Latest / The Brief / What Happened?
Transcript
- Rent control made the ballot, but the story didn’t start on election night.
- It started with a campaign to get those questions in front of voters.
- Who pushed, who resisted, and why did it catch fire? The path to the ballot was anything but accidental.
- Then came the counteroffensive: a cross-sector coalition urging voters to say “no”—organizers, owners, nonprofit voices, and MHA at the center of the strategy.
- And yet… both measures passed...
- Policies locked in, uncertainty up, and the scramble began.
- What unfolded as projects paused and stakeholders recalibrated??? Today, you’ll hear the inside account—from the origins of the ballot questions to the coalition fight to the aftermath—told by Sehsil Smith and Todd Lillgenquist.
- Stick with us.
- You're listening to the Brief, a podcast from the Minnesota Multi-Housing Association.
- Whether you're a property owner, manager, maintenance pro, product/service partner, or just curious about the industry we've got fresh insights, and quick takes, to keep you informed and ahead of the curve.
- No fluff.
- No filler.
- If it affects your residents, your business, or your bottom line.
- You'll hear about it here.
- This industry provides more than buildings.
- It offers Minnesotans a solution for home That solution is multi housing.
- Welcome to MHAs, The Brief.
- This episode of The Brief is proudly sponsored by our founding partner, Citizens State Bank.
- Rooted in the Upper Midwest with a growing presence in Minnesota, Citizens State Bank is deeply committed to supporting the region’s housing providers and small businesses through personalized financial solutions.
- Whether you're financing a new property in the Twin Cities, refinancing in Rochester, or expanding your operations across the state, their experienced team is here to help.
- Citizens State Bank specializes in property management banking solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of Minnesota’s property owners and managers.
- From commercial real estate loans, competitive deposit accounts, and a state-of-the-art business online banking suite, they provide the local insight and resources you need to keep your business moving forward.
- Experience the difference of working with a bank that understands Minnesota communities.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn how Citizens State Bank can help you achieve your goals.
- Member FDIC.
- Equal Housing Lender.
- Thanks to Citizens State Bank for backing this podcast and helping us bring valuable industry insights to Minnesota and beyond Week after week.
- Welcome to the brief.
- My name is Aubrey Albrecht.
- I'm the Vice President of Education and Chief Innovation Officer at MHA, and today's episode is titled What Happened.
- We have two very special guests who were on the front lines of the rent control ballot measures in 2021.
- Cecil Smith, our president, and CEO at MHA, and Todd Renquist, MH a's Vice President of Government Affairs and Chief Operating Officer.
- Four years later, almost to the day.
- We'd love to hear about MHAs efforts in opposing these ballot initiatives.
- Todd and Cecil, can you walk us through what happened and how MHA got involved? Yeah, four years.
- And here we are first.
- I think one thing we need to talk about is the difference between rent control and rent stabilization.
- And from our perspective, there is no difference.
- control equals rent stabilization.
- So the distinction that is often tried to be made there is no distinction, or there's, there is no difference.
- And I thought that rent control was preempted.
- Rent control is preempted in Minnesota, however, rent control can be adopted if it's passed on a at a general election via ballot measure.
- And that, that is how we get to the start of this story.
- each city has their own charters and method of adopting ballot questions.
- does not have.
- You cannot pass a, an initiative through ballot measure.
- So what they had to do is grant themselves authority at a future election to adopt a rent control ordinance.
- St.
- Paul couldn't go directly to the question because they do allow ballot measures to be, become ordinances via that, that avenue.
- So the activists.
- From different housing advocacy organizations in response to housing affordability, believed that rent control was going to be a solution, which it's a, in the academic world a proven, case study of a bad economic policy.
- But nevertheless, they proceeded and in August of 2021, the ballot measures was were certified.
- A question in St.
- Paul, which was the ordinance.
- And then three.
- in Minneapolis There were three ballot questions.
- The question one was the, was the strong mayor, government reform.
- Question two was the defund police.
- And question three was the rent control amendment to enable a future vote.
- complicated landscape Minneapolis and on St.
- Paul.
- The other thing that was on the ballot was the reelection of mere Melvin Carter.
- So August 5th we announced the sensible housing ballot committee which to be a coalition of many partners.
- In that campaign, including the realtors, locally and nationally.
- Apartment association, friends at the national level, national Apartment Association, national Multifamily Housing Council, and then different business interests.
- In the region, the Minneapolis Regional Chamber of Commerce, St.
- Paul chamber, the downtown council, and then.
- we move forward with this labor groups that were concerned about jobs and housing also got involved the operating engineers and the carpenters.
- And so it was a really broad coalition that worked really well together to build out what became a $5 million campaign and.
- Using professional campaign strategists and campaign managers.
- We worked through a campaign targeting 51,000 voters in St.
- Paul, and nearly 98,000 in.
- And that resulted in 900,000 being spent on mailers.
- Eight rounds of mailing in each city, two and a half million dollars on digital phone, texting, video over the Radio, even billboards.
- And then we spent over a million dollars on door knocking with paid canvases out in great numbers, knocking on the doors of these folks to talk to them about the ballot questions.
- So the theme of the campaign was think twice.
- It's really hard to explain how damaging rent control is, because who doesn't want the rent to not go up on its face? It sounds like it's logical.
- We want to control rents.
- We want to keep rents down, but the negative impacts are plentiful and that has been studied at length.
- So then.
- In St.
- Paul, at least three weeks before the election, October 12th, mayor Melvin Carter, who had sat out and hadn't, voiced an opinion on the ballot measure, came out in support of the ballot measure.
- And he said, it's not perfect, but it can be amended at a future time.
- Which come to find out, they had to wait a year before they could amend it, but that was three weeks before the election.
- And that was pivotal, at least in St.
- Paul for the results.
- So the results were November 2nd 53 to 47 in both cities, effectively.
- In both cities.
- It, it passed.
- And in St.
- Paul, we came within about 1700 votes in Minneapolis, came within 3,100 votes.
- Both very close.
- And the campaign that we propped up was a three month campaign, raised $5 million, built this massive coalition that had never been done in the housing arena before.
- Certainly not at MHA it was, devastating on November 2nd to lose that, not only for us and our members, but ultimately the communities that adopted this St.
- Paul.
- And you know, in Minneapolis, potentially in future.
- And since then there has.
- Virtually no construction in St.
- Paul.
- And St.
- Paul has been the poster child nationally and internationally for why Rent Control doesn't work.
- Minneapolis has taken note of that.
- And a couple years ago, two USC professors issued a report and found that in St.
- Paul, those who gained the most.
- renters with higher incomes and were more likely to be white the those who were harmed the most were lower income and minorities.
- So the exact opposite of one of the intended purposes.
- And so, one of the many, many reasons why ring control doesn't work and the cautionary tale has played out exactly the way.
- We thought it would in St.
- Paul, unfortunately.
- Yeah.
- And unfortunately it's attracted attention.
- Wall Street Journal's done several articles on why St.
- Paul is the case study for why you don't do rent control.
- So, you know, the good news is Minneapolis hasn't taken the next next step to put this on the ballot.
- It's there in the charter that they can have a vote.
- At a future date adopting rent control in Minneapolis.
- But I think they have seen the cautionary tale that St.
- Paul has become for what can the devastating effects to a, a housing market and a, and a city overall with terrible policy however well intentioned it is.
- So, four years went by really fast.
- And looking back on this, it was a monumental effort by a lot, a big team of people.
- It's unfortunate that we fell short but it was the best possible campaign.
- At the end of the day, we felt like there was really no stone left unturned to try and stop this from happening.
- And we're very proud of that effort, at least.
- So for asking.
- Thanks for listening.
- Thanks for having us.
- Conversation and incredibly insightful.
- It sounds like the Twin Cities has really been ground zero for a policy experiment with real consequences.
- And unfortunately, we're still feeling those ripple effects.
- Don't go anywhere.
- There's more ahead.
- After the break, we will take a look at what's happening at MHA, and of course we're checking in with Mira, our AI assistant, who could even help you navigate the rent stabilization policy in St.
- Paul.
- Looking to refresh your flooring without the hassle? Bloomington Carpet One has you covered—with expert guidance, quality products, and solutions tailored for multi housing professionals.
- Whether it’s one unit or an entire building, their team helps you choose flooring that’s stylish, durable, and budget-friendly.
- Visit carpet-one-bloomington.com
- or stop by their Bloomington showroom to see the difference that local expertise and national buying power can make.
- Bloomington Carpet One.
- Beautiful made affordable.
- This episode is also sponsored by Renova One.
- You may remember them as Renovation Systems—but they’ve grown, evolved, and rebranded to reflect what they truly are: a nationwide, one-stop partner for all your unit turns and property improvements.
- From flooring and painting to restoration and full turnkey renovations, Renova One delivers it all—fast, responsive, and without the headache of juggling multiple vendors.
- Still local.
- Still the hustle you trust.
- Now with even more ways to scale with your portfolio.
- Learn more at Renova One .com
- and see how they're redefining service in multifamily.
- Hey everyone, welcome back.
- It’s Denise here—and since this episode drops during Thanksgiving week, we’re doing things a little differently in this segment.
- Rather than running through upcoming classes or events, we want to take a moment to say… thank you.
- To all of our members who stood with us in the fight against the rent control ballot measures—thank you.
- You donated, door-knocked, testified, showed up to city council meetings, and helped bring facts and context into a very emotional conversation.
- And you continue to engage—with us, with your elected leaders, and with your communities—to move the needle on this issue.
- We know it’s not easy work.
- But it matters.
- And we are truly grateful to be in this with you.
- From all of us at MHA—thank you for being part of this incredible community of housing providers.
- Now, let’s head into one of our favorite segments… Hey Denise! Is it ask mira time? Yesssssssssss Let’s ask mira about rent control in Saint Paul! Ok, mira, How do I navigate the Rent Stabilization policy in St.
- Paul? Here’s what mira had to say: To navigate rent stabilization in St.
- Paul, the biggest thing to know is that rent increases are capped at 3% in a 12-month period—unless you apply for an exception through the City.
- Now, there are a few paths if you need to go above that cap: There’s something called a Self-Certification Increase, which lets you raise rent up to 8%—but you have to meet specific criteria, and it’s subject to an annual review.
- Then there’s the Just Cause Vacancy Increase, where if a unit is vacated for an approved “just cause,” you can raise rent by the CPI plus 8%, again with City review.
- And finally, there’s the Staff Determination Increase, which doesn’t have a set limit—but you’ll need a strong case and full documentation to get it approved.
- Right, and you can’t just raise rent and hope no one notices.
- You’ve gotta submit an application with financial worksheets—and tenants have to be notified when you do.
- Both sides have 45 days to appeal the city’s decision.
- Exactly.
- And if you’re changing who pays utilities—say you used to include them in rent and now you don’t—you must lower the rent to reflect that.
- And you have to follow state law.
- Also, if you want to raise rent after a vacancy, you have to prove the vacancy was for a “just cause”—and that’s defined by the ordinance.
- So you’ll need documentation.
- Whew.
- Not exactly light reading.
- But it’s all important—and enforced through the City’s administrative process.
- Both housing providers and residents have rights under the ordinance, and each case is handled unit by unit.
- And that’s why we’re thankful for mira.
- If you want to dig deeper, head to m m h a .com
- and click on her little avatar at the top of the page.
- She’s ready 24/7.
- Just don’t ask her about cranberry sauce.
- She has STRONG opinions.
- We’ll leave that for the next episode.
- Alright, that’s going to do it for this episode of The Brief.
- But before we go—mark your calendar for the next one.
- Yes! We’re sitting down with MHA’s Board Chair, Jennifer Gordon, for an episode you will not want to miss.
- We’ll be talking leadership, vision, and what’s ahead for Minnesota’s housing industry in 2026 and beyond.
- It’s thoughtful, candid—and honestly, pretty inspiring.
- So hit that follow button, and we’ll see you back here in two weeks.
- Same feed, same voices—just a little more GORDON.
- [laughs] Love it.
- Thanks for listening.
- this has been The Brief, an original podcast produced by the Minnesota Multi Housing Association.
- It is hosted by your two favorite AI voices—me, Denise Wilson… …and me, Logan Garcia.
- Our story editor is Todd Lillgenquist.
- Aubrey Albrecht is our showrunner and managing producer.
- The Brief’s executive producer is Sesil Smith.
- Follow and listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, mmha.com,
- and wherever you get your podcasts.
- And one more big thank-you to Citizens State Bank, our founding sponsor.
- Their support powers this podcast—and their team powers smart financial solutions for Minnesota’s housing providers.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn more.
- See you next time!