Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Generosity: The Ransom of Jerusalem's Captives
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, we've covered the siege of Jerusalem in 1187 before — the surrender, the negotiations with Balian of Ibelin. But what happened right after the gates opened is a story that often gets overshadowed. I'm talking about the fate of the tens of thousands of Frankish captives — men, women, children — who suddenly found themselves at Saladin's mercy. Luna: I've always wondered about that. The Crusaders had slaughtered everyone in 1099 — did Saladin do the same? Lucas: Quite the opposite, actually. And that's what makes this episode so striking. When Balian of Ibelin came to negotiate the surrender, he made it clear: if the city was taken by force, the Franks would fight to the death, killing their own families and destroying Muslim holy sites. Saladin, advised by his qadis and especially by al-Qadi al-Fadil, offered generous terms: a ransom. For ten days, the Franks could leave safely if they paid a set price. Lucas: The terms were, by medieval standards, almost lenient. According to Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, who was in Saladin's camp, the ransom was set at ten dinars per man, five per woman, and one per child. But the city was packed with refugees from the surrounding countryside — people who had fled the advancing Ayyubid army. Many simply couldn't pay. Luna: So what happened to the ones who couldn't afford it? Lucas: That's the heart of the drama. The ten-day period was a scramble. Balian and the Frankish nobles tried to pool money, but the total collected was nowhere near enough. By the end, about 7,000 men, 8,000 women, and 10,000 children had been ransomed — but some sources say up to 70,000 people were in the city. Thousands were left behind, facing enslavement. Lucas: Now, Saladin could have simply sold them all into slavery and pocketed a fortune. But here's where his reputation for generosity — or what his critics called profligacy — came into play. Imad ad-Din tells us that Saladin freed many of the elderly and the poor without any ransom at all, especially women who had lost their husbands. He also allowed the Frankish women to take their children with them, even if they couldn't pay the child's ransom. Luna: Wait — he let them go for free? That must have cost him a lot of money. Lucas: Absolutely. Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, Saladin's biographer, estimated that the total ransom collected was around 100,000 dinars — but the potential value of the captives on the slave market was several times that. Saladin's own treasury was strained, and his emirs were furious. They had expected a share of the loot. Instead, they watched their sultan give away their potential profits. Lucas: One story that really captures the moment: Imad ad-Din describes a Frankish woman who had lost her husband and children in the chaos. She came to Saladin begging for help. Saladin not only freed her but gave her money to travel to Antioch. When his emirs complained, he supposedly said, 'It is better to give than to receive.' That's a paraphrase, but it reflects his ethos. Luna: That's incredible. But wasn't this seen as weakness by some of his own people? Lucas: Yes, it was a real controversy. Ibn al-Athir, writing a generation later, notes that some Muslim scholars criticized Saladin for being too lenient. They pointed to the precedent of the First Crusade, where the Crusaders had massacred everyone. They argued that a firm hand would deter future invasions. But Saladin's counter-argument, as recorded by al-Qadi al-Fadil, was that mercy was a form of strength — it showed the Franks that Muslims were different, and it would make future surrenders easier. Lucas: And in a way, he was right. The ransom of Jerusalem became legendary in both Christian and Muslim chronicles. Christian writers like William of Tyre's continuators grudgingly admitted that Saladin had treated the captives with humanity. And in the Islamic world, it solidified his image as a just and generous ruler. Luna: But what about the ones who weren't freed? Did they really become slaves? Lucas: Unfortunately, yes. Imad ad-Din writes that about 5,000 to 7,000 people were taken as slaves, mostly young men and women. They were distributed among Saladin's emirs and soldiers, or sold in the markets of Damascus and Aleppo. Some were later ransomed by the Crusader states, but many spent years in captivity. It's a dark note in an otherwise uplifting story. Lucas: One more detail: there's a famous account of Saladin's own son, al-Afdal, who was given a Frankish slave girl as a gift. Al-Afdal later freed her and married her, which caused a scandal at court. But that's a story for another episode. Luna: So what's the legacy of this ransom? Did it affect the Third Crusade? Lucas: Absolutely. The stories of Saladin's generosity spread through Europe, carried by the freed captives. Richard the Lionheart and other Crusader leaders knew they were facing a different kind of enemy — one who kept his word and showed mercy. That actually made negotiations during the Third Crusade more civil. Both sides knew that surrender to Saladin was not a death sentence. Lucas: In a way, the ransom of Jerusalem was a strategic masterstroke. It saved Saladin from a bloody street fight, it enriched his treasury modestly, and it built a reputation that would serve him well in the years to come. Not bad for a few days of bargaining. Luna: It really humanizes him. Makes you wonder how history would remember him if he had ordered a massacre instead. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why this moment, more than any battle, defines Saladin for many people. It's a reminder that even in the brutal context of the Crusades, there was room for humanity.