Latest / Where Parents Talk: Evidence-based Expert Advice on Raising Kids Today / We Don't Have to Fix Everything: How I Teach Teens Resilience Without Becoming a Helicopter Parent
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to the Where Parents Talk podcast.
- 0:09We help grow better parents through science, evidence, and the lived experience of other parents.
- 0:14Learn how to better navigate the mental and physical health of your tween teen or young adult through proven expert advice.
- 0:22Here's your host, Lianne Castelino.
- 0:28Welcome to Where Parents Talk.
- 0:30My name is Lianne Castelino.
- 0:31Our guest today is a resilience coach and a speaker.
- 0:35Ann Paphitis is also a personal reinvention expert.
- 0:39She previously ran a school for kids who didn't fit the mainstream, many of whom were grappling with anxiety, depression, or bullying.
- 0:48Ann is also a mother of three, and she joins us today from Cork, Ireland.
- 0:54Welcome and thank you so much for being here.
- 0:56Hi, Leanne.
- 0:57Thank you so much for having me, and hello to all your listeners.
- 1:01Well, and we're talking about a subject matter that is a buzzword in many ways, but we're hearing about it more and more all the time in different aspects of society, and that is resilience.
- 1:11What did working with kids, young kids who were struggling, teach you about resilience that perhaps no textbook could have?
- 1:22That's a really great question.
- 1:24And, well, it's hard to say because I didn't use a textbook.
- 1:29I really just went with what I experienced with the kids.
- 1:32But what I did learn is that resilience does exist in everybody, that it just needs the right conditions and nurturing for that to become apparent or to bloom within those people because it's very easy for it to be
- 1:53suppressed or even destroyed.
- 1:56So really, it's about the patience and the willingness to keep really seeking for that resilience that exists inside everybody.
- 2:06You know, especially in the teenage stage, I think, like younger kids are perhaps a little more resilient, but certainly as they come into the teen stage, it becomes a lot easier for the resilience to become kind of damaged.
- 2:22So it's really about believing in the ability for everybody to overcome whatever it is that they're going through and to have the patience to allow that to happen.
- 2:32Because it varies wildly from child to child.
- 2:36So some people just need a little bit of support and encouragement.
- 2:40And the next thing you know, they're up and running and they've bounced back.
- 2:45But for some, it really, really is quite deeply buried.
- 2:48And so it takes really long to make sure that get them to recover from whatever it is that has put them into the state that they're in.
- 2:56So it's really, I think the main thing that I learned was patience and to never give up, to never stop believing in the possibility there were many times that we had students that some of my colleagues or staff
- 3:10members would come to me and say, I really don't see how we're going to get this one through.
- 3:14And I don't think that they're going to change.
- 3:16And I'm a real soft hearted person and I find a very, that's my default setting is to believe in people and believe in the best in them.
- 3:27And so it was always very hard for me to ever want to give up on you.
- 3:31And in fact it really was impossible.
- 3:34So I would persist in saying we have to keep believing, we have to keep trusting, we have to be patient even in the face of massive adversity.
- 3:41You know, children who would just behave in such a difficult way because they, it would seem as if they were almost self sabotaging, but you just have to keep believing that if you keep trying different angles and different
- 3:55ways to get to it, you would eventually get there.
- 3:58So patience.
- 3:59Patience, yeah.
- 4:01And let's unpack what that means from a parent's perspective.
- 4:05In the household you talk about, you know, having the conditions for resilience to sort of blossom and come to the fore and nurturing is, is part of that.
- 4:14So what does look like for a parent on the day to day when they're trying to set the table or the foundation to build resilience in their kids?
- 4:25Look, that's a really, I mean that's always the million dollar question for parents and I think there's no real simple, straightforward answer because it really does depend on the family dynamics and the way things are going and what
- 4:40your child is experiencing.
- 4:42But I think the main thing, lesson I learned first as a parent and then as someone working with other people's children is that, you know, parents can sometimes, or for all of us, it's quite difficult not to project
- 4:58our own perceptions onto the child.
- 5:01So when.
- 5:03And there is.
- 5:04And I learned, I remember quite distinctly learning this fact, looking at my daughter and thinking to myself, she is not me.
- 5:15She is a different person.
- 5:16And her experience of the world and her view of the world is not mine.
