Latest / Yaron Brook Show / Philosophical Issues of the Day -- With Greg Salmieri | Yaron Brook ShowNew Recording (draft)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Photos of Aledo.
- 0:04Speaker 2: Interest and the individual lots.
- 0:10Speaker 1: This is the show, Oh right, everybody, welcome to your
- 0:17Speaker 1: on book show on this Monday, March tenth. Uh, it's Monday.
- 0:25Speaker 1: We do interviews in the evening and I'm extremely happy
- 0:28Speaker 1: to have Greg Greg Slamieri with me.
- 0:31Speaker 3: Greg is a regular guest on the IRN Book Show.
- 0:34Speaker 3: He is coming to us from the University from Texas,
- 0:37Speaker 3: from his home in Texas, but he is of course
- 0:41Speaker 3: a professor at the University of Texas Austin.
- 0:44Speaker 1: University of Texas in Austin. God and.
- 0:51Speaker 2: Hi, Hi, Greg, Hi, how are you?
- 0:53Speaker 1: I'm good, I'm good. How about you?
- 0:55Speaker 2: All right?
- 0:57Speaker 4: This seems to be an argument taking place down there
- 1:00Speaker 4: between my son and my wife, so hopefully that's.
- 1:03Speaker 1: Not picking up so who wins those arguments?
- 1:07Speaker 2: No comment. He seems agrieved by.
- 1:10Speaker 5: Something, all right, So hopefully that's not too distracting. So
- 1:19Speaker 5: we don't have one specific theme for today's For today's show,
- 1:23Speaker 5: there's been an accumulation of some questions that you know,
- 1:27Speaker 5: I've talked about in the show and you've commented on,
- 1:29Speaker 5: and we thought it would make would make interesting for
- 1:32Speaker 5: the show. So we're going to cover some of those
- 1:34Speaker 5: and then of course what makes this particularly interesting is
- 1:37Speaker 5: what you guys have to ask, any questions you guys have,
- 1:41Speaker 5: And as I've said, there's probably a bunch of questions
- 1:46Speaker 5: on philosophy, on the history of philosophy that I have.
- 1:50Speaker 1: Given incomplete answers.
- 1:52Speaker 3: To put it that way, that that now is a
- 1:54Speaker 3: good time to ask an expert.
- 1:56Speaker 1: So it's a great time to ask greg.
- 1:58Speaker 3: I thought we'd thought maybe because it's the oldest, but
- 2:03Speaker 3: still with some questions that came up about about Plato
- 2:07Speaker 3: and maybe in contrast to Aristotle. There was a question
- 2:12Speaker 3: I think a while back that somebody asked about was
- 2:15Speaker 3: Plato and altruist and how do we relate It's also
- 2:19Speaker 3: as a modern concept, is it was it invented by Christianity?
- 2:23Speaker 1: Does it have older roots as an ideology? And some
- 2:28Speaker 1: of those roots do they go back to Plato?
- 2:33Speaker 4: If by altruisms a little ambiguous, it could mean a
- 2:37Speaker 4: few things. So if we mean by altruism the idea
- 2:42Speaker 4: that other.
- 2:42Speaker 2: People are what we should be living for, we should.
- 2:44Speaker 4: Be living for others, that's how Comped put it, And
- 2:49Speaker 4: then that's.
- 2:50Speaker 2: A modern idea.
- 2:51Speaker 4: You get it Comped putting it in that way in
- 2:53Speaker 4: the nineteenth century you have. If you're going to have
- 2:56Speaker 4: an earlier analog to that, it's it's maybe there are
- 3:01Speaker 4: some things in Stoicism, but I would say, especially Jesus,
- 3:04Speaker 4: this idea that you're what you do to the least
- 3:06Speaker 4: of my brothers is what you do want to be
- 3:08Speaker 4: in this orientation towards other people, and particularly the I
- 3:14Speaker 4: think this is a kind of very central to Christianity.
- 3:17Speaker 4: To the least well off other people, to the poor,
- 3:20Speaker 4: et cetera, to the downtrodden, to the meek, et cetera.
- 3:24Speaker 2: That is a particularly Christian thing.
- 3:27Speaker 4: That is the orientation not just to other people, but
- 3:29Speaker 4: to the people that you.
- 3:31Speaker 2: Might look down on.
- 3:33Speaker 4: But in Christianity, of course, it's not because you're actually
- 3:36Speaker 4: going to be able to help those people. Jesus didn't
- 3:39Speaker 4: think you could accomplish much of anything. Right, It's to
- 3:44Speaker 4: show your devotion to God and to emulate God and
- 3:47Speaker 4: not caring for yourself and caring about those people. So
- 3:49Speaker 4: that I think is a particularly Christian view. And then
- 3:51Speaker 4: the modern view that you're serving other people is what
- 3:56Speaker 4: I think you get an Encombe. And then in a
- 3:59Speaker 4: little bit less of a gross form in male in
- 4:02Speaker 4: utilitarianism and bens them and other utilitarianisms. But so again,
- 4:06Speaker 4: if we're talking about the serving other people in particular,
- 4:09Speaker 4: then I think it's this modern view other people in
- 4:11Speaker 4: effect taking the place of God as the thing to
- 4:14Speaker 4: which you should sacrifice. But if the idea is that
- 4:17Speaker 4: morality is about sacrificing and sacrificing yourself to something, and
- 4:21Speaker 4: other people just happen to, you know, be the people
- 4:24Speaker 4: that this theory puts into that place, then the view
- 4:29Speaker 4: is of course older and much more widespread. And so Kant,
- 4:33Speaker 4: for example, content with a King dot comport with a
- 4:36Speaker 4: See Kant is not an altruist in the sense of
- 4:40Speaker 4: thinking you should have your life oriented around other people.
- 4:42Speaker 4: He doesn't think you should be trying to achieve things
- 4:44Speaker 4: for them anymore than you should be trying to achieve
- 4:46Speaker 4: values for yourself. What you should be doing is trying
- 4:49Speaker 4: to live in the way that he thinks is rational,
- 4:52Speaker 4: which is by being willing to sacrifice everything to these
- 4:56Speaker 4: impersonal duties. And there's a variant of that kind of
- 5:01Speaker 4: view in Plato and the Stoics as well.
- 5:03Speaker 2: An earlier form of the view that.
- 5:07Speaker 4: Kant is the kind of paradigm of and it's a
- 5:10Speaker 4: variant of and I think maybe less virulent form of it,
- 5:13Speaker 4: because it's not explicitly anti self in the way that
- 5:16Speaker 4: Kant's CONT's theory is. So, Kant is thinking of anything
- 5:23Speaker 4: for you, anything that promotes your happiness as an object
- 5:26Speaker 4: of inclination or desire. He calls it inclination, and he's
- 5:30Speaker 4: defining the moral by explicit contrast to that.
- 5:34Speaker 2: Whereas all the Greek.
- 5:35Speaker 4: Philosophers, including Plato or just all the significant ones, thought
- 5:41Speaker 4: that it's best for you yourself to be virtuous, and
- 5:47Speaker 4: so in that sense you can think that they're all
- 5:49Speaker 4: egoists or have an egoistic element. Virtue is going to
- 5:51Speaker 4: be good for you, it's your own flourishing life, etc. However,
- 5:55Speaker 4: there's a sense in which some of the time they're
- 6:00Speaker 4: thinking of virtue in a way where the content of
- 6:04Speaker 4: it is coming from a prior understanding of what's good
- 6:06Speaker 4: for you, and these virtues are either part of that
- 6:09Speaker 4: or a means to attain it, or maybe some package
- 6:11Speaker 4: deal of those two things. I think that you can
- 6:13Speaker 4: find that in Aristotle. You can find that in a way,
- 6:16Speaker 4: and Epicurius I think much wrong in both of their views,
- 6:19Speaker 4: but some idea of it's intelligible how we're understanding it's
- 6:23Speaker 4: virtue as you are good, and even in some of
- 6:26Speaker 4: Plato's writings, but in other places in Plato and also
- 6:29Speaker 4: especially in the Stoics, they're thinking of what's good for
- 6:32Speaker 4: you is or is largely about getting virtue, and the
- 6:36Speaker 4: content of virtue is not at all derived from a
- 6:39Speaker 4: prior understanding of your own good, and sometimes is.
- 6:46Speaker 2: Understood by contrast to.
- 6:48Speaker 4: The things that people ordinarily regard as good, so much
- 6:50Speaker 4: so that we're starting to get a kind of proto
- 6:52Speaker 4: version of the self is the opposite of value, which
- 6:55Speaker 4: I think is what you get pure in content. And
- 6:58Speaker 4: it is one or two places where Plato approaches content
- 7:01Speaker 4: that he says, you know, self love is where bad
- 7:05Speaker 4: actions come from in the laws.
- 7:08Speaker 3: And to what extent is aristotle or repudiation of that
- 7:13Speaker 3: of the worst in Plato.
- 7:19Speaker 4: Well, one way you can put is Aristotle's an embrace
- 7:21Speaker 4: of the best.
- 7:22Speaker 2: In Plato, this.
- 7:23Speaker 4: Idea that virtue is what's good for you. Virtue is
- 7:27Speaker 4: the living up, is valuing your own soul and living
- 7:30Speaker 4: up to your reason and so forth, which particularly in
- 7:33Speaker 4: the early Socratic dialogues, there's a lot of and has
- 7:36Speaker 4: a very egoistic flair to it, and some in the
- 7:42Speaker 4: Republic and elsewhere also, But Aristotle is much more explicit
- 7:47Speaker 4: that there isn't any sacrifice ever involved in doing what's
- 7:51Speaker 4: best for you, sorry, in being virtuous, that virtue is
- 7:54Speaker 4: the thing most worth having. Again, Plato in most moods
- 7:57Speaker 4: will say things like that, But there is this passage
- 8:00Speaker 4: where Plato says, or the Athenian Stranger, one of the
- 8:04Speaker 4: characters in the Laws who's speaking for him, says that
- 8:08Speaker 4: you know, we shouldn't be self lovers, we should be
- 8:10Speaker 4: lovers of the good and of reason, and indeed self
- 8:13Speaker 4: lovers where everything bad comes from. And there are a
- 8:15Speaker 4: few early passages in Aristotle or pseudo Aristotle that echo
- 8:19Speaker 4: some of those themes.
- 8:20Speaker 2: But in his main writing on ethics, the Nicol McKean Ethics, he.
- 8:24Speaker 4: Has this really bold passagers that even though selfishness self
- 8:28Speaker 4: love fill outas love, you know, phil like in Phosphy
- 8:30Speaker 4: and outoast self. Uh.
- 8:32Speaker 2: This is a term of approprium.
- 8:34Speaker 4: People use it as an insult, but h and the
- 8:38Speaker 4: people that people called selfish are typically bad people, their
- 8:41Speaker 4: thieves and so forth. But the virtuous man is actually
- 8:44Speaker 4: more so a lover himself. He loves himself more than
- 8:47Speaker 4: anybody else, and we should be lovers of self in
- 8:49Speaker 4: the way he is. And this is a really bold move,
- 8:53Speaker 4: you know, reclaiming a term of opprobrium. And Aristotle doesn't
- 8:57Speaker 4: do that kind of thing often, but he does it
- 8:59Speaker 4: there with that term, and on a few other points
- 9:02Speaker 4: where he's wanting to stress that what's good is good
- 9:05Speaker 4: for you, and you're like, there's no conflict between what's right,
- 9:09Speaker 4: what's rational, and what's best for you.
- 9:11Speaker 2: Yep.
- 9:12Speaker 1: So there's actually a question on Plato.
- 9:15Speaker 3: So I help a Campba asks did Plato seek to
- 9:19Speaker 3: destroy man's mind like Kant did?
- 9:21Speaker 1: He just wasn't as good at it.
- 9:25Speaker 4: I don't in people's motives when they do bad things
- 9:29Speaker 4: are often mixed, and it's hard to apportion exactly how
- 9:34Speaker 4: much is the thing they claim that they're after, and
- 9:35Speaker 4: how much is it, you know, which is often good,
- 9:37Speaker 4: and how much is it something hateful and bad. Both
- 9:46Speaker 4: Plato and Aristotle are very impressed with the developments in
- 9:52Speaker 4: mathematics where they're forming axiom systems and they're trying to
- 9:58Speaker 4: demonstrate geometric true you know, from fundamental things.
- 10:01Speaker 2: They're trying to understand the heavens and similar terms.
- 10:03Speaker 4: And both of them have this idea that there's something
- 10:05Speaker 4: the mind is doing when you're doing this kind of
- 10:08Speaker 4: work that's unique to human beings, that's really special. That
- 10:13Speaker 4: you're kind of alive and being fully human when you're
- 10:15Speaker 4: doing this kind of thing, and they really value that.
- 10:19Speaker 4: And they also both contrast it to other more prosaic forms,
- 10:26Speaker 4: as they would say it, forms of reasoning, particularly ones
- 10:28Speaker 4: involved in productive work. They associate this higher kind of
- 10:33Speaker 4: reasoning with something you can do if you're you know,
- 10:35Speaker 4: an aristocrat at leisure in effect, and not with the
- 10:39Speaker 4: kind of businessy thinking that's leading to an emerging middle
- 10:44Speaker 4: class in Athens. You know a guy, you know, he
- 10:48Speaker 4: doesn't even have you know, ancestral wealth, and here he is,
- 10:50Speaker 4: you know, manufacturing shields for the army and making a
- 10:53Speaker 4: lot of money.
- 10:54Speaker 2: And both of them are kind of.
- 10:56Speaker 4: Look askance at some of those people and so, and
- 11:01Speaker 4: they're not doing any of this kind of purely abstract
- 11:03Speaker 4: reasoning that we the philosopher's so value. So what's going
- 11:07Speaker 4: on here is it a real appreciation for something uniquely
- 11:12Speaker 4: human and powerful about the kind of abstract reasoning that
- 11:15Speaker 4: they don't yet know how to relate to the rest
- 11:18Speaker 4: of human life, right, and they couldn't know it yet.
- 11:21Speaker 4: It had to be learned over time, and it was
- 11:23Speaker 4: a great achievement when Francis Bacon and others put those
- 11:26Speaker 4: things together. So is it like they're they're they're glimpsing
- 11:28Speaker 4: this tremendous thing that the part of our human power,
- 11:31Speaker 4: they don't know what to do with it. Or is
- 11:33Speaker 4: it that they're resenting people who are working for a
- 11:35Speaker 4: living and the emerging middle class And it's kind of,
- 11:38Speaker 4: you know, lazy aristocrats slapping back of them.
- 11:41Speaker 2: And I think, in.
- 11:42Speaker 4: Fact, there's some of both motives in both thinkers, both
- 11:45Speaker 4: Plato and Aristotle. And you know, it's hard to apportion
- 11:50Speaker 4: how much of each in each. Plato, though, there is
- 11:55Speaker 4: this other strand of real.
- 11:57Speaker 2: Contempt for and hatred of worldly things.
- 12:01Speaker 4: You know, philosophy is preparing for death, and he's he's
- 12:05Speaker 4: drawn to asceticism and in a way that Aristotle isn't.
- 12:09Speaker 2: And I think.
- 12:10Speaker 4: That that resentment towards bodily pleasures, resentment towards so many
- 12:19Speaker 4: of the things of this world, is a real part
- 12:22Speaker 4: of Plato's motivation in a way that it isn't part
- 12:24Speaker 4: of Aristotles, and that would be the kind of life hating,
- 12:27Speaker 4: mind destroying part of it.
- 12:31Speaker 1: But you wouldn't put him anywhere near a KNT.
- 12:35Speaker 4: I mean, I don't have an X ray into either
- 12:37Speaker 4: of their souls. You get that much purer in Kant
- 12:40Speaker 4: and in count you have a reaction against happiness in
- 12:48Speaker 4: a way that that you don't have for Plato. You
- 12:50Speaker 4: have the moralizing of the hatred of happiness. You have
- 12:54Speaker 4: a very deeply Christian self sacrificial strand that is not
- 12:58Speaker 4: in Plato. And you have a fear that the Enlightenment
- 13:02Speaker 4: is going to destroy altruism and are trying to protect
- 13:06Speaker 4: protect the idea of sacrifice from the incursion of reason
- 13:10Speaker 4: by you know, rethinking reason, and that.
- 13:15Speaker 2: I think is a very different kind of motivation. You
- 13:16Speaker 2: don't know anything like that, and play it one.
- 13:18Speaker 1: Might be yeah, all right.
- 13:20Speaker 3: So a separate strand of questions that often come up
- 13:24Speaker 3: have to do with the nature of free will, or
- 13:27Speaker 3: in particularly the the the unique perspective objectivism has on
- 13:32Speaker 3: free will. So maybe you can give us a quick
- 13:35Speaker 3: kind of summary of the objectivist position of free will,
- 13:38Speaker 3: and then we've got some application a few applications for that.
- 13:43Speaker 2: The first point is that we have it so free
- 13:47Speaker 2: will is the ability to.
- 13:48Speaker 4: Make choices, and choices understood as real choices, things that
- 13:53Speaker 4: change the future from what it would have been if
- 13:55Speaker 4: you would chosen otherwise.
- 13:58Speaker 2: It's there's that old I think it's in the Lawrence
- 14:02Speaker 2: of Arabia.
- 14:03Speaker 4: There's a scene where you have the British military officer
- 14:08Speaker 4: and the Muslim tribesmen and or armand tribesman, and the
- 14:15Speaker 4: tribesmen are saying, you know, everything's written, everything's written, and
- 14:18Speaker 4: the English are saying nothing is written and it or
- 14:20Speaker 4: you know, this isn't written anyway.
- 14:22Speaker 2: That is, the future is not set.
- 14:23Speaker 4: I can make the future one way or another based
- 14:25Speaker 4: on the choices that I'm making.
- 14:26Speaker 2: It's not all faded.
- 14:27Speaker 4: And that is the fundamental idea of free will, that
- 14:31Speaker 4: the future is not set already. The future will be
- 14:33Speaker 4: determined by what happens now, including by what you do now,
- 14:37Speaker 4: and what you do now is not determined by the past.
- 14:40Speaker 2: You have a.
- 14:41Speaker 4: Choice in the moment and the future could be either
- 14:43Speaker 4: of it can be multiple ways. That's the kind of
- 14:46Speaker 4: core idea of free will, and objectivism embraces it. It's
- 14:54Speaker 4: a pro a clearly inexplicitly pro free will philosophy, and
- 14:59Speaker 4: it identifies identifies free will specifically in the power we
- 15:04Speaker 4: have over our own minds. So although much of what
- 15:07Speaker 4: happens in us happens automatically by physiological causes, that we
- 15:11Speaker 4: don't have any direct.
- 15:12Speaker 2: Control over.
- 15:14Speaker 4: Whether we think or not how we think, whether we
- 15:19Speaker 4: raise or lower our level of attention is something that
- 15:23Speaker 4: we can control directly, and through our control of that,
- 15:26Speaker 4: we shape our characters, our actions, and everything else. And
- 15:29Speaker 4: the kind of locus of control is in the choice
- 15:32Speaker 4: to engage or disengage your mind. And it's a choice
- 15:35Speaker 4: you're making all the time. It's a choice to sort
- 15:37Speaker 4: of an effect be in the driver's seat of your cognition,
- 15:40Speaker 4: or let the reins go and an effect drift from
- 15:46Speaker 4: moment to moment, or in part to maintain that drift,
- 15:49Speaker 4: pushing away thoughts you don't want to face. And that's
- 15:52Speaker 4: the kind of central idea of the objectives to view
- 15:54Speaker 4: of free will. It's not wholly unique in the history
- 15:58Speaker 4: of thought. I've noticed that people who are very on
- 16:02Speaker 4: about free will and on about power and agency and
- 16:04Speaker 4: choice tend to not all of them, but at a
- 16:07Speaker 4: few important moments in the history of thought tend to
- 16:10Speaker 4: notice its connection to engaging or disengaging your mind. Probably
- 16:17Speaker 4: the best writer on this, and the first to make
- 16:19Speaker 4: really clear that he's endorsing free will as opposed to
- 16:23Speaker 4: de terminism, and there's no, you know, mushy area between them,
- 16:26Speaker 4: is the the commentator on Aristotle named Alexander of Aphrodisseus,
- 16:31Speaker 4: and he's really fantastic on this.
- 16:35Speaker 2: John Locke is.
- 16:36Speaker 4: Very good on this, that free will consists in the
- 16:39Speaker 4: kind of control you have first conformance over your mind.
- 16:42Speaker 2: And in particular do you deliberate about something or not?
- 16:44Speaker 4: Do you just go with how you feel in the moment,
- 16:46Speaker 4: or can you keep on thinking about it in the fact?
- 16:50Speaker 1: Why do you think so?
- 16:53Speaker 3: The deterministic view, the anti few view, is so prevalent
- 16:57Speaker 3: today among intellectuals, from Sam Harris to prominent philosophers to
- 17:03Speaker 3: pretty much everybody seems to be anti free will.
- 17:09Speaker 4: Well, it's associated with science. I think part of that
- 17:14Speaker 4: is because, in a way, because of cond though not
- 17:19Speaker 4: exclusively so, there was a there's a mechanistic view of
- 17:26Speaker 4: man associated with with Newtonianism, although doing themselves held but
- 17:32Speaker 4: the idea like things are machines. We understand how machines work.
- 17:35Speaker 4: We understand matter as working by things pushing against each
- 17:38Speaker 4: other and colliding into one another and exerting forces on
- 17:41Speaker 4: one another, kind of like a clockwork, right, And we
- 17:43Speaker 4: understand how clockworks work. And we seem to be very
- 17:45Speaker 4: complicated things made of parts.
- 17:47Speaker 2: Like this, and so shouldn't we be, you.
- 17:51Speaker 4: Know, like machines like clockworks, in which case we would
- 17:53Speaker 4: be determined by what our parts do. And that tends
- 17:58Speaker 4: to go with although I don't actually think the right
- 18:00Speaker 4: way of understanding machines thinking of causation as a kind
- 18:03Speaker 4: of mapping from past states to future states. This was
- 18:08Speaker 4: the past and this is the next, kid, and you
- 18:09Speaker 4: think about how a system evolves through states, and you
- 18:12Speaker 4: think about causality that way that I think is view
- 18:16Speaker 4: of causation is very associated with Hume, but it's not
- 18:20Speaker 4: new with you. Kant when he comes on the scene,
- 18:24Speaker 4: wants to save sacrifice and wants to save morality, and
- 18:29Speaker 4: part of that is insisting that we have choice. But
- 18:35Speaker 4: he associates choice with God and immortality, with these three
- 18:41Speaker 4: things that you have to believe exist, God, immortality, and
- 18:45Speaker 4: free will in order to function morally and sacrifice yourself,
- 18:48Speaker 4: though you can't have any evidence that they exist and
- 18:51Speaker 4: can't know they exist from looking out at the world.
- 18:53Speaker 4: And so he has this kind of area where he
- 18:55Speaker 4: makes room for mysticism. And then these things are in
- 18:58Speaker 4: this area that you have to be missed about the
- 19:00Speaker 4: real you, not that you can observe, but the U
- 19:02Speaker 4: as exists outside of space and time, must have choice,
- 19:06Speaker 4: and also must be immortal and so forth, or at
- 19:09Speaker 4: least you're entitled to believe that, and you have to
- 19:11Speaker 4: believe it in order to function. You're entitled to believe
- 19:14Speaker 4: it because you can't know it's false, and you're entitled
- 19:16Speaker 4: to because you need it to function and to function morally.
- 19:19Speaker 4: So with that kind of company God in immortality and
- 19:23Speaker 4: a world you can't know anything about, free will isn't
- 19:25Speaker 4: fairly poor company. And that's one reason why it's been
- 19:30Speaker 4: less less believed in by scientifically minded people. I think,
- 19:34Speaker 4: since it's also more generally the way we think about
- 19:39Speaker 4: science is fairly materialistic, and that's associated with it anile
- 19:46Speaker 4: of free will. Although fundamentally, you know, the main reasons
- 19:52Speaker 4: historically for why people haven't believed in free will have
- 19:55Speaker 4: been theological. God knows everything, God controls everything, then you
- 19:59Speaker 4: don't have any choice. Think. The way that it's the
- 20:02Speaker 4: denial of free will has come into science has actually
- 20:04Speaker 4: been through the secularization of some religiously motivated errors, including
- 20:11Speaker 4: religiously motivated ways of thinking about causality. But that's a
- 20:14Speaker 4: kind of fairly deep issue in the philosophy of science.
- 20:16Speaker 4: But it's infected how we think about cause and effect
- 20:19Speaker 4: in the physical realm, and it's made it more natural
- 20:22Speaker 4: to just think of science as going with determinism.
- 20:26Speaker 3: So probably the most prominent intellectual out there who talks
- 20:30Speaker 3: a lot about free will or the lack of it,
- 20:32Speaker 3: is Sam has And yet Sam is quite modelistic. He's
- 20:38Speaker 3: constantly trying to convince us that he's right about specific issues.
- 20:42Speaker 3: Sometimes he's very good, sometimes he's terrible, but he's he's
- 20:46Speaker 3: always adamant about his position and quite consistent.
- 20:51Speaker 1: How do you, how do you do?
- 20:52Speaker 2: How do you?
- 20:53Speaker 3: How does somebody like that hold that in their mind?
- 20:55Speaker 3: On the one hand, he's trying to convince you of something.
