Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / 👻 Bourbon Boos: Dough Ball Cookie Dough Flavored Whiskey Review 🍪
Transcript
- 0:00On today's episode of the Bourbon Bytes podcast, we're looking at several new whiskey releases,
- 0:05including Jim Beam's Knob Creek 21-year-old bourbon,
- 0:08Forward Slash's Incantation Vol. 2 mead-finished bourbon,
- 0:13and the latest release of a Midwinter's Night Dram from High West.
- 0:16Plus, I'm kicking spooky season off with a very scary pour,
- 0:20Dough Ball Cookie Dough Flavored Whiskey. Let's see how this goes.
- 0:36Hello everyone, and welcome to the Bourbon Bytes podcast. I'm your host,
- 0:40Clifton, and this is the week of October 9th, 2025.
- 0:44As I mentioned last week, we're going to get into some spooky pours to celebrate this season,
- 0:49and today's whiskey review is no exception.
- 0:51But before we get into that, we have some whiskey news to talk about.
- 0:56For the past week or so, I've been getting several emails from distilleries about their
- 1:00new whiskey releases and new labels coming soon, so we're going to highlight a few of those before
- 1:05getting into our review, but welcome to the show. Thank you for listening in. If it's your first
- 1:09time here, welcome. This podcast is all about whiskey news and reviews with a gaming twist,
- 1:15so we don't really have any gaming news this week, but I do want to mention something that
- 1:20people are getting very up in arms about. Rock Band 4, and all the DLC associated with it,
- 1:25is going to be delisted from the PlayStation and Xbox stores. It's been 10 years since this
- 1:30game came out, and a lot of the music licenses are expiring, so fans are calling this a 'crime
- 1:36against gaming'. I think that's one of those things that happens when you license real music
- 1:41for a game like that is, you know, they don't have those rights forever. So while I never really
- 1:45played those games growing up, mainly because, well if you don't know, I am an amputee. I am
- 1:50missing my right arm, so I could never play any of those like guitar, like drumming games. It just
- 1:54didn't really work for my setup. Now I'm sure there's some accessibility controls I could,
- 1:59you know, adapt it to and try it now as an adult, but yeah, never really piqued my interest. But
- 2:04yeah, fans are upset about that. And it makes you wonder, like, should they keep those games up with
- 2:09just the other tracks that haven't, you know, had a license expire? Or are those even playable,
- 2:14right? Like, it's like, could you continue to sell it and then remove most of the main features
- 2:19that came with the game when it first came out? It's an interesting topic. I mean, I guess they
- 2:23could always just replace it with, like, generic, like, library music, not recognizable songs, but
- 2:29that's not any fun. So I'm curious to hear what you guys think. Are you guys upset about things
- 2:33like that? Or would you rather them keep a version of it up in the store? Now I'm not saying there
- 2:39aren't ways that you could probably get that game and a copy of it and save it locally. Not to
- 2:44advocate against, you know, piracy, but if you own the game, you know, I think ROMs are legal. So
- 2:50check that out. But before I get this podcast banned, let's go ahead and move into our whiskey
- 2:54news for the week. Now the first of these isn't actually a new whiskey, but it's a new to me
- 2:59whiskey, and it has a brand new label. So a couple years back, Barrell Craft Spirits released a Barrell
- 3:05Foundation five-year bourbon, and it was pretty well received. And apparently they launched a
- 3:10double barrel version of it for 2025. I wasn't aware, but they've changed up the label now to
- 3:16make it a little bit more unique on the shelves. I think that's something that I've always kind of,
- 3:21you know, felt about Barrell's products is a lot of the labels look pretty similar, but this new
- 3:26label for the double barrel release has a textured background. So it's a similar color, but there's a
- 3:32bit of like a, I guess, maybe a barrel looking texture to it. It's very light. It's bright orange,
- 3:37so it's hard to really tell what they're going for here, but it's made to help it be a standout
- 3:42against the regular release. I think maybe there was some confusion among fans of whether it was
- 3:46the double barrel or the regular one, although the old label I was looking at, and it still says
- 3:50double barrel. So I guess the coloring scheme may have been confusing because it was the same color.
