Latest / Consumerpedia / 68 - Rewards Cards
Transcript
- 0:01Whether it's point smiles or cash back, who doesn't want to
- 0:05be rewarded for shopping? The lure of getting something
- 0:07extra can encourage people to apply for new credit cards and
- 0:11to use them to score those rewards.
- 0:13In recent years, many credit card rewards programs have
- 0:16become more complex and confusing, and frustrated card
- 0:19holders have been complaining to federal regulators.
- 0:22I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:25checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 0:27consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:31consumers select services, avoid trouble and save money.
- 0:35Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:38any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:41completely independent and objective.
- 0:44Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 0:48the consumer man Herb Weisspaum. In this episode we're going to
- 0:52talk about the possibility of new rules to regulate credit
- 0:55card reward programs. It's being considered.
- 0:58We'll focus on airline reward credit cards and look at some of
- 1:00the eye opening promotional offers.
- 1:03Plus, travel expert Christopher Elliott will join us to explain
- 1:06how chasing travel rewards can actually cost you money.
- 1:09In May, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the CFPB,
- 1:12issued a report on rewards cards outlining the numerous problems
- 1:16card holders are encountering. The agency hosted a public
- 1:19hearing along with the Department of Transportation.
- 1:22Here's a little bit of what Director Rohit Chopra said at
- 1:24that hearing. Credit card companies have
- 1:26focused heavily on ways to entice customers using features
- 1:31other than the real cost of credit, the interest rate and
- 1:35fees they charge. Credit card rewards take center
- 1:39stage in the industry's marketing blitzes, particularly
- 1:44in the form of frequent flyer miles and other proprietary
- 1:49points programs. The largest and most dominant
- 1:52airlines play a massive role in this market.
- 1:56Most of us have witnessed the advertising online, in our
- 2:01mailboxes, on television, and even while seated on an airplane
- 2:06about airline branded credit cards that make promises about
- 2:10frequent flyer mile sign up bonuses, free round trips for
- 2:16you and your family, and other travel perks.
- 2:19Frequent flyer programs have evolved from many years ago from
- 2:23a perk for the airline's most loyal customers to a multi
- 2:28billion dollar currency market where credit card companies and
- 2:32air airlines buy, sell, convert and issue miles and points
- 2:38throughout sectors of the economy.
- 2:40Miles and points can be purchased with cash earned and
- 2:44redeemed for shopping on items completely unrelated to flying.
- 2:49These points programs are major assets and competitive weapons
- 2:54for airlines and credit card companies alike.
- 2:57Let's talk more about this with Brad Lipton, Senior Advisor to
- 3:00the General Counsel at the CFPB. He joins us from CFPB
- 3:04headquarters, just across the street from the White House and
- 3:06the nation's capital. Very good to.
- 3:07Talk to you. So I would assume the CFPB is
- 3:10looking into credit card rewards programs because of those
- 3:13consumer complaints you've received, right?
- 3:14That's right, Yeah. We've received over 1200
- 3:17complaints in 2023 involving credit card rewards and our
- 3:20internal calculations suggest that's a more than 70% increase
- 3:23in complaints from pre pandemic levels about credit card
- 3:26rewards. So when your agency reviewed
- 3:28complaints about rewards cards, you identified 4 recurring
- 3:32themes, and I'd like to discuss each one of them with you
- 3:34individually #1 consumers fail to receive promotional rewards
- 3:38when the financial institutions impose vague or hidden
- 3:41conditions. What's going on there?
- 3:42We're concerned that credit card companies, in particular big
- 3:45companies, make promises to consumers at, you know, in big
- 3:48prints and advertising about sign on bonuses or other ways
- 3:52that consumers can earn credit card rewards points.
- 3:54But when it comes time for those points actually will be
- 3:57rewarded. There's terms and conditions in
- 3:58the fine prints that actually make it very hard for consumers
- 4:01to get those points that they've earned, according to the
- 4:05marketing and other big disclosures.
- 4:07From my personal experience, I think that fine print usually is
- 4:10you have to spend like $3000 within the first three or six
- 4:13months or something like that in order to get those 60 or 70,000
- 4:16miles that are in the big bold headline.
- 4:18Is that one of the problems you're talking about?
