Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Nature vs. Nurture Debate: Genes & Environment in Psychology
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology Undergrad. Hey, everyone.
- 0:02So today we are doing a special session that
- 0:04is honestly designed specifically for you. Like,
- 0:07if you are a fellow psychology undergrad trying
- 0:10to make sense of your coursework, you know how
- 0:13incredibly dense this stuff can be. Oh, totally.
- 0:15It's a lot. Right. And today we're tackling one
- 0:18of the most notoriously messy topics out there,
- 0:23which is behavioral genetics. Yeah, messy is
- 0:26definitely the right word for it. Because usually,
- 0:28right, when you think about a biological diagnosis,
- 0:31you expect this sort of sheer precision. Like
- 0:33it feels like engineering. You break your arm,
- 0:36you go get an x -ray, you see that jagged white
- 0:38line, the doctor points right at it, and boom,
- 0:41you know the cause and the effect. It's just
- 0:43simple. Right, it's binary. It's either broken
- 0:45or it's not. Exactly. It's this clean mechanical
- 0:48failure. And honestly, that kind of clarity...
- 0:51is deeply comforting to us. Like, the human mind
- 0:54loves that. Oh, we love it. We want our problems
- 0:57to be highly visible, easily categorized into
- 0:59these neat little boxes. But the moment you step
- 1:02into the actual world of behavioral genetics,
- 1:05that x -ray machine is just, well, it's completely
- 1:08useless. Yeah, you get nothing. We are looking
- 1:10at a landscape of human behavior that is incredibly
- 1:14murky. So the mission for today's deep dive is
- 1:17really to cut through that murkiness for you.
- 1:19We're going to explore the core concepts of behavioral
- 1:23genetics, define the mechanics of how our traits
- 1:26actually develop, and also tackle the really
- 1:29profound moral and religious implications of
- 1:32this science. Because the stakes here are incredibly
- 1:34high. Like if you look at philosophy, there are
- 1:37generally considered to be three great, you know,
- 1:40enduring problems about human existence. Right.
- 1:42You've got the mind -body problem. Yeah. You've
- 1:44got the existence of free will. And then you
- 1:47have nature versus nurture. The big three. Exactly.
- 1:50But what is truly fascinating is that out of
- 1:52those three, only nature nurture is constantly
- 1:55called a debate. A debate, yeah. It's always
- 1:58framed in our culture as this boxing match between
- 2:01two opposing forces. Which is completely the
- 2:04wrong way to look at it. Like framing the origins
- 2:06of human behavior as this simple debate between
- 2:09biology and environment. I mean, it just misses
- 2:12the entire biological reality of how those two
- 2:14forces actually work together. Right. But to
- 2:16understand why society cares so much about this
- 2:19supposed debate, we really have to look at how
- 2:22we assign blame and praise to the people around
- 2:24us. Oh, absolutely. Our entire sense of moral
- 2:27character, like our whole justice system, really
- 2:30depends on it. Exactly. I mean, think about how
- 2:32we view physical traits versus behavioral traits.
- 2:36We are constantly talking about the genetic lottery.
- 2:39Right. Like, we don't blame a remarkably short
- 2:42person for their lack of height. We recognize
- 2:44that it isn't some sort of moral failing. It's
- 2:47simply biology. Yeah, you just got the short
- 2:49jeans. But on the flip side, society heavily
- 2:52praises, say, a concert violinist for her decades
- 2:55of grueling practice. Oh yeah, she works so hard.
- 2:58Exactly. Just like we really quickly condemn
- 3:01slackers or bullies for their hostile behavior,
- 3:03we just sort of assume the physical trait is
- 3:05nature and the behavioral trait is purely a product
- 3:08of nurture and personal choice. But the underlying
- 3:11reality is so much messier than that, you know?
- 3:14Yeah. That violinist undoubtedly put in thousands
- 3:16of hours of hard work, sure, but she also likely
- 3:19possesses an inborn biological gift. Maybe it's
- 3:23a perfect pitch or really specific neuromotor
- 3:27coordination that just makes her fingers unusually
- 3:29nimble. Her biology rewarded her hard work. on
- 3:33a magnitude that like an average person's biology
- 3:36simply wouldn't. Exactly. Or similarly, think
- 3:39about a seven foot tall basketball player. He
- 3:41certainly has the genetics for height, obviously.
