Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 3 - Is There A future In Supply Chain?
Transcript
- Dan Culverhouse: Hello and welcome to episode three of Under the Pallet Wrap a supply chain podcast where we discuss interesting and important trends, risks, challenges from the world of industry, I guess. And I'm Dan Culverhouse. This is Keith Dupres In this, we don't set an agenda. We don't follow a script. We simply debate one question and see where the conversation goes. today's question is, is there a career future in supply chain? So Keith, is there? Keith: The first question is what makes us ask that question? We have quite a lot. Everywhere, we're both on LinkedIn, we see absolutely strewn across our feeds all the time about how AI, for example, and automation is going to change the world we live in. ⁓ How do you think it's going to affect our particular industry? Have you seen a lot of it encroached on what you're doing? you used it to your benefit? In-person participant 1: What's your opinion so far? Keith: What's your opinion so far? Dan Culverhouse: The machines are coming, right? You're right. It's hard to go onto any kind of media and not read an article about jobs disappearing and the future is all automated and AI driven. And then it's all over supply chain for sure. And I think, you know, it's a genuine fear of people. And I don't think it's without. you know, without some substantiation. think that there are, there are challenges. There will be changes. think AI is, I use it every day. I don't know about you. And I think there's barely a day goes by where I don't utilize it in some form or another. And I think, you know, when you look at across the wider industry, I think it's, it is a huge part of our lives now and will continue to grow and accelerate. I guess the question really is, it replace us? I mean, think that's, know, the doom gloomers, those who watched Terminator back in the nineties, you know, will definitely remember Cyberdyne Systems and how it's going to take over everything. I have a personal belief that the reality is maybe not quite so bad. Will it have an impact? Yeah, of course it will. And, you know, the personal computer had a huge impact. The Internet had a huge impact. The calculator had a huge impact. The printing machine had a huge impact. But you know what? The world didn't end. It just adapted. Yeah. So I think I think there is a genuine fear and I think things are going to change. But, you know, I don't know that I see that. And I think, yeah, let just say this. I think that the jobs that we do, the roles that we play in supply chain are not simply a series of logical decisions. So you can put all the data you like around this. But I just don't think that the reality of making all of this work is just a case of having the data and making logical decisions. Wouldn't you agree? I mean, it's not that simple, is it? Keith: Yeah, well, I think both of us are probably old enough to remember how the internet changed our world. first it changed it unrecognisably, but in what way? I think around that time I was very much involved in underground, know, on the shop floor when the internet became part of our lives. And I was at least 26. I got a mobile phone. So if I look back at my life, of course it changed everything, but I don't think it changed the nature of my role particularly. It might have made certain things easier to access. Do you know what it is? I can't actually remember. We would have had to have got books and gone to the library to access information, and the internet obviously made that a lot easier, but it didn't diminish the need for consultants. I think sometimes it levels the playing field and it means that information is more accessible to a wider group of people. But it doesn't necessarily replace the need for the work to decipher that information and make it useful. We all hear about the people being replaced, thousands of people being placed by agents. But I think, you as you said, In-person participant 1: But I think you as you said The key for me is there's truly understanding of value added Keith: The key for me is truly understanding of value added. need and a result for using automation. The same as building automation in the warehouse. There's no need if you have a deployment of base level requirement. I think the struggle, struggle to actually see the results implementation. And yes, like you, I use it all the time. ⁓ do I use it? Research, ⁓ sampling, my abilities, not reducing my abilities. It doesn't make me feel less valuable, actually makes me feel more valuable. It makes me feel sharper. I can trust my worth a bit more. Of course, if you trust AI to know everything, it's a pattern recognition tool. Ultimately, if you expect it to know more than you, if we don't know more about the subject in the tool itself, then you're on a hiding to nothing. And if you're off... opinion as a founder or warehouse owner who believes that the agent knows more than the person, then yes, you know, you may choose to replace people and you may find out that you've got a louder problem or a bigger problem than you had before. That's my general Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah, I think I always have a little bit of a worry. And I think the way you see the way AI companies advertise themselves and as a real push, it feels like or and maybe this is just a way of getting people to try it and adopt it. But if there's a real decision outsourcing kind of approach to the AI companies, ⁓ just the most basic things, you know, I think I've even seen an advert for an AI ⁓ agent, you know, that tell you whether you're wearing the right clothes for a date or something. I mean, it's just like, what? And I know that's nothing to do with what we're doing, but the point is, it's what I worry about is this decision outsourcing that I don't need to think anymore. I can just ask. And as you said, what you're asking is only good as the information that's out there. It's not original thought. It's just... summarizing what it can take from the sources that it uses and regurgitates it back to you. mean, in the art world, people talk about it all the time, they? That AI can recreate art, but it's only an interpretation of what's already been done. It's nothing original. It can create music, but it's just, you could say, make me a song that sounds like The Foo Fighters. And it can do that, I'm sure. But it won't be an original. It will just be an interpretation, copy. So it's all the time when you're in these places and yeah, trust me, you can get things done a lot quicker when you utilize the power of AI and to automate processes and activity. But to think, one of the things I always like to say when we're talking about this sort of thing is that, Most of the solutions, the AI solutions that are created to ⁓ apparently replace the need for a operator, for a manager, for the, you know, that can make all your supply chain decisions. So maybe it's a supply chain planning tool, you just chuck the data in and then it's going to give you your answer. You don't even need to think about it. It's written by techies, right? And no offense to techies, they're very good at what they do, but they're not operators. don't... understand the nuance of how things occur and how it requires more than just data and logic to come to the right conclusion. You know, so, you know, we've both worked in customs a bit. I saw it, you know, it's been this huge surge of custom software, these AI driven where they can do all your declarations for you. But the one thing they don't mention in all of their marketing in that, and I find it a little bit naughty really, is that What it's saying it can do is it will take the information that you give it and it will make a declaration for you. It's not saying that it will actually make sure that that information is correct and that the interpretation of the HSCode and etc etc are the right ones. But it will take the information that you give it and do a legal declaration. But that's not everything, right? Because if you can look at it and say, actually, if I use this HSCode, I can reduce the... you know, the tariffs and, you know, et cetera, et then that's where the skill comes in. And it's not just simply a case of, you know, A plus B equals C because there's always a D and E and an F in there somewhere that makes the decision a little bit different. And if it's not written down, if it's not data in its experience, then I don't care how clever the machine is, if that information is not there for it to use, can't use it. So it's not, it can't give the same answer as you or I. You know, so it can't replace us. Keith: Yeah. It can aid a decision, but you're always going to need to justify the decision. You're always going to need to explain the decision, especially when it comes to classification. You're going to need to explain the logic. It's not enough to just say, have an agent. You need to know how to set this up. I 100 % agree with your example. It leads me to the question. I think I've got my own opinion about where it's... incredibly useful, but do you, where do you see it being utilised? What, what, planning can't be automated in your view? I like just, I've seen some good dashboards where people have taken data in the past, they might have invested thousands on a piece of inventory software as an example, when In-person participant 1: I think I've got my own opinion about where it's incredibly useful. do you, where do you see it being utilized? What can and can't be automated in your view? I like to, I've seen a few good dashboards where people have taken data. In the past, they might have invested thousands on a piece of inventory software as an example. When Keith: Ultimately, all they've done is taken the data, they've trained it to provide an outcome based on clear parameters, and they've used that as a specific bespoke tool to help their operation. I've seen that before when you can't find enough to peg product to suit your needs. And I think that's why I talk about leveling the playing field. If you need something, you can build something as long as you fully understand Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: the inputs and the outputs and what you expect it to do and where it can break. I've seen some really cool forecasting and inventory-based tools. I've always been a bit of a dashboard builder myself, using Excel, Access, and everything else, learning from Google, to try and build visibility where there is none. But of course, as you well know, if you haven't got the data, these things, you might as well be. pointing your finger in the air. So it does make it quicker to build something more interactive. But where do you see the possibilities and where do you see it really not working in your experience? What will it replace? What won't it? Dan Culverhouse: I think what I really like about it, I completely agree that areas like forecasting and planning, it's very helpful. It can process a lot of information. But where I think it's really powerful is that you can interrogate it. So it will come up with an answer. You'll feed a load of data in and it will come up with an answer. The other thing I also like is where you have holes in your data. it can help you fill those holes. So yeah, and it can just make some assumptions on your own, but you can then challenge it and interrogate it and suggest it interprets things differently. So I think that there is, I think it's this interaction and the interrogation that you can do that which, and it learns and it can learn from that interrogation or that questioning. you know, which, I think is very powerful because, you know, I think we've been able to process large amounts of data for a long time, but the, the, skill to be able to play with it and change it is always there, but it was much harder and it took a long time and you had to replay the whole kind of processing. Whereas now that you can just go, yeah, yeah, I like that, but I don't like this, but can you take a look at that? Or, you know, and it's, you literally can. have conversations with it in that sense. And I think that's the power. I think it's the interaction between yourself and the AI that is the big step forward. Yeah, I find that very, very helpful. It's still not going to be able to make those decisions because until you tell it what you're thinking, it can't, it's not necessarily in the data. So I think that's really powerful, but it's a collaboration. And I think that's my point on this. And I've spoken before about, obviously my background is very much more around the physical operation and the automation. And there's the same fear in warehousing as there is across the supply chain that warehouses are gonna become these automated closed operations where... know, stuff feeds in one end and a load of DPD packages come out the other end. And the reality is just not that. You know, there's very, I mean, I'm sure you could make a case for a very simpleized, simpleized, is that a real word? I don't know, but a simplified setup where you could entirely automate the entire process. It was one product, people order it and it just picks it out, puts it in a package and pushes it out. It's always possible, but the reality is that companies don't run like that and everything is a lot more nuanced and complex. And I see the best automated operations are collaborations between robotics and people. Does it reduce the head count? Yeah, of course it does. But in the main, what it reduces is that peak, you get into a retail warehouse and the head count can double during a peak period. And anyone who's supervised or managed one of those operations knows that those periods are terrible. You've got a bunch of people who come in, not their fault, but they don't know the operation. don't really care that much because they're only there for a few weeks. It's just a very basic level job. They're getting paid to move stuff back. So you can't expect them to care that much. So the quality of what you're doing goes down. Actually, your performance rarely goes up because you've got so many people around that don't know what they're doing. that it creates as much mess as it does help, but you just need the power to be able to produce all those orders. Whereas when you automate that process, the machine can take the strain. And when you go through peaks, you don't need the same uplift in people. You still need some, but not anywhere near the same degree. The machine can take the strain. And therefore, you can upgrade your performance massively, and you don't lose all of that quality. So the customer still gets the orders they want. But it still takes people, but those people are a little bit more skilled. They work in collaboration with the robotics. And therefore it's powerful. that's a real major shift in how you can utilize machinery and intelligence in systems. But it's a collaboration, you know, and I think that's where the power is. But to think that you could... remove a supply chain manager, let's just say he's in charge of planning and forecasting with an agent and it could truly answer all of the queries. I just think it's naive. And who's to say, it could come. mean, who knows where this might go, but it's nowhere near, we're not near that at this stage. I just don't see that. that being a reality from, you know, all the years I've spent in operations and they've changed a lot in that time. You know, when I started to use to manage the stock on a piece of paper, let alone on the system. So I've seen a lot of transformation, but at no time have I really felt that this could run intelligently without human input. I just don't see it. Keith: Yeah, I think I come from the same point of view. Just look at all the years we've worked. And I don't want to sound naive, I know more. Look how long I've worked in the supply chain. I could know everything there is to possibly know, but we've seen so many changes coming in, in the way warehousing is done. And to me, just extends to capacity and capability if done in the right way. increasing the stakes, adding consistency, making things more stable, more predictable. And I think it will only go on to do more of that. And I'd to hope it can help us plan future plan a more. ⁓ has always been one of the ⁓ bug bears of retail. But not so much the forecasting itself, it's the predictions and the predictability of how actions are going to affect the outcomes. I think there will be a wonderful companion in that respect. And I've seen some great developments. And this is what excites me. And, you know, if I look back at all the things over the years, I've just hated doing. They've been menial tasks. They've been... They've wasted my time and I'd rather be creative. And I think that's where technology is built to improve what we're doing. that middle ground. Are there any jumps do you think that are particularly at risk? We've said the supply chain manager is almost even more integral now. Analysts, I hear a lot about analysts being a bit, consultants and analysts being a bit under risk. I think it will strengthen a lot of that. Maybe you have to differentiate yourself, Dan Culverhouse: I think you could make a case for a lot of roles to be under risk, but I think it's more that they'll have an impact. They'll be impacted by it and they'll need to adapt. Where I actually see a lot of challenges is in the base level roles. Data entry, there's a lot of people that kind of, the early, the roles you take when you first start, right? the really boring data entry or, you know, basic picking jobs. I think, you know, that's where it's going to get hit the most. You know, I think that there is a, yeah, you know, and then you can go up the chain and then sort of junior kind of lead. It's the specialist roles more than the leadership roles, I think. I think people always need to be led. And a machine can't lead you because you know if chat GPT tells you to go and do something, you know, you can just ignore it But but you know you do see that that and I guess what that if the the You know a lot of that really early low level roles become defunct and not required The question that runs through my head often and I was talking to someone recently who said the same thing. It's like How do you get to the middle management point? Because we all got to the middle management point by going through a lot of these really crappy, boring, entries level jobs. which can potentially be relatively easily replaced by AI, but what you learn from doing those jobs is invaluable in your later career. What I learned when I worked on the shop floor drives everything I do today still. If you don't have to do that as much, or not everybody can take that path through, what's the path to get into a supply chain manager's role? I don't know the answer to that actually because... the paths are going to be different. You can learn and I know you can go to the university and get a degree in it or whatever and maybe then you can parachute in a high level, but it's not the same. It's not the same as having experienced those roles on the way through. So yeah, I think that's one of questions I have in my head is how do you get from leaving school to becoming a manager of something or a leader of a skilled area like a supply chain function? if you don't do the jobs in the middle, in the early part, because they're now all done automatically. Keith: Yeah, I was actually, I'm sort of conflicted around this because I did say earlier that levels to playing field, it does at a certain level. If you know what you're doing and you want to build, it's a lot more accessible to you once you've got the knowledge. But I think you're completely right. I mean, what about five S's? nothing has up to someone is. just through being given us an opportunity to deal with and something like with a process. You see how they pack and see how they approach their day. You do worry a little bit whether that layer would be neglected. I'd like to hope as a leader I wouldn't make those four competencies. But as time goes on, it's hard to predict how people will, how they'll treat employment. whether you need a degree. We've often spoke about how supply chain should be, it should be a desirable career unless second courses on supply chain at school, let alone universities. It's not really a mind-boggling, necessarily a university career. It might be someone, and I think that might be a bit misguided if it becomes more about capacity to deal with at all rather than the practical. at the place in on the top floor. I might hope it doesn't. You always need someone to pick and pack. I just hope people's voices don't get lost in the excitement. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and it's the skill though of when you get to that kind of management, that leadership level of making decisions as to how a supply chain should function or how to make the right decisions in certain scenarios. There's so much that you can learn by educating and, you know, going to university and all that. You know, certainly in my experience, the best people in those roles are the ones that have actually experienced it. They've done it the wrong way. They've done it the hard way. They've done things and they've learned and they've seen the developments, you know, as they've built up their career. And if you're kind of coming in at the side now midway through that process and you've not experienced all that stuff on the way up. Yeah, I just question that how good your decision your your, you know, it's that situational leadership is that situational reflection of when you see all these things coming together, you know, there's all sorts of data points that will give you some guidance, but there's a nuance that is just experience and. Yeah, just understanding that the unwritten parts. which, you know, and it's hard because it's very difficult to be specific about it. But I think that's the very nature of it is why it's not a simple case of writing a logical set of instructions and following them. It's the nuances that aren't written that are situational, you know, that ⁓ makes it a lot harder. And if you've not experienced that at all, you just come straight out of education into a place where you have. that decision making ⁓ expectation. I see that as really hard. know, certainly, as I say, in my experience, the people I've employed, the most successful ones are the ones that done it, not the ones who've read about it. You know, it's, it's, that's the reality in my mind. Keith: So if you were to design an apprenticeship for the future in supply chain or even a course, what sort of things would you think you would need to include? On my mind, I was back when I was an apprenticeship apprentice and it was all fat. It was un-living. This is how you use the printing press. It was quite specific, but most of it was your hands, using your hands and that came around it. was definitely on the shop floor. If you were designing an apprenticeship for nowadays, where do you think the balance is in teaching people how to use their judgment as well as how to use their practical applications? what do you have around that? Dan Culverhouse: I think it comes down to there needs to be some emphasis on understanding the mechanics. So what I mean is that it's very easy to just throw a load of data at a system and it comes back with all sorts of incredible insights. But if you've got no indication about how the mechanics of those insights have been built, You don't you know, I think all you can do is listen to what it tells you. You can't then interrogate it further. You can't you know, so so I think that there needs to be regardless of whether you have to do it or not and here's is a I guess a very different scenario, but it's a similar thing in my mind. It's like learning to drive. 90 % of cars that are bought these days are automatics, right? So why bother learning to drive a manual car? Well, by learning to drive a manual car, you start to understand how gearing works and how that gearing can influence the way that the car behaves and that. So I don't drive a manual car, but I learned in a manual car. And I think it helps you have a deeper understanding about what you're driving and how it influences the outcome, where you get and how quickly you get to it. And I think that's the same in something like supply chain and logistics is that if you can't understand how, you know, I don't mean the intricate details of every calculation, of what are the influences that change an outcome. If you don't understand much about those influences, then all you can do is take what it tells you at face value because you have no experience to challenge it. So think you need to understand the mechanics despite the fact that all those automations are there, there needs to be a way for you to be able to do some of those tasks. Sit there with that data and try and forecast the next six months demand. Understand what data points it uses to come up with its answer. Because then when you see the outcome, you can interrogate it, you can challenge it, you can look at it in a different way. You can bring in influences that maybe the data doesn't show. But for you to be able to do that, you and I do it because we did those jobs before they were, that automation was available. And I think to some degree, people need to be, know, a apprenticeship needs to be able to go into what is now automated to experience it or to at least learn how that calculation is made or how those, how you end up in that position and what the outcome. And also, you what happens if I make this decision? What happens if I make that decision? Now, the great thing is, of course, with AI and that is that you could have a whole bunch of scenarios playing and you could say, OK, well, my decision would be to do this. And it could play out that scenario and you could see what would happen in the main. Certainly, you could get some power. So I think it's about understanding the mechanics. having some experience of doing it without the automation and then being able to play out those scenarios to see how those they respond because ultimately we decide what we want to do because of the experiences that we've had over the last 30 years. Yeah, I think for me that was how it worked. But then I do accept that I am a... hands on person. I'm a person that learns through experience. learn through doing. I'd never had much success in the more formal education. Same question to you, Keith. How would you approach it then? Because that's how I work. Keith: Yeah, well, the word that comes to mind is practical theory. And I was also thinking, check on board your point about the manual versus the automatic car. I learned in the manual, I still drive in manual car. My daughter is about to learn how to drive and I think, at they learn in a manual car. But you still have manual. Dan Culverhouse: I insisted making it. Keith: Yeah, you still have manual cars. Part of me is thinking, when do you, when does something become obsolete enough not to learn it? And thinking about supply chain, I just don't think it can become obsolete. Paper filing, okay, shows our common sense, but actually understanding the series, the basics, how to work out, for example, how to calculate a freight rate, for example. That is something that can be practically taught and understood. You have to classify products physically using products in question, understanding the customs rules, understanding how the nomenclature works, understanding the basis around international trade. This can be tested. And I think it should be evidence-based that before... Before you move onto levels of responsibility, you need to provide some level of evidence, whatever you're going to set that up as. That's how you would train it. In terms of warehouse floor, as long as you are doing a physical job, I think it's easy to train it and understand it. I think when it comes down to it, any sort of role like planning, Some of those are just going to lean heavily on data to make decisions. You need a layer whereby someone has to understand how to do that manually before they use the tools. Learning connects in one with the other, but they still have to feed into each other. Dan Culverhouse: It's the implications of an action, the implications an action can have. know, to say to just use that car scenario again, if you don't really understand the implications of changing gear, then you won't really understand that when you put your foot down on your automatic car, what happens and why the car races off, you know, and does things. You so it's understanding the implications of an action. You know, and I think you learn that through getting involved in it. And I guess the question now then is that if that's the case. So I think we're saying that education is clearly important and there needs to be ⁓ good ways of being educated. But the experiential side of it is also very important. what do companies need to do if that bottom layer of roles is not necessarily there in the same way? How do companies... take people from university or from school and build them into leaders or managers. And I know all the leadership side, the behavioral side is one thing. And that's, think that's not really what we're talking about today. It's the technical side of understanding the nuance of the technical side of the industry. What the companies need to invest in is it simply apprenticeships where they have to accept that these people are having to do roles that maybe to some degree are defunct just so they learn enough about it. If you're a big logistics company, how would you build that skill? Keith: This is where I feel that AI can work for the better good because it can build models to train people where it trains synthesized outcomes based on your inputs. I can visualize almost, I can almost picture a Sims-type type scenario where you are responsible for an operation and this is something used to pay attention to how you use all the inputs to build your outcome. I can see a real future in that. But I think that layer's always got to be there. Otherwise it could make or break an operation ⁓ if you've got people just following orders. We've all been in operations where you've walked the floor and you've asked someone, why are you doing that? ⁓ because that's what I was told to do. Then you print it out. This is a bit, let's go through this. Can you see? why that might be a little bit unhelpful. ⁓ yeah, I never thought of it that way. And you see the revelation in that person that they can question what they're doing and they don't have to follow blindly. And lastly, you have the wider conversations with their supervisors. Did you know that your team were just copying what you said? Are you not monitoring the outcomes? And then you can train them to be a better manager. So I think AI can be used to build effective managers. And again, we're not talking about this right now, but if it aids the people side, it aids their awareness of how people operate and how they behave and how they follow orders, all the cultural elements, how hierarchical some warehouses can be and what people really think. And if they are of a personality or in position where they They do tend to just follow orders and not question. It can amplify those things, so... ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Well, you and I know power of continuous improvement, right? And the power of continuous improvement is asking those people who do the job every day to think about the wider implications of what they do and not just to blindly do it. Because most people, mean, I'm sure you've experienced this a hundred times as well, but when you get together a group of people who do the job, the amount of ideas they have on how they can improve is immense. And you can make such great progress. And it's not the guy who's sitting at the top in the comfy chair. In-person participant 1: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: with his suit on or, you know, and getting paid the nice salary. It's his skill or her skill is being able to reach into the operation and find those skills from the people who are doing it on a day to day basis and utilizing all of that power and that knowledge to make a difference. And if all of that power suddenly becomes autonomous to us and therefore it's done in a black box. How do you do that continuous improvement? And it may be you can say, well, the AI has got the intelligence to be able to see it. Great. But what if it gets it wrong? What if it starts taking you in a path that is not giving you what you want, yet nobody has the in-depth knowledge to know, hang on, hang on, this is going in the wrong direction. This is not what we want. We want to change it. you if you're totally reliant on a data model, then you suddenly lose your power to influence its direction. And I think that's, that's, you know, it's a concern. I think it's why. People need to continue to develop this critical thinking, this imagination, this innovative mindset that doesn't rely on a machine to tell them what to do all the time. And I think, you know, we're talking about, is there a future career in this area? I absolutely believe there is. It's just not the same as it's been for the last 30 years. It's starting to change and you're using tools differently. And therefore roles will change, they will shift. Where the emphasis of people is will be different. But there's going to be people in my mind anyway. Keith: I want it to ever replace the good old Gemba walk because that is the most valuable element in my view ⁓ of my role. It's the bit I enjoy the most. I love accelerating my knowledge to make decisions quicker. And I love designing more streamlined tools that mean that people don't have to spend hours ⁓ on entry. we can use the data in real time rather than two months later. That's amazing. I don't even think we've seen the beginning of it. We can, I would love to hope that we can use AI to accelerate our thinking on things like sustainability, climate change, waste, decisions for the good. And I think ⁓ for that reason, it shouldn't be feared. With the right governance, with the right layers, with the right leadership. with solutions in mind, not temporary solutions, but more long-term efficiency. think it's one of the best tools ⁓ I've ever seen. But I've also seen a lot of noise, a lot of, it will get rich quick things, shall we say. I like the fact that it can liberate. ⁓ But like all platforms, all technology, if you go in blindly, if you go in, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah. Keith: thinking it's the solution to everything, you're likely to be disappointed, especially at this stage. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, think, I think it's quite often with innovations, unintended consequences of those innovations. think, know, innovations come in and they transform our lives and they were intended for a certain purpose, but they always, there's always unintended consequences of change. Social media is a really obvious one that it connected everybody, but actually the unintended consequences actually has separated people and people don't interact in the same way anymore. And it's made people lonely. You know, that was never the intention of whoever started the, you know, Mark Zuckerberg when he first started Facebook. And I'm sure that wasn't his idea when he started it, but it built a power of its own and there are massive unintended consequences of it. And the same will apply here. You know, I think, it's through all of those experiences in the past, we need to take these new innovations with them. Yeah, with the right mindset of how do I use it? How do I collaborate with it? Not how do I replace things with it? You know, that's you know, that's just inevitably that will fail and that will fall and it will cause problems. Whereas if you look at how do I enhance my performance through this? Keith: Yeah, of course. Dan Culverhouse: I think the future is bright. Keith: How do I add value? Dan Culverhouse: And how do I use that to add even more? Keith: Yeah. Yeah. How can I continue to add value to the business, the operation, to myself and to my team? So on that note, would you say you're a tech optimist? Do you fear AI? A general fan? What's our position? I think we've got a similar one. Dan Culverhouse: I ⁓ am a tech optimist. think that, you know, the tools and the innovations are amazing. You know, I never cease to be amazed. And I'm sure as I get older, that will only increase because I've become less and less in touch with them. I think as long as you use, take the right mindset as, you know, anybody who invents something, it will always be like, ⁓ it's going to change the world. It's going to replace all of this. The reality is that's rarely true and it's an opportunity to enhance, not to replace. And as long as we take that view on things, then keep bringing it, keep making AI more powerful and more helpful, because it will just mean that we can do more. And when some of the things that will have taken years to try to contemplate or model, we can do instantaneously and that can only be helpful. As long as we are approaching it in the manner of here's how it can help but what are the potential ways it could go that aren't helpful and how do we protect against that? You know, I think that's, you we should have learned enough over the last 50 years of innovation that all of these things come with an intended and an unintended consequence and we need to be mindful of the unintended to ensure that we keep it in a positive path and we learn from it. And I also have a confidence and an optimism that humans are hugely adaptable. ⁓ And with every one of these changes, certain roles will disappear, but new roles come. You know, there's a whole new world ⁓ of things that we can't even thought of yet that will become really, really important tasks and jobs and, you know, however, careers. So, yeah, I feel positive that the future Career and supply chain is not what it was when you and I started out, but it's still as exciting ⁓ and fulfilling. mean, you know, knowing that you're able to make something work the way that it does is great. That's why I do it. And seeing how you can develop others to be able to do that is great. And I don't think that changes. That fundamental remains the same. So do we agree? Keith: Indeed, I do. ⁓ If used to enhance, that's what I would want to use it for, to enhance, if we can move stuff across the world in a responsible way, for the least, smallest footprint, and we bring people together, make decisions easier, innovate, improve. Yes, I'm 100 % on board and excited and that's the element I'm certainly attracted to. Like all new innovations, it needs a level of responsibility. Can we trust that everybody running the show to have that level of responsibility or to leave it all in sundry to determine what issues for? I don't know. We don't yet know. But I don't think it's cause to fear. I think it's cause to be aware, responsible and interested. And it actually is added a boost. to my permanent interest in the supply chain is just make me even more excited about what I'm doing. Like what more can I do? This is amazing. What great things can I make for my client, for the industry in general? How can I add value? How can I, especially with the sustainability elements I'm working on, how can we get to a point where that becomes easier for the industry to do things in a less harmful way, to repurpose products? to build the end-to-end visibility through the chain to make decisions easier to get the message across louder, more effectively. I'm all for it. I don't know what's going to happen in the But I think there's a good future. And if my daughter was to say, I want a career in supply chain more so than ever, I would encourage her to do so. Dan Culverhouse: Yep, I firmly believe the future is bright. I think we all have a responsibility to ensure that it's directed and we continue to take responsibility. You know, if we hand our brains over to others, then there's an inevitable outcome. I just don't see that being the way that most people would want the world to evolve and therefore they'll continue to want a degree of control. I don't look to governments for help for that. think that's our responsibility. Bring it on, say, bring it on. The future. I think a career in supply chain is more exciting than it's ever been. So there we are. Do we think there's a future? Absolutely. And it's better than ever. Keith: Yeah, we're ready. 100 % no doubt. So on that note, we talk of technology, but no matter how much it advances, you may have noticed my glasses steam up because ironically, I'm using new technology from a company called Warmbox and my room does exactly, does feel like a warm box, feels like a greenhouse. But nevermind, Dan and I decided to keep it real from the beginning and we're going to do that. What you see is what you get. and these things amuse me. So we've got another question for you next week and we look forward to seeing you and for now goodbye. Dan Culverhouse: Thank you. As fun as ever. Speak to you next week. In-person participant 1: See you soon. Keith: See you soon.