- 4:20One of the issues with terms and conditions that we hear from
- 4:22consumers and consumer complaints are issues like gift
- 4:26cards not being allowed to count towards the total amount.
- 4:29Things of that nature where consumers are told if they spend
- 4:32a certain amount of money in a certain period of time they will
- 4:34get a bonus. But it turns out there are
- 4:36certain categories of spending which are carved out in the fine
- 4:39print and consumers, of course, reading the big print, would
- 4:41have no way of knowing that. So there's a qualification goal
- 4:43of how much you have to spend to get the miles, and if you use
- 4:46the card to buy gift cards, that doesn't count.
- 4:49That's right. OK.
- 4:50That's something a lot of people probably don't know.
- 4:52Secondary of concern, consumers lose benefits that they
- 4:55previously earned when credit card issuers and merchants
- 4:58devalue rewards. I think we're all aware that
- 5:00with the airline industry, things are always changing with
- 5:02the rewards program. Is that part of what's going on
- 5:04here? Yeah, that's right.
- 5:06We've heard from consumers that issuers as well as their
- 5:08merchant partners reduce the value of awards that consumers
- 5:11have already earned. You know, consumers are
- 5:13responsible for paying their credit card bills and they live
- 5:15up to their end of the bargain. And we're very concerned that
- 5:18consumers complain that companies don't live up to
- 5:20theirs. They value points, change the
- 5:22value of them with no notice to consumers, or they remove
- 5:25benefits that consumers have come to expect based on
- 5:28representations from the company.
- 5:29So that's a big concern. So continuing of the most common
- 5:31complaints #3 consumers face obstacles and receiving their
- 5:35preferred redemptions when companies fail to quickly
- 5:38resolve rewards related issues. So there's not a lot of good
- 5:41customer service going on here when there are problems.
- 5:43Yeah, that's right. One thing I would emphasize here
- 5:46is that we've really seen credit card rewards taking center stage
- 5:49in industries marketing campaigns lately.
- 5:51That's really been a big change. And another big change that
- 5:54we've seen in this market is the rise of these points cards.
- 5:57About 50% of credit card rewards at this point are on proprietary
- 6:00currencies, things like individual credit card companies
- 6:03points. And this seems to have raised a
- 6:06slew of new issues the consumers have raised for us.
- 6:09And in particular issues where consumers are promised these
- 6:11points and they're promised that they will be able to transfer
- 6:13them to merchants and use them at those merchants.
- 6:15And then when problems arise, they are caught in what we like
- 6:18to call a doom loop between the credit card company and the
- 6:21merchant. So there's a problem with the
- 6:23transfer portal, the online portal, The credit card company
- 6:25says call up the merchant, they'll fix it.
- 6:27And then the consumer does what they're told, they call up the
- 6:29merchant and lo and behold, they're sent back to the credit
- 6:31card company and said call the credit card company.
- 6:33They're the one who has to fix. It really puts consumers in an
- 6:36impossible position. And again, just to emphasize,
- 6:38these are consumers who have earned these points.
- 6:40They've been promised these points and it's really not
- 6:42acceptable to us if they're not able to spend them.
- 6:44And #4 is probably the most concerning to me.
- 6:47Consumers suddenly lose rewards when issuers unilaterally revoke
- 6:52previously earned balances. They just pull the plug on your
- 6:54account. Yeah, that's right.
- 6:56Under the terms and conditions of many credit cards, credit
- 6:58card companies are allowed to unilaterally terminate consumer
- 7:01credit card accounts. But the issue we're seeing there
- 7:03as to reward is that then they take the position that those
- 7:06rewards points go away as well. And so consumers in many cases
- 7:09have saved up thousands or even million rewards points.
- 7:12And then for things completely out of their control and things
- 7:15that are also often times poorly explained to them by credit card
- 7:17companies, the credit card company closes their account and
- 7:20they take the position those rewards just disappear.
- 7:22So when your agency issued this report on rewards credit cards
- 7:25back in May, the report said that the CFPB will continue to
- 7:29monitor credit cards, rewards programs and take necessary
- 7:32action on these issues as appropriate.
- 7:34So I assume you're going to look at the marketplace and decide if
- 7:37there's any need for any new regulations to deal with all
- 7:40these problems people are reporting to you.
- 7:42We're really. Looking at taking these
- 7:43complaints very, very seriously and following up from our joint
- 7:45hearing with Department of Transportation, continuing to
- 7:48review consumer complaints and look into these issues.
