of a child is to
- 1:26:05mimic adults though you would yes if you don't believe that then this book will not be useful
- 1:26:09i've never thought of it like that if you if you would have said what's the point of a child i'd
- 1:26:14just say to well to grow up to be a productive member of the point okay so the point is a bad
- 1:26:19word right that's like michael faraday saying what's the point of a newborn baby it's to grow
- 1:26:23But what does a child do?
- 1:26:26What, in the most raw, basic, fundamental terms, children are imitation machines?
- 1:26:32Apprentices.
- 1:26:33They're apprentices.
- 1:26:34Apprentices, right.
- 1:26:35And I mean, I was just so weirded out because, like I said, we never had kids.
- 1:26:39We have these grandkids.
- 1:26:39And suddenly, like, you're sweeping the floor.
- 1:26:41Like, can I help you sweep the floor?
- 1:26:43And you're like, you know, 10 years from now, you're going to be like, get lost.
- 1:26:47But they're just, you're doing something.
- 1:26:49You're doing it because it needs to be done.
- 1:26:51It's not a fake thing that you're doing to waste time.
- 1:26:54And it's like, can I help?
- 1:26:56Can I do this?
- 1:26:56Oh, can I pour the flour into the bread?
- 1:26:59Can I help you, you know, clean this thing?
- 1:27:01Can I help you move this stuff?
- 1:27:03Oh, you're moving leaves from here to there?
- 1:27:04Let me help, right?
- 1:27:06This is what they're doing.
- 1:27:07They watch you do it.
- 1:27:08They do it.
- 1:27:08And this is how they learn.
- 1:27:09You talk, they talk.
- 1:27:11You read, they're like, well, reading is kind of interesting.
- 1:27:14I want to do that.
- 1:27:15And they learn to do the things that you do.
- 1:27:17they imitate adults who are doing useful and important stuff and if kids do that then they
- 1:27:24work properly as kids and if they don't then they don't right and so you can add all this other
- 1:27:31stuff but as long as you don't address that central issue if you are preventing them from
- 1:27:36being kids then it doesn't matter too much what else you do so that's what that book's about what
- 1:27:40What were the things that moving to more natural shoes, what did that solve?
- 1:27:46My feet stopped hurting.
- 1:27:48I was, I had, what's it?
- 1:27:50I can't even remember the name of it now.
- 1:27:52It's been so long.
- 1:27:53But I had this thing, like I would get out of bed in the morning and I couldn't, huh?
- 1:27:57Plantar fasciitis.
- 1:27:58I couldn't walk for 15 minutes because everything was so tightened up.
- 1:28:03And I would try, yeah, and I would try things to sleep in.
- 1:28:06It would pull my, you know, be stretching this or stretching that.
- 1:28:09I'd put things in my shoes.
- 1:28:10I'd put things around my feet.
- 1:28:12I would, you know.
- 1:28:13And I was at the point where I was like, okay, I'm just going to get orthopedic shoes.
- 1:28:16I'm looking.
- 1:28:17It's like, those are going to be $500.
- 1:28:18What are orthopedic shoes?
- 1:28:19They actually, you send them a mold of your feet, and they make something that exactly fits your foot.
- 1:28:26And is that counterintuitive then, really?
- 1:28:29Well, it's intuitive to do it because you think, oh, then my foot will make perfect contact all the time.
- 1:28:35And what's counterintuitive is that's not going to help because your shoe is still screwed up at the front and you're not able to release the energy from your big toe.
- 1:28:46Right.
- 1:28:46Your big toe is made in a certain configuration so that you get all this energy and you release it and you release it by using the front of your foot in a certain way.
- 1:28:56And if you can't do that because your feet look like your shoes look like this instead of like that.
- 1:29:00it's reminding me actually uh in my former life as a film director we made a film in um
- 1:29:08russia about it was like six or seven years ago with the nenet people do you know who the nenets
- 1:29:14are they're like a nomadic um they live in tp well they live in chums they're called okay it's
- 1:29:21yamal peninsula that's it it's like one of the super cold it was minus in centigrade minus 45
- 1:29:27when we were there and they they're nomadic but they actually i took i went out there with my
- 1:29:34baffin minus 50 boots you know like and before you know like i had a zero suit all in one everything
- 1:29:42you know and it was brutal my colleague got a crossbin um at one point but they used um still
- 1:29:50use reindeer skins for almost everything including their boots right which i ended up trying because
- 1:29:57the the you know the kind of baffin boots i mean they're these canadian boots they're supposed to
- 1:30:02last and down to minus 50 but they don't your feet get bloody cold well what the ninets all they did
- 1:30:08right was they had these kind of like thigh length big they were like socks basically and they were
- 1:30:15made from um fur out reindeer fur reindeer skins on one side a bit of not much but a bit of like
- 1:30:23hay inside as in dried grass and then on the inside the fur in so two layers okay and no socks
- 1:30:30nothing so you walk around on the snow and it would feel like it would actually feel like you're
- 1:30:35walking on the snow because yeah you know there was nothing to cushion your but they were way
- 1:30:41well i ended up wearing them the whole of the trip in the end because they were so much warmer
- 1:30:46and now i'm thinking about what you're saying it's like they probably also were better for me
- 1:30:51because I was actually walking along the ground and my foot was doing.
