Latest / Ego and Other Things / How My Father's Abuse Made Me an Anarchist - The Vital Question Series
Transcript
- William: My father had unexamined moral intuitions and values which were never explained to me, and which certainly I was not allowed to question, he used to justify the force and violence and abuse, that he used against me on the basis of unjustified, unexamined moral principles and values. Now, was he really doing it on the basis of morality and philosophy? No, morality and philosophy were a cover for the abuse he himself had suffered and was now trying to work out through me by his abuse. as we'll learn as we go throughout this series, that's actually what's happening in politics too, just on a a more abstract level where it's easier for people to work out their own abuse. As I was beginning to try to work through in process this philosophy of mysticism and metaphysical Satanism that I had stumbled upon. But really before I was able to get exposed to wider philosophy in general, especially the Western tradition, and and kind of cut overcome this mystical philosophy, I began to become interested in politics. In fact, around 15 I was kicked out of my my dad's house, went to go live with my mom, and I still had a lot of unacknowledged feelings, anger, questions that I really couldn't directly confront my parents with, certainly not directly confront my father with. And so I had to find other avenues of understanding and processing these things, much like I had to do with the concept of metaphysical Satanism. So I began to be interested in politics, I think, as an attempt to work out these different kinds of struggles in my life. And much of my political interests, it's centered around concepts of freedom, concepts of authority, the understanding of or the question of what is justice, what is a just use and extension of force and violence and control of the state. against a sit the citizen. And this was a perfect psychological parallel to the question of was it right for my father to use force and violence against me in order to control or correct or teach me? Again, I wasn't really aware of the psychological content of this philosophical attempt at the time. This was something I came to understand later. At the time, this was just politics. This was just something that had industry. You see, my my dad had talked to me about politics and economics, and I had had other conversations with my my grandfather from my mother's side about similar topics. In fact. My dad was this kind of traditional conservative. I'm from the United States, so when I'm talking about conservative, I'm talking about American conservatism, and when I talk about liberalism, I'm talking about American liberalism. And even at the time, those two political orientations were different than they are now. Almost in in some senses unrecognizable. much of this was happening in the in the twenty tens. I think I was fourteen in twenty ten. So we're both conservatism and liberalism had different flavors at the time. But And we'll get into a little bit of about what they looked like and kind of what I was reacting to here in a minute, but I'm just want to setting up the the sort of context for it. politics became an easy path for me to try to work out psychological problems on the unconscious level, because political conversations were a part of my family dynamic. My father was passionate a passionate conservative. He would watch Fox News and he would lecture me about. his his view on conservative economics and conservative other conservative kinds of policies at the time. And at the same time, I would frequently go visit my grandfather. And my grandfather was a a passionate liberal. In fact, I think he was a a hippie. He kind of grew up in the in the the sixties and seventies. Was part of the student protest movements at the time. even part of the I believe it was a a Unitarian church, which is tends to be a very liberal denomination within Christianity in general. Passionate liberal. And both of them, in one sense, were the the stereotypes of their their respective political beliefs. you could have predicted what my grandfather saw thought on the issue of abortion by asking him what he thought on his issue when it came to welfare, right? There was not a lot of nuanced thinking when it came to either when it came to the various positions, it was more like a camp of ideas which they ascribed to, and which didn't necessarily make coherent sense with one another, didn't necessarily align with one another, wasn't necessarily principal thinking as much as it was party thinking. And of course, a very similar dynamic would happen with my father. And I remember from an earlier age, even when I was still living with my father, is my father would say some kind of comment off the top of his head. Let's say he would talk about but talk about welfare and talk about how welfare we shouldn't Welfare, I don't know, welfare was a system that was being abused and the government shouldn't be funding it that much and people should have to go work and you know, some sort of conservative line like that. I would take that, I would hear it, and then I would go to my grandfather and I would repeat the same thing that my father said to my grandfather to see what his response would be, because I knew that these were on diametrically opposite ends of the spectrum. And my grandfather would tell me something about how, you know, the people on welfare. are victims of an oppressive society and much of this has to do with catching up with past discrimination and oppression and we need the welfare state otherwise people are gonna slip through the cracks and you know the again more sort of liberal kinds of points. And I would take those points from my from my grandfather and I'd go back to my dad and I would peep the I would repeat the points to him and see what his reaction was. And I would kind of do this I would I would I would do this every once in a while or kind of as frequently as I could, bec one on the one hand because it was fun. I liked these kinds of conversations. They're interesting to me. And at this point they weren't really real to me. I mean, these concepts were just social concepts out there. I