- 20:58Speaker 3: On the other hand, he's denying your ability to choose
- 21:01Speaker 3: well part.
- 21:02Speaker 2: Of what goes.
- 21:09Speaker 4: There's another term here, which is do do you think
- 21:12Speaker 4: that ideas matter? And ultimately, I think to consistently understand
- 21:18Speaker 4: how ideas matter and what role they have in our lives,
- 21:21Speaker 4: you have to believe in free will. Do you know
- 21:24Speaker 4: fully consistently do it? But there's a real difference between
- 21:28Speaker 4: people who believe that human beings are run by ideas
- 21:32Speaker 4: run by culture, which are ideas we run ourselves by culture,
- 21:36Speaker 4: by the ideas we share and so forth, and people
- 21:39Speaker 4: who think that we're run by.
- 21:42Speaker 2: Genetic urge is.
- 21:43Speaker 4: But the differences between people aren't ideological cultural, And Harris
- 21:48Speaker 4: has a real appreciation for the role of ideas in life.
- 21:51Speaker 4: He just tends to think of ideas more like software. Right,
- 21:55Speaker 4: you know, you've downloaded objectivism, and someone else has downloaded Islam,
- 21:58Speaker 4: and that explains why he's, you know, blowing him or
- 22:01Speaker 4: you know, Islamism forms a form of Islam, and that
- 22:05Speaker 4: explains why he's blowing himself up and you're not. And
- 22:07Speaker 4: then there's another guy who's what was downloaded into him
- 22:11Speaker 4: wasn't Islamism, but it was a.
- 22:13Speaker 2: Form of Islam.
- 22:13Speaker 4: That makes him more of a sanctioner of the Islamist
- 22:16Speaker 4: and so forth. But someone else's and it's you you
- 22:19Speaker 4: think of it as sort of software that's downloaded or
- 22:21Speaker 4: memes that are spread between people.
- 22:24Speaker 2: And in that sense, you're thinking.
- 22:25Speaker 4: Of it at a certain level of depth, as you
- 22:28Speaker 4: know it's it's still deterministic, it's not free will.
- 22:30Speaker 2: But nevertheless, there's a real.
- 22:34Speaker 4: Enthusiasm in Harris and and and a caring about the
- 22:37Speaker 4: ideas people hold. And I think implicit in that and
- 22:41Speaker 4: implicit in what he's doing to fight for them, is
- 22:44Speaker 4: a recognition that he's thinking about these ideas and he
- 22:46Speaker 4: has a kind of choice about it. But that could
- 22:48Speaker 4: be subtle noticing that, and you can notice and care
- 22:52Speaker 4: about ideas without understanding them is chosen in that way,
- 22:57Speaker 4: you can notice and care about consciousness without noticing fully
- 23:01Speaker 4: the role of choice. And Harris is someone who cares
- 23:03Speaker 4: a lot about consciousness, right like he's a in a way,
- 23:05Speaker 4: he's kind of a mystic in some way to do
- 23:07Speaker 4: with consciousness.
- 23:08Speaker 2: But he's not a materialist.
- 23:10Speaker 4: He's definitely someone who believes there's a mind and the
- 23:12Speaker 4: mind is powerful that it's not he doesn't quite believe
- 23:17Speaker 4: there's a self because he's but but ideas and you know,
- 23:20Speaker 4: ideas matter to him, and that's a kind of motivation
- 23:25Speaker 4: that I think, like any motivation to be consistent, ultimately,
- 23:27Speaker 4: you need free will in the mix.
- 23:29Speaker 2: But he's orientation again.
- 23:33Speaker 4: His stories good ideas versus bad ideas, ideas that lead
- 23:35Speaker 4: to good lives and success and peace and so forth,
- 23:38Speaker 4: versus ideas that lead to misery and war.
- 23:42Speaker 2: And that's why he's so good on the issues. He's
- 23:45Speaker 2: good on landing. Yep.
- 23:47Speaker 3: So another intellec told has come to prominence the last
- 23:51Speaker 3: couple of years is Richat Hannania, who is a real mix.
- 23:56Speaker 3: I mean he's sometimes strikes is brilliant, really in sight,
- 24:00Speaker 3: fault and original and original thinker actually, and sometimes it's
- 24:05Speaker 3: just this stupid thing I mean things that strike strike
- 24:07Speaker 3: is really just dumb.
- 24:11Speaker 1: How do you evaluate him?
- 24:12Speaker 3: And and do you think the issue of free will
- 24:16Speaker 3: plays a role in in in his thinking?
- 24:19Speaker 4: Yeah? I mean I think the fundamental problem with him
- 24:22Speaker 4: when where he's wrong is that he doesn't believe in
- 24:24Speaker 4: free will. And I don't know whether he would say
- 24:27Speaker 4: he does or doesn't, but he also doesn't believe that
- 24:30Speaker 4: ideas matter properly. So the way I think of Hananya
- 24:35Speaker 4: is he's someone who really values intelligence and reason, although
- 24:43Speaker 4: he has those two things packaged together. He's not very
- 24:45Speaker 4: clear around the difference between someone who's you know, maybe
- 24:48Speaker 4: not that innately powerful of mind, but really being rational
- 24:52Speaker 4: and uh, and.
- 24:53Speaker 2: Someone who's.
- 24:57Speaker 4: Uh, you know, he doesn't have the choice and the
- 24:59Speaker 4: the the rational and the intelligence component as distinguished as
- 25:05Speaker 4: I think they ought to be. But he's someone who
- 25:07Speaker 4: really values intelligent, rational people and is really disgusted by stupid,
- 25:14Speaker 4: irrational pointlessness in a way that High certainly have always
- 25:18Speaker 4: been as a child, and that I clearly i Rand was,
- 25:20Speaker 4: and you could see this valorization of intelligence and rationality
- 25:24Speaker 4: and the things not being fully distinguished always in her work,
- 25:28Speaker 4: in his work, I think, and a lot of us
- 25:30Speaker 4: who gravitated towards objectivism in our sense of life as
- 25:34Speaker 4: children reason and human beings. And we can do this
- 25:37Speaker 4: versus you know, that guy over there who can't think
- 25:40Speaker 4: or won't think, or something. He just seems like like
- 25:42Speaker 4: like a brick, you know, or or like functioning like
- 25:44Speaker 4: a beast. And I think for Hanania that contrast is
- 25:48Speaker 4: really salient. It's what he has in mind by high
- 25:51Speaker 4: versus low human capital, which he talks about a lot,
- 25:54Speaker 4: and and and in so far as he's interested in
- 25:57Speaker 4: ideas and cultural systems. It's which ones will apply, will
- 26:00Speaker 4: appeal to, and encourage how human capital versus which ones
- 26:03Speaker 4: low human capital. But there's not really the idea of
- 26:09Speaker 4: attending to what are the ideas someone holds and what
- 26:13Speaker 4: are the choices they're making? And what's just that some
- 26:16Speaker 4: people are smarter than others, And they're not totally separate,
- 26:20Speaker 4: of course, because if you choose well and think well,
- 26:25Speaker 4: over time you develop better ideas and the ideas empower
- 26:28Speaker 4: you to come up with smarter conclusions. So it's not
- 26:30Speaker 4: like intelligence, you know, functional intelligence is totally separate from
- 26:33Speaker 4: the choices you're making. They're what manifests this intelligence. And
- 26:37Speaker 4: someone you meet is always a choice infused, an idea infused.
- 26:42Speaker 4: But he tends to treat it as one thing and
- 26:47Speaker 4: not to be alert to the issue of choice, and
- 26:51Speaker 4: to be less alert to the issue of ideas in
- 26:53Speaker 4: life than I think he ought to be. And for
- 26:56Speaker 4: both of those reasons he's but especially the not emphasizing
- 27:00Speaker 4: of choice and the choice to be rational versus the
- 27:03Speaker 4: irrational people. He is generally not moralistic, and you could
- 27:06Speaker 4: see it. He was at one time a racist, and
- 27:08Speaker 4: you could see where the racism was coming from. Right,
- 27:11Speaker 4: there's a lot of He thinks of himself as smart,
- 27:13Speaker 4: he thinks of it as genetic. He thinks, you know,
- 27:16Speaker 4: a lot of people are telling us to sacrifice and
- 27:19Speaker 4: tear down standards because and people of other races are
- 27:25Speaker 4: seen as beneficiaries of that, whether they really are or not.
- 27:27Speaker 4: And he's read books like the Dull Curve and other
- 27:29Speaker 4: things like that, and he's come to associate intelligence with
- 27:32Speaker 4: some racism, not with others, and so then he, you know,
- 27:35Speaker 4: becomes a racist, right. He rejects that eventually, not because
- 27:41Speaker 4: he doesn't think there are any average differences in intelligence,
- 27:44Speaker 4: so I think, because I think he still probably.
- 27:45Speaker 2: Does, but because.
- 27:49Speaker 4: Like most white people aren't that good and aren't that bright,
- 27:52Speaker 4: and some black people are. And anyway, the kind of
- 27:54Speaker 4: policies that are associated with one or the other are
- 27:57Speaker 4: manon he becomes convinced of liberalism and free markets and
- 27:59Speaker 4: so forth, but he doesn't, and he regards some of
- 28:03Speaker 4: his old views as odios, right, And he wrote a
- 28:06Speaker 4: piece on them called something like why I used to suck.
- 28:09Speaker 2: But notice it's why I used to suck.
- 28:10Speaker 4: There's no like, how did I make this mistake, and
- 28:12Speaker 4: he does talk a little bit about what led him
- 28:14Speaker 4: into that mistake and so forth, but it's all like
- 28:17Speaker 4: this kind of thing befell me. There was no taking
- 28:20Speaker 4: responsibility for making a bad choice or for the consequences
- 28:23Speaker 4: of his bad ideas on other people.
- 28:26Speaker 2: If he were promoting these kinds of ideas and if.
- 28:28Speaker 4: He's using his intelligence, is making a case for really
- 28:32Speaker 4: odious ideas, and maybe that would have, you know, gotten
- 28:34Speaker 4: other bright people to follow it. Now I think he's
- 28:37Speaker 4: made up for that now, but he's you know, using
- 28:39Speaker 4: his l make the case for a.
- 28:40Speaker 2: Lot of good ideas.
- 28:41Speaker 4: But there's still no sense of personal responsibility in it.
- 28:44Speaker 4: It's all.
- 28:47Speaker 2: He writes, you know, more deterministically.
- 28:51Speaker 1: Right, so too in his.
- 28:53Speaker 4: View of associations, right, like there's a lot wrong with MAGA,
- 28:56Speaker 4: but that's not a reason not to vote for Trump, and.
- 29:00Speaker 2: And how he looks about the Ukraine situation and so forth.
- 29:04Speaker 3: He interviews racists regular in a show. He will give
- 29:07Speaker 3: them a platform, that is, he platforms people he finds odious.
- 29:12Speaker 4: Yeah, although there there's some idea that maybe like he's
- 29:17Speaker 4: a vector back to sanity or back to reasonability, like
- 29:20Speaker 4: he could make this journey and maybe some of these
- 29:22Speaker 4: people clear, but still there's no whatever the view is,
- 29:26Speaker 4: there's no.
- 29:30Speaker 2: Moral ire around any of this.
- 29:33Speaker 4: He has discussed reactions to ideas that he views as awful, bad, wrong,
- 29:38Speaker 4: He'll he'll mock them, you'll you'll hear the contempt in
- 29:41Speaker 4: his tone of writing and so forth, But there's not
- 29:44Speaker 4: a blaming. There's no moral fire to it.
- 29:47Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 29:49Speaker 3: Do you think these deterministic views part of what seems
- 29:55Speaker 3: like a real rise of anti semitism and.
- 30:01Speaker 1: Racism. I mean we've I think.
- 30:03Speaker 3: We've talked about it on the left, but now on
- 30:05Speaker 3: the right, which kind of where its home is I
- 30:08Speaker 3: guess in the past, But this seems to be Joe
- 30:12Speaker 3: Rogan's now interviewing explicit anti Semites and defend, and of
- 30:15Speaker 3: course Tackle Cass has been doing it for a while.
- 30:19Speaker 4: I don't think it's the rise of anti semitism or
- 30:23Speaker 4: explicit racism is associated with an increasing popularity of explicit determinism.
- 30:31Speaker 4: That is, if you you asked all of these people,
- 30:36Speaker 4: if you ask you know, is their free will or
- 30:39Speaker 4: are we determined ten or twenty years ago when you
- 30:42Speaker 4: asked it now? I don't think there'd be a huge shift,
- 30:45Speaker 4: or that the shift would correspond to who has gotten
- 30:48Speaker 4: more racist, But it's racism is a deterministic way of thinking,
- 30:54Speaker 4: and it's a way of thinking that doesn't value reason
- 30:58Speaker 4: and individuality.
- 30:59Speaker 2: And I think it's not changes on the.
- 31:05Speaker 4: Explicit understanding of the metaphysical issues, but people less seeing
- 31:09Speaker 4: themselves as individuals, less valuing reason, being more afraid, and
- 31:12Speaker 4: more retreating into tribes. That's, on the one hand, and
- 31:17Speaker 4: on the other hand, a lessening of some stigmas against it,
- 31:21Speaker 4: but a big part of it. And this does relate
- 31:24Speaker 4: to free will. It is not the explicit view of
- 31:28Speaker 4: whether one has free will, but the extent to which
- 31:31Speaker 4: one thinks of oneself as an agent. Another way of putting,
- 31:34Speaker 4: to the extent to which one has self esteem, the
- 31:36Speaker 4: extent to which one feels effications in the world and
- 31:39Speaker 4: able to create things and control one's destiny. Whatever one
- 31:42Speaker 4: would explicitly say about how much control anyone has. Do
- 31:46Speaker 4: you feel capable, do you feel able? Do you feel
- 31:48Speaker 4: like you could exert yourself to achieve something? Or do
- 31:50Speaker 4: you feel like a victim of the universe? And the
- 31:53Speaker 4: more you feel like a victim of the universe, And
- 31:55Speaker 4: maybe it's a victim of those guys in the universe,
- 31:57Speaker 4: and and they're in a cabal and so forth, the
- 31:59Speaker 4: more various forms of tribalism uh uh dominate and uh
- 32:05Speaker 4: and anti Semitism is just one of the ugly forms
- 32:08Speaker 4: of it.
- 32:10Speaker 1: So so I did a show a few days ago
- 32:13Speaker 1: on explaining Trump, and you know, I think a lot
- 32:21Speaker 1: of people thought I was pretty harsh on him.
- 32:23Speaker 3: But but you found me to be too generous, uh,
- 32:29Speaker 3: in terms of my arguing that Trump is a is
- 32:33Speaker 3: the the ultimate pragmatist. So why is pragmatism too generous
- 32:37Speaker 3: and indeed inaccurate in in in describing him?
- 32:41Speaker 1: And how would you describe him to be more accurate?
- 32:44Speaker 4: Well, when I think of a pragmatist politician, I think,
- 32:50Speaker 4: in one way, the ultimate example is John F.
- 32:52Speaker 2: Kennedy. That was Rand's kind of example of it.
- 32:54Speaker 4: And then in another way, at a lower rung of
- 32:57Speaker 4: intellectual sophistication, it's people like Richard Dixon and Lindon Johnson
- 33:05Speaker 4: and Barack Obama for that matter, that he's a little
- 33:07Speaker 4: bit more like Kennedy. What is what is pragmatism? Well,
- 33:11Speaker 4: pragmatism is a philosophical theory about in the first one
- 33:19Speaker 4: about the role of ideas in life and the role
- 33:22Speaker 4: of truth in life. And it's a kind of fairly
- 33:24Speaker 4: sophisticated theory in in in an Atlas shrug, you can
- 33:28Speaker 4: think of Floyd Ferriss as a kind of pragmatist in
- 33:30Speaker 4: a way. He has views about these esoteric you know, matters,
- 33:34Speaker 4: and and he's got a whole, whole, you know, complicated
- 33:38Speaker 4: line about it and theories about human motivation and what
- 33:41Speaker 4: a person is, and what the role of truth in
- 33:42Speaker 4: life is and how ideas really are blah blah blah.
- 33:45Speaker 4: And a politician who has that in the real world
- 33:47Speaker 4: would be Kennedy. What what what the ideas amount to is?
- 33:52Speaker 4: It's the idea that ideas aren't important, but you could
- 33:55Speaker 4: hold it as a a a theory and and you know,
- 33:59Speaker 4: complicated ways of explaining away and trying to undermine ideas.
- 34:03Speaker 2: And that's what Rand.
- 34:04Speaker 4: Thought Kennedy was doing in a lot of his speeches.
- 34:06Speaker 4: It's what a lot of philosophy professors and psychology professors
- 34:09Speaker 4: have done. You're you're an intellectual, but you're aimed at
- 34:13Speaker 4: the mind and at undermining abstract thinking. As an intellectual
- 34:18Speaker 4: mattere of theory is about how to do that. That's
- 34:19Speaker 4: what practiced him in the kind of most specific senses.
- 34:22Speaker 4: Then there's a kind of thing which is a lower
- 34:25Speaker 4: order pragmatist. Think someone like Richard Nixon, who rand often
- 34:29Speaker 4: described as a practist. He is not a philosopher with
- 34:34Speaker 4: kind of very abstract ideas about how to undermine the mind.
- 34:37Speaker 4: But he's the sort of immediate offspring of that. He's
- 34:43Speaker 4: someone who is engaged in real politics. He's but engaged
- 34:50Speaker 4: in real politics as a theory, right, Like he thinks
- 34:52Speaker 4: this is the way to understand things, and other ones
- 34:54Speaker 4: are wrong, and he's dissembling in certain ways, and he's
- 34:59Speaker 4: a dealmaker and so forth, but has a view about
- 35:03Speaker 4: this as one approach in contrast to others, and there
- 35:07Speaker 4: is a kind of some level of understanding of a
- 35:10Speaker 4: principled approach and trying to undermine it. If understanding is
- 35:15Speaker 4: he's strong at least cognizance of it. You can think
- 35:17Speaker 4: of mister Thompson and Atlas Shrugged as this kind of
- 35:19Speaker 4: a pragmatist. Or I think really all of our presidents
- 35:23Speaker 4: after JFK have been this kind of a pragmatist.
- 35:26Speaker 2: There.
- 35:27Speaker 4: They're erudite, thoughtful, people, but they're skeptical of abstract principles.
- 35:32Speaker 4: They tend to be kind of wonkish, and they'll drown
- 35:35Speaker 4: you in details about how it doesn't really work the
- 35:37Speaker 4: way you think it works if you have some abstract principle.
- 35:39Speaker 4: But Trump isn't like that. He's not wonkish or thoughtful
- 35:43Speaker 4: even about why you shouldn't be thoughtful. He's not someone
- 35:46Speaker 4: with you know, some complicated rap uh to tell you
- 35:50Speaker 4: about the role of ideas in life, or even some
- 35:54Speaker 4: complicated rap to tell you about his policies. He's much
- 35:57Speaker 4: more like a brute. He's much more like a his
- 36:00Speaker 4: Khan or a till of the Han. I mean, we
- 36:01Speaker 4: don't know what these people actually like, but what the
- 36:03Speaker 4: stereotype of them is. He's much more like you described
- 36:06Speaker 4: him as a mafioso or a corner loud.
- 36:09Speaker 2: It's that kind of thinking. An outlets shrugged.
- 36:10Speaker 4: He's much more like Cuffee Megs, and Cuffey Megs looks
- 36:13Speaker 4: at Dadney like he doesn't get her, like he doesn't
- 36:18Speaker 4: even think of her as someone to make a deal
- 36:19Speaker 4: with her, to try to manipulate She's just he's he's
- 36:25Speaker 4: mister five. It has no comprehension, he's a much lower
- 36:29Speaker 4: level of person, and he's not that kind of person.
- 36:32Speaker 2: I don't think is the product of bad ideas.
- 36:36Speaker 4: That's kind of like the dregs of society that's always
- 36:39Speaker 4: been there. It's the product of certain kinds of ideas
- 36:41Speaker 4: that they're elevated and can be in a position of
- 36:44Speaker 4: national prominence, whether in business or in politics. But it's
- 36:49Speaker 4: it's just a very different thing. And if you look
- 36:51Speaker 4: at for example, Mark and Dreesen talking about why he
- 36:57Speaker 4: would support Trump and what he'd know, there are some
- 37:00Speaker 4: things Mark Indac says in this contact that makes sense
- 37:02Speaker 4: and stiff for then I.
- 37:03Speaker 2: Could, but but others things that are quite bad.
- 37:05Speaker 4: But what he's doing is he's being he's got a
- 37:07Speaker 4: view about it, and the view about it is why
- 37:09Speaker 4: it's okay to deal with this kind of guy in
- 37:11Speaker 4: this way, Why he's better. That's pragmat that's pragmatist thinking.
- 37:16Speaker 4: But you know, if you want to, you know, give
- 37:18Speaker 4: a toddler a bazuka and think that that's going to
- 37:21Speaker 4: help you get the criminals out of your house or something,
- 37:23Speaker 4: you're the pragmatist, not the toddler.
- 37:25Speaker 1: He's you know, he just is what he is.
- 37:29Speaker 4: Yeah, and it's and now in the case of someone
- 37:32Speaker 4: like Trump or someone like a mafioso, they're that way
- 37:34Speaker 4: by choice, and they're they're blameable for it. But the
- 37:38Speaker 4: thing they are by choice is a lot less of
- 37:41Speaker 4: a sophisticated thing than what I think of as a pragmatist.
- 37:45Speaker 1: Do you think there's Do you think there's elements of
- 37:47Speaker 1: nihilism there?
- 37:48Speaker 2: Oh, yeah, for sure.
- 37:50Speaker 4: I think there are some elements of nihilism in pragmatism generally,
- 37:54Speaker 4: but less then this is it's a kind of you know,
- 38:02Speaker 4: if you're there's a a real My view of Trump
- 38:10Speaker 4: is very, very low. I don't think the man has
- 38:13Speaker 4: any values at all, and I think he's only driven
- 38:17Speaker 4: by resentment for people who seem better than him, or
- 38:20Speaker 4: seem to think they're better than him. I think that
- 38:22Speaker 4: is the kind of basic thing that's driven him for
- 38:25Speaker 4: as long as I have kind of seen him at
- 38:27Speaker 4: some points A prestige secret but even the prestige seeking
- 38:30Speaker 4: is this. You know, I'm from from the outer boroughs
- 38:35Speaker 4: and I want to show that the people from Manhattan
- 38:37Speaker 4: are many better than me, but not show it by
- 38:39Speaker 4: actually accomplishing something. Just you know in their face about it.
- 38:42Speaker 4: I think he's that kind of really low loudish person.
- 38:45Speaker 4: I mean, these are we're going into details of his biography,
- 38:49Speaker 4: and I think what you see in his public presentation
- 38:53Speaker 4: has always always been that. And I think that is
- 38:57Speaker 4: a kind of nehilistic type of motivation, not elisabeth A theory,
- 39:01Speaker 4: but just a kind of motivation that's around resentment of hate. Yeah,
- 39:08Speaker 4: motivation that's involved in the people who you know, want
- 39:12Speaker 4: to burn down their own neighborhoods out of some grievance
- 39:15Speaker 4: they have against the society. Maybe there's something to the
- 39:17Speaker 4: grievance in some way, but truly, really thinking about what's
- 39:21Speaker 4: best for you is not that I can't lead to this,
- 39:22Speaker 4: and I think it's the same kind of mentality.
- 39:27Speaker 3: All right, So we have a lot of questions, so
- 39:29Speaker 3: let's go to those and then if we have time,
- 39:32Speaker 3: we can come back to a few other topics and
- 39:35Speaker 3: maybe make sure we end on a positive note. All right,
- 39:40Speaker 3: So let's say we got Molten's Splendor.
- 39:44Speaker 1: Yeah, that's.
- 39:47Speaker 3: I found outspoken malo judgment uncomfortable. That's surprising from somebody
- 39:52Speaker 3: who with a name like Molten's Splendor. What situations require
- 39:57Speaker 3: that outspoken malo judgments be At what point is silence
- 40:02Speaker 3: considered acceptable considered acceptance because am all judgment is not
- 40:08Speaker 3: openly made.
- 40:12Speaker 4: Well, it's in a situation where your silence would imply
- 40:19Speaker 4: acceptance or consent by the social.
- 40:23Speaker 2: Milieure that you're in.
- 40:24Speaker 4: So, you know, if you're one person in a lecture
- 40:27Speaker 4: hall and there are thousands of people in the audience
- 40:29Speaker 4: and someone on stage says something you disagree with, nobody
- 40:31Speaker 4: could possibly you know you're you're not speaking up, doesn't
- 40:37Speaker 4: communicate anything. But if you're you know, talking one on
- 40:44Speaker 4: one with somebody and he's saying something that you find
- 40:47Speaker 4: abhorrent and looking at you as though you agree with him,
- 40:51Speaker 4: then you're not saying anything to de mirror does suggest
- 40:54Speaker 4: you agree with him?
- 40:55Speaker 2: Or again, there's a kind of person.
- 40:59Speaker 4: I had a particular person in high school who is
- 41:00Speaker 4: a bit like this, and I have some relatives who
- 41:02Speaker 4: are a bit like this who they'll start making undermining jokes
- 41:07Speaker 4: about people. And at first it might just be a joke,
- 41:11Speaker 4: you know, and it might just be fine and not
- 41:12Speaker 4: ill intentioned, but but they escalate a little bit like
- 41:15Speaker 4: they're looking for, like what can they get can they
- 41:17Speaker 4: enlist you on their side, and at some.