- 1:30:57Yes.
- 1:30:58It was a weird sensation to begin with.
- 1:31:00You ever walked on snow in bed?
- 1:31:02It's like walking on snow in bed.
- 1:31:03I haven't done that yet.
- 1:31:03I'll go out and try it later.
- 1:31:05Well, you need to find something that you can, you know,
- 1:31:07you need to put something waterproof.
- 1:31:08But also they're just warm because there's actually air in there.
- 1:31:13The trouble with those boots is they put all that felt and stuff in there
- 1:31:16but they don't leave any gaps for the air.
- 1:31:19But they're also preventing your foot from moving.
- 1:31:21they're like i'm gonna pack stuff under the foot and around the foot and here it's like and so first
- 1:31:26of all all what that's doing is sending the shock instead of being absorbed by your arch is going to
- 1:31:32your ankles and if you stiffen your ankles it goes to your knees and so you get knee problems and
- 1:31:37ankle problems you know um but also it's preventing them from moving which means you're getting less
- 1:31:42blood flow which means you know the muscles aren't exercising so yes it's actually so the ones you
- 1:31:48use now they're just very thin sold and flat and that's it yeah yeah i mean it's it's a boot it's a
- 1:31:54the yeah this thing is just literally it's just some deer skin it's i mean like moccasins yeah
- 1:31:59it's got some sheepskin in but after like two weeks that's just mashed down into nothing and
- 1:32:05the you know the the sole is so if i'm walking across rocks i feel the rocks yeah you know if
- 1:32:11i'm if i'm walking on something i feel that thing which is actually at first it's it's a little weird
- 1:32:16but you know about the grounding movement as well i've heard of it yeah you can imagine what it is
- 1:32:21but yeah there are i was funny enough i don know why yesterday on i was on the internet and one of those popped up a guy had a volt meter and he was showing that when he stood on the ground with you know i don know whether it true or not but but but that a thing now grounding yeah sure yes maybe you doing that as well
- 1:32:40i i could be i do have a soul in between me and the ground so is it made of is it it's rubber oh
- 1:32:46okay so it's not leather so i'm not no i would try leather ones the the main thing is i walk on a
- 1:32:52lot of rocks and in the woods a lot and so if i have leather it's going to rip and i'm gonna have
- 1:32:55to replace it a lot how much land have you got here by the way uh we have down at the farm there
- 1:33:00is around 200 acres and up here there's around 50 and do you spend a lot of time out in the woods
- 1:33:05and stuff um not so much in the winter because i don't ski but in the summer i go out and cut wood
- 1:33:10for us and our friends and so i'm out in the woods all the time i'm jealous i'd love i i would i once
- 1:33:17when i was younger i bought when i used to live in london i when i first earned some money that
- 1:33:22you know i bought uh 15 acres of woodland which unfortunately i sold because i used the money to
- 1:33:29buy a house in the end but for a good five or six years i used to go there every weekend
- 1:33:35and just camp on my own land and just do all kinds whatever just various forest skills or
- 1:33:42whatever you know it's super um nourishing for a guy especially then interestingly my middle
- 1:33:50daughter loves doing that stuff as well yeah she's got one with all the knives and stuff
- 1:33:53she yeah she's always out in the garden or we've got land now so um making fires and doing stuff
- 1:34:02she's picked that's cool yeah but yeah it's a nourishing way of life i you know i'm we just
- 1:34:09don't have the land where i live like you've got a lot of land here yeah and it's one of the reasons
- 1:34:15that you were asking Jody about, you know, moving to New Hampshire.
- 1:34:19Part of it was because there's still land here.
- 1:34:21You know, if I go to...
- 1:34:23And is most of your 250 acres wooded?
- 1:34:25It is.
- 1:34:26We just have a little bit clear to live in the rest of the small woods.
- 1:34:29So you eat this whole house with wood, I take it.
- 1:34:30Yes, we do.
- 1:34:31Yeah, that's what I do all summer is cut trees down and I stack them.
- 1:34:34You can see our woodshed back there.
- 1:34:37So we have about three years worth of wood.
- 1:34:38Another hugely satisfying thing.
- 1:34:40It is.
- 1:34:41I do that as well.
- 1:34:42We just felled six old trees.
- 1:34:46Unfortunately, they're pines, so they don't burn really hot.
