Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Tanya Otsuka Confirmed to Serve on NCUA Board. What that Means for Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:35MARK TREICHEL: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:38episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39This will likely also be the last episode for 2023, which has been a good year.
- 0:44I think we're approaching on, or just hit 30, 000 downloads and substantially more
- 0:51listens since we started two years ago.
- 0:53I appreciate you listening.
- 0:54And today's episode is being recorded exactly at noon, December 21st.
- 1:01And it's exciting times over at NCUA.
- 1:03Why?
- 1:04Because they got a new board member coming on.
- 1:06The Senate confirmed.
- 1:09Tanya Otsuka to join Todd Harper, chairman and Kyle Hauptman, current
- 1:15vice chairman, that'll be, that title will be evaporating pretty soon.
- 1:19If not at Tanya Otsuka's first board meeting, perhaps the one
- 1:22following that, but so now what happens is she has to get sworn in.
- 1:27Once she's sworn in, Hood Rodney Hood is done and Miss, Ms.
- 1:33Otsuka will become the second Democrat on the board.
- 1:37Now I got a an email from Ken McCarthy over at American Banker asking me my
- 1:42thoughts on how that might influence NCUA.
- 1:45I don't know if he's come out with an article on it or quoted me yet, but I
- 1:48shot him some some notes relative to that and the answer to the question.
- 1:53First question he asked was, what will this mean for the NCUA
- 1:57board from a perspective of when was the last time there were
- 2:00two Democrats on the NCUA board?
- 2:03And that was a board that concluded its its reign of a triumvirate on May.
- 2:09In May of 2016, and it was chairman Debbie Matz, vice chairman Rick Metzger and
- 2:15Mick Waters, who was the sole Republican.
- 2:18Now it's, so it's been seven years, roughly almost seven years, just short
- 2:23of seven years, since there was a NCUA board that was led by two Democrats.
- 2:28Now, what will this mean for NCUA?
- 2:31It means that.
- 2:33The budget in 2025 will be higher than the one in 2024.
- 2:36It would be anyway, but there'll be adding some staff in my opinion.
- 2:40It also means I had heard actually ran into somebody today
- 2:44on my walk that confirmed it.
- 2:46But I had heard from a couple of different sources that Chairman
- 2:48Harper was trying to get Ms.
- 2:51Otsuka on before.
- 2:53The board meeting last week, which was when NCUA approved their
- 2:582024 2025 budget, because they weren't able to get her in place.
- 3:04They cut the budget back to an increase of 7%.
- 3:06There were some positions that fell out.
- 3:09But even before that the two Republicans in my mind probably kept.
- 3:13The probably kept climate change from being an initiative that would be
- 3:18discussed in the budget documents or any money spent on I I'd heard that you
- 3:23know, that was something that, that may have been a little bit prohibited from
- 3:28chairman Harper's desires in the budget.
- 3:30And he is adding some staff in the area of specialists on consumer compliance.
- 3:37My prediction is that in 2025, that budget will go up even more.
- 3:42My prediction is this will give him even, make him more empowered
- 3:47as chair, not that he wasn't as chair, but having a second vote.
- 3:51Potentially to back him up on nearly everything he wants to do.
- 3:54I'm expecting that they will be lockstep with CFPB even more lockstep
- 3:59with CFPB on most things that comes out from CFPB, but in particular
- 4:04share overdrafts and NSF fees.
- 4:06So, the first time that you'll probably see something where there's a bit of
- 4:11a more of a full court press on these Democratic, issues will be at the NCA
- 4:16board meeting in January, but also in January, one of the key documents
- 4:20of the year comes out and I'll be doing a podcast when it does come out.
- 4:24But that document is the examination priorities for 2024 that typically
- 4:30comes out in the 3rd week of the year.
- 4:32And while other board members can influence that, that the federal
- 4:37credit union act names the chairman of NCUA as the spokesperson for NCUA.
- 4:43So when letters to credit unions come out, that can be 100 percent the words
- 4:48of the chairman, they can seek input and Todd is of the of the political variety
- 4:54where he does seek input, but in the end, he decides what goes in that letter.
- 4:59So he's going to have a little bit.
- 5:01I Think he's going to lean into consumer compliance.
- 5:03Consumer compliance is always on the priorities.
- 5:06Last year, it had the most verbiage.
- 5:08If you looked at which of the six priorities last year had the most
- 5:12words associated with it, consumer compliance was number one, even though
- 5:15it was fourth or fifth on the list.
- 5:18I'm predicting that'll move up on the list.
- 5:20I'm predicting they will do a full court pressed on share overdrafts and
- 5:24NSFs and probably a few other things.
- 5:26Now, in that letter, they also point out what their exam scope is
- 5:30going to be on consumer compliance.
- 5:32Perhaps we'll see them list more of those of those as priorities
- 5:37more different regulations that they're going to be looking at.
- 5:40Why?
- 5:40Because they have a Democratic led board and because they are putting
- 5:44specialists in in this arena.
- 5:46So, again, you can expect more in that letter.
- 5:50You can expect more in 2025.
- 5:52Now it would have been nice if for, for the Democrats and for Chairman
- 5:56Harper, if she could have been on in time to influence the budget more.
- 6:01But that's going to have to wait to 2025.
- 6:03Five with the caveat that there are two tools that NCOA can use to
- 6:09reorganize monies from the budget.