- 41:19Speaker 2: Point what you're doing is not is.
- 41:23Speaker 4: What they're doing is they're looking for a kind of
- 41:25Speaker 4: agreement or sanction from you. And at some point, you know,
- 41:30Speaker 4: it's always contemptual to judge where it is, but at
- 41:32Speaker 4: some point you're helping them, you're supporting them when you're
- 41:35Speaker 4: not saying otherwise, And.
- 41:39Speaker 2: Saying otherwise is not always a making a federal case
- 41:43Speaker 2: of it.
- 41:44Speaker 4: You say, no, I really disagree with that, I don't
- 41:47Speaker 4: think that's true, or I don't think that's right, And
- 41:50Speaker 4: you know that's often enough. You don't have to get
- 41:53Speaker 4: on a soapbox. Now, there are other situations. You're you know,
- 41:58Speaker 4: a business person, you're being persecuted, there's something really evil
- 42:01Speaker 4: going on, and we.
- 42:02Speaker 2: Have to go through the different situation.
- 42:04Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, and you know it's it's it's worth introspecting
- 42:08Speaker 3: about why you find it's so uncomfortable. It is uncomfortable
- 42:11Speaker 3: in the culture in which we live, which is a
- 42:14Speaker 3: culture of non judgmental often, but it's worth thinking about
- 42:19Speaker 3: why it is, what it is about it that makes
- 42:21Speaker 3: you uncomfortable.
- 42:23Speaker 4: Yeah, and in what forms you can first become comfortable with,
- 42:26Speaker 4: like and what forms you can start exercising this that
- 42:29Speaker 4: are showing that whatever bad thing you think will happen
- 42:33Speaker 4: when you express your judgments don't happen, and that there
- 42:36Speaker 4: are ways to do it. That may be because you
- 42:39Speaker 4: might have or your your models of somebody expressing the
- 42:41Speaker 4: moral judgment might be, you know, not good ones or
- 42:45Speaker 4: not ones that would work well for you to do
- 42:46Speaker 4: given your personality or situation. But the more you try
- 42:49Speaker 4: to do it, like anything else you're afraid of, you
- 42:53Speaker 4: you know, build up the skills to do it and
- 42:56Speaker 4: the recognitiontive and it's something you know, we can all
- 42:59Speaker 4: work on, all.
- 43:01Speaker 3: Right, not ya alvich algorithm. Juran said in today's show
- 43:07Speaker 3: that a small subset of people would die under pure capitalism,
- 43:12Speaker 3: and he's okay with that. Did you mean, I guess
- 43:15Speaker 3: you're asking me, did you mean wife beating drunks?
- 43:19Speaker 1: Generally? I have a low view of foid feeding drunks
- 43:22Speaker 1: or people with down syndrome.
- 43:23Speaker 3: Why is donating to a home for retarded not necessarily altruistic?
- 43:33Speaker 2: Was that? Which of us is for that? Is?
- 43:37Speaker 4: I mean, first of all, I have to say I
- 43:38Speaker 4: have a much more extreme view than you're on under this,
- 43:40Speaker 4: I think everybody would die under capitalism, just like everybody
- 43:43Speaker 4: would die under every system.
- 43:45Speaker 2: We're not immortal.
- 43:45Speaker 4: Under capitalism, there's some chance of some chance for life extension.
- 43:49Speaker 4: But I think everyone will someday die, But you mean
- 43:53Speaker 4: will die earlier, younger, not be helped of.
- 43:58Speaker 3: I mean, I find I find the arguments that sometimes
- 44:00Speaker 3: I see objectivists make a utopian in the negative sense
- 44:06Speaker 3: that it's under capitalism everybody's better off, nobody is worse off,
- 44:10Speaker 3: and nobody worse off in a physical sense. Let's say
- 44:13Speaker 3: nobody would die, everybody would be.
- 44:15Speaker 1: Rich, and I find that particulous.
- 44:17Speaker 3: I mean, some people are still going to be unbelievably
- 44:20Speaker 3: emol and in a sense kill themselves, and the safety
- 44:25Speaker 3: net would be more discerning and might purposefully not catch
- 44:29Speaker 3: them in those circumstances.
- 44:33Speaker 4: And so that's a very different case from the people
- 44:35Speaker 4: with bouncing, the escal handicaps, things like that, who you
- 44:40Speaker 4: would expect there would be.
- 44:42Speaker 2: There's every reason to.
- 44:46Speaker 4: Want to help such people when one can do it
- 44:50Speaker 4: at low cost. I mean, there's all upside and no
- 44:52Speaker 4: downside for everyone involved, for their lives going better, for
- 44:57Speaker 4: they're not starving on the street, for they're being able
- 45:00Speaker 4: to make whatever they can of their lives given their limitations,
- 45:04Speaker 4: and so you would expect there to be you know,
- 45:08Speaker 4: people as there are and have been.
- 45:11Speaker 2: Wanting to do what they can to help them.
- 45:14Speaker 3: Yeah, and I think what makes it non altruistic is
- 45:16Speaker 3: all the everything Greg just said.
- 45:20Speaker 1: And think about it.
- 45:22Speaker 3: The first people who would be donating to such causes
- 45:24Speaker 3: are the family members, and in a relatively wealthy society,
- 45:30Speaker 3: such donations.
- 45:32Speaker 1: Could might be enough. It might not.
- 45:34Speaker 3: Acquire massive contributions from a lot of other people, even
- 45:38Speaker 3: though they might be a lot of other people who
- 45:40Speaker 3: would be quite happy to do it, given the horror
- 45:46Speaker 3: of what would happen to these people if they weren't
- 45:49Speaker 3: taking care of.
- 45:50Speaker 4: But also, this is not how one judges a society.
- 45:54Speaker 4: This is a fairly small part of society. And if
- 45:57Speaker 4: other things are functioning well, the problems that sets people
- 46:03Speaker 4: insofar as they're they can be remedy.
- 46:05Speaker 2: It will be remedy.
- 46:06Speaker 4: It's not the thing to focus on in society.
- 46:11Speaker 1: Uh Dave.
- 46:13Speaker 3: Some humans have neural disabilities which make them incapable of
- 46:18Speaker 3: self reliance for survival. How does such humans differ from
- 46:21Speaker 3: non human animals that depend on humans for survival.
- 46:28Speaker 2: Non human animals that depend like pets.
- 46:31Speaker 3: Yeah, so what makes these people human versus animals that
- 46:36Speaker 3: are not human?
- 46:37Speaker 4: Yeah, but I mean most animals that are not human,
- 46:39Speaker 4: you know, go off and survive on their own wild
- 46:41Speaker 4: They don't need people like you see, it would be a
- 46:43Speaker 4: goldfish or a pet or something.
- 46:47Speaker 2: Well, first of all, human beings are a species, right.
- 46:50Speaker 4: It's not that you define human beings as rational animal
- 46:53Speaker 4: and then you go around to everything in the universe
- 46:56Speaker 4: and you see, is it rational animal, then it's human.
- 46:58Speaker 4: If it is, it is, and if it's it's not
- 47:00Speaker 4: that it doesn't have a functioning faculty of reason. A
- 47:04Speaker 4: human being is human being is a certain species of animal,
- 47:08Speaker 4: differentiated by other species of animal by being the one
- 47:11Speaker 4: that lives by reason, but that has you know, various
- 47:15Speaker 4: you know, rational faculties that it could use in certain ways.
- 47:18Speaker 4: But any life form exists in all kinds of injured, defective,
- 47:23Speaker 4: malformed states. It's it's again a fact about the species,
- 47:27Speaker 4: not a fact about everyone severally that they're this kind
- 47:31Speaker 4: of life form.
- 47:31Speaker 2: And then with respect to.
- 47:35Speaker 4: Moral principles and rights, the fact that we are this
- 47:38Speaker 4: kind of life form that lives by reason has implications
- 47:43Speaker 4: for how we should treat one another, and that those
- 47:46Speaker 4: implications are then going to spill over or are they're
- 47:49Speaker 4: going to apply, although in unusual ways, to people who,
- 47:53Speaker 4: because of injury or birth defect or whatever it is,
- 47:58Speaker 4: are not able to live by reason. For one thing
- 48:00Speaker 4: that I think the most kind of obvious point to
- 48:02Speaker 4: make is one has to know that somebody is really
- 48:07Speaker 4: and irremediably like this that is unable to live by
- 48:12Speaker 4: reason in order to treat them as though they don't
- 48:16Speaker 4: have reason right like the fact that they were a
- 48:17Speaker 4: human being. Means that we first have to if you know,
- 48:20Speaker 4: you see someone, think this is someone who could live
- 48:22Speaker 4: by reason, and I'm going to treat him, you know,
- 48:25Speaker 4: respect his choice and try to deal with him by persuasion,
- 48:28Speaker 4: et cetera until I have very good reason not here.
- 48:31Speaker 4: And as a legal system, we're going to have to
- 48:33Speaker 4: have that default. And then you have to prove, well,
- 48:35Speaker 4: this person's incapacitated or whatever or you know, it goes
- 48:38Speaker 4: by age like children canton. But that you know, we
- 48:41Speaker 4: make laws that about you know, when people reach an
- 48:44Speaker 4: age of majority and some but all of that is
- 48:46Speaker 4: in the context of it's a fact about human beings
- 48:49Speaker 4: as a species that here's how we live, and then
- 48:52Speaker 4: in light of that, you come up with principles and
- 48:54Speaker 4: means of interacting with individuals of that species that apply
- 48:58Speaker 4: that knowledge in light of everything else we know about
- 49:00Speaker 4: living species, which is that they could be immature, diseased, defective, infinessence,
- 49:07Speaker 4: or whatever the case may be for a given person.
- 49:11Speaker 1: Okay, Davos asks, do you think the assumption that all
- 49:14Speaker 1: humans have the cognitive capacity to develop abide by irrational
- 49:19Speaker 1: philosophy can be construed as stereotypical? Thanks so much for.
- 49:24Speaker 2: Your insight as stereotypical.
- 49:27Speaker 3: Stereotyping stereotyping humans and assuming they all have the ability
- 49:33Speaker 3: to be rational.
- 49:35Speaker 4: Well, only if you use any generalization as stereotyping. I mean,
- 49:41Speaker 4: any claim about a kind in general you can make
- 49:44Speaker 4: fun of as a stereotype or say it's just a stereotype.
- 49:47Speaker 4: But there are lots of things we know about human
- 49:49Speaker 4: beings in general. They all need protein, is that a stereotype?
- 49:53Speaker 4: Or they all need water in order to live like
- 49:55Speaker 4: all other animals do.
- 49:56Speaker 2: Is that a stereotype?
- 49:57Speaker 4: Or they have kidneys and brains and and so forth,
- 50:00Speaker 4: except for the ones who don't, which then you understand
- 50:03Speaker 4: is a special case.
- 50:04Speaker 2: Of defect and.
- 50:07Speaker 4: How I want to know more about why you're deriding
- 50:13Speaker 4: you know what, things would not count the stereotypes if
- 50:16Speaker 4: the fundamental fact about how we live and survive is
- 50:20Speaker 4: in your view.
- 50:21Speaker 3: Yeah, Barry asks where would you say consciousness comes from?
- 50:29Speaker 3: And how would you defend it? I think that's what
- 50:33Speaker 3: he's writing.
- 50:37Speaker 4: It seems to me a little bit like asking a
- 50:39Speaker 4: question like, where would you say with comes from and
- 50:42Speaker 4: how would you defend it? I've heard that everything has
- 50:45Speaker 4: length but no with, and you seem to be a
- 50:49Speaker 4: withist who believes that things have with as well as length,
- 50:52Speaker 4: or where would you say the width comes from? And
- 50:53Speaker 4: how would you defend it? There's something wrong with the question.
- 50:56Speaker 4: Things have with?
- 50:58Speaker 2: You could see that they have with, You could tell
- 50:59Speaker 2: that they have with.
- 51:00Speaker 4: Uh.
- 51:00Speaker 2: I don't know where it comes.
- 51:01Speaker 4: And it's part of the nature of things that things
- 51:03Speaker 4: have length and with and if we just think of
- 51:05Speaker 4: it as length, we're abstracting away the other thing we
- 51:08Speaker 4: know it has, which is with and depth.
- 51:10Speaker 2: And it's not something that uh, that needs to be
- 51:15Speaker 2: defended exactly.
- 51:16Speaker 4: It's it's it's not a theory that things have with
- 51:18Speaker 4: it's something that's observable about them, and like where what
- 51:22Speaker 4: makes you think they don't? And and what what things
- 51:25Speaker 4: are you taking as kind of basic that don't need
- 51:29Speaker 4: defense that and you're thinking that I'm adding with to
- 51:32Speaker 4: my list of things that it's going to have to
- 51:33Speaker 4: defend it.
- 51:33Speaker 2: It's it's perceptibly obvious, and think things have with.
- 51:37Speaker 4: You couldn't even understand what length was without contrasting it
- 51:40Speaker 4: with with and so forth. And consciousness is like that,
- 51:44Speaker 4: we wouldn't even be able to form a concept of
- 51:46Speaker 4: matter except by contrast to consciousness. We're directly aware of
- 51:51Speaker 4: our own consciousness. You couldn't think, and if you weren't conscious,
- 51:55Speaker 4: and you couldn't think about thinking and think about what
- 51:58Speaker 4: views are true and false and what things they to
- 52:00Speaker 4: be defended and have evidence.
- 52:01Speaker 2: For them or not.
- 52:02Speaker 4: If you didn't already know that there is consciousness, you're
- 52:05Speaker 4: kind of presupposing that in the whole way of thinking
- 52:07Speaker 4: about it. And then the questions is, yeah, but where
- 52:11Speaker 4: does it come from? Like how did it get to
- 52:13Speaker 4: be that there's consciousness in the world?
- 52:15Speaker 2: It may answer this, I don't know. I also don't know.
- 52:17Speaker 4: I don't know about a lot of things how they
- 52:19Speaker 4: got to be in the world. It seems to be
- 52:21Speaker 4: a feature. I mean, it is a feature of certain
- 52:23Speaker 4: living things. Presumably it came to be with them. There's
- 52:28Speaker 4: evidently a lot, a lot about matter that we don't understand,
- 52:33Speaker 4: such that when it forms part of certain systems, certain
- 52:39Speaker 4: kinds of living things, it comes to be conscious, or
- 52:42Speaker 4: consciousness arises.
- 52:43Speaker 2: We don't know why that is.
- 52:44Speaker 4: But there's a lot of stuff we don't know, and
- 52:46Speaker 4: you know, someday, hopefully we'll figure it out. Presumably there
- 52:48Speaker 4: are whatever fact it is about the things that make
- 52:52Speaker 4: us up that enable us to become conscious when they're
- 52:55Speaker 4: organized into the right kind of systems. Presumably there are
- 52:58Speaker 4: other implications of those facts that you know, we don't
- 53:01Speaker 4: yet understand, and someday we will, at least I hope
- 53:07Speaker 4: he will.
- 53:07Speaker 1: Somebody all right, a room asks, I enjoy beats and
- 53:13Speaker 1: sound design, driven techno music and associated late night raves.
- 53:20Speaker 1: These things give me spiritual fuel and optimism for my future.
- 53:25Speaker 1: Is this preference immoral? Ps? I also enjoy your money enough.
- 53:33Speaker 2: Okay, So what does he enjoy techno driven.
- 53:36Speaker 3: Techno music, the sound design, driven techno music, and associated
- 53:43Speaker 3: late night raves?
- 53:45Speaker 4: So ed M and stuff and he's you know, dancing
- 53:47Speaker 4: around and pumping his fist in the air or whatever it.
- 53:50Speaker 4: Uh No, I don't see what's immoral about that. I'm
- 53:56Speaker 4: sure you could fletch it out in a way that
- 53:58Speaker 4: would make it immoral, and we might, but I don't
- 54:00Speaker 4: think most people who are going to raves and listening
- 54:02Speaker 4: to dance music are indulging in anything im moral.
- 54:05Speaker 2: And even there's before that, there's a question as to.
- 54:11Speaker 4: What's the aesthetic quality of this stuff, and is there
- 54:15Speaker 4: some you know, are you wrong to think this is
- 54:17Speaker 4: good music?
- 54:18Speaker 2: Or or is there you know, are you missing out
- 54:20Speaker 2: or something.
- 54:21Speaker 4: But even if the answer to those things is yes,
- 54:23Speaker 4: this is bad music or not even music at all,
- 54:25Speaker 4: and you're missing out, you're not in moral for listening
- 54:30Speaker 4: to it if you like it, And maybe maybe there
- 54:32Speaker 4: were things you do to develop your taste, but maybe not,
- 54:34Speaker 4: and maybe this music is great.
- 54:36Speaker 2: So I gave a talk some years ago.
- 54:40Speaker 4: There was an okon that was themed around aesthetics and
- 54:43Speaker 4: the Romantic Manifesto, and I gave a talk on principles
- 54:47Speaker 4: and personal values in ethics and Aesthetics, which might have
- 54:52Speaker 4: been subtitled I know it's only rock and roll, but
- 54:54Speaker 4: I like it. And it was about the various things
- 54:59Speaker 4: that you can get from art that or part of
- 55:02Speaker 4: it was about the various things you can get from
- 55:04Speaker 4: art that aren't the kind of high values that are
- 55:09Speaker 4: being described in the Romantic Manifesto. And while you shouldn't
- 55:12Speaker 4: try to interpret whatever you like in terms of those
- 55:16Speaker 4: values directly, like getting motivation to pursue high value something
- 55:20Speaker 4: which I see a little bit of in this question.
- 55:23Speaker 4: And now you just with something you value, reflect on
- 55:26Speaker 4: while you value it, and try to articulate it to
- 55:28Speaker 4: yourself and see what you can get out of it,
- 55:30Speaker 4: and try to integrate it with your other values. And
- 55:33Speaker 4: the more you can do so, the better. And and
- 55:36Speaker 4: then it's an objective value. And if you find that
- 55:38Speaker 4: it clashes and and you know, then then it's.
- 55:42Speaker 2: Not an objective value.
- 55:46Speaker 1: Do you know if that talk is online?
- 55:49Speaker 4: I'm pretty sure it is. Okay, someone can find it
- 55:52Speaker 4: and link to it. You've got to an army of
- 55:54Speaker 4: people who do that.
- 55:55Speaker 2: In your.
- 55:58Speaker 1: Clock asks.
- 56:00Speaker 3: Do you see the Democrats coming back in twenty twenty
- 56:02Speaker 3: eight as a more nineteen nineties Bill Clinton esque party.
- 56:06Speaker 3: I just don't see them moving in a free market direction.
- 56:09Speaker 3: Maybe they'll drop the transgender stuff but maintain the socialism.
- 56:15Speaker 2: I don't know. I've been.
- 56:19Speaker 4: So in twenty sixteen, I thought that the Democrats were
- 56:25Speaker 4: going to get a lot worse than they did immediately
- 56:27Speaker 4: in the wakeup Trump. I thought we were going to
- 56:29Speaker 4: get a kind of like there was going to be
- 56:31Speaker 4: all AOC and Bernie Sanders types and it was going
- 56:34Speaker 4: to be like impossible to figure out who to vote
- 56:35Speaker 4: for in twenty twenty. And I thought, you know, there
- 56:38Speaker 4: was some of that, There was AOC, But I thought
- 56:41Speaker 4: the Democratic Party went less off the deep end as
- 56:46Speaker 4: a party than I thought they were going to do. Obviously,
- 56:48Speaker 4: there was all kinds of crazy stuff happening on the
- 56:50Speaker 4: lab with Black Lives Matter and you know, what's called
- 56:55Speaker 4: Wochism and so forth, but it was less extreme than
- 56:58Speaker 4: I expected them to be.
- 57:00Speaker 2: On the other hand, I.
- 57:02Speaker 4: Think we're learning that some of the worst elements of
- 57:06Speaker 4: the party, even when they weren't literally in the driver's seats,
- 57:09Speaker 4: had more control over over tech policy and other things
- 57:16Speaker 4: in the Biden administration than was, you know, than they
- 57:21Speaker 4: were open about at the time. So it's a little
- 57:23Speaker 4: hard to know how each of these parties is going
- 57:25Speaker 4: to develop. The fact that the Republicans under Trump have
- 57:32Speaker 4: turned so anti capitalist, against trade, for industrial planning and
- 57:37Speaker 4: so forth, and that there is hardly any constituency on
- 57:41Speaker 4: the left for being right on those things for any
- 57:45Speaker 4: reason other than backing, you know, hating Trump makes me
- 57:50Speaker 4: think it's unlikely that whatever things emerge on the left
- 57:54Speaker 4: as a reaction to Trump are going to be organized
- 57:57Speaker 4: around you know, markets and trade. I think it's more
- 58:01Speaker 4: likely that you'll get a kind of you know, resurgent,
- 58:04Speaker 4: never Trump wing of the Republicans that likes those things.
- 58:08Speaker 4: But the Republicans, maybe you'll get the Democrats. Maybe you'll
- 58:10Speaker 4: get better on some other things or less bad on
- 58:12Speaker 4: some other things. But it's very hard to predict. And
- 58:16Speaker 4: you know, I wouldn't have predicted in you know, twenty fourteen,
- 58:20Speaker 4: the Republican Party having developed along the lines that it did.
- 58:22Speaker 4: So who knows what changes for better or worse are
- 58:26Speaker 4: possible for one of these parties in the next decade.
- 58:29Speaker 3: There are some better people, It's say, sent a left
- 58:33Speaker 3: economists who are not bad, you know, and glicis Noah Smith,
- 58:39Speaker 3: you know a few others, I.
- 58:41Speaker 4: Mean, even people like as reclined who's very bad on
- 58:44Speaker 4: something has been pro technology, pro progress, pro getting rid
- 58:50Speaker 4: of certain kinds of onerous regulations. And I mean this
- 58:52Speaker 4: is someone who I first encountered, as you know, someone
- 58:56Speaker 4: in a gross way debating John Allison and being really
- 58:59Speaker 4: dishonored that my view is in that debate. But you know,
- 59:03Speaker 4: in other ways you could see him getting better. And
- 59:04Speaker 4: you know that happened to Christopher Hitchins, so who I
- 59:07Speaker 4: first encountered to someone defending socialism in a debate with
- 59:10Speaker 4: Harry Binsweger, but became better in his liter years.
- 59:14Speaker 2: So there are there are signs of better things among
- 59:19Speaker 2: some leftists.
- 59:22Speaker 4: There's a book Abundance that you have just come out
- 59:24Speaker 4: are about to come out by Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson,
- 59:27Speaker 4: and you know there are that that looks promising.
- 59:30Speaker 2: So there are factions, but I doubt they'll be.
- 59:35Speaker 4: As good as you know people were in the nineties,
- 59:38Speaker 4: because there's not a I think it'll be a little
- 59:41Speaker 4: bit more maybe pro technology, and but I doubt it'll
- 59:46Speaker 4: be against Central Planet, which seems to be something that
- 59:51Speaker 4: we're getting across the political continuum by people who are
- 59:57Speaker 4: more pro progress and anti progress, and so beside us
- 59:59Speaker 4: to find it hard to see where we're.
- 1:00:02Speaker 2: Going to find an anti planning intent coman.
- 1:00:04Speaker 3: I think the best example of that is the Yes
- 1:00:06Speaker 3: in my Backyard, which is kind of anti zoning, which
- 1:00:10Speaker 3: is planning. But whether they're willing to extrapolate that to
- 1:00:13Speaker 3: something more broad up is unlikely.
- 1:00:16Speaker 2: Unfortunately, it's not have.
- 1:00:17Speaker 4: Been clear to me that the mbiists are anti zoning
- 1:00:21Speaker 4: and planning as opposed to they want defend zing and
- 1:00:24Speaker 4: planning that they think will result in more development. They're
- 1:00:27Speaker 4: not saying get rid of zoning codes that make every
- 1:00:29Speaker 4: place like Houston. They're saying, let's zone this place for
- 1:00:32Speaker 4: higher occupancy and let's, you know, make the city more walkable,
- 1:00:36Speaker 4: and let's have more these facilities. It's it's it's less
- 1:00:39Speaker 4: an issue of what government should and shouldn't be doing,
- 1:00:43Speaker 4: and more an issue of what kinds of things should
- 1:00:49Speaker 4: we be planning for, at least for most of them.
- 1:00:52Speaker 3: All right, let me quickly saying, Jonathan, and let's see
- 1:00:59Speaker 3: test us Yes and Wes. Of course, thank you, Wes,
- 1:01:04Speaker 3: Thanks guys for your stickers. All right, let's see Thomas asks.
- 1:01:11Speaker 3: A number of serious people are starting to afford to
- 1:01:13Speaker 3: Trump as a Russian asset based on trips and statements
- 1:01:17Speaker 3: from the eighties and his actions now in Ukraine, pouts
- 1:01:20Speaker 3: and Russia. Conspiracy nonsense or actual plausible possibility.
- 1:01:26Speaker 4: I mean, I haven't really followed any of that. It's
- 1:01:29Speaker 4: the same as you know, in his first term there
- 1:01:31Speaker 4: were people saying there was compromat on him and so forth.