- 3:54I don't know, but this whiskey did win a 96 point score from Wine Enthusiast, a 91 point score from
- 4:01Whiskey Advocate, and platinum in the LA Spirits Awards, as well as the American Spirits Council of
- 4:08Tasters. So I'm going to keep an eye out for this bottle. I haven't had it. I was a big fan of the
- 4:12regular Foundation. I thought it was a solid addition to their lineup, but double barrel
- 4:17sounds really, really good. So I'll keep an eye out for this brand new label. Now, speaking of new
- 4:22labels, I'm taking a look over at our friend Coming Whiskey over on Instagram. That is Jacob. If
- 4:26you're not yet following him, he is a great resource for the whiskey community. And one
- 4:31bottle label caught my eye, and mainly because it looks a little Halloween-y. It's called
- 4:36Incantation Volume 2, and this is from Forward Slash is the brand. I'm not very familiar with
- 4:42them, but this is a straight bourbon whiskey finished in a mead barrel, which is something
- 4:46that I've never really heard done. I mean, I know people finish things in a honey barrel,
- 4:50but I don't think I've ever seen a mead finished whiskey. Sounds very, very nice, though. It's 51.5%
- 4:56ABV, so 103 proof, and they're actually based out of Winter Park, Florida. The back of the
- 5:02bottle says, for the second release in our mead barrel maturation series, Incantation,
- 5:06we set out to highlight one of the most distinctive aspects of Zimerium Meadery's
- 5:11barrel-aged meads: Treatments. This particular barrel once held a mead infused with over 200
- 5:17vanilla beans, allowing its flavor to develop richness and depth. Now, here's where it gets
- 5:22even more interesting. So that vanilla mead actually spent 10 months in apple brandy barrels,
- 5:28and on the day that it was emptied, they filled it with their bourbon blend. So there's definitely,
- 5:33I see what they're talking about layers, like we're talking about a apple brandy barrel that
- 5:37was used to age mead that had vanilla beans, and now they're putting bourbon in it. So
- 5:41I'm excited to see this. I would definitely keep an eye out. I have not, like I said,
- 5:45heard of the brand before, but I see a couple of people in the comments excited for this release.
- 5:49I'm excited, especially seeing that it's higher proof. You know, it's not like it's going to be a
- 5:53flavored whiskey, which speaking of which, we'll get into one of those later today.
- 5:57But yeah, I like all those impacts from those barrels. Bottling it high proof, you know,
- 6:02103 proof is a pretty impressive move. Now, I wish we knew a little bit about the bourbon.
- 6:07We do know that it is a straight bourbon whiskey, but that's about it. So I'd love to know more
- 6:11about where this is from. If I had to guess, probably Indiana, but there's nothing wrong
- 6:16with that. All right. Well, another email that ended up in my inbox this week was Beam's fall
- 6:21bourbon lineup. They've just announced two new releases, the Hardin's Creek batch for 2025 and
- 6:27the Knob Creek 21 year. Now I'd heard of the Knob Creek because our friend Fred actually ended up
- 6:33with a bottle of the 21 year old release. It seems like quite a bit of folks got a chance to try it
- 6:38at the Kentucky Bourbon Festival. I'm seeing it pop up on a lot of YouTube channels. I know Cameron
- 6:42from Drums and Drams did a review as well as Bourbon Junkies. So I am definitely keeping an
- 6:47eye out for that. I am a huge Knob Creek fan. I really enjoyed the 18 year that I had. The first
- 6:5215 year I had was a bit of a miss, but I've heard that previous or sorry, later batches have come
- 6:57out quite a bit better. Now, the label for this release was posted on the TTB back in April,
- 7:03actually. So that's all I really know about it. Like I said, 21 years old, 100 proof. So it's not
- 7:08going to be cask strength. That's going to be the standard proof as their main core age data lineup.