- 5:21So for parents, I think the hardest lesson to learn is that no matter how much you think you understand what your child is going through or what they feel, you really don't.
- 5:32You might have an idea or you might have experienced something similar, but you cannot know what they were feeling or what they were experiencing.
- 5:41So it is really important in my view to remind yourself that you are not your child.
- 5:48You can't possibly know.
- 5:49So the advice to me as parents always is to try to engage with your child to really understand what it is that they are going through and what is causing these difficulties and to put aside the judgment, you
- 6:06know, as, as parents, we often find it much easier and we much more patient and understanding talking to almost a complete stranger or a colleague at work than we are with our own children.
- 6:17And that's because of the way we project onto them.
- 6:20When they're very small, we very involved in.
- 6:26What's the word?
- 6:28Shaping their view of the world.
- 6:31So it's easy to imagine that they've become these beings who share our outlook and our feelings and our abilities to deal with things that come on.
- 6:42Come to, you know, along in the path of life, but they really don't.
- 6:45And that was the thing that amazed me the most and the thing that was always the.
- 6:50The most transformative breakthrough when working with children and their parents.
- 6:54Bearing in mind I wasn't in the.
- 6:56In the role of an advisor to parents on how to parent their children, I was just working with their children, but very in a meeting I would have with them, giving them feedback on their child's progress.
- 7:05They would, you know, ask me things or, you know, have questions about the way the child was developing.
- 7:11And when I would explain to them that this is what the child was experiencing was very often like a watershed moment for them because for them, they did not really understand that that was what the child was, how
- 7:23the child was experiencing their life and their environment and what they were going through.
- 7:30So it's hard to get through because kids don't often share that with parents.
- 7:35They feel like they might disappoint them or they might feel as if the parent won't understand.
- 7:41That's the main thing I used to get from kids is my parents don't understand.
- 7:45When I try and explain to them, they get cross and they shout at me because they expect things of me.
- 7:51You can be a really patient parent, but you might not be hearing exactly what your child is saying.
- 7:57You think you're listening, but you're not hearing.
- 8:00And it is difficult.
- 8:01And sometimes my advice to parents would be, is get someone to help you work through this together.
- 8:07So, you know, finding professional help, somebody who can bridge that gap of communication between you and help you and your child communicate with each other better if you really find you're not getting through.
- 8:18So my advice to parents is if you aren't seeing progress in terms of not, not necessarily just in your child becoming better, but in your communication getting better, look for some professional support and help it could be a
- 8:35teacher or somebody that you, that your child feels comfortable with and, and shares with and then to work together in, in a group space where you maybe have someone that's a mediator between you.
- 8:45Because very often things get heated.
- 8:48You know, children will say things and then the parent gets angry and they feel like this is not right, my child is being disrespectful or whatever the case may be.
- 8:56So communication is really important.
- 8:59So I don't know if that answers your question, but, but that's been my experience with that.
- 9:03It does.
- 9:03And building on that point because you've said that we all have the capacity for resilience.
- 9:07So then I guess the question then becomes can resilience be taught or must it be experienced?
- 9:17Look, I think that's difficult because certainly there's a way in terms of leading someone towards a more resilient outlook and way of being.
- 9:30But we all learn differently and certainly in the teenage years years, I think it's a lot harder for them to, to absorb or take on board something simply by being told or shown something.
- 9:44The teen years is very much about experience and experimenting.
- 9:48So enabling your child to, to develop those skills themselves is very important.
- 9:56It is challenging because you know that it's a very precarious age because you're walking the line between making sure your child gets out of this alive, literally or helping them to become fully fledged adults who can make really
- 10:12good decisions and you know, be resilient and productive adults.
- 10:20So it's a bit of a fine line.
- 10:22So it, I think it really depends on what it is that the child is having resistance to and their particular personality.
- 10:32So you know, that's something that a parent would need to try and gauge if, if they keep, you know, banging on at the child and, and it just doesn't seem to be getting through to do stop and ask
- 10:43yourself that question is, would, would my child learn this better through actually experiencing and then thinking about a way that you could do that without putting them any kind of danger or, or a situation where it's going to
- 10:55be long term detrimental so, you know, end up failing a year at school or something, you know, so, so trying to find ways to build that resilience and in the child without being harmful, not just from a physical
- 11:09and, and outcomes perspective, but also long term like in terms of making their resistance to this worse.