- 1:01:34Speaker 4: I mean, he certainly acts just like he would if
- 1:01:38Speaker 4: he were a Russian asset, but there are more ways
- 1:01:40Speaker 4: that reasons than one why somebody could do that. And
- 1:01:43Speaker 4: the kind of simplest explanation is that he's the kind
- 1:01:47Speaker 4: of guy who admires brutes. And if he's the kind
- 1:01:50Speaker 4: of guy who admires bruts, which I think we can
- 1:01:52Speaker 4: tell that he is without any kind of theory, then
- 1:01:54Speaker 4: you wouldn't need all that much to get him to
- 1:01:59Speaker 4: the Russian and wouldn't need much to get him to
- 1:02:01Speaker 4: act in the way that he is now. Is it
- 1:02:02Speaker 4: possible that you know, someone in the KGB, you know,
- 1:02:05Speaker 4: noticed that he's that kind of guy back then and
- 1:02:07Speaker 4: thought like, maybe we could help his political career or something.
- 1:02:10Speaker 4: You know, that kind of thing could happen, But I
- 1:02:13Speaker 4: don't know of any particular evidence that it did. There
- 1:02:16Speaker 4: are people saying yet, but you should expect, you know,
- 1:02:19Speaker 4: there to be a lot of noise. And the way
- 1:02:21Speaker 4: I think about processing information is, in a world where
- 1:02:27Speaker 4: there's so much communication as we have now, and so
- 1:02:30Speaker 4: much access to any idea anybody spread, you should expect,
- 1:02:36Speaker 4: even if there's no evidence for something, certain kind of ideas,
- 1:02:40Speaker 4: you should expect to get a kind of audience and
- 1:02:43Speaker 4: to have some people who seem pretty smart advocating for them,
- 1:02:47Speaker 4: and to have things that it's hard to tell whether
- 1:02:48Speaker 4: they're really evidence or not, because your ability to detect
- 1:02:51Speaker 4: and tell what counts as evidence in a certain domain
- 1:02:54Speaker 4: isn't that good unless you're knowledgeable in that domain. And
- 1:02:57Speaker 4: so the theory that Trump is a Russian asset, or
- 1:03:02Speaker 4: that Obama is secretly gay, or that there are kinds
- 1:03:05Speaker 4: of theories that you should expect are going to come
- 1:03:07Speaker 4: up and there's going to be something to be said
- 1:03:09Speaker 4: for them in people's in social media, whether they're true
- 1:03:12Speaker 4: or false.
- 1:03:12Speaker 2: And the whole trick.
- 1:03:14Speaker 4: Of thinking about this stuff is to set your threshold
- 1:03:18Speaker 4: such that you have a sense of when is there
- 1:03:21Speaker 4: enough smoke here that there's a reason I think there's
- 1:03:24Speaker 4: a fire, and when is it the kind of thing
- 1:03:27Speaker 4: that you'd expect, just as the noise of how the
- 1:03:29Speaker 4: debate goes. And I haven't seen anything that takes these
- 1:03:33Speaker 4: theories above the threshold where I'd expect it to be
- 1:03:36Speaker 4: stuff like this even if it wasn't true.
- 1:03:38Speaker 2: Being said.
- 1:03:41Speaker 3: Dave says, do you find a distinction between an ideological
- 1:03:45Speaker 3: pragmatist who is driven to action with a pragmatic vision
- 1:03:49Speaker 3: of reality and someone who acts produces pragmatic effects in
- 1:03:55Speaker 3: reality accidentally or without intent.
- 1:04:00Speaker 4: I don't know what pragmatic means are the kind of
- 1:04:02Speaker 4: effects a pragmatist would produce.
- 1:04:04Speaker 2: I mean, even so far as I think there's a distinction.
- 1:04:07Speaker 4: Like that, I would put say, you know, JFK on
- 1:04:12Speaker 4: the first side of it and Richard Nixon on the
- 1:04:14Speaker 4: second side of it. But if somebody's acting in a
- 1:04:17Speaker 4: brutish manner, I think that's a simpler phenomenon.
- 1:04:21Speaker 2: It's not.
- 1:04:21Speaker 4: And they're not specifically pragmatic effects. They're irrational effects. And
- 1:04:27Speaker 4: pragmatism is in effect a kind of rationalization of irrationalism, right,
- 1:04:34Speaker 4: And there's complicated, sophisticated rationalizations of irrationalism, and there are
- 1:04:38Speaker 4: ones that are like simpler you know Layman's versions of that.
- 1:04:45Speaker 4: But there's such a thing as just being so irrational
- 1:04:50Speaker 4: and undeveloped intellectually that you don't feel the need for
- 1:04:52Speaker 4: a rationalization of it, at least not anything that's systematic
- 1:04:55Speaker 4: and thoughtful as irrationalization of it, Like thinking is sort
- 1:05:00Speaker 4: of unreal to you. Yeah, and principles are sort of
- 1:05:04Speaker 4: unreal to you. Pragmatism is what you have when principles,
- 1:05:08Speaker 4: the need for principles is something that you're aware of,
- 1:05:12Speaker 4: and it's a rationalization for rebelling against it. But if
- 1:05:15Speaker 4: you're totally amoral, you're totally you have no compunctions about
- 1:05:19Speaker 4: having no principles, then you have no need for pragmatism.
- 1:05:23Speaker 3: Yep Adam says Greg does Putsin's brain Dugan Alexander Dugan
- 1:05:30Speaker 3: have a philosophy of his own or does he mainly
- 1:05:33Speaker 3: pick and choose whatever will please Putin?
- 1:05:37Speaker 2: I don't know that much about him.
- 1:05:38Speaker 4: I mean, I've seen the one or two interviews that
- 1:05:40Speaker 4: most people have seen, but I've not read him, and
- 1:05:42Speaker 4: I don't know much about the guy.
- 1:05:44Speaker 2: So I don't know.
- 1:05:45Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean I think he's he's Yeah, I don't
- 1:05:50Speaker 3: think it picks and chooses.
- 1:05:51Speaker 1: I think.
- 1:05:54Speaker 3: I'm not even sure how close they are. That is,
- 1:05:56Speaker 3: in spite of the fact that he's called Putsin's brain. Okay,
- 1:06:01Speaker 3: Evan says, great to see Greg back on the show.
- 1:06:04Speaker 3: It is thanks Sevan Dave. If a creditor makes an
- 1:06:09Speaker 3: accounting era doesn't charge an individual.
- 1:06:12Speaker 1: For product service that they received, does.
- 1:06:15Speaker 3: That individual have a mall ethical duty to disclose the
- 1:06:19Speaker 3: error to the creditor?
- 1:06:24Speaker 4: And then I don't think in terms of duties, I
- 1:06:27Speaker 4: think he should, but he shouldn't try too hard to.
- 1:06:30Speaker 4: That is, if if it's like a store clerk and
- 1:06:34Speaker 4: you're at the store and the person you know not
- 1:06:37Speaker 4: short changes you, but it's the opposite over you know,
- 1:06:38Speaker 4: whatever makes an error in your favor, and you're right
- 1:06:41Speaker 4: there and you see it and you notice that, then
- 1:06:43Speaker 4: I think, you know, out of general goodwill and not
- 1:06:46Speaker 4: wanting the unearned and not wanting this person to get hurt,
- 1:06:49Speaker 4: but you should just say, you know, however, you get
- 1:06:52Speaker 4: home and and and you know you were given two
- 1:06:54Speaker 4: dollars extra, now you're going to drive across town back
- 1:06:56Speaker 4: to the place that correctly are like, it's not I
- 1:06:59Speaker 4: don't think you any responsibility to do that. And I
- 1:07:01Speaker 4: think it would be in a lot of contexts to
- 1:07:03Speaker 4: sacrifice to do it. Likewise, you know your bank does it,
- 1:07:07Speaker 4: and now you're going to call the bank and get
- 1:07:08Speaker 4: on tech support with them. It's going to take you
- 1:07:10Speaker 4: an hour and a half. And you know I wouldn't
- 1:07:12Speaker 4: do that. But if there's a click here to report
- 1:07:16Speaker 4: and it's easy.
- 1:07:16Speaker 2: To do, then I would do it. Yeah, and I
- 1:07:19Speaker 2: think you should do it.
- 1:07:22Speaker 1: Which it says, assuming I man developed Objectivism to provide
- 1:07:25Speaker 1: a philosophical foundation for Atlas Shrugged, has a novel become
- 1:07:29Speaker 1: a means for introducing the world to objectivism?
- 1:07:33Speaker 2: Has it become a means to it?
- 1:07:35Speaker 4: So, in other words, the idea is the philosophy was
- 1:07:38Speaker 4: a means to the novel, but then now the novel
- 1:07:40Speaker 4: has become a means to the philosophy. Well, if your
- 1:07:44Speaker 4: goal is to introduce somebody to Atlas, to to Objectivism,
- 1:07:48Speaker 4: then I think at Lass Shrugged is a fantastic means
- 1:07:51Speaker 4: to do it, regardless of whether it is itself the
- 1:07:54Speaker 4: means that. I don't think it exists as the means,
- 1:07:56Speaker 4: so that it exists as a novel created for an
- 1:07:58Speaker 4: aesthetic purpose, but it is a fantastic means of introducing
- 1:08:02Speaker 4: someone to this philosophy if.
- 1:08:03Speaker 2: You want to.
- 1:08:05Speaker 4: And there are lots of things like that, like, for example,
- 1:08:08Speaker 4: I often teach the movie Twelve Angry Men, and I
- 1:08:11Speaker 4: teach it in a class on philosophy as a means
- 1:08:14Speaker 4: to introducing certain points in philosophy. That's my reason for
- 1:08:17Speaker 4: signing the students to watch this movie and getting a
- 1:08:19Speaker 4: lecture on it. But it's not like the movie as
- 1:08:22Speaker 4: such is a means to that. The movie is a movie,
- 1:08:24Speaker 4: and it's a means to, you know, the aesthetic enjoyment
- 1:08:28Speaker 4: that it is. So something can be used as a
- 1:08:35Speaker 4: means to something, and it's fine to use it as
- 1:08:37Speaker 4: a means to something without that meaning the essence of
- 1:08:39Speaker 4: what the thing is.
- 1:08:44Speaker 1: Justin says, yes, in watching from the beginning rather than live,
- 1:08:48Speaker 1: I'm sure there's a bunch of value coming at me.
- 1:08:51Speaker 1: Thank you both. Thanks Justin appreciate it all. Right. Let's see.
- 1:08:59Speaker 3: Liam said it says, did the Nazis past tariffs rapidly
- 1:09:05Speaker 3: and aggressively like Trump? I've been watching some of Hitler's
- 1:09:08Speaker 3: speeches and he constantly self aggrandizes like Trump.
- 1:09:13Speaker 4: I don't know about their economic policies with respected tariffs
- 1:09:17Speaker 4: either way.
- 1:09:18Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, they definitely had an economic agenda.
- 1:09:21Speaker 4: And you can read a bunch of Hitler's speeches, and
- 1:09:23Speaker 4: I've assigned some in courses on political philosophy because I
- 1:09:27Speaker 4: want people to get a sense of, like, well, what
- 1:09:29Speaker 4: were Nazis actually like?
- 1:09:30Speaker 2: And they definitely had the idea of.
- 1:09:35Speaker 4: Aggressive authoritary in control of the economy and made what
- 1:09:40Speaker 4: they regarded as bold moves that Hitler regarded as you know,
- 1:09:42Speaker 4: claim to really help the German economy, although the German
- 1:09:45Speaker 4: economy was never doing really well.
- 1:09:46Speaker 2: So I don't think they did, but or could have.
- 1:09:49Speaker 4: But what particular moves and whether it was tariffs and
- 1:09:52Speaker 4: on them at what time?
- 1:09:53Speaker 2: Without it, don't.
- 1:09:57Speaker 3: Lucinda says, thoughts and Plato's ion I read it recently
- 1:10:03Speaker 3: and reminded me a lot of the inspirationalism Rand criticizes.
- 1:10:08Speaker 1: Did Plato originate that view.
- 1:10:12Speaker 4: The inspirationalism Random criticizes, I'm not sure. In other words,
- 1:10:18Speaker 4: do you think you're just a conduit for some you
- 1:10:21Speaker 4: don't write by reason? Yeah? Okay, so in that sense, yeah,
- 1:10:24Speaker 4: so so the ion for is one of these early
- 1:10:29Speaker 4: Socratic dialogues by Plato where he's interviewing a kind of
- 1:10:32Speaker 4: a rhapsode Ion, a kind of poet in rhapsode or
- 1:10:36Speaker 4: Socrates is and it turns out the guy doesn't understand,
- 1:10:39Speaker 4: you know, his poems or any other poems, or Homer's poems,
- 1:10:42Speaker 4: and he reads Homers understand and and this view emerges
- 1:10:45Speaker 4: where the muses are like a magnet, and then the
- 1:10:49Speaker 4: great poets are like iron rings hanging off that magnet,
- 1:10:52Speaker 4: and then other people are hanging off of it whatever,
- 1:10:54Speaker 4: and so like all the kind of stuff is coming
- 1:10:57Speaker 4: down from the from the muses, through the great poets
- 1:11:00Speaker 4: to the rest of us, and it's coming down to
- 1:11:02Speaker 4: us generally without the people who are conduits of this
- 1:11:08Speaker 4: stuff understanding it. And you get that idea in a
- 1:11:11Speaker 4: number of the early Platonic works. You get it, certainly
- 1:11:15Speaker 4: in the Apology and in the Mino of that there
- 1:11:19Speaker 4: are people who who speak true things by inspiration without
- 1:11:23Speaker 4: understanding them. And I don't know if Plato's the first
- 1:11:27Speaker 4: to think that. He couldn't have been, because all the
- 1:11:31Speaker 4: like the Greek poems typically start with a invocation to
- 1:11:35Speaker 4: the muse to speak through the poet, like you know,
- 1:11:37Speaker 4: think of the beginning of the iliad like sing Goddess
- 1:11:40Speaker 4: of the Wrath of Achilles or in the in the
- 1:11:42Speaker 4: APSI tell me of the Man of many turns orever
- 1:11:44Speaker 4: you want to call it. So this idea that the
- 1:11:48Speaker 4: you know, God speak to you, you're inspired when you're
- 1:11:50Speaker 4: doing poetry is older than Plato, but he's probably the
- 1:11:53Speaker 4: first articulate philosophical defense of it the first time.
- 1:11:57Speaker 2: I one knew.
- 1:12:00Speaker 1: Thanks Listinda Jason. Movie spinoffs, franchises and sequels have made
- 1:12:06Speaker 1: some of the planet's best billionaires. I don't know what
- 1:12:10Speaker 1: that means yet.
- 1:12:11Speaker 3: Ran thinks we need more original characters. Correct me if
- 1:12:15Speaker 3: I'm wrong. Discuss if longevity permits. Do you look forward
- 1:12:20Speaker 3: to well done Atla Shark mini series, movie and musical,
- 1:12:24Speaker 3: and if it maintains I've got a story now and
- 1:12:28Speaker 3: I mean almost almost made a musical atlasug and if
- 1:12:33Speaker 3: it maintains popularity Atlas spinoffs, new adventures and backstories, So
- 1:12:37Speaker 3: correct me if I'm wrong.
- 1:12:39Speaker 1: Discuss I don't know. This is movie spinoffs, franchise sequels.
- 1:12:46Speaker 1: This is the superhuman movies. I guess, yeah, they make billions.
- 1:12:50Speaker 1: I mean a lot of people like them.
- 1:12:51Speaker 3: I don't, And I think aesthetically they're just not that
- 1:12:55Speaker 3: meaningful or enjoyable, or.
- 1:12:58Speaker 1: I'd like some original all scripts.
- 1:13:02Speaker 4: Yeah, I'm with you on this. I'm bored by these
- 1:13:04Speaker 4: superhero franchises. I don't remember the last one I've seen,
- 1:13:07Speaker 4: but there were just so many, and it's it's I
- 1:13:10Speaker 4: don't in general like superhero type stories. Some of them
- 1:13:13Speaker 4: that are really good, but uh, it's not if all
- 1:13:15Speaker 4: that's all I know about a story that's a point
- 1:13:17Speaker 4: against it rather than for it.
- 1:13:19Speaker 2: And I don't love these.
- 1:13:23Speaker 4: Universe building you know, we have to set something else
- 1:13:25Speaker 4: in the universe of Star Wars or whatever. Like a
- 1:13:26Speaker 4: few of the things that have been said in that
- 1:13:28Speaker 4: universe turned out to be really good. I thought and Or,
- 1:13:30Speaker 4: for example, was really good, but I had to be
- 1:13:32Speaker 4: popped into watching it by a bunch of people telling
- 1:13:34Speaker 4: me it was good, because like, what do we need
- 1:13:35Speaker 4: another thing said in this in this chalaxy? What I
- 1:13:38Speaker 4: like about the ones I liked aren't that they're said
- 1:13:41Speaker 4: in this fictional universe. So there's something.
- 1:13:45Speaker 2: Feels tired and uncreative to me.
- 1:13:47Speaker 4: And that were just, you know, and more than I agree,
- 1:13:55Speaker 4: of failing to appreciate what it is that's good about
- 1:13:58Speaker 4: the the good stories. It's not that they're set in
- 1:14:01Speaker 4: this world. They have this bit of ip that we
- 1:14:04Speaker 4: could then, you know, spin some franchise off on again.
- 1:14:08Speaker 2: There have been good works made that way, but it's
- 1:14:10Speaker 2: not I don't know. It feels tired, uninspired.
- 1:14:17Speaker 1: I tired and inspired is good? I think yeah? And
- 1:14:21Speaker 1: then Jason Ass continues.
- 1:14:23Speaker 3: He says, do you look forward to a well done
- 1:14:25Speaker 3: Adler Schwag mini series, movie, musical? And would you would
- 1:14:30Speaker 3: you like to see spinoffs and new adventures and backstories.
- 1:14:33Speaker 4: I would not like to see spinoffs, new adventures and factors.
- 1:14:36Speaker 2: In general. I don't like things like that for other
- 1:14:39Speaker 2: works of art, Like you know.
- 1:14:41Speaker 4: You can imagine, you know what Cassette does when she's
- 1:14:44Speaker 4: a mother, you know, the spin off of Victor Hugo
- 1:14:47Speaker 4: or or you know, movie did Part three or something.
- 1:14:50Speaker 4: It just feels like the story has the beginning of
- 1:14:54Speaker 4: middle and an and it functions as it functions. It
- 1:14:58Speaker 4: feels like, why would you do that? I think it's
- 1:15:01Speaker 4: doing a disservice to our well worked story to add
- 1:15:05Speaker 4: sequels to it unless you have a really good and
- 1:15:08Speaker 4: strong idea for why to do it. And and in general,
- 1:15:11Speaker 4: you know, again there have been occasions where somebody's created
- 1:15:13Speaker 4: something with real artistic merit that way, but I think
- 1:15:17Speaker 4: in general it's it's not good, particularly when the original
- 1:15:21Speaker 4: author is not there to do it right. But so
- 1:15:27Speaker 4: I I And if you really love a work, and
- 1:15:30Speaker 4: you love it for what it is, and what it
- 1:15:33Speaker 4: is is something that's self contained and draws an end
- 1:15:36Speaker 4: to its story, there's something unpleasant about the idea of
- 1:15:42Speaker 4: somebody going in and trying to tamper with that.
- 1:15:44Speaker 2: Now.
- 1:15:44Speaker 4: I would really like to see a well done Atlas
- 1:15:47Speaker 4: Shrugged mini series. None of the I've seen people who
- 1:15:52Speaker 4: had scripts, and some of them I thought were very
- 1:15:54Speaker 4: earnest in what they were trying to do with it
- 1:15:55Speaker 4: and so forth, and well motivated. But I haven't seen
- 1:15:58Speaker 4: anything that I think would make I haven't seen anything
- 1:16:02Speaker 4: that makes him think any good, ah good Atlas shrugging.
- 1:16:09Speaker 4: The series is likely to be on the horizon anytime
- 1:16:11Speaker 4: scene he made no more than I do.
- 1:16:13Speaker 3: You're around No, I agree with you. I think that's right.
- 1:16:15Speaker 3: There was an attempt at a musical. It It almost
- 1:16:19Speaker 3: got made, but it was mixed by by Leonard at
- 1:16:24Speaker 3: the last minute.
- 1:16:25Speaker 1: I've never heard of him, not not at the very
- 1:16:28Speaker 1: last minute.
- 1:16:28Speaker 4: It was.
- 1:16:28Speaker 3: It was mixed when they when when the guy wrote
- 1:16:31Speaker 3: the music, and the music was just not.
- 1:16:34Speaker 1: Up to the script.
- 1:16:36Speaker 3: Wasn't bad if you're going to condense Auto Shrugged into
- 1:16:39Speaker 3: a two hour musical, it wasn't bad. But the music
- 1:16:42Speaker 3: just didn't live up to what it needs to be
- 1:16:45Speaker 3: to be a music.
- 1:16:46Speaker 1: To be a good musical.
- 1:16:48Speaker 4: I can't imagine it as a musical, but I don't
- 1:16:50Speaker 4: think it lends itself to that, although I wouldn't have
- 1:16:53Speaker 4: thought labor.
- 1:16:58Speaker 3: Yeah it Yeah, it needed that quality and it didn't
- 1:17:01Speaker 3: have the quality of a Limus Robelos musically. James, if
- 1:17:06Speaker 3: the United States collapses into fascism, would you say, Iinman
- 1:17:11Speaker 3: has failed, has failed.
- 1:17:14Speaker 2: It's the rest of us it would have failed. Yep.
- 1:17:17Speaker 2: But she did her part.
- 1:17:19Speaker 4: And you could quibble about whether she could have done
- 1:17:21Speaker 4: something a little better, you know, back forty or fifty
- 1:17:25Speaker 4: years ago, but.
- 1:17:27Speaker 1: She did so much.
- 1:17:29Speaker 2: Yeah, she did so much.
- 1:17:30Speaker 4: And it's you know, in somewhat you might say we've
- 1:17:33Speaker 4: failed a subjectivist who've been trying to avert it. But
- 1:17:35Speaker 4: I think it's a bigger failing of the culture in general.
- 1:17:39Speaker 4: And there are lots of respects in which the culture
- 1:17:41Speaker 4: in general has failed, whether or not we fall into
- 1:17:44Speaker 4: a dictatorship. You know, we could be so much better,
- 1:17:47Speaker 4: so much happier, so much freer than we are, if
- 1:17:50Speaker 4: more people rose to the occasion, if the people who
- 1:17:53Speaker 4: among us who are trying to fight for the good
- 1:17:56Speaker 4: were better about it and better. It's spreading our ideas.
- 1:17:59Speaker 4: But you can't name, you know, any one person, and
- 1:18:04Speaker 4: certainly not anyone who who's been dead for that long
- 1:18:08Speaker 4: for the fate of a country, particularly when they've done
- 1:18:13Speaker 4: more than can be expected of anyone to write it.
- 1:18:17Speaker 3: Andrew, what do you think motivates objectivism historically? Is it
- 1:18:23Speaker 3: merely a failure of philosophers to recognize the individuals is
- 1:18:28Speaker 3: a metaphysical unit or means to collectivist ethical aims or
- 1:18:33Speaker 3: something else?
- 1:18:35Speaker 2: What is it that motivates objective?
- 1:18:37Speaker 3: No, collectivism of God? What is it it motivates collectivism historically?
- 1:18:40Speaker 3: Is it merely a failure philosophers to recognize the individual
- 1:18:44Speaker 3: as a metaphysical unit or means to a collective ethical
- 1:18:48Speaker 3: aims or something else?
- 1:18:51Speaker 4: I mean, I think we have to think about in
- 1:18:53Speaker 4: what period because it's not like there was just one
- 1:18:56Speaker 4: collectivist movement at one time. I don't mean that we
- 1:18:59Speaker 4: have to mint it super fine and say like well
- 1:19:02Speaker 4: in nineteen thirty two, but like the republic is collectivist,
- 1:19:07Speaker 4: and a lot of classical political philosophy is collectivist. I
- 1:19:11Speaker 4: think that has a somewhat different motivation than the collectivism
- 1:19:15Speaker 4: of the nineteenth century, which is into the twentieth century,
- 1:19:20Speaker 4: which is coming out of a kind of individualistic liberal movement.
- 1:19:23Speaker 4: And so you know, which collect and then then the
- 1:19:26Speaker 4: rise of collectivism the resurgence of it recently, So which
- 1:19:29Speaker 4: one are we talking about? I mean, I think in general,
- 1:19:33Speaker 4: individualism goes with an acceptance of reason, and collectivism within
- 1:19:38Speaker 4: a rejection of reason. But very early on, before there's
- 1:19:43Speaker 4: much understanding of how reason functions in a human life
- 1:19:47Speaker 4: and a society.
- 1:19:49Speaker 2: There are cases where.
- 1:19:54Speaker 4: Enthusiasm about reason goes with a kind of collectivism by default,
- 1:19:58Speaker 4: Like I have a good idea for how people can
- 1:20:00Speaker 4: conduct things, and doesn't occur to me that I can't,
- 1:20:03Speaker 4: you know, organize everybody in accordance with it, and you know,
- 1:20:08Speaker 4: so there's a kind of comparative innocence to the ancient
- 1:20:12Speaker 4: forms of collectivism that I don't think are coming from
- 1:20:15Speaker 4: a rejection or antipathy towards reason. But the more post
- 1:20:20Speaker 4: Enlightenment collectivism, I think is coming out of a a
- 1:20:27Speaker 4: turn against reason and self esteem, basically a kind of
- 1:20:32Speaker 4: loss of confidence in the ability of the mind.
- 1:20:37Speaker 3: Michael says, do you see Austin, Texas as the next
- 1:20:39Speaker 3: Silicon Valley? It seems like blue cities in red states
- 1:20:44Speaker 3: are the place to be.
- 1:20:48Speaker 4: I don't know how to make those kind of, you know,
- 1:20:53Speaker 4: economic predictions. I mean, the Silicon Valley seems for now
- 1:20:58Speaker 4: like it's the next Silicon Valley. I mean, is all
- 1:21:01Speaker 4: of the the major AI tech stuff and so forth
- 1:21:06Speaker 4: seems to be happening there, even after people thought it
- 1:21:10Speaker 4: was over.
- 1:21:12Speaker 2: I doubt that that industry will all move to Austin.
- 1:21:15Speaker 2: Austin does seem to have a kind of scene developing
- 1:21:19Speaker 2: for kind of heterodox political thought and commentary. We'll see
- 1:21:24Speaker 2: where that goes and if it gets better or worse.
- 1:21:26Speaker 2: A lot of the people who who seemed good on
- 1:21:29Speaker 2: that or a lot of the people whether they seemed
- 1:21:31Speaker 2: good or not, who were in the ascendency in that space,
- 1:21:37Speaker 2: people like Joe Rogan and so forth, I think, have
- 1:21:42Speaker 2: become more and more transparently foolish or bad such that
- 1:21:47Speaker 2: I doubt that there'll be assets in the nucleation of
- 1:21:52Speaker 2: a better culture of discussion here. And but you know,
- 1:21:58Speaker 2: with what some of the stuff that's coming on at the.
- 1:22:01Speaker 4: University of Texas, with the the the the Foundation of
- 1:22:08Speaker 4: the University of Austin, with a few other other think
- 1:22:12Speaker 4: tanks that are operating here, and it seems like there
- 1:22:15Speaker 4: is a kind of gathering discussion of ideas here that
- 1:22:21Speaker 4: it could become in the next year, is more of
- 1:22:24Speaker 4: a center for that. It's it's hard to predict because
- 1:22:27Speaker 4: the whole cultural political landscape right now is in a
- 1:22:32Speaker 4: is a very unstable position, which I think creates opportunities
- 1:22:36Speaker 4: for for good things to emerge, but also makes it
- 1:22:38Speaker 4: very hard to predict.
- 1:22:40Speaker 3: Yep, Michael, is what separates Trump from Hitler that Trump
- 1:22:47Speaker 3: cares more about prestige than power. He doesn't have an
- 1:22:51Speaker 3: ideology like Hitler and Putin. He just wants recognition as
- 1:22:55Speaker 3: an end in itself.
- 1:22:59Speaker 4: I mean, I don't think it's good to take Hitler
- 1:23:03Speaker 4: always as your paradigm of a bad guy or a
- 1:23:07Speaker 4: villains than anyone you think is bad, you know, or
- 1:23:10Speaker 4: even of a dictator, anyone you think is bad. How
- 1:23:13Speaker 4: do they relate to him? Are they less bad? Are
- 1:23:15Speaker 4: the same bad? How much more bad? And in what way?
- 1:23:17Speaker 4: In what way? Like Hitler is a is fairly a
- 1:23:21Speaker 4: typical He was in some ways more ideological. He was
- 1:23:27Speaker 4: more the head of a kind of movement that like
- 1:23:29Speaker 4: the typical kind of dictator is much more like a
- 1:23:34Speaker 4: mob boss type person, much more like the kind of
- 1:23:38Speaker 4: you know, people who rule you know, Latin American like
- 1:23:41Speaker 4: Banana Republic kind of dictatorships, or or uh, the kind
- 1:23:46Speaker 4: of African dictators and and so forth. That's the more
- 1:23:49Speaker 4: typical case, and one should if one sees, you know,
- 1:23:54Speaker 4: dictators rising, you think more about Trump's not a dictator, ye,
- 1:23:57Speaker 4: although I.
- 1:23:58Speaker 2: Think he would. He wants to be.
- 1:24:00Speaker 4: He's the find of person who wants to be. But
- 1:24:03Speaker 4: there are always there are tons of people like that.
- 1:24:05Speaker 4: The causes are the in the world, but the causes
- 1:24:08Speaker 4: of their coming to power when they do aren't them.
- 1:24:10Speaker 4: They're what's there are opportunistic infections in effect on the world.
- 1:24:14Speaker 4: And the question is less about this guy versus what's
- 1:24:19Speaker 4: making him and his style of politics palatable to so
- 1:24:24Speaker 4: many people, or indeed really exciting to so many people.
- 1:24:27Speaker 2: And especially to good people or the better people who are.
- 1:24:30Speaker 4: Attracted to him, because it's it's it's very much always
- 1:24:33Speaker 4: an issue of the the better people who are attracted
- 1:24:37Speaker 4: to something having an outside, outside influence on on on
- 1:24:44Speaker 4: it being powerful, and that's, you know, something you want
- 1:24:47Speaker 4: to understand with with with But yeah, I don't think
- 1:24:51Speaker 4: Hitler was certainly more ideological than Putin, than Erduan, than Trump,
- 1:24:57Speaker 4: than Franco, you know, than all and then all the
- 1:25:00Speaker 4: sundry you know, dictatorial leaders in different countries around the world.
- 1:25:03Speaker 4: So he's and he and Lenin are kind of unusual cases.
- 1:25:07Speaker 1: In that respect, even with Selinia was more intellectual.
- 1:25:12Speaker 4: Yeah, than most And now all of these people are
- 1:25:16Speaker 4: cases of a country descending from a better world government
- 1:25:21Speaker 4: into a worse But yeah, I don't know how much
- 1:25:26Speaker 4: more to say about that, But I don't think that
- 1:25:27Speaker 4: the the comparisons to Hitler are that youthful for bad leaders.
- 1:25:34Speaker 4: If they're the one comparison, what has It's got to
- 1:25:36Speaker 4: be a you have a wide matrix of of what
- 1:25:40Speaker 4: authoritarian leaders look like, and then Hitler is one point
- 1:25:43Speaker 4: within within that.
- 1:25:44Speaker 3: Yeah, rich it says, congratulations, you're on you just raised
- 1:25:50Speaker 3: a supercheck goal on the show, Greg, what do you
- 1:25:53Speaker 3: think about moving goalposts?
- 1:25:55Speaker 1: This question shows on for it you got to keep
- 1:25:58Speaker 1: the incentives alive.
- 1:26:00Speaker 4: I think actually, when you're playing a game doing you
- 1:26:02Speaker 4: sometimes move the goalposts to make it like a literal.
- 1:26:05Speaker 4: Goalposts can get moved. Sometimes it's whether they're in it's
- 1:26:08Speaker 4: whether it's a that's cheating with the general rule of
- 1:26:11Speaker 4: the game, or whether it's cheating.
- 1:26:12Speaker 3: And I don't think it's cheating here here, I don't
- 1:26:14Speaker 3: think it's cheating. Since I set the woulves, I could
- 1:26:17Speaker 3: set the mass not cheat. Liscinda asks what are your
- 1:26:21Speaker 3: favorite movies?
- 1:26:21Speaker 1: Greg?
- 1:26:23Speaker 2: My favorite movies. I'm bad at this. They don't really
- 1:26:28Speaker 2: have lists like that.
- 1:26:33Speaker 4: I was just watching with my son the movie Ratituy
- 1:26:37Speaker 4: and I really love that movie. It's probably the best
- 1:26:40Speaker 4: animated movie I think of all time and just really
- 1:26:43Speaker 4: strikingly good. I've talked a lot about it with my
- 1:26:47Speaker 4: friend Puyah who who wrote a fantastic blog post on
- 1:26:51Speaker 4: it or substat post how this movie saved my life.
- 1:26:55Speaker 4: You guys can find it. It's in the sub stack
- 1:26:57Speaker 4: Outliving Iran. There's a lot of great content. I put
- 1:27:01Speaker 4: you on your substack so that's one really great movie.
- 1:27:02Speaker 4: If anyone hasn't seen, I recommend. I really like my
- 1:27:06Speaker 4: My listen now is going to be skewed towards things
- 1:27:09Speaker 4: that I might consider showing a five year old because
- 1:27:11Speaker 4: I have a five year old. But I really like
- 1:27:14Speaker 4: the and I've always liked the version of Robin Hood
- 1:27:18Speaker 4: with Errol Flynn in it from the the thirties, yep.
- 1:27:23Speaker 4: And I like that that that Robinhood movie as a
- 1:27:26Speaker 4: kind of classic adventure film. Are four more modern, not
- 1:27:31Speaker 4: not very recent, but modern films.
- 1:27:33Speaker 2: I'm the Godfather Godfather.
- 1:27:35Speaker 4: I think it is fantastic at what it does, and
- 1:27:37Speaker 4: there's a really high quality film.
- 1:27:41Speaker 2: Others aren't coming to mind now, all right?
- 1:27:46Speaker 3: That doodo bunny, Greg, what are your thoughts on gun rights?
- 1:27:50Speaker 3: Yuron doesn't seem to have much respect for them, which
- 1:27:53Speaker 3: is not a not a good representation of my view,
- 1:27:57Speaker 3: But yes.
- 1:27:59Speaker 4: Yeah, I think I'm aligned with what Yuran's actual views
- 1:28:01Speaker 4: on gun rights are.
- 1:28:04Speaker 2: One, I don't think it's that important an issue.
- 1:28:06Speaker 4: I think you have a right to self defense, and
- 1:28:08Speaker 4: you have a right to the weapons or tools you
- 1:28:11Speaker 4: need for self defense, and therefore I think there's a
- 1:28:13Speaker 4: right in most contexts to have a handgun. But I
- 1:28:16Speaker 4: think since it's specifically a tool of killing, it's reasonable
- 1:28:21Speaker 4: that there are registration requirements and other kinds of you know,
- 1:28:25Speaker 4: background chats or other kind of requirements on it. I
- 1:28:27Speaker 4: don't think, I don't have strong opinions on exactly what
- 1:28:31Speaker 4: they should be.
- 1:28:31Speaker 2: And I think it's the kind of thing.
- 1:28:33Speaker 4: That would likely differ from one just well ruled country
- 1:28:38Speaker 4: to another, and within a just well ruled country, you know,
- 1:28:41Speaker 4: from one municipality to another. So I think basically we
- 1:28:46Speaker 4: are in the range of America's gun laws, or in
- 1:28:49Speaker 4: the range of what's reasonable, and they could change quite
- 1:28:52Speaker 4: a bit in one direction or another and still be
- 1:28:54Speaker 4: within the range of what's the reason.
- 1:28:56Speaker 2: I think there's a kind of.
- 1:29:01Speaker 4: Over concerned with guns among some people that comes from
- 1:29:04Speaker 4: a kind of mistaken view of what political change would
- 1:29:08Speaker 4: look like. And but but I do think there's a
- 1:29:13Speaker 4: right to that. I think it's not, however, mostly for
- 1:29:19Speaker 4: political reasons that you will rebel against the government, but
- 1:29:22Speaker 4: for reasons of like what if someone breaks into my house,
- 1:29:24Speaker 4: what if what if you know, I feel like I'm
- 1:29:28Speaker 4: understrapping and.
- 1:29:28Speaker 2: So forth, and I should have the means to protect myself. Yeah.
- 1:29:34Speaker 2: You know who's actually very good on guns is Sam Harrises.
- 1:29:37Speaker 1: He's excellent, really.
- 1:29:39Speaker 2: Good writ.
- 1:29:41Speaker 1: Yeah, he's got a podcast.
- 1:29:42Speaker 3: He really breaks it down nicely and in a very
- 1:29:45Speaker 3: rational way. Nathan, would a digital universal taxonomy using objectivism
- 1:29:54Speaker 3: be an effective.
- 1:29:55Speaker 1: Tool for thinkers, assuming it could.
- 1:29:57Speaker 3: Be automated for ease ease of you in that you
- 1:30:02Speaker 3: could see explicitly the inner workings of your mind.
- 1:30:07Speaker 2: Yes, I think there are projects like that.
- 1:30:11Speaker 4: I'm actually a bit involved with one that people trying
- 1:30:16Speaker 4: to I don't know how publicly that. I don't know
- 1:30:19Speaker 4: I could say any more about that in very early days.
- 1:30:21Speaker 4: But there's a computer scientist who's interested in building this
- 1:30:26Speaker 4: kind of thing, and we've talked about it a lot
- 1:30:27Speaker 4: over the years and have dabbled in it.
- 1:30:33Speaker 3: Cool Rob, How did Hegelian max Steiner derive and knocko?
- 1:30:41Speaker 4: Egoism derived? Seems a little I don't know that I
- 1:30:49Speaker 4: would use that word. I mean, I'm not I've read
- 1:30:53Speaker 4: the ego and its own you know, quite a while
- 1:30:55Speaker 4: about and I don't have it well enough in mind
- 1:30:58Speaker 4: to reproduce all the arguments from it. But I think
- 1:31:03Speaker 4: the basic idea is a kind of rejection of any
- 1:31:07Speaker 4: kind of authority and any kind of limits on what
- 1:31:10Speaker 4: one wants, and that that gives you that kind of
- 1:31:12Speaker 4: a view.
- 1:31:16Speaker 3: Web also asks thoughts on Hubert Spencer and Marshall McLuhan.
- 1:31:21Speaker 4: Well, those are people who are too pretty different. I
- 1:31:24Speaker 4: don't know any kind of connection between them, you know,
- 1:31:29Speaker 4: I don't know that much Spencer. I've read a little
- 1:31:31Speaker 4: of him. Most of what I've read I haven't. I
- 1:31:35Speaker 4: haven't liked.
- 1:31:37Speaker 2: But it feels like to me, the kind of social
- 1:31:43Speaker 2: Darwinist view.
- 1:31:45Speaker 4: Misses what is distinctive about human beings, which is that
- 1:31:51Speaker 4: human relationships. For all other animals, the fundamental relationship among
- 1:31:57Speaker 4: members of the species is one of competition, and any
- 1:32:00Speaker 4: cooperation that there might be, say between the parents raising
- 1:32:03Speaker 4: young or one hive of bees or whatever, is set
- 1:32:06Speaker 4: in a context of the species members are competing with
- 1:32:09Speaker 4: another for resources. Whereas for human beings, I think the
- 1:32:12Speaker 4: fundamental relation is win win because we don't compete for resources,
- 1:32:17Speaker 4: because we don't have any fixed inputs to our life process.
- 1:32:20Speaker 4: We produce resources, and we can find ways to make
- 1:32:24Speaker 4: resources for us, things.
- 1:32:25Speaker 2: That otherwise would have been useless.
- 1:32:26Speaker 4: And then once you once you notice that about human beings,
- 1:32:32Speaker 4: the whole way in which evolutionary theory and other things
- 1:32:34Speaker 4: apply to us, that is applied to societies and so forth.
- 1:32:38Speaker 4: I think looks and people within a society looks very,
- 1:32:41Speaker 4: very different. But you can, you know the spencer social
- 1:32:47Speaker 4: Darwinism is a little bit of a too reductive reading
- 1:32:49Speaker 4: of what he's not about. And I don't feel like
- 1:32:50Speaker 4: I have enough command of everything he thought to to
- 1:32:53Speaker 4: give a verdict on him as a whole, as a thinker.
- 1:32:57Speaker 2: The other one he asked about was Marshall mcluan.
- 1:32:59Speaker 4: He's the is the message or massage guy who who
- 1:33:02Speaker 4: wrote a lot about hot versus cold media and stuff
- 1:33:05Speaker 4: like that.
- 1:33:05Speaker 2: But I don't.
- 1:33:07Speaker 4: Actually in high school I had a teacher who was
- 1:33:09Speaker 4: into him and we read some stuff by him, and
- 1:33:12Speaker 4: it's like television production class I was taking.
- 1:33:14Speaker 2: But I don't have enough of a sense of him
- 1:33:16Speaker 2: to really say anything. Intelligence.
- 1:33:20Speaker 3: Okay, Jacob asks regarding Catholicism, what do you think is
- 1:33:25Speaker 3: the worst part of it for kids adults?
- 1:33:29Speaker 1: For me, it was.
- 1:33:31Speaker 3: Duty ethics or misintegration of pride original sin.
- 1:33:38Speaker 4: Well, I wasn't raised Catholic or in any particular religion.
- 1:33:48Speaker 4: My parents are kind of well, my father's from a
- 1:33:51Speaker 4: Catholic family and my mother from a Jewish family, and
- 1:33:54Speaker 4: they were sort of hand wavy kind of agnostics. They'd
- 1:33:57Speaker 4: say things like, well, there's got to be something which
- 1:34:01Speaker 4: at some level really is true. There are many things,
- 1:34:04Speaker 4: But so I don't have a like I had a
- 1:34:07Speaker 4: Catholic upbringing and I can reflect on, you know, what
- 1:34:10Speaker 4: was good about about it, And I think more at
- 1:34:13Speaker 4: the level of what is the effect of religion in
- 1:34:16Speaker 4: general and then Christianity specifically, rather than the effects of
- 1:34:21Speaker 4: you know, Roman Catholic, because Policism as opposed to being
- 1:34:23Speaker 4: a Luceran or an Episopelian or an Eastern Orthodoxy or something.
- 1:34:28Speaker 2: So I don't have any.
- 1:34:29Speaker 4: Opinions at that level of resolution that you're asking, but
- 1:34:32Speaker 4: definitely the doctrine of original sin, the idea that you
- 1:34:36Speaker 4: should be oriented around the meek, and in general. I
- 1:34:41Speaker 4: think of Christianity, if you want to think about what
- 1:34:43Speaker 4: its essence is as a religion.
- 1:34:47Speaker 2: Is I think it's in a tap on self esteem.
- 1:34:49Speaker 4: I think the fundamental message of Jesus is that you
- 1:34:52Speaker 4: shouldn't have self esteem, and there are ways to dress
- 1:34:55Speaker 4: it up more nicely, but if you think about what
- 1:34:57Speaker 4: the Sermon on the Mount is about.
- 1:34:59Speaker 2: That's what I think. In the end, the messages and.
- 1:35:03Speaker 4: Some denominations in some areas stressed that stuff more than others.
- 1:35:08Speaker 4: But that's what I think is the art of the
- 1:35:11Speaker 4: idea that your life, that you're not competent and you're
- 1:35:15Speaker 4: not worthy.
- 1:35:19Speaker 3: Caleb Asques Pikaf once got a letter from a Greek
- 1:35:22Speaker 3: historian on a show on the Rise of Ancient Greece.
- 1:35:26Speaker 3: The idea was an intersection of self fish high barbarians
- 1:35:32Speaker 3: with intellectual exchange of global trade. Always wanted to hear
- 1:35:37Speaker 3: Greg's thoughts.
- 1:35:39Speaker 2: I wonder if he's talking about Steve Jillivtt.
- 1:35:41Speaker 1: Yeah, I think so. I think so.
- 1:35:43Speaker 2: I had some communications with letters about that.
- 1:35:46Speaker 4: I'm not enough of a historian and particularly of the
- 1:35:49Speaker 4: period of sort of you know, archaic Greece to have
- 1:35:56Speaker 4: well developed opinions on just you know why it happened
- 1:35:59Speaker 4: when it and particularly if we're talking about you know,
- 1:36:02Speaker 4: why Homer happened, as opposed to why Thailies happened, or
- 1:36:05Speaker 4: why Plato.
- 1:36:05Speaker 2: Happened, or you know why they were able to develop there.
- 1:36:09Speaker 4: Jason Ryans is someone who knows a lot more about
- 1:36:11Speaker 4: this and whatever, a lot more thoughts about and D.
- 1:36:13Speaker 4: He's teaching a course for the iron Ran University now on.
- 1:36:17Speaker 4: I think he's gonna do a series of courses on
- 1:36:18Speaker 4: Greek culture and history, but he started with this early period,
- 1:36:22Speaker 4: so i'd really recommend I haven't. I haven't heard the course, actually,
- 1:36:25Speaker 4: but he just told me a bit much about what
- 1:36:27Speaker 4: he wanted to cover, and we talked about some of
- 1:36:29Speaker 4: his notes for a night. I'd really recommend looking to that.
- 1:36:32Speaker 4: I do think that the being at nexus of trade.
- 1:36:39Speaker 2: Is really important for the development of ideas.
- 1:36:41Speaker 4: And if you think about where the kind of Greek
- 1:36:43Speaker 4: ideas developed and when, including when the center of where
- 1:36:48Speaker 4: the intellectual hubs were shifted, it had a lot to
- 1:36:51Speaker 4: do with where we're the look I give trade.
- 1:36:55Speaker 3: Yeah, uh, Lucinda. Any vice on how to best approach
- 1:37:02Speaker 3: learning music theory?
- 1:37:06Speaker 4: Well, that's an interesting question for me. So I've not
- 1:37:10Speaker 4: had kind of formal education in music theory like you
- 1:37:15Speaker 4: get if you go to a conservatory, and I always
- 1:37:18Speaker 4: or take music theory classes, and I always kind of
- 1:37:21Speaker 4: wonder a bit how much music theory I know when
- 1:37:23Speaker 4: I talk to people who know what I seem to
- 1:37:25Speaker 4: know a lot to me, but there are other things
- 1:37:27Speaker 4: I don't write on the terms for it, the.
- 1:37:33Speaker 2: You. What I care.
- 1:37:38Speaker 4: About and would care about in learning music is to
- 1:37:41Speaker 4: have a conceptual understanding of what I'm doing in playing
- 1:37:44Speaker 4: music or writing it, so that it's not an issue
- 1:37:47Speaker 4: of you know, I hit these two notes and I
- 1:37:50Speaker 4: don't know why they go together, and I don't know
- 1:37:51Speaker 4: what I'm doing, and I don't understand what a key is,
- 1:37:53Speaker 4: or what a court is or what a resolution is.
- 1:37:55Speaker 4: But I think if you learn, I don't know because
- 1:38:05Speaker 4: I don't really. I mean, I had guitar lessons from
- 1:38:07Speaker 4: a jazz kind of guitar player when I was first
- 1:38:09Speaker 4: learning guitar, and he talked a lot about chords, And
- 1:38:11Speaker 4: there's just I don't have enough separated out about the
- 1:38:15Speaker 4: different ways you could learn it, on the different approaches
- 1:38:17Speaker 4: to have. On three, I have how I explain it
- 1:38:20Speaker 4: to people when they ask me about different things when
- 1:38:22Speaker 4: they don't know anything about music.
- 1:38:24Speaker 2: But that's different than advice on how to learn it.
- 1:38:27Speaker 2: And then I don't know that.
- 1:38:28Speaker 3: Everything John asks, did rand ever read an entire book
- 1:38:34Speaker 3: of cons or even an entire essay?
- 1:38:38Speaker 4: Well, he's not really an essayist unless you're thinking of
- 1:38:40Speaker 4: things like what is the what is enlightenment? I don't
- 1:38:45Speaker 4: if you're asking me, is like a historian of her,
- 1:38:47Speaker 4: a scholar of her. We don't have direct documentary evidence.
- 1:38:50Speaker 4: We don't have like whole books that are marked up,
- 1:38:53Speaker 4: So I don't know.
- 1:38:54Speaker 1: You read examptly, what's your evaluation of her? Evaluation of content?
- 1:39:02Speaker 4: It's accurate, but at a very high level, So it's
- 1:39:06Speaker 4: not an evaluation of this bit of this argument at
- 1:39:09Speaker 4: this place, but kind of what's in general going on
- 1:39:12Speaker 4: in this work and what's its historical significance. And I
- 1:39:15Speaker 4: think people underestimate the value of that kind of thinking
- 1:39:22Speaker 4: and of you know, tertiary works in history. Nobody understands
- 1:39:27Speaker 4: the history of philosophy by having read all the books
- 1:39:32Speaker 4: in it one by one and thought about them just
- 1:39:35Speaker 4: on their own.
- 1:39:36Speaker 2: And and it's like, even if you've done that.
- 1:39:38Speaker 4: And I've read you know a lot of them, or
- 1:39:40Speaker 4: certainly on everything, right, your ability to do that and
- 1:39:44Speaker 4: to integrate them and think about how they relate to
- 1:39:45Speaker 4: each other is depending a lot on scaffolding that you're
- 1:39:49Speaker 4: getting from secondary and tertiary sources that try to integrate
- 1:39:52Speaker 4: it on what you're thinking about, is this integration right
- 1:39:55Speaker 4: or wrong? And a lot of the work is this
- 1:39:58Speaker 4: kind of big picture putting things to do together and
- 1:40:00Speaker 4: then checking it with spot readings of particular things.
- 1:40:04Speaker 2: And things that you you know, picking a few things
- 1:40:07Speaker 2: that you go deep on.
- 1:40:10Speaker 4: Leonard Peacock certainly went deep on a lot of these
- 1:40:13Speaker 4: particular texts and arguments, and Rand was kind of talking
- 1:40:18Speaker 4: to him throughout his doing that, and like, I'm sure
- 1:40:20Speaker 4: she worked through things, like I'm pretty confident that you
- 1:40:24Speaker 4: worked through particular arguments in the first critique with Leonard
- 1:40:28Speaker 4: when he was writing lectures on them. So, but whether
- 1:40:30Speaker 4: she ever sat down and read the whole thing, you know,
- 1:40:32Speaker 4: cover to cover, I don't know.
