Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #215 - Garth Mullins (Crackdown Podcast)
Transcript
- 0:02Check Podcasts. Welcome back to This is Van Color. Last month, Vancouver
- 0:11police rated DOLF, the Drug User Liberation Front, for operating a compassion club
- 0:17that was purchasing illicit drugs from the dark web to test and distribute at cost
- 0:22to its members. Now, DOLF had received provincial funding, so critics have
- 0:27been asking why taxpayer money was spent on purchasing heroin, cocaine and meth off
- 0:32the dark web. Here to talk about it, we're joined by a co
- 0:35founder of DOLF and the host of the Crackdown podcast. He's Garth Mullins.
- 0:41Garth, so nice to meet you in person. Finally, it's good to
- 0:44be here. Mo. I got to ask you, so DOLF got rated
- 0:47for running this compassion club. For people who don't know what that is.
- 0:51Can you explain exactly what a compassion club is and what it does. Yeah,
- 0:55it's when a group of people that all need something together, Like say,
- 1:00in the early days of HIV AIDS, people organized together to get themselves
- 1:04meds when those meds weren't available, to pool their money and buy meds.
- 1:07People did the same thing in this city for years, with medicinal cannabis to
- 1:12buy. Weeded together when that was still illegal. So it's an old idea,
- 1:17right. And so how much taxpayer or public funds were being used by
- 1:23DOLF in this operation and in the Compassion Club operation. None, all the
- 1:29money that went to buying drugs, buying meth coke, heroin, No public
- 1:38taxpayer money went to that. It was all private donation money. But DELF
- 1:41was receiving provincial funds for other things. Sure, yeah, to run an
- 1:45overose prevention site and to do drug testing. These things are activities that other
- 1:52non government organizations are funded to do. The government pays different community organizations to
- 1:57run these kind of a health services on their behalf. And and DOLF was
- 2:00no different than other groups in that respect. So I've seen a lot of
- 2:02critics basically conflate the two things, saying, hey, listen, DOLF is
- 2:06receiving money for these operations, but also private funds are not. They are
- 2:10buying drugs off the dark web. Can you see where people might have an
- 2:15issue with that that this organization that is publicly funded is buying drugs off the
- 2:20dark web. I mean, there are some politicians that are just outright saying
- 2:23we're taking taxpayer money and buying drugs with it and that's just not true.
- 2:29It's bs We've clarified it many times to some of those politicians, they don't
- 2:32care. It's a nice, you know, sexy thing to say to Volga
- 2:37politicians sticking to their narratives, dar and believe this. Speaking of a politician,
- 2:42I want to read a quote from a BC premier, David Ebe He
- 2:45said after the raids of Dolf. He said, it is unfortunate because they
- 2:49were breaking or they were providing essential life saving work, but they DOLF were
- 2:54also breaking the law, which we will not tolerate. I have my own
- 2:59thoughts on that, but I want to ask you why didn't DOLF go through
- 3:02legal means to perhaps create a safe supply program where they could effectively distribute these
- 3:07ILLSSA drugs to members of their Campassion club. Well, first of all,
- 3:10it's nice of the premier to acknowledge that we were doing life saving work.
- 3:16Why didn't we try and do it legally? First? We did. We
- 3:20didn't set out to be outlaws. We sought permission from Health Canada to do
- 3:24a small you know, to basically give us legal standing so that we could
- 3:30do this service legally. It would give us the ability to negotiate agreements with
- 3:34pharmaceutical companies to you know, get the heroin or whatever from pharmaceutical manufacturer.
- 3:39But Health Canada said nope, no way, so we were sort of forced.
- 3:44We had no other choice. And what do you feel when you hear
- 3:46the premier saying that because he again he's acknowledging that DOLF is doing life saving
- 3:52work. But then he's saying, well, the rules are the rules,
- 3:54and you would just morally think that perhaps life saving work would trump any sense
- 3:59of rules or what is right around. I mean, it's frustrating, right
- 4:01because they've gone and arrested my friends for saving people's lives, so that's really
- 4:06outrageous. Also, this is something the government should be doing. We're doing
- 4:11his job saving lives, protecting citizens as something get governments. Therefore, that's
- 4:15what we pay our taxes for. And lastly, he's in the state,
- 4:19he leads the state, the state makes the rules to change the rules.
- 4:24And finally, if we all obeyed every single rule all the time, we
- 4:28would never get anywhere in history. This is how come we have safe injection
- 4:31sites because people broke that law first and set up unpermitted safe injection sites.
- 4:38This is how we had needle exchanges. It used to be illegal when I
- 4:42started being injection heroin user. Back when I was a teenager, it was
- 4:46illegal to give out syringes and I had to share syringes with other people.
- 4:50So people broke that law. I mean, people break unjust laws to twist
- 4:56the arm of government to move history forward. And we're not the only any
- 5:00ones who've done it. People who are opressed, exploited, otherwise screwed over,
- 5:03they have done it throughout history all over the world. Absolutely, And
- 5:08I want to explain why I chuckled there, because what you're explaining is so
- 5:12simple, the logic is so sound, and I find it's really frustrating when
- 5:15you have the BC Chief Coroner, you have doctor Bonnie Henry coming out and
- 5:19saying, hey, we should change the Police Act, or we should change
- 5:21these rules, or we should make these exemptions, and they get ignored.
- 5:26Right, So that's where I do find it frustrating. I think it's a
- 5:28very excellent point that you bring up in terms of he can make the rules,
- 5:31so why does it he That's right. One rule that did come about
- 5:35earlier this year was decriminalization. However, I just feel like since the passing
- 5:41of d KRIM. We've almost seen a recriminalization with Bill thirty four saying that
- 5:46drug users can't use drugs in public or perhaps even if they're high in public,
- 5:49they could be criminalized for that. We definitely see this push against safe
- 5:54supply. Do you feel like we are being regressive in terms of our drug
- 5:59policy where they're as perhaps some hope at the start of the year, Yeah,
- 6:01I mean it's too bad because decriminalization was only just beginning and we were
- 6:06already seeing some good results. There was a seventy six percent decrease in the
- 6:11amount of people being arrested for simple possession, so less people who were just
- 6:15holding a small amount of drugs, who were just drug users trying to survive
- 6:19the day. Less of those people are winding up in jail. And if
- 6:23you're not going to jail, then you're a better place to go and actually
- 6:27get treatment, or especially you're not getting released from jail with a different tolerance
- 6:30and maybe overdosing. So right there, that's just one statistic from the province
- 6:35that shows we were on the right road, but politically they lost their appetite
- 6:42for it. New Premier David eb and there just seemed to be backing away
- 6:45from all aspects of harm reduction, from safe supply, from DCRIM, from
- 6:49the whole lot of it. And let's talk about that, because there are
- 6:51a lot of people saying like, hey, we've tried the harm reduction experiment,
- 6:55we've done safe supply, and you know what, maybe it's fine to
- 6:58keep people alive or not to instantly from doing drugs, but really we need
- 7:01to focus on getting people into treatment, even if that includes involuntary treatment.
