Latest / Her Legacy: Women, identity, culture & modern life / The Loneliness and Liberation of Speaking No Language | Her Legacy
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that follows you when you stop praying, and it is not the peaceful quiet you were promised. It is the sound of your own heartbeat, loud and unaccompanied, echoing in a room where you used to belong. I want you to imagine standing in the center of a sanctuary you haven’t entered for years. Maybe it’s been five years. Maybe it’s been twenty. The air smells different now—less like incense or old hymnals, more like dust and memory. For me, that smell was always tied to a sense of absolute certainty. I was raised in a faith community where doubt was treated like a structural flaw in the foundation. You didn’t question the beams; you just leaned on them until they held you up, or until they collapsed under your weight. When I left, I didn’t walk out with a dramatic slam of the door. There was no shouting match, no final sermon delivered in anger. It was quieter than that. It was a slow unraveling, thread by thread, until the tapestry of my life simply couldn’t hold its shape anymore. And today, I’m sitting with you in that unraveling. I know you might be feeling untethered right now. Like you’ve stepped off a moving train and are standing on the platform while the world rushes by without you. Let’s sit with that for a second. That vertigo is real. It’s not just about theology or doctrine; it’s about losing the map you were given at birth. We often talk about leaving religion as if it’s purely an intellectual exercise. We discuss the contradictions, the politics, the ethics. But anthropologically speaking, what we’re really talking about is community. It’s the rhythm of shared meals. It’s the way someone knows how you take your tea because you sat next to them every Sunday for fifteen years. It’s the collective exhale after a prayer that says, 'You are not alone.' When you leave that space, you don’t just lose beliefs. You lose your witnesses. You lose the people who have seen you grow from a stumbling toddler into a confused teenager, into a weary adult. You lose the archive of your own history. I remember sitting in my car outside my childhood church last winter, just watching the lights go out one by one. I felt a grief so physical it made my chest ache. It wasn’t grief for God, necessarily. It was grief for the version of myself that fit there. The version that believed she could be saved by showing up, by doing the work, by being good enough. It’s complicated, isn’t it? To mourn something that perhaps wasn’t healthy for you. To miss the warmth of a fire that was slowly burning down the house. Society tells us that leaving should feel like liberation. It should feel like taking off tight shoes after a long day. But for many of us, especially women who were socialized to care deeply about harmony and belonging, it feels more like amputation. We are taught that we owe our departure an explanation, an apology, or a justification. We worry about the look on our mother’s face, the silence from our best friend, the pity in our father’s eyes. I spent months trying to craft the perfect narrative for my exit. I wanted it to be gracious. I wanted it to be wise. I wanted them to see that I hadn’t rejected them; I had just outgrown the container. But here’s what I’m hearing from listeners like you: the truth is messier. Sometimes you leave because you’re angry. Sometimes you leave because you’re tired. Sometimes you leave because you can no longer lie to yourself or to them. And none of those reasons make you less spiritual, less moral, or less worthy of love. We need to give ourselves permission to grieve the loss of the tribe without feeling guilty for needing the tribe. Community is not a sin. Wanting to belong is not a weakness. It is human. The problem arises when that belonging comes at the cost of your integrity. When you have to shrink parts of yourself to fit through the door. That is not a home. That is a holding cell with better acoustics. So, where do you put all that energy? All that devotion that once flowed toward pews and pulps? This is the part nobody talks about. The void. After the initial relief fades, and the guilt sets in, you are left with a vast, open landscape. You have to learn how to build a table where you are the host. You have to learn how to create rituals that mean something to you, not because they were handed down, but because you chose them. For me, this looked like finding small pockets of grace in unexpected places. It looked like staring at the sky without naming the creator. It looked like cooking dinner for friends and calling it communion, even though there was no bread or wine. It looked like reading poetry instead of scripture, finding the same awe, the same terror, the same beauty in the words of Mary Oliver or Ocean Vuong. This new spirituality is slower. It is less certain. It requires you to trust your own inner compass when there are no landmarks. It is terrifying. But it is also incredibly freeing. You begin to realize that the divine isn’t a destination you arrive at by following rules. It’s a presence you cultivate by paying attention. By being present. By loving the people in front of you, exactly as they are, without trying to save them. I want to challenge the idea that disillusionment is a failure. In anthropology, we often study rites of passage. These are moments where identity is stripped away so a new one can be formed. Leaving the church that raised you is a rite of passage. It is a death, yes. But it is also a birth. You are being born into a self that is whole, not fragmented. A self that doesn’t need external validation to know it is worthy. This process strips away the performative aspects of faith. You stop performing goodness. You stop performing piety. You start practicing authenticity. And that is hard work. It is harder than saying the right prayers at the right time. It is harder than smiling through the discomfort when someone asks why you stopped coming. Because now, you have to live the truth, not just speak it. You have to be okay with being misunderstood. You have to be okay with being lonely sometimes. You have to be okay with the fact that you might never find another community that feels quite as tight-knit or as all-encompassing as the one you left. And that’s okay. Because what you gain in exchange is agency. You gain the power to define your own values, your own morals, your own meaning. You become the author of your own soul, rather than a character in someone else’s story. If I could send a letter back to the girl sitting in the third pew, hands folded tightly in her lap, trying to believe the words she was saying, I would tell her this: You are allowed to change your mind. You are allowed to outgrow the stories that no longer serve you. You are allowed to seek truth even when it hurts. Even when it breaks your heart. Even when it isolates you. Your worth is not tied to your obedience. Your holiness is not measured by your conformity. You are already enough, just as you are, in all your messy, questioning, beautiful complexity. You don’t need to earn your place in the universe. You already have it. I know it feels like you are falling. But you are not falling. You are flying. And the wind beneath your wings is your own courage. It is shaky at first. It is uncertain. But it is yours. And as you learn to trust it, you will find that the sky is much bigger than you ever imagined. Much vaster. Much kinder. And infinitely more full of wonder. Thank you for letting me into your headspace today. Thank you for trusting me with your story, however incomplete it may feel right now. I’ll be thinking of you, and of that sacred, silent space where you are finally free to breathe. Until next time, keep listening to your own heart. It has been telling you the truth all along. Love you.