- 7:13Now, retail on this bottle is $250, which I think puts it in line with the other releases.
- 7:18I think it's fair for a 21 year old bourbon. That's not something you see every day. Would I like it to
- 7:24be maybe a higher proof release for that price? Absolutely. But I'm definitely going to keep an
- 7:28eye out for this one. Now, unfortunately, I don't think I am on Jim Beam's PR list, but if anyone has
- 7:33a contact out there that would be willing to send me a sample, let me know and maybe let Adriana from
- 7:38Whiskey Mountains and Women of Whiskies know as well, because I'm sure she is dying to try this
- 7:42bottle. Now, I don't know too much about the Hardin's Creek release. I know it's going to be
- 7:47launched on October 17th. So as I learn more about that new one, I will share it here on the podcast.
- 7:52So two really cool releases and one that I am very excited. The other I'll wait and see.
- 7:59Now, one last note, Jim Beam is offering a Friendsgiving event on November 13th at the
- 8:05Distillery. You get to join Fred and Freddie Noe for a bourbon and Thanksgiving feast featuring
- 8:11pours like Little Book: The Infinite Two, Bookers: The Reserves Two, of course, Knob Creek 21 that we
- 8:16just talked about, and Jim Beam Lineage Batch Two. This is happening on November 13th at the
- 8:22Distillery from 6 to 9 p.m. Price is $150 per person, which sounds like a good time. I mean,
- 8:27if I was there, I'd love to absolutely hang with those folks and have a wonderful Thanksgiving meal
- 8:31and try some incredible bourbon. So if you are in the area and looking to attend, let me know how
- 8:36it goes. All right. Well, last whiskey release to talk about today is the announcement of the
- 8:42High West Distillery's A Midwinter Nights Dram Act 13. So the last one I actually had was Act 11.
- 8:49So it's been a couple of years since I've had this one, but they just released the info on this
- 8:53particular bottle. It's going to retail for $150. It's available to purchase actually on their
- 8:58website now. They say it is a blend of straight rye whiskeys ranging in age from 4 to 10 years old,
- 9:04finished in ruby and tawny port barrels. This has always been a favorite of mine. I think it's,
- 9:09you know, just an exceptional pour coming in at 98.6 proof. I always think of it as the perfect
- 9:14holiday whiskey. And, you know, now it's about the time to be buying those Thanksgiving and
- 9:19Christmas pours before it's too late. So I'm going to keep an eye out for this new release. I'm a big
- 9:23fan of Act 11 and I've always been a fan of this lineup. So I'm looking forward to getting a chance
- 9:28to try it. I know people are kind of a little upset with the pricing going up to closer to $150.
- 9:32I think I paid $120-ish, $130 for my last one, but that was straight from the distillery. I actually
- 9:39had a chance to buy it after doing a tasting and tour of the distillery when I was there. So I had
- 9:44to pull the trigger on it then. But this one, I might just wait to see if it pops up locally and
- 9:48then just see how I'm feeling and if I'm willing to pull the trigger at the moment. But I have
- 9:54traditionally really enjoyed these pours and I'm sure this year's release is no exception.
- 9:59All right. Well, that does it for news this week. I realized last week's episode was a bit long,
- 10:03so I'm going to keep this one a little bit shorter. But we do still have our Byte-Sized Review.
- 10:16So like I teased earlier on, the month of October, I'm doing things that are either
- 10:22bottles that I've had for a while, but I've been scared to try, or bottles that have been eyeing
- 10:26me from the liquor store shelf. And I've not really had an occasion to buy them, but they
- 10:30scare me a little bit. But we're going to try them for this spooky month this year. The first
- 10:35of which is a sample bottle that has been sitting in my closet for well over a year and a half now.
