Latest / Carbon Weekly News / Inside a 4.45 Million Tonne Soil Carbon Deal | CWN EP5
Transcript
- speaker-0: You can't say with a straight face that we're gonna accomplish Paris goals now without removals. speaker-1: both the ability to remove ⁓ carbon from the atmosphere and storing it in the soil, which is why we normally say that we have the solution right at our feet. speaker-2: We we essentially launched to specifically target this rice methane problem, methane and water problem. ⁓ so rice, you know, contributes around ⁓ over twelve percent of ⁓ of global methane emissions. ⁓ it consumes over thirty percent of irrigated water. Then episode number three. We're still here a week to go to New York ⁓ Climate Week. I wanna say carbon week, but for us it's probably carbon week. ⁓ so great to be here with you again. speaker-3: Yeah, we've survived, as you said. speaker-2: We've survived. We've survived. We're continuously surviving. And I feel like over the last ⁓ two weeks we actually had so many news coming up. I think I we could have talked about like five or six things. It's always like before New York Climate Week or during New York Climate Week, everyone tries to push out their news. And ⁓ that's obviously makes a lot of sense. You wanna go in with publicity into New York Climate Week. You want something to talk about. But I haven't seen anything from Mombach or Zenken, maybe We've done something wrong or maybe there's something coming up still. speaker-3: Yeah, we're waiting on approvals for being able to announce a few things from from buyers. So, you know, the that fun part of the process where you thought you could go live with a deal and then ⁓ someone doesn't let you. So yeah, we'll see. speaker-2: then sometimes like it takes a year sometimes, right? You sign it, you're happy and then a year later you announce and everyone's like, congrats and you're like w that ⁓ that was that was a year ago. speaker-1: All right, bye. speaker-2: Then let's jump straight into it. first thing we want to talk about is a topic that is or was really dear to your heart is regenerative agriculture and soil carbon. Akrina, like ⁓ I I think in Europe the biggest ⁓ developer for regenerative agriculture projects just announced I think it is, but our guest, if you have a guest. ⁓ will tell us a little bit about it. One of what the biggest regenerative agriculture carbon deal, four point four five million tons of carbon credits from Kazakhstan. And I think that's super exciting. 4.45 million. This is the the scale we need. ⁓ and for me, obviously it's very exciting that it comes out of Europe. I we've seen a lot of re big regenerative agricultural deals in ⁓ the US, we've seen in Mexico, and we've seen some Africa and India, but I think Europe is still is still coming. And so I'm super, super excited to have Michael Battelson from Akrina with us to talk us a little bit through the news. Who can do this as a better better than I can do it anyways? Michael, nice to have you. speaker-1: Adrian, Dan, thanks so much for having me on CWN today, allowing me to have the opportunity to talk a little bit about AGRINA, but also not least Nature-Based Solutions, Soil Carbon, and of course the off-take agreement that we recently announced. ⁓ Very happy to be here today. speaker-2: Fantastic, fantastic. No, I mean, ⁓ Akrina we we know each other quite a bit. And I I'm passionate about Denmark as well. I studied in Denmark. I just said before my one sentence I know in Den Danish, which is you can snag a litdansk. no no, I c I can speak a little bit more, but ⁓ I'm I'm passionate about ⁓ Denmark. I really enjoyed living there. So yeah, creates Great, you you have the chance to come over. Maybe to jump right in, can you tell us a little bit more about the deal? Like what is it? How did it come together? Where's it happening? Over what time frame and so on. I'm I'm very curious as regenerative agriculture. I think especially with Vera and the VM forty two, we've seen a lot of I would say blockbuster projects coming up with a lot of volume, which is great. ⁓ so yeah, maybe can you can tell me us a little bit more about speaker-1: So, ⁓ at Agrina, we've been working with RegenAC since, well, five, six years ago, where we initiated our first flagship project, which is the Vera VM42 project that we currently hold in 10 countries around Europe. And a natural step for us, of course, is to then expand. We've been expanding both in the number of countries we are in and in the number of hectares that we've brought on to our existing platforms over the year. And of course, now with this latest deal, we announced the new project that will be our ⁓ single country project, but still with the VM42 methodology, which is the 21st market that we enter. So as you said already, it is a big deal. not only for a greener for obvious reasons, of course, but also for the nature-based space, I would say. And in particular, it's a great testament to the soil carbon credits. ⁓ It is a deal where over seven years, ⁓ there is about 4.5 million ⁓ tons of CO2 equivalent involved and thereby a lot of credits and a lot of impact. is sitting in the northern Kazakhstan rain belt, whereby we can go in and implement this project. ⁓ We expect to have around 1.6 million hectares on that program by 2028. So yes, definitely a large project with lots of impact to follow from that. speaker-3: I I have tons of questions. Being a bit of a soil nerd myself, one of my claim to fame that I always tell people at parties is that I'm one of the co-authors of VM forty two. Generally it falls a little flat. speaker-2: That works at parties? Like what kind of parties are you going to? speaker-3: You missed my punchline, but it's it doesn't generally play very well at most parties. yeah, I'm curious to hear what you know, what kinds of practice changes are you guys most focused on and what is that process like to sell to a Kazakh farmer to convince them of this change? And is it something that they're already seeing other people around them make these changes and and they're just late adopters, or are they are they first adopters of techniques that we've seen? ⁓ have have efficacy in other parts of the world. speaker-1: Yes, ⁓ of course, when we talk about a project this size and a project ⁓ in the region X space, it does come with a lot of requirements on the supplier, It does bring in the need to have real infrastructure and rigor, ⁓ such as the MRV. the farmer networks, how to work with the farmers, how to do the science, how to do the ground-truthing and all of these things. And as you mentioned, working with the farmers is a big part of this because those are the ones actually driving the impact change on the ground. So if we look at Region Act sort of overall, there are several... sort of ⁓ main pillars in the region and ag space that you would normally see, which is a big part of it reduced or no tilling ⁓ at all. So as little soil disturbance as possible. That then ⁓ going into cover cropping, residue management, ⁓ less use of fertilizers ⁓ with less use of or less soil disturbance follows also much less use of diesel and inputs altogether. So thereby driving both the ability to remove ⁓ carbon from the atmosphere and storing it in the soil, which is why we normally say that we have the solution right at our feet, right? So at the soils. but at the same time also driving reductions in the footprint for a much needed footprint in the whole food and beverage supply chain network. So, that's definitely one of the large benefits of this project type. speaker-3: I I was curious also on the commercial side, are you guys able to share ⁓ region, industry, any details about who the the buyer is? Obviously this is a really sizable agreement and ⁓ you know we've we've seen a few other large agreements announced. Typically a a deal of this size carries a a name like Microsoft or or or a few others with it, but I'm just curious how ⁓ you know how you guys are are able, what are you able to share about the buyer? speaker-1: Yeah, so unfortunately, we aren't able to share who the buyer is. ⁓ Unfortunately, that hasn't changed before today. So ⁓ I won't be dropping any sort of news bombs on that account, unfortunately. speaker-3: I thought we'd be the spot where you'd be able to announce it. But it is a I'm I'm inferring from your answer that it's a single like it's a single buyer as opposed to something that's split up across many different buyers or something. speaker-1: That can be probably the third from that one. speaker-2: Well, thanks so much. I I that was my question as well. I was very curious. ⁓ because from from my perspective, and I can only speak from the buyer's perspective, I think what I've ⁓ seen in the past is that there is still a little bit of hesitation sometimes from bias towards regenerative agriculture, if you compare it for instance with ⁓ ARR. And then probably now it's a lot because he Did both at at Indigo and now now with Mombak. And I think a feel still also like it, especially in Europe, a lot of companies are waiting for EU CRCF to at least get that government stamp. I we all know nothing will change for the project. I think with the CRCF, you will not change your project and how you do it, right? But The stamp is really good. How how do you convince a buyer that your project and regenerative agriculture project, ⁓ yeah, lives up to the to the impact it's promising? speaker-1: Yes, so think ⁓ as with a lot of other, I think that's a really good question. So as with a lot of other projects and project types, it is increasingly being ⁓ important how to actually display the rigor that you put into your project. And I think that working with a standard like the VM42, which allows us to really display the standard that we want and the high quality in our credits is something that we already, with the first project we launched ⁓ our European, a greener carbon project across 10 countries could display but also see how clients react to ⁓ that display of quality and rigor. And then of course, I think it's also about how we as a company have built the platform. both for working with the farmers and how to engage with them on where they are and on their everyday life on a farm, but not least also, again, coming back to the same word, but rigor in the MRV process whereby we really go deep into the ground truth thing, but also at the same time allow for ⁓ satellite imagery and machine learning to ⁓ to document and verify these impacts on the ground, so to speak. speaker-3: On the MRV side, are you guys managing that entire process yourselves? Do you have other partners that you're working with as a part of this? I I yeah, just as you said, I imagine there's quite a large ⁓ combination of modeling and measurement under VM forty two that would have to happen for you to to do this across such a broad landscape. So just curious, yeah, if you can share a little bit about the approach you guys take there. speaker-1: Yeah, so definitely a lot of proprietary parts of the model and also the data work that goes into it. ⁓ But at the same time, ⁓ working with partners where it makes sense and where it goes sort of required. ⁓ So it is a combination of those, but I think the platform that we've built ⁓ really does contain the end-to-end ability to run a project ⁓ both of this type and of this scale, which again is a little bit or a lot testamented by having now two large scale projects on the platform, I think with a lot of hectares already being ⁓ handled. speaker-2: I I also think if I correct me if I'm wrong, I I've I think the European project ⁓ also has a triple B rating, right? So I think it's I I also think there's I'm not even sure is there a regenerative agriculture project with a better rating. so that obviously is also also great. I'm wondering one more thing, is like I've seen recently just You know, like get like mails like crazy from projects. ⁓ but I've seen a couple in the past that actually say they will do the isometric soil carbon standard. I'm not sure also to Dan, ⁓ but both of you, have you seen any comparison or what will be different? Because I mean Dan you you also had these thinking a lot in the past, right? Which standard should we go with? And I think in the end you ended up with isometric. I'm just Very curious how does conversation because I'm not very deep in the re regionac, ⁓ if there is a conversation that already compares to standards. speaker-1: Was that a question for me or for Dan? speaker-2: I'm not sure we ever known something about it. speaker-3: Yeah, I can give my answer, but I would love to hear your perspective, ⁓ Michael as well. I mean, I think we you know, we are as you said, Adrian, right, really important to think about which standards you're you're using in the market. Of course, there's lots of trade-offs and costs and speed and customer experience and and the approach ⁓ that that the different registries are using, especially with some of the new entrants like isometric, using quite a different process. ⁓ ⁓ than than what we've seen historically from from Vera. You know, Indigo ended up because we were so we had so much challenge ⁓ and for forecasted also a lot of challenge in navigating the pathway with different registries. We ended up working with both Vera to create VM42 and also with the Climate Action Reserve to make the ⁓ soil enrichment protocol. And then our US project ended up being listed on on under car. ⁓ whereas some of the international projects that that indigo did were, of course, ⁓ with with Vera. So and that was that was also 1.0 when we didn't really know what we were building here. And so having now seen this process, you know, a couple of times and seen Vera and Isometric battle it out for reforestation project developers right now. Yeah, I'm really curious to hear your perspective on how you guys, presumably you picked Vera. Because VM forty two was the only option when you started the projects, have you looked at making a transition? Do you see reasons to ⁓ to move to any of these newer protocols like isometric? Or do you think this yeah, the the the MRV approach and and ⁓ you know overall approach of of Vera is is good enough and works well for your project type? speaker-1: So being mainly on the commercial side from my perspective, I'll refrain from going too deep into the differences between the methodologies and these things. what I can definitely say is that ⁓ VM42 was the methodology for our first project. ⁓ We issued our first... a batch of credits from that project almost to the date a year ago after a process of back and forth with Vera. But how we've seen our clients respond to the Vera and to the way that those credits come about and the rigor in that methodology, I would I would think that our scientists has mainly sort of that in there for having good feedback from both the market and the clients. To speculate around isometrics would not really fall under my sort of strong suits of deep knowledge, I would say. speaker-2: Fair. Okay. To wrap it up, what what's on the horizon for Ukraina in the next years? speaker-1: In the next years, ⁓ well, growth, I would say, both in ⁓ bringing more hectares onto our projects that currently stand. But of course, we also do want to be ⁓ continuously driving regeneric and ⁓ soil carbon forward. ⁓ because it is really the passion, also the platform that we've put a lot of effort into driving. ⁓ it's a project type that we think has a massive ⁓ potential still with the solutions just beneath our feet for both removing carbon from the atmosphere, but also reducing footprint in the farming sector. all together. speaker-2: Fantastic. Thanks so much for coming and congrats again on the on the big achievement. I mean four point five mil is is quite a big feat. So ⁓ t to to what is it? Tulukke or t shit, my is bad. Tuluke and tuck for that. speaker-1: Many thanks and your Danish isn't that bad I must say Adrian. speaker-2: No, no, no, no, no. They're dolid. speaker-1: Thanks a lot Adrian and Darren. Thanks, Ragnar. speaker-2: Have a good one, ⁓ Cheers, bye. speaker-1: Cheers, bye. speaker-2: Another important topic that is CDR COP. And we have two super interesting guests here that will speak about it and a little bit alongside one big initiative called Think Negative. They will tell us a little bit what it's about, but I would say let's jump in there. All right, Antie and Chris, welcome to CWN. I'm super excited to have you both and maybe Auntie, you start and tell us a little bit more about yourself, but then also about think negative, what is it, why should we care? And Chris, you can jump in whenever you feel is right. speaker-1: Thank you, Adrian, for the ⁓ invitation and opportunity to be here. yeah, Antti is my name. I'm the co-founder and vice chairman of PuroEarths. And we are a carbon removal standard and registry. Yeah, and we've been part of Think Negative now for ⁓ last year and this year, ⁓ which is a platform that enables different participants in the CDR, the carbon dioxide removal ecosystem, to ⁓ join and work together in advancing the role of carbon removals within the ⁓ UN ⁓ framework. speaker-0: Yeah, I'm Chris Neidle. I'm ⁓ the Carbon Removal Lead for an organization called the Climate High Level Champions. And we're a organization that actually supports the the president ⁓ of the COP every year. The the COP conference is ⁓ hosted by a different country. So we assist them directly on developing and delivering the action agenda. As the carbon removal lead, my role is to try to insert embed carbon removal into different areas ⁓ of the action agenda. ⁓ been in the carbon removal space for about a decade, which is a long time for carbon removal, not quite as long as Anti. And ⁓ prior to that I was a advocate for ⁓ renewable energy for fifteen years globally. speaker-2: Fantastic. Thank you so much. ⁓ it's very diverse and I I think ⁓ obviously we see in the in the carbon removal space that there's a lot of partnerships between different initiatives and I think this is also like how I think negative ⁓ works. I I I mean we are also part of it at at Zencken. But maybe can can we talk about? I mean There are big goals, right, that we have for for carbon removal. There's a lot of I mean, investment and volume that we need to to get to. Why is it so important to bring this topic especially to COP thirty one this year? speaker-0: Yeah, I can I can start with that. I mean, I think you can COP is, you know, to use an Americanism, it's it's it's the Super Bowl or the World Cup, I guess you could say, of of sort of climate ⁓ action and attention. And it it really has a a pull gravitationally on the you know limited attention span that that we have ⁓ globally. And so there's sort of two ways of thinking about that. You know, there's important work that happens within the COP. It's the the negotiations for the implementation of the Paris Agreement, it's this action agenda I described. Which is a many ⁓ layered ⁓ sort of articulation of new ambitions and commitments. And so being featured in that is is critically important ⁓ for obvious reasons, but it also brings together so many different actors in one space in a condensed period of time. And me and Auntie were just talking about this in Tokyo last week, but So much about carbon removal is being able to really infiltrate and be at the right tables and be incorporated into the the the vision. And ⁓ just by being at COP creates these enormous opportunities for gaining more of that traction, more of that integration. So it's just a critical opportunity that really can't be missed ⁓ for a very diverse sectors like ours that has to grow and spread very quickly. speaker-2: Fantastic. And I mean, from from my perspective, but also from Dan perspective, obviously we have a lot of ⁓ sustainability people from corporates, but also I would say strategy and CFO and so on. A lot of them they won't be at COP, right? ⁓ they won't be there. But as he said, Chris, it's still really important. But what could COP change on how they buy carbon removal next year and And fault commerce. speaker-1: Well, I mean, ⁓ it's unlikely that this scope will change a lot ⁓ in terms of the activities and purchase portfolios or create portfolios for next year. But things that happen there are likely to have an impact on what is available in 2032 or 2035. So as we know, this is a huge industry that needs to be built and We need all the incentives that are ⁓ possible to enable the setting up this industry and growing it today so that tomorrow everybody has the ability to actually buy stuff. speaker-0: Yeah, I'd say it's an it's an indirect connection. But again, it's it's being able to gain credibility and understanding and focus is the thing that really the oxygen that feeds in a both direct and indirect ways the prospect of purchasing or policies that are put in place that actually create demand. So just a moment to again be included in that mix ⁓ you know, has a a really powerful impact, I think, on the future standing of carbon. speaker-3: Are you seeing durable CDR start to be a stronger part of the conversation? Like it feels to me that there are some tailwinds now with biochar, for example, seeing a rather explosive increase in the total amount of of credits issued and engagement with buyers. That perhaps that's bringing durable CDR into a new category. But I'd love to hear is that is it having an impact? Are you are you seeing more engagement and more response on this category? speaker-0: Yeah, I mean biochar is a good example. It's kind of the the gateway or the the poster child ⁓ you know of CDR. It it it it carries a lot of weight, I think. I think in sort of really projecting important concepts, including durability, ⁓ including that carbon removal is real. It's happening. There's a market for it. It can be made globally in different types of ways. And a lot of times that's the sort of frame of reference through which people approach carbon removal is through a limited set of of solutions like that. But I would say, yeah, durability, you know, it's an evolving picture where it used to be this kind of strict divide between what we call nature-based, which obviously you know well, Dan, and durable. And I think what we're seeing now almost each year is this not quite a happy ⁓ marriage or merger, but a more sophisticated understanding that we need both from a science perspective and actually the combination of these very diverse pathways. makes for a much more powerful product ⁓ for for buyers as well. So I think we complain and we're we're eager and you know urgently want to be, you know, more integrated, but we see step changes every year. And I think this year we're in a really good position because some of the the framing around it, you know, this is the UNEP 1.5 overshoot report just came out. You know, we're now at that reality moment that really I think people understand carbon rulers should is that if we want to keep 1.5 alive, the the you you don't have that without carbon ⁓ you know, and so that'll be an important sort of background music, I think, for this cop that really kind of changes the way I think we talk about carbon rule and people understand it. speaker-1: Yeah, if I may add, indeed, Biochar is a great example and something that is very easy to approach. ⁓ So, the investment size is relatively small and you can get stuff started with a few million euros or dollars. And ⁓ there are so many ⁓ good references that have bought ⁓ Biochar credits and have been proud of that. ⁓ ⁓ intermediaries like Zenken have done a tremendous job in making them even more approachable. now that there are these good examples, it is also easier to bring into that sort of more official agenda or policy-led schemes agendas. speaker-2: Also to me it always feels like on a corporate level it's like biochar is fantastic, it works really well. We go and say, like, hey, you maybe don't have hundred euro per credit, but let's look at, for instance, Oxford principles and like slowly phase in biochar. But then I always look at more national policies like Article Six and so on. and really often there is like biochar and so on have have no no big say, right? Now with EVTS, I think we've seen the first things, but also their biochair is not part of at the moment. But obviously at least we we get decks and and and backs. But I'm just thinking like for article sa article six, if Germany for instance needs to buy credits, then they obviously if it runs through a tender and so on, then they will go for the cheapest credit that will make article six, right? And I see that in a lot of other markets, like for instance South African carbon tax, you also you can go for for any credit that that fits the requirements. Do we see, or maybe you have some insider information, but I'm always curious, same for COSIA, that we make some some progress on integrating durable carbon into into these kind of schemes? speaker-0: I I'll just say Auntie can speak to some of the particulars on that. Well, one just sort of I think really important theme, or not theme, but reality to really pick up on, is that all of these things influence each other. and that to get to finally penetrate the inner mechanics of compliance systems or the the larger voluntary markets, there has to be a frame of reference that's set up that those trust. Earlier. And that's why the really important work of these initial buyers like Frontier and Microsoft, they say it explicitly if you ask them, the real end goal is to sort of influence policy. They're they're creating, they're they're grappling with some of the the questions and difficulties around, you know, how what constitutes carbon removal? What does durability or permanence actually really mean? What's an acceptable MRV system? And if you've really been following this for the last few years, where we are right now, where it's starting to make integration into ETS systems. ⁓ that is really the outcome of this other pioneering work. You know, they're not separate from each other. So while right now there's very there is some precedents that have been made, ⁓ Anti can speak to because he's been, you know, more directly involved in it with Article Six, the very first Article VI deal for carbon removal. Germany actually, or GIZ is now moving forward with a pilot ⁓ around Article Six and carbon removal with three African countries. So we're beginning to see those early adopters and pioneers arrive. And that is the the grist for for more ambition from other countries. So, you know, I of course we would want more, we would like to see it, but I think it's actually spreading out in a way and taking hold that I wouldn't say we're on track, but I think it's moving in the right direction. But I'm wondering if if Auntie Auntie agrees. speaker-1: Yeah, well, we're now at the face of doing the practice runs. So yes, we are, you know, one of the parties that are facilitating the world's first ITMO ⁓ transaction for, ⁓ you know, geologically stored carbon, which is happening in ⁓ Norway and will be delivered to Switzerland ⁓ to ⁓ together with the corresponding adjustment. So there's a bunch of coalition of buyers and ⁓ And ⁓ yeah, these grades will will go also to the ⁓ NDC of Switzerland in the same transaction. So, ⁓ I mean, it's nice and it's good that we get the sort of the sequence and the bureaucracy right. But I think in order for this to be meaningful, ⁓ we would need to see more countries set sort of separate goals for, you know, regular sinks and then separately for removals. speaker-2: Yeah, because that was my thinking. What is the incentive for a country? If they have no like for instance goals set up, like for instance in Germany, I think it's five percent ⁓ of their climate neutrality targeted still of two forty, they are allowed to do with international credits. But if they have nothing like separate sub targets set up, then obviously there is not a big incentive to do so, right? ⁓ so they would then probably if I understand it correctly, would say like of these five percent, let's say ten percent, twenty percent or whatever needs to be I would say removal and then maybe different durabilities or do I understand that correctly? speaker-1: Yeah, that would be ideal. Yeah. speaker-2: Of course. Because I always think it's ridiculous that a company that has a net zero target in two forty, let's say under SBTI, they're only allowed to use durable ⁓ removals. And then a country that has the same target, they don't call it net zero mostly, right? In ⁓ at least in Germany they call it climate, climate neutral still. they then allowed to use any kind of international credit. So ⁓ some it it feels like there's definitely something not adding up hundred percent from my perspective. speaker-0: Yeah, I mean, I think we we again the the kind of this this the story of this is sort of unfolding in real time. Like what you're talking about where it doesn't add up. Me and Auntie talk about this all the time, as do others. It came up, you know. It's about inclusion of carbon rule. And I think what's forcing the issue on it is time relative to the progress we're making. So we're now in a f period of time, we've known for a long time, ⁓ but it's I think it's really sort of the world is waking up to it and decision makers is that We're gonna need to do removals. ⁓ it's just ⁓ it's a fact, ⁓ to to reach the the the goals that we have and to wind back the clock, you know, so to speak, ⁓ for for overshoot. That is that was an obscure idea not not a long time ago. One that there was a lot of resistance and biases against. In in very rapidly that's fading away just because events are overtaking reality. ⁓ you can't say with a straight face that we're gonna accomplish Paris goals now without removals. And so the policy will be maybe a lagging indicator of of that fact, but it will that lag will close and we're gonna start to see more and more progress. And we already are. ⁓ so I'm I'm actually somewhat optimistic while, you know, deeply ⁓ anxious and uncomfortable as we all kind of have to be as a default emotional mode as CDR advocates, but we're making a lot of progress. And you know, it hopefully every cop becomes this marker about what can we get declared and said out loud from high stages? What can we be included in? and I think the opportunities are incredibly ripe for that this year, but at cops in general. speaker-2: I I also think it's another thing that I wanted to add on the pressure and slowly getting there. ⁓ we obviously in next week or so, or it's in two weeks, we in Europe have the Empowering Consumer Directive coming up, right? And one thing we've seen that now with a couple of companies. One for instance was McDonald's, Germany. ⁓ there was another one called Dr. Utgar. It is like they're doing a lot of baked baked goods. They had a goal, I don't know, two forty five and so on, ⁓ of net zero, and they didn't have a strategy to get there. And that's the reason they're not allowed to make that claim, even just saying ⁓ we're gonna be net zero in two twenty f ⁓ two thousand forty five. ⁓ and if you set up a strategy and you say, Okay, we're gonna reduce and that's it, then you still under MCO, you it will be illegal so to say to say you're gonna be net zero to forty five, right? Because if you look at things like the new ISO standard or SBTI, then I also say, okay, you have to phase in removals earlier. And I think this is also the interesting ⁓ step change that we see, right? That now from a legal perspective even, you're not allowed to say you're gonna be net zero at a certain point if you don't have a strategy phasing in carbon removal. And it would be weird if That would be true for companies and not for countries at a certain point. It's a statement, not a question. speaker-1: I mean, that may you're absolutely correct, of course, and the use case for credits is absolutely critical. It would need to be verified. That would already in itself ⁓ unlock a huge amount of new demand. if companies can, you know, safely ⁓ without fear of sort of green shaming. ⁓ They could make use of credits and, for example, neutralize the emissions of a certain product or product line. speaker-2: Sam. All right, cool. But to to wrap this up, what do you think from a policy perspective, if you each of you could name like one thing that would have the biggest impact on CDR, what would it be? Chris, you go first. speaker-0: Yeah, and and I want to steal yours because you probably have the same thing. I think I mean a lot of what we deal with right now, it's not the sexiest thing. And I'll talk about, you know, when we think about policy, it's what's the next thing that has to happen in order for then the next thing to happen. You have to think in those stages. And a lot of it is that the the the kind of architecture for accounting around climate was not built for carbon removals. It's almost the way that the grid wasn't built for solar, right? And so, you know, you have to adapt that. That infrastructure for it. And so a lot of with carbon removal, it's different than other solutions, that it fits in in many different ways. There's many instances in which you can use carbon removal in a climate effective way. ⁓ you know, the one I'm obsessed with is the integration of CDR into industrial products as a use in their waste streams and their, you know, in their processing. Right now, accounting in terms of being able to credit that, that that has happened towards is not there's so much ambiguity there that it it can't really drive. markets or or or participation. And so really accelerating and in understanding we have a problem there and bringing together the right actors to resolve those ambiguities in a in a favorable way as rapidly as possible is the first order of a business, I think, because so many other things rest on top of that. ⁓ and Auntie might agree with and even have more things to add to it. But I would say that working on that area, I think, is is absolutely critical to resolve. Otherwise we're kind of groping around in the dark and with, you know, best wishes rather than a a real market. speaker-1: Yeah, I mean, fully agree, of course. And that is definitely the primary thing. ⁓ I mean, ⁓ it would be great if we saw a number of countries actually setting some ⁓ separate quantified targets for removals, you know, to act as the pioneers. And there does in a way also perhaps lay the foundation for the next level of requirements for other countries. ⁓ speaker-2: That would be that would be great. speaker-0: Yeah, inclusive C D R and N D C's is the is the Exactly. Exactly Yeah. That's that's a huge ⁓ not far off in the future, but you know, in the in the near term, I think is really the kind of the the the big one that we we sort of use as our North Star for effective advocacy. speaker-2: Yeah. speaker-3: This is the first time that I've heard someone ask that question recently and not get the answer, just be more buyer demand. So it's it's good to hear that there are other things that that also need to to be worked on, ⁓ beyond just, you know, getting more buyers around the table. But speaker-2: And how can people speaker-1: It is true. It is true that we need more buyers, but how do we get them? Well, we need to get them something in return. And ⁓ the clarity on the claims that you can make for a corporation and for a country is essential. speaker-2: And how can people support think negative? speaker-1: Well, there's actually a platform that, well, if you go to think-negative.org, you'll see the ⁓ mission and information about the whole initiative, more in detail, and then separately, it is possible to become a sponsor and select the sort of a suitable sponsorship type. And then there's also a ⁓ programming application platform that is available for all the Think Negative members. The threshold or the way to become a member is actually quite easy. Just apply and you are in. And then you can ⁓ pitch or bid for ⁓ a slot in the pavilion, the physical pavilion that is inside the Blue Zone. So definitely worthwhile to check it out. There's ⁓ programming guideline document according to which the rating or the scoring of those bits is going to happen. So I would encourage everybody to do that. speaker-0: Yeah, and I would just add, you know, a big part of Think Negative is ⁓ the outward communications. How do we sort of package, you know, a lot of the problem that CDR has is it sort of dissolves within this bigger attention space. And so the patterns that people like me and Auntie and Dan see that look like progress that show that this is real aren't immediately visible, I think, to the world. And so I think a real key for us is as we're sending our communications out through Think Negative and our partners about what the good news is, what are the major moves. We need people to not only read those, but to pass them along ⁓ as well. And then I would also add for folks that are involved in the carbon removal space, and Dan, I'll be ⁓ pinging you probably later on this. We want to be able to catalog the the moves that have been made this year. ⁓ what are the unprecedented sort of frontier pushing things that have happened in carbon removal, whether it's a new kind of project or a new kind of partnership or a new policy put in place. And so for those that are already within the CDR universe, you know, we'll be reaching out to there to see can we catalog those in a coherent way through COP so that that picture becomes a little bit more clear and more trust is built. So we we have a lot of communication to do with our partners to make that happen, you know, in the now two months we have ⁓ for Cop to before COP happens. Can't believe it's that soon. speaker-2: No, the year's is basically over. All right. Thanks guys. ⁓ it was it was a great chat and thanks for telling us a little bit more about Think Negative and yeah. Everyone support Think Negative. See you. Perfect. Thanks. speaker-1: Thank very much. speaker-3: Thank you guys. speaker-2: Then let's go on to another topic that we already talked about before, which is carbon credit ratings. ⁓ Deep Sky just announced that ⁓ they got a pre-issuance ⁓ rating for the direct air capture facility from Severa. And ⁓ I think it was triple A to A. So it's basically a range. They they do this sometimes. And it's the first ever pre issuance rating for a direct air capture project. And Dan and I, we were already talking a little bit about it. What does that even mean? What is the use of a pre issuance rating and why would especially a direct air capture project need a rating? Like then maybe start at the beginning. speaker-3: Yeah, I you know, I think that obviously the ratings companies are needing to continue to find more places to sell and and more opportunities to to market their products. I think there is a lot of value to understanding in this pre-issuance world what the quality of a project is. We see every buyer we engage with wanting to understand What's the quality? What's the delivery risk? What's the team look like? Are these guys going to be able to execute? Am I going to be written up in a Guardian article because I'm getting credits from this project? Right. These are really important questions. But generally we sort of see buyers falling into one of two camps where either they are big enough that they run diligence in-house and do a pretty detailed process, in which case they don't really need a rating, or they hire some third party to either basically go out and do the diligence for them, but answer the questions as they need them or hire an intermediary to d run the full process for them, like a like Senkin. ⁓ and so, you know, in my in my mind, it's sort of this question of, okay, well then who would who would benefit from this kind of a rating because it probably doesn't meet all the diligence requirements of a buyer in either of those two camps. ⁓ you know, I think my perspective is more in the world of a post-issuance rating has the potential to allow a spot purchaser or some other corporate that wants to just do a small deal, get off the ground and and, you know, understand the quality of the thing they're buying before they do it. That I think is a really clear use case. This one, not so much. And for a direct air capture project, as you said, right? I would imagine that the the biggest risks here are probably can the team really follow through with this project? And that's not really what a rating looks at. speaker-2: Yeah, and as a disclaimer, we we actually work with Deep Sky and we did like a big off take with ⁓ a major aviation company. So I know it's a good project, but I'm also wondering on on the pre-issuance side, ⁓ what is what is the value? Because I'm not sure if a company will then say like hi, I'll give you some catalytic investment because of a rating. There would always then on top of that also do the two things that you just said, either in house ⁓ due diligence or with someone like us. So I'm also curious ⁓ what this is about. There's maybe some value in that and then I'm not hundred percent sure. Maybe if you the rating agencies they have some offer like if you do preissuance, then you maybe it's like a deposit on the on the full rating later on. I I can imagine, right, if they for instance maybe it already did some of the due diligence at that point and then it's ⁓ it translates into a full rating, but I also see a little bit more value on it ⁓ later on. And yeah, if it also for the for the ⁓ direct air capture side, I'm I'm not sure. I think at this point, in my view The investors into direct air capture, they are basically almost see that a little bit as story and R and D investment, not so much about because it's it's not cost effec efficient, right? At this point. ⁓ everyone knows that. So I'm not sure if they actually do it because they even need to be 100% sure about these rating things. But we also don't know. Maybe ⁓ Deep Sky also talked to buyers and they're like, Look, we know what the news were about with Climeworks. So maybe now we have to maybe there is some kind of narrative that we don't know about, right? Because I know that some they are like I talk to ⁓ buyers and they are a little bit scared of the these whole Climeworks news. I also I I was actually I bought myself some Climeworks credits and I think 219 or 220 or something like that. And I recently got a news that ⁓ I if I want to change my delivery date and want to push it back, ⁓ but therefore get twice as many credits. Or if I want to in instead invest into biochar and other projects, ⁓ and then they can deliver it now and they will deliver more. So obviously. ⁓ there is timing issues, but I'm not sure if the initial investors actually that was what they were aiming for. And that's the reason I'm not sure if I maybe have a narrative that or a different narrative than than someone at at a direct air capture company. speaker-3: Yeah, it it feels a little bit like may as you're saying, maybe it's a entry point of okay, have a rating and then we'll do all of our other work on top of that. Maybe there's a group of folks who who are in that camp. We have seen that with some buyers who say they would like to buy from rated projects. they just have a preference for it. Typically that's a buyer who is again of an earlier newer into the market. So they're just trying to kind of cover that risk a bit more. ⁓ but again, you know, if you're if you're trying to raise investor capital, it feels like it's more some of these general startup risk questions. And do you really want to bet on this team? And having seen the ratings process, I don't think that's exactly what you're getting out of this. I don't think a venture capital investor who's a carbon ⁓ supplier investor is gonna be looking at ratings in order to judge, you know, where they should place bets in their portfolio. So speaker-2: No. But then on the other hand I'm also thinking again And that me, I'm I'm an engineer, but I love marketing and sales. Once you have the headline in the internet that one project got rated with AAA, and someone in the future will search for Google, tell me if this is high quality. I'm 100% sure that all the LLMs will say, like, this is a fantastic project, they have triple A. Because the internet is not when LLMs are not smart from this perspective. So I I I see some value from that perspective, to be honest. ⁓ but yeah, it's maybe different ⁓ value than the initial thought from that we had maybe. speaker-3: Well, Deep Sky is thinking that far in advance about how L L Ms will review their project in the future for future buyers, then hats off to them. I I guess we should be ⁓ we should be doing this kind of work ourselves. So speaker-2: But let's ⁓ switch gear to a different project methodology, which is biochar. I see super critical, they just released a new report which they call the Biochar Supply Crunch. and they say 81% of high quality biochar supply was committed by July 2026. and in 2025 that threshold wasn't crossed until October. So we see that biochar supply towards the end of the year gets tighter and tighter. And we've seen that last year. ⁓ there was one financial player that tried to get ⁓ industrial biochar credit towards the end of the year. I don't not sure I think it was November or something like that. And we see that often with corporates, towards the end of the year or like beginning of of ⁓ or Q one of next year, they're trying to case basically go into procurement and then either the credits are not there anymore in biochar. I'm not sure also sure about AI, you can tell me a little bit about it. But for biochar, really often towards the end of the year everything is sold out because there's not a lot of ⁓ old supply lying in the markets that you could always say like, okay, ⁓ I couldn't get the high quality biochar, let's go one one step down. What we would sometimes see with other project types. But for Biochar, there was literally just nothing left. So they in the end had to pay forty percent more. And then they told me that in the year after, again, so mid or beginning of this year, they got offered the old price, so forty percent down again. So ⁓ I definitely see this biochar supply crunch, but yeah, also say biochar sales in in H one, so basically first half of twenty twenty six. nearly doubled compared to twenty twenty five and that's excluding Microsoft, the rest of the market grew more than fivefold. So if you take Microsoft out, the other buyers are actually growing quite quickly in the in the biochar space. ⁓ and off takes trough nearly all of that growth. So I think maybe some learned in the past and they were like, ⁓ damn, sport is maybe not the best way to interact with that market. Let's let's figure out these off takes. How how do you see that? Do you see that? speaker-3: Yeah, it's a very interesting dynamic. I think we're as a supplier trying to figure this out for the first time. We have credits that we just issued in July and had our first swing at the spot market to understand how the buyer dynamics play out, how allocation is being done, what times buyers are locking up their allocation for a given year, because it just as you said, right? A lot of the smarter buyers don't want to end up at the end of the year. In a crunch in November, December, trying to figure out how to fill their portfolio. ⁓ at the same time, there often can be an end-of-year crunch because they thought they were going to get credits from someone else. And so there's an opportunity to to sell into that market. And it's a very different dynamic than the forward catalytic off-take space that we have played in in the past and one where Not a lot of suppliers have experience in in this either. So you feel a little bit more like a, you know, grain trader, I would imagine, or a, you know, a a car salesman where you're sort of, okay, I got this inventory, but do you want it or do you know go, ⁓ get it over here? ⁓ yeah, I'm gonna have to drop your allocation down and move you up or move you back. And ⁓ fortunately, there is a lot of, you know, we are seeing a lot of demand. And what we've heard from a number of buyers is there's not a lot of high quality. product available in the market. So if you actually do want to buy spot and you want to interact with with good projects, your options are are extremely limited. And that of course plays to the hand of suppliers who are able to participate, but it's a really small number who who are kind of willing to or capable of of playing in that market, right? You've, for the most part, especially in a world where most projects are delayed or behind schedule or are ⁓ or are signing up as much of their volume ahead of time as they can. Of course, you know, you this is not a a place that you can enter. So we're we're trying our hat at it a little bit to trying our hand at it to see if but but also learning as we go to understand how these dynamics work. speaker-2: I also it's very two different sales approaches, off take and spot, as you just mentioned, right? I think in like off take, you just have a really structured sales approach. You come together, you talk about, you do due diligence, ⁓ and so on and so forth, and you can build up your champion and so on. And then spot, as you just said, sometimes is like Hey, I sometimes get a LinkedIn message, it's like Hey, so next week we actually ⁓ running this RFP and we need to buy fifty thousand credits. ⁓ I'm following you for the past year ⁓ and I want you to participate. ⁓ can I send you the requirements? And I was like, Okay. Yeah, and also by the way, it's only two weeks ⁓ that RFP period, so then you have to ⁓ basically hand it in. And it's A three week sales process and then I asked them, like, hey, can we talk? Can I maybe and he's like, No, sorry, I'm so busy. so basically it's a person that followed me for a year. I've I've never talked to that person, and they like, I like your work, but can you participate and offer me what you have? And I was like, Okay, let me see what I have. It's it's an interesting process. speaker-3: It can be a little nerve wracking if you if you if you're in a position of needing to offload credits and you don't know exactly where they're gonna go. So ⁓ you know, I I think as I said, we're we're in this interesting position as well where we're actually getting more credits earlier than we had thought. Which is a great position to be in, but it also then also it creates the supply to say, okay, now I've got to go figure out where I want to allocate these or how best to allocate them as responsibly as possible. So ⁓ let's talk into we'll continue talking about this topic, but I'm sure I'll have more thoughts as we're a little deeper in the year and we've had more ⁓ more opportunity. There's a side of me that says, ⁓ just find one buyer who'll take all of it and you can be done with it. And then there's another side who's like, ⁓ let's have 20 deals running where we can try all these different things out and learn as much as possible about the market. ⁓ but you know, we'll see. speaker-2: And the thing is like our strategy is always educate them up, you know? Educate them from spots and let them get to know you and then try to push them into off takes. Not forcefully, but with education. speaker-3: Yeah, exactly. speaker-2: All right, we're coming to the end of the episode, but the end doesn't mean it ends right now. We still have around 30 minutes and we have another topic and guest. ⁓ we just said it in the beginning already. So many things happened over the last ⁓ two weeks, so many interesting things and good things actually happened. As mentioned probably before New Year Climate Week, it's always a good thing to announce stuff, right? And ⁓ one thing that was announced and it's quite a big thing. It's the Google's biggest methane deal. Before we were talking about should it should we call it methane or methane? And we checked the difference between British and American English. And I said, My wife, as she is South African, and in ⁓ South Africa you get thrilled in the British English. Whenever I say something American, she's like, No. It's not sidewalk, it's pavement. And ⁓ so I will stick to the British version and then you can stick to the American version. I say methane from now on. Google signed its biggest rice methane deal, which is ⁓ I think a million credits through two thousand and thirty. ⁓ I'm not sure, Dan, have you ever heard anything about methane, rice methane credits? ⁓ do you have any experience, any thoughts on it? speaker-3: Well, I I happen to have met Xavi before. So ⁓ I know a little bit about this from him. And then also during my life at Indigo, actually the first place that we started looking as a company when we were trying to think about getting into carbon removal and avoidance was in in rice and in alternative wetting and drying and the the same techniques that are being used in these kinds of projects. So, you know, I didn't know anything about this before then, but obviously learning over the years, just how much of an emitter this is, ⁓ you know, and and the techniques that are used for flooding rice fields so commonly around the world. ⁓ so yeah, I I actually happen to know quite a bit about it, but ⁓ it's it's a really exciting to to see this deal announced because this is certainly the largest of of any deal we've seen in this in this space. speaker-2: No, it's it's crazy. And I think ⁓ the whole super pollutant narrative ⁓ definitely ⁓ helps you as well. And ⁓ yeah, I'm super excited to have ⁓ Xavi here today with co-founder of Miti Labs, the company behind that one million credit deal with Google. ⁓ Shavi, thanks for coming. We're we're super happy to have you. Thank you so much for having me. Yeah, fantastic. ⁓ Super super excited. Yeah, cool. Maybe to to kick it right off, can you tell us a little bit more about like what is this deal about and also about yourself and and Miti Labs? Yeah, let me give you a bit of a ⁓ a boring spiel on on us at Miti Labs. So we are we're a business that started about three years ago ⁓ with my two co founders, Dev Del andate. Dev is based in ⁓ out in Bangalore ⁓ with most of the team. ⁓ Nate and I are both in the US and then we've got a a small kind of commercial team in Europe. we we essentially launched to specifically target this rice methane problem, methane and water problem. ⁓ so rice, you know, contributes around ⁓ over twelve percent of ⁓ of global methane emissions. ⁓ it consumes over thirty percent of irrigated water. So it's a it's a huge water challenge as well. We obviously talk about methane a lot because it's it's what ⁓ we commercialize, but the water as a co-benefit or you know in some cases starting to be commercialized is quite a an important one as well. And ⁓ and yeah we've now, you know, ⁓ been three years season after season ⁓ supporting onboarding and supporting farmers and transitioning to what we call alternate wet wetting and drying. So going from kind of conventional rice practices to ⁓ alternate wedding and drying. And what what essentially is happening here, if if you haven't been familiar with with this whole area of rice methane is ⁓ traditionally ⁓ well rice is essentially grown by about a hundred fifty million smallholder farmers. As Dan was mentioning, of course there's there's also farm and ⁓ rice farming in the US and you know in in near where I'm from in Barcelona, we've got quite a bit of rice as well. But when you look at the kind of hectares and sizes, it's really the majority of it is grown in India, Southeast Asia, China. And that's mainly grown by farmers that, you know, manage around one hectare farm size. So it's really a this d huge distributed challenge across a lot of smallholder farmers. And most of these farmers today, they essentially flood the field from the start of the season to the end of the season. They transplant rice into a already flooded field, flooded throughout the whole time. This is basically even through monsoon, you see kind of water still being pumped onto the field. ⁓ and so it's it's ⁓ you know, it's this continuous thing. And then what we're essentially trying to do is we're well, what the problem with this flooding is that the ⁓ the soil doesn't get oxygenated. And so these ⁓ these microbes in the soil that are releasing this methane ⁓ have a chance to continue growing. And so what we do in this technique, which is alternate wetting and drying, I consider it the lowest hanging fruit in the transition of, you know, climate smart rice is you allow oxygen to reach the soil in certain parts of the season. So you don't want to affect yield, but you do let it in certain safe periods of the season ⁓ get oxygenated. And it's super simple technique. And it has, you know, you can reduce methane by over fifty percent, ⁓ water use by over thirty percent. And and so it's kind of a I consider it a a big bang for your buck, as the Americans would say, Adrian. speaker-3: You you say methane with the American ⁓ pronunciation and you also use terms like Big Bang for your bucks. I it's just amazing. ⁓ from Barcelona to London, but spoken like a true American. I I love speaker-2: Exactly. I re I recently got married to an American, so I think I'm being I'm being slowly converted. speaker-3: Maybe that time spent studying in the US also did some damage. Yeah. ⁓ that's really interesting. How d how do you I mean, obviously you said part of the challenge here, right, is these small holder farmers. How do you aggregate them? How do you explain the practice change to them? How do you coordinate such a distributed set of processes to make this come together? speaker-2: Yeah, I'd say when when we think about the problem to scale these rice solutions, whether it's AWD or it's other solutions that we could obviously discuss around stubble burning or or dry seeded rice and th there's there's a long way to go from kind of how these smallholders grow rice to the large commercial rice farmer in Arkansas, right? And so there's there's a whole spectrum. I think there's two main challenges. The first one is in the aggregation of these smallholder farmers. It's kind of like ⁓ like an Amazon last mile delivery challenge, right? How do you get to all of these different points? that's one challenge. The other challenge that we can also talk about later is the the the whole monitoring and measurement approach in this like super ⁓ smallholder setting. And so on the on the last mile approach. We basically work with different stakeholders on the ground. In in some cases in our projects, we work directly with farmers. ⁓ and in some cases we work with ⁓ partners on the ground. These tend to be local NGOs. And and what we're essentially doing is, I mean, ⁓ we've got our our own MITI ops teams on the ground, but we leverage a lot of the trust that these organizations have within their local settings. So You know, we operate in a few different states in India, we'll usually find the best organization that has successfully launched agriculture or livelihood projects in that area. We'll have to kind of start small. So really start with ⁓ we started about two years ago, we had about 8,000 hectares on boarded. Now we're about ⁓ over a hundred thousand. And so we started with really ⁓ a small setting and then you you need to you know, educate that at that village level on kind of how you can overcome a lot of the risks. The biggest risk for the for the farmer is ⁓ loss in yield, right? And so really you you and many times start with half of their fields ⁓ and then once they understand that actually by doing safe AWD there's no yields lost and they'll increase into the whole field. There's different techniques. ⁓ but it's all about having a trusted partner speaker-3: At the end of the day. speaker-2: ⁓ the right financial incentives. The majority of the revenue from these programs goes to the the farmer community and ⁓ and setting up a project in a way where you can, you know, ⁓ understand. I think one key thing that we also talk a lot about with farmers and now more and more on the demand side is the water piece. Because at the end of the day, you know, we're working in some of the most water stressed regions in the world. and you know, ⁓ these farmers, they get free electricity to pump as much water as they want from the government. ⁓ and so there's no incentive to stop doing that. But what they are starting to notice is that, you know, their village had ⁓ you know, three boroughs five years ago, and now there's, you know, 15 barwells in the village. And so they're the or or kind of the river that they're pumping the water from was allowed them to do two seasons of rice a few years ago and now they can only do one season of rice. And so there is that kind of the the water topic is a big one in in how we pitch this ⁓ to the farmers. But yeah, there's different approaches and and how we ⁓ onboard ⁓ farmers into the programs. speaker-3: That's really interesting, Shabi. I think one of the questions that comes up for me is, you know, as you're convincing farmers to participate in this, you talked about they'll start with one field and then move into another field. What's the payback period for them in a program like this? Like do they see the gains from this immediately? Cause they're getting carbon credit revenue after that first season they participate with you, or are they having to take this a little bit on a leap of faith where you're saying, no, the revenue will come in the future, but at least you didn't see any decrease in your yield, so therefore you can make this transition. speaker-2: Yeah, it's a question. No, we ⁓ so we issue credits every six months. ⁓ we we mainly focus on at the at the moment on regions where there's two seasons of rice per year. And so at the end of each season, we'll issue credits and then ⁓ that's when the farmer payment will happen. but yeah, I mean there's there's always I think this technique of kind of splitting your field is pretty common within agriculture. It it also allows you to, you know, every season's different, right? So a farmer can see a ⁓ you know, a loss in yield for environmental reasons and that happens to be the year they started AWD, ⁓ they could very logically think that that's the the case. You know, you can speak to the neighbor, but that's never quite the same comparison. So ⁓ this whole kind of splitting your field in different ways and and having that as a reference is something that that we do often and it's ⁓ it's a technique that works. ⁓ so yeah, I mean it's been ⁓ Y you know, how how we think of expanding these programs. ⁓ we obviously work with different partners in different regions. and we you know, we we look to kind of plant these different seeds or these different pilots in different areas and then it expands very quickly. ⁓ and so you really wanna we started slow with many different programs and now it each of those are growing to, you know, tens of thousands of of hectares. So it's It's quite exciting. There's also India at some point we can talk about some of the work that we ⁓ started doing in the Philippines where we recently launched pilots more kind of for that compliance market purposes. So that's a a whole other ⁓ you know, world of of ⁓ complications for for many different reasons. But it's kind of a I'd say new learnings for us going from India to to Southeast Asia, which will be a fun, fun little adventure. Xavi, and back then when we first talked, I think you were running ⁓ with gold standard, but I think now I also somewhere read something about isometric. Yeah, that's right. That's right. We currently ⁓ work with both gold standard and isometric. ⁓ so isometric launched their I mean when we started a lot of this work was kind of a phase where these ⁓ RICE programs, there have been certain rice programs in China that had ⁓ kind of gone through ⁓ quality concerns. And there'd been kind of a revamp of the Vera and the Gold Standard methodologies. That's kind of when we launched the business, ⁓ which was I guess a a good moment to say, okay, we're gonna do this better. and so we we at that time we launched with gold standards updated methodology and now we also work with isometrics new methodology that came out, I think, this May or June. ⁓ which is which is cool to have different options. Is there is there a big difference between the two? I don't see a huge difference in the methodology. I think ⁓ obviously they they work differently, those standards in in kind of your I'd say the way that ⁓ you know, timelines and and I'm yet to see kind of strong demand indicators ⁓ for one methodology or another, but it's very early days, right? So ⁓ I think we like to understand how you know the demand will will view those different methodologies. For us, in terms of the work on the ground, the the MRV work, ⁓ nothing really changes between standards. ⁓ we always try and go a little bit above and beyond what that methodology is requiring. And so it hasn't been much of a of a shift. If we talk about demand indicators, maybe it's a thesis and you have a strong opinion because you're basically only talking about met methane, ⁓ is that I mean we're talking, I would say eighty percent or so European buyers and then twenty percent ⁓ outside of Europe. It feels like especially in the US, this whole methane superpollutant narrative is way stronger than what we're seeing in Europe. When I talk to buyers ⁓ really often superpollutants, methane and so on is is more like a a side topic. It comes up often. Mostly I think because education wise, I think ⁓ a lot of the European buyers are not educated on on methane and they also it takes them a little bit longer to get away from I always call it VCM one point zero to VCM two point zero. It's just Europe is a little bit slower on that side. Do you see the same or how how do you look at that? Yeah, it's a good qu I don't know, honestly. It's look, I mean These things you can communicate them in so many different ways, right? You could position us as an agriculture project, ⁓ but then you're you're not SOC, you're ⁓ and so we've kind of gone through our evolution. At the end of the day, I I I always think of our job as a market maker. And we think of ourselves as okay, well, we need to put rice on the map of this VCM world, ⁓ or carbon markets world in general. And so, yes, I would say that in the US. specific businesses in the US, primarily ⁓ the super pollutant wave has been ⁓ meaning within the technology sector I guess has been quite ⁓ meaningful and so obviously that that helps a lot. I'd say for Europe, where we probably see most of the demand is in the ⁓ value piece. I think that it's you know our projects just happen to be ⁓ a really you know for for however ⁓ the market wants to define ⁓ a good quality project ⁓ or rating agencies or others. I think we're a project type that if you do things well like we're doing, I believe, you can get, you know, really good quality for a relatively low price, depending on, you know, what you compare it to in the market. And so I think that's where we see most of the success in Europe. I think in the US you see that as well, but you do also get this kind of like specific demand for methane and other superpollutants. Where we've maybe done quite a bit of work in that area is to make sure that rice is in there because I think in a lot of the super pollutant world, a lot of it is ⁓ industrial, right? And for us, you know, there's pros and cons. It's like, well, it's harder to measure an open system like rice compared to industrial projects, but you also have all of the social and water and environmental co benefits that don't come from those industrial projects. And so we kind of have to keep kind of banging on our horn of hey. ⁓ you know, whether you're into superpovidants or you're into good value credits, ⁓ you know, this is a solution that can work for you because yeah, all all we're kind of trying to do here is, you know, how do we get mobilized more capital to scale this this big challenge? speaker-3: You mentioned ⁓ MRV and and measurement and ⁓ you know, I when I was closest to this area five, six years ago now, like at that time people were talking about okay, we will be able to use satellites to look for water presence and absence and basically know whether somebody was following the practice and use that as a a guide. Is that does that play a role for you guys now in being able to to leverage distributed methods or or do you actually have to have sensors on the ground as well that are you know, tapped in, ⁓ pun intended ⁓ to to be able to measure how water's being used in the farm. speaker-2: No, that's right. The the I I honestly think if we hadn't kind of met Nate along the way and developed this satellite ⁓ based MRV solution, th there's no chance we could well, we could scale these rice practices. We couldn't scale them for the requirements that the VCM currently has. it's way too expensive to have sensors and way too inefficient to have people speaker-3: Cause speaker-2: physically monitoring across, you know, hundreds of thousands of hectares, let alone millions, once we scale that at that level. And so for us, what we do today is you know, I like to think of it split it between kind of the monitoring and the measurement. So on the monitoring side, what you're basically trying to do is what did a farmer do during that season? ⁓ what practices did they follow? How did they follow them? And so it's that kind of digital twin of that farm. ⁓ and there we we use ⁓ Synthetic aperture radar, ⁓ which is a type of satellite imagery that is able to detect everything from water level on the field, soil moisture, so kind of how deep those dry downs are. ⁓ and we essentially track the hydrology of the field during the season. And that is kind of one of the key indicators. Then you can also obviously track crop growth and a lot of different indicators that will help you get a picture of what happened on that field. And that's the monitoring piece. With that, we're able to understand AWD was followed, X, Y, and Z ⁓ dry downs took place at a at a field level. and then we get into the measurement piece where which is a whole other complication. And for measurement, ⁓ you know, what we're trying to kind of bring the market, there's still some you know, allowance for these kind of tier one IPCC ⁓ multiplier, fa factors ⁓ to be used. We we've really found that, you know, as you can imagine, ⁓ doing a project in the north of India or the south of India with very different agroecological zones, you're gonna get very different results. And so those factors don't usually work. ⁓ and so we go for the approach of direct measurement. So we kind of stratify our fields, we ⁓ and then we do we run test control sites for those stratas to measure ⁓ physically measure you know, carbon fluxes, methane fluxes and and nitrous oxide. And and that gets analyzed in a lab. And so that's really how we understand what happened in that field. And then we do model and extrapolate that out across ⁓ the regions. So that's that's how we do kind of the monitor and measure, ⁓ which allows us to do it at at large scale. I've sorry that I'm coming back to the to the buying side. I was just thinking, I mean, on a really easy perspective on the market, like buyers really often they separate and say removal and avoidance, right? Now you you two know way more about Google than I do because you're both working ⁓ with Google, but obviously other buyers. I think Google is only buying removal. And then super pollutants, right? I think only these these two things from from the carbon space. So basically, are you then always looking into what narrative you fit? Because if Google says sorry, you only do removal, then Mittilabs doesn't work, right? Or like how do you think about this? Because I'm always trying, like I I love MITI Labs, but then there are some buyers that ⁓ just don't have the capacity and resources to look a little bit deeper and then just say tell me like Adrian, just give me hundred percent removal things. ⁓ so I'm always trying to like what is the narrative that you can give me to convince buyers to to get MITI labs into the portfolio, especially in Europe? Yeah, it's ⁓ I mean look, the the ⁓ I'd say the buyers that are removal only are obviously a a challenging set of ⁓ actors for us to chase. Yeah. Thankfully that's ⁓ limited group ⁓ at least so far. And ⁓ and you know, there's there's a lot of things that we constantly explore and we've run tons of pilots on everything from biochar from all of the rice stubble and there's a lot of soil organic carbon work that, you know, it happens in parallel to a lot of the work that we do. And so it's it's an adjacent sea that, you know, we we explore and and potentially could could do at at some point to tap into that removal side. But At this point, what you're really looking to do is looking for the the corporates that have a a portfolio approach where they are doing removal, but also other project types, or that are open to that discussion, which I think that's where most would be in. ⁓ mainly when they start to see the quality areas and now one thing I will say, ⁓ Adrian and and kind of you you probably have more experience in this than I do because I'm sure you speak to a lot more corporates. The the ⁓ the challenge is of course in trying to get someone's attention who is, you know, bombarded with so many different types of projects to go down the rabbit hole of, you know, one niche area. It's it's a humongous niche, but, you know, rice methane. And so w why go down that route? Well, I think that's where, you know, obviously having ⁓ buyers like Google and and and others that we'll be announcing kinda helps in making it worth their while. ⁓ so it's it obviously took us a while to kinda get there. But I think it's it's kind of the the validation that we're hoping it has. Now, I don't honestly have much of a point of view on on the portfolio approach. ⁓ you know, when when I hear from buyers that they're doing removal only, it's it's hard for me to find a reason why they should explore us. And that's not really ⁓ a road I go down too often. ⁓ I think that's maybe maybe your job or someone else's job to do. I'm sure you guys are better at that. what that I've just thought about, you know who has a really good narrative, especially in Europe, is peatland. And really often what they have is mostly avoidance credits. They obviously they also have removal credits. But it's funny, sometimes buyers come to me and they say removal only. But also if you have peatland, that would be fantastic. Like in European peatland often, you know? Yeah. Because somehow they have a good narrative. And I don't know why, but C-suite loves Peatland. so it's kind of crazy. Like sometimes ⁓ they say removal only, but then they say peatland. No, that's also fine. So I think it's really often it is storytelling and narratives and like ⁓ talk to someone with a short attention span and make a case. And I I find that quite crazy because it makes no sense. I mean, I love Piedland, but ⁓ it's not ⁓ like that they're making this because like this exception because they have like this one one one reason where they say like yeah because Ptland does XYZ it's just like no Pete land's fantastic. So it's just like how can we agree with you. I think it's ⁓ I I I think it's ⁓ look this market obviously the there's its own complexities of of ⁓ I think marketing matters a lot and how you you know storytell for your project is is key. And so yeah I think Obviously for us, I would say that kind of adding removals into the projects and understanding kind of what areas to complement would open up ⁓ more doors. And again, what we're trying to do is kind of tr help transition these these regions. but of course, I'd say the the policy level or kind of like those levels are we we try and stay a bit more focused on kind of the projects themselves and and I think there's enough demand for these project types within the corporates that that we speak to that, you know, we're currently focused on those. ⁓ I'd say, you know, how we help transition buyers that already partake in kind of avoidance and reduction, or kind of do some super pollutant work, kind of targeting those and and seeing how we could fit in their portfolios. ⁓ and a lot of times they're kind of adding that environmental or that social aspect that they maybe didn't have before. And so those are usually interesting angles for us to explore. I think ⁓ you know, India is obviously a a huge market for a lot of these corporates. And so in a lot of cases, that's a really interesting angle for us. And then finally, I think what we're seeing more and more recently is the water piece. Like water is just so critical for so many organizations. I'm sure Dan and the team think a lot about the the water piece and and for us it's being kind of ⁓ yeah another I'd say maybe wave. you obviously have the food and beverage companies, because we also work kind of within the insetting side with kind of rice ⁓ players, but even within the ⁓ the food and beverage side and and now a lot of the technology businesses where water is just such an important focus. And and those are all just kind of, as you said, reasons to maybe spend a bit more time exploring us and and that could lead to to to a new partnership. Yeah, definitely. I think water is a big thing. Shavi Congrats again. Thanks so much for coming on the show and give us some insights. And I would also say that's a wrap for the episode today. ⁓ thank you so much everyone for coming. And yeah, then see you see you in your climate week. speaker-3: See you in New York. speaker-2: Thanks guys. Bye bye. See you soon, bye bye.