Latest / Bloomberg Law / Lawsuits Filed Against Hawaiian Electric Over Fires
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 2: Boy for generations the highest beauty, culture and rich history,
- 0:23Speaker 2: true artists, musicians and visitors from around the world. Tragically,
- 0:31Speaker 2: it took less than a single day for us to
- 0:33Speaker 2: lose Lina in the deadliest fire our country has seen
- 0:39Speaker 2: in more than a century.
- 0:41Speaker 1: Hawaii's first Lady overcome with emotion from the devastating loss
- 0:46Speaker 1: after a wildfire destroyed the historic town of Lehina in
- 0:50Speaker 1: the deadliest natural disaster in the state's history. More than
- 0:54Speaker 1: one hundred people are confirmed dead, more than eight hundred
- 0:57Speaker 1: still unaccounted for. Of buildings have been destroyed others damaged
- 1:03Speaker 1: at an estimated cost of nearly six billion dollars. While
- 1:06Speaker 1: the cause of the fire is still under investigation, there's
- 1:10Speaker 1: mounting evidence that Hawaiian electrics down power lines played a part.
- 1:15Speaker 2: Power line just went down that whoefully so justin.
- 1:18Speaker 1: Golf and video from security camera footage at the Maui
- 1:22Speaker 1: Conservation Center captured a flash of what could have been
- 1:26Speaker 1: an early trigger to the deadly fire.
- 1:29Speaker 3: There's a flash and I think that's when it's free
- 1:31Speaker 3: is falling on a power line. The power goes out.
- 1:34Speaker 1: Now, Hawaiian Electric is facing at least eight lawsuits over
- 1:38Speaker 1: its role in allegedly sparking the fires, and some of
- 1:42Speaker 1: the lawsuits are seizing on a legal strategy that doesn't
- 1:45Speaker 1: require proving negligence. This legal shortcut help push PG and E,
- 1:51Speaker 1: California's largest utility, into bankruptcy and secured fire victims a
- 1:56Speaker 1: thirteen and a half billion dollar settlement in twenty twenty.
- 2:00Speaker 1: But the legal argument known as inverse condemnation has never
- 2:04Speaker 1: been used in Hawaii courts. Joining me is Shelley Ross Sachser,
- 2:08Speaker 1: a law professor at Pepperdine University. Shelley tell us about
- 2:13Speaker 1: inverse condemnation.
- 2:15Speaker 3: If you are familiar with the idea that the government
- 2:18Speaker 3: can use its power of eminent domain to actually take
- 2:25Speaker 3: someone's property for public use. What we're talking about are
- 2:30Speaker 3: things like they need to expand the road, and so
- 2:33Speaker 3: they have this power of eminent domain. It's also called
- 2:37Speaker 3: condemnation when they determine that they're going to take your
- 2:41Speaker 3: property and they will give you just compensation, which is
- 2:46Speaker 3: generally the fair market value of the property that they've taken.
- 2:51Speaker 3: An inverse condemnation is a claim where instead of the
- 2:58Speaker 3: government condemning private property. The private property owner says, government,
- 3:06Speaker 3: you have restricted me so severely in the use of
- 3:11Speaker 3: my land that you might as well have taken it.
- 3:14Speaker 3: So I the property owner, am bringing a claim against
- 3:19Speaker 3: the government saying whatever the government's action, whether it be
- 3:23Speaker 3: regulation or some denial of a permit, the landowner can
- 3:29Speaker 3: claim you have taken my property, you need to pay
- 3:33Speaker 3: me just compensation. So that's why it's inverse condemnation, is
- 3:39Speaker 3: it's the property owner that's bringing the claim against the government,
- 3:44Speaker 3: not the government coming to the property owner saying we
- 3:47Speaker 3: need to pay you just compensation and take your property.
- 3:52Speaker 1: Hawaiian Electric is an investor owned company, So how would
- 3:55Speaker 1: this work against Hawaiian Electric.
