Latest / Culture Room: Books, film, music & culture / Why You Must Write Terrible First Drafts (And How to Survive Them) | Culture Room
Transcript
- I just threw three hundred words into the trash can. And I did it with a smile, because for the first time in my life, I actually wanted to delete them. We have been sold a lie, haven’t we? A very smooth, very glossy lie that suggests creativity is a river that flows only when the banks are clear and the water is pure. We watch interviews with our favorite authors or filmmakers, and they talk about their process as if it were a straight line from inspiration to masterpiece. They say things like, 'It all came together so quickly,' or 'I knew exactly where it was going.' And you sit there, holding your pen, or staring at your blinking cursor, feeling this heavy, cold stone in your stomach because your work doesn’t look like that. Your work looks like mud. It looks like a tangled ball of yarn that someone dropped down the stairs. And you think, 'There’s something wrong with me. There’s something broken in my creative wiring.' But let me tell you what is actually broken: not you. The expectation. The idea that good writing should feel good from the very first sentence. It doesn’t. Good writing feels like digging through a swamp. It feels uncomfortable. It feels messy. And it is absolutely necessary. Let’s sit with that for a moment. Why does our inner critic show up so early? Usually, it arrives before we’ve even written the first paragraph. It stands over our shoulder, arms crossed, judging every word choice before we’ve had a chance to explore it. This critic is loud, and it is mean, and it wants perfection immediately. But here is the secret that the critics never tell you: the first draft is not supposed to be perfect. It is not supposed to be readable. It is not supposed to be anything other than existing. Your job in the first draft is not to write well. Your job is to write. To get the clay on the table. If you try to sculpt while you are still mixing the mud, you will end up with neither sculpture nor mud. You will just have a mess on your hands and a lot of frustration. I remember reading an interview with a novelist who said she wrote her first drafts in complete silence, but she also wrote them in total disregard for quality. She called them 'vomit drafts'—not because they were unpleasant, but because they were raw, unfiltered, and honest. She didn’t care if they were beautiful. She cared if they were true to the story she needed to tell. That distinction changed everything for me. So, how do we give ourselves permission to be bad? It sounds simple, but it is one of the hardest things we will ever do. It requires us to step away from the part of our brain that wants to be liked, to be smart, to be impressive. That part of the brain is useful for editing, but it is toxic for creating. When you are creating, you need to be childish. You need to be reckless. You need to allow yourself to write sentences that are clunky and ideas that are thin. I used to spend hours polishing a single paragraph, trying to make it sing, only to realize later that the whole scene didn’t fit the story anyway. What a waste of energy! What a waste of love. Now, I have a rule. I call it the 'Trash Can Rule.' If I don’t like what I wrote, I don’t fix it. I leave it there. I put a note in the margin that says, 'Fix this later,' and I move on. I trust that the future version of me will be better equipped to handle it. The present version of me is too busy exploring the landscape to worry about the paving stones. Let’s trust that process. Let’s trust that the mess has a purpose. Think back to that episode we talked about regarding the terror of showing your mess. Remember how we discussed the anxiety of sharing incomplete work? Well, the antidote to that anxiety is often just finishing the messy work. Not finishing it perfectly, but finishing it. There is a profound difference between being stuck and being done. Being stuck implies you are waiting for permission to proceed. Being done means you have completed the journey from nothing to something. Even if that something is ugly. I remember working on a piece last year—a short essay about memory and loss. I wrote thirty pages of it, and I hated every single page. It felt flat, distant, academic. I almost abandoned it. But I forced myself to finish it. I pushed through the boredom, through the self-doubt, until I reached the final period. And then, when I went back to edit, I found a thread. Just one small sentence near the end that sparked something. That one spark lit up the whole thing. Without those terrible thirty pages, I never would have found that spark. The bad writing was the fuel. It was the necessary friction that created the heat. So, if you are sitting with a draft that makes you cringe, I urge you: stay with it. Finish it. Trust that the gold is buried under the dirt, but you have to dig through the dirt to find it. It’s not just about the plot, is it? It’s about the relationship you have with yourself during the creation process. When you hate your first draft, you are often hating yourself. You are saying, 'I am not good enough to create this.' But that is not true. You are good enough to create this. You are good enough to create the mess. The skill comes later. The artistry comes later. Right now, you are in the phase of discovery. You are walking into a dark room and feeling along the walls to see where the door is. You might bump into things. You might trip. That is okay. That is part of the walk. I want you to try a different approach today. Instead of trying to write a good sentence, try to write a true one. Or a funny one. Or a strange one. Lower the stakes. Make it playful. If you treat the first draft like a game, the pressure dissipates. You start to play with words instead of fighting them. You start to listen to the rhythm of your own voice rather than the judgment of an imaginary audience. Tell me more about how that landed for you. Does it feel lighter when you remove the pressure to perform? Because it did for me. It transformed the act of writing from a test into a conversation. And then, eventually, you get to the rewrite. And oh, the rewrite is its own kind of magic. Because now you have material. Now you have something to work with. You are no longer building a house from scratch; you are renovating one. You know where the pipes are. You know which walls are load-bearing. You can knock things down and build things up with intention. This is where the craft lives. This is where you polish the marble. But you cannot polish what does not exist. You must first have the rough stone. So, embrace the roughness. Embrace the awkward phrasing. Embrace the plot holes. They are not failures; they are signposts. They are telling you where the story needs to go next. They are inviting you to dig deeper. I promise you, the most satisfying moments in creative work are not the first successes, but the breakthroughs in the second draft. That moment when you look at something you thought was worthless and suddenly see its shape, its color, its heart. That is the reward. But you have to get through the valley of the shadow of the bad draft to get there. And you do not have to walk alone. We are all in this valley together. We are all throwing words into the trash can. We are all learning to love the mess. Thank you for letting me into your space tonight. Keep writing, keep messing up, and keep trusting the process. I’ll be right here, listening, whenever you’re ready to share what comes next. Until then, take good care of yourself.