- 11:18So yes and no.
- 11:20You can.
- 11:21Some, for some kids just explaining it to them gets through to them, just you know, seeing it laid out, they get the idea.
- 11:27But for some of them.
- 11:28They really have to experience it and see the value in what you're saying for themselves actually being able to turn around going, I didn't really believe you, but now I see the result.
- 11:38So when a young person, be it a child or you know, an adolescent, goes from self doubt to thriving, what is usually the turning point?
- 11:48Is there something that we can identify as a commonality in terms of what is the tipping point for them there?
- 11:59Yeah, that's a really, really good question.
- 12:02And I have to say it's, it's not something I've actually ever really managed to pinpoint where that change comes about because in my experience it's very often incredibly gradual.
- 12:17It's a bit like, you know, a snowball rolling down a hill.
- 12:20So it starts off slowly and like it's not very visible and then the next thing you're aware that it's picked up momentum and it starts to have its own sort of self propelling mechanism going on.
- 12:32So I can't say there's really a, a pinpoint.
- 12:35And again, it really depends on the individual.
- 12:39You know, some of them really need you to keep pushing them along, pushing them along and then only then they really slowly take.
- 12:45So I mean we had some kids who, who honestly maybe started when they were maybe 10 or 11 with us and it was only about the time they were 16 or 17 that you really saw them start to
- 12:56come into their own.
- 12:57And then you had others who came in and, and within a year were completely different beings.
- 13:02So, so that, that tipping point very much varies.
- 13:06But I think it's when, when, when they themselves start to see that they, they are changing and they feel that and it's often in the way that they engage with their parents as well.
- 13:20So it's when they suddenly don't feel like the parent is always on at them about something and that, that can happen.
- 13:28You know, it really depends on the dynamic of the relations quite slowly.
- 13:33So their perceptions take, take a while to change on that.
- 13:38Yeah.
- 13:39So on that note then, how does practice play a role in terms of closing the gap between a child believing they're capable of doing something and them actually doing it and you know, and knowing that they're able to
- 13:54do it, but actually believing they can do it?
- 14:00I mean it, practice is everything because one, one incident of them getting something right or managing to overcome something is not going to undo it.
- 14:10You know, and again it depends on the age of the, of the child and, and what they've been through.
- 14:14So I mean we know there's These adults who still struggle with some of those things because they haven't had enough opportunities to undo the damage that's been built into their, into their mindset about themselves.
- 14:28So creating repeated opportunities for your child to, to prove to themselves they can do something is really, really important.
- 14:37And being always mindful of the way that you feedback to them about how that went is so, so the practice is not really just for your child.
- 14:49It's also for you as a parent to, to work on the way that you leverage those opportunities to improve your child's self esteem and their ability to keep pushing forward.
- 15:04You've certainly had a lot of experience in your own life.
- 15:07And in terms of your lived experience with resilience, can you take us through some of the highlights and how did that inform the way that you chose to raise your children as it relates to resilience for them?
- 15:25I think the underlying philosophy that I've always had for myself, which, which I know, like underlying philosophies of your life is a bit of a weird expression because none of us are walking around going, you know, this is
- 15:41my philosophy in life.
- 15:41You're just kind of living and existing and being.
- 15:45But, but I certainly did apply it to my own children and, and it informed really the foundation of the school that I, that I set up.
- 15:54And that was the belief that, that, that we all want, want the best for ourselves and, but that, that most of us, I mean as humans, we're, we're like the same as animals.
- 16:12We want to avoid pain.
- 16:14We experience things that cause us to be afraid of reliving that particular experience again, we start, you know, we build into our minds, oh, I did that.
- 16:26And that led to this negative consequence and it's very hard to undo that.
- 16:30So what I would do for myself primarily, but what I would teach my children and the children in the school to do was to, when faced with something that felt daunting or, or that you, that you were afraid
- 16:43of what was going to happen is to really sit and think about what is the worst outcome that could happen from this thing happening and to really paint, I mean, depending on what it is.
- 16:55I mean, some things are low stakes, but some things are high stakes.
- 16:58But to work out what does that mean for me, what are the different possible outcomes for this?