- 3:58Speaker 3: Well, first of we'll let me clarify a little bit
- 4:02Speaker 3: more about the constitutional provisions that that issue here. Hawaii
- 4:08Speaker 3: Constitution Article one, section twenty says private property shall not
- 4:14Speaker 3: be taken and it adds or damaged for public use
- 4:19Speaker 3: without just compensation. So if we're looking at the federal Constitution,
- 4:25Speaker 3: it says nor shall private property be taken for public
- 4:29Speaker 3: use without just compensation. However, there are about twenty seven
- 4:35Speaker 3: state constitutions that include that phrase damage where the property
- 4:43Speaker 3: is injured for a public use. So it's really not
- 4:48Speaker 3: that the utilities are taking the properties. It's that they
- 4:54Speaker 3: have damaged the property while operating for the public benefits.
- 5:00Speaker 3: So I just want to clarify that the damage clause
- 5:05Speaker 3: also called a damaging clause, is there in the constitution
- 5:11Speaker 3: which makes the argument for inverse condemnation relevant to the
- 5:17Speaker 3: idea of property that is being damaged for a public benefit.
- 5:23Speaker 3: In this case, the public benefit is supplying electricity.
- 5:27Speaker 1: And how do you get from the government to Hawaiian
- 5:31Speaker 1: Electric private utility?
- 5:33Speaker 3: That comes by looking at the fact that the government
- 5:39Speaker 3: has delegated the power of eminent domain to public utilities
- 5:45Speaker 3: even though privately owned and so Hawaii Revised Statutes Section
- 5:52Speaker 3: one oh four Dash four says that the right of
- 5:57Speaker 3: eminent domain is granted to public utilities and others. So
- 6:03Speaker 3: the idea is because these utilities are delegated the power
- 6:09Speaker 3: of eminent domain condemnation, that therefore they are also liable
- 6:16Speaker 3: for inverse condemnation claims because they are performing a public benefit.
- 6:24Speaker 1: Has this theory of inverse condemnation been used in courts
- 6:28Speaker 1: in Hawaii, No.
- 6:30Speaker 3: Not that I can see at all, Although it is
- 6:33Speaker 3: clear that Hawaiian Electric Company has used the power of
- 6:39Speaker 3: eminent domain to acquire easements, et cetera.
- 6:43Speaker 1: Explain how this was used in California against PGN.
- 6:49Speaker 3: SO California over a long period of time developed this
- 6:54Speaker 3: idea from the California Constitution, which says that private property
- 7:00Speaker 3: may be taken or damaged for a public use only
- 7:05Speaker 3: when just compensation is paced. The point is it's the
- 7:09Speaker 3: same as Hawaii in that it includes that damaging thought.
- 7:13Speaker 3: So California developed the idea of using inverse condemnation over
- 7:21Speaker 3: time when there were property damages from blood control projects
- 7:27Speaker 3: that developed beginning I think around nineteen eighty eight. And
- 7:33Speaker 3: so we have a Southern California Edison case. This was
- 7:38Speaker 3: an appublic case. The court said there, we are not
- 7:42Speaker 3: convinced that any significant differences exist regarding the operation of
- 7:47Speaker 3: publicly versus privately owned electric utility. And so they concluded
- 7:54Speaker 3: that Southern California Edison may be liable in inverse condemnation
- 8:00Speaker 3: as a public entity.
- 8:02Speaker 1: I mean, does this mean they don't have to prove
- 8:04Speaker 1: that Hawaiian Electric or PGNY was negligent?
- 8:08Speaker 3: That is correct, So they just have to prove that
- 8:12Speaker 3: it was Hawaiian electric company that was some kind of
- 8:18Speaker 3: nexus to the damage that occurred. But it doesn't have
- 8:23Speaker 3: to be negligent because inverse condemnation is not a tort.
- 8:29Speaker 3: It's related to the constitution and the taking clause of
- 8:33Speaker 3: the federal Constitution. But also we have in some states
- 8:38Speaker 3: taking and damaging, and those states include California and Hawaii.
- 8:45Speaker 3: So California, the idea is it's called strict liability, which
- 8:51Speaker 3: I think is incorrect because strict liability refers to a tort.
- 8:57Speaker 3: So I would say it's just a matter that if
- 9:01Speaker 3: the company is acting for a public benefit, it's performing
- 9:06Speaker 3: a public benefit supplying electricity. If landowners are damaged by
- 9:13Speaker 3: that activity for the public benefits, then the utility has
- 9:18Speaker 3: to pay just compensation for those damages. But this is
- 9:23Speaker 3: only for property damages. This is not the personal injury.
- 9:28Speaker 1: So wrongful death is definitely not included in this.
- 9:32Speaker 3: Absolutely not that would have to be under toward law.