- 7:50We've taken enforcement action with respect to credit card
- 7:53rewards. We did a major enforcement
- 7:54action against a large bank in June of 2023.
- 7:57And this is an issue we are very concerned about and continue to
- 8:00look at using all of our tools, whether it's enforcement
- 8:03guidance, regulations. This is something an issue that
- 8:05is concerning to us and we're going to take a hard look at it.
- 8:07And just to be clear, the CFPB is not opposed to rewards credit
- 8:11cards. You're just going to make sure
- 8:12the consumers are not tricked into applying for them and that
- 8:15they get with their promise. Did I get that right?
- 8:17Absolutely right. We have really seen credit card
- 8:19rewards taking center stage and industries, marketing campaigns
- 8:23and consumers are living up to their end of the bargain.
- 8:26They're earning these credit card rewards points.
- 8:28They have a lot of evidence. They're choosing their credit
- 8:30cards based on the rewards available.
- 8:32And our concern is that consumers should get treated
- 8:34fairly with those points in the credit card companies and
- 8:37merchants to partner with them should live up to their end of
- 8:39the bargain as well. You know, this is also for us a
- 8:42competition issue. 1 issue that we have seen is that big
- 8:45companies, big credit card companies, big banks have
- 8:48increasingly made themselves exclusive relationships with
- 8:51merchants, entered into exclusive contracts with
- 8:53merchants about how credit card points and rewards are going to
- 8:56be used. That really puts the smaller
- 8:58players in a difficult position. What we hear from them is that
- 9:02they would like to compete on credit card rewards points, but
- 9:04they just don't have the resources of these big companies
- 9:06that lock in these exclusive deals.
- 9:08So there's really a competition angle, but and very much as you
- 9:11said, a consumer harm angle, we really think the consumers are
- 9:14who earn what these credit card rewards points should get what
- 9:16they've earned. This podcast had a problem or
- 9:19believes they weren't treated fairly.
- 9:21They want to complain about a rewards credit card.
- 9:23Do you? Does the CFPB want to hear from
- 9:25them? Would you like them to file a
- 9:26complaint? Absolutely.
- 9:28Please send your listeners, everyone who's listening right
- 9:30now, consumerfinance.gov. If you've had a problem with the
- 9:33Consumer Financial product or service, including credit cards,
- 9:35including credit card rewards, log on to consumerfinance.gov
- 9:38and file a complaint. We really read those complaints.
- 9:41They drive all of our work enforcement guidance policy.
- 9:44We are absolutely interested in listening to consumers and I can
- 9:46just tell you from first and experience, those complaints
- 9:49really drive the work of the agency and we are absolutely
- 9:52dedicated to making sure that consumers are treated fairly,
- 9:54particularly with respect to credit card rewards.
- 9:56So please, please, please log on and let us know if you've had
- 9:58these issues. Brad Lipton with the Consumer
- 10:00Financial Protection Bureau. The CFPB is a very active
- 10:04Regulatory agency that tries to make Consumer Financial products
- 10:07work for us and the economy as a whole.
- 10:09Brad, thanks for being with us. Thanks for having me on.
- 10:11Now, following that CFPB report on rewards cards in May, the
- 10:15American Bankers Association said consumers like rewards
- 10:18credit cards. The ABA accused the agency of
- 10:20putting politics over policy. In a statement, the association
- 10:24said, quote, if the Bureau wants to truly help consumers, it
- 10:27should start by defending the credit card rewards programs
- 10:30that Americans use everyday to stretch their dollars and help
- 10:33make ends meet. End of quote.
- 10:35Up next, there are benefits to having a travel rewards card
- 10:38sometimes for some people. We'll talk about that next.
- 10:42If you like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a
- 10:45consumer PDS supporter by using the link at the bottom of the
- 10:48show notes to make a small contribution each month.
- 10:51This is consumer pedia. Airline frequent flyer program
- 10:56started out as a simple but powerful way to build customer
- 10:59loyalty. Get award miles based on how far
- 11:02you flew. Earn enough miles and you could
- 11:04redeem them for various types of award seats.
- 11:06These frequent flyer programs are still going strong, but
- 11:09today the airlines are pushing their rewards credit cards, and
- 11:12they offer some big bonuses to do that.