- 7:06What's your response to that that narrative, because I am hearing it a lot
- 7:11from politicians and from people in the dative. Fair comment. I mean,
- 7:14what, we've tried harm reduction studies and pilot projects and very small things,
- 7:18and we've found from the evidence gathered there that these initiatives are really really effective.
- 7:25Like safe injection sites are very effective at avoiding overdose. In fact,
- 7:30they're one hundred percent effective. They're fantastically effective at saving people's lives. We
- 7:34just don't have enough of them. They're just not around the province. Safe
- 7:38supply is also really effective, but only about four percent, you know,
- 7:41only about four thousand of the four thousand of the two hundred and twenty five
- 7:46thousand people that could need it are able to access safe supplies less than two
- 7:49percent. Yeah, right, better math. But what we're seeing is these
- 7:56little pilot projects showing what's possible, but then we never roll them out.
- 7:59We never or expand them to give them a full full shot at being successful.
- 8:05So people might say, oh, we've tried harm reduction doesn't work.
- 8:07We haven't. We've done a few experiments to show what's possible, but then
- 8:11we've never rolled it out, We've never done the next step. So really
- 8:15it's weren't a bad spot. Right now, we are now in the podcast
- 8:18exclusive part of my chat with Garth Mullins. Garth, thank you so much
- 8:22for sticking around. Yeah, thanks, Mo. I got to say,
- 8:24it's an honor to meet you in person. We've done this a couple of
- 8:26times. It's all being remote, but to sit with you. I really
- 8:30do admire your work, everything you're doing at Crackdown Podcast, and I think
- 8:33you're a really important voice in this city. So thank you for your time.
- 8:35I really appreciate that. I like your segments. I like your van
- 8:39color moments on Twitter. I'm always retweeting them, so are re exing them
- 8:45or whatever. Thank you so much. I appreciate that. I want to
- 8:48talk about something that we kind of touched on in the TV segment, and
- 8:52again it is about when you have Public Health Officer Bonnie Henry, doctor Bonnie
- 8:56Henry, you have BC's chief corner. So the point you have experts from
- 9:01Ben Perrin to Mark Tyndall consistently saying for years that we need to amend the
- 9:07Police Act, that we need to expand safe supply, we need to expand
- 9:11certain harm reduction services, and the government just immediately shuts it down, and
- 9:16they're so hardline in saying, you know, we don't want to do this,
- 9:20And there seems to be this cognitive dissonance where the government keeps telling us
- 9:22like, oh, these people are experts and we'll listen to them and everything
- 9:26they want to do on COVID, but not on this other file. How
- 9:31frustrating is that from your advantage point being on the front lines of this drug
- 9:35policy crisis. Well, on the one hand, yeah, it is very
- 9:39frustrating. But also I've never believed that the government just needs to see the
- 9:45right evidence before it, or the right amount of studies, or the right
- 9:48heartstrings need to be pulled, Like I know that policy changes in history changes
- 9:54because you force it. You know that we'd never have gotten a nice reform
- 9:58from government because they're just nice people who have a nice idea. It's because
- 10:01a group of people have organized and twisted their arm and compelled to change.
- 10:07And I mean it's not just for drug users or drug policy, it's like
- 10:11everything. I mean, I'm sure that when eventually the labor code allowed for
- 10:16the weekend, it's not because the boss has wanted. It's because people were
- 10:20on strike, you know, And that's how we get changed. And that's
- 10:24just that's the way it is. When we think about this policy file or
- 10:30this public health emergency. Is part of the issue that drug users can easily
- 10:37be villainized and they can be demonized because again I'm trying to understand maybe your
- 10:41opinion on why the government can see evidence of a certain path and just completely
- 10:46reject it. Oh yeah, I mean, we absolutely are villainized. There
- 10:52was a press release that came out from the NDP government of BC just a
- 10:58few months ago. You know, they were talking about they were getting ready
- 11:01for this new bill thirty four. They changed decrim a little bit to prevent
- 11:07drug use in certain spaces and the headline of the press release was, you
- 11:13know, families are now able to feel safe when accessing public spaces. And
- 11:16the picture of three kids, you know, blowing bubbles on a sunny day
- 11:20with the sunshine and the trees, and the whole narrative is like pointing at
- 11:24me and other people in my community saying you're a monster. The bare sight
- 11:28of you just just being coming into the visual field of children is harmful.
- 11:35And that's really hard to hear because lots of us are parents. Lots of
- 11:39us also were treated. You know, we're around people when we were kids,
- 11:43some of us who shouldn't have been in charge of kids, and you
- 11:48know, we go to great lengths to try and protect and respect kids.