- 9:35Speaker 3: The only thing that inverse condemnation covers in property damages.
- 9:40Speaker 1: As far as the relevant provisions in its constitution, Hawaii's
- 9:45Speaker 1: constitution mirrors California's. So is this inverse condemnation strategy a
- 9:51Speaker 1: slam dunk for the plaintiffs in Hawaii.
- 9:54Speaker 3: Oh no, no, I don't think it's a slam dunk
- 9:56Speaker 3: at all, because different states have dealt with their own
- 10:01Speaker 3: damaging clauses differently. But the idea of the Takings Clause
- 10:06Speaker 3: and the Fifth Amendment under the Federal Constitution is that
- 10:12Speaker 3: we do not want individuals to have to bear the
- 10:17Speaker 3: burden that should be borne by the public as a whole.
- 10:22Speaker 3: In other words, if Hawaii Electric is supplying electricity to
- 10:28Speaker 3: the entire state of Hawaii, that's the benefit to everyone
- 10:32Speaker 3: in Hawaii. But in doing that, there were people in
- 10:37Speaker 3: Lahina whose property was damaged as part of that supplying
- 10:44Speaker 3: electricity to the state. And because of that inverse condemnation,
- 10:51Speaker 3: damaging's clause is trying to say those landowners should not
- 10:56Speaker 3: have to bear the burden for this public benefit fit
- 11:00Speaker 3: of supplying electricity. Now, how that comes about is maybe
- 11:06Speaker 3: everybody has to have rate increases to pay for those damages.
- 11:11Speaker 3: But the same applies if the government needs to take
- 11:15Speaker 3: somebody's property to expand the road, they need to pay
- 11:19Speaker 3: that person just compensation. It's for a public benefit, and
- 11:25Speaker 3: so we end up with, you know, our taxes probably
- 11:28Speaker 3: paying that to the individual landowners.
- 11:32Speaker 1: Courts in Hawaii tend to be pretty liberal and sympathy
- 11:36Speaker 1: for the you know victims here. Could that play any
- 11:40Speaker 1: part in it?
- 11:41Speaker 3: Well, I think it could, because again it's the whole
- 11:45Speaker 3: idea of eminent domain and condemnation and paying just compensation
- 11:52Speaker 3: and then turning around inverse condemnation, regulatory taking, and in
- 11:59Speaker 3: this case damaging. The idea is those individuals should not
- 12:05Speaker 3: have to bear the burdens of supplying electricity to the state.
- 12:10Speaker 1: And in this case, Hawaiian Electric has a market capitalization
- 12:14Speaker 1: of about two point three billion and the potential liability
- 12:18Speaker 1: could reach six billion. So successful lawsuits here could put
- 12:23Speaker 1: Hawaiian Electric into bankruptcy like PG and E exactly.
- 12:28Speaker 3: But it's interesting the bankruptcy court in PG and E
- 12:32Speaker 3: looked at California's law and went through it and affirmed
- 12:37Speaker 3: that that was the correct interpretation. But California had precedent.
- 12:42Speaker 3: Hawaii does not have precedent, So Hawaiian Electric Company is
- 12:48Speaker 3: in a different position than PG and E.
- 12:51Speaker 1: These class action lawsuits also alleged that Hawaiian Electric was negligent,
- 12:57Speaker 1: for example, failing to shut off the power line despite
- 13:00Speaker 1: warnings that high winds might blow those lines down and
- 13:04Speaker 1: spark wildfires. So if the inverse condemnation strategy doesn't work,
- 13:09Speaker 1: then they'll have to prove negligence on the part of
- 13:10Speaker 1: Hawaiian Electric. Will that be difficult for.
- 13:12Speaker 3: The plaintiffs in this case, I don't think so. I
- 13:16Speaker 3: don't know, but certainly there was negligence found with PG
- 13:22Speaker 3: and E, so it could be that the inverse condemnation
- 13:27Speaker 3: argument won't matter if they do prove negligence, which I
- 13:32Speaker 3: think from just things that I've heard that that might
- 13:35Speaker 3: not be too difficult to prove. In terms of the bankruptcy.