- 11:15Our next guest, Stephen Carvel, is a finance professor at the SC
- 11:18Johnson College of Business at Cornell University.
- 11:21Hi. How are you doing?
- 11:22Very well. Thank you.
- 11:23Airline rewards cards become a big revenue source for many
- 11:27airlines. How much we talking about what
- 11:28percentage of their income these days?
- 11:30Well. I think it varies.
- 11:32They get pre purchased miles from the banks that they do
- 11:36business with, so it's 1015%. So is that why we have flight
- 11:40attendants Hawking the airline's credit card before we land on
- 11:43every flight? If you ask me to say explicitly,
- 11:46I'm unsure of it, but I believe for the flight crew it's a bonus
- 11:50program. Of course, from the airline's
- 11:52point of view, their their motivation is to make sure that
- 11:55as many people as possible are signed up.
- 11:58They have a captive audience. But in the old days, they wanted
- 12:01you to sign up because they wanted the loyalty.
- 12:03Now it's because they're making so much revenue from it.
- 12:06I think, you know, from the standpoint of an airline, they
- 12:09look at loyalty in a spectrum. They want to create a marginal
- 12:13motivation to fly on United or fly an American if possible, and
- 12:19that's how they view that process.
- 12:21So unlike the original frequent flyer programs, which required
- 12:24you to buy a ticket and fly, you can earn points or miles just by
- 12:28using the card to buy groceries or gasoline or whatever.
- 12:30But the airlines are fine with that because they make money
- 12:32every time you use the card, right?
- 12:34Every time you use the card, the merchant who is accepting that
- 12:39credit card is usually paying somewhere around 2 to 3% off of
- 12:43the top of the revenue stream. And that money goes to the bank.
- 12:48And then the bank will, you know, share some of it with the
- 12:52airline. That's a lot of money.
- 12:53You know, there's a lot. You know, if you think of how
- 12:55many millions of people have the card and how many thousands of
- 13:00dollars they charge, possibly a month, that adds up to a lot of
- 13:04money. While miles have becoming a way
- 13:06of form of currency, they're not really worth anything unless you
- 13:09earn enough of them to use them. And unless you fly a lot, that
- 13:12may not be easy to do. Yeah, you know, I don't know.
- 13:15It depends on what you want to do do.
- 13:16You can usually get an upgrade so you know that's a possible
- 13:20use of the miles even if you're not getting an entire free trip.
- 13:23But yeah, I mean if you're only going to use 10,000 miles a
- 13:26year, it's not going to add up to much.
- 13:28It's going to take you a few years to get a free flight.
- 13:30There's nothing to stop the airlines from changing the goal
- 13:32posts or how many miles it takes for a reward.
- 13:35Years after you started earning them, your currency's been
- 13:37devalued. Why are they doing this?
- 13:39Why aren't they afraid of annoying their customers?
- 13:41Well. I think, but as more and more
- 13:44people accrue more and more miles, those miles actually
- 13:48translate into liabilities. You know, whether it's for a
- 13:51hotel for points or on points in an airline.
- 13:55That's just a way for them to control that growing liability
- 13:59every once in a while. Plus, as you just mentioned, if
- 14:02the flights are generally full, you know, it's not like you're
- 14:06translating those miles for an empty seat.
- 14:08You're displacing a paying customer by translating the
- 14:12miles. And then they look at that and
- 14:13say, OK, what is the reasonable opportunity cost of the seat
- 14:18that you're trying to buy? And then they might raise the
- 14:21number of miles required to buy it.
- 14:23I know that some people feel like it should be immutable, but
- 14:26of course, it says in the contract that it isn't, or it
- 14:29says in the literature that it's not, that they have the ability
- 14:32to do that from time to time. Some of them are doing it now
- 14:34not just by the leg, but by the number of miles on the leg, so
- 14:39they have different ways of adjusting it.
- 14:41So what do you see down the road?
- 14:42Will airlines continue to be as aggressive with their marketing
- 14:45of these Co branded credit cards?
- 14:47You know, I think that we're finding already, if you look at
- 14:50the statistics, that more and more people are topping out on
- 14:55their credit card limits, meaning that they're not going
- 14:59to qualify. Their credit ratings are going
- 15:02down for a large part of the population and then the rest of
- 15:06people have already chosen the people who have really high FICO
- 15:10scores, et cetera. They already have one or two
- 15:13cards that they're using as their preference cards.