- 10:42I bought this for a live stream like a year and a half ago, and I just had too many flavored
- 10:46whiskeys to do. So I set this aside. I was like, it didn't really fit the theme. But I figured
- 10:51since it is almost holiday season, you could be cozying up with a bottle of A Midwinter's Night
- 10:55Dram, or you could be having a shot of this while you're baking cookies with the family.
- 11:01So if you don't know already, I'm talking about Dough Ball Cookie Dough Whiskey. This is a whiskey
- 11:07with natural flavors and caramel color. Just want to get that out off the bat. And it's coming in
- 11:12at 35% ABV or 70 proof. Now this is produced and bottled by Patco Brands out of Fairfield,
- 11:19California. And I will say I've seen these Doughball bottles on the shelves for a couple
- 11:24years now. And I think they have a pretty good fan base and a nice following. Now whether or
- 11:29not these are the same people that are drinking A Midwinter's Night Dram, I highly doubt it.
- 11:32But I've seen a few reviews where people are saying like, I don't want to like this,
- 11:35but I really like it. And I kind of feel like that's how I am with some flavored whiskies.
- 11:40You know, I am still a big fan of Fireball. You know, it's a joke, but I feel like on the right
- 11:44occasion, a nice cold pour of that out of the freezer will get you going on any day. I also
- 11:49liked, uh, what was it? Screwball. Screwball peanut butter whiskey that came out, um, probably
- 11:54like five years ago now, but that was one of my favorite flavored whiskeys, I think, because it
- 11:57still had a lot of the whiskey flavor and it wasn't, um, overwhelming with the sweetness.
- 12:02Now, a couple of weeks back, I did a live stream where I tasted through three different new
- 12:07flavored whiskeys, including the Jack Daniel's Blackberry, the Jim Beam Pineapple, and the Crown
- 12:13Royal Chocolate. So if you missed that, check out the YouTube channel, youtube.com slash bourbon
- 12:18bytes. I go live almost every Thursday night at 7 p.m. Pacific, 10 p.m. Eastern. Would love to have
- 12:23you as a subscriber and a viewer over there if you're just here for the podcast. You can also
- 12:28find me everywhere on the web, bourbonbytes.com, bytes with a y as it's spelled here on the
- 12:33podcast. There's a link to my Instagram, my TikTok, my podcast, which you obviously have already found,
- 12:38the YouTube channel, some really cool merch, and my favorite part, the Byte Club membership,
- 12:43which is your way to support the channel for as little as two dollars a month. You can make a
- 12:47huge impact, allowing me to buy crazy whiskeys like this one and also supporting the channel
- 12:52in other ways. But do check that out. I notice we've been getting quite a few new free members
- 12:57on Patreon, which is all great, but I would rather if you're going to be a free member,
- 13:01I'd rather you join the bourbonbytes.com Byte Club. That way, it's just kind of more of a
- 13:06my hub for place on the Internet, not that Patreon is going anywhere. I'll still be
- 13:10posting on there as well. But I'd like to, you know, if you're going to join for free,
- 13:13come on down to the Byte Club. Shout out to newest free members: Chance, James, Rance, Jim, Dana,
- 13:21and Devildog1. Like I said, bourbonbytes.com. There's also a link to our Discord server,
- 13:25which includes tons of fun channels to share your interests and passions and what you've
- 13:30been drinking lately. So check it out. Byte Club members get access to exclusive rooms depending
- 13:34on their tier, including our monthly movie night where we watch a retro movie. It's October,
- 13:39so we're definitely going to do a horror 80s horror movie this month. So I'll start thinking
- 13:43about what we do. I think someone recommended The Fly. I haven't seen it, but someone mentioned that
- 13:47as a good 80s horror movie to watch. So let me know if that's something you want me to watch
- 13:50or if there's anything else that comes to mind. You also can get access to our monthly tasting
- 13:55subscription box, where is where I send you samples every month. You can get that at the
- 14:00BourbonTeraByte tier. It's a great group of guys who get together and drink whiskey. And if you
- 14:04want to join us, all you got to do is join the Byte Club. So that's it with the plugs. Let's go
- 14:09get into this Dough Ball Cookie Dough Whiskey. Now, perhaps you're supposed to be drinking this
- 14:16as either a shot or a cocktail or over ice. I'm going to do it neat because I feel like
- 14:21putting it over ice is probably going to bring down some of the flavors a bit. And I want to
- 14:25give an honest first impression of this whiskey. So we're going to do it neat for today's review.
- 14:30Let's go in and give this a nose. OK, not too much, honestly, I hope this is going to be like
- 14:36crazy sweet on the nose. It's there. It's sweet, but it's almost like a chocolate, like a melted
- 14:42chocolate chip note. It doesn't say chocolate chip cookie dough, which is kind of I'm surprised.
- 14:46I thought it'd be more of just like a generic cookie dough note, but there's like a good
- 14:50chocolate note there that kind of reminds me of the Crown Royal Chocolate. But this one's
- 14:55a little bit more of like a melty kind of chocolate, like the chocolate that would be
- 14:58in a chocolate chip cookie. There's also a good bit of vanilla there. And I think, you know,
- 15:02unfortunately, it's probably mostly coming from the artificial flavor. I don't think that's really
- 15:06coming from the whiskey itself. We don't know, by the way, if this is a bourbon, if this is a
- 15:10Canadian whiskey. Most likely it's, you know, it's either American whiskey or Canadian whiskey.
- 15:15A super young whiskey usually is what they go for. I know Fireball is, I think, Canadian whiskey,
- 15:21if I remember correctly. But a lot of them just use, you know, barely aged whiskey. That's why
- 15:25they don't have to call it like a straight bourbon or anything like that. They can use, you know,
- 15:28as long as it touches wood and it's been aged in wood, they can call it a whiskey. But honestly,
- 15:32I'm pretty impressed that this isn't as sweet on the nose. Now, I'm hoping the palate holds up
- 15:36because I've said this before, but I'm not a fan of flavored whiskies that are overly sweet.
- 15:41It's something that I find in almost all of them. Unfortunately, I feel like they try to compensate,
- 15:46you know, the flavor with just like tons of sugar. And it's just so overwhelming,
- 15:50especially if you want to use it in a cocktail. It's like you don't need to add any sugar to it
- 15:54because it's so sweet already. I'd actually prefer things to be a little bit more natural.
- 15:58That way you can, you know, like I said, mix into a cocktail, add some simple syrup,
- 16:01maybe some vermouth. But, you know, making it so sweet, it makes it hard to do anything with,
- 16:06in my opinion. But maybe that's just me. Maybe I'm not the target audience.
- 16:09But let's go and give this Dough Ball Cookie Dough Whiskey a taste. Cheers.
- 16:15OK, yeah, there's the there's the cookie dough flavor. I still get a little bit of
- 16:20that chocolate chip note, like it's like a milk chocolate melty. But honestly, the flavor,
- 16:27they kind of nailed it. Like it kind of does taste like a chewy kind of cookie,
- 16:31like, you know, not necessarily like raw cookie dough, because I think that has a very specific.
- 16:35I don't know. There's something about raw cookie dough that has a little bit slightly different
- 16:38of a flavor. I think it's a little more vanilla, whereas a baked cookie has a bit more of those
- 16:42toasty dessert quality elements to it. I think this has that. I think it has a little bit of
- 16:47like a toasted pie crust kind of note that I think attributes really well to a baked cookie.
- 16:52I'm gonna go for a second sip. I'm pleasantly surprised by that first one.
- 16:56Yeah, unfortunately, it's sweet, right? I think I was hoping that it wasn't going to be that crazy
- 17:01sweet, but I figured with a cookie dough flavored whiskey, you can't really expect it not to be.
- 17:05It's viscous, but in a way that's just because it's the sugar sticking to your tongue.
- 17:09And finish wise, it actually has quite a bit of a kick for a 70 proof.
- 17:13You know, I prefer these to be at least 80 proof, which some whiskies have been that are flavored.
- 17:17But this one, unfortunately, is 70. Now, I guess our target audience probably wants something
- 17:21smooth, as I should say. But this is, you know, a pretty complex flavored whiskey. Like I said,
- 17:26starts out with that melted chocolate. There's a little bit of like toasted marshmallow there as
- 17:30well. But there is a baked good note, like a I said pie crust, but I mean, it probably is just
- 17:36cookie. Let's be real. But it's a pretty they've nailed this flavor. You know, it does say made
- 17:41with natural flavors. We don't really know what that means, but they at least taste it tastes
- 17:46like a cookie. So if that's their goal, they nailed it. Is it made for someone like you and
- 17:51me that just likes to drink a whiskey that tastes like whiskey? Probably not. I'm going to have to
- 17:55give this whiskey a rating based on, you know, my feelings towards it. It is a flavored whiskey,
- 18:02so I'm going to treat it as such. Fun fact, this one actually won a double gold at the San Francisco
- 18:06International Spirits Competition, as well as the Proof Awards Unmasked, where it won double gold
- 18:12and Proof Awards Masked, where it won gold. So it's doing really well. Forbes magazine actually
- 18:17called it the best of class flavored whiskey when they reviewed it. So, you know, I think there is a
- 18:23place where it just may not belong on my whiskey shelf. Now, pricing wise, I'm not sure if I
- 18:28mentioned that. I don't think I did. This bottle goes for about twenty four, twenty five dollars,
- 18:33which is relatively high. I got a mini bottle for about two dollars, 50 cent. But for a flavored
- 18:38whiskey, that's, you know, pretty up there. And I think the way that this taste is justified. But
- 18:43I know that something like Fireball, which is mass reduced, is, you know, not half the price,
- 18:48but almost half the price. So I do think it's steep in its category, but that doesn't mean
- 18:52it's bad by any means. Out of 10. Hmm. This is tough because I feel like I don't think I've ever
- 18:58given a flavored whiskey a rating out of 10. I just feel like I say my ratings for like,
- 19:02OK, this is going to be mean. I like serious whiskeys, which, you know, that's not an
- 19:06insult. I don't think cookie dough flavored whiskey takes itself too seriously in terms of
- 19:11being a well-reviewed whiskey in the bourbon influencer circle, you know. But I will say
- 19:18it's it's a little sweet for me. It's a little pricey, but it's not bad by any means. So this
- 19:22is going to get a five out of 10. It's not something I would buy again. It's something
- 19:27that I would probably have, you know, as a fun shot with some friends, maybe make it into a
- 19:31cocktail. But even that it's so sweet that I don't know if it would even hold up in a cocktail.
- 19:36So this one might be better just enjoyed over ice as a way to wind down after a long day.
- 19:41But it's definitely made for somebody that somebody just isn't me. So I'm glad I had a
- 19:46chance to try it, though. Let me know if there's other crazy flavored whiskeys you want me to
- 19:49review. Like I said, this month of October, I'm doing some bottles I've been scared to review
- 19:54for various reasons. And I say that because I don't actually know what I'm reviewing next week,
- 19:58but I'll figure it out before then. So let me know if you have any recommendations or
- 20:01suggestions of what I should pick up to review. And I think that does it for this week's episode.
- 20:06Thank you so much for listening. Like I said, it's a little shorter than usual, I think, but
- 20:10doesn't mean it's not a good time. So make sure to follow me on your favorite podcast platform.
- 20:15If you're watching this on somewhere like YouTube, hit the thumbs up button, leave a comment there
- 20:19on the channel. But most of all, thank you so, so much for listening. I'll be back next week with
- 20:24even more whiskey and video game news, plus another byte-sized review. All right, y'all,
- 20:29cheers. Have a great rest of your week. And until then, this has been Bourbon Bytes,
- 20:33a whiskey podcast with a gaming twist. Cheers, and I'll see you next episode.