- 11:52We have this thing, you know, down on in the downtown east Side,
- 11:56people say six up when they try to warn each other of cops,
- 11:58and you sort of hear that down the block. It's passed on six up,
- 12:01six up, people say to each other. But we also say kids
- 12:05on the block, and that means, you know, like if you're smoking
- 12:09rock or dealing or whatever, just stop while the family comes through. There's
- 12:13some kids coming through. Just a little respect, you know. And I
- 12:18was taught that growing up when I was a kid, you know, the
- 12:20older the older people around taught me that. The old heads in the East
- 12:24Van taught me that. And you know, I try and pass that along
- 12:28too. But it's like the fact that we're just considered these monsters by the
- 12:33province or by whatever government I think makes us really easy to escapegoat. And
- 12:39it's just interesting that they didn't push back against the narrative about drug use in
- 12:45public spaces because I remember growing up in the nineties and the district of North
- 12:48Vancouver, which happens to be like the wealthiest municipality in all of Canada,
- 12:52and I remember being in elementary school and someone found a needle on the playground
- 12:58and what happened was we had a school assembly about it, just teaching the
- 13:03kids. And I think it was good education because this is real life,
- 13:05and again, it can happen in any neighborhood, but we had like an
- 13:07assembly about it. But if you see a needle, don't touch it,
- 13:11call an adult, whatever, all this other stuff, and so it's not
- 13:13like this phenomenon is new, right, And there clearly hasn't been any evidence
- 13:18to prove that decriminalization has increased discarded needles in playgrounds. No, they are
- 13:24admitted too. Like in meetings with the government, with the health of public
- 13:28health people and with the cops, they've all said there is no evidence to
- 13:31show increased public drug use because of decriminalization. I mean going back to you
- 13:39know, when I was really young, I used in public sometimes. I
- 13:43was very careful to discard my needles safely, so I never left them around
- 13:48where anyone could encounter them. But I didn't have access to a safe injection
- 13:52site. This was before insight, and so I would use in the hopes
- 13:56that if I overdosed, someone would see me ying on the street and call
- 14:01an ambulance or something like that. That was just my way of kind of
- 14:05practicing a little bit of harm reduction, I guess. And then there's a
- 14:09lot of people who just don't have anywhere else to use. So really,
- 14:13if public use is the problem, housing and overdose prevention sites is the answer.
- 14:18Just push Trying to push people to some other location pushes people out of
- 14:22the visual field of the rest of society. It's back into the back alley,
- 14:28and it's in places where if you overdose, you won't be seen and
- 14:31yields die. So then where does this narrative about, you know, the
- 14:37menace of public drug use or seeing people do drugs in public? Where does
- 14:41that come from? Is it not even about the drug users, but it's
- 14:43about having a cudgel to bash your political opponent with, Like, where what's
- 14:50the motive behind kind of spreading something that again doesn't bear out in the evidence.
- 14:54Well, I think I think there's also a lot of visible poverty and
- 14:58homeless that's happening right now. Sometimes these things intersect. There's also been a
- 15:03great backlash against that too, so much so that you know, the city
- 15:09council just sort of partnered with the cops in this giant sweep of Hastings Street
- 15:15in the spring and continuing to do it even though there's no work for people
- 15:18to go. You know. So I think it's I think it's people are
- 15:24offended by visible poverties. Some people are, and popular culture has loads of
- 15:28myths about what drug users are. And you know, we've spent decades scaring
- 15:33the shit out of ourselves with news coverage and popular culture films and stuff like
- 15:37that. Now you and I have been talking about the drug toxicity crisis for
- 15:41years now, It's obviously never been peachy or optimistic by any means, but
- 15:46at this moment in time, again as an outsider, it just feels very
- 15:50grim. And it was something that we touched on the television segment as well,
- 15:54this recriminalization, the popularity of ideas espoused by people like peer polyev ABC
- 16:02Vancouver saying that it won't renew the lease or contracts of an overdose prevention site,
- 16:07not to mention temporary modular housing as well. Am I wrong? Like,
- 16:11does this feel like the lowest moment in terms of this crisis? Because
- 16:15I just don't even like, again, we're kind of rolling back things,
- 16:18which just doesn't seem like it's a good trajectory. I mean, so the
- 16:23numbers have been getting worse and worse and worse, like year after year that
- 16:26it goes up and up, and then there was a point where we were
- 16:30making some slow and incremental progress. The government really never felt a sense of
- 16:37urgency like I do, but there was possibility, and now we're just seeing
- 16:41that evaporate. That they're in full reverse on safe supply, on decriminalization,
- 16:48it seems like on harm reduction, and you know, I'm not sure where
- 16:52this goes but meanwhile the drug supply is getting worse and worse, Like since
- 16:57COVID, we've seen benzo dope become the norm, and that is not just
- 17:03fentanyl, which people got to know. It replaced heroin and fentanyl. You
- 17:07never know how much you're getting her the potency or the dosage, so that's
- 17:11what kills you. But now it's being mixed with benzodiazepines, which the combination
- 17:18of both opioids and benzo diazepines makes for an even worse overalls, and it
- 17:22also makes for if you don't die, you're just like you have memory loss.
- 17:27You feel really disoriented and fucked up, and it's like parts of your
- 17:32life are disappearing. When i'm you know, when I think about you know,
- 17:36my friend she's got she now does benzo dope because she never wanted to,
- 17:41but it brought about a habit. You would become dependent on both the
- 17:45benzos and the opioid part. But she can't remember if we've had conversations.
- 17:49She's just like her life is like a tape with big sections cut out of
- 17:55it, big sections missing, and she's trying to put the pieces together and
- 17:57try and string them together. Can understand what's happening to her, And there's
- 18:02thousands of people like that, and it's just it's making things so much worse.
- 18:04So well over in Victoria, they're playing politics with our lives. In
- 18:11the real world, things are getting dramatically worse, just in terms of the
- 18:15toxic drug supply and then having the abandonment of the only path out of here
- 18:22by the government. It is I think it is one of the worst places
- 18:25we've ever seen. It is the worst place we've ever seen. I want
- 18:27to ask you about fentanyl and safe supply because I think to the general public,
- 18:36this idea of safe supply of heroin, coke, meth, maybe that
- 18:38makes sense, but I still think that even some people who are pro safe
- 18:41supply might cringe a little bit at the thought of safe supply for fentanyl.
- 18:45Is that is that an avenue that you know, Dolph is pursuing, or
- 18:52that is interested in, or just the movement is interested in, or you
- 18:56know, is there a line being drawn in terms of like, yeah,
- 18:59well we'll do safe supply for these drugs, but not for you know,
- 19:02there's there's plenty of discussions about the need for safe supply fentanyl because heroin's good
- 19:07I mean, believe me, hero it is delicious, but it doesn't really
- 19:14substitute perfectly for fentanyl. Fentanyl is a lot stronger, but fentanyl's used safely
- 19:21in hospitals and medical settings all the time. So if you know the potency
- 19:25of what you're getting, you can use it safely. You know, if
- 19:30you've never used drugs before, starting with a bunch of fentanyl, we'll kill
- 19:33you for sure, So don't do that. But there are there are ways,
- 19:37just just the same as heroin and coke of using you know, a
- 19:41pharmaceutical known supply in non potency measure dose all that where you can really reduce
- 19:51the risks dramatically, and and so yeah, we do, we do need
- 19:55to do that. That is the next step. Would would you have any
- 19:57insight into why DOLF didn't sue safe supply of ventanyl then for its Compassion club.
- 20:03I mean, we found it difficult to find good heroin. You know,
- 20:08good heroin is now hard to come by, so it's just like finding
- 20:14finding a good source of ventanyl when you've been cut off from going to pharmaceutical
- 20:22manufacturers. So if we were able to then we would know, But the
- 20:25government has shut that door for us, so we would have to go to
- 20:29the black market and try and find you know, really good ventanyl. That
- 20:33could be quite hard. We felt like we would start with the drugs where
- 20:37we had more access and confidence and experience with them. But I mean,
- 20:45I think that would have been the next chapter. The group was starting to
- 20:48have those kinds of discussions. The results from a year long study of the
- 20:56Compassion Club members was just coming in when the rest took place of the Dolph
- 21:00members, So we were just seeing the great results that were coming through.
- 21:06But I think those same Compassion Club members, the next thing would be to
- 21:10ask them what would improve things for you? And I'm sure a lot of
- 21:14them would say availability to feannol Right, Yeah, Do you want to talk
- 21:19about Eleanor Sturco for a second if you want. I find it interesting because
- 21:26she recently appeared in a YouTube video by YouTubers Tyler Olavera and Kevin Dullgreen,
- 21:32who recently was arrested for something for theft I believe, I don't quote me
- 21:37on that, So she's in this video that I think, to her own
- 21:41admission, or at least to the admission of observers, portrayed the downtown East
- 21:48side in a very negative light. There was a lot of misinformation, and
- 21:52it doesn't seem to register as a political controversy, which I found really interesting
- 21:56because you would think that her political opponents would immediately jump on it, CNDP
- 22:00would jump on that. You think that people in the media would take interest
- 22:03that she appeared in this video that seems to again convey a lot of misinformation,
- 22:08perhaps even disinformation. Why why do you think no one in BC media
- 22:17or you know, the BCNDP hasn't jumped on this opportunity to to bring this
- 22:22to public light. Yeah, I don't know. I think if she was
- 22:27really concerned or was worried about the disinformation that she's associated with, that she
- 22:33would have asked them to take it down or to re edit it or do
- 22:36something. But she hasn't asked for anything like that, right, So I
- 22:38don't think as far as I know, no, I think she I should
- 22:41probably pull this absence we're on record here, I think she said in a
- 22:45tweet. I'm sorry, let me h. Yeah, she said, I
- 22:52currently appear in a YouTube video that I believe is inaccurate and exploitative. I
- 22:56can confirm that I did not agree to participate in the video and was recorded
- 23:00by the filmmakers without my consent. Although I stand by my own comments,
- 23:03I do not agree with the characterization of BC made in the video, nor
- 23:07the premise of ambushing people on the street as clickbait, and so it's not
- 23:12really an apology, but she is saying that the video is inaccurate. I
- 23:17guess I just find in this hyper politicized world that you would think your opponents
- 23:22would jump on that, or the media would have some interest in sort of
- 23:25the social media outrage as we saw with the deputy BC Greens leader for liking
- 23:30an appropriate tweet. So I don't know, I just look at that and
- 23:33I just find it curious that the BC media and again the BCNDP haven't really
- 23:37jumped on her. Well. I think the BCNDP are trying to harvest her
- 23:41votes, right, you can see this, Yeah, I'm sure they are.
- 23:45You can see this by them trying to recriminalize drug users in public spaces
- 23:49and to go backwards on DCRIM. They're trying to get that right leaning voter.
- 23:56And you know there's the Pierre pauliev at the federal level and the BC
- 24:00United Party. They're both drumming up this law and order sort of moral panic,
- 24:07which it seems like every ten years some people on the right try to
- 24:11drum up this, Oh, the city's never been worse. We have to
- 24:15lock them up and throw away the key, all that stuff again. And
- 24:18the NDP seems to want a piece of that action there, which is weird,
- 24:22right because they have a super majority in it shows to me either their
- 24:29gutless cowards or that's what they really think. And probably it's both. They
- 24:34probably have people who are really like law and order chest thumpers among them,
- 24:38and also a bunch of cowards. But it's it is amazing. I mean,
- 24:44if they wanted to do something else, they certainly could because a BC
- 24:48United Party is not winning with anybody. Nobody seems to like them. They're
- 24:52split with the Conservative Party. Why think their policies are something to cheerlead or
- 24:59try to tail eight after? It's ridiculous, you know, It's interesting,
- 25:03right because in that framing, it's almost as if the BC Conservatives, who
- 25:07again they might be pulling high but they only have two seats in the BC
- 25:11Ledge, none of which are elected. The BC Conservatives seem to be pulling
- 25:15the Overton window, right, They're they're forcing BC United to take a more
- 25:18hardline stance, and then by extension, the BCNDP are also you know,
- 25:22moving a little more to the right as well, which is just so strange
- 25:26because again, the BCNDP has a supermajority in BC United, is the official
- 25:30opposition, So why are they being so influenced by the little party? What
- 25:33the fuck are you in public life? If you're just like going to like
- 25:37at the drop of a pin, you're going to start running to the right,
- 25:41Yeah, you know, I mean why why being a party that ostensibly
- 25:45back in history called itself socialist. I know that some of those people did
- 25:49a lot of work to get that word out of there, but you know,
- 25:52come on, what do you what are you involved in any of this?
- 25:56Four? Is there any politician out there getting right on any level,
- 26:00whether it's municipal, provincial, or federal. I mean, the BC Greens
- 26:04seemed to be doing a good job on their criticism of the drug policy of
- 26:10the NDP. Yeah, yeah, yeah, Sony. First then I was
- 26:14doing a good job. Were you in those meetings when when I think Nikki
- 26:18Sharma was there and I guess they had the All Party Committee? Yes,
- 26:22what was the vibe there because they were supposed to have this bipartisan, you
- 26:26know, non political, evidence based approach, and then again now looking at
- 26:33today, they're all kind of divided on this file. So explain that to
- 26:37me sitting in those meetings, well with all the parties. I mean,
- 26:40the government didn't send any ministers there, so the government wasn't taking it seriously.
- 26:44I think it was like make work for the backbenchers or something like that,
- 26:48you know. I mean to me, it didn't feel serious the way
- 26:52that. Like I've been to these inquiries before, bunches of them, you
- 26:56know, and there's usually some to make it seem like an important thing is
- 27:02happening here. This was like a classroom at SFU with you know, some
- 27:04people sitting in it. I think there's some cold coffee on the side or
- 27:08something like that. Right, Like, it didn't feel like something important was
- 27:11happening. I think it's because it was an idea of the Greens, right,
- 27:15so it's like it's a good, good idea, you know, bring
- 27:18all the different parties together, let's make some recommendations on this, let's call
- 27:23some witnesses with expertise before us. Not a bad idea, but the fact
- 27:27that it came from the Greens meant that nobody was going to put much money
- 27:32or effort or serious people into it. So it's just I don't know.
- 27:36So your opinion is that it was kind of designed to fail or it wasn't
- 27:40really designed to achieve anything. Yeah, I mean, the report felt fine.
- 27:45Everything in it seemed decent enough, but it wasn't like it wasn't an
- 27:49urgent call. It wasn't like a good program for the future. No one
- 27:53really took it up and said we're gonna now make this the program of the
- 27:56government or anything like that. Yeah, I just I just I guess what
- 28:00I found frustrating is, from my understanding, the whole point of that All
- 28:03Party Committee was like, listen, we're not going to politicize this. We're
- 28:07going to go out together, we're going to gather information, we're going to
- 28:08come up with recommendations, and we're not going to use this as a political
- 28:12cudgel. And again today November thirteenth, twenty twenty three, all the parties
- 28:19are using it as a political cudgel. No one's sticking to like the recommendations
- 28:23from that report, right, I mean, it was the Green Party's recommendation
- 28:26to take politics out of out of this whole debate, right, But the
- 28:33Green Party aren't going to form government, no, and they're consistently being framed
- 28:37by their opponents and by some members of the media as fringe, right,
- 28:41Like, that's a very Oh they're out there. Even their old leader Andrew
- 28:45Weaver has you know, kind of condemned all the work that they've been doing
- 28:48and saying that they're fringe. So, yeah, I don't know, I
- 28:52don't know how you move forward on that. Yeah, I mean, I
- 28:55just think that they had a good idea there of taking the politics out of
- 28:57it. But since it was their idea and the two parties that can benefit
- 29:03from keeping politics in this are are going to be like sure, pat,
- 29:07pat you on the head, will come to your h you know, you're
- 29:10all party convention, you're all party meetings for a little while. But we're
- 29:14not taking politics out of this. That's that's what politicians do, is politics.
- 29:18Asking politicians to not be political, it's not going to happen, you
- 29:22know, They're the BC United is getting mileage out of this. This is
- 29:26the only thing BC United is visible on, Like, is there any other
- 29:30issue where's Kevin Falcon even. You know, it seems like their leader is
- 29:33like m I A on this too. So I mean, I I don't
- 29:37know, And I would argue they're getting mileage on it, but it's not
- 29:40even resulting in polling popularity, right, So it's like they're in the news
- 29:44about it, but it's not getting clicks because because their ideas are these are
- 29:49the ideas that the BC United is putting forward on drugs are old ideas from
- 29:55the last century of just say no and quid and all this stuff. And
- 29:59everybody out in voter land they've all got someone in their family or someone at
- 30:03work, or someone in their church or mosque or whatever community center it's vulnerable
- 30:08to overdose and death. And they know because they we've all grown up a
- 30:12little bit. We know you can't just quit it. Not that easy.
- 30:15So all these old knee jerk ideas, when they actually hit the ground,
- 30:21I think most people are just like, no, thanks, that's not going
- 30:22to work. Yeah, when we think of the three levels of government,
- 30:27municipal, provincial, and federal, who they all obviously have some responsibility on
- 30:33this file, but who's really in charge, who can really make the biggest
- 30:37impact. Well, I mean This is such a classic Canadian parlor game that
- 30:41politicians like to play, right is they say, oh, it's the other
- 30:45level of government's the Feds, it's the province, it's this, right,
- 30:48it's that. In fact, you're right, like all of them can make
- 30:52moves to do something about this, and when the governments want to cooperate and
- 30:56get something done, they can. Like when the Olympics to Vancouver, the
- 31:00three levels of government worked in perfect harmony. They got the police even to
- 31:04work in a in one group because there was so much money to be made,
- 31:08Like the VPD in the RCMP, who traditionally don't like each other,
- 31:11and ceases and all everybody was all working together in one big, happy family
- 31:17with wearing red mittens. Right, And you just don't see that here,
- 31:21you know, just because there's nothing politically in it. The Olympics is very
- 31:25popular and so there's lots of votes and no one can say no to sports.
- 31:29It's always popular. But this, uh, you know, people dying,
- 31:33it's just not popular, right, So it's like there's there's nothing in
- 31:37it for the for the governments to work together, because they can get more
- 31:40mileage out of pointing in each other and saying, oh, it's their fault.
- 31:42It's their fault, but really, no one's in charge. We have
- 31:45a diffusion of responsibility, and governments love to have a diffusion of responsibility when
- 31:51they want the status quo to continue, But they don't want to have to
- 31:53say that, right, So no one wants to They don't want to wear
- 31:56it. That's right. The status quo is fine with me. No one
- 31:59wants to say that. But if they have a diffusion of responsibility, they
- 32:01get to kind of have a phantom power of the continuing of the status quo.
- 32:07Right. Let's talk about the City of Vancouver and City council and City
- 32:12Hall for a second. You know, there's a lot of criticisms that we
- 32:15can make about Kennedy Stewart and his mayorship, but I think at the end
- 32:20of the day, you know, he was an advocate or a champion for
- 32:23d crim We can again debate how much impact he actually had, but he
- 32:28seemed to be at least sympathetic to what was happening and did seem to care
- 32:34on some level in terms of the drug debt. I voted for him,
- 32:36Okay, yeah, because you know I was in meetings with him and had
- 32:40we had strong words of disagreement about d CRIM but the fact is he put
- 32:45it on the table. He called everyone's bluff and put it on the table
- 32:49after we had been begging for it to get on the table for you know,
- 32:52since the nineties. He actually pulled the switch and caused it to happen.
- 32:55So, like, I give him a lot of credit. He he
- 33:00got off side with the Vancouver Police. Yeah, you know, he said
- 33:05it's reasonable to think about is this budget gone too high? Should we really
- 33:09think about it? He I mean, when a mayor of Vancouver, I've
- 33:14never seen a mayor of Vancouver get off side with the police before they are
- 33:17like yes, sir, yes, or will give you anything you want.
- 33:20So to see that that takes a huge amount of courage. I disagreed with
- 33:23them on lots of stuff, but like this guy, you know, stood
- 33:30up for some stuff and I got a lot of respect for him for that.
- 33:31It was certainly front and center in his platform right when he ran in
- 33:35twenty eighteen. And so I guess I'd like to hear it from you in
- 33:38terms of what's the difference being now that we've had one year of this ABC
- 33:44super majority, what has changed on the ground. I mean, like I
- 33:51think, you know, when Kennedy Stuart ran this this time, he got
- 33:57beat by the back clash, right, and I've seen this before. Philip
- 34:01Owen is the guy who you know, he's an old NPA mayor, but
- 34:05he originally said yes to insight and he got beat by his own party,
- 34:08but by the same backlash, you know, and and and you know,
- 34:14luckily we saw the continuance of Insight through Larry Campbell and other people. But
- 34:19you know, we we saw a strong backlash bring Ken sim and the ABC
- 34:25majority sweeping City Hall and the other boards. And so one of the first
- 34:30things they decided to do was make Van Do a public enemy number one.
- 34:36So we are now, you know, an endangered species because he painted a
- 34:42target on us, and other people like Eleanor have looked at that target.
- 34:46Eleanor Sturko, the shadow Minister of Addictions that we're just talking about, have
- 34:50looked at that target and thought there's political mileage to be made here. So,
- 34:52I mean, that's that's one thing he did for sure. He basically
- 34:58said that any solution to any social problem in this city is just higher cops.
- 35:04He ran on it. Basically the whole Yeah, yeah, Ken Sim
- 35:07Sorry, His whole platform was we're going to hire one hundred more cops,
- 35:10which they did, they ended up one of the few promises they ended up
- 35:15keeping. But the idea that we can solve anything with cops turns this place
- 35:21into a nasty, nasty place. I mean, it's it's already a hard
- 35:24enough place to live, but I think it just really you know, And
- 35:29he was explained that, like just for someone who might be listening and not
- 35:31understand that relationship with police. Right, Well, so for example, you
- 35:38know, like housing, right, the reason why there's homelessness in Vancouver to
- 35:44the extent there is is because the average rent is like twenty five hundred bucks
- 35:46a month. Right. You don't need a bunch of professors to study the
- 35:50problem. It's fucking obvious. And the solution that he suggested, and that
- 35:55Ken sim suggested and saw through was we're just gonna evict people, raid people,
- 36:02send in the cops, shut down Hasting Street, and just evict everybody
- 36:07to nowhere. There's nowhere to go. So that does not solve anything,
- 36:14except for when people have to drive through the downtown east Side on their way
- 36:16to downtown. They don't have to see as many tents now and frankly,
- 36:22it's fucking awful and inhumane. And I was in the middle of it.
- 36:25I saw it, and it was it was nasty. I mean, it
- 36:28was just it's terrible. And that idea that that's what we need to do
- 36:34is just call the cops on any social problem. It's just it. Not
- 36:37only is it a cap on the imagination like thinking of what's possible, of
- 36:43how we would actually do something about this, it's just kind of reinforces this
- 36:49nasty spirit. Right, Yeah, you bring up the rent thing, and
- 36:52that's something that I agree is obvious and I have done, you know,
- 36:55a rant on it and on television, but it's to me again, that
- 37:00was one of those commentaries that I got a lot of backlash, people being
- 37:04like, oh, you're being too reductive. You know, homelessness is not
- 37:07tied to the cost of rent. And I'm not saying it's entirely a one
- 37:10one on one to one, but it's like it's a major factor in terms
- 37:15of just affordability in this city. But then homelessness, right, so,
- 37:20how do we not look at the the cost of rent? And there is
- 37:23a good percentage of the population that doesn't equate those two things together, and
- 37:30it's it's mind boggling to me, Like you and I consider here and be
- 37:31like, ah, it's obvious, but I'm just wondering, like, how
- 37:35do we lose How did some people in the population lose the idea that these
- 37:39two things are related. Well, it's it's scapegoating and gas lighting, right,
- 37:44Like we've been talking about how drug users get scapegoaded for stuff. So
- 37:47it's easier to say, oh, homelessness is because of drug users. They're
- 37:52homeless because they use drugs. You know. It's it's like sort of that
- 37:58same mental health fit up too, you know. And so the solutions start
- 38:01to be instead of we actually have to invest billions and billions and build public
- 38:06housing, no, the solution turns out to be we have to reopen the
- 38:09old Riverview buildings and just lock people up, you know, And that lock
- 38:13people up is a lot more simple, knee jerk desirable thing for a lot
- 38:16of people, because we've got this country that's built on this idea of banishment,
- 38:22you know, of some people get to be here, some people don't
- 38:24get to be here, and you know, it sort of goes back to
- 38:29the DNA of the country, I guess, but it's yeah, it's it's
- 38:34a sad state of affairs. But that's that's the law and order chest thumping
- 38:38stuff, you know. That's and that politics always seems to take off.
- 38:45And people have been told this by people, politicians, newspaper columnists, different
- 38:52kinds of experts. So I think that a lot of people's own common sense
- 38:54would be when they think, oh, my god, the rent is killing
- 38:59me here. You know, they see their own paycheck right barely making it.
- 39:02They think my kids can't live in the city, or they think of
- 39:07themselves Jesus, I almost had a brush with homelessness when I changed jobs a
- 39:10year and a half ago or something. They might think that, right,
- 39:14they're in the same lot with homeless people who are living on the street,
- 39:19renters and people without housing. They're all in the same lot, right,
- 39:23And that's kind of a scary thing to think. But we're constantly told to
- 39:29not think that way, right, you know, And we're all different and
- 39:31those are different people because of drugs or mental health or something like that.
- 39:36You know, has the city done anything to sort of give you hope?
- 39:40And again, I know I touched on the fact that they're going to let
- 39:44the least expire on that overdose prevention site. But has there been any outreach
- 39:46from the city to drug users that makes you think, Okay, maybe there's
- 39:51some openings here. No, I don't think so, not that I'm aware
- 39:55of. You know, we've at van du Vancouveria Network drug users. Anytimes
- 40:00someone treats us bad in the media, you know, like Eleanor Sturko or
- 40:05the city, we write to them and we invite them down. We and
- 40:08we don't do it in public. We just write a very like non aggressive
- 40:13letters saying might just come down and they can see it's not a very fancy
- 40:15place and you can see the kind of programming and kind of people who are
- 40:22part of VAN do. We always extend the invitation, but we never get
- 40:25They never take us O so VANDU is written to Eleanor Sturko, es mayor
- 40:30Kenson. Yeah, the city, the city manager or whoever they didn't not
- 40:36yet can take I don't think so. I'd have to check up on the
- 40:37city thing, but Eleanor Stirko is the more recent one. Yeah, any
- 40:42response just very busy. But I mean, if somebody is going to use
- 40:46us as a as a pinata in public and beat on us with a hockey
- 40:52stick. They at least ought to come down and see what's going on.
- 40:55Yeah, I just think that's good practice. I mean, I obviously,
- 41:00you know, I will happily go at certain politicians on this program, but
- 41:04I've always said that they're more than welcome to come in and give their side
- 41:07of the story, and that's really all I can offer. And I get
- 41:10complaints all the time from different you know, elected officials or their staffers,
- 41:15and that's always just my response is, you know, first of all,
- 41:16if you think I got something completely incorrect, let me know something that was
- 41:22not factual, and you know, take it up with check if you'd like.
- 41:25But then if you just think I was being unfair or wasn't presenting your
- 41:28side of the story, then come on and let's talk about it. And
- 41:30again, some people are and then some people some people just don't even want
- 41:35to do that, which makes me wonder how genuine they are in terms of,
- 41:40you know, their own beliefs, right, or if it is just
- 41:44political. We did the same thing on Crackdown, you know, we started
- 41:47in our first season. I interviewed Steve Addison, who's the chief communications person
- 41:52for the Vankover Police Department. I think we had the Minister of Housing Shane
- 41:58Simpson on or whatever it was development. Yeah, yeah, that's it.
- 42:02We had some other minister on. I think I've tried to have addictions ministers
- 42:07on crackdown before, but you know, they screwed around. We eventually just
- 42:13said forget it, you know, and and when I would we did have
- 42:15a couple of ministers on. What they had to say was just pure politician
- 42:20bullshit. It made terrible radio. So it's just like and I didn't want
- 42:23to cut it, you know, to you know, we never cut it
- 42:25to make them seem like like they're saying something they're not. But it is
- 42:30like, you know what, I don't does that whatever. But we still
- 42:32give people the right to reply, right if we're going to cover something,
- 42:36we always send saying you know, we're going to write this and do you
- 42:38have anything to say on this or whatever. I just want to end on
- 42:42this note, and I you know, it's not particularly important, but I
- 42:45would like your thoughts on it. Obviously there we touched on this in the
- 42:49TV segment. There's this controversy surrounding when Attorney General Nikki Sharma, who was
- 42:55not Attorney General. I think at the time when you had met her,
- 42:59NBC PREMI David Ebee, when were they aware that Dolf was purchasing drugs off
- 43:04the dark web? It's this, this fucking watergate, like you knew what
- 43:09when? Where's the missing eighteen minutes of the Dolph tape? Well, that's
- 43:15what I want to get on it. It's interesting because the public, in
- 43:16terms of media and certain politicians have like really lapsed onto this that they want
- 43:21answers about when when this When we learned this? I mean I saw,
- 43:24I saw the piece that came out, and then I saw a lot of
- 43:27other people in media is in on it. Everybody has fucking known it forever
- 43:32because we told the world Aaris and Jeremy were in Time magazine. We told
- 43:37everybody what you're doing. Everybody knew, including Eleanor Stirko, including the right,
- 43:43including Pierre Paulieff. Everybody knew. Well, I remember there was a
- 43:46protest that you guys had a year ago, year and a half ago.
- 43:50Jean Swanson was right, yeah, Geane, So I saw hand of the
- 43:52drugs. You know, everybody thought it was public knowledge. Yeah, but
- 43:58but do you find it's weird that like the focus is now on this like
- 44:01who knew what, as opposed to again the daily drug deaths. Like it
- 44:06just seems to be this diversion of like what's at the core in terms of
- 44:10what's important, you know what, I mean, absolutely absolutely, And it's
- 44:14because the people who are asking who knew what, when where don't care if
- 44:19we die. It really seems to me because if they did, they would
- 44:22be offering some kind of solutions to this, you know. And I mean
- 44:27they would say if they were here, oh we've we've probably said more recovery
- 44:31beds or something like that, right, But I'm here to tell you like
- 44:35I tried to quit. I tried to go clean and be absent, and
- 44:38I tried and wasted years of my life trying to do this. And if
- 44:42other people make it, that's great, but I never could. It's really
- 44:45hard. Yeah. And you know, I've sat in NA Narcotics anonymous twelve
- 44:51step group rooms full of people and the person doing the talk will say,
- 44:55how many people have been here before? You know, like have have been
- 45:00part of NA and then started using and gone away and come back and gone
- 45:04away? How many people have been here before? Once and hands go up,
- 45:07and then and keep your hands up for twice, three times, four
- 45:12times. And there's tons of the room, so almost nobody who's never been
- 45:15before. Everyone's relapsed and come back and relapsed and come back. And then
- 45:20they say, at the end of the thing, keep coming back. The
- 45:22program works if you work it, keep coming back, they say, And
- 45:24that's great, right, But it also says this is a year's long process
- 45:30if you're gonna try and get clean, right, and some people over the
- 45:35course of those years will make it, and some of us won't ever be
- 45:39clean, Like I don't think I'll ever be without some kind of opioids in
- 45:44my system. But you don't have years when the drug supply is lethal,
- 45:49right. We need something that's gonna work this afternoon. You know that's gonna
- 45:53work right away, because every time you relapse, you're going and using off
- 45:59the toxic drug and you could die. Then you won't be able to come
- 46:01back to the NA meeting and have another shot at it. So I mean,
- 46:07that's why I don't think it's very serious. Anybody who's really serious about
- 46:10this isn't gonna say recovery and that's it. I think that recovery is an
- 46:17option, but people have to be alive to get there, right, So
- 46:21it's it can be part of it, but it can't be the only thing.
- 46:23And I certainly shouldn't risk death if you're in a relapse or yeah whatever,
- 46:28or just as a user, you shouldn't be risking death by ingesting or
- 46:34consuming what you're consuming. I know I said that was the last question,
- 46:37but I have I think I've won more and it is it is one that
- 46:42is more inward focusing because I'm a part of quote unquote the media. What
- 46:45do you think the media gets wrong when they cover this particular file? Is
- 46:51there something that kind of grates you in terms of what you see that that
- 46:55is presented to the public. Yeah, I mean it's like so hard to
- 47:00say the media, right, because it includes things like the post media chain,
- 47:07like it's the biggest newspaper chain in the country, and they just they
- 47:10will publish things that are factually incorrect about the about the whole situation. Right.
- 47:17There's things like CBC, which is does does a much better standard,
- 47:22but you know it can be hit miss. There's people like you that do
- 47:25a much better job. So it's like hard to think of the media as
- 47:30all one thing. But if I was to try, I would say that
- 47:34too often the sort of vibe is like that the overdose crisis is kind of
- 47:38like this force of nature or this like this accident that's happening, or kind
- 47:44of like COVID. You know, this this thing, but no one's really
- 47:46intentionally causing it. You know, it's this we'll all try and do something
- 47:51about it, but it's kind of like a hurricane or something like that.
- 47:52You know, but it's not right, It's it's actually it's because of it's
- 47:59because of a bunch of policy decisions that have been made. Right, that's
- 48:02why we have the overdose crisis because the drug market is unregulated. So whereas
- 48:08like what's in the coffee is regulated, what's in the iPhone is regulated,
- 48:13right, Like we know of those things. There's safety standards. There's like
- 48:17it can only have so much caffeine, or the beans have to be whatever.
- 48:21Right, there's like I don't even know the details, but actually trust
- 48:23that there's a system that make sure that I won't poison myself for the top,
- 48:27Yeah, and there's nothing like that for drugs. Right, If the
- 48:30coffee was poisoned, it'd be a huge scandal. That's right, Yes,
- 48:34that's right. Right. So, but with drugs, we decided we have
- 48:37the most out of control system. Like if people want to put some control
- 48:43on this, then the idea should be to regulate it, like to put
- 48:46some kind of rules around it. David Ebe talks about it's important to follow
- 48:50the rules. Right, there's no rules on the drugs, on what's in
- 48:53the drugs. You know, if we would actually try to regulate that,
- 48:58then we could save a lot. So the media coverage, you know,
- 49:00some people get done and some people say it, but it's just like the
- 49:05politicians themselves that are covered in the media that maybe are like, oh,
- 49:08our hearts are heavy today with the most recent statistics about how many people have
- 49:14died. It's like, well, if your hearts are heavy, it changed
- 49:15the rules. Yeah, you know, And I think that's I would like
- 49:20it if more often media would bring it back to the authors of this whole
- 49:23disaster, which are government. Yeah, you know, they're the ones who
- 49:28have done is they're the ones who could undo it and just say well why
- 49:31don't you you know, and and and you know, that's that's the angle
- 49:36that it should be. I think that's a great answer, and I think
- 49:38it actually applies to a lot of quote unquote crises that we have. I
- 49:43mean, I er percent. I do believe that the housing crisis is by
- 49:46design. And that's not to say that David is there trying to make a
- 49:51housing crisis. It's just to say that there were policies built on policies that
- 49:54actually exacerbated and worsened conditions to the point that we're at. And I do
- 50:00find frustration in the idea that that is a controversial statement. Yeah. Right,
- 50:06If you say all the housing crisis by design, it's like, well,
- 50:07no one wanted this, and it's like, actually, no, they
- 50:10did want to inflate land values, you know. And then you get to
- 50:14pivot to something from earlier on in our conversation, which is the diffusion of
- 50:17responsibility between the different levels. So if you say, hey, if you
- 50:22are sad, are so sad about it or angry about it, why don't
- 50:23you change the rules? Ah, well, it's this other level of government
- 50:27over here. But my response to that is, when you guys really want
- 50:30to do something, you all cooperate. Yeah, like the Olympics, Like
- 50:34the example I gave, when government really wants something it will move heaven and
- 50:38Earth to do it, you know, like when when we were worried that
- 50:43COVID was going to really ravage and kill our province, which I mean,
- 50:45which it did. Yeah, a lot of people did die, a lot
- 50:49of people did get very sick, and we're still in it. But there
- 50:54was no end to what we would do, right Like, especially in that
- 50:58first wave. I never thought I would live to see the day when they
- 51:00unplugged the economy of the earth, but they did that. And you don't
- 51:05need to unplug the economy of the earth to solve the overdose crisis. You
- 51:09don't need to even unplug the economy for a minute. We can do it
- 51:14with much less disruption. It just needs a bit of courage. I can't
- 51:17think of a better way to end this conversation, Garth, You're the man.
- 51:22Really a privilege and an honor to be able to meet you in person,
- 51:24to have these chats as we have over the years. So thank you
- 51:27so much for your time. Yes, Sta, I'm back at you,
- 51:30and stay safe and keep sick. Absolutely, folks. We haven't done one
- 51:34of these long form pods in a while, but I'm so glad that we
- 51:37could and of course, what a privilege and a long time coming to host
- 51:39our guest in person. He is the host of the Crackdown podcast, which
- 51:44you can find wherever you're listening to this podcast. He is, of course
- 51:46Garth Mullins and I am Moamir telling you that in a city where you can
- 51:51be anything, be colorful pace