- 15:15So I think the the number of ads is going to start dropping and
- 15:20therefore they're not going to be paying as much attention to
- 15:22adding more and more people because the yield on that ask is
- 15:26going to keep on dropping. And I think we're probably
- 15:28already seeing that. So what are they going to do?
- 15:31They're going to keep on getting me to figure out ways to use my
- 15:34card more often. Any other thoughts you have
- 15:36about these reward airline reward credit cards?
- 15:39I think people should look at it and say that having the card as
- 15:43an intermittent traveler, you'll have a higher probability of not
- 15:47having to stress out about them not having room for your luck.
- 15:50I have an American Airlines card.
- 15:52I think it cost me $79 a year to have the card.
- 15:56And part of the benefits of having that card gets me
- 16:01immediately regardless of my status zone for boarding, you
- 16:05know, So at some level at least, maybe also that $79, if I'm a
- 16:10reasonable traveler, it means that they'll be likely room it
- 16:15on the overhead for my baggage, you know, when I get on the
- 16:18plane as opposed to people or boarding zone five or six or
- 16:22seven. And you know, if I get a free
- 16:25flight every once in a while every year or so or every two
- 16:28years, that's a bonus on top of that.
- 16:31So I would almost look at it as this is a way for me to have a
- 16:34lower stress travel, less likely to be bumped automatically off
- 16:39the flight, things like that. And you may also get free
- 16:42luggage or possibly some other perks.
- 16:45Yeah, yeah. One or two bags free.
- 16:46Check. Those are the perks.
- 16:48It's cost you $79 a year for $99 a year, depending on which kind
- 16:52of card using Yeah, those benefits might just be worth it
- 16:55on their own. Steven Carvell is a finance
- 16:57professor at the SC Johnson College of Business at Cornell
- 17:00University. Thank you for spending time with
- 17:02us today. Happy to do it, have a great
- 17:04day. Up next, travel expert
- 17:06Christopher Elliott joins us from somewhere in Europe to talk
- 17:09about why he is not a fan of travel rewards cards.
- 17:12I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumerpedia,
- 17:16powered by checkbook.org. Consumer PDF Fast Facts When
- 17:22comparing rewards cards, figure out what they're really giving
- 17:25you. With a 3% cash back card, you
- 17:27get $3 back for every $100 you spend.
- 17:31The value of the points or miles you earn for that same purchase
- 17:34might not be worth $3. Here are some of the ways you
- 17:37may be able to redeem your credit card rewards as a
- 17:40statement credit deposit to a bank account, buy gift cards or
- 17:43merchandise, pay for hotel rooms or airline tickets, and donate
- 17:47to charity. When decided how to use your
- 17:49points, CNBC suggests trying to get a one to one value, meaning
- 17:53one point or mile is worth a penny.
- 17:55To calculate if you're getting a one to one value, take the cost
- 17:58of the redemption item, such as a gift card or travel
- 18:01reservation, and divide it by how many points or miles are
- 18:04needed. We couldn't discuss travel
- 18:08rewards without talking to a good friend of this podcast,
- 18:11syndicated travel columnist Christopher Elliott.
- 18:14His On Travel column appears in USA TODAY and newspapers across
- 18:17the country. Chris not only writes about
- 18:19travel, he's been traveling around the world full time since
- 18:222017. Hello Herb, how are?
- 18:25You So where in the world are you this time?
- 18:28This time I'm in Berlin, Germany, the capital.
- 18:31So when we spoke to you in April for the travel show, you were in
- 18:34beautiful Curacao, off the coast of Venezuela.
- 18:37Before that, New Zealand. How many miles do you think you
- 18:40rack up in a year? Oh.
- 18:42That's a good question. In the last year I've been
- 18:44around the world at least once, so whatever that is, probably
- 18:48much more than that. And yeah, that's a lot of miles
- 18:51or kilometers. And being a travelling man, as
- 18:53Ricky Nelson would say, if you're old enough to get that
- 18:56musical reference way to go, you must be totally focused on how
- 18:59many airline miles and hotel points you can accumulate.
- 19:03Wrong. No, I'm not actually.
- 19:05I have a somