Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / CCP §664 6 Changes Affecting Settlement of Real Estate Disputes, With Emphasis on Probate and Family
Transcript
- 0:03Greetings, everybody. My name is Howard Gould.
- 0:07I'm co -chair of the real estate section of the
- 0:09Beverly Hills Bar. I want to welcome everyone
- 0:11who's joining us today. Also, I would like to
- 0:14welcome anyone who's interested in assisting
- 0:17with the executive committee and maybe a position
- 0:20helping to run things not too far down the road
- 0:23to join the executive committee meetings, which
- 0:25are generally held once a month, usually a Tuesday
- 0:28or Thursday afternoon by Zoom about three o 'clock.
- 0:31We definitely like to get more people on the
- 0:34executive committee to help plan programs. The
- 0:38next thing I would like to do is to let you know
- 0:39about what our upcoming programs are from September
- 0:43basically through February. September 17th, we're
- 0:47going to do our review of the 2025 case law.
- 0:50That got a bit delayed this year, but we are
- 0:53planning to hold that on September 17th. And
- 0:55our speakers have been with us before, Anna Liu
- 0:58and Olivia Doppler from the Bay Area. On October
- 1:0223, we're going to do a program we've never done
- 1:05before, which is landlord insurance coverage
- 1:08for habitability claims in landlord tenant disputes.
- 1:12Our speaker, former president of the Beverly
- 1:14Hills Bar and insurance law specialist, Steve
- 1:17Roucher. We're putting on that program and he
- 1:20is also bringing with him insurance agent, somebody
- 1:24I've known a long time, Dan Fine. And that'll
- 1:27be a sort of a new topic and hopefully will be
- 1:30of interest to everybody. November 5 is an incredibly
- 1:35timely program about SB 79, the Transit Oriented
- 1:40Development Bill that allows large developments,
- 1:44much larger than before, sometimes adjacent to
- 1:46single -family neighborhoods, that related to
- 1:49transit development. And Sherrie Bonstel of Greenberg
- 1:52-Lusker is giving that program with a Trevor
- 1:55Damian is going to be talking about that and
- 2:00maybe some of the economics of those sorts of
- 2:03developments and what he does to track all the
- 2:08thousands of. lots that are now open for this
- 2:11sort of increased development. We don't usually
- 2:15do programming in December. I hold an executive
- 2:17committee holiday dinner, so we get to at least
- 2:20be in person once a year together. So if you're
- 2:23on the executive committee, it's something to
- 2:24look forward to. January 21st, we're doing a
- 2:28legal ethics program, since everybody's MCLE
- 2:32reporting is due soon after that. And we have
- 2:36a Jennifer Felton is coming back. She's for us
- 2:39before on escrows and topics relating to that.
- 2:43But this time she's doing an ethics program about
- 2:47advising on documenting and resolving real estate
- 2:50matters and what the ethics issues are. And she
- 2:54has a. list of some very timely topics that come
- 2:58up in those types of transactions for real estate
- 3:02lawyers. February 18th, we're going to do a program
- 3:05we also haven't done for a long time, if at all,
- 3:10which is real estate investments in conflict.
- 3:14And we're going to talk about partition actions
- 3:16and receiverships. And our speakers are Ori Blumenfield,
- 3:21an attorney, and Stephen Donnell. Stephen and
- 3:24I have known each other a long time. And Stephen
- 3:26acts as a receiver, and his office has handled
- 3:33those matters for a very long time. In terms
- 3:37of your questions today, Please use the Q &A.
- 3:40We don't use the chat here for the questions.
- 3:44And we'll try to follow those along and bring
- 3:48them up where appropriate in the presentation
- 3:51this time permitting. And your MCLE certificates
- 3:58will come very promptly from the Beverly Hills
- 4:00Bar after the presentation. They get those out
- 4:03very quickly. So you can look for that in your
- 4:05email, certainly within 24 hours after the presentation.
- 4:10It's my pleasure today to introduce two speakers,
- 4:15two lawyers that I actually worked with and that
- 4:17I know well and we're very lucky to have with
- 4:20us Scott Ron and Alphonse Provenziano for this
- 4:25program where we're going to talk about the changes
- 4:27in code of civil procedures section 664 .6 affecting
- 4:32settlement of all disputes really that are in
- 4:36the courts but in particular real estate disputes
- 4:39that we're interested in with an emphasis on
- 4:41probate and family law matters which have some
- 4:44special considerations under the statute for
- 4:47and just in terms of practice issues for settlements.
- 4:52Scott Rahn is the founding partner of RMOLLP,
- 4:56a probate litigation boutique based here in Los
- 4:59Angeles, where he focuses exclusively on trust
- 5:02and state and conservatorship disputes. With
- 5:05more than 20 years of experience, Scott has represented
- 5:08clients ranging from individual beneficiaries
- 5:11and fiduciaries to global financial institutions.
- 5:14Before founding RMO in 2015, he held key litigation
- 5:18roles at national firms where he developed a
- 5:21deep expertise in fiduciary litigation and related
- 5:25regulatory matters. Scott in particular is known
- 5:28for in -depth financial investigations in his
- 5:31matters and his successful handling of intra
- 5:34-family disputes where there are sometimes decades
- 5:36-long history of family friction. Among other
- 5:40positions, Scott is a former president of the
- 5:42Beverly Hills Estate Planning Council. He also
- 5:45speaks Spanish in case somebody needs a Spanish
- 5:49speaking estate and trust and conservatorship
- 5:53litigator. His law degree is from University
- 5:56of San Diego School of Law. Alphonse Provenziano.
- 6:01He's a prominent divorce and family law attorney
- 6:04and the founder of Provinziano and Associates
- 6:06in Beverly Hills. The firm is focused exclusively
- 6:09on family law and along with his international
- 6:14connections in order to handle those matters.
- 6:17Al keeps a multilingual staff who speak a number
- 6:20of different languages. He handles high stakes,
- 6:24high net worth matters, including complex divorces,
- 6:27international custody disputes. cross -border
- 6:30asset division and prenuptial and postnuptial
- 6:33agreements. Al is a certified family law specialist.
- 6:36He's handled more than 2 ,000 matters and over
- 6:39220 trials since 2004. And he is a fellow of
- 6:43the International Academy of Family Lawyers and
- 6:46serves as the president -elect of the Beverly
- 6:48Hills Bar Association, a position he'll take
- 6:52on next month. Al is also a former deputy district
- 6:55attorney. He attended UC Hastings College of
- 6:59Law. now known as UC Law San Francisco. Thank
- 7:01you both for joining us. And Scott, I think you're
- 7:05going to get us started here. I am. Thank you,
- 7:08Howard. Thank you for having us. Thank you, Al.
- 7:11Looking forward to presenting here with you today.
- 7:15I want to start with a fact pattern that will
- 7:17feel familiar to many of you. A family owns a
- 7:21Beverly Hills apartment building the surviving
- 7:23spouse has. lifetime occupancy rights. The adult
- 7:27children of the deceased spouse have the remainder
- 7:29interest. And after litigating, they agree on
- 7:32management reserves, distributions, future bio
- 7:36formula, and a sale after death or default. Everyone
- 7:40signs, the case is dismissed. And then eight
- 7:43years later, the spouse becomes incapacitated.
- 7:46A successor takes over to manage. The roof needs
- 7:49replacing. There's tons of deferred maintenance.
- 7:52Rents have fallen. uh as somebody have here in
- 7:55the city and one child demands that the property
- 7:58be sold and the question is no longer whether
- 8:01the family settled the case eight years ago they
- 8:04clearly did the question is whether the document
- 8:06and the court can supply answers today that will
- 8:11allow them to resolve their new dispute that
- 8:15is the practical import of the revised section
- 8:18six six four point six the statute preserves
- 8:21an enforcement forum but it cannot rescue a settlement
- 8:25that never answered the questions that the property
- 8:29would eventually come to ask, as in that hypothetical.
- 8:33So the program is really going to look at a couple
- 8:35different questions. Who has the authority to
- 8:39bind the settlement, the affected interests,
- 8:42what capacities, what precisely has to happen
- 8:46during the years of ownership? management, financing,
- 8:51occupancy, sale, et cetera, of that property,
- 8:55where and by what remedy are the parties going
- 8:58to be able to enforce those duties after dismissal?
- 9:01Because finality is not created by the word settlement,
- 9:05despite what many may think. Finality needs to
- 9:09be engineered in the agreements that are client
- 9:12signed, the approvals, the implementation documents,
- 9:16and the dismissal. So to see why we need to separate
- 9:22the settlement from the statute, because 664
- 9:25is not an agreement. It's not a contract. It's
- 9:29simply the summary enforcement vehicle that the
- 9:32legislature has given us. So 664, if we can go
- 9:37to the next slide. There we go. Thank you. So
- 9:49664 replaced slower enforcement routes with essentially
- 9:54what is a summary procedure. If the parties have
- 9:58a qualifying settlement, the court can determine
- 10:01whether an enforceable agreement exists, it can
- 10:04interpret the terms of that agreement, and it
- 10:07can enter judgment consistent with the terms
- 10:10of that settlement agreement. But while the court
- 10:13can interpret the agreement, it cannot create
- 10:16material terms that the parties never agreed
- 10:19upon. That boundary is critical in the real estate
- 10:23transactions and settlements that we're talking
- 10:25about here today because valuation, financing,
- 10:30taxes, title, possession, management, maintenance,
- 10:35default mechanics are often material. They're
- 10:38not simply implementation details. So a quick
- 10:42rundown through the timeline of 664 .6 came around
- 10:46in 1981 to give us a summary enforcement mechanism
- 10:49for qualifying written or oral in court settlements
- 10:55that were put on the record. In 1993, the statute
- 10:59was amended. to expressly retain jurisdiction
- 11:03until there was full performance if it was properly
- 11:07requested by a party. Fast forward to about 10
- 11:11years, I'm sorry, about 20 years to the 2021
- 11:15era where attorneys can generally sign for clients
- 11:18as long as they have express authority, but not
- 11:21in probate cases, which we handle, or family
- 11:24law cases, which Alan has firm handle. Fast forward
- 11:28to January 1, 2025, AB 1756 is adopted, and the
- 11:34new 664 adds dismissal without prejudice and
- 11:38post dismissal procedures really designed to
- 11:42help the court clear calendars while preserving
- 11:45enforcement access. And what we end up looking
- 11:50at here is really two different consents, right?
- 11:53You have the assent. to the settlement agreement
- 11:56itself and in a probate action as with a family
- 11:59court action, the council signature is insufficient.
- 12:04It does not substitute for a party signature.
- 12:07You have to have the signature of the client
- 12:09or you have to have an oral affirmation of that
- 12:13settlement on the record. And then you have the
- 12:17procedural stipulation to the retention of jurisdiction
- 12:20post -dismissal. And that's under 664 .6, which
- 12:24the attorney can consent to. The party can as
- 12:28well. But the lawyer themselves has the authority
- 12:31to do that. And you can't. collapse these 2 signatures,
- 12:36certainly not in probate and family law matters.
- 12:39Council may be able again to sign off on the
- 12:41jurisdictional enforcement issue, but they can't
- 12:44consent to a probate or family law settlement
- 12:47itself. And some authorities that you might want
- 12:50to take a look at regarding these issues, Weddington
- 12:54Productions versus Flick. from 1998 and Lehman
- 12:58versus Adams Extract and Spice from 2015, which
- 13:03both stand for the proposition that the court
- 13:05can interpret the terms of an agreement, but
- 13:08cannot create new terms, at least new material
- 13:12terms. And then conservatorship of McElroy, which
- 13:16stands for the proposition that even apparent
- 13:18conduct, such as a head nod, is insufficient
- 13:22to satisfy the assent obligation. Again, they're
- 13:27either signing or they're making an oral affirmation
- 13:30on the record. And then finally, CHU versus CHU,
- 13:34which many of you may have heard of, a probate
- 13:36settlement can combine oral and written assent.
- 13:39It's fine as long as it's one or the other. But
- 13:42other issues need to be considered, like minors'
- 13:44interests and their consent. And the court approval
- 13:48process has its own notification requirements.
- 13:53Next slide. So importantly, the amendment 1756,
- 14:04the amendment 2664 .6 does not change this basic
- 14:07architecture. What it does change is where the
- 14:11case sits and how parties get back before the
- 14:16court while performance is incomplete. So starting
- 14:20with the legislative intent, 1756 was presented
- 14:25simply as a technical and non -controversial
- 14:28docket management revision. Its expressly stated
- 14:33goal simply was to let courts clear conditionally
- 14:37settled cases from their dockets, from their
- 14:40calendars, without making parties file new actions
- 14:43if performance later faltered. Probate and family
- 14:48law consequences frankly receive little legislative
- 14:51attention. It just wasn't really something that
- 14:54they paid attention to. But what looks like docket
- 14:58housekeeping in a simple cash settlement circumstance
- 15:03can become something else entirely when settlements
- 15:07affect real property interests and in our cases
- 15:11fiduciary conduct over a number of years. So
- 15:16operationally. the statute changed in a number
- 15:19of ways and that the court may dismiss as to
- 15:23settling parties without prejudice and retain
- 15:26jurisdiction until full performance, as long
- 15:30as the parties or their counsel stipulate. After
- 15:33a notice of conditional settlement under Rule
- 15:361385, the court can issue an OSC and even without
- 15:40a stipulation, dismiss the entire action without
- 15:43prejudice while retaining enforcement jurisdiction.
- 15:48After judgment or qualifying dismissal, the parties
- 15:52can file settlement related motions, including
- 15:56liens, good faith settlement, minor or disability
- 16:00compromise, and of course, non performance or
- 16:04failure to perform filings. And if a party gives
- 16:07notice that a written settlement required signatures
- 16:10from all parties, but not all parties signed,
- 16:14then the court has to retain, shall exercise,
- 16:18retain jurisdiction. Importantly, in terms of
- 16:22filing fees, which are very important to the
- 16:24courts, the clerk must accept qualified filings.
- 16:29And if you've already paid your first appearance
- 16:31fee on the action already, you don't have to
- 16:34pay a first appearance fee again, which can cause
- 16:37some confusion. Also, a later dismissal with
- 16:41prejudice is permitted under the statute, but
- 16:44the statute is silent on what happens with the
- 16:48remainder of 664 .6 subsection F, if there is
- 16:53a dismissal with prejudice. So, stay tuned. And
- 16:58there, importantly, in that context, there are
- 17:01some I guess some gaps that we want to raise.
- 17:07One is the missing signature paradox. Retained
- 17:12jurisdiction is mandatory upon notice, but the
- 17:15court may still have no enforceable settlement
- 17:19to enforce if you're missing signatures. There's
- 17:23no case law on this yet. The revised statute
- 17:26is new as of the beginning of last year, so we're
- 17:30all. standing by waiting to see what happens
- 17:32with this. You have issues related to the entire
- 17:35action versus a partial settlement dismissal.
- 17:39So Subdivision A of 664 .6 speaks in terms of
- 17:43the settling parties, but Subdivision E authorizes
- 17:47the court to set an OSC concerning dismissal
- 17:50of the entire action. So if you're involved in
- 17:53a multi -petition, as we often are, or multi
- 17:56-party case, Those actions require surgical notices
- 18:02and surgical orders to make sure that you're
- 18:05addressing each of the specific circumstances,
- 18:08each of the specific pleadings, actions, and
- 18:12parties. Dismissal with prejudice is another
- 18:15issue. Subdivision D allows it, as I mentioned,
- 18:19but the survival of every subsection F procedure
- 18:23is not addressed. So, I would just say treat
- 18:27what we discussed today as a conservative, but
- 18:30not yet settled practice because we don't have
- 18:33guidance on it yet from the judiciary. Rule 3
- 18:37.1385, conditional settlement notice remains
- 18:42an important consideration because a conditional
- 18:44settlement can follow that rule's alternative
- 18:48process without necessarily seeking a 664 .6
- 18:52dismissal. And 664 .6 may not always be needed,
- 18:57facts and circumstances. And importantly, deadlines
- 19:00survive settlement. So a case by the name of
- 19:04Hot Living, I don't know if I'm pronouncing that
- 19:06correctly versus GM, it's from this year, stands
- 19:09for the proposition that any dismissal will trigger
- 19:13the 180 day attorney fee motion deadline, even
- 19:18if counsel behaves as though because the court
- 19:22retained jurisdiction under 664 .6, there's unfinished
- 19:26issues and the matter is still alive and it's
- 19:28not dismissed yet. So pay attention to those
- 19:31things. And Al, family law gives us a different
- 19:36procedural home, the judgment, but the same real
- 19:40-world problem where property obligations can
- 19:44outlive the date of that settlement agreement.
- 19:48Talk to us about this. Yeah, absolutely. And
- 19:51I think in terms of a family law case, it's always
- 19:56going to be a little different than a lot of
- 19:58other civil cases and probate cases. Family law
- 20:03use of 664 .6 differs greatly from general probate
- 20:09and civil practice. And that is essentially that
- 20:15a dissolution proceeding is always going to conclude
- 20:18in a judgment, not a dismissal. So, you know,
- 20:24AB 1756's new dismissal retain jurisdiction procedure
- 20:28in subdivision E is written in cases that end
- 20:32in a dismissal. But I think there's actually
- 20:35the ability to have a direct application in family
- 20:40law, but it might be in some ways in which people
- 20:43are not really thinking about because you're
- 20:46never really going to dismiss a case unless the
- 20:49parties get back together or the parties are
- 20:55desiring to just not go forward with a divorce
- 21:00case at this time or move to a different forum.
- 21:02But what we often see in terms of the practical
- 21:05opportunity, I think, in a family law case is
- 21:08that we have a marital settlement agreement.
- 21:11And marital settlement agreements are often going
- 21:13to be kept confidential. So you can do a judgment
- 21:17in a case. And the judgment itself doesn't necessarily
- 21:24get, is not a dismissal at its end to a case,
- 21:28but it references a confidential settlement agreement
- 21:30that's merged into the judgment, but isn't completely
- 21:36filed in the court file. And that's something
- 21:39that a judgment would retain language on in itself.
- 21:43Typically, most family law judgments are going
- 21:46to retain language that the court is going to
- 21:49have the ability to enforce the settlement agreement
- 21:53based on non -performance. But now, what you
- 21:56have in 664 .6 subdivisions F is an ability to
- 22:04bring that confidential settlement agreement
- 22:07into the light. So where you thought you had
- 22:11confidentiality, in a judgment of dissolution,
- 22:15you may in fact be exposing yourself to an enforcement
- 22:18proceeding where that confidential judgment comes
- 22:21out. The other interesting thing that kind of
- 22:25tied in with probate is something that I think
- 22:28people haven't really thought about. We have
- 22:32domestic violence restraining order actions in
- 22:35family law. And you're dealing with probate which
- 22:40is going to be family members, domestic violence
- 22:43restraining orders could be triggered in these
- 22:45situations. And in many domestic violence restraining
- 22:48order cases, you have things like control of
- 22:51the house and exclusive control of a piece of
- 22:54property. So you can imagine in the hypothetical
- 22:58with the Beverly Hills rental agreement, if there
- 23:01was some combat between the parties, for example,
- 23:05some threats or harassment that you see in a
- 23:08probate case that spills over into a domestic
- 23:10violence case. Well, under 664 .6, it's an interesting
- 23:16thing because that's one area in family court
- 23:20where you might want a dismissal as part of a
- 23:23settlement. And you might want to have triggering
- 23:26events that allow you to then bring this back
- 23:30into court. So this is actually a benefit to
- 23:34all those people trying to settle domestic violence
- 23:37restraining order cases that deal with property
- 23:39control terms or just general terms itself. You
- 23:42could have a settlement agreement. dismiss it,
- 23:46give a notice that the case is settled, and allow
- 23:50the court to retain jurisdiction. And those settlement
- 23:52provisions could be, for example, stay away from
- 23:55this piece of real property, stay away from these
- 24:00parties. And why the benefit of that is nobody
- 24:04wants to have a Kletz record. They don't want
- 24:07a California law enforcement tracking system
- 24:09record that shows that they were found as a domestic
- 24:11violence perpetrator. That will take your jobs.
- 24:14It will be a black mark on you as you go forward
- 24:18in the future. So an interesting thing about
- 24:21the law that I don't think anyone's thought of
- 24:23in family law at this point in time, but is really
- 24:26something to consider is how you can do that.
- 24:30Because under the family code, there's a strong
- 24:32provision that prevents you from having what
- 24:37we call as a non -clet's order. And that's family
- 24:40code section 6380 at SEC. So basically it's abolished
- 24:45that you could, we used to in the olden days
- 24:47have a settlement agreement. It says, look, the
- 24:48parties agree as a non -clet's order that you
- 24:51would stay away from each other. And you can't
- 24:53do that. But this, the new provision of 6 .64
- 24:56.6, I believe allows legal authorization to dismiss
- 25:00it, note a settlement agreement. And then later
- 25:03on, you come into issues of enforcement. And
- 25:06that ties in directly with control over pieces
- 25:08of property. But back to you, Scott. Yeah, can
- 25:12we move to the next slide, please? Yeah, and
- 25:16I just want to say that probate adds another
- 25:20structural complication, where you often have
- 25:26the people in the caption are not always representative
- 25:30of the full universe of interests that the court
- 25:33is there to protect. And another wrinkle is that
- 25:37the person who's signing the agreement may be
- 25:40acting in more than one capacity, perhaps as
- 25:44a fiduciary and a beneficiary, for example. So
- 25:48you have representative capacities, you have
- 25:51a trustee, you have an executor, administrator,
- 25:53guardian, conservator, conservatee, Agent, beneficiaries,
- 25:58heirs, you know, they all have different and
- 26:01sometimes conflicting authorities, duties, obligations,
- 26:05rights. You have interests that go well beyond
- 26:08the caption. You have minors, right? You have
- 26:10unborn or unassertained beneficiaries. You have
- 26:14contingent beneficiaries, creditors, charities,
- 26:18and non -participating trust beneficiaries, all
- 26:21of whom might have an interest that could be
- 26:23affected. You have court supervised acts. You
- 26:26have settlement authority that does not necessarily
- 26:29supply authority to modify a trust, but that's
- 26:35what you're effectively doing or distributed
- 26:36in the state, or the ability to compromise the
- 26:40interest of a minor, approve an accounting or
- 26:43authorize a fiduciary's dealings, perhaps a self
- 26:47-interested transaction was one example. You
- 26:51often have multiple proceedings under one case
- 26:54number, and so a global settlement may touch
- 26:58upon an 850 petition, an accounting, a removal
- 27:02or a surcharge, elder abuse claims, and potentially
- 27:07a civil action. Without ever pleading or without
- 27:13ever without every party being settled in exactly
- 27:17the same way, because everybody's just kind of
- 27:19put into the same. Case and probate also succession
- 27:24is expected, right? A signatory may die. They
- 27:26may lose capacity. They can be resigned. They
- 27:30could resign. They could be removed suspended.
- 27:33or replaced for some other reason before any
- 27:36of the real property issues at hand really come
- 27:41to light. And real property, unlike many of the
- 27:46people in the cases we deal with, it has an indefinite
- 27:50operating life, right? You've got rents, you've
- 27:53got debt that needs to be serviced, insurance
- 27:55and taxes that need to be paid. repairs and maintenance,
- 27:59tenants you're dealing with, perhaps easements,
- 28:01environmental conditions, title defects can arise,
- 28:05and all of those things can potentially continue
- 28:08or will continue after the litigation is supposedly
- 28:13over. So it's really important in looking at
- 28:17your settlement and these proceedings and what
- 28:20the enforcement of that settlement is going to
- 28:22look like to identify every capacity That's an
- 28:27issue and expressly a person who is wearing more
- 28:32than 1 hat who's both an individual beneficiary
- 28:35and a fiduciary. You might need to sign twice
- 28:38an entity will need to sign through an identified
- 28:42authorized representative, a personal representative,
- 28:45which is often confusing for people in our space,
- 28:49whether they're the trustee or the executive
- 28:51or the administrator. depending on how you were
- 28:55put in, you may sign only after your appointment
- 28:58and only if you're given that authority. And
- 29:02if there's individual liability, then releases,
- 29:04indemnity, or guarantees intended, you know,
- 29:08you can't assume that the fiduciary signing that
- 29:12is going to accomplish what you set out to do.
- 29:14So, specifically in probate, and there's obviously
- 29:18crossover issues with family law, with civil
- 29:21actions. And probate the question of who signed
- 29:24is really incomplete. The real question is. Who
- 29:28is being asked to sign in what capacity with
- 29:32what authority, which interests are they going
- 29:35to bind and what approval is that going to be.
- 29:40Subject to the case of chew that I mentioned
- 29:43earlier. Is a good example of these issues that
- 29:48involve multiple trust petitions, substantial
- 29:50real property, entity interests. An oral agree
- 29:54settlement agreement placed on the record minor
- 29:57beneficiaries, a guardian ad litem. Later written
- 30:01agreements and ultimately court approval. And
- 30:04as a case went up on appeal, the appellate court
- 30:07recognized that there was a mix and match mixing
- 30:11and matching of oral and written a sense. Right
- 30:15which is okay as long as all the parties agreed
- 30:18to the same agreement. But you had issues there
- 30:22involving the miners interests and the approval
- 30:25process that needed to be addressed as well and
- 30:28weren't necessarily addressed. The way that the
- 30:31appellate court thought they needed to be so
- 30:33true really stands for the proposition that enforceability
- 30:36of a settlement agreement and approval. of the
- 30:40represented interests are separate inquiries
- 30:42and you gotta make sure that you've got both
- 30:45and you're going through that analysis as you're
- 30:48looking to resolve a case before you ever even
- 30:50get to the enforcement issues. And CHU also really
- 30:56stands for the proposition that broad future
- 30:58language and I know this. This is something that
- 31:02we've seen in agreements over the years. We're
- 31:05going to work the collaboration clause. We're
- 31:07going to work together. And there's going to
- 31:08be fair and equitable tax treatment. Or we're
- 31:12going to put this into a long form that never
- 31:15comes about. Those things really only invite
- 31:19implementation disputes as to what's fair. I
- 31:23think fair and reasonable are a litigator's best
- 31:27friend because we can all disagree on what's
- 31:30reasonable and what's not. Finally, I think CHU
- 31:33stands for the proposition that it shows how
- 31:38real property allocations, sales, taxes, accountings,
- 31:43releases, and future beneficiary rights cannot
- 31:47be treated as boilerplate. These things really
- 31:50need to be couture specifically designed for
- 31:54the facts and circumstances. that are at issue
- 31:58for you in your specific case. So going back
- 32:03to the Beverly Hills apartment building. So assume
- 32:06that the settlement gives the surviving spouse
- 32:09income for life, access to the property for life.
- 32:14gives puts management in the hands of a corporate
- 32:17management company, trustee requires quarterly
- 32:21distributions, permits capital reserves, gives
- 32:23the children a buyout right upon her capacity,
- 32:26requires stay on death, etc. So what happens
- 32:29if that successor trustee and the children disagree
- 32:32over the appraisal date, how they're going to
- 32:35pay for deferred maintenance, debt payoff, tenant
- 32:38improvements, capital gains, allocations, what
- 32:43How do you determine in capacity or whether a
- 32:48proposed buyer that perhaps the children are
- 32:51bringing and maybe they disagree amongst themselves
- 32:52qualified. What section what section six six
- 32:56four point six can do is bring everyone back
- 32:58to the court. But if these questions are left
- 33:02open and not covered by the settlement agreement.
- 33:06you're not going to have anything to enforce.
- 33:10And I think that's one of the important takeaways
- 33:12here is that 664 .6 is not going to rescue you
- 33:15from a bad settlement agreement. Scott? Yeah,
- 33:19go ahead. Earlier you mentioned that 664 .6 would
- 33:24basically mean you don't have to file a new action.
- 33:27Correct. In the circumstance you're describing
- 33:29now, would that be the alternative that would
- 33:31be pursued is to file a new action? Does that
- 33:34give the court then broader authority? If you're
- 33:38going to file a new action instead of seek enforcement?
- 33:43Yes. I think you're going to, yeah, I mean, if
- 33:46you have an agreement that has holes in it, you
- 33:50don't have anything to enforce. So seeking enforcement
- 33:52of an agreement that doesn't address the issues
- 33:55that you're seeking to have the court enforce,
- 33:58you're going to have to initiate a new action.
- 34:00because the court, again, cannot create material
- 34:04terms to save you from a bad agreement. So yes,
- 34:07is the short answer. And so that materially differs
- 34:10from family law, because you're always going
- 34:13to have clearly identified parties. You're going
- 34:15to have the husband and the wife, or the spouses,
- 34:19husband and husband, wife and wife, or parents.
- 34:22And so even if you had a confidential MSA, you're
- 34:25going to clearly know who the parties were and
- 34:27are going to have signed. The one caveat or exception
- 34:30to that rare occasions will have a guardian ad
- 34:32litem appointed to a party that's incapacitated
- 34:37for some reason that would need to be a signatory.
- 34:40And then we get third party claimants. And this
- 34:42is most frequently seen in terms of parents that
- 34:47might own or have an interest in real property.
- 34:50So that is an opportunity where if you're drafting
- 34:53a settlement agreement disposing of a piece of
- 34:55real property and you want to settle that part
- 34:58of the case with the parents, and you want to
- 35:01do it with a settlement agreement and a notice
- 35:04of dismissal, the same things that Scott is talking
- 35:09about would come up in a family law case. Yeah.
- 35:15Yeah, and I think the cost of dormancy while
- 35:18the case is believed to be settled, but the implementation
- 35:23of that settlement is pending or ongoing. It
- 35:26is important. We've highlighted here in the slide,
- 35:29but the actions dismissed without prejudice and
- 35:33the court retains jurisdiction, at least limited
- 35:36enforcement jurisdiction. But for us, the administration
- 35:41may be ongoing. For us, the fiduciaries would
- 35:44need to maintain their bonds, reserves, pay for
- 35:48insurance, do accountings. They have tax filings
- 35:51to do. you know, while perhaps some of these
- 35:55other obligations remain unperformed. And I think
- 35:58if you're not considering those issues in our
- 36:00cases, right, you're doing a disservice to the
- 36:03client because they're going to come back and
- 36:04say, hey, look, like we solved, you know, the
- 36:08real estate issue, right? Stepmom's going to
- 36:11stay in the house, you know, until she dies.
- 36:13But who's going to pay for, you know, all of
- 36:16the carry costs? And, you know, who's going to
- 36:20pay for the fiduciary, right? Who's going to
- 36:21pay for all of their fees, their costs, the accountant,
- 36:25the lawyers, all of those things. And I think
- 36:29it's important to look at the fact that you've
- 36:33got three very different scenarios here. You've
- 36:35got probate, you've got family law. Al's highlighted
- 36:37some of the distinctions that exist in family
- 36:40law. And then you've just got the civil court
- 36:43proceedings. And you've got one statute that's
- 36:46trying to speak to three very different Scenarios
- 36:51and I wanted to run through just some some quick
- 36:54hypotheticals and one. I think that probably
- 36:56pertains more to your practice. Al, but certainly
- 37:01can apply to to ours as well. You have the deferred
- 37:05sale, right? You have a spouse and a minor child
- 37:08who are going to remain in the residence until
- 37:10that minor graduates. The other spouse remains
- 37:13on the loan has that obligation remains on title
- 37:17and a buyout or sale is going to come. come later.
- 37:21How does that get addressed in your space out?
- 37:24Yeah, Family Code sections 3800 to 3810 define
- 37:30a deferred sale of the home. And it's often known
- 37:33as a Duke order, although that's a really old
- 37:35case in Ray Marriage of Duke, which is a 1980
- 37:41case, 101 Cal App 3rd 152. And the Family Code
- 37:47just codifies that. It says, look, if there's
- 37:49an adverse impact on minor children of an immediate
- 37:52sale of the house, and it's not outweighed by
- 37:55the economic detriment to the non -custodial
- 37:58party, the court shall upon request reserve jurisdiction
- 38:01and defer sale on appropriate conditions. And
- 38:05it gives the court broad discretion. What are
- 38:07those appropriate conditions? Most of the time
- 38:09in practice, it's going to be very hard to get
- 38:12the court to order a due quarter. So where do
- 38:14you see these? You're going to see it in a settlement
- 38:16agreement. You're going to see it in a stipulation.
- 38:19And so in family court, you're The gold standard
- 38:24is always to have retention language under 664
- 38:27.6, language for sale triggers, valuation dates,
- 38:32buyout offsets, all the stuff that. Scott's talking
- 38:36about, you're going to have to work into your
- 38:40judgment or your MSA. That would then be enforceable
- 38:43under 664 .6. And usually, the triggering effect
- 38:48is always going to be once the children turn
- 38:5018. It can be, and I've seen deferred sale orders.
- 38:54uh it by agreement in other contexts uh similar
- 38:58to uh what scott was talking about maybe you're
- 39:00going to give someone a life estate or you're
- 39:03going to give someone an asset but defer when
- 39:06that's going to be sold so having those things
- 39:09resolved up front uh is what it's going to going
- 39:13to be and i know in my experience seeing uh cases
- 39:15being forced on the back end the court will a
- 39:17lot of times say look i don't have the ability
- 39:19to change this agreement much like scott has
- 39:21mentioned they're going to say the agreement
- 39:23is what the agreement is. It's not modifiable.
- 39:26It's either a settlement agreement or a judgment.
- 39:30And think about that when you're drafting your
- 39:32settlement agreements. Who do you want to have
- 39:34interpret those terms of the settlement agreement?
- 39:37Is it going to be the judge? Is it going to be
- 39:38an arbitrator? And how is it going to be resolved?
- 39:42Do you ever consider putting in a term that allows
- 39:46the court discretion to modify these things based
- 39:49upon changed circumstances, which make enforcement
- 39:54as drafted unreasonable or unclear? Well, in
- 39:59terms of family law, I think most of the time,
- 40:02most parties are always going to want and just
- 40:05desperately want some certainty in their affairs.
- 40:10So I, in my experience, haven't seen that. There's
- 40:13nothing that stops that from being drafted. But
- 40:15then it basically means that the litigation is
- 40:17going to be ongoing. Because now you're going
- 40:20to have people come back and have a change of
- 40:22circumstances and say, I can't do this anymore.
- 40:25But the practical reality is it does happen.
- 40:27If someone loses a job and can't pay for it anymore,
- 40:30even if they're ordered to do it, they may have
- 40:33an impossibility to perform. In which case, then
- 40:36you would have to sell the house. There was a
- 40:40question, if parties to the dissolution matter
- 40:42have real property and a family member on title,
- 40:45other than the MSA, is there some other document
- 40:49or dismissal required on the civil side? I'm
- 40:54not sure exactly, procedurally, how that comes
- 40:56up. Well, here's what the family code requires
- 40:59for that, is that if you know of someone else
- 41:03who owns an interest in a property, you have
- 41:06to join that person to your case so that the
- 41:09court has authority over the party. So if there's
- 41:13a house that multiple people own, you can't divide
- 41:16the interest in that house and have a resolution.
- 41:21Rarely do we see quiet title actions come up
- 41:23in family law. That would be another vehicle.
- 41:25But usually, it's parents or some relative that
- 41:30owns the house, co -owns it. You're going to
- 41:32want to join them to the case and then resolve
- 41:34all interests. And that would be a motion for
- 41:37Joinder to do that. I did put on a program about
- 41:41a year or maybe longer ago about how the family
- 41:45law judges have extraordinary power sometimes
- 41:48over third parties who are joined in regarding
- 41:50their real property interests. And it was quite
- 41:52surprising how much authority the family law
- 41:55judge can exercise over that third party if they're
- 41:59brought into the divorce regarding their interest
- 42:01in the property. Yeah, the court has that broad
- 42:04discretion to bring in a third party or to, for
- 42:07example, bring in a joint pension plan to make
- 42:09orders to divide up a pension. And that's where
- 42:13you have to be, as Scott has mentioned, very
- 42:17clear in your triggers, your evaluations, if
- 42:21you're going to keep holding onto an asset after
- 42:24the case is over. Yeah, I think one of the other
- 42:29tools that we see somewhat frequently, Howard,
- 42:31just to talk about the change circumstances issue
- 42:34is an alternative dispute resolution return clause
- 42:38in the settlement agreement to bring, at least
- 42:41bring people back to the table, right? And force
- 42:43them back into, preferably with the neutral who
- 42:47helped resolve the case, right? Because they're
- 42:49going to have the background. It'll be more efficient,
- 42:50more cost effective, and perhaps will get you
- 42:53a Well, I don't know if it'll be a better result,
- 42:56but certainly a more cost effective and efficient
- 42:59resolution than you might otherwise have if you're
- 43:02going to have to initiate proceedings. So, it's
- 43:05a tool that we use frequently in our agreements
- 43:08and it's something that's commonly done in our
- 43:10space. I'm not sure if that's similar in your
- 43:12space though. Yeah, you pretty much if you're
- 43:15going to draft an MSA, you want to have somebody
- 43:19who's going to interpret the provisions of the
- 43:21agreement that are left vacant. So you want to
- 43:24appoint someone as the many times what we'll
- 43:26see in family law cases is that you'll appoint
- 43:29a arbitrator to decide all of the boilerplate
- 43:34or vague. things and you can basically have that
- 43:37arbitrator make those decisions and then it's
- 43:39a final decision that's not appealable. Now you
- 43:42have to, what's your comfort level with that
- 43:44arbitrator who's going to do it? But then you
- 43:48have finality right now because the biggest problem
- 43:51much like I think in your space Scott is that
- 43:53you have these latent actions you thought it
- 43:56was resolved but now you know look, we have a
- 43:59deferred sale of the house when the child's eight,
- 44:0110 years later we're coming, and now the child's
- 44:0418. Well, who's claiming? Uncle owns part of
- 44:07the house and says, well, I want reimbursement
- 44:09for the use. And you didn't have all these things
- 44:12tied up. So it's all in the drafting. And the
- 44:14one thing in family court is you do get the broad
- 44:17discretion because it's a court of equity. And
- 44:21it sounds like that you've seen that as well
- 44:22in your practice, Scott. We have a probate courts.
- 44:26It's an equity as well But as we're often reminded
- 44:28by the judges that the the equity is guided by
- 44:32the rules which is a relief to one of my former
- 44:35partners and mentors who used to carry around
- 44:38his probate code and You know throw it on his
- 44:41desk if if I told them that there was something
- 44:43that could potentially be inconsistent with one
- 44:45of the code sections Because of the equity issues
- 44:49go ahead Howard. Sorry given the timelines you're
- 44:51talking about you're gonna I've obviously included
- 44:54some alternative way to appoint a new arbitrator.
- 44:57If it was 10 years later, that arbitrator may
- 44:59not be available. That is always an issue as
- 45:04well. Go ahead. Yeah, I mean, it's rare to see
- 45:07these in family court. Usually, people want finality.
- 45:10Your vast majority of your cases are going to
- 45:13be the house is sold or it's awarded and there's
- 45:15a buyout. And then you have these lingering issues.
- 45:19But if you do have these, that's kind of the
- 45:20warning zone for family law attorneys, especially
- 45:23when you're dealing with real property. Don't
- 45:25think of this as an immediate judgment in your
- 45:27MSA. Make sure that it's enforceable long term.
- 45:30And think about what happens. Like Howard said,
- 45:32is the arbitrator going to go away? Who's going
- 45:35to? pick it up. Are you going to appoint a judge
- 45:38of the Superior Court by assignment as the arbitrator,
- 45:41for example? That could be a solution. So it
- 45:44is complex when you're dealing with these sort
- 45:46of multi -generational long -term disputes. Usually,
- 45:50if we see a case that comes through our firm
- 45:52and they say they come in and they say, OK, it's
- 45:54been going on for nine years and I've had seven
- 45:56attorneys, we start really saying, this may not
- 46:00be the case for us, but not every case is like
- 46:02that in family law. Sometimes there might be
- 46:04some real issue there that nobody was able to
- 46:06crack, but you've got to really get to the bottom
- 46:09of it. I had a case once where the husband provides
- 46:12a reported case, which is in Ray marriage of
- 46:14Serato, where the husband actually gave all of
- 46:17the assets to his best friend. And we had to
- 46:23join the best friend for the purpose of rescission.
- 46:27And so you can see how those things might play
- 46:29out in a family law context. Yeah, I mean, I
- 46:34think whatever the context is your practice area
- 46:37of mind civil, right? If you're looking at a
- 46:41case that involves a long term property settlement.
- 46:45You need to be very careful about how you draft,
- 46:48right? Making sure that you're preparing an agreement
- 46:51that covers not only the contractual terms. But
- 46:54how that's going to operate and and really be
- 46:57looking at what future enforcement. Might look
- 47:01like in terms of those specific provisions and
- 47:04what other alternatives you have, ADR, et cetera,
- 47:07what it's going to look like when you're going
- 47:09to come back and ask the court to do X, Y, or
- 47:12Z, X, Y, or Z better be in that agreement. Otherwise,
- 47:15you're likely to have difficulties. I think one
- 47:21of the things to just looking at, you know, formation
- 47:24and authority on that agreement, you know, We
- 47:28haven't seen, I won't say we've seen it frequently,
- 47:30but the number of times is more than I can count
- 47:32on one hand. We have a short form agreement that
- 47:35doesn't say whether it's binding or non binding.
- 47:38Right? And you've got 1 party that wants to enforce
- 47:41it and 1 party who says. You know, this was just
- 47:43a term sheet. You know, we were supposed to memorialize
- 47:46it and don't confuse the 2 and don't use both
- 47:51concepts. Certainly not in your agreement. I
- 47:54think again, getting back to. in our cases specifically,
- 47:58who are all the signatories? What are their capacities,
- 48:00et cetera? Define what you're settling for our
- 48:05cases by petition. And the recitals can be very
- 48:10long in these agreements as a result, but what
- 48:13are all the petitions that are contained in the
- 48:15action? What were all the claims? Who are the
- 48:18parties? What were their capacities? What are
- 48:20all the case numbers? You can have a conservatorship
- 48:22proceeding. You can have a trust proceeding and
- 48:24a state proceeding, et cetera. So there can be
- 48:27any number of things. And if approval is a condition,
- 48:32which it is frequently in probate cases, who's
- 48:36going to seek it? By when are they going to seek
- 48:39it? What happens if approval is not granted?
- 48:44Does the rest of the agreement, is it severable?
- 48:47Does it remain enforceable? Those things all
- 48:49need to be thought through. It's rare that a
- 48:52court isn't going to jump to to settle a case,
- 48:55but it does happen, particularly if you haven't
- 48:57considered whose interest might be impacted.
- 49:01I think when you get to the specifics as to the
- 49:04real property issues, I mean, use the legal description,
- 49:09use the APN, right? Who's the record title owner,
- 49:13et cetera, right? The house, right? So it gets
- 49:17the house or the building or this property at
- 49:21this street address and the street address is
- 49:22wrong. Fix the valuation method. How is it going
- 49:26to happen? What is the valuation date? Which
- 49:29is something that happens in our cases all the
- 49:30time. I'm sure in yours as well, Al. Do you use
- 49:33the date of marriage, the date of separation,
- 49:35the date of the judgment? How is an appraiser
- 49:39going to get picked, right? And the legal standard
- 49:42by default is always the fair market value at
- 49:45the time of sale and family loss. So if you want
- 49:47to use a different time, because you want to
- 49:50compensate for deferred sale and increase in
- 49:52value, you'd have to specify that clearly in
- 49:56a judgment or a settlement agreement. We have
- 49:59about 10 minutes to go. OK. I just want to talk
- 50:05quickly about enforcement and exit, right? You're
- 50:08really, you know, you're building a ladder in
- 50:11these agreements, right? Like, notice, you know,
- 50:16giving notice of failure to comply, a cure period,
- 50:21right? Is there some sort of accounting or expert
- 50:24determination, valuation, et cetera, that needs
- 50:26to happen? Again, ADR. is a viable option in
- 50:30these agreements, right? Are you going to return
- 50:32to mediation? Are you going to go to arbitration,
- 50:36right? Or ultimately, are you going to go back
- 50:38to court on a 664 .6 if necessary, right? And
- 50:42I think you need to specifically make sure you're
- 50:44covering interest fees. What specific performance
- 50:48looks like? If somebody has to sell the property,
- 50:51you have to specifically spell that out, what
- 50:54that looks like. If there's a stipulated judgment,
- 50:58how does it work mechanically? Is there a credit
- 51:01for partial performance? If you've given half
- 51:06a loaf, how does that work? What kind of credit
- 51:08do you get? I think that it's moving to dismissal
- 51:15with prejudice before documenting full performance
- 51:20is a huge risk here. And I think that it's a
- 51:25mistake I think that far too many people make
- 51:27is they're just happy to have the case done,
- 51:29the client's happy to have the case done, and
- 51:31they're perhaps not thinking about what the implications
- 51:34are after dismissal. Just some quick takeaways
- 51:45here as we approach the end, the amended code
- 51:51section simply preserves court access, right?
- 51:56Again, it does not make a wholly, W -H, not H
- 52:01-O -L -Y, settlement agreement a complete agreement.
- 52:05They're not going to save a bad agreement from
- 52:07itself. You need to separate formation, authority,
- 52:13approval, jurisdiction and performance. A settlement
- 52:17can succeed at one stage and completely fall
- 52:21apart at another. And you need to be thinking
- 52:23through each of those stages as you go through
- 52:25constructing that agreement and how it's going
- 52:28to function, both in terms of a settlement, but
- 52:31enforcing that settlement. In the probate code
- 52:35cases that we handle in the family code cases
- 52:37that Al handles, you need to obtain the party's
- 52:41consent to the agreement itself, right? Don't
- 52:44confuse that with our ability as lawyers, as
- 52:48officers of the court, to stipulate to 664 .6.
- 52:53Draft your terms, right? And when it pertains
- 52:57to real estate specifically, draft your terms
- 52:59as though it's closing instructions, right? An
- 53:03operating agreement, escrow instructions, right?
- 53:06With successors and fallbacks, right? Don't simply
- 53:09fall back on in agreement to cooperate. Thank
- 53:11you for advancing the slide. Sorry, I missed
- 53:13that. And then treat the notice and the retention
- 53:17order and that final dismissal as strategic opportunities,
- 53:21right? Finality, as I said in the beginning,
- 53:23needs to be engineered. You can't just presume
- 53:26that because you got the settlement and you got
- 53:30the dismissal that everything's going to work
- 53:32the way everybody hopes that it does or hopes
- 53:36that it would, I should say. And I think it's
- 53:41sort of in a family law case, the judgment will
- 53:44sit there, and the attorneys will still be the
- 53:49attorneys unless they substitute off. So as a
- 53:52family law attorney, it's your duty or obligation
- 53:55to check in with your clients to see how everything
- 53:59is running mechanically if you're still the attorney
- 54:01of record. Are the people paying the obligations
- 54:06that they need to do? And are they engaging in
- 54:09all of the activity that's called for in the
- 54:11judgment? Something that we do to prevent something
- 54:14from coming into a post -judgment proceeding
- 54:18is what we would call it in family law, would
- 54:21be to have someone file a notice of acknowledgement
- 54:23of satisfaction of the judgment. Because the
- 54:25judgments in family law or settlement agreements
- 54:27will call for performance over a certain period
- 54:29of time. So for example, you may have an equalization
- 54:32payment. that millions of dollars are structured
- 54:36over many years to be paid out. At each stage
- 54:40of the payment, when the payment comes, you want
- 54:42to have the party come in, sign a notice of acknowledgement
- 54:45of judgment, file that so that down the road,
- 54:50let's say your client dies, and now it goes into
- 54:52the heirs are fighting it and saying, look, I
- 54:54didn't get enforcement. I didn't get what I was
- 54:57supposed to. we still entitled to this from the
- 55:00estate, these payments that are called for, there's
- 55:04no lack of clarity. I've seen it so many times
- 55:06where people don't document in family law the
- 55:09ongoing payments that they're making and just
- 55:11hoping that everybody is being honest and that's
- 55:14a real trap for the payor. Another thing to keep
- 55:17in mind of in family law is that we have to deal
- 55:20with quadros and almost everybody has a quadro
- 55:24of some type or fashion. family law attorneys
- 55:28just if you ever see this it's just something
- 55:30that you want to know that you want to have clearly
- 55:33a retention of all unresolved assets in your
- 55:38divorce and the authority for the court to divide
- 55:41up those assets and sometimes that can be a pension
- 55:44and then you do have to bring a post -judgment
- 55:47uh, proceeding or subsequent proceeding, uh,
- 55:49to enforce, uh, a division of an asset that'll
- 55:53ultimately be a quadro. And a quadro is a qualified
- 55:56domestic relations order that allows the transfer
- 55:58of 401ks and IRAs tax -free to the other party,
- 56:03or it allows support to be paid, um, if there's
- 56:06unpaid support from a retirement account. Uh,
- 56:09and, and so... that type of jurisdiction is inherent
- 56:13in the authority of the court. But if you don't
- 56:15put it in your judgment or settlement agreement,
- 56:17and you just say all the assets are resolved,
- 56:20you could end up losing out on your quadro or
- 56:23your support that you're seeking from the quadro.
- 56:28From what you're saying, it sounds like it's
- 56:30a good idea to put in these settlement agreements
- 56:32something about the notice of acknowledgement
- 56:34of satisfaction of judgment, just to remind yourself.
- 56:38three or four, 10 years down the road to deal
- 56:41with that detail? Yeah, you do. And it really
- 56:45needs to be something. Look, when you're paying
- 56:47the recipient, the payee, they've got all the
- 56:50incentive to come to your office or to sign a
- 56:53docu -sign at the time of paying. But after they've
- 56:56got the payment, Maybe they don't. And banks
- 56:58only keep records for seven years. So people
- 57:01think, look, I paid the money. It's fine. And
- 57:04we all walk away. But then you could be hit in
- 57:07family law cases with people coming down the
- 57:09road saying, hey, I never received all of these
- 57:13equalization payments. Or you sold the house,
- 57:16but you pocketed all the money and didn't provide
- 57:18it to me. And the records are gone. So in order
- 57:21to insulate your clients from that, that's a
- 57:23best practice. Not every client's going to want
- 57:24that. Not every client's going to pay for that.
- 57:26But when you're thinking about large estates,
- 57:28high net worth states, ultra high net worth estates,
- 57:31this is really, it can start becoming a big number
- 57:34on performance. And so it's worthwhile to have
- 57:37that process of following up to avoid an enforcement
- 57:42action. So in that long -term settlement, I'm
- 57:46sorry, Scott, go ahead. No, I was just going
- 57:48to say that's a really great point, Al, and it's
- 57:51my takeaway from this presentation, because we
- 57:53do see those issues on the back end, right? Things
- 57:56were copacetic while the spouse was still alive,
- 58:02right? They didn't mess with the spouse, but
- 58:03they never liked the spouse's kids, right? So
- 58:06now the spouse is gone. Maybe I'll take another
- 58:08dip in this and see what kind of records they
- 58:11kept. It's a really powerful tool and an important
- 58:16one. So thank you for raising that. Given these
- 58:20long -term settlements that you may be looking
- 58:22at, what do you do about calendaring the client
- 58:27follow -up to make certain there's nothing changed
- 58:29or nothing to be reviewed? I think that's something
- 58:35that's For our server, we have a... review of
- 58:39the cases on a monthly, quarterly, annually basis.
- 58:43And then it's just assigned. If we do this judgment,
- 58:46we just calendar when the payments are due. And
- 58:49then we follow up with the client to make sure
- 58:51that they've made the payment and that the notice
- 58:55of acknowledgement of judgment is signed off
- 58:56on so that there's no questions. And then other
- 58:58clients, let's say they relieve you at the end
- 59:01of your case. They have the MSA, they're done.
- 59:04I don't want to pay attorney's fees anymore.
- 59:07You need to send them a closing. letter with
- 59:08all the important deadlines in addition to the
- 59:11settlement agreement and judgment because you
- 59:13could say you know hey look it's in there you
- 59:14know what you're supposed to do but it's still
- 59:16a best practice to send a letter that you advise
- 59:20your client that these are all their continuing
- 59:21duties under the settlement agreement or judgment.
- 59:25Well, you know, they're going to call you first
- 59:27when they get the letter saying they didn't do
- 59:29what they were supposed to do. And they're going
- 59:30to say, why didn't you tell me? Right. Exactly.
- 59:34Yeah. Yeah. Well, and I feel like, you know,
- 59:36maybe 20 or 30 % of the calls we get are all
- 59:39post what we call post judgment and family law,
- 59:41which would, you know, we don't file a new action.
- 59:43You just file it in the same divorce case to
- 59:47suit on. It's not, it's the little bit of a distinction
- 59:49between civil and probate. Scott, do you, what
- 59:53would you think would be a The thing to do about
- 59:56calendaring any follow up on these long -term
- 59:59settlements. I agree. I mean, I agree with Al's
- 1:00:02process. I think it's sound. I think for most
- 1:00:05of our cases. I dare say most of them are one
- 1:00:10-offs. We represent a family, we represent them
- 1:00:12once, occasionally more than once. But once we've
- 1:00:17succeeded and we've gotten the settlement and
- 1:00:20the case is dismissed, the client doesn't want
- 1:00:22to keep us on retainer. I understand that. I
- 1:00:24don't take it personally. Closing it and letting
- 1:00:28them know what their obligations are is the best
- 1:00:31practice, making sure that they understand it.
- 1:00:34If they want to continue, We calendar, just like
- 1:00:38Al said, just like you would a court hearing,
- 1:00:39right? Just as you would anything else to make
- 1:00:41sure that you're on top of what your obligations
- 1:00:43are on behalf of your client. You know, it's
- 1:00:46kind of funny because we could, in our practice,
- 1:00:48we could do the post -nup, the divorce, and then
- 1:00:51we have the new spouse prenup, and then, you
- 1:00:53know, we don't have, it's really a frequent flyer
- 1:00:55if then you do the second divorce around. That
- 1:01:00is a great note, I think, on which to end the
- 1:01:02presentation. Thank you both so much for putting
- 1:01:06this together. Some really interesting subject
- 1:01:09matter and obviously a lot of things practitioners
- 1:01:12need to keep in mind so that they're doing the
- 1:01:15best for the client and also keeping themselves
- 1:01:17out of difficulties later since, you know, you
- 1:01:21know, years can pass and things can change and
- 1:01:24who knows what's really going on in some of these
- 1:01:26matters and both family law and probate and trust
- 1:01:31matters have some long timelines that hopefully
- 1:01:34we don't see too often in the civil side of things.
- 1:01:37But thank you both, great program and look forward
- 1:01:41to working with you guys in the future or maybe
- 1:01:44having everybody back for some other programs.
- 1:01:46Thank you. Yeah, thank you so much, Howard. And
- 1:01:49it was a pleasure working with you, Scott. And
- 1:01:51thank you for putting, Scott did so much of the
- 1:01:54laboring work on this and it was really amazing.
- 1:01:57My pleasure. Pleasure to speak with you. Thank
- 1:01:59you, Howard. Thanks, everyone.