had no idea what what welfare really was or I had no solid conception of the people it was either affecting or hurting. I had no idea whether determined these kinds of things, but I liked talking about them. And I was also fascinated just by the fact that two people who you know from an early age I had a sort of I don't know what to say a facile respect in the sense that every child respects and admires their their parents, at least up until a certain age. And they looked to their parents and their grandparents as you know sources of information and sources of authority when it comes to important topics. So it was fascinating to me. And also confusing to me at the same time that my my father, on the one hand, had very strong opinions about politics that were strongly opposed to my grandfather's view on politics. And I belt I held I held both of these people in terms of I guess respect and knowledge up to a certain age. And that kind of transaction was really interesting to see the contrasting views. And I think it was one of the first things where I had to I had no answer necessarily. I had to reconcile these different political views with one another and the values, you might say, underneath these different kinds of things. So I began that I think that began this political interest that ended up setting up a a perfect psychological capture for trying to work out my own feelings of rage against. the misuse and abuse authority that I had experienced at the hands of my father as a child. And so I wanted to say there was a little bit of this in freshman year, but I wanted to say about sophomore year, I started to become much more actively interested in politics in general, going out of my way to I guess do research on the internet, think about these things almost instinctively, and try to talk about them with the students around me, most of whom didn't really care. I didn't want to have to talk about it or Or weren't interested, which is kind of what sh you might expect from from high school students, right? And I'd have some some small exchanges with my teachers, and I'd have some exchanges with my dad, and I had some exchanges with my grandpa, and I started to develop my own independent attitude towards these two dominant parties. essentially my mind. I I mentioned before how In the 2010s, or at least in the early 2010s, sort of pre 2016, the at the very least, the way that the ways that the parties represented themselves was something like the conservatives, or maybe a more accurate way is to say that the ways in which the parties were presented to me was something like the conservatives were really interested in economic freedom. but social constraint, right? So when it came to problems of economy, when it came to what job you're going to work, when it came to being able to make money, when it be came to, you know, how to spend that money, when it came to taxes, when it came to regulation, when it came to the just the business world in general, the economic world in general, the conservatives favored freedom. They can they favored people being allowed to make their own decisions when it came to their work and how to spend their money, not the government making that decision for them. But when it came to to social issues, issues like abortion and gay marriage and morality and Christianity within government or religion within government, they were seen as socially restricting. They wanted to pass laws and regulations that would essentially force people to act in a way that was in line with the conservative moral perspective. So outlay outlawing gay marriage, outlawing abortion, outlaw outlawing Different kinds of things that they saw as morally objectionable. Now, is that actually was that actually the case of conservatives at the time or even conservatives now? No. Conservatives are I think one of the interesting things about conservatives is that they are as interested in economic regulation as liberals are, just in different areas, right? So They love to spend money on defense spending because they think that defense spending is you know a priority. But of course, both the taxes and the subsidies, all the money that flows into defense defense spending significantly warps the market in a variety of wa in a variety of ways and and defrays all kinds of of costs and monies away from sectors of the economy that could actually use it. They're also oftentimes interested in upholding corporate law, which again protects certain companies from liabilities that smaller companies have to deal with. and again manipulates and more and warps the actual functioning of a free market. So there are a variety of other things that you could bring up to where conservatives are not necessarily interested in a free market. They're interested in protecting their own economic interests. And sort of the same thing when it comes to the social issues. Like conservatives are pretty restrictive in some areas about what they matter. They think that somebody else should be forced to conform with their moral views. And of course, they want to use legislation to force that on other people, but there are also issues like religious freedom, in which conservatives are are very keen to keep the government out of some particular social issues. So While that was the way it was presented to me at the time, I don't really and and oftentimes people still talk about it. I I hear conservatives talking about conservatives as the party of freedom, while the particularly the party today, but even back then, they were let's say their echo their perspective on economic freedom was was Very selective, very selective at best. Even when it came to economics, never mind social issues. And today it's even today it's even more restrictive. since Trump and nationalism and tariffs and things like that. I mean, the government has never been the Conservative Party has never been more interested in using the government to constrain economic activity than it has today. So how they can call themselves a party of freedom, I don't know. But liberals were presented to me in in the opposite light. So when it came to economics, the idea was that liber liberals were really interested in determining how a person spends