- 3:44Yeah, you don't just practice being tall. Right.
- 3:46But he also required a highly nutritious protein
- 3:49rich diet during his childhood to actually reach
- 3:52that genetic potential. And those are just the
- 3:55physical talents. I mean, the science gets infinitely
- 3:58more complicated when behavioral genetics turns
- 4:00its lens onto deeply psychological traits. Oh
- 4:04man. Yeah. We are talking about characteristics
- 4:06that define who we are. Like a person's baseline
- 4:08tendency to worry or their fundamental honesty,
- 4:12their sexual orientation, and yes even their
- 4:14religiosity. Wait, religiosity? Yeah, how religious
- 4:17someone naturally tends to be. These are deeply
- 4:20personal characteristics that fall into this
- 4:22massive gray zone. Right. They are neither entirely
- 4:24fixed by nature at birth, nor are they totally
- 4:27under our own conscious control. OK, let's unpack
- 4:30this. Because if traits like religiosity or a
- 4:34tendency toward bad behavior and impulsivity
- 4:36have actual biological genetic roots, doesn't
- 4:40that totally mess with our moral compass? It
- 4:43really makes you think, doesn't it? Yeah. I mean,
- 4:46how do we judge right and wrong or hold anyone
- 4:48accountable for their actions if their genetic
- 4:50code is just like the one pulling the strings
- 4:53behind the curtain? If we connect this to the
- 4:55bigger picture, we have to realize that while
- 4:57genes are involved in absolutely everything we
- 4:59do, they never act in a vacuum. Acknowledging
- 5:03that biology heavily influences a trait like
- 5:06honesty doesn't. erase personal responsibility.
- 5:09Right, it doesn't give you a free pass. Exactly,
- 5:12it just deepens our understanding of how our
- 5:14moral selves develop over time. Biology provides
- 5:17a starting decline, a set of predispositions,
- 5:20but it is absolutely not a pre -written destiny.
- 5:22Right. So we know traits are this incredibly
- 5:26complex mix of biological predisposition and
- 5:29environmental upbringing. But the obvious question
- 5:32for us as undergrads studying this is how do
- 5:36behavioral geneticists actually untangle those
- 5:38two forces to study them in the first place?
- 5:41Well, historically, researchers learn the fundamentals
- 5:43by working with animals. Simply because you can
- 5:47strictly control both their breeding and their
- 5:49environments. Because you can't do that with
- 5:51people. Exactly. If you want to isolate genetics,
- 5:53you just keep the environment identical. Right.
- 5:56And there's that classic experiment involving
- 5:58dogs that perfectly illustrates this concept.
- 6:00Ah, the Scott and Fuller one. Yeah, exactly.
- 6:02So imagine taking two incredibly aggressive dog
- 6:05breeds, like some really angry chihuahuas, and
- 6:08two incredibly docile breeds, like super happy
- 6:10beagles. OK. You take half the puppies from the
- 6:13aggressive parents and immediately have the docile
- 6:15dogs raise them. And then you take half the docile
- 6:17puppies and give them to the aggressive dogs
- 6:19to raise. Cross fostering. Right. You are testing
- 6:22a simple fundamental premise. Will the aggressive
- 6:26Chihuahua parents teach the docile beagle puppies
- 6:28to be mean? Or does the puppy's inborn genetic
- 6:32nature just win out? And animal breeders have
- 6:35utilized these principles for literally thousands
- 6:38of years to select for specific behavioral traits
- 6:41in livestock and pets. Yeah. It's how we have
- 6:44so many dog breeds. But obviously we cannot conduct.
- 6:47cross -fostering experiments on humans. No, no.
- 6:50We can't just assign babies to random families
- 6:52in a lab to test their baseline aggression levels.
- 6:54And honestly, history shows us the horrific,
- 6:58tragic consequences of attempts to selectively
- 7:00breed humans through eugenics movements. Yeah,
- 7:03it goes to some incredibly dark places very fast.
- 7:06It really does. So since we can't play musical
- 7:08chairs with human babies, researchers have to
- 7:11rely on two main methods under the umbrella of
- 7:13quantitative genetics. And those are adoption
- 7:15studies and twin When we look at twin studies,
- 7:19we are specifically comparing identical twins
- 7:21who share 100 % of their DNA. Like literal clones.
