Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Supreme Court of Canada Orders Acquittal: A Miscarriage of Justice
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for a regular segment, joined as always by Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan defence lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Legally Speaking on CFAX Afternoon.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Michael, how are we doing?
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: Interesting things on the agenda Up.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: First I'm reading the Supreme Court of Canada concluding the Court of Appeals should have entered an acquittal after setting aside a conviction of a BC woman in relation to the death of a baby.
- 0:24Adam Stirling: What happened here?
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: Nothing good happened here.
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: This was just a complete tragedy start to finish, and so it's.
- 0:32Michael Mulligan: A BC case started out in BC and it involved a woman who had taken care of another woman who had taken care of this 19-month-old toddler, I guess, and she'd done that on a number of occasions.
- 0:47Michael Mulligan: This was up in Cranbrook back in 2011.
- 0:50Michael Mulligan: And tragically, the young girl that she was taking care of died in the bathtub and the cause of death was determined to be drowning in the bathtub.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: Of death was determined to be drowning in the bathtub, and part of the trouble for this woman the babysitter, I guess we'll call her who was charged eventually with second-degree murder arose out of various inconsistent things that she'd said reporting how this happened, like, for example, when she called 911, she claimed that she had just turned her head for a moment in the bathroom and when she looked back, the child had fallen down in the tub.
- 1:30Michael Mulligan: And then, in a subsequent statement to the police, she said she'd briefly stepped out of the room.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: So she gave slightly different versions of events about what happened, which caused suspicion, and eventually there was an autopsy performed by a medical examiner from Alberta, and the medical examiner offered various opinions about the cause of death and also opining about some injuries seen on the head of the toddler who passed away, and it resulted in the woman being tricked with secondary murder.
- 2:01Michael Mulligan: Now, another confounding factor I should say here is that the mother of the baby or toddler also revealed that a short period of time prior to all of this, the child had suffered a viral brain infection and had been hospitalized for it.
- 2:18Michael Mulligan: So there are some other things going on that may have contributed to what happened in the bathtub.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: But this woman who was charged with second-degree murder had what's called a preliminary inquiry.
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: It's like a hearing about whether there's enough evidence to proceed to trial in a serious criminal case, and at that preliminary inquiry this medical examiner testified and offered opinions about things including an injury on her child's lip, the cause of drowning and so on, and largely on the strength of what the medical examiner had to say at the preliminary inquiry, the woman was required to stand trial for second-degree murder.
- 2:56Michael Mulligan: The preliminary inquiry judge determined there was enough evidence to proceed with a trial.
- 3:00Michael Mulligan: Now the problem started to arise because there had been a review of some of this medical examiner's work done in Alberta and the Alberta government wrote to the BC, the police and Crown in BC and they provided 140 pages of material detailing the results of an independent review conducted by three other medical examiners that raised concerns about the reliability of the opinion of this examiner in this case and a series of other cases, and outlining what all those were.
- 3:35Michael Mulligan: And the problem was that the Crown didn't provide all of that to the defence.
- 3:41Michael Mulligan: They didn't know that there'd been this independent review calling into question the conclusion drawn by this medical examiner and in that context, not knowing about those concerns about the person's opinions, defense agreed to plead guilty to a charge of criminal negligence causing death.
- 4:03Michael Mulligan: And the woman did that and she was sentenced to a year in prison, which she served.
- 4:09Michael Mulligan: And then, several years later, after that all had transpired and I should say the sentence, according to the Supreme Court of Canada, had a completely devastating impact on this woman's life.
- 4:21Michael Mulligan: She lost custody of her own four children, she was ostracized from her community, she wound up with a drug addiction, she became homeless, wound up in poverty, served her entire sentence, just completely ruined, destroyed her life in any way, every way imaginable.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: And then in British Columbia, some years later, there was a special prosecutor appointed to look into the case and the special prosecutor concluded, realized that the Crown at the time had withheld the information about the medical examiner, hadn't given it to the defense, and so that resulted in the case going before the Court of Appeal and the Crown in BC, the special prosecutor agreeing taking the position of the Court of Appeal.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: There was just a terrible miscarriage of justice in terms of what happened here.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: Of course in criminal cases there is an obligation, and for very good reason, that the Crown is required to provide to the defense evidence and material they have which is exculpatory, like evidence that might show you might not have done it right.
- 5:25Michael Mulligan: They can't just keep that secret and it was without that information that the woman had pled guilty to this other offense.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: And I should say it's understandable why somebody might choose to do that in the circumstances, because a conviction for murder results in a life sentence.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: So if I tell you you're on trial for murder, if you're convicted you're in prison, potentially for the rest of your life, or you complete guilty to this other offense and go to jail for a year, it is easy to see how somebody might pick up should do so.
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: On that basis it went to the court of appeal and the court of appeal concluded that indeed there was a miscarriage of justice, which is very interesting.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: I'll come to another postscript on this case in a moment.
- 6:04Michael Mulligan: They concluded that and then the Crown took the position saying, well, the appropriate remedy would be for the Court of Appeal to enter an acquittal.
- 6:14Michael Mulligan: And the way that works is that there's a section of the criminal code dealing with, well, what happens in the court of appeal, where they determine that there was a miscarriage of justice, what should happen, and it's under 686, sub 2 of the criminal code.
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: And the court of appeal has three options under that section.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: One option is to order a new trial.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: Another option is to enter what's called a judicial stay of proceedings, where the court just says that's it, this isn't going further.
- 6:41Michael Mulligan: Or the third option is to enter an acquittal.
- 6:44Michael Mulligan: And at the Court of Appeal, interestingly, the Crown took the position that the appropriate remedy here would be an acquittal and said clearly that, look, if there was a new trial ordered, the Crown would call no evidence and the result result would be she would be acquitted.
- 7:00Michael Mulligan: The Court of Appeal rejected that.
- 7:03Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal said no, no, we're not doing that.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: We think that there is other evidence in this case right, which could theoretically have resulted in a jury convicting, even if you deal with the potential problems with the medical examiner's evidence.
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: They said well, we think it's the least possible, so we're not going to do that, despite the Crown saying no, you should be acquitting her.
- 7:24Michael Mulligan: And so that's what went to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada had to decide what's appropriate.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: How should a court of appeal deal with it where you have the Crown standing up saying there's a miscarriage of justice here.
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: She should be acquitted?
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: Should the Court of Appeal nonetheless just say, well, we're entering a state of proceedings?
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: I mean, on one level they have a similar effect, right, but at the end of the day the woman has served her entire sentence, her life has been decimated and really sort of what's at stake is well, how is that viewed?
- 7:56Michael Mulligan: Might that help somehow repair her reputation somehow if it's an acquittal rather than a stay?
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada revisited that issue and how that section is to be interpreted, and they concluded that the appropriate remedy here was an acquittal Given the Crown acknowledging there is a miscarriage of justice.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: And that's what was found by the Court of Appeal.
- 8:17Michael Mulligan: Clearly, and given the proposition that the Crown saying saying, look, there should be an acquittal and if you order a new trial we would call no evidence and the immediate result would be a acquittal, right, yeah, and the supreme court of canada agreed.
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: The supreme court of canada said look, that's what should have happened here.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: There shouldn't be a necessity of going through sort of a pro forma, ordering a new trial and and then having the Crown stand up and say we call no evidence and we invite you to acquit, and then having another trial judge acquit that.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: Where there's a miscarriage of justice and where the Crown is taking that position in particular, that would be the appropriate result If Canada's done, for all the good it's going to do this woman, who's had her life ruined by how this case was handled and the failure to provide her or her lawyers with the information about this review of the medical examiner's opinions.
- 9:12Michael Mulligan: Now the other fascinating postscript about this very same fact, pattern and case and medical examiner is the medical examiner took issue with how he was treated and he wound up getting involved in litigation with the Alberta government and with the CBC over a.
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: The CBC did a TV special about this case and that background and what happened and the it was the Fifth Estate, the episode about it.
- 9:44Michael Mulligan: And so, fascinatingly, on just in March of this year, the government of Alberta issued a letter of apology to the medical examiner saying that he was treated unfairly.
- 9:59Michael Mulligan: And he was treated unfairly.
- 10:01Michael Mulligan: And he was an apology saying, amongst other things in this apology there have been no miscarriages of justice in connection with this doctor's work, which is just fascinating, given, of course, we've just had the BC Court of Appeal and now the Supreme Court of Canada rendering these decisions on the very basis that there is a miscarriage of justice.
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: Now I suppose you could square that circle to some extent by saying well, look, the clear miscarriage of justice here was not telling the defense about the independent review by three other pathologists of this doctor's work that clearly on its own resulted in the miscarriage of justice.
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: The person just didn't know what was going on and the potential problems with his opinion.
- 10:47Michael Mulligan: Had that happened, of course, you would have then had the potential, for the defense might have then said well, we're not entering guilty plea to anything.
- 10:55Michael Mulligan: Your case is premised on this.
- 10:57Michael Mulligan: We're going to proceed and we're going to rigorously challenge and cross-examine this person about his opinion, at which point.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: Of course, he would have then had an opportunity to be quote treated fairly in the sense that he could have then, I suppose, defended his opinion in court.
- 11:14Michael Mulligan: And so you've got this just really interesting scene of affairs where a woman's life has been ruined by the failure to provide the information and the doctor is filed engaged in this litigation and complaint about being treated unfairly, which has resulted in this remarkable apology, saying something which to, at least on one level, appears to contradict what the Supreme Court of Canada, bc Court of Appeal and the special prosecutor concluded, bearing in mind, I suppose, that a caveat, which could be the unfairness or the miscarriage of justice, could have been not telling them, telling defense about the conclusion rather than necessarily the conclusion being wrong.
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, the other postscript is that the Supreme Court of Canada points out that the family of the deceased is supportive of the woman being found not guilty.
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: Their view is that that's the appropriate thing here, and you can just imagine the just compounded tragedy, right, if you're the parents of this deceased child, finding out not only having lost your child child but also now potentially have had the child's caregiver having been, wrongfully, you know, winding up spending a year of her life in prison and her life destroyed over it, right?
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: No doubt that's completely unsatisfactory as well.
- 12:29Michael Mulligan: So their position was that as well, that she should have been acquitted.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: So just a fascinating case out of BC.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: And really the takeaway for all of us involved in the criminal justice system is you've got to make sure that you're just carefully letting the other side know all of the evidence that you've got, and if you don't, it can just ruin lives start to finish, and this is an example of that.
- 12:51Michael Mulligan: Now, that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada and to the extent that the acquittal now, rather than the state of proceedings, provides some solace and closure, at the very least we've got that and the medical examiner has his apology from the Alberta government.
- 13:07Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 13:09Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue in just a moment on CFAX 1070.
- 13:12Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continues on CFAX 1070.
- 13:15Adam Stirling: Joined, as always by Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 13:19Adam Stirling: On CFAX 1070, joined as always by Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 13:22Adam Stirling: Michael up next on my agenda.
- 13:22Adam Stirling: It says a sentence reduction for police video recording a man arrested for impaired driving while using the toilet.
- 13:29Adam Stirling: It says, but no further reduction to avoid deportation.
- 13:33Adam Stirling: There's some layers here?
- 13:36Michael Mulligan: There sure are.
- 13:36Michael Mulligan: I mean, on one level, this is a case of a burden, and on one level, you look at it and say, well, first of all, it doesn't look too remarkable.
- 13:42Michael Mulligan: To begin with, it was an impaired driving case that started with the man rear-ending another vehicle in a fender bender, and so, at first blush, you look at that and say, well, this doesn't seem too aggravated.
- 13:53Michael Mulligan: Nobody was injured.
- 13:54Michael Mulligan: The problems for this man, though, really relate to both his immigration status and his record.
- 14:02Michael Mulligan: First of all, his immigration status.
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: He's 57 years of age, he's lived in Canada for over 34 years, but he's only a permanent resident.
- 14:09Michael Mulligan: That's a problem, because, if you wind up being guilty of what's called serious criminality, you are subject to being deported without a hearing, no matter how long you've been here and whatever your circumstances might be, and that's a good reason why, if you are a permanent resident and eligible to apply for citizenship, do so, because you might find yourself on the outs after 34 years.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: Now the other problem for this man you still might think how is this going to turn into quote serious criminality?
- 14:38Michael Mulligan: Because one of the ways to get there is that you need to get a jail sentence of more than six months or be convicted of something that could land you in prison for more than 10 years.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: So the problem for this man is he's been a very, very bad driver for all that period of time.
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: He has on his record, according to the judge, 32 driving prohibitions, 16 separate.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: This is beyond the 32, 24-hour driving prohibitions.
- 15:05Michael Mulligan: Those are usually for alcohol, along with a substantial number of criminal code, other motor vehicle act infractions, and so just an incorrigible it looks like impaired driver, and the man had a trial where he was convicted and sentenced.
- 15:21Michael Mulligan: There was a new trial ordered after he'd served 111 days in jail, and then that brings us to this case, the trial decision.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: The first part of it, or one of the issues of the case, was that after the man was arrested and after he'd brought to the police station and after he provided his breath samples, they kept the man in cells for some reason.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: It was unclear why and when they kept him in cells at the police detachment.
- 15:44Michael Mulligan: There they were video recording him on a video system where you could both, I guess, watch it and also it's recorded, and the video system included a video of him.
- 15:55Michael Mulligan: The toilet, like it's a cell with a toilet with no nothing blocking it, and so the video recording of the man included a video of him defecating in the toilet clearly on the video.
- 16:08Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, there are two other elements.
- 16:11Michael Mulligan: One is that there is apparently a sign, or more than one sign, notifying people, like in the booking area, subject to video recording in the cell right, and apparently there is some policy whereby they're supposed to give you like a screen or something if you ask for it to use the toilet, but there's no indication, no, that you could get such a screen so you don't ask for that became illegal yeah you have to know to ask for it.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: Good luck with that.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: One right um.
- 16:36Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that the videotaping of the man using the toilet, uh, constituted a constitutional breach that had impacted his dignity, embarrassing him, you know, showing him in this way, although the judge, and so the issue then was what's the remedy for that?
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: And so the judge rejected a remedy of staying the proceedings they know this is quite serious, given the man's record, that's not happening Also rejected the idea that there should be some evidence excluded as a result of that, because really the investigation was finished, so that wasn't going to be a remedy.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: And so the judge said well, there could be some remedy if he's convicted, in terms of some reduction in the sentence as a remedy for this toilet videotaping.
- 17:17Michael Mulligan: Well, the man was convicted.
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: And then the issue for the judge was the man's submission was look, don't send me to jail for more than six months or I'll be deported on the basis of serious criminality.
- 17:29Michael Mulligan: And the judge had to review in some detail all the law surrounding that.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: And indeed judges can take into account, like the collateral consequences of a case to determine, you know, what impact should that have on your sentence, right, like, for example, if somebody was, you know, fired from their job and lost everything and so on as a result of the same circumstance.
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: That's a consideration, right in terms of what sentence should be imposed, and so you can give some consideration of the fact that you may get deported over something.
- 18:00Michael Mulligan: A judge can at least think about that, and here, however, the judge concluded that it's just not appropriate to reduce the sentence to artificially get it under six months.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: The last time the guy was convicted of impaired driving, he was given five months and 29 days.
- 18:17Michael Mulligan: I think somebody was obviously thinking about well, don't turn it into a deportation.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: But the judge said no, into a deportation.
- 18:23Michael Mulligan: But the judge said no.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: He said no, that's not appropriate, I'm not doing that.
- 18:27Michael Mulligan: And did, however, take into account the fact that he'd already spent 111 days in prison and did take into account the fact that he was video recorded on the toilet although he found that that was a minor impact on him and ultimately concluded that on the impaired driving count, he should get what he eventually calculated as 198 days in prison, like a year, minus subtracting the time he'd already served and this and that, which is 6.6 months.
- 19:00Michael Mulligan: So it would appear that on that count alone, he's in some jeopardy of being removed from Canada, despite how long he's been here for.
- 19:10Michael Mulligan: The other interesting element of all this was well, what's the sentence?
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: There's a separate charge of driving while prohibited and the judge found that that should be a consecutive sentence, like one that is, after the impaired driving sentence is served right, not running at the same time, after the impaired driving sentence is served right, not running at the same time.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: And on that count, the judge pointed out that the man was subject to five previous driving prohibitions at the time he was driving, like for five different reasons.
- 19:38Michael Mulligan: He'd been prohibited from driving, but he was still driving, and the judge actually used the language flabbergasted that the Crown wasn't seeking the maximum possible sentence, which would be two years less a day for the driving while prohibited.
- 19:49Michael Mulligan: Given that, but having, I guess, calmed down a bit from being flabbergasted, the judge did take into account the fact that he'd already served a period of time in custody, that he was going to have these collateral consequences of likely deportation, that there should be some consideration given to mitigate the sentence in terms of the toilet videotaping, and after all of that, gave him 120 days consecutive, so after he served the next 6.6 months on the driving while prohibited case.
- 20:20Michael Mulligan: So the net result of all that is that the man did get a sentence that exceeded the six months, so it's likely to be serious criminality and the likely result is going to be deportation for citizenship.
- 20:31Michael Mulligan: To get on with that, because there are indeed a long list of possible offenses where, even if you don't go over the six-month mark, the charge itself like for things like assault with a weapon right.
- 20:56Michael Mulligan: Maybe you're charged with assault by throwing a TV remote control at somebody or something, right.
- 21:00Michael Mulligan: Regardless of what sentence you get, you may find yourself inadmissible to Canada and out, and so if you're eligible you've been here for years get on with it.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: The other cautionary tale of course this should be a takeaway for other police departments don't videotape people naked who are in cells, and the judge pointed out there could be reasons to do it, like if you had a reason to think somebody was going to harm themselves or you thought somebody was trying to dispose of drugs secreted on their body, like there could be reasons why you could legitimately do it.
- 21:31Michael Mulligan: But you can't just have a video camera pointed at the toilet and record a person in sort of the most embarrassing way.
- 21:38Michael Mulligan: That's just not going to be permissible and even though here it was viewed as a relatively minor factor, it was viewed as a breach and I'm sure if you had, the police continue to do that.
- 21:48Michael Mulligan: In light of this clear judicial message, hey, don't do that right.
- 21:52Michael Mulligan: The next time there may be a more significant remedy.
- 21:54Michael Mulligan: So no toilet videotaping.
- 21:56Michael Mulligan: And if you're prohibited, stop driving.
- 21:58Michael Mulligan: And if you're eligible for citizenship, get on with it.
- 22:01Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the BC Provincial Court.
- 22:03Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday on CFAX 1070.
- 22:07Adam Stirling: Thank you so much, Michael.
- 22:08Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 22:10Michael Mulligan: Thanks so much.
- 22:10Michael Mulligan: Always great to be here.