- 1:34:50But I haven't even got through a third of them yet.
- 1:34:54And we've got wood for days.
- 1:34:58It's going to last us so long.
- 1:35:00I don't even know how long it's going to last.
- 1:35:01Well, I mean, we have a fire in the winter just constantly.
- 1:35:05And so we go through about three cords, I would say.
- 1:35:08Does it run all night then?
- 1:35:09um it there will be coals in the morning and so we have to get it going again and we could get up
- 1:35:15in the night and you know like set an alarm and get up at three o'clock and put it in but we're
- 1:35:19just too lazy yeah we don't need to do so yeah you only have to put up with 10 or 15 minutes of
- 1:35:24yeah we get up it's like 50 degrees in the house and so you make coffee and you make a fire and is
- 1:35:29it really insulated in here no no no no no this this was originally a hunting cabin the part we're
- 1:35:36sitting ending right here was a hunting cabin. It had terrible insulation. At one point, we made
- 1:35:44this into an office, and it turns out there was insulation in here, which was keeping...
- 1:35:50But really, no, this is not a house that we would build from scratch. So, in that sense,
- 1:35:56it's very much like an education system, right? You could say, well, we can tinker with this,
- 1:36:00and we could tinker with this, but really what you want to do is just start over and say,
- 1:36:04what's the house we would want the house and we know what house we would want if we could do it
- 1:36:10but it's just it's too much money and it's too much trouble so we're just put another layer of
- 1:36:14in what we call kingspan you know that stuff that insulation yeah i mean i'm about to do that
- 1:36:21i think to an outbuilding we've got at home which is just makes your rooms a little bit smaller on
- 1:36:27the inside that's all it does yeah i mean and we could do it and we could do things with the windows
- 1:36:32and we're probably going to put insulation under the floor
- 1:36:35because this is up on pilings.
- 1:36:38So there's, you know, like two feet under there.
- 1:36:40So that gets cold.
- 1:36:42You know, that floor down there is actually on cement.
- 1:36:45So that gets cold.
- 1:36:47But if it ain't broke, don't fix it sometimes.
- 1:36:50Right.
- 1:36:50Yeah, so we'll do what we can.
- 1:36:52You know, I would love sometimes to just get a bunch of Amish people up here,
- 1:36:55lift the house up and turn it 90 degrees because the sun's over there.
- 1:36:59and so all the windows are over here you know um so yeah it's just the house is facing the wrong way
- 1:37:07but it's you know it's it's like just the place we live is so wonderful have you ever thought about
- 1:37:14taking your excess energy and turning into heat and any i know it's not a very efficient way to
- 1:37:20things but it could if you because you've got excess energy right we do and it means we can
- 1:37:25run like we have a heater now in one of the bathrooms and it's electric and we can do that
- 1:37:29during the day and it wouldn't even run the batteries down that much i mean we're looking
- 1:37:33more for things like to get a big chest freezer and run that we want to replace um our gas water
- 1:37:40heater with electric because then that's free you know as long as we have the system um we haven't
- 1:37:46thought too much about using it for heat somehow that just seems extravagant well yeah it is but
- 1:37:51And if it's excess heat, presumably some days they switch off and they stop topping the batteries up, right?
- 1:37:58Yeah, they do.
- 1:37:59And yes, on a day like today, they were done by like 11 a.m.
- 1:38:02So the rest of the day we could.
- 1:38:04She gets Bitcoin miners up here.
- 1:38:06Well, why not?
- 1:38:07It's not that much electricity.
- 1:38:10What we would probably do at some point is we'll get an electric car because we'll be able to charge it and top that off.
- 1:38:16So we are always looking for, okay, what else could we do with electricity that we now do with propane?
- 1:38:22Because propane is really our only connection to the world, the grid.
- 1:38:28They have to come up here twice a year and fill up a couple of tanks.
- 1:38:31But we're using less and less all the time.
- 1:38:33You could even buy those.
- 1:38:35We used to have propane at our last house.
- 1:38:39But we used to buy or borrow.
- 1:38:42We used to pay for these big canisters that were only this big.
- 1:38:44Yeah.
- 1:38:45But we only used it for cooking.
- 1:38:49And we did have an on-demand heater, actually, that used to work.
- 1:38:53But we didn't really get through much.
- 1:38:54We used to get through two big ones of those a year.
- 1:38:56Yeah, we have one of those.
- 1:38:58They're just hard to move around.
- 1:39:01But we have a heater in that room that we just run when it's really, really cold most of the time.
- 1:39:06We ignore it.
- 1:39:07We use propane for the water heater and for our stove and oven.
- 1:39:10And that's it.
- 1:39:12So it's not very much.
- 1:39:14and we could probably go for two years
- 1:39:17and not get a fill-up and still be okay.
- 1:39:19But it is still sort of one more connection
- 1:39:23where, oh, we're going to raise the price of propane by a factor of 10.
- 1:39:26And then you're like...
- 1:39:27If you get an electric car, that's a whole new world of pain.
- 1:39:32Is it?
- 1:39:33I think it is because...
- 1:39:35Can you fix an electric car?
- 1:39:37I can't.
- 1:39:39I think I know people who could, though.
- 1:39:41What happens in the batteries?
- 1:39:42you know as far when you said well you know we're self-sufficient and the prices and the
- 1:39:47wouldn't be surprised if you worked it out on paper and realized that um the the purchasing of
- 1:39:52an electric car because buying a second-hand electric car is probably not a good idea because
- 1:39:56it's the battery that's the thing so you you have to spend quite a lot of money and then who knows
- 1:40:04you know it would have been cheaper just to use a diesel one or yeah i don't know what a lot of
- 1:40:10people around who do is they have golf carts electric golf carts that's a good idea because
- 1:40:14then when you know the batteries wear out it's easy to pop it out and get another one you fix it
- 1:40:18um and if the whole thing craps out it was you know they're getting amused from golf courses for
- 1:40:23you know a thousand bucks or something but where do you where do you go where would you go we would
- 1:40:27go up and down our road we would go to the farm in a golf course or golf cart i would you know
- 1:40:33drive out like if i need to take a bunch of chainsaws out someplace throw them in a golf
- 1:40:37cart take them out on a on a path and leave them where i'm going to use them stuff like that i mean
- 1:40:42people just use them to get around we had a couple at the farm down there and they mostly would use
- 1:40:47them like oh i got to take a bag of grain over to the chickens you throw in the back of that and you
- 1:40:51just go over so they're really nice and they're easy um and they're quiet and as long as they work
- 1:40:56they're great and then they stop working and then nobody can figure out how to fix them yeah
- 1:41:01Yeah, or we would use a quad bike still, I think.
- 1:41:04But there are no easy.
- 1:41:05Right.
- 1:41:06So, yeah, and we have one of those, and we're having some problems with it.
- 1:41:09But, you know, we'll get it fixed up.
- 1:41:11And, yeah, so there are things you can do with it,
- 1:41:13but it's just people keep telling us, like, yeah, if you had an electric car,
- 1:41:16then you could charge it basically for free.
- 1:41:20Or a hybrid, right, so that you can still run it on gas if you need to.
- 1:41:24Yes.
- 1:41:24And that would be a better choice.
- 1:41:26I don't like all this electric stuff, I'll be honest.
- 1:41:29because of it because it disempowers me as a as a fixer it really does yes and also it means that
- 1:41:38i'm i'm yeah beholden to the battery companies really i have to buy a new battery and i know
- 1:41:45tesla batteries don't have a long life like they're the main one i know about they don't have a
- 1:41:50particularly long life cycle in a car and when they when you change them they're like a substantial
- 1:41:56cost of the car it's not like you just go and get a new battery and pop it in it's like half the car
- 1:42:01that is yeah that's the major component of the car that's the thing that makes it different from
- 1:42:06other cars so yes whereas my yeah my i've got a toyota hilux that has a really simple engine in
- 1:42:13it when you open the in 2015 when you look inside you'll recognize all the parts but they when you
- 1:42:20drive them, if you've been driving new cars, you'll be like,
- 1:42:25something wrong with this, because you have to put it into
- 1:42:27gear for real Oh well I actually prefer that Me too I don mind that at all i mean it yeah we have a truck that somebody borrowing now it manual transmission i fine with that i like that
- 1:42:39and i i think we talked about this when you first got here i just i have come to appreciate more and
- 1:42:45more pieces of equipment where all the connections are visible and traceable and understandable
- 1:42:51and as soon as you put a computer into something it's like that's that link is broken that could
- 1:42:57be doing anything well yeah that's the point and it is doing anything yeah my car that i'm that you
- 1:43:02kindly got me up that hill there in the first thing it does when you switch on is uh it says
- 1:43:08google services is sending do you agree to this that and the other and i went through and i ticked
- 1:43:14everything no no no no no no you know but almost certainly i mean there's sat nav in there there's
- 1:43:20everything is i i am a product driving around and people are tracking me and yeah and i don't like
- 1:43:25that and if you go you don't have to go back that far in history like my 2015 is a great truck i love
- 1:43:32it and it's got it's got electric windows which is so it's it's got yeah it's got some mod cons
- 1:43:38but beyond that it's just a good truck and it and i can last time it got fixed it cost me about
- 1:43:44300 to change something whereas the one we had before that which was a whatever land rover
- 1:43:50discovery or whatever that was always more than a thousand pounds whenever something went wrong
- 1:43:56always and half the time it was the sensor that needed replacing because the light came on and
- 1:44:02said there's you know like my like what bugs me most is when it tells you there's not enough air
- 1:44:08in the tires yeah we get when did we ever have that and there's some special battery we need to
- 1:44:13buy for the sensor in the tire but when did you ever need to know how much air in your tires you've
- 1:44:18either got a puncture or you're just driving around in your car because you can tell not
- 1:44:23hopefully yes you can tell if if you can hear that you've got a puncture other than that
- 1:44:27the wheels are the wheels it doesn't have to be exactly full of air i know yeah no it's no there's
- 1:44:34there's a lot of uh stuff like that where it's just but even beyond like the radio and google
- 1:44:39it's just you know oh we're we're using a computer to you know uh manage the the mixture of air and
- 1:44:45gas and if that decides to crap out then you can't do anything you know so just yeah every i i am
- 1:44:53really getting to appreciate all the things where and i i'm not a car fixer i know many people who
- 1:44:59are right and i i sort of envy these bonus grandkids because they're growing up on a farm
- 1:45:04where people are fixing shit left and right all the time and they're gonna see it and that's the
- 1:45:09the attitude they'll be in is if something breaks you fix it you know they will unfortunately though
- 1:45:14do away with
- 1:45:16petrol cars and diesel cars.
- 1:45:18They're going to try.
- 1:45:20Do you think that people might take up
- 1:45:22arms in this country if they try and get rid of that?
- 1:45:26You know,
- 1:45:26I think that is
- 1:45:28one of the things that it could be, but
- 1:45:30one of the things that happened in COVID
- 1:45:32was I really thought
- 1:45:34religion, I thought churches
- 1:45:36were going to be a line you couldn't cross
- 1:45:39and people just caved.
- 1:45:41And that was one of the most
- 1:45:43depressing things I ever went through. It was just like, they're like, oh, sorry, you can't go to
- 1:45:48church on Sunday. And I thought, man, I don't go to church myself. But I was like, man, that's not
- 1:45:52a thing you just say okay to. And then they said okay to it. So I don't know. I don't know how
- 1:45:58conditioned people are, how much they value now convenience over freedom or responsibility,
- 1:46:04wherever. And it might just be they're like, okay, this is how it works, right? You just tell
- 1:46:08us what to do and we'll do it i don't know but that that would be i mean americans do love their
- 1:46:13cars i think that's right up there with guns um so it's going to be interesting right now my my
- 1:46:19sense is that they announce this because they want to sound like it's a lofty goal but they
- 1:46:24don't really have the intention of doing it they just push of actually getting rid of internal
- 1:46:29combustion they just say well we'll push it back another five years because they'll always they're
- 1:46:33never like okay next year we're doing this it's always like oh in 2050 we'll do it yeah but it's
- 1:46:39um it's it depends because it relies on the environmental spiel doesn't it if that if that
- 1:46:47people seem to be losing i've noticed just my anecdotal kind of eye has noticed that far less
- 1:46:55people believe in that stuff now and and and it's kind of cracking and that's why i'm saying i don't
- 1:47:00think they'll ever get around to doing it. And then, you know, you get places that, oh, we'll
- 1:47:04buy a fleet of, you know, school buses that are all electric and oh, they won't run in the winter
- 1:47:09because we forgot. Batteries don't work that well in the cold. You know, so I think people see the
- 1:47:14stories and people have been told, oh, New York City is going to be underwater by, you know,
- 1:47:182018. No, wait, we meant 2020. No, no, we meant 2024. Next year, next year it'll be underwater.
- 1:47:26And people are just like at a certain point, it's just fatigue.
- 1:47:29You're just like, okay, I'm not really going to listen to that anymore.
- 1:47:35So I think that's one of the ways that any movement like that can overplay their hand
- 1:47:41and just keep saying, and that's the thing you see with Trump.
- 1:47:44Trump's a Nazi, Trump's a Nazi.
- 1:47:45And at a certain point, people just, yeah, okay.
- 1:47:48You just keep saying that.
- 1:47:50But they can normally keep finding a new thing, can't they?
- 1:47:54Possibly.
- 1:47:55And they might.
- 1:47:56Yes, although, again, I think there's a – I hope that people just get fatigued and just say, you know what, let's move on to something more substantive, right?
- 1:48:05Oh, the end of the world's coming.
- 1:48:07No, the end of the world's – no, now it's coming, right?
- 1:48:10So, you saw around the end of the century, all these people, oh, you know, God is coming back and we're all going to die or something, blah, blah.
- 1:48:16And it's like the world will end in the Mayan calendar.
- 1:48:19And it's like after a while, it's just like, okay, another one of those.
- 1:48:22That kind of fatigue.
- 1:48:23Like, yeah, yeah, yeah, I've heard this.
- 1:48:25you know tell tell me when the when the you know the meteorite is you know going to hit next week
- 1:48:31and then and then i'll worry about it might be wood fires that's something they talk about where
- 1:48:36i live can you believe that i mean and the worst thing about trying to ban wood fires is that you
- 1:48:41can see smoke coming out of people's chimneys so and from a long way away where i live yeah and it
- 1:48:46would be a real thing that because everyone i know uses wood yeah not not to necessarily heat their
- 1:48:54whole house but for fun really yeah it's you know we use it often to heat a lot of our house
- 1:49:00but we sit around the fire every night you know whereas but yeah i don't know if if they if they
- 1:49:07banned it in towns already right and that's the thing so the people in town are just like okay
- 1:49:12whatever but seriously there's a lot of people out who need internal combustion engines and they need
- 1:49:17cars and they need you know to run their stoves using fossil fuels and they need this stuff and
- 1:49:24when you suddenly come and say yeah you can't do that anymore well they can't they well it's like
- 1:49:30you guys will just give in because you have no guns how do they know what you're doing up here
- 1:49:35anyway does anyone ever come up you know no people people don't very much um and there's an
- 1:49:41interesting thing in new hampshire which is one of the things i love most about it so the the towns
- 1:49:46every town will revalue property every once in a while because they need to know how much
- 1:49:51you have to pay them to run schools and stuff so but and so they send people to come up and like
- 1:49:58we'll measure your house and come in and and you know see how many bedrooms you have and whatever
- 1:50:02and you're free to just say get the fuck out of here yeah and they'll turn around and leave
- 1:50:07yeah you don't have to let them on yeah they're they're supposed to do it but you know you just
- 1:50:14go away
- 1:50:15I bet most people don't realize that as well
- 1:50:17yeah a lot of people don't but the people doing it
- 1:50:19have probably had enough shotguns pointed at them
- 1:50:21that they're like okay
- 1:50:23have a nice
- 1:50:25day
- 1:50:26well
- 1:50:26Ian we've been talking for nearly two hours
- 1:50:31mate and I've already been
- 1:50:33speaking to your wife for an hour
- 1:50:34I'm still reading from
- 1:50:37your idea of
- 1:50:38what's the book called that that's in then
- 1:50:41which the
- 1:50:42The extreme self-governance.
- 1:50:45It isn't a book yet.
- 1:50:47So I will send you the, I can show you the grant.
- 1:50:50Does it have a name?
- 1:50:51Does that governance model have a name?
- 1:50:54It doesn't yet.
- 1:50:55So if you'd like to come up with one, you could.
- 1:50:58So, yeah.
- 1:50:59I like challenges like that.
- 1:51:01I can't.
- 1:51:02It's, I don't know.
- 1:51:05It's the kind of thing that, like I say,
- 1:51:07I either want it to be a science fiction book or a computer game.
- 1:51:11that i can model because i want to see it i want to i want to see it play out yeah you know like in
- 1:51:17kind of sims where everyone says what they can don't do and don't like right from the beginning
- 1:51:23and then an algorithm then acts acts as the law and and because it would you know i'd rather see
- 1:51:32it modeled before it got rolled out if you see what i mean you know yeah no no i and i you know
- 1:51:39I'd be happy to consult on anything that anybody wants to do with it.
- 1:51:42I'm not the guy to write either of those things.
- 1:51:45Other than that, I think it's something for the far future, unfortunately.
- 1:51:49Yes, but what I'm trying to do, so there's Milton Friedman, who I'm sure you know about.
- 1:51:54He said something that motivates me.
- 1:51:56It keeps me going sometimes when you just think, God, everything sucks.
- 1:51:59He said, only in a crisis will you have real change.
- 1:52:03And when a crisis occurs, what happens next depends on the ideas that are lying around.
- 1:52:09when, as he put it, and I love this phrase,
- 1:52:12when the politically impossible becomes the politically inevitable.
- 1:52:15So that's what I'm doing.
- 1:52:16I'm trying to get people to think about things like community centers
- 1:52:19instead of schools and thinking about using political parties
- 1:52:22instead of a whole government to get what they want or whatever.
- 1:52:25So if I can stick that idea in your head and you'll go away
- 1:52:28and a week from now a month from now you be thinking about us and go could we make this work Then I succeeded Well the place that you try these things out believe it or not are in free cities
- 1:52:43And in, like, the special economic zones
- 1:52:46are the same for economics.
- 1:52:48Yeah.
- 1:52:48You try out a new model in a small area.
- 1:52:53But, yeah, I mean...
- 1:52:56I mean, what's funny is it's still the free cities,
- 1:52:58and I don't know that much about them,
- 1:52:59but it is still a like, it's somewhat geographic.
- 1:53:03We're all going to get together here.
- 1:53:04Yes, but you could, as a microcosm,
- 1:53:09you could say within the confines of this city.
- 1:53:13Sure, but you could also then say
- 1:53:15we will have several cities in a network
- 1:53:17and they don't have to do, right?
- 1:53:20They can cooperate with the other cities
- 1:53:22and you see what can work in a network
- 1:53:24and what has to be in a locality.
- 1:53:27And that's a way to experiment with that
- 1:53:29Because nobody knows the answer to that question yet.
- 1:53:31But more and more, I think more and more you will find things like we don't have to actually be in the same place to do this.
- 1:53:37I know, but the beautiful thing about what you're describing is that it's a function of technology.
- 1:53:43Yes.
- 1:53:44Which is great because you can't look to the past to see where it's been manifested before.
- 1:53:49Yeah.
- 1:53:50It doesn't.
- 1:53:51And so it has never been tried.
- 1:53:52It can't have been tried.
- 1:53:54There's no way you could have that system unless it exists in a kind of personal, interpersonal way, which it kind of does, I suppose.
- 1:54:00When you meet someone, you know, like in the street you've never met before in a random place, you've got things that you won't do to them and they've got things that, you know, like, but you know what I mean.
- 1:54:12Yeah, it's just this very small, you know, least common denominator of what we've agreed not to do to each other, which mostly means don't hurt each other and don't take our stuff, which, you know, then becomes libertarianism that, oh, that's what we were saying.
- 1:54:25And it's like, yeah, okay, but you don't need the name.
- 1:54:28You just need the idea of consent.
- 1:54:30Before we go then, do you think libertarianism is a, is a, is kind of like, and don't take this the wrong way, but is a very elevated form of, of, of living a very hard, you know, do you know what I mean? Like, is it when you go through the evolution of, of life and of ways to interact with your fellow men, is this kind of like at the pinnacle of what you could understand about, about life?
- 1:54:56Oh, I don't think it's the pinnacle at all. I think it is. I think it's the distinction I see between that and other political movements is they're at least trying to base everything on first principles, which I'm a big fan of, right?
- 1:55:17I mean, you look at the Republican Party, what do they stand for?
- 1:55:20Who the hell knows?
- 1:55:20Nobody knows.
- 1:55:21What do the Democrats stand for?
- 1:55:22What do the various parties in Europe stand for?
- 1:55:24Nobody.
- 1:55:25We want this bag of stuff, and we don't like that bag of stuff.
- 1:55:29And like right now, somebody who's a Republican here, if they say, I'm a Republican or I'm
- 1:55:33a Democrat, it tells you nothing about what they actually think about almost anything.
- 1:55:39Statistically, you can say, yeah, if they're Democrat, they're probably pro-abortion, but
- 1:55:43Republicans are too.
- 1:55:44or they're probably anti-gun except some of them are pro-gun.
- 1:55:49So it's just there's no set of principles there except we want to win elections.
- 1:55:54Libertarians have the luxury of knowing they're not going to win any elections.
- 1:55:58So they can be very principled, right?
- 1:56:02Until they start winning.
- 1:56:04Right.
- 1:56:05When they start winning, then it'll suddenly be,
- 1:56:08oh, now the extra principle that comes in is we must continue to win.
- 1:56:14And that changes everything.
- 1:56:16That changes the nature of the venture.
- 1:56:18It changes the nature of the institution.
- 1:56:20It changes everything when your concern becomes winning, right?
- 1:56:25So in that sense, you can say, I would say they have a more principled stance, but they
- 1:56:31can afford to, right?
- 1:56:32Because they're never going to be called upon, or not never, they will not anytime soon be
- 1:56:39called upon to actually solve problems and have to deal with all the people who want to kill them
- 1:56:45as a result of their solutions which democrats and republicans have you know centuries of
- 1:56:50experience with so but but elevated i think is you know what i mean is it it's more i put it this way
- 1:56:59i think um yeah but i wouldn't necessarily i don't know what to i i don't call i wouldn't say
- 1:57:07I'm a libertarian because I don't really know what that means necessarily.
- 1:57:10It might mean something different to you.
- 1:57:12But the principles of non-aggression, the principles of, you know, the golden rule,
- 1:57:17all these kind of things, they seem to be the kind of ideas that you end up at,
- 1:57:22if you know what I mean.
- 1:57:24I do know what you mean.
- 1:57:25And I think, though, that you end up at them when you have a certain set of experiences.
- 1:57:31Like, in fact, I'll give you a copy.
- 1:57:33You can have that.
- 1:57:33And I'll give you a copy.
- 1:57:34One of the books you mentioned, Losing the Religion of Liberty,
- 1:57:37it's actually about this. It is about sort of becoming a religious, in a sense, libertarian,
- 1:57:45this is the right answer, and how I sort of got away from that. And now I just look at,
- 1:57:50okay, this is one possible way to run things. There are lots of possible ways to run things,
- 1:57:54depending on what your goals are, you know. So again, it can come down to something as simple
- 1:57:59as if you decide as a matter of choice, not as a matter of a principle in the world,
- 1:58:04not as like a law of gravity or anything.
- 1:58:07If you decide as a choice that individuals are more important than society,
- 1:58:11then yes, libertarian is going to seem, that's going to seem very obvious to you.
- 1:58:15But if you believe that humans are, you know, you take more of a Gaian thing,
- 1:58:19humans are this sort of bigger, not even a species,
- 1:58:23but there's some magic organism that's doing this stuff
- 1:58:26and you're just one little part of this organism.
- 1:58:28Then if you have to go, you have to go, right?
- 1:58:31Then you just get a completely different view of things.
- 1:58:33so you know and so yeah we have to get rid of the dissenters if your goal is some kind of harmony
- 1:58:40then okay that's fine if your goal is no the dissenters are the important ones then it's not
- 1:58:46fine in the free cities movement that is solved by competing places small competing places who
- 1:58:54have their own ideology or okay they're basically contractual in in in i mean you don't have to be
- 1:59:02but the model that i like the most is we build a city it has a wall yeah and if you want to join
- 1:59:09the city you can opt into the city whenever you want there is a contract an actual contract not a
- 1:59:13social contract an actual contract that says what you can and can't do and if you choose to that's
- 1:59:18good if you don't you go to that door yeah yeah well no you go to the other one that does do what
- 1:59:23you want right and you know but i i kind of in a way i like your idea of of um of having it
- 1:59:32having having that aspect of it exist in the digital realm in because that's a more 21st
- 1:59:41century i mean free the ideas of free cities have existed kind of without the mind you we're using
- 1:59:46the contract that's the kind of innovation i suppose but the innovation with yours is you
- 1:59:51You don't have to change a huge amount.
- 1:59:54I mean, you do.
- 1:59:55But about the actual physical realm, you don't have to change a lot.
- 1:59:59All the things that I'm advocating, the technology exists.
- 2:00:02We know how to do it.
- 2:00:03We do it for other things.
- 2:00:04We have insurance companies.
- 2:00:06We all pay money in, and then they pay money out.
- 2:00:09There's nothing new here.
- 2:00:10It's just letting go of this idea.
- 2:00:13Well, everybody has to get insurance from my company.
- 2:00:17It's like, no, they don't.
- 2:00:19They can go without insurance.
- 2:00:20They can get a different company.
- 2:00:21You know what? Another expression that we use a lot is governance as a service.
- 2:00:26No, but what you're describing, it should be.
- 2:00:29Governance is a service that should be provided and you should be able to choose between your governance.
- 2:00:34So if you're not getting a good service, you should be able to get a better service.
- 2:00:39I know democracy apparently solves that problem, but it doesn't.
- 2:00:42No, it doesn't.
- 2:00:43We've just kind of like discussed.
- 2:00:45No, it doesn't.
- 2:00:45I like the word service because like to be serviced, like you get serviced like a bull services a cow.
- 2:00:50You know, that's how I think of government service.
- 2:00:53Yeah, I'm going to service you real good.
- 2:00:56No, it's not.
- 2:00:57It's the treatment, you know, like, yeah.
- 2:01:01I meant to tell you earlier when you were talking to Jody, you were talking about state mottos.
- 2:01:06And actually, you know, if you're not in America, you don't see these things.
- 2:01:09But ours changed during COVID.
- 2:01:11It is no longer live for your diet.
- 2:01:13It is now public health trumps everything.
- 2:01:16And also the New York change there.
- 2:01:20from the Empire State to in loco parentis.
- 2:01:24That's actually their motto now.
- 2:01:28I'll take your word for it.
- 2:01:31Let's end on some good misinformation.
- 2:01:33That's what I like.
- 2:01:35Ian, thanks indeed.
- 2:01:37I wish we could do this again.
- 2:01:40You know, you like to do it in person, but otherwise, I mean, I can do this forever.
- 2:01:46It's a prerequisite of what I do.
- 2:01:48and you probably understand why.
- 2:01:51I do.
- 2:01:51It wouldn't be the same online
- 2:01:53and it wouldn't be the same having to drive down your drive
- 2:01:57and all this stuff.
- 2:01:58No, no, no, that's all fun.
- 2:01:58No, but this is, I get something out of this as well.
- 2:02:02Sure.
- 2:02:02And not only just this conversation,
- 2:02:04but in the fact that I've come to this amazing place
- 2:02:07and I've seen, you know, when I go, I'll remember
- 2:02:09there's two people living just there.
- 2:02:12Well, if I'm ever in the UK, I'll let you know ahead of time.
- 2:02:15Yeah, come to our farm.
- 2:02:16I'd love to see that.
- 2:02:17You'd be welcome to.
- 2:02:17but thanks very much for your time thank you love this conversation thanks thank you