- 7:24Yeah, biologically speaking. And we compare them
- 7:27with fraternal twins who share roughly 50 % of
- 7:30their DNA, just like any regular siblings born
- 7:33at different times. Right. And by comparing these
- 7:36two groups, researchers can observe how specific
- 7:39traits manifest. Let's look at a sharp contrast
- 7:42to see how this works in practice. OK. Let's
- 7:44compare height. versus spoken language. Oh, good
- 7:48example. If you look at identical twins, their
- 7:51heights are almost perfectly correlated. Fraternal
- 7:54twins have similar heights, but the correlation
- 7:56drops significantly. Because they only share
- 7:58half the genes. Exactly. that massive gap in
- 8:01similarity between the identical twins and the
- 8:03fraternal twins gives us a really strong mathematical
- 8:06clue about the heavy genetic influence on height.
- 8:09But then look at a trait like spoken language.
- 8:12If an identical twin is raised in a household
- 8:14that speaks exclusively Spanish, they will speak
- 8:16Spanish. If a fraternal twin is raised in that
- 8:19exact same Spanish -speaking household, They
- 8:22also speak Spanish. The 100 % genetic match of
- 8:27the identical twins doesn't make them any more
- 8:29likely to speak the exact same language than
- 8:32the fraternal twins who only share 50 % of their
- 8:34DNA. Precisely. The genetic variance just doesn't
- 8:38matter for that specific trait. Yeah. The environment
- 8:40dictates the outcome entirely. So what does this
- 8:43all mean? Here's the mental shortcut for you
- 8:45to remember how this works for the exam. If a
- 8:49tree shows a massive difference in similarity
- 8:51when you compare identical twins to fraternal
- 8:53twins, nature is flexing its muscles. I like
- 8:55that. But if the trait stays exactly the same
- 8:58across both twin types, nurture is the one driving
- 9:02the car. That is an excellent rule of thumb.
- 9:04Yeah. But because quantitative genetics relies
- 9:06so heavily on measuring these statistical differences
- 9:09between twins, it ultimately generates a mathematical
- 9:12figure called the heritability coefficient. Oh,
- 9:15boy. And that single number is a massive trap
- 9:18for unwary psychology students. Oh, it absolutely
- 9:21is. The heritability coefficient varies on a
- 9:23scale from zero to one. and it measures how differences
- 9:27among individuals within a population relate
- 9:30to differences in their genes. And the mind -bending
- 9:33reality that behavioral genetics has uncovered
- 9:35over the last few decades is that literally everything
- 9:39has some statistical footing in genetics. Everything.
- 9:42Things you would never intuitively expect. Like,
- 9:45how many hours of television a person watches
- 9:46per week? What? Really? Yeah. Or their highly
- 9:50specific political attitudes regarding taxation.
- 9:52That's insane. And even their math of getting
- 9:55divorced. They all show genetic influences. Which
- 9:59feels completely wild. How could watching TV
- 10:02be genetic? I know, it sounds fake. But the ultimate
- 10:05counterintuitive example of heritability is even
- 10:08stranger. The heritability coefficient for a
- 10:11human being having two arms is exactly zero.
- 10:13Zero. Okay, wait. Let's unpack this. Having two
- 10:16arms is obviously a deeply biological genetic
- 10:19process. You literally grow them in the womb
- 10:21following a genetic blueprint. So how can the
- 10:23heritability be zero? Does that mean having arms
- 10:26is purely an environmental trait? It sounds like
- 10:29a complete paradox, right? But it all comes down
- 10:32to understanding what heritability actually measures.
- 10:36It does not measure the genetic makeup of an
- 10:38individual. It measures the differences between
- 10:40people in a specific population. The differences.
- 10:44since almost no one in the human population varies
- 10:47in the genes responsible for arm development.
- 10:50I mean, virtually all humans have the exact same
- 10:53underlying genetic code for growing two arms.