- 13:41Speaker 3: Certainly California went through this too, and so the governors
- 13:46Speaker 3: Jerry Brown at the time and then Newsom looked at
- 13:51Speaker 3: what it would take to keep them from going into
- 13:54Speaker 3: bankruptcy because we don't want that to happen to the utilities,
- 13:59Speaker 3: and the would be we just want to make sure
- 14:03Speaker 3: that as a society, and this is going to apply
- 14:08Speaker 3: no matter what disasters we're going to be based in
- 14:11Speaker 3: the future, all of the burdens should not fall on
- 14:16Speaker 3: individuals when the public should be taken care of it
- 14:21Speaker 3: because it's part of what we need to do to
- 14:25Speaker 3: continue adapting and surviving. So That's why I think it's
- 14:29Speaker 3: an attractive concept that doesn't require faults. All it requires
- 14:34Speaker 3: is we're trying to spread the cost.
- 14:37Speaker 1: And do other states besides Hawaiian California have these damaging clauses.
- 14:44Speaker 3: This idea of the damaging clause that's in the Hawaii
- 14:49Speaker 3: Constitution and in California and in about twenty seven different states.
- 14:55Speaker 3: This was first pointed out in an article by Marine
- 15:00Speaker 3: Brady in the Virginia Law Review in twenty eighteen. And
- 15:07Speaker 3: she is a historian who also does property law, and
- 15:13Speaker 3: she wrote this article and it said, this article recovers
- 15:19Speaker 3: the hidden history of the state damaging's closets. And the
- 15:25Speaker 3: reason those were put in was because when we were
- 15:30Speaker 3: doing infrastructure like the railroads, what was happening is that
- 15:36Speaker 3: the private railroads were given the power of eminent domain,
- 15:40Speaker 3: and if they took property to run the railroad track,
- 15:46Speaker 3: then that property owner was entitled to compensation. However, when
- 15:52Speaker 3: they ran the railroad track, in some cases they would
- 15:57Speaker 3: just leave properties with out any access because they dig
- 16:02Speaker 3: through a hill to lay the tracks, and so this
- 16:06Speaker 3: devalued other property. And so these damaging pauses were put
- 16:12Speaker 3: in in many cases in the eighteen hundreds the late
- 16:17Speaker 3: eighteen hundreds to account for this problem, and Hawaii originally,
- 16:25Speaker 3: and this comes out of Molly Brady's article, that Hawaii
- 16:30Speaker 3: first considered this language in nineteen fifty and they declined
- 16:36Speaker 3: to add the damaging language because they said the state
- 16:41Speaker 3: courts are not fully agreed on the meaning of it.
- 16:44Speaker 3: But then at the next constitutional convention in nineteen sixty eight,
- 16:50Speaker 3: they adopted it. And this again is from Molly Brady's research.
- 16:56Speaker 3: She said in Hawaii Delegate Peter Lewis lament how one
- 17:01Speaker 3: Honolulu resident had suffered as an elevated freeway passed feet
- 17:06Speaker 3: from his bedroom window, subjecting him to headlights and constant
- 17:11Speaker 3: traffic noise. So that was the idea of the damaging's clauses.
- 17:16Speaker 1: So this inverse condemnation strategy has worked in California cases,
- 17:21Speaker 1: has it worked elsewhere?
- 17:22Speaker 3: I've looked at all of the cases that involved this
- 17:27Speaker 3: idea of the damaging's clauses, which have been used not
- 17:32Speaker 3: just for flooding and wildfires, but it's also been used
- 17:38Speaker 3: for things like public work, so for sewers when that's
- 17:43Speaker 3: backed up and it's not being taken care of and
- 17:46Speaker 3: property is damaged It's also been asserted when the police
- 17:51Speaker 3: have to go after a criminal and they go into
- 17:54Speaker 3: somebody's store or house in pursuit of the criminal and
- 17:59Speaker 3: they damaged the property, and the question is that a
- 18:04Speaker 3: damaging under inverse condemnation? And there has been mixed law
- 18:09Speaker 3: on that.
- 18:10Speaker 1: Thanks so much for being on the show, Shelley. That's
- 18:12Speaker 1: Shelley Ross Saver, a law professor at pepper Down University.
- 18:15Speaker 1: And that's it for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show.
- 18:18Speaker 1: Remember you can always get the latest legal news on
- 18:20Speaker 1: our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 18:25Speaker 1: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast slash Law,
- 18:30Speaker 1: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 18:33Speaker 1: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 18:37Speaker 1: and you're listening to Bloomberg