their money. So using force and violence to extract resources from people and restricting how how co companies and corporations operate and a variety of other things that were meant to either increase the welfare of other people or protect the society in general from the overage of markets and corporations and whatnot. So restrictive economic policies or the idea that the government would be much more involved in the economic life as compared to the social life. And the social life, liberals, at least it was presented to me that liberals were about freedom, about people being able to make their own decisions about you know how they're gonna live their life. So open to gay marriage, not necessarily pro-abortion, I would say probably pro-choice is the best way to put that. You know, tolerating of Trans people. I guess you might say what the whom whom the mas the mass majority of people would consider odd at the time, so tolerance of their lifestyle. Maybe not agreement with him, but tolerance of their lifestyle. That people should be open and free to live the kind kinds of lives socially that they wanted to l to live. It was only that their economic activity would be much more string much more shaped by the government. And so like the simplified split was something like conservatives economic freedom but social restraint by or social intervention by the government. Liberals, economic intervention by the government, but social freedom. And being the and I and I again I I went sort of back and forth between these different kinds of political philosophies, or the two major political philosophies that I was familiar with at you know as a fourteen, fifteen 16-year-old, right? And looking at both and seeing, like, okay, well, what what do I think is actually good? Like, what do what do I think is actually what would I actually want? And when people talked about the economic freedom that conservatives were all about, regardless of whether they actually were about that or not, I was all on board with that. You know, I I I there was something about freedom, freedoms and economy that were. was compelling to me. And I was attracted to thinkers like Milton Freeman or or pro-market economic arguments, you might say, on the one hand. And wary of economic control, wary of socialism and communism and these different kinds of things. And on the other hand, I would look at the liberal camp and I would say, and I would when they talked about social freedom, I thought, yes, like, that's what that's what politics should be about. It should be about social freedom too, because people should be able to make they should be able to, you know, individually decide what they want their life to look like. It shouldn't be up to the to the state to determine how they're going to live their life or or or even what they they think is morally right or wrong outside of obvious crimes. People should be free to creatively and individually live life in the ways that they deem best. And when it came to r the restrictive sides of either of these ideologies, I thought that not only were they bad, but they didn't work, right? So restrictive economic policies, all that happened would that would would be that people would sort of find a way out of them, they would cause distortions in the markets, this would ultimately cause economic problems in in the long run. And so even if you wanted to help somebody by diverting resources to like welfare and And whatnot, ultimately the long-term consequences of that would be more destructive. So not only was freedom and economic policies preferred, but it was actually more effective. And the same thing when it came to social freedom. The idea that we would try to regulate people's moral lives seemed insane to me. And because people were trying to live out their lives individually anyway. And so not and ultimately who would be able to judge? Who would be able to be the person who gets to judge whether or not a particular action or particular lifestyle is immoral or or not? It seemed like bringing in a human authority who had no basis as far as I could tell to determine the difference between right and wrong when it came to many of these non-obvious issues, social issues. And so being the, you know, the the budding political philosopher genius that I was at you know 14, 15. I thought, well, man, we only have these two parties. And over here we have economic freedom but social restraint. And over here we have social freedom but economic restraint. Wouldn't it be wonderful if we could have a political movement that combined both, that combined economic freedom and social freedom. And I got really excited about this idea. I yeah, I got really excited about this idea. I thought, You know, I should become a champion for this kind of idea. I think everybody would, I think you could make the best arguments from from both of these camps. I think, you know, I mean, man, you could win, you could win the presidency doing this. I thought about becoming president, and I was like, well, I'm gonna run for office. I started looking into how to kind of run for office at this point because I was so excited by this political idea's potential to change the world. And in one sense, I thought it was. Obviously true. And so at this point, I started looking into how to make how to how do you go about creating a political party? And I learned about the two-party system. I learned about how the what they call them third parties are sort of systematically discriminated against in the party system. And how the argument of like don't throw your vote away really, really. persuades people not to actually vote according to their interests, but according to the you might say the lowest common denominator, and all these different kinds of things. But most importantly, I think at that point, I started to learn about the third parties that were available. And there were of course a number of third parties available, but the one that really that not so much shocked me, but Well, basically I found the Libertarian Party. And I remember I remember going on the computer and going to the Libertarian website and there was this graphic right there on the front page that took the the conservative