- 17:04And if I, if, and then, then get to that outcome and then say if I, if this is what happened from this thing that I'm going to do, where would that lead me and what would my options be?
- 17:16And really having a multitude of potential scenarios and what those outcomes would be and where they would lead you to.
- 17:24And really, the word I used, the expression I used to use, is to walk it all the way down to the end of the line and then see and then assess that absolute worst case scenario, worst outcome at
- 17:38the end of the line.
- 17:39Where does it leave you?
- 17:40And what would you do if that's where you were?
- 17:43Because very often for students, it's the unknown that scares them of doing something.
- 17:49So when they think, oh, if I hand this assignment in and I get a bad mark, and then they become paralyzed and they can't do this work because they're scared because they might get a bad mark.
- 18:02And then if you explain to them, well, if you got a bad mark, what would that mean and where does that lead you to, and what would be the outcome of that?
- 18:09And then suddenly they realize, oh, well, actually, the outcome's not as bad as what I'm imagining in my mind.
- 18:16You know, that's a simplistic year.
- 18:18I had students who would be writing exams for.
- 18:20We rank.
- 18:21Our students wrote Cambridge exams.
- 18:24So it was their, like, end of school experience.
- 18:27And they'd be worried now, maybe I'll fail.
- 18:30I won't get a good mark.
- 18:30And then I would say to them, okay, so what would that mean?
- 18:34And when you, like, walk them through that, yes, maybe you failed.
- 18:38So that would mean you have to spend another six months to rewrite that exam.
- 18:43And what does that mean long term?
- 18:44And then you looked at all the.
- 18:45The potential fallout of all of that, suddenly it didn't seem as bad, because in their minds, when they start to express it and write it down, it sounds much less terrifying than some kind of unknown scenario that's in
- 19:01their heads.
- 19:02So that was always, for me, when I was faced with really difficult situations in my personal life, I would have to calm myself down and say, okay, let's think about this logically.
- 19:11If you choose this, what is what could happen?
- 19:14If you choose that, what could happen?
- 19:16And if this happened or that happened, where would I be and what would I do?
- 19:20And do I have the ability to resolve either of those potential disastrous outcomes?
- 19:27And once you understand, well, I actually could fix that problem.
- 19:30It's not, you know, like I would say to the students, not a death sentence.
- 19:34You're not going to jail for the rest of your life if you fail this exam.
- 19:38And sometimes just diminishing the magnitude of the fallout is all they need to be able to suddenly keep it in perspective.
- 19:48Yes, failing an exam or failing a year of school is really you know, not great, nobody wants to do that.
- 19:55But in their minds it's something much more monumental than that which they can't really express.
- 20:01So once you turn it into, once you verbalize it, it becomes the monster's less scary.
- 20:06It's like shining a torch on the monster under the bed.
- 20:09Then you see it's actually just a dust bunny.
- 20:11It's not that bad.
- 20:13So as that young person is going through that process, certainly parental reassurance can play a role.
- 20:21What should that look like?
- 20:24And I know every single example is going to be different, but generally, what are some commonalities in terms of the reassurance that a parent can provide with the goal to help their kids build that resilience muscle?
- 20:40You know, I think the most valuable thing that parents can do so, and parents with the kindest hearts and the best of intentions only want to protect their children from the hurt they can feel or experience from things
- 20:58that go wrong or don't work out or which they fail at.
- 21:02But I think at the end of the day, the main thing children want to know is that you will still love them.
- 21:12Obviously parents kind of know that and I think parents do say that to them, but children don't always believe that.
- 21:20And it's again, it's about walking to the end of that line.
- 21:24And for a parent to say, well, if this and this happened, this is what we would do.
- 21:31You know, this is how you, you could do that and I would back you on that thing.
- 21:36So making, just constantly reinforcing with the child that, that it will never diminish their value in the parents eyes.
- 21:45I mean it sounds very tweet, but even though we read about that and we believe that's what we're telling our children over and over again, that was the number one thing that I found.
- 21:55Kids finding the most daunting thing, not so much about the failure themselves, but about how their parents would respond, feel about them.
- 22:05You know, obviously peer peer pressure is also a problem, you know, but you'd get lots of kids who'd be scared about repeating a year at school because they'd lose all their friends.
- 22:14And you know, if you as a parent say, yeah, sure, you might not be in class with those friends anymore, but we could still arrange for them to come around and you could hang out together and giving the
- 22:27kids the reassurance that you would support them in making sure their lives are not so completely disrupted that that's what, that's what they're afraid of.
- 22:39We all know the reality.
- 22:40If a kid does repeat a year.
- 22:42They might still be friendly with some of the kids they were before, but they're going to make new friends.
- 22:45But you can't tell children that.
- 22:47But helping them to say that's okay, if that happens, what is it that you're afraid of?
- 22:52Okay, what do you think would help you to, you know, make that less terrible for you and what can I do to help you?
- 22:59So also being led by the child.
- 23:02You know, sometimes parents will be.
- 23:03Think they're being helpful.
- 23:04I will do this, and I'll help you with that.
- 23:07It's not really always they.
- 23:09Sometimes they'll feel as if they're burdening you now with more responsibilities.
- 23:13So being led by your child to understand what it is that they're afraid of, what they would like, what they feel themselves, they're empowered to be able to do themselves, and where you would fit into that role, being
- 23:27led by the child in terms of the way they view it.
- 23:31That whole dynamic becomes interesting, let's call it, when we're talking about teens, tweens, young adults.
- 23:38Right.
- 23:38Because it's that fine line between emerging adults and letting them figure it out and supporting them if they fail, while being reassuring.
- 23:51So any thoughts on what that, you know, could look like or should look like when we're talking about teens and above?
- 23:59Yes.
- 23:59And of course, of course things start to change.
- 24:02And.
- 24:02And you know, what I'm talking about can.
- 24:07Can sound very much like letting kids kind of do whatever they want.
- 24:10And it's really not about that.
- 24:11It's about also at the same time as saying, when you do these things, I will still be there for you.
- 24:18But also having the boundaries of saying, this is where it starts to become.
- 24:25You have to carry the responsibility yourself.
- 24:27Like, I can support you with whatever, but at the end of the day, you're the one who's making the choices for your own life.
- 24:37And I remember having that conversation with each of my kids as they sort of came into that space, making sure they understand the difference between being there and supporting for them, supporting them through whatever they're going through, but
- 24:52also understanding that at the end of the day, they carry the consequences.
- 24:58Like I would explain to them, I'd say, you know, if you did something really stupid and you ruined your life, I would be heartbroken.
- 25:04I would still love you.
- 25:05I would do what I could do for you.
- 25:08However, you need to understand that the choices you make impact you and your own life.
- 25:14So you need to decide that if you choose to do or not do something that has an impact on you.
- 25:21You need to understand where that's going to take you.
- 25:24And you have to understand that you are the one that's going to live with that.
- 25:28I will continue with my life based on the choices good and bad that I have made.
- 25:33But you will have to live with the choices you have made for your life.
- 25:37And that I think is a really important lesson because as parents we very often try and smooth things over.
- 25:45And that, that you know, brings me to thinking about parents who always try and do something or rescue their children, you know, fix, fix the disaster that they've walked themselves into.
- 25:55And while that, that feels like taking care of your child and being a parent, there has to be consequences because we don't really like resilience and responsibility are really two sides of the same coin.
- 26:08So you can be resilient, but you need to also be responsible and accountable for what you do.
- 26:14And, and, and the tweens going into teens, that is the really crucial time to teach children about consequences of their choices so you can help them and rescue them, but you have to also at the same time make
- 26:29them understand that there's certain things you won't be able to do that for everything.
- 26:34And they have to learn that with small, low stakes choices when they're in that sort of still semi protected area within your life.
- 26:45We live in decidedly, uniquely challenging times if you're a parent for a whole host of reasons.
- 26:52When we think about resilience in today's world, it takes on all kinds of different, you know, ways, shapes and forms what concerns you most as you kind of scan what you're seeing in the world today with your lived
- 27:07experience and your professional experience and your experience as a parent of what concerns you most and at the same time what gives you hope around the topic of resilience?
- 27:21I think, I think in this, these days it, the biggest challenge parents face is they are no longer the main channel of knowledge and information to their children.
- 27:36You know, even when you, when, when I was young and at school, sure you getting information from, from your school, from your friends, you know, the limited sort of media we're exposed to, tv, movies, whatever magazines.
- 27:50But, but now that has just exploded and, and the amount of information coming at kids is very confusing.
- 27:58So, so I think that is very, very problematic.
- 28:03It, I've seen, I've seen lots of kids really struggling with depression and really feeling as if there's no hope for the future for them as, as humans for very many reasons.
- 28:16And that is a really big challenge because as a parent it's very hard to break through that.
- 28:22How do you say to them, everything's going to be fine?
- 28:24And they're looking at, you know, what the media is feeding them in terms of, you know, this bleak outlook for mankind.
- 28:33That being said, this is where you realize humans are, you know, survivalists because there are still many, many young people.
- 28:44I would say the majority of young people actually still carry that, that wonderful thing that, that we have in youth, which is eternal optimism and the belief that they can do anything.
- 28:58And it is about tapping into that.
- 29:00And if students are students of history, they see how people have believed that the world was going to end multiple times, and it did seem that way.
- 29:11The world has been brought to the brink of disaster multiple times, and young people, you know, sometimes aren't aware of that.
- 29:20And it, it's hard for us as adults to, to say to them, you know, things will be fine, especially when we're feeling overwhelmed ourselves.
- 29:28But, but when, when they are able to, to see their own abilities blossom and grow, the belief in that it nurtures that belief that they can do anything and change the world.
- 29:42And I think that that's really important.
- 29:44And, you know, it can be very disheartening working with, with young people when you see how much they're struggling with and you see the things that are going on in the world.
- 29:52But every single one who, who steps out there and starts to find their way in the world and, and become really responsible and great functioning and contributing adults in our society, you realize that there's still a lot of
- 30:09really brave and resilient and productive creative young people coming up there who see the world sometimes much better than we actually as adults do.
- 30:23So although the, the information overload can be very overwhelming for many of them, at the same time, they have access to so much understanding and awareness of what there is out there and what they're capable of, much more
- 30:38than we ever did as, as young, when we were young.
- 30:42So I think it's.
- 30:44It's up to us as responsible adults to make sure that our children are being exposed to the kinds of things that uplift them and motivate them as opposed to just the negative.
- 30:55And that comes into, you know, being aware of what you speak about around them, your response to things that you see and hear around them.
- 31:04How many of us are, you know, complaining and, you know, bemoaning the fate of the world as opposed to actually focusing on highlighting to our children the positive things and the good things that are happening in the world?
- 31:16I'm a great believer in good news and sharing and highlighting success stories of things that are going right in the world.
- 31:24So, and I mean, I'm not blaming parents or, or any adults around that, but, but we're not really aware of that.
- 31:31And, and the news and the media is very culpable in that they just give you the bad news over and over and over again.
- 31:37And that's what kids are, are, are feeding into.
- 31:40So for me, seeing kids coming, I used to do that with them, is, is kind of get them to, I would make a point of discussing as a discussion point in the, in the classroom environment, positive things that
- 31:53I'd come across.
- 31:54So knowing that it's a two way street is really important as well.
- 31:59We only have about a minute left, but I did want to ask you, Ann, is there something you're particularly proud of in terms of how you approached teaching resilience to your own three children?
- 32:13I think, I mean, sometimes I question was it anything I did or was it just.
- 32:18They were really just great, great humans inside themselves.
- 32:21But certainly looking at my kids having grown up and what they taught me about myself and understanding what I was doing in terms of my own resilience and that what I passed on to them was something that I
- 32:37could share with other people, I would say that has been not really my proudest moment, but the thing that, that I cherish the most in terms of my own experience with my children and the children, every single child
- 32:48that came through my school taught me something about myself and about the world and about young people and how they operate in our space.
- 32:56Lots of really interesting insights.
- 32:58Ann Petus, resilience coach, speaker and personal reinvention expert.
- 33:03Thank you so much for your time and your perspective today.
- 33:07Thank you, Leanne.
- 33:07Thank you so much for having me.
- 33:09And all the best to all the parents out there.
- 33:11It's a great, rewarding journey.
- 33:14It definitely is.
- 33:15Thank you so much, Ann.
- 33:18To learn more about today's podcast guest and topic, as well as other parenting themes, visit whereparentstalk.com.