Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / 6 Ways State Policymakers Can Build More Future-Focused Education Systems: A Podcast Series with the Aurora Institute: Episode 4
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:07and you're listening to Six Ways State Policymakers Can Build More Future-Focused
- 0:12Education Systems, a podcast series with the Aurora Institute.
- 0:15The Aurora Institute is a national nonprofit organization working on policy
- 0:20advocacy, field building and capacity building, research and knowledge sharing,
- 0:24and convening to advance innovative approaches that transform education for youth across America.
- 0:30In April of 2024, the Aurora Institute released state policy recommendations
- 0:35to transform education for all learners,
- 0:38especially those who have been underserved by the current system.
- 0:41Each five-minute segment in our series will cover one of the six identified policy shifts.
- 0:47Joining us today is Virgil Hammons, CEO of the Aurora Institute, and Jennifer Kabaker.
- 0:55So let's talk about the fourth recommendation, which is to align accountability and data systems.
- 1:00So Jennifer, tell us more about what this means on a systems level.
- 1:04What are we looking at here?
- 1:06Sure. So our current accountability systems focus on ranking and sorting schools and systems.
- 1:11They're top-down, and they are not designed to really help schools improve or
- 1:15to better serve students.
- 1:16Additionally, those accountability systems don't reflect what local communities
- 1:19want from their education systems, which we said before would be defined by
- 1:23portraits or profile of a graduate.
- 1:26So by aligning accountability systems and supporting data systems with a portrait
- 1:31or profile of a graduate,
- 1:32skates could start actually holding schools accountable for a more robust set
- 1:37of indicators that capture not just results on summative assessments,
- 1:40but more meaningful measures of school quality.
- 1:42You could imagine a lot of what these mean. So they could include academic measures,
- 1:46but it could also be inputs like access to real world learning or career development for students.
- 1:51It could also be indicators of school climate or student sense of belonging.
- 1:56States like Kentucky have already begun to engage their communities in tackling
- 1:59this work, but there's much to be done still because of some of the federal
- 2:04requirements around compliance on existing accountability systems.
- 2:08What we imagine this all would look like is what we call reciprocal accountability.
- 2:12So accountability systems that are developed in partnership with communities,
- 2:15that's parents, learners, educators, the business community,
- 2:20other community members, to help identify what inputs and outputs the school
- 2:24should be held accountability before.
- 2:26And the ultimate goal of that system is around continuous improvement.
- 2:29So what's the information that states and local leaders need to actually determine
- 2:33whether students are on a path to success and to hold the systems accountable
- 2:37for that student progress?
- 2:38But you could also imagine what the data systems look like that could move beyond
- 2:43just collecting student demographics and outcomes on summative assessments,
- 2:47but to become what are called learning and employment records or LERs.
- 2:51And those would capture what students know and are able to do both inside the classroom and beyond.
- 2:57It could ultimately possibly replace transcripts and follow learners beyond
- 3:01the K-12 system and into higher ed and the workforce, effectively breaking down
- 3:05the silos between these systems that we face today.
- 3:08Yeah, we see a lot of that, those silos that pop up in so many different ways
- 3:13in the world of education.
- 3:14But what's one of the biggest challenges with this policy shift?
- 3:18Absolutely. So the first is thinking through how we authentically and meaningfully
- 3:23engage with communities to elevate voices of educators and learners,
- 3:27families, administrators, community members to help inform those accountability systems.
- 3:33That's something that has to be done carefully and authentically.
- 3:35We have some really interesting examples on the ground for how to do that,
- 3:39but you could imagine that it could look different in different places.
- 3:41And the other thing that comes out of this conversation about reciprocal accountability
- 3:45is this idea that we could be
- 3:47designing accountability systems that look different in different places.
- 3:50And that might mean collecting data that makes it difficult to compare a district
- 3:56in one city in a state versus a district in another city in that same state.
- 4:00This is a concept often called comparability.
- 4:03But we believe that comparability should not take precedence over an accountability
- 4:07system that's responsive to student and community needs or a system that's not
- 4:11designed to support continuous improvement.
- 4:13And moving away from a system that prioritizes comparability will take a lot
- 4:18of political will, building a big tent to support this conversation.
- 4:21Yeah. What might this look like in practice in a classroom? You know,
- 4:25what's a vision of success for seeing this implemented? Absolutely.
- 4:29So when accountability systems are aligned with broader visions for student success,
- 4:34schools and systems will actually have a meaningful incentive to focus their
- 4:38efforts on providing learners with high quality and engaging learning experiences,
- 4:43which we think will effectively lessen the focus on summative assessments and preparation for them.
- 4:48So really dialing up the emphasis on what teaching and learning looks like and
- 4:53ensuring that those learning experiences really meet the needs of the learners.
- 4:56We also think that states and school leaders will have access to more holistic
- 4:59information about school quality and educational outcomes, and that will result
- 5:04in more meaningful ways to support schools and educators and learners in improving those outcomes.
- 5:09And then when we talk about the data system, this is where I get really excited
- 5:13because we can imagine a world where every student, educator,
- 5:16and caretaker has real-time access to data, where they can understand student
- 5:21progressions, evidence of what they know and are able to do,
- 5:24and where they still have room to grow.
- 5:25So a parent could have access to a digital portfolio of their student's work,
- 5:29but that student could also take that digital portfolio and share it with a potential employer.
- 5:35That's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Virgil Hammons and Jennifer Kabakar.
- 5:39Be sure to check out the next episode in our series.
- 5:42I'm Aurora from ELA, and this was Six Ways State Policymakers Can Build More
- 5:47Future-Focused Education Systems.