position and the liberal position on two sides and it was sort of like social restraint or sorry, it was sort of economic economic restraint and social freedom. On two sides of the liberal position and social restraint economic freedom on the two sides of the conservative position. And then falling in between economic freedom and social freedom was libertarianism. And so I realized at this point: there is already a party who is is doing this, and they're the libertarians. And then I started to learn about Libertarianism. And so it didn't it turned out that I wasn't actually a political genius after all, but that actually somebody had already come around and and put two and two together and actually had started a party and a movement that was based around you know freedom, essentially this idea of freedom from government authority and power and overreach as a political party itself. and they were a third party. I think they're actually the third, the third, like after Democrats and Republicans, the Libertarians party is the third most, I guess, populated party, but it's significantly less. And part of the reason why the Libertarians are unable to can green gain much traction is because they're sort of systematically shut out of both the political process as well as the the media process. which is a whole separate conversation. And I also don't want you to get the the thought right now that I am a libertarian. I'm sort of just talking about my my process through here. I actually have a lot of problems with the libertarian philosophy, but this is where I was when I was, you know, fifteen or sixteen. And so I began to look into libertarianism. And I found a tradition of thinkers or a tradition of political ideas that emphasized this kind of freedom as the as this sort of you might say the guiding principle of politics. And actually that that notion of freedom being the undergirding philosophy of libertarianism was a turning point. for me in my own philosophical p philosophical journey. Because up until that point, I didn't even recognize the this I didn't even recognize the idea of principles underlying a a political philosophy. And When I looked at the Conservative Party, I thought it was just the way that I viewed it, and the way it really is, and that's probably the way I still view it, and the way but the way it really is, is a group of people who happen to share the same interests going in the same direction. so there's nothing there's no principle which underlies the Republican Party. And in the same way, looking at the Democratic Party, there is no principle which underlies the Democratic Party. party. These are both just amalgamations of people who happen to share similar interests. And maybe you can draw some philosophical insights from each party or philosophical focuses from each party. Like you can talk about how conservatives are interested in tradition, generally speaking, or you can talk about how l liberals are more interested in equity and equality. But neither party has a principle which underlies its its philosophy, you might say. It's political outlook. It is amalgamation of people holding similar interests. And that amalgamation becomes what the party is. You can actually see this transfor transformation taking place right now through someone like Donald Trump. Twenty years ago, the Republican Party today would be unrecognizable from the people that were running in, you know, from sort of like George Bush. the sort of neoconservatism the kind of conservative conservatism that Reagan and Bush were pushing for, that would have been completely out of step with the kind of nationalism that and the yeah, the sort of nationalism that that Trump is going for. And in the same way if you took somebody like Jimmy Carter or or Bill Clinton and you compared the the current Democratic Party They would it would be massively, massively different. By the standards of the Democratic Party today, somebody like Bill Clinton is a conservative. So The parties, the name of the parties, you might say, they shift over time. They change what they're all about. I mean, there's literally something called the Great Switch that happened, I I think I want to say in the early early twentieth century. I'm not really sure about the dates on that, but there was a great switch in which kind of the ideologies of the parties crossed over different lines or there was a different mix. And the parties have evolutions throughout time and things which which one party once held dear generations later can become the the new the new standard bearer for the current party. So a hundred years ago, well yeah, I would say all the way, let's say a hundred years ago, you had somebody like Herbert Hoover, who was pro-tariff, right? Conservative Republican pro-tariff was nationalist, right? The Republican Party in the in the early 20th century was nationalist. As it de as it went throughout the 20th century, it became more and more neoconservative, much more about international free markets, in part because of the l the influence of the libertarian, libertarian party within within the conservative coalition. And now it's kind of come back to full circle to being pro-nationalist again. And it's interesting to see. the kind of you can only see almost see the development of the of the Democratic Party in its perspective against this because the the Democratic Party used to be very pro tariff and pro protections for laborers used to be very anti immigration. the Democrats used to be very anti-immigration because it would hurt the the laborers in the in the United States, the the working classes in the United States. And the Republican Party, later in the twentieth century became very pro-immigration because it would help businesses to lower the cost of of labor. among other things. And now you see the Democratic Party being very pro immigration and the Republican Party being very anti immigration, the Republican Party being pro-tariff, the Democratic Party being anti-tariff. So you know and I'm not saying anything any of this to to support or or argue against any of these kinds of things. I I Politically I'm an anarchist at this point. And so all this bickering over how we should use state violence just seems kind of silly to me. But and we'll get to that in another point. But this the the point is to say, I guess going off on this rant here, the point is to say that the party's changed. And really they're just an amalgamation of collated interests seeking power. And really the primary interest is power, not so much principle. And the Libertarian Party at the very least was presented as something which was based on principle. I don't think libertarians are any more principled than anybody else. It was political amalgamation. I think they're just better at trying to sell that sense of like, well, we're standing on principle. essentially because they don't stand on principle. They don't stand on a principle of reason or they don't stand on a principle of freedom in a consistent way, but they compromise with the violence of the state all the time. But my interest in libertarianism starting to see signal a shift in my thinking at this time towards the principles, the moral principles, which undergirded the political philosophy, you might say, the political perspective, or the answer to these certain kinds of policy questions, if you will, or how government should be. And that was the first time where I started. again to I would say descend philosophically. Recognize that the philosophical question of what kind of government should we should we have had underneath it a deeper question of what principle or what moral principle is going to guide the political question. That you couldn't really answer the political questions effectively or coherently without coming to understand some questions that lie underneath. I didn't have that intuition from the beginning. That was something that was first revealed to me when I came up against libertarianism and they presented the idea of freedom as the principle which answers the question of how should we have, how should we set up our government? Now ultimately I would walk away from libertarianism because I would begin to recognize that libertarianism as a political philosophy was was contradictory in the sense that it was interested in freedom in in a wide variety of ways, but when it came to police, firefighter, judges, when it com when it came to sort of the you might say the minarchist state, they were still interested in monopolies of violence and coercion, and one group of people or a person determining the structure. of the state for everybody else without their consent on the basis of force and violence. And so at the bottom they were inconsistent. Now they had a lot of excuses for why they were inconsistent. A lot of this came down to to arguments for so-called necessity, that we need the government, we need a certain degree of evil in the world, I suppose, to have an organized society, which makes you wonder if you believe that you need some kind of evil, some necessary evil if you will, to allow society to function, then why do you say that freedom is an ultimate good? But I might do a video critiquing libertarianism a different kind of time, a different time. I would say that the the most frustrating conversations I have are with libertarians because they're the most inconsistent. they have the grasp of a principle of freedom and they refuse to apply it consistently out of an argument for practicality, which is exactly what the other two parties are doing. Democrats and Republicans are doing the same kind Same kind of thing, but dressing it up in different ways. Which is to say that every political party that exists is interested in using force and violence to impose its way of understanding the world on everybody else who have never consented to a government or an institution or the democratic process in and of itself as a way of determining either its economic or its social life. Again, critiques of the Democratic political system. I believe I I've done a video on this before. So if you're interested, you can go, you can go check that out. but getting back to this movement in my thought that began to take place here, I began to realize that as I said, the political systems underneath they have deeper questions involved. If you want to answer them coherently, if we don't want to be confounded in a bunch of contradictions or if we don't just want to be acting out our own instinctual preven premises at this political level where now, you know, my preferences get forced in everybody else through the through the violence of the state. And that really began my philosophical journey. I because I began to ask the question, okay, what principle should underline our political discussions? And in my political discussions with other people around me, whereas before those conversations would be about, well, I think we should do this and you think we should do that, and we would argue over maybe the details of it without ever getting to the question of values. The question of like what value are we bringing to this argument argument? It began to be a question of values for me. It began to be a question of well, what is right and what is wrong? What should we prioritize and not prioritize and based on what values? And what I found interesting about that evolution into the question of values in my conversations with people is that people were very unwilling to have that conversation with you. If you wanted to argue about the welfare state. and back and forth, right, about the details of whether it was going to be effective or not for something, that was fine. And well, it wasn't necessarily fine. People would have very heated conversations actually about it. So it was not necessarily fine. But It was almost as if my experience is almost as if people lost the ability to really persuasively argue when it came to the question of values. Meaning if I would bring up you know, I i i f at the time, this is just a hypothetical, if I was talking about, well, I think that we should get rid of the welfare state because it's an imposition on freedom through the violence of taxation, something like that, right? And they would say, no, we need to keep it because it's going to help people material materially to live. If I started talking about, well, isn't freedom more important than material? That conversation was something that you could barely barely get to, barely have with somebody before they would really start to get angry with you about questioning their values and about examining values. And, you know, to be fair. Was I necessarily always tactful in my conversations about values? Definitely not. But it was an interesting shift because my argumentation style didn't really change. My the content of what I was discussing with people changed. When I got to the question of values, things were much more volatile. Things were much more shocking. People would look at you oddly for trying to talk with them about moral values. And I think that in part, The reason why that was happening was because people really kind of feel entitled to their moral to their moral values. They well, they feel entitled, that's one thing, but they also never really think about them too deeply. At least this is what I recognize with most people. They didn't really think about their moral values all that deeply. And I even started to experiment. You know, by this time I was I was becoming more and more familiar with philosophy in general and with thinking and like Socratic questioning and this this kind of stuff. And I began experimenting with people when it came to like the basic morality that people accept, right? So we we accept things like, you know, do not murder, do not steal, do not rape, do not lie. There are all these different kinds of moral Axioms, you might say, that as a society we say that we agree on. And I started to take some of those questions and I would go to a person and I would say, Why is it wrong to murder? And the very question, even bringing up the question of why is it wrong to kill somebody, is shocking to people. It's shocking to people because they they think, Do you think it's okay to murder people? Right? So they almost never think about it or never have conversations with it. And certainly, probably children don't bring it up that often, or if they do, they're just hushed down about it. In fact, I this was my own experience when asking about, you know, why is this wrong or that wrong, why is that wrong? A lot of times the reaction that people would get is like, because it is, or because it's against the law, or because you'll get in trouble for it. And none of those things are actually answers to the question of why something like murder, for example, is wrong. And so people were dumbfounded when I would ask a question like that right from the get-go. They didn't know what to say because they never they had never really thought through it all that much. And maybe they would give they would give an example, but ultimately it would it would just devolve into something like, well, that's because of the way it is, or that's because it's it's obvious that it's wrong to kill people. But if you were at all if you were at all skillful with Socratic dialogue or questioning, quickly, people would be unable to answer basic questions. Questions. didn't have a principle. They didn't have a reason. It was just something that a lot of people accepted on authority. Now I was never necessarily doubting that something like murder or theft or anything like that was wrong. I was trying to figure out explicitly why it was wrong and recognized that most people didn't have an answer because they had never really thought about it. And and in that sense, they didn't know whether or not. It was really right and wrong. And even worse than that, there were instances of murder and theft that people thought were particularly justified. I mean, war and taxes are two examples where these are these things are are definitionally murder and theft, but people could not give me an explanation as to why, in the context of these two things, why they were moral and justified. So I began to recognize not. Only that moral questions were at the foundation of political questions, but that people didn't even know why they believed there and they held to the values or the moral beliefs that they had. They had no idea. and they hadn't really thought about it. Now, this wasn't everybody, but this was most people whom I met. Most people whom I met could not answer these questions or give me any kind of coherent Answers to them. And to be fair, I didn't necessarily have an answer to them either. I couldn't have coherently defended it at the time. But it was shocking to me to find out that something which people were basing violence and force off of at a systematic level was being justified by th by intuitions or values that people had never even thought about. That was shocking to me because you think about something like the estate. Which has a monopoly of force and violence and affects us on a daily basis in a variety of ways. And that state exists on the basis of people's moral opinions, which they have never really thoroughly examined at all or thought about at all, but are rather just acting on instinctively. And so people were willing to use force and violence. And the violence and the power of the state to force their unexamined moral intuitions or values on other people without without a second thought. And this was happening on a daily basis. And for the for the astute viewers, you'll notice that one of the reasons I might have been concerned about this from a psychological viewpoint was because this is exactly what my father, and what many parents, but what my father was doing to me. My father had unexamined moral intuitions and values which were never explained to me, and which certainly I was not allowed to question, where what he used as the basis for force and violence. So he used to justify the force and violence and abuse, yelling and screaming and hitting and stealing stuff and forced labor and all these kinds of Actions against me that he used against me on the basis of unjustified, unexamined moral principles and values. Now, was he really doing it on the basis of morality and philosophy? No, morality and philosophy were a cover for the abuse he himself had suffered and was now trying to work out through me on on by his abuse. And as we'll learn as we go throughout this series, that's actually what's happening in politics too, just on a a more abstract level where it's easier for people to work out their own abuse. But philosophically speaking, this began me on the journey of recognizing that If I wanted to have a real political viewpoint, if I was going to get to the point of saying, yes, we should use force and violence to impose, you know, X circumstance on people, then I need to have a thoroughgoing understanding of the moral principles and values that I'm actually bringing to the question of how should we how should we set up our society or how should our government run. And that began my first exploration of moral principles. And My first moral intuition was around that question of freedom. And you know, what freedom meant, what freedom was, why it was of value, why did I want to be free as compared to unfree? I began to think about freedom. Think about freedom. And the question of freedom and is going to be where we're going to go in our next video. since we're we're kind of approaching a good length in this video already. But if I had to say like what should you take away from this video so far? It is I would say the insistence or the mission that you should have towards examining your own moral principles. I am absolutely sure that people that you guys listening to this, listening or watching this video right now, have political opinions. Some of you may have very strong political opinions, but I'm also willing to bet that a certain amount of you have never thought very deeply about the values themselves. I'm willing to bet that some of you your interaction with other people when it comes to discussion of values is to say if we disagree on values, then we're really unable to come, we're really unable to agree or disagree on anything. that the question of values, if it can't be reconciled as if we can't reconcile that as similar, then we simply can't proceed in a conversation. There is this kind of refusal to I would say really phys philosophically confront the coherence of one's own values in the first place. We th we often think that we are entitled to our values, that values are something which we just have and which we have a might might say an unlimited right to hold and to act for the sake of and when people disagree with our values It's an in re it's an irreconcilable disagreement that it can't be something that is it's not something that can be can be brought to to reason or discussion. And that's not true. I mean the the entire branch of ethics is dedicated to what are our values and why are they our values and what justifies them being of value to us. And there's deep and rich conversation there. There's deep and rich ideas there. There's a deep and rich history that has gone on there. It is not enough to stop at what your values are and then to disengage from conversational rational inquiry. But the digging into the basis of your values is something I would say that is as necessary to actually get to the truth of what is of value, the truth of what is moral, the truth of the principles that we bring to any kind of political discussion. If you've never asked yourself the question, why is murder actually wrong? And trying to defend that thesis with another person, this is something that I would try and do. Because you'll find if you haven't done this before, that the basis for your own moral beliefs is a lot shakier than you might think. We have to always be willing to question the foundation of our beliefs as much as our beliefs themselves. The actual context. or the container of our beliefs, as well as the the content of those beliefs. And it's still today my experience that most people I I go up with, they wouldn't be able to to rationally defend their own values or moral philosophy. if questioned seriously. And I find that to be disturbing because we should bring we should be bringing reason to our moral understanding as much as we are bringing reason to anything else. And in fact, I think if we brought more moral if we brought more reason to our our moral discussions and we were more willing to have moral discussions, that the kind like the political discussions in particular that go on in this country would what might be a little bit more productive. We might be less tempted to simply cut somebody off because they morally disagree with us and refuse to conversate with them and therefore create a permanent divide with them. Because we are unwilling to even try to rationally understand moral differences and where they might come from. So I would encourage you to look at the the moral foundations of your beliefs and to really examine those. And you'll find that it's much more difficult to Hold on to prejudice moral beliefs once you actually try to examine them. So that's really what I would take away from this video overall. But in the next video, we're gonna start talking about this concept of freedom and the kind of questions that freedom ultimately led me onto. from this point on, I really fell away from political philosophy in general. It'd be something I I came back to, but I began just to examine much more like I said, morally based questions. Or I I began to dig into moral philosophy and pretty much left politics behind. there was a certain point in which I became an anarchist as I thought that was the most morally consistent position that you could take as somebody who valued freedom, but it was But I was much more interested in examining the notion of freedom than I was in defending anarchism as a political point. And that's still true today. I I still consider myself an anarchist or another word for that might be like voluntarist, just because the actual historical tradition of anarchism is different from the position that I actually hold to. But anarchism is not really something that I concern myself with. all that much or voluntarism on a political level is not something I concern myself with all that much. I believe the deeper questions, particularly the moral questions, are of much more importance than the ultimate political consequences to those moral beliefs. But we will get into that next time. So If you guys have any thoughts, please leave them down in the comments. I would love to be able to know more of your thoughts about this. And as always, thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.