- 10:56The genetic variance for that trait is zero because
- 10:59there's no difference to measure. Exactly. Therefore,
- 11:02if you do find people who differ in the number
- 11:04of arms they have, it's almost always due to
- 11:06an environmental accident or an injury, not a
- 11:08difference in their genetic code. Wow. OK, so
- 11:11heritability isn't telling us how quote unquote
- 11:14genetic a trait is in a single person, it's strictly
- 11:17telling us how much genes explain the differences
- 11:20in a whole group of people. Exactly. And relying
- 11:23too heavily on percentages creates this false
- 11:25dichotomy. Trying to divide a human trait into
- 11:28a neat percentage, say, claiming that intelligence
- 11:31is 60 % genes and 40 % environment is like listening
- 11:35to a breathtaking symphony and asking the conductor
- 11:38how much of the music comes from the brass section
- 11:41and how much comes from the string section. You
- 11:43just can't do it. They integrate completely to
- 11:46create the sound. You can't just slice the audio
- 11:48wave in half and separate them. Which means,
- 11:52if genes and environment play together like a
- 11:54symphony, we really need to understand exactly
- 11:57how they physically interact inside the body.
- 12:00And that brings us to gene -environment interaction,
- 12:04which you'll usually see abbreviated as GXE and
- 12:07the incredible science of epigenetics. Let's
- 12:09start with a foundational GXE study, the CASPY
- 12:12research from 2002. Oh, this one is huge. It
- 12:15really is. They were studying a specific gene
- 12:17called MAOA, which codes for for an enzyme that
- 12:20breaks down neurotransmitters in the brain. Some
- 12:23people have a variant of this gene that produces
- 12:25less of this enzyme, which has long been associated
- 12:28with a predisposition for violence and antisocial
- 12:31behavior. Like the quote unquote warrior gene.
- 12:33Exactly. But the researchers found something
- 12:36absolutely crucial. This low activity gene variant
- 12:39only led to violent behavior if the child carrying
- 12:42it had also been severely maltreated and abused
- 12:45growing up. Wow. So the environment had to literally
- 12:48unlock the genetic potential. Like, if a child
- 12:51had that exact same violent gene variant but
- 12:53grew up in a safe, loving, supportive environment,
- 12:56the gene had absolutely no effect on their behavior.
- 12:59None. The gene by itself was harmless. It required
- 13:01the environmental trigger. Exactly. And the biological
- 13:04mechanism behind that unlocking process, the
- 13:07actual physical how of the situation, is epigenetics.
- 13:11Epigenetics. The epigenome is a layer of chemical
- 13:14compounds that sits directly on top of your DNA.
- 13:17Think of it this way. If your DNA, your actual
- 13:19genetic code, is a written paragraph, the epigenome
- 13:23is the punctuation in that paragraph. That is
- 13:25the perfect analogy. Just as adding a comma or
- 13:28a question mark fundamentally changes the meaning
- 13:29of a sentence without altering the actual words,
- 13:32the epigenome tells your genes what to do. The
- 13:35environment doesn't mutate your DNA. Instead,
- 13:38it leaves chemical tags, often through a process
- 13:41called DNA methylation. Right. Essentially, your
- 13:44body attaches a tiny methyl group directly to
- 13:47a gene sequence. This methyl group physically
- 13:50blocks the cellular machinery from reading that
- 13:53gene, effectively turning it off, or silencing
- 13:56it. It's like putting a sensor bar over a word.
- 13:58Exactly. And the critical part is that this methylation
- 14:01process is directly driven by your environmental
- 14:04experiences. Here's where it gets really interesting,
- 14:07because the historical proof of this mechanism
- 14:09is just staggering. It really is. hunger winter.
- 14:13During the winter of 1944 to 1945 there was a
- 14:17brutal civilian famine. Pregnant women who were
- 14:20previously healthy and totally well -nourished
- 14:22were suddenly subjected to extreme prolonged
- 14:25starvation. And the immediate physical toll on
- 14:28the babies was obvious. They were born incredibly
- 14:30small. Right. But what scientists discovered
- 14:32when they tracked those babies down 60 years
- 14:35later is where the science gets profound. Wait,
- 14:3860 years later? Yes, six decades later, the researchers
- 14:41found that the prenatal starvation had fundamentally
- 14:43altered those individuals' DNA methylation. Wow.
- 14:47While they were starving in the womb, their bodies
- 14:50had epigenetically silenced certain metabolic
- 14:53genes to help them hoard every single calorie
- 14:57just to survive. And the tragic part is, even
- 15:00though those people grew up and lived in a modern
- 15:02world with absolute food abundance, their epigenome
- 15:06was still permanently punctuated. for starvation.
- 15:09Exactly. Their bodies held on to that early trauma,
- 15:12leading to significantly higher rates of insulin
- 15:14resistance, severe obesity, and coronary heart
- 15:17disease compared to their own siblings who weren't
- 15:19exposed to the famine. It's heartbreaking. The
- 15:22environment their mothers experience literally
- 15:24reprogrammed the molecular machinery of how their
- 15:27genes express themselves for the rest of their
- 15:29lives. We see the exact same physical mechanism
- 15:31in animal models too. Take the famous rat maternal
- 15:34licking studies. Oh, the rat moms. Yeah. If a
- 15:38rat mother frequently licks and grooms her pups
- 15:41during the first crucial week of life, the physical
- 15:44affection actually removes methyl groups from
- 15:47a specific gene in the pups' brains. Affection
- 15:50physically changes their brain chemistry. Literally.
- 15:53This gene controls the production of leukocorticoid
- 15:57receptors, which are vital for shutting down
- 15:59the body's stress response. So more maternal
- 16:02affection leads to less methylation, which means
- 16:05the gene is turned on, producing more receptors.
- 16:07Right. And those rats grow up to be incredibly
- 16:09calm, resilient, and way less stressed for their
- 16:12entire adult lives. Precisely. And tragically,
- 16:15we see the human equivalent of this exact mechanism.
- 16:18Yeah. When neuroscientists examined the postmortem
- 16:20brain tissue of human suicide victims who had
- 16:23died. documented histories of severe childhood
- 16:24abuse, they found the exact same type of heavy
- 16:28epigenetic methylation on that glucocorticoid
- 16:31receptor gene that they saw in the neglected,
- 16:34unliked rats. That is just... wow. The severe
- 16:36early trauma had epigenetically silenced the
- 16:38gene, permanently reducing their brain's physiological
- 16:41ability to handle stress hormones. It is mind
- 16:45-blowing to think about. Like, in the near future,
- 16:48scientists might actually be able to use a simple
- 16:50blood test to measure the physiological traces
- 16:53left on a person's genome by childhood neglect.
- 16:56It's very possible. Nurture literally writes
- 16:58itself onto our na - It leaves a permanent readable
- 17:02chemical footprint. What's fascinating here is
- 17:05that while this sounds deeply sobering, it is
- 17:08also the very mechanism that explains human resilience.
- 17:12Right. Remember, adversity alone doesn't guarantee
- 17:14mental illness. Countless people who experience
- 17:17severe trauma remain perfectly healthy and well
- 17:20adjusted. Because it's an interaction. Exactly.
- 17:23It's the interaction that matters. Inherited
- 17:25differences in specific gene segments determine
- 17:27who is biologically hypersensitive to their environment
- 17:30and who is naturally resilient. The epigenome
- 17:33is just the bridge between what we experience
- 17:35and how our biology reacts. But I have to say,
- 17:38hearing that childhood trauma chemically marks
- 17:40our DNA could sound really depressing to a lot
- 17:42of people. Oh, for sure. It fleets dangerously
- 17:44with biological determinism. Like, if our environment
- 17:48changes our gene expression and our genes dictate
- 17:50our physical reactions, are we just biological
- 17:54robots riding out a chemical chain reaction?
- 17:56That's the fear, isn't it? Yeah. This circles
- 17:58us right back to our opening philosophical questions
- 18:00about free will. It's a completely valid concern,
- 18:03but the empirical science actually points in
- 18:05the exact opposite direction. Okay, how so? Biological
- 18:08traits are highly malleable. Let's look at a
- 18:11deadly genetic metabolic disorder called PKU,
- 18:14or phenylketonuria. It is caused by a single
- 18:18terrifying gene mutation that completely prevents
- 18:21the human body from metabolizing a specific amino
- 18:24acid called phenalamine. Right. If left untreated,
- 18:28the amino acid builds up in the brain, causing
- 18:30severe cognitive impairment, seizures, and eventually
- 18:33death. It is 100 % genetic death sense. But,
- 18:37and this is the incredible part. It is 100 %
- 18:39treatable with a completely environmental intervention.
- 18:42If you simply screen the baby at birth and change
- 18:45their diet to avoid foods containing that specific
- 18:47amino acid, they live a totally normal, perfectly
- 18:51healthy life. The environment completely neutralizes
- 18:54their genetic destiny. Yeah. Or look at something
- 18:57as basic as human height. Height is highly genetic,
- 19:00but the global average height has skyrocketed
- 19:03over the last century. Right. Why? Not because
- 19:06our genes suddenly mutated, but because of better
- 19:08childhood nutrition and the reduction of extreme
- 19:11poverty. The improved environment literally pulled
- 19:14more physical potential out of the exact same
- 19:17human genome. Exactly. And when it comes to the
- 19:20vast majority of complex human behavior, we have
- 19:23to remember that aside from a few rare, severe
- 19:26single gene mutations like Huntington's disease,
- 19:29Our actions are absolutely not controlled by
- 19:31one or two master genes pulling the levers. Right,
- 19:34it's not that simple. Not at all. Behavior is
- 19:36governed by tiny, almost imperceptible effects
- 19:39spread across thousands and thousands of different
- 19:41genes, all interacting with millions of environmental
- 19:44inputs. There is no strict biological blueprint
- 19:47dictating your every move. So think about what
- 19:49that means for our society at large. Yeah. The
- 19:52concept that human beings differ genetically
- 19:55doesn't threaten the moral foundation of equality.
- 19:57Like Thomas Jefferson said, all men are created
- 20:00equal. That isn't threatened by this. We aren't
- 20:03clones, but that genetic diversity combined with
- 20:06our unique experiences is actually what makes
- 20:09freedom and self -determination biologically
- 20:11possible. This raises an important question.
- 20:15If we acknowledge all these biological and environmental
- 20:17influences, where does human agency actually
- 20:21reside? That's the million dollar question. I
- 20:23think theologian Mordecai Kaplan offered a brilliant
- 20:25way to frame this. Oh, I love this quote. He
- 20:28originally said this regarding the forces of
- 20:30human history, but it applies perfectly to behavioral
- 20:32genetics, he noted. Genetics gets a vote, not
- 20:36a veto, in the determination of human behavior.
- 20:39Genetics gets a vote, not a veto. I absolutely
- 20:42love that framing. It perfectly captures the
- 20:45science. Your biology absolutely has a say in
- 20:47who you are. It sets certain baselines. It provides
- 20:49specific predispositions. And it certainly makes
- 20:51some choices harder than others. But it does
- 20:54not have the final overriding authority to dictate
- 20:58your actions. Alright, let's wrap up this study
- 21:00session and make sure you have the core concepts
- 21:03locked in for your exams. Good idea. First, remember
- 21:06that the heritability coefficient is a super
- 21:09tricky statistic. It measures the genetic variance
- 21:12within a population, not the genetic makeup of
- 21:14an individual. Always remember the paradox of
- 21:17the two arms. Yes, the two arms. Second, nature
- 21:20and nurture are not a boxing match. They are
- 21:23a symphony of horns and strings playing together
- 21:25to create the music of human behavior. Beautifully
- 21:28put. And finally, epigenetics acts as the chemical
- 21:31punctuation to your DNA paragraph, adding commas
- 21:34and exclamation points based entirely on what
- 21:37you experience in life. As you continue to study
- 21:40psychology, I strongly encourage you to think
- 21:42about how this science fundamentally changes
- 21:44your understanding of yourself and the people
- 21:46around you. When you look at your peers, realize
- 21:49that everyone's behavior, their quirks, their
- 21:53unique struggles, their hidden talents, is a
- 21:56deeply complex intersection of countless genetic
- 21:59votes and entirely unique environmental circumstances.
- 22:03We are all walking, breathing gene environment
- 22:05interactions. It totally shifts how you view
- 22:08the world. So as we close out today's deep dive,
- 22:12we want to leave you with the final thought to
- 22:14ponder on your own. Go for it. Think back to
- 22:16that x -ray machine from the very beginning of
- 22:18our conversation. If medical science reaches
- 22:21a point where your exact epigenome can be mapped
- 22:24just as clearly as a broken bone, revealing the
- 22:27chemical scars of every stressor, every famine
- 22:30or environmental trauma your ancestors ever endured,
- 22:33how would you change the way you live today?
- 22:36Wow. Knowing that your daily choices are quite
- 22:38literally the chemical ink for tomorrow, how
- 22:40would you change the way you write the punctuation
- 22:42for the next generation? Thanks for diving deep
- 22:45with us today.