- 1:40:37Speaker 3: R Justin asked, what is your evaluation of the first
- 1:40:40Speaker 3: fifty days of the Trump administration?
- 1:40:46Speaker 4: Bad? But it's hard to tell how much on the
- 1:40:51Speaker 4: specifics because we're in a kind of bog of war
- 1:40:54Speaker 4: situation where, for example, it's hard to actually know what
- 1:40:58Speaker 4: Dodge is doing and or whatever you call it, and
- 1:41:01Speaker 4: what's going to come out of it.
- 1:41:02Speaker 2: What will they save any money at all?
- 1:41:04Speaker 4: How much disruption is being caused by their acting in
- 1:41:08Speaker 4: erratic ways, how much of that would be necessary to
- 1:41:11Speaker 4: accomplish some good ends if they have them, or if.
- 1:41:14Speaker 2: They have them.
- 1:41:15Speaker 4: So there's a lot that it's hard to rely on
- 1:41:17Speaker 4: the reporting about the details of things, And I don't
- 1:41:20Speaker 4: think it's that good to think in terms of ten days,
- 1:41:22Speaker 4: twenty days, thirty day, second week, first month, whatever. The
- 1:41:26Speaker 4: essential of Trump is that his whole person in his
- 1:41:32Speaker 4: political career is an attack on rationality, on principle, and
- 1:41:38Speaker 4: on morality, and we're seeing that kind of in the
- 1:41:42Speaker 4: way the administration conducts itself in a lot of fields.
- 1:41:45Speaker 4: But also I think there's a lot to be desired
- 1:41:49Speaker 4: in a kind of reporting that's happening. And so it's
- 1:41:51Speaker 4: just hard to know too much of the details or
- 1:41:56Speaker 4: or I.
- 1:41:56Speaker 3: Don't Sormary, what do you think about the trend of
- 1:42:03Speaker 3: tech embracing MAGA.
- 1:42:07Speaker 4: It's a little hard to know.
- 1:42:10Speaker 2: How real it is.
- 1:42:12Speaker 4: So we are in the period for MAGA that's analogous
- 1:42:19Speaker 4: to just after George Floyd for wocism. Right, there's a
- 1:42:24Speaker 4: kind of a sense that this is what we're supposed
- 1:42:27Speaker 4: to say.
- 1:42:27Speaker 2: There's a fear of.
- 1:42:32Speaker 4: Certain belligerent and outspoken people who will kind of push
- 1:42:35Speaker 4: back on you in various ways, and and maybe harm
- 1:42:38Speaker 4: you electorally, or harm you, you know, through the power
- 1:42:41Speaker 4: of government or through mob action if you say too
- 1:42:45Speaker 4: much of the wrong things. And there are a lot
- 1:42:47Speaker 4: of people who, uh, you know, for for certain party lines,
- 1:42:50Speaker 4: and there are a lot of people who are would
- 1:42:53Speaker 4: have seen themselves as generally aligned with something like, you know,
- 1:42:57Speaker 4: I'm generally supportive of minority rights or or or or
- 1:43:00Speaker 4: just I think of myself as generally on the left.
- 1:43:03Speaker 4: Somebody would think, but like, what's going on now is
- 1:43:05Speaker 4: crazy and I'm not comfortable with it, but I'm afraid
- 1:43:08Speaker 4: to say it. And I think a lot of people
- 1:43:09Speaker 4: had that feeling in the wake of the George Floyd
- 1:43:13Speaker 4: and the rioting and the white fragility becoming a you know,
- 1:43:17Speaker 4: a big best seller and all of that. And I
- 1:43:18Speaker 4: think we're we're in a similar space with people who
- 1:43:23Speaker 4: see themselves as anti left, unhappy with the left, looking
- 1:43:28Speaker 4: for something new and mechanism that there are a lot
- 1:43:34Speaker 4: of people who I think, this isn't what I was
- 1:43:36Speaker 4: looking for, This isn't what I signed up for. I
- 1:43:38Speaker 4: was curious about another option, but I'm not sure this
- 1:43:40Speaker 4: is it. I was always kind of look warm on it,
- 1:43:42Speaker 4: but they're I think not, you know, they're not in
- 1:43:48Speaker 4: a place where those opinions are they ready to voice.
- 1:43:50Speaker 4: And it's hard to tell of the people who are
- 1:43:54Speaker 4: tech people who are more enthusiastic about Trump, how many
- 1:43:59Speaker 4: of them are really bought into madding in the same
- 1:44:02Speaker 4: way that it's was hard to tell how many of
- 1:44:05Speaker 4: the businesses that put up BLM signs, you know, that
- 1:44:08Speaker 4: was really what they were about, or is it a
- 1:44:09Speaker 4: kind of bandwagon or fear or capitulation. So I don't
- 1:44:14Speaker 4: think we'll know yet what to make of this for
- 1:44:17Speaker 4: a few months or a few years.
- 1:44:20Speaker 3: What do you think of Rene Gerard, whom Peter tele
- 1:44:24Speaker 3: considers his favorite philosopher.
- 1:44:26Speaker 2: I've never read him. I've heard Teal talk about him.
- 1:44:29Speaker 2: I was at a conference.
- 1:44:30Speaker 4: Once where Teal was speaking, and I've read some secondary
- 1:44:35Speaker 4: articles on the connection, but I've never I've never read
- 1:44:37Speaker 4: then of them.
- 1:44:43Speaker 3: Why it says if elun Musk is supposedly not a
- 1:44:47Speaker 3: nine ran hero, I challenge you to name Betta. You
- 1:44:52Speaker 3: name somebody, real life example, who's better, who are more
- 1:44:56Speaker 3: consistent than a lun Musk?
- 1:45:00Speaker 4: Well, right now, I think Jeff Bezos, even prior to
- 1:45:03Speaker 4: the recent thing with the post has always struck me
- 1:45:06Speaker 4: as a better example of an Iran hero than mosque
- 1:45:10Speaker 4: Steve Jobs. But none of these people are are our
- 1:45:15Speaker 4: perfect embodiments of a fictional character. Fictional characters are idealized,
- 1:45:19Speaker 4: and just like you can't, you know, point to someone
- 1:45:23Speaker 4: who is a Jean Valjean or or a Hester Prynn
- 1:45:31Speaker 4: or whatever like exactly. Real people aren't exactly like any
- 1:45:35Speaker 4: fictional characters, and the fictional characters are are heightened and exaggerated.
- 1:45:39Speaker 4: And Elon Musk is like an Iran hero in certain
- 1:45:42Speaker 4: respects in certain areas of his life at certain times,
- 1:45:45Speaker 4: and like an Iron Brand villain in other respects in
- 1:45:47Speaker 4: other areas of his time, as a lot of people
- 1:45:49Speaker 4: are right now if one wants to think about, the
- 1:45:59Speaker 4: implication is that either these people are great all around,
- 1:46:02Speaker 4: or or and Rand's novels are unrealistic, and there's a
- 1:46:05Speaker 4: respect in which they are unrealistic and are meant to be.
- 1:46:11Speaker 4: They're they're stylized and dramatized, and they're they're calling attention
- 1:46:15Speaker 4: to some of the real causal forces at work in
- 1:46:18Speaker 4: human life and in the human mind, but by showing
- 1:46:21Speaker 4: them in a purer, higher relief form.
- 1:46:23Speaker 2: Then you normally see them or maybe almost ever.
- 1:46:26Speaker 4: See them, so you know, they just are different than
- 1:46:29Speaker 4: the people you meet, even if in essentials sometimes they're
- 1:46:32Speaker 4: the same. And if you want to think about how
- 1:46:34Speaker 4: is Atlas maybe a little on one of the respects
- 1:46:38Speaker 4: in which Atlas is unrealistic and I think, uh intentionally
- 1:46:43Speaker 4: so is that the the heroes of it, even though
- 1:46:50Speaker 4: they in various senses sanction the bad regime and and
- 1:46:55Speaker 4: need to learn to withdraw their sanction from it. You
- 1:47:00Speaker 4: don't see, like, you know, Hank really reared and you know,
- 1:47:04Speaker 4: really being in favor of Clifton Losi as opposed to
- 1:47:08Speaker 4: you know, Clifton sorry of of mister Thompson as opposed
- 1:47:11Speaker 4: to his political rival, and where you you can't imagine,
- 1:47:15Speaker 4: you know, uh Dagne and Hank having an argument where
- 1:47:18Speaker 4: one of them is is supporting you know, one party
- 1:47:22Speaker 4: and the other the other. They're they're they have a
- 1:47:24Speaker 4: pan of contempt and disinterest in what's going on in politics.
- 1:47:27Speaker 4: They they they viewed a lot of them as bad
- 1:47:29Speaker 4: and they're not. There are factional rivalries you can tell
- 1:47:32Speaker 4: in the politics about the trunk, but it's at such
- 1:47:35Speaker 4: a remove from the what any of the heroes are
- 1:47:39Speaker 4: thinking about, so they couldn't imagine being aligned with one
- 1:47:42Speaker 4: or the other. And in fact, what happens is that,
- 1:47:46Speaker 4: you know, many of the great business people and great
- 1:47:49Speaker 4: people in general get caught up in the the factional
- 1:47:55Speaker 4: rivalries among status politicians.
- 1:47:58Speaker 2: You know, there are some who are it's dude enough
- 1:48:02Speaker 2: to see to not do that, But in general, that's.
- 1:48:06Speaker 4: What happens, and that's part of why it's so much harder,
- 1:48:10Speaker 4: too to turn a society around. Then it would be
- 1:48:15Speaker 4: if if all the best people, in proportion to how
- 1:48:17Speaker 4: good they were, were, you know, not on the side
- 1:48:23Speaker 4: of Joe Biden or Donald Trump or or or you
- 1:48:27Speaker 4: know some other.
- 1:48:30Speaker 2: H grifter.
- 1:48:33Speaker 1: Dave asks, as a professor, do you consider students using
- 1:48:36Speaker 1: AI to whole cloth develop their homework assignments to be
- 1:48:40Speaker 1: a form of cheating, form of intellectual second hand in
- 1:48:44Speaker 1: this oh.
- 1:48:46Speaker 4: Law, like they just put the thing in in the end. Yeah,
- 1:48:48Speaker 4: that's then just not doing the assignment. I think, you know,
- 1:48:52Speaker 4: there are good ways to use AI in your thinking,
- 1:48:55Speaker 4: in your research, and I think teachers need to need to,
- 1:49:00Speaker 4: more frankly than I have, think about what good kind
- 1:49:03Speaker 4: of assignments that make good use of AI is or
- 1:49:07Speaker 4: what such good assignments would be, and how you could
- 1:49:09Speaker 4: use it in the writing and editing process and so forth.
- 1:49:11Speaker 4: And in part because the technology is developing so quickly
- 1:49:14Speaker 4: and it can do different things this year than it
- 1:49:17Speaker 4: can do last year, it's it's it's it's hard to
- 1:49:20Speaker 4: develop those those kind of assignments and so forth. But
- 1:49:23Speaker 4: so I don't think, you know, no one should use
- 1:49:25Speaker 4: it and shouldn't be used anywhere to do with anything
- 1:49:27Speaker 4: in school. But if what you're doing is using it
- 1:49:29Speaker 4: to do your homework for you, then then yeah, it's cheating.
- 1:49:34Speaker 3: H Do you agree with Richard Hanania that the right
- 1:49:37Speaker 3: has a low human capital problem.
- 1:49:43Speaker 4: In a way, But I don't think that's the deepest
- 1:49:46Speaker 4: or right way to put it.
- 1:49:50Speaker 1: How would you put it?
- 1:49:51Speaker 4: I mean, I think there's it's right now appealing to
- 1:50:00Speaker 4: and trying to appeal differentially to uneducated people. And there's
- 1:50:07Speaker 4: I think reasons why it's been that way for some time,
- 1:50:12Speaker 4: but they're they're somewhat ideological, Like if essentially nobody's ready
- 1:50:20Speaker 4: to reject Christianity rooting branch, and if you're not ready
- 1:50:24Speaker 4: to reject Christianity root and branch, you should be a socialist.
- 1:50:29Speaker 4: That's the political implication of Christianity. So if you're going
- 1:50:33Speaker 4: to have an anti socialist party in a country that's
- 1:50:38Speaker 4: like that, either it's got to be really radical and
- 1:50:42Speaker 4: trying to uproot altruism and religion, you know, from the basis,
- 1:50:46Speaker 4: it's got to be a party driven by Enlightenment ideas.
- 1:50:49Speaker 4: And even if it's not going to say, you know,
- 1:50:51Speaker 4: we're anti Christian in every respect, it's going to have
- 1:50:53Speaker 4: to be pro individualism and pro reason and et cetera
- 1:50:57Speaker 4: in a way that no party has been in quite
- 1:50:59Speaker 4: a very long time. Or it's going to have to
- 1:51:06Speaker 4: be selling kind of obvious versions of having your cake
- 1:51:08Speaker 4: and eating it too, and it's going to have to
- 1:51:12Speaker 4: be distracting people from the ways in which their ideas
- 1:51:14Speaker 4: are inconsistent. And I think both of our parties are
- 1:51:18Speaker 4: you know, do that in different ways.
- 1:51:20Speaker 2: But the.
- 1:51:23Speaker 4: Fact that the Right has been associated or the Republicans,
- 1:51:27Speaker 4: I don't think it's an accident of the party that's
- 1:51:29Speaker 4: associated with capitalism in a culture that's unwilling to.
- 1:51:36Speaker 2: Break with the bad ideas that.
- 1:51:39Speaker 4: Are inimical to capitalism in it that that party has
- 1:51:42Speaker 4: become kind of religious and more anti intellectual.
- 1:51:51Speaker 3: Justin says you said Trump was evil in the Youreon
- 1:51:54Speaker 3: book show last year. Do you still stand by that?
- 1:51:57Speaker 2: Yeah?
- 1:51:58Speaker 1: Absolutely.
- 1:52:01Speaker 3: Lucinda, a German intellectual, recently argued that Plato would look
- 1:52:05Speaker 3: positively upon Germany's democracy. To me, the whole approach seems
- 1:52:09Speaker 3: anachronistic and not very convincing any thoughts.
- 1:52:14Speaker 4: Yeah, I agree. You can't that this kind of thing
- 1:52:18Speaker 4: is an achronistic unless you're using Plato as a kind
- 1:52:20Speaker 4: of symbol of something very abstract, like you know, he
- 1:52:24Speaker 4: was for principle or something like that, or he was
- 1:52:29Speaker 4: for this. But like, if you're trying to think about
- 1:52:32Speaker 4: how somebody would think about a particular political development, you
- 1:52:38Speaker 4: have to think not just about what were their views
- 1:52:41Speaker 4: very abstractly, but how did they understand the world they
- 1:52:47Speaker 4: were in in their time? Uh, And that's why they
- 1:52:50Speaker 4: viewed things the way they did.
- 1:52:51Speaker 2: Like, if you're.
- 1:52:51Speaker 4: Trying to think about why does one person among people
- 1:52:57Speaker 4: who think that there's you know, a lot wrong with
- 1:53:00Speaker 4: Trump and a lot wrong with the Democrats. Among people
- 1:53:04Speaker 4: who say to themselves as objectivists, why are some of
- 1:53:06Speaker 4: them regard one as the lesser of two evils, and
- 1:53:08Speaker 4: others as the other the other lesser.
- 1:53:10Speaker 2: Of two evils.
- 1:53:11Speaker 4: Like, it's not always and only about differences at the
- 1:53:14Speaker 4: level of philosophy. It's also about like differences the level
- 1:53:17Speaker 4: of like, how do you understand where we are in history?
- 1:53:20Speaker 2: And what kind of world?
- 1:53:21Speaker 4: Where like are we, you know, ten minutes away from
- 1:53:24Speaker 4: our very inhortanvating, or are we like you know, where
- 1:53:27Speaker 4: are we? How do we understand like where we are
- 1:53:29Speaker 4: now in history and what's going on in history? And
- 1:53:33Speaker 4: you need to think about that, think about how people
- 1:53:35Speaker 4: would understand specific political developments, even what would I Ran
- 1:53:39Speaker 4: think about this election or that election or whatever forty
- 1:53:41Speaker 4: years after she died of fifty, you have to kind
- 1:53:43Speaker 4: of project, well, how would you understand all the things
- 1:53:45Speaker 4: that happened in between her time and then, and then
- 1:53:48Speaker 4: apply it to now. Well, if you're you're talking about
- 1:53:50Speaker 4: somebody who lived in ancient Greece, there wasn't industry, there
- 1:53:53Speaker 4: weren't machines. That The only kind of democracy there was,
- 1:53:56Speaker 4: didn't you know, was in small countries where people could
- 1:54:00Speaker 4: practically all know each other until like so many things,
- 1:54:03Speaker 4: you have to kind of Plato's view of any particular
- 1:54:07Speaker 4: current development, unless again we're just taking him as a
- 1:54:09Speaker 4: symbol for somebody who believed this very abstract thing. But
- 1:54:12Speaker 4: if you're taking him as a person with a whole
- 1:54:14Speaker 4: lot of thoughts and how you have to think about, like,
- 1:54:16Speaker 4: how would you have processed, you know, one hundred and
- 1:54:19Speaker 4: fifty totally world changing things that have happened between his
- 1:54:22Speaker 4: time and now to think like, you know, what do
- 1:54:24Speaker 4: you think German unification was a good or bad thing?
- 1:54:26Speaker 4: Or what would you think about you know, AfD or
- 1:54:29Speaker 4: this is like it's just you know, it's that's the inactroncement.
- 1:54:35Speaker 3: Justin Do you have any theory on what's happening to
- 1:54:38Speaker 3: Elon Musk? He seems to be spiraling out of control.
- 1:54:42Speaker 4: No, I don't know that much about him personally, and
- 1:54:45Speaker 4: there's not that much information available, you know, and it's
- 1:54:50Speaker 4: hard to know. When someone asks in a way that's
- 1:54:54Speaker 4: surprising for the bad or surprising for the good, it
- 1:54:57Speaker 4: then makes you think about either reinterpret his earlier a
- 1:55:00Speaker 4: since maybe you know, at times when they seemed better,
- 1:55:03Speaker 4: less of it was really him and more of it,
- 1:55:04Speaker 4: you know, we're with someone handling him or I don't know,
- 1:55:08Speaker 4: I don't know enough about I don't think any someone might.
- 1:55:11Speaker 4: But I don't think that much is publicly known about
- 1:55:14Speaker 4: the facts of his life and what's going on that
- 1:55:17Speaker 4: I don't think most people should be speculating about him.
- 1:55:19Speaker 4: I don't certainly am not in a position to, except
- 1:55:21Speaker 4: to say that he's obviously his businesses have obviously accomplished
- 1:55:27Speaker 4: a lot. He seems to have a lot to do
- 1:55:29Speaker 4: with that. It doesn't seem accidental like he was just
- 1:55:31Speaker 4: a figurehead as far as I can tell. And he's
- 1:55:35Speaker 4: now acting in some ways that are really disturbing and wrong,
- 1:55:39Speaker 4: and more than any particular thing he's doing politically or
- 1:55:43Speaker 4: which kennedyates he's supporting, it's the kind of thing that
- 1:55:46Speaker 4: actually Hananya has very been very eloquent on the kind
- 1:55:49Speaker 4: of spreading on X of not even what the content policy,
- 1:55:53Speaker 4: but he's personal spreading on X of all kinds of
- 1:55:57Speaker 4: you know, irrational viciousness and and and and the the
- 1:56:04Speaker 4: enforcing a very low epistemic standard through his own conduct
- 1:56:07Speaker 4: and what he what he praises. That I think is
- 1:56:10Speaker 4: the most most troubling thing about must Why, I mean,
- 1:56:15Speaker 4: won't could discuss, but I think there are real challenges
- 1:56:22Speaker 4: in being an exceptional person for the good and and
- 1:56:27Speaker 4: and having contrary opinions to the people around you, and
- 1:56:30Speaker 4: being a strong personality who's able to get a lot
- 1:56:33Speaker 4: a lot done and I'm by force of will and
- 1:56:35Speaker 4: perseverance accomplished things there are there are if you're that
- 1:56:43Speaker 4: kind of person, and in general, if you're any good
- 1:56:46Speaker 4: kind of person, if you're unusual in any respect.
- 1:56:49Speaker 2: For the good, A lot of the kind of standard
- 1:56:54Speaker 2: ways of acting or typical behaviors or things everybody learns
- 1:56:57Speaker 2: when they're young that help them to be not stand
- 1:57:01Speaker 2: out in bad ways, like don't work for you. You
- 1:57:04Speaker 2: have to kind of re engineer those things for yourself,
- 1:57:06Speaker 2: given what's distinctive about you. It maybe it serves you
- 1:57:11Speaker 2: not to care too much about what other people think
- 1:57:12Speaker 2: in some situations where maybe you should listen to more
- 1:57:15Speaker 2: other people if you're like.
- 1:57:16Speaker 4: Way more often right than them on certain things. And
- 1:57:18Speaker 4: so there are certain kinds of habits or abilities exceptional
- 1:57:24Speaker 4: kind of people often have to re engineer for themselves.
- 1:57:28Speaker 4: And there are failure modes of people who are really
- 1:57:33Speaker 4: good at certain things that come about by failures to
- 1:57:36Speaker 4: do that, particularly when they get into new and different
- 1:57:39Speaker 4: kinds of situations, and you could guess that something in
- 1:57:42Speaker 4: that genre is, you know, to do with what's going
- 1:57:45Speaker 4: on with Musk, But any more than that I think
- 1:57:47Speaker 4: would just be going way beyond.
- 1:57:48Speaker 2: But certainly I can.
- 1:57:50Speaker 1: Know justin ask any thoughts on Kurtis Yovin's philosophy.
- 1:57:59Speaker 4: What I know of it is, you know, it strikes
- 1:58:04Speaker 4: me as juvenile and sophmoric. But that's the kind of
- 1:58:06Speaker 4: thing people say about Iran who don't know her well.
- 1:58:09Speaker 4: And I think there's real reasons to think that it
- 1:58:12Speaker 4: is juvenile and some more in his case, but I've
- 1:58:14Speaker 4: not done a real deep dive into him.
- 1:58:19Speaker 3: Matt, my brother, believes we can only ever a simp simp.
- 1:58:27Speaker 1: Asymptotically approach absolute truth with there always being some move
- 1:58:34Speaker 1: f uncertainty. Can you try to steal man and then
- 1:58:37Speaker 1: argue against this position?
- 1:58:40Speaker 4: So this is the classic kind of pragmatist view. So
- 1:58:45Speaker 4: truth is the ideal end of inquiry, and we can
- 1:58:50Speaker 4: approach it but never reach it. So there's a kind
- 1:58:54Speaker 4: of wrong.
- 1:58:57Speaker 2: It might view.
- 1:58:58Speaker 4: There's a wrong view of consciousness behind this, and I'm
- 1:59:00Speaker 4: not going to quite treat it as steelman and then
- 1:59:02Speaker 4: attack because I don't think that's actually the right method
- 1:59:05Speaker 4: for dealing with ideas. But what is this view and
- 1:59:09Speaker 4: what's its nature? And the nature of the view is
- 1:59:11Speaker 4: you have the idea. You find this in the paparians
- 1:59:14Speaker 4: a lot, and you find it in pragmatists that in effect,
- 1:59:18Speaker 4: we have a kind of mental model or mental picture
- 1:59:21Speaker 4: of reality, and it never perfectly matches reality, but where
- 1:59:27Speaker 4: we don't ask where it came from or how it
- 1:59:29Speaker 4: got there. It's just everyone's got a mental picture somewhere,
- 1:59:31Speaker 4: and then the work of knowing an inquiry is trying
- 1:59:34Speaker 4: to gradually make that closer and closer to reality, and
- 1:59:39Speaker 4: you can never achieve it. And notice that the way
- 1:59:43Speaker 4: this works is it's sort of like treating your whole
- 1:59:47Speaker 4: picture of reality as the unit, and you're modifying it
- 1:59:51Speaker 4: to get there. And what is the kind of absolute truth?
- 1:59:53Speaker 4: What is the idea of absolutely Like he said it
- 1:59:55Speaker 4: two plus two absolutely that two plus two is four
- 1:59:57Speaker 4: absolutely true? Well, yeah, but it's not a it's a
- 2:00:01Speaker 4: limited thing. It's just one fact. And what we're thinking
- 2:00:04Speaker 4: about when we're thinking about the absolute truth is the
- 2:00:05Speaker 4: whole And so it's just kind of Hegelian practmatist notion
- 2:00:08Speaker 4: that we're judging your whole kind of mental set, your
- 2:00:11Speaker 4: whole view of reality, and that thing can only get
- 2:00:14Speaker 4: closer and closer than the truth, but can never be
- 2:00:15Speaker 4: absolutely true.
- 2:00:16Speaker 2: But in fact, what truth and falsehould apply to.
- 2:00:19Speaker 4: As I understand it, is not the whole of your cognition,
- 2:00:23Speaker 4: but particular claims. And if you think about particular claims
- 2:00:27Speaker 4: as being true or false, but it can be true
- 2:00:29Speaker 4: or false. Two plus two is four. You know, Biden
- 2:00:34Speaker 4: did win the joy twenty election and Trump one did
- 2:00:39Speaker 4: win the twenty twenty four election. And we could think
- 2:00:41Speaker 4: about how we know these things, and there are other
- 2:00:45Speaker 4: things that are mere approximations. We don't know the answer
- 2:00:48Speaker 4: to this, but we know it's somewhere in this range.
- 2:00:51Speaker 4: And what's going on in this way of looking at
- 2:00:56Speaker 4: it is the real crux or the focal point you
- 2:00:59Speaker 4: have to think about, is can we know specific things
- 2:01:04Speaker 4: and then have other things we don't know? And you
- 2:01:06Speaker 4: think like I'm certain of this, I know that I
- 2:01:08Speaker 4: don't know that, And some things are known and they're true,
- 2:01:10Speaker 4: and other things you don't know what's true and until
- 2:01:12Speaker 4: forth or is the unit of judgment and effect omniscience?
- 2:01:16Speaker 4: So there's you're to have the truth would be to
- 2:01:20Speaker 4: know everything about everything, in which case nobody could do
- 2:01:22Speaker 4: it and you can only approach it. And anything not
- 2:01:25Speaker 4: knowing about one thing counts as being less sure or
- 2:01:29Speaker 4: less fully knowing about something else. That's I think the
- 2:01:31Speaker 4: kind of view of knowledge that's in the background behind
- 2:01:34Speaker 4: the asyntatically approaching truth model.
- 2:01:40Speaker 1: Let's see p Gupta.
- 2:01:43Speaker 3: Some of my friends think Trump isn't any worse than
- 2:01:46Speaker 3: recent presidents overall, but just unwilling or unable to hide it.
- 2:01:51Speaker 3: He's only more obvious. What would you say, makes him
- 2:01:56Speaker 3: essentially more bad?
- 2:01:58Speaker 4: So first of all, I think that's the best case
- 2:02:01Speaker 4: one can make for him. So the best thing one
- 2:02:04Speaker 4: could say about Trump and the best case for him is, yeah,
- 2:02:06Speaker 4: this was all going on the whole time. He's just
- 2:02:09Speaker 4: bringing it out in the open. And maybe it's better
- 2:02:11Speaker 4: to have it out in the open than David Crafty
- 2:02:13Speaker 4: and hit and everybody can see what it is and
- 2:02:15Speaker 4: so forth. But I don't think that's true. I think
- 2:02:22Speaker 4: what a society accepts in its leaders matters for who
- 2:02:28Speaker 4: it is and how it's going to develop. And there's
- 2:02:35Speaker 4: a difference between There's that old line that what's the line.
- 2:02:39Speaker 4: Something is hypocrisy is the tribute that vice plays to
- 2:02:45Speaker 4: virtue or something like that. There's a difference between down
- 2:02:52Speaker 4: with standards and trying to cheat on the standards. And
- 2:02:57Speaker 4: I don't think it's true that everybody in the government
- 2:03:00Speaker 4: and the government as a whole has been entirely non
- 2:03:05Speaker 4: objective and driven by caprice and arbitrarys. There's been way
- 2:03:08Speaker 4: too much of that. But a big part of what
- 2:03:11Speaker 4: makes America function is that America, I think, has a
- 2:03:14Speaker 4: kind of immune system of objectivity in our political lives.
- 2:03:20Speaker 4: Americans and including American bureaucrats, are by and large not
- 2:03:24Speaker 4: power lusters.
- 2:03:25Speaker 2: There are power lusters among them, but there's a culture of.
- 2:03:32Speaker 4: When people are given too much power, when they're given
- 2:03:36Speaker 4: arbitrary caprice, that they try to come up with ways
- 2:03:41Speaker 4: of rationalizing and justifying what they're doing and giving themselves
- 2:03:46Speaker 4: standards to which they're accountable for that even if they
- 2:03:50Speaker 4: fudge and twist them and so forth. Along the borderlines.
- 2:03:52Speaker 4: They have a sense of there's controls on what I
- 2:03:55Speaker 4: can do. I'm not a dictator, I'm not a king,
- 2:03:57Speaker 4: and I'm thinking about like people at all the arreas
- 2:04:00Speaker 4: their mental agencies and drug regulars and all these people
- 2:04:02Speaker 4: who have powers they shouldn't have and who our lives
- 2:04:06Speaker 4: are too much in their hands given how much power
- 2:04:08Speaker 4: they've been granted by Congress and granted by the voters
- 2:04:11Speaker 4: in different ways, Like why aren't things worse than they are?
- 2:04:14Speaker 4: They're pretty bad, but they're they're way better than they
- 2:04:16Speaker 4: are in most places at most times. And I think
- 2:04:19Speaker 4: a reason for that is there's a a a wanting
- 2:04:22Speaker 4: to have procedures, a wanting to have standards, a wanting
- 2:04:26Speaker 4: to be able to justify what you're doing to impartial parties.
- 2:04:30Speaker 4: That is imperfectly there, but really there and a lot
- 2:04:33Speaker 4: of the culture of America and in the American government,
- 2:04:38Speaker 4: and it's to not see that and to kind of
- 2:04:44Speaker 4: attack all elements of the bureaucracy without noticing where there's
- 2:04:53Speaker 4: presences of that and where that's helping us, I think
- 2:04:55Speaker 4: is is destructive.
- 2:05:02Speaker 3: So I justin asked, are you optimistic about the progress
- 2:05:06Speaker 3: movement led by individuals like Jason Crawford.
- 2:05:10Speaker 2: Very much so. So.
- 2:05:12Speaker 4: Jason is a particular bright spot in it, and he's
- 2:05:15Speaker 4: working on a book Tech Optimist Manifesto. I think he's
- 2:05:18Speaker 4: calling it a technic favorites techno optimist or techno humanist manifesto.
- 2:05:22Speaker 2: But he's writing a book. It's coming out in.
- 2:05:25Speaker 4: In little installments on his substack, and I think after
- 2:05:28Speaker 4: that it'll be published just as a whole book. I'm
- 2:05:32Speaker 4: one of you know a number of people who's giving
- 2:05:34Speaker 4: him comments on the chapter says he writes in and
- 2:05:35Speaker 4: they're they're very good.
- 2:05:36Speaker 2: I think so.
- 2:05:38Speaker 4: I'm particularly bullsh about Jason's work and have been since
- 2:05:41Speaker 4: the beginning since he started his his his blog Routs
- 2:05:43Speaker 4: of Progress when it was when it was just a blog.
- 2:05:46Speaker 4: There are other people in this in this field who
- 2:05:48Speaker 4: are good the I'm forgetting his name, But the guy
- 2:05:52Speaker 4: who's at the who's at CATO, who does on their
- 2:05:56Speaker 4: progress stuff, is good Mary, and they put out some
- 2:06:01Speaker 4: fairly good stuff, and I've fiwn him. I'm impressed by
- 2:06:05Speaker 4: some of the work that Derek Thompson has done. Who
- 2:06:07Speaker 4: who's a kind of more left line guy but writes
- 2:06:09Speaker 4: on progress stuff for The Atlantic, And he's the one
- 2:06:12Speaker 4: who's doing a book with Derek Thompson.
- 2:06:14Speaker 2: Now.
- 2:06:14Speaker 4: The essay by Tyler, Cowen and Collison on the Need
- 2:06:18Speaker 4: for a Science of Progress was a really good essay.
- 2:06:22Speaker 4: And I've been to a number of the events that
- 2:06:24Speaker 4: Jason's organized or co organized, and I co organized with
- 2:06:27Speaker 4: him myself at Texas, and most of them have been
- 2:06:30Speaker 4: have been good.
- 2:06:31Speaker 2: Yep.
- 2:06:35Speaker 1: Justin what makes The Godfather great film?
- 2:06:38Speaker 4: In your opinion, Everything that happens happens for a reason
- 2:06:45Speaker 4: that advances the plot and the theme.
- 2:06:47Speaker 2: And it's not just the from.
- 2:06:49Speaker 4: The perspective of the script, the way the shots are composed,
- 2:06:53Speaker 4: the music, everything about it just is well and deliberately
- 2:06:57Speaker 4: chosen to convey what it conveys. Creates a world which
- 2:07:01Speaker 4: is not a pleasant world, but it's a world in
- 2:07:03Speaker 4: which choices have consequences, in which you could see the
- 2:07:07Speaker 4: way people develop and with certain moral facts are are highlighted.
- 2:07:15Speaker 1: Thanks us.
- 2:07:15Speaker 3: How can New Zealand give personhood to a mountain? An inanimate,
- 2:07:19Speaker 3: insatiate object? What is therestional or so? Can you explain
- 2:07:23Speaker 3: called Papa's falsification? Wow, that's a big question.
- 2:07:27Speaker 2: And they're they're very disparate.
- 2:07:28Speaker 4: Yes, I didn't know that Austria that New Zealand gave
- 2:07:33Speaker 4: personhood to.
- 2:07:33Speaker 2: A mountain, right, I don't know anything about this, do you? No?
- 2:07:36Speaker 3: I don't somebody somebody mentioned it in my show Eliah that,
- 2:07:41Speaker 3: but I don't know anything about it.
- 2:07:43Speaker 4: So this is the first time hearing of that. Good
- 2:07:47Speaker 4: luck to the aussis if they think you can make
- 2:07:48Speaker 4: them out to the.
- 2:07:48Speaker 1: Person, it's the new Zealand don't don't don't blame the
- 2:07:51Speaker 1: Nausis for this.
- 2:07:51Speaker 2: One, okay. And the kiwis that kiwis the kiwis good
- 2:07:56Speaker 2: luck to What do you want to explain about his view.
- 2:08:00Speaker 1: Offul playing falsification?
- 2:08:05Speaker 4: I mean, what's more interesting about Popper than the falsificationism?
- 2:08:08Speaker 4: Is the stuff I was talking about before. You get
- 2:08:11Speaker 4: that in conjectures and reputations and other books. But falsificationism
- 2:08:15Speaker 4: is that is what you know, people tend to learn
- 2:08:16Speaker 4: about in a you know, like a philosophy of science
- 2:08:20Speaker 4: for your class, where Popper is taught.
- 2:08:22Speaker 2: And it's the idea that in effect human is right.
- 2:08:25Speaker 4: You can never prove something by induction, and indeed, not
- 2:08:31Speaker 4: only can't you prove it, but you can't get any
- 2:08:33Speaker 4: evidence for it at all. So all that we can
- 2:08:36Speaker 4: do in science things Popper is either falsify a theory
- 2:08:42Speaker 4: or fail to falsify it. And what science does is
- 2:08:45Speaker 4: it puts forth forth a theories, and there's no kind
- 2:08:51Speaker 4: of it's not a rational thing or a matter of
- 2:08:57Speaker 4: reason where the theory came from, or why you thought
- 2:09:00Speaker 4: it in the first place, just you know, whatever you
- 2:09:01Speaker 4: come up with. And then what you do is you
- 2:09:05Speaker 4: use reason to try to find the ideas or theories
- 2:09:10Speaker 4: that have make predictions that could be falsified, make predictions
- 2:09:16Speaker 4: that could turn out to be false, and then you
- 2:09:18Speaker 4: test them. And you have a position where different people
- 2:09:21Speaker 4: advance different theories and they try to falsify them, and
- 2:09:24Speaker 4: you hold on to the ones that have thus far
- 2:09:28Speaker 4: not been falsified. And if you have a kind of
- 2:09:32Speaker 4: system whereby you're doing that and it's vigorous enough and
- 2:09:34Speaker 4: there are enough different people doing it, with enough different
- 2:09:36Speaker 4: theories and so forth, and you're distinguishing between the enterprise
- 2:09:39Speaker 4: of testing falsifiable theories and other things people do where
- 2:09:43Speaker 4: they're expounding things but they're not falsifiable and they're not
- 2:09:46Speaker 4: testing them, then you have reason to think that over time,
- 2:09:50Speaker 4: the batteries battery of theories held by people who are
- 2:09:54Speaker 4: doing this will, you know, get closer to the truth.
- 2:10:00Speaker 3: Hanania still believes in race realism. He doesn't believe it
- 2:10:04Speaker 3: has anything to do with policy anymore?
- 2:10:07Speaker 1: Is this still? Is that still anymall position to hold?
- 2:10:14Speaker 4: I don't necessarily think it depends on why he thinks
- 2:10:16Speaker 4: it and what the issues are, and it's not. I mean,
- 2:10:19Speaker 4: I don't think it's I don't think it's true, and
- 2:10:24Speaker 4: I don't think there's good evidence for it. And I
- 2:10:26Speaker 4: think the reasons people think it have to do with,
- 2:10:30Speaker 4: you know, pretty wrong views of humanity and thinking and
- 2:10:35Speaker 4: bad method in philosophy of science. But if someone and
- 2:10:39Speaker 4: a kind of failure to understand evolution, and there are
- 2:10:43Speaker 4: a number of issues I think are just wrong with
- 2:10:45Speaker 4: the reason why so many people believe some version, a
- 2:10:48Speaker 4: kind of looser soft version of race realism, but.
- 2:10:53Speaker 2: Ar what they might call racialism.
- 2:10:55Speaker 4: The idea that we can detect in the data of
- 2:10:59Speaker 4: what people are good or at pognitively, things that we
- 2:11:03Speaker 4: can tell are results of genetic differences, that's what I
- 2:11:07Speaker 4: and that those map onto ancestral populations roughly what we
- 2:11:11Speaker 4: call racist That's what I would take to be the theory,
- 2:11:13Speaker 4: and I don't think there's evidence for that, but it's
- 2:11:16Speaker 4: I think I think a lot of people believe, and
- 2:11:18Speaker 4: a lot of people who are reasonably good on other things,
- 2:11:22Speaker 4: but have too conventional view of science.
- 2:11:24Speaker 2: And I think that most of.
- 2:11:25Speaker 4: The better people who believe it, or at least suspect
- 2:11:28Speaker 4: that it might be true. I think has as Hananya
- 2:11:31Speaker 4: has come to think that it doesn't have any of
- 2:11:33Speaker 4: the political consequences that a lot of the racists think
- 2:11:36Speaker 4: that it has. And therefore, and that the tendency of
- 2:11:40Speaker 4: people to seize on this and get excited about it
- 2:11:42Speaker 4: and talk about it has to do with them wanting
- 2:11:45Speaker 4: those kind of political consequences. So it's something that we
- 2:11:48Speaker 4: you know, it's reasonably viewed as impolite to focus on
- 2:11:52Speaker 4: or attend to. And I don't regard that position as
- 2:11:57Speaker 4: necessarily a moral in someone who holds it, but I
- 2:11:59Speaker 4: do think it's it.
- 2:12:06Speaker 1: Why do you use the word evade to explain evil?
- 2:12:14Speaker 2: Why do I?
- 2:12:14Speaker 4: I mean, I got the word from min Rand, who
- 2:12:17Speaker 4: uses it, but I think it's a good word. It's
- 2:12:20Speaker 4: meaning avoid, and there's a mental action that her view is,
- 2:12:25Speaker 4: and I think it's right at the root of evil,
- 2:12:27Speaker 4: which is trying to avoid seeing certain things, trying to
- 2:12:35Speaker 4: put certain things out of mind when you suspect that
- 2:12:37Speaker 4: they're trip trying to avoid certain knowledge and evaide seems
- 2:12:42Speaker 4: like a good word for that to a word that
- 2:12:44Speaker 4: means avoid, get away from. And if if there is
- 2:12:48Speaker 4: that mental act, because I think we can tell that
- 2:12:50Speaker 4: there is, and if it is generative of.
- 2:12:54Speaker 2: The kinds of motives that.
- 2:12:58Speaker 4: Lead people to take the very accident, which are the
- 2:13:00Speaker 4: symptoms of evil than evasions of evil, it's a good
- 2:13:04Speaker 4: way to that point. I have a whole talk on this.
- 2:13:06Speaker 4: I think it's up on Ara's Internet on the nature
- 2:13:11Speaker 4: of evil.
- 2:13:14Speaker 3: Frankyeman once noted that she knew of a stronger argument
- 2:13:18Speaker 3: for the existence of God, there was better than the
- 2:13:22Speaker 3: existing arguments. Does anyone in the institute have an inkling
- 2:13:26Speaker 3: of what that argument would be?
- 2:13:30Speaker 4: No, not really. I mean I'm not even positive that
- 2:13:33Speaker 4: she said that. I think she said it, and if
- 2:13:35Speaker 4: she did in some kind of offhand context, like there
- 2:13:37Speaker 4: are better.
- 2:13:38Speaker 2: Arguments than any of these.
- 2:13:39Speaker 4: I think the best argument for the existence of God,
- 2:13:42Speaker 4: or whether it's worth but I know of, is the
- 2:13:44Speaker 4: one Locke makes in book four of his essay I
- 2:13:48Speaker 4: an even understanding, which I.
- 2:13:50Speaker 2: Don't think is ultimately a good argument.
- 2:13:51Speaker 4: I don't want to go into it all now, but
- 2:13:53Speaker 4: for anyone who wants what I think is the best
- 2:13:55Speaker 4: argument to read Locke.
- 2:13:58Speaker 1: Answers. Do you think alone Musk is more like Yale
- 2:14:01Speaker 1: winand or Robert Stadlam.
- 2:14:07Speaker 4: I don't know exactly what's going on with him, and
- 2:14:09Speaker 4: so it's hard to tell. And he's not We're not
- 2:14:11Speaker 4: at the end of his story yet.
- 2:14:14Speaker 2: Yep.
- 2:14:18Speaker 3: Justin what is a rational, non racist explanation for why
- 2:14:22Speaker 3: African American communities still struggle with poverty and crime?
- 2:14:28Speaker 4: Well, I gave a talk on this at at okon
- 2:14:33Speaker 4: and Effect on Racism, so you can look up that
- 2:14:35Speaker 4: talk and see, but it's why the community still struggle
- 2:14:38Speaker 4: with poverty and crime. Well, one way of thinking about
- 2:14:42Speaker 4: it is why do problems persist in these communities rather
- 2:14:49Speaker 4: than getting solved? Right, And some of them have festered
- 2:14:52Speaker 4: and gotten worse. First of all, they festered and gotten worse.
- 2:14:54Speaker 4: They weren't always crime written communities. And there were a
- 2:14:57Speaker 4: series of government policies that have institutionalized certain communities, not
- 2:15:03Speaker 4: just Black communities. I think some appalationan communities too, and
- 2:15:06Speaker 4: so forth into dependency and poverty. That's one thing that's
- 2:15:11Speaker 4: happening on the one hand, right, So think about the
- 2:15:13Speaker 4: War on Poverty and the Great Society programs. Basically, that's
- 2:15:18Speaker 4: what they've done, right, They've institutionalized people who are in
- 2:15:21Speaker 4: poverty into poverty when you already have existing racism. That's
- 2:15:24Speaker 4: causing people to read these things through a racial lens.
- 2:15:27Speaker 4: And then one of the communities that this is happening
- 2:15:29Speaker 4: to is people that people already have a racial prejudice against,
- 2:15:32Speaker 4: and that's going to reinforce it and make it harder
- 2:15:34Speaker 4: for people to escape out of that because it's going
- 2:15:36Speaker 4: to reinforce the.
- 2:15:38Speaker 2: Racism and the racial associations.
- 2:15:40Speaker 4: Then you think, what is the process by which racism
- 2:15:43Speaker 4: is overcome in a society, And the process by which
- 2:15:47Speaker 4: it's overcome is it involves the free market, but involves
- 2:15:52Speaker 4: in particular real market innovations that need to happen when
- 2:15:56Speaker 4: there's a prejudice against something, say against a certain kind
- 2:15:58Speaker 4: of product. Let's say, right, it's not just somebody notices,
- 2:16:02Speaker 4: some entrepreneur notices this product is good, but people don't
- 2:16:04Speaker 4: think it's good, So I'm going to open a store
- 2:16:06Speaker 4: selling it and make a billion dollars. Well, if nobody
- 2:16:08Speaker 4: thinks it's good, and there are reasons they don't think
- 2:16:10Speaker 4: it could, even if they're prejudices or whatever against the product.
- 2:16:12Speaker 4: He's not going to make a billion dollars. He has
- 2:16:14Speaker 4: to figure out. There's a business problem of how do
- 2:16:16Speaker 4: I market this thing? How do I overcome the prejudice,
- 2:16:18Speaker 4: how do I do it right? And so, if there
- 2:16:20Speaker 4: are hiring practices, training differentials, all kinds of things against
- 2:16:24Speaker 4: a certain population that's making it harder for them to
- 2:16:27Speaker 4: find certain work. And there are kind of cultural issues
- 2:16:29Speaker 4: in their community and in other communities that are making
- 2:16:31Speaker 4: boalries create, there's entrepreneurial work that needs to be done
- 2:16:36Speaker 4: to overcome that. There, racism doesn't end just by a
- 2:16:39Speaker 4: law that's enforcing racism disappearing. There's what there's the phrase
- 2:16:44Speaker 4: affirmative action, which is bad and what it's come to mean.
- 2:16:47Speaker 4: But there's something people have to do to overcome it,
- 2:16:49Speaker 4: just like there's something people have to do to overcome
- 2:16:52Speaker 4: any other problem. And if you know that, you know whatever,
- 2:16:55Speaker 4: the magnetic properties of data MAX tapes are better than
- 2:16:58Speaker 4: the magnetic properties or VHS tapes or whatever, that doesn't
- 2:17:00Speaker 4: mean that those tapes will sell better unless you figure
- 2:17:03Speaker 4: out how to market it, how to build a whole
- 2:17:04Speaker 4: business around it, how to correct it's imbalance, and what
- 2:17:06Speaker 4: we've had since the Civil Rights Act.
- 2:17:08Speaker 2: Basically is it's been.
- 2:17:10Speaker 4: Illegal to have any kind of innovation in hiring practices,
- 2:17:13Speaker 4: employment practices around race issues. You have to show that
- 2:17:17Speaker 4: you're not racist by meeting quotas and soil worth.
- 2:17:19Speaker 2: You can't quite have a pepro So.
- 2:17:21Speaker 4: It's made everything to do with race and employment law
- 2:17:24Speaker 4: a covering your ass and box checking exercise. It's totally
- 2:17:27Speaker 4: paralyzed thought in this field for fifty years. And then
- 2:17:33Speaker 4: on top of that, education education is controlled by the
- 2:17:37Speaker 4: government in a way that rules out innovation in the
- 2:17:41Speaker 4: education system right, and then it's made racially sensitive in
- 2:17:45Speaker 4: ways that makes it look away from any differentials because
- 2:17:48Speaker 4: they don't know anything they can do to fix them,
- 2:17:50Speaker 4: so they have to try to cover them up.
- 2:17:51Speaker 2: And there's no kind of innovation.
- 2:17:52Speaker 4: So you have every kind of incentive in the welfare state,
- 2:17:56Speaker 4: in the state control of education, and an affirmative act
- 2:18:01Speaker 4: of hiring law, the Civil Rights Act, in the affirmative
- 2:18:03Speaker 4: action regime that would freeze all the kinds of thinking
- 2:18:06Speaker 4: that would be needed to solve this problem, the anti racist,
- 2:18:10Speaker 4: real anti racist thinking, including thinking about how to overcome
- 2:18:13Speaker 4: these things, not as some kind of duty you know,
- 2:18:15Speaker 4: to society, but as you know, selfishly trying to get
- 2:18:18Speaker 4: the best employees, trying to get the best market share,
- 2:18:20Speaker 4: trying to get the best school, et cetera. Has been
- 2:18:23Speaker 4: made illegal effectively for half a century. And for that reason,
- 2:18:27Speaker 4: you'd expect communities that were hardest hit by this kind
- 2:18:30Speaker 4: of thing to begin with to meyer and wallow in
- 2:18:33Speaker 4: that kind of situation. And that's I think what we've had,
- 2:18:35Speaker 4: and that's why it hit the African American community particularly badly,
- 2:18:38Speaker 4: although there are a few other communities that are hit
- 2:18:40Speaker 4: badly by it. And then you therefore get a kind
- 2:18:43Speaker 4: of culture of dependency and a culture of racism, and
- 2:18:46Speaker 4: a culture of not expecting other people, not expecting black
- 2:18:49Speaker 4: people to do well, and black people not expecting it.
- 2:18:51Speaker 4: And it's not people say it's a cultural problem. The
- 2:18:55Speaker 4: problem isn't Black culture that's bad, although there are bad
- 2:18:57Speaker 4: things in it. But the black culture is a part
- 2:18:59Speaker 4: of the American culture, and it's all set up in.
- 2:19:02Speaker 2: A way that.
- 2:19:04Speaker 4: Enforces racial thinking and lower expectations and etc. And that's
- 2:19:09Speaker 4: the explanation of it.
- 2:19:10Speaker 1: Yeah, that's good, Okay, justin would Jeff Bezos have done
- 2:19:16Speaker 1: what he did with the Washington Post. If Kamala had
- 2:19:19Speaker 1: been elected, who knows.
- 2:19:22Speaker 2: I don't know. We don't know what he's done with
- 2:19:25Speaker 2: it yet.
- 2:19:25Speaker 4: He posted one really good message and he hasn't done
- 2:19:30Speaker 4: much since, so so you know, we'll know what he's
- 2:19:34Speaker 4: done when we see how the editorial policy evolves over
- 2:19:37Speaker 4: the next year.
- 2:19:38Speaker 2: And if what he's doing is.
- 2:19:42Speaker 4: Kissing up to the new regime and using language that's
- 2:19:47Speaker 4: respectable to insel for some other people to do it,
- 2:19:50Speaker 4: but the real motive is toty in favor with the
- 2:19:52Speaker 4: new regime, then yeah, he probably would have done that.
- 2:19:56Speaker 4: With another regime, he would have toned it up to them,
- 2:19:58Speaker 4: and he's just you know, boot licking and being a toty.
- 2:20:01Speaker 4: If what he's doing is actually coming out for his
- 2:20:05Speaker 4: own values, then I think, yeah, he would have done
- 2:20:07Speaker 4: it in either case, because if you think about what
- 2:20:10Speaker 4: happened with the kind of better tech people who either
- 2:20:18Speaker 4: supported the Republicans in this election or didn't support Democrats
- 2:20:23Speaker 4: as they had previously supported, there was a real kind
- 2:20:26Speaker 4: of breaking with the past in that, and they came
- 2:20:29Speaker 4: out publicly and took a stand in not doing what
- 2:20:32Speaker 4: they did before. And I think they had reasons for it.
- 2:20:35Speaker 4: I think tech in particular was really badly treated by
- 2:20:39Speaker 4: the Biden administration, and I think something broke in the
- 2:20:44Speaker 4: relationship a lot of those people and a lot of
- 2:20:46Speaker 4: that industry had to the Democratic Party. And I don't
- 2:20:49Speaker 4: think that break was immediately repairable.
- 2:20:53Speaker 2: And I think they were, you know.
- 2:20:57Speaker 4: Publicly distanced from the administrations or from the Democratic Party.
- 2:21:02Speaker 4: So I don't think they would or could have or
- 2:21:04Speaker 4: would have had any motivation to kind of crawl back
- 2:21:07Speaker 4: and into their holes. And I suspect actually that we
- 2:21:12Speaker 4: would have gotten more good content from this demographic of people,
- 2:21:19Speaker 4: so not just Bezos, but Mark and Triesen and Mark
- 2:21:21Speaker 4: Zuckerberg and all of those kind of people if Harris
- 2:21:24Speaker 4: had won, because I don't think they would have liked Harris.
- 2:21:26Speaker 4: I don't think they would have been inspired by her.
- 2:21:28Speaker 4: I think they would have felt like, we've already come
- 2:21:31Speaker 4: out some distance against her, and there's not much more
- 2:21:33Speaker 4: to lose in saying a bit more. And they wouldn't
- 2:21:36Speaker 4: have been in a situation of having to.
- 2:21:40Speaker 2: Be afraid of the current regime.
- 2:21:45Speaker 4: Which agrees with them about some of what was that
- 2:21:47Speaker 4: about the past regime, and that fact the existence of
- 2:21:51Speaker 4: the current regime, and the fact that all these people
- 2:21:53Speaker 4: are obviously afraid of it, whether they're saying they are
- 2:21:55Speaker 4: or not. They weren't saying they were afraid of Biden
- 2:21:57Speaker 4: when he was in power. Right, When someone's actually holding
- 2:22:00Speaker 4: a gun over you and your your speeches curtailed by it,
- 2:22:04Speaker 4: you don't say that, right.
- 2:22:05Speaker 2: And that's what we didn't see much of it before, right,
- 2:22:09Speaker 2: I am. I think they're they're intimidated now. They were
- 2:22:16Speaker 2: intimidated then.
- 2:22:16Speaker 4: I think we saw them breaking from the people they
- 2:22:19Speaker 4: were intimidated by before, and I think they have more
- 2:22:21Speaker 4: reason to be more intimidated by this regime. And the
- 2:22:27Speaker 4: fact that they've already publicly broken with the past regime
- 2:22:33Speaker 4: and supported to some extent, even if it's only by
- 2:22:37Speaker 4: not supporting the Democrats in the last election, the current
- 2:22:40Speaker 4: one makes them associated with it. And then the fact
- 2:22:43Speaker 4: that you have so much indefensible garbage coming out on
- 2:22:53Speaker 4: the right these days makes it harder for people who
- 2:22:56Speaker 4: want to be putting a positive rational methods to do
- 2:23:02Speaker 4: it and get oxygen for it. So I suspect that
- 2:23:06Speaker 4: if there wasn't a if Trump wasn't empowered culturally, if
- 2:23:11Speaker 4: he was defeated badly, for example, that there'd be more creativity,
- 2:23:16Speaker 4: more independent voices, just less group think on the anti
- 2:23:23Speaker 4: left side, and that some of these people, Bezos, maybe
- 2:23:26Speaker 4: Musk and recent and so forth, would be part of that.
- 2:23:30Speaker 2: But now they're.
- 2:23:32Speaker 4: Trying to curry favor with the party that's empowered to
- 2:23:35Speaker 4: some extent, even if that's not what's primarily driving them.
- 2:23:38Speaker 2: And that is I think having an impact on what
- 2:23:42Speaker 2: kind of ideas we're seeing.
- 2:23:45Speaker 3: Hype of Reason asks, have you read the Corpus Hemetica,
- 2:23:51Speaker 3: that is, Reason lets us understand all things? If not
- 2:23:55Speaker 3: kin to explore how it's ancient Egyptian Greek origins and
- 2:23:59Speaker 3: influence and Enlightenment thinkers thoughts.
- 2:24:04Speaker 2: No, I haven't, and I don't have much to say about.
- 2:24:09Speaker 3: All right, Lucinda. AI has been very useful for finding
- 2:24:13Speaker 3: relevant secondary secondary texts or relevant essays on things I'm
- 2:24:18Speaker 3: looking into, also being useful for structuring my day, which
- 2:24:22Speaker 3: has greatly helped me deal with sleep problems.
- 2:24:26Speaker 1: AI is incredibly valuable.
- 2:24:28Speaker 4: Yeah, you have to look and find the uses for it,
- 2:24:31Speaker 4: and they're often I've often, you know, thought it would
- 2:24:35Speaker 4: be useful for one thing, and then it wasn't, and
- 2:24:37Speaker 4: then tried it for something else I didn't think it
- 2:24:39Speaker 4: would be too useful for and found that it was useful.
- 2:24:41Speaker 4: But it's it's really developing quickly, and so you know,
- 2:24:45Speaker 4: and then different ais are different than their strength strength
- 2:24:48Speaker 4: and weaknesses, so you've got to just try it out.
- 2:24:52Speaker 4: It's you can't trust it, I think what it says
- 2:24:54Speaker 4: too often, but for finding resources, who would be an
- 2:24:59Speaker 4: example of someone who think sets and such and where
- 2:25:01Speaker 4: where could I find it? You know, so long as
- 2:25:03Speaker 4: you can check at the end of the session that
- 2:25:06Speaker 4: you know what it's saying is true, and you generally
- 2:25:10Speaker 4: can I think it's really really useful. I use it
- 2:25:13Speaker 4: a lot for what I'm doing translating reading Greek texts.
- 2:25:18Speaker 4: What are five other ways I might translate this word?
- 2:25:20Speaker 4: And why is it in this voice or mood and
- 2:25:22Speaker 4: so forth, And it's just a great conversation partner in general.
- 2:25:25Speaker 2: What it's really useful.
- 2:25:26Speaker 4: For is where there's a resource that's or set of
- 2:25:30Speaker 4: resources that available to it, it can make that research
- 2:25:35Speaker 4: conversational resource conversational with you.
- 2:25:37Speaker 2: So because all the books on.
- 2:25:39Speaker 4: Greek grammar and Greek whatever are all you know, in
- 2:25:41Speaker 4: the public domain, and so in in these databases.
- 2:25:44Speaker 2: Because they're all.
- 2:25:45Speaker 4: Nineteenth century works, you can affect talk with all of
- 2:25:47Speaker 4: them and that's really useful.
- 2:25:49Speaker 1: That's cool. All right, Fan of Aristotle, thank you, all right.
- 2:25:55Speaker 1: Last question.
- 2:25:59Speaker 3: Thoughts on kind of the young objectives intellectuals in the
- 2:26:05Speaker 3: kind of AOI orbit movement.
- 2:26:11Speaker 4: I'm I'm pleased with them, and everyone's different than I
- 2:26:16Speaker 4: want to go through person by person, but there are
- 2:26:18Speaker 4: a lot of young people now who are just starting
- 2:26:21Speaker 4: to do a work that's publicly available that I think
- 2:26:25Speaker 4: is very good, that I've been working with in one
- 2:26:28Speaker 4: capacity or another or friendly with for years now, and
- 2:26:33Speaker 4: who I think have a real kind of first handed
- 2:26:36Speaker 4: graph of objectivism and first handed graph of whatever field
- 2:26:39Speaker 4: they're working in, and abilities to combine them in ways
- 2:26:43Speaker 4: that I think are you know, that's what you really
- 2:26:45Speaker 4: want an intellectual. You had Muhammadad a couple of weeks ago,
- 2:26:49Speaker 4: a week or two ago. He's someone i've I've worked
- 2:26:52Speaker 4: with and I think is developing really nice. And what
- 2:26:54Speaker 4: he had to say on your show I thought was insightful,
- 2:26:56Speaker 4: and his keys on on the American Revolution I thought
- 2:27:00Speaker 4: was very good as a kind of popular work of history.
- 2:27:04Speaker 4: But also there was a fair amount of philosophy of
- 2:27:07Speaker 4: history in there that is a little bit below the
- 2:27:09Speaker 4: surface and related to themes in philosophy of science, and
- 2:27:12Speaker 4: I'm really proud of him that he was able to
- 2:27:14Speaker 4: do that. Stephen Wharton, who's a graduate student in philosophy
- 2:27:19Speaker 4: at Saint Andrews and has been visiting here at Texas
- 2:27:22Speaker 4: and working with me on some projects, just gave his
- 2:27:25Speaker 4: first talk at the iin ran Con here in Austin,
- 2:27:28Speaker 4: a talk on rights that I thought was really really fantastic.
- 2:27:34Speaker 4: Nick mad I've mentioned earlier, who's writing this sub stack
- 2:27:37Speaker 4: Outliving Iran on his experiences in Iran, and since is
- 2:27:44Speaker 4: you know, what he's writing is a memoir, but there's
- 2:27:46Speaker 4: a real, I think, deep thinking going on in and
- 2:27:50Speaker 4: about the nature of freedom, the nature of dictatorship, what
- 2:27:53Speaker 4: kind of a universe it is, is it benevolent internet?
- 2:27:56Speaker 2: And what does that mean?
- 2:27:57Speaker 4: That he's really grappling with issues deeply and using what
- 2:28:00Speaker 4: he's learned from objectivism well in doing that. And I
- 2:28:02Speaker 4: think eventually there'll be a really fantastic book out of that.
- 2:28:06Speaker 2: And in the meantime, it's just.
- 2:28:09Speaker 4: What he has to say now is fascinating and harrowing
- 2:28:12Speaker 4: and everybody should should be reading that blog if they're
- 2:28:15Speaker 4: not out living area, and you'll learn a lot from
- 2:28:17Speaker 4: it about the world. I'm pleased by the way Ibis,
- 2:28:24Speaker 4: who's also been on your show, Ibis Slade, is thinking
- 2:28:28Speaker 4: about history, particularly Black American history, but nineteenth century history generally,
- 2:28:32Speaker 4: in a way that I think is very reality oriented,
- 2:28:37Speaker 4: uh and philosophically deep.
- 2:28:38Speaker 2: And he's you know, avoiding kind of obvious.
- 2:28:43Speaker 4: I don't want to say he's only avoiding consider obvious,
- 2:28:45Speaker 4: but there are kind of ways that people tend to
- 2:28:47Speaker 4: do cartoon history that's too reductive. They're too quickly looking
- 2:28:52Speaker 4: for who the good guys and the bad guys are,
- 2:28:54Speaker 4: which which you should be doing, but they're not. They're
- 2:28:57Speaker 4: getting stereotypes of the characters too quickly and not not
- 2:29:02Speaker 4: thinking enough deeply about them and about you know, why
- 2:29:06Speaker 4: movements that were largely for the good failed when they
- 2:29:08Speaker 4: did and have worked. And I think this has got
- 2:29:11Speaker 4: a really good orientation towards that work and uh, particularly
- 2:29:15Speaker 4: that he's come to so much of it on his
- 2:29:16Speaker 4: own without without much training either in universities or although
- 2:29:22Speaker 4: he's getting it now from from objectivists. So these are
- 2:29:25Speaker 4: just a bunch of people, several of them here in
- 2:29:28Speaker 4: Austin that I'm working with. There's, uh, there's a graduate
- 2:29:35Speaker 4: student at Princeton who I'm not sure if I should
- 2:29:38Speaker 4: be naming, but who's yeah, I think, just really sharp
- 2:29:43Speaker 4: and doing a lot of you know, earlier in her studies,
- 2:29:48Speaker 4: but doing h a lot of I think fresh thinking
- 2:29:53Speaker 4: about issues in the in the foundation of ethics that
- 2:29:55Speaker 4: I think is going to uh pay off in really
- 2:29:58Speaker 4: high quality work in the And all of these people
- 2:30:01Speaker 4: I think have done a lot of thinking about objectivism
- 2:30:05Speaker 4: in a way that's connected to their thinking about their
- 2:30:07Speaker 4: own lives and the issues that are happening in the
- 2:30:12Speaker 4: world today and that are happening in their own fields,
- 2:30:15Speaker 4: and they're they're doing, I think, the kind of work
- 2:30:18Speaker 4: you need to do to really understand that integrate this
- 2:30:21Speaker 4: philosophy and use it as a lens to understand the world.
- 2:30:23Speaker 4: So I'm really pleased to see this happening. And for me,
- 2:30:28Speaker 4: the other person who all mention, who's not any more
- 2:30:31Speaker 4: young and up and coming in the same way, but
- 2:30:33Speaker 4: to me is connected to all of these people because
- 2:30:38Speaker 4: I knew her when she was so knew what this
- 2:30:41Speaker 4: is Gina, and Gina is writing a book. I'm also
- 2:30:45Speaker 4: giving feedback that, you know, reading drafts of it as
- 2:30:49Speaker 4: she writes that I think is really going to be fantastic.
- 2:30:51Speaker 2: She has a.
- 2:30:54Speaker 4: Contract with a major publisher that I expect will get
- 2:30:57Speaker 4: help get the book a lot of attention. The publisher
- 2:30:59Speaker 4: obviously are very bullish, yeah, bullish on the book.
- 2:31:02Speaker 2: They gave her, you know, an advance. And yet.
- 2:31:07Speaker 4: I'm the young people who I'm seeing now and talking
- 2:31:11Speaker 4: to a lot now, I see very much taking the
- 2:31:13Speaker 4: kind of trajectory I saw Gena Taig in terms of
- 2:31:16Speaker 4: how they're thinking about their work, how they're thinking about objectivism,
- 2:31:20Speaker 4: how they're thinking about their lives. And I'm optimistic that
- 2:31:23Speaker 4: we're on a pathway of having Gina have a huge
- 2:31:25Speaker 4: impact on the world and having more people who are
- 2:31:28Speaker 4: having it, you know, five, ten, twenty years from now
- 2:31:31Speaker 4: than than than are now.
- 2:31:32Speaker 1: That's great. So three questions snuck in while.
- 2:31:36Speaker 3: You are answering that, So we'll do these quickly if
- 2:31:39Speaker 3: you're okay with that. What about this is analytics synthetic economy?
- 2:31:43Speaker 3: What about Eric Orenz.
- 2:31:47Speaker 1: He's on the right, a feminist, anti reactionaries, supports Ukraine
- 2:31:51Speaker 1: and is science based.
- 2:31:53Speaker 2: Do you know, I don't know him in particular.
- 2:31:55Speaker 1: Okay, you know, I have to look him up. Let's see.
- 2:32:04Speaker 3: Lucinda says, Ai also has been very very helpful for
- 2:32:08Speaker 3: learning ancient Greek, although I still have to compare it
- 2:32:12Speaker 3: with my textbooks sometimes. Well, Cinda is studying philosophy, studying
- 2:32:18Speaker 3: objectivism pretty deeply, and studying agent.
- 2:32:22Speaker 2: Had some good email exchanges.
- 2:32:23Speaker 1: That's good. Good, I'm glad, I'm glad.
- 2:32:26Speaker 3: Uh And Frank says, as a guitarist, did you like
- 2:32:31Speaker 3: the Dylan movie the Guitarist?
- 2:32:35Speaker 4: Well, I guess as a guitarist, I should be thinking
- 2:32:37Speaker 4: about how did they how do they play the guitarist
- 2:32:40Speaker 4: and what's his name? Shall the guy who was playing
- 2:32:44Speaker 4: Dylan and also the guy who the woman who was
- 2:32:46Speaker 4: playing Joan Baiaz did a really good job learning and
- 2:32:51Speaker 4: impersonality both of their performance style, and that was really
- 2:32:54Speaker 4: impressive in addition to everything else that was impressive about
- 2:32:57Speaker 4: the acting. And the acting was was very good in movie.
- 2:33:01Speaker 4: But that's not a really oppression of the movie more generally,
- 2:33:05Speaker 4: other than you know, bad aspect of it.
- 2:33:07Speaker 2: Was really good. I was positive but mixed on the
- 2:33:11Speaker 2: Dylan movie.
- 2:33:12Speaker 4: This is no direction home, which is a movie based
- 2:33:15Speaker 4: on the book, Dylan Goes Electric. That's about the climax
- 2:33:19Speaker 4: of it is is plugging in electric guitar at the
- 2:33:21Speaker 4: at the nineteen sixty five.
- 2:33:26Speaker 2: Newport Folk Festival.
- 2:33:30Speaker 4: The book frames a lot of the story here through
- 2:33:35Speaker 4: the contrast between Bob Dylan and Pete Seeker as people
- 2:33:40Speaker 4: who represented different things artistically and culturally, and the movie
- 2:33:45Speaker 4: does a very good job picking up on that. It
- 2:33:47Speaker 4: it is not, you know, in good ways here, it's
- 2:33:51Speaker 4: not historically accurate. It makes Seeger play a larger personal
- 2:33:54Speaker 4: role in Dylan's life than he did it combined to
- 2:33:56Speaker 4: other characters, and gives thing roles to a securing a
- 2:33:59Speaker 4: way that I think real does nicely capture two visions
- 2:34:04Speaker 4: of what this kind of music can be, and what
- 2:34:06Speaker 4: music's role in cultures, and what the kind of folk
- 2:34:09Speaker 4: music movement was about, and why Dylan was this kind
- 2:34:12Speaker 4: of strange fit with it or creature that kind of
- 2:34:16Speaker 4: came through it and and with had a big influence
- 2:34:20Speaker 4: on it. It had an influence on him, but it
- 2:34:21Speaker 4: all blew up, and I think that story the movie
- 2:34:25Speaker 4: tells well. I think the romantic subplot of the movie
- 2:34:29Speaker 4: doesn't really work for me. If I thought that his
- 2:34:34Speaker 4: actual love life was like the thing in the movie.
- 2:34:38Speaker 4: I would think, well, it's a biographical movie. They're working
- 2:34:41Speaker 4: what they have to work with, and so, you know whatever.
- 2:34:44Speaker 4: It doesn't quite integrate that well, but that's you know, life,
- 2:34:46Speaker 4: Life's messy. But in fact, they really changed his romantic story,
- 2:34:50Speaker 4: the relationship with I forget what they called her in
- 2:34:53Speaker 4: the movie, but sus Routello is the actual woman.
- 2:34:55Speaker 2: They stretch out.
- 2:34:56Speaker 4: Like two or three years longer than he was with her,
- 2:34:59Speaker 4: so that could constantly be this love trial which triangle
- 2:35:02Speaker 4: between her and Joe and Bayez, and it doesn't really
- 2:35:07Speaker 4: make sense of It doesn't integrate well with the other
- 2:35:12Speaker 4: thematic and plot conflicts in the movies, and it's not
- 2:35:14Speaker 4: true to his life.
- 2:35:15Speaker 2: So I sort of don't know.
- 2:35:17Speaker 4: They didn't have fewer characters, I'm sure, but it just
- 2:35:19Speaker 4: didn't kind of add up to me esthetically. So in
- 2:35:22Speaker 4: that respect, I thought the movie didn't quite integrate and
- 2:35:25Speaker 4: hang together.
- 2:35:25Speaker 2: Well.
- 2:35:26Speaker 4: What it is good at, though, I think, is two things.
- 2:35:31Speaker 4: It portrays a kind of intelligence very well, and people's
- 2:35:35Speaker 4: reaction to intelligence. So Dylan was very much a side
- 2:35:39Speaker 4: shit to I'm a big fan of his and I've
- 2:35:41Speaker 4: read a lot about it. He was someone who I
- 2:35:44Speaker 4: don't think. He was very good at picking up on
- 2:35:50Speaker 4: certain ideas and certain moods and noticing things and then
- 2:35:53Speaker 4: finding very eloquent ways to articulate them in songs. And
- 2:35:55Speaker 4: you see him doing that in the film, and they
- 2:35:58Speaker 4: portray that and people's reaction to that very well. And
- 2:36:01Speaker 4: that's a nice thing to see, like some somewhat appreciated
- 2:36:03Speaker 4: intelligence and and uh and and skill and and dramatizing
- 2:36:07Speaker 4: well and dramatizing people's response to it well. So that
- 2:36:09Speaker 4: was a really nice feature of the film. And also
- 2:36:13Speaker 4: the kind of rebelliousness of an artist who doesn't want
- 2:36:17Speaker 4: to be constrained and boxed in and and some of
- 2:36:19Speaker 4: it's good and some of it's a little bit dysfunctional,
- 2:36:23Speaker 4: and I think that they also portrayed well. So that's,
- 2:36:25Speaker 4: you know, something to look for in the movie. And again,
- 2:36:28Speaker 4: it's good at portraying that.
- 2:36:29Speaker 1: Good all right, Lucinda says, I'm also studying French. Now,
- 2:36:33Speaker 1: good for you to Cinda. That's great. And justin asks.
- 2:36:38Speaker 3: Is the ancient Chinese philosopher Loo Loo too a pro
- 2:36:44Speaker 3: liberty thinker.
- 2:36:47Speaker 4: I don't know enough to really say, I don't. I
- 2:36:50Speaker 4: don't think in that time, and.
- 2:36:58Speaker 2: I don't think there was a kind of pro liberty movement.
- 2:37:00Speaker 4: He was part of a pro liberty development in a
- 2:37:03Speaker 4: way that, at least to my understanding, that I could
- 2:37:06Speaker 4: say like he was, you know, in a way that
- 2:37:08Speaker 4: you could say John Locke was, or you know, Groceus
- 2:37:11Speaker 4: and puffendor for or anybody like that in the kind
- 2:37:13Speaker 4: of early Enlightenment tradition. So I don't see him as
- 2:37:16Speaker 4: part of a movement for liberty, although and I don't
- 2:37:18Speaker 4: know that much about Chinese history, and I could be
- 2:37:20Speaker 4: missing something.
- 2:37:22Speaker 2: Then there's a question of are there things in his
- 2:37:24Speaker 2: ideas that.
- 2:37:27Speaker 4: Are true and conducive to liberty and you could adapt
- 2:37:30Speaker 4: them and there I don't know. I would worry about
- 2:37:34Speaker 4: anachronism in people reading him that way, but but there.
- 2:37:37Speaker 1: Might be think, yeah, I don't know either.
- 2:37:39Speaker 3: But I will say that the people in China who
- 2:37:44Speaker 3: were pro liberty, pro freedom that I met over the
- 2:37:46Speaker 3: years all thought very highly of him. But I think
- 2:37:50Speaker 3: part of it was they were looking for someone who
- 2:37:55Speaker 3: is Chinese that they could they could latch onto in
- 2:37:58Speaker 3: a sense, is part of they in a sense tradition
- 2:38:02Speaker 3: or something like that. So so so I don't know
- 2:38:06Speaker 3: how objective they were about it.
- 2:38:08Speaker 2: And there is something healthy about that.
- 2:38:10Speaker 4: And so I was looking for someone in your own tradition,
- 2:38:12Speaker 4: insofar as you're looking for the things that have currency
- 2:38:15Speaker 4: in your culture, that you think are good about your
- 2:38:18Speaker 4: culture and are pulling it in the direction you want
- 2:38:20Speaker 4: to go, that you can build on. So it's not
- 2:38:22Speaker 4: just sort of tribal if you're looking for who are
- 2:38:25Speaker 4: you know figures?
- 2:38:27Speaker 2: But again I don't it's.
- 2:38:28Speaker 1: Yeah, they thought very very highly of them.
- 2:38:31Speaker 3: But I found as I traveled around the world and
- 2:38:34Speaker 3: in a lot of countries they have some figure in
- 2:38:37Speaker 3: their past that they say, oh he's Outrand or a
- 2:38:41Speaker 3: hyek or something that represents them something something important. And
- 2:38:46Speaker 3: I'm sure you know in a lot of these places
- 2:38:48Speaker 3: there were there were better people in the past.
- 2:38:52Speaker 1: But I think I think they make too much.
- 2:38:55Speaker 3: For the most part, they make too much of them.
- 2:38:59Speaker 1: This has been great, as always, So we've actually the
- 2:39:02Speaker 1: end of our list. Yes, yes, we've caught up. Thank you,
- 2:39:10Speaker 1: So what's it?
- 2:39:11Speaker 2: Thanks for having me on? Of course it's always some funds.
- 2:39:16Speaker 1: Yes, and we did well, we did.
- 2:39:18Speaker 2: Well, excellent.
- 2:39:20Speaker 3: Then I'll be decent absolutely Bye, Bye everybody, Thanks to
- 2:39:25Speaker 3: all the super chatters, you guys were great.
- 2:39:27Speaker 1: Bye