- 6:11One of those is there is the mid year budget, which happens in July.
- 6:16So you get to July and you decide, you know, we really want to add
- 6:19a few more positions of this.
- 6:20We don't need that.
- 6:22And I will predict that chairman Harper will make some changes.
- 6:27Perhaps the most material changes in a mid year budget in 2024, as
- 6:31we've seen since since Debbie Matz was in charge you know, in 2016.
- 6:36So watch for that in July.
- 6:38But the other thing they can do is they have this power called an overhire.
- 6:42So in the federal government, they have full time equivalents that are FTEs
- 6:47that are approved in a, in the budget.
- 6:49Now, approval of that.
- 6:52the bodies, the numbers, but it also assigns the dollars.
- 6:56Those dollars are not always spent.
- 6:58And so as long as you stay under the dollars spent, you can
- 7:03do what's called an overhire.
- 7:04So for example, I have in the budget for a region, I have a hundred
- 7:08examples, just picking a number.
- 7:10And when I start the year, I only have 90 of those.
- 7:13Folks on board, I get to the middle of the year and I, I still only have 90 on.
- 7:20Well, I have not spent the half that I could have spent that year.
- 7:23That gives me some play in the budget where I can take some
- 7:26other positions over hire.
- 7:28I could say, let's hire.
- 7:3020 examiners and, and go up to 110 and then burn the money at a little faster
- 7:35rate in the second half of the year.
- 7:37Or I could have folks come to the office of the executive director saying, you
- 7:41know what we had a cybersecurity incident and we need more people in that area
- 7:45and the executive director can fund these overhires and then it all kind of
- 7:50comes home to roost at the full budget.
- 7:53That gets approved in November of December for the next year.
- 7:56So it's a good tool that the executive director can can utilize.
- 8:01Now, when I was at NCWay, the executive director reported to the board,
- 8:04but supervised by the the chairman.
- 8:08The chairman has more pull still with the executive director.
- 8:11I think they've tweaked how the appraisal process works for the executive director.
- 8:15So the other board members have a little bit more clout over just reporting
- 8:20to them than they did when I left a couple of years back, but in any event.
- 8:24The chairman can walk down to Larry Fazio, the executive director, and
- 8:28say, you know what, I think we need a few more consumer compliance folks.
- 8:32When you have some over, over higher capacity, I think we should do that.
- 8:35Larry, what do you think?
- 8:37And of course, you know.
- 8:38When the chairman says that to you you have a, you have to have a good reason
- 8:41to disagree meaning that it's not legal.
- 8:44So, I make fully expecting that Todd will be able to flex flex his muscle a little
- 8:49bit and do some things that he's probably wanted to do since he became chairman,
- 8:53but he didn't have that second vote.
- 8:56Now, the other thing is typically you see the.
- 9:00The Democrats vote together and the Republicans vote together.
- 9:04Now I was at NCUA as the deputy executive director back in the year of 2000.
- 9:10And there were situations there where it didn't quite work like that.
- 9:14Then chairman Norm DeMoore was so excited when Yolanda Wheat came in because he
- 9:18had quote unquote, his second vote.
- 9:20Well, guess what?
- 9:21They very rarely voted together.
- 9:23They didn't like each other.
- 9:24They took each other on at board meetings, after board meetings.
- 9:27The things that I heard them say to each other were were chaotic and
- 9:32stressful for staff a little bit less than the professional level
- 9:36that we have now with this board.
- 9:38So now what I'm saying is I fully expect these two Democrats to work together.
- 9:42But it doesn't mean Todd will get everything.
- 9:44Now, Tanya Otsuka is coming over from Sherrod Brown, working with Sherrod Brown.
- 9:49I know that I believe that Chairman Harper is pleased to get her on board.
- 9:56But the way.
- 9:58Todd tends to be while he's on the democratic side, he tends to, on
- 10:02some issues to be more moderate.
- 10:04I'm looking at and looking forward to see where Tanya Otsuka lands on all this.
- 10:10She, she's the first Asian board member, and she's also
- 10:14in her thirties lower thirties.
- 10:16So she brings youth to the board.
- 10:18All of these things are going to be good, but they're going to mean something
- 10:21as to what her agenda is based on the journey she's taken in life and
- 10:25what her priorities are going to be.
- 10:27So it's going to be interesting to see where that goes, but I fully suspect
- 10:30that she will support Todd on many of these initiatives because they are.
- 10:34The ones I've mentioned are big Biden administration, big Democratic
- 10:40Democrats supportive type issues.
- 10:42You're going to see these things in my opinion, coming up in 2024 and beyond.
- 10:49And Todd's got a long run left on his term.
- 10:51I'm sure he's very excited to get into 2024.
- 10:55Now again, as I mentioned on the front end, this is likely going
- 10:58to be my last podcast for 2023.
- 11:01I did a podcast earlier this month where I, two of them actually, where I tested
- 11:06some AI functions and you're going to see a little bit more of that on a related
- 11:12podcast, likely as soon as early 2024, but I'll announce that probably in January.
- 11:21With that, I want to thank you for listening this year.
- 11:24I hope wish you happy holidays, merry Christmas, happy Hanukkah, happy Kwanzaa,
- 11:30and I look forward to recording at least weekly podcasts and likely more into 2024.
- 11:39All right.
- 11:39Thank you so much for listening.
- 11:41This is Mark Treichel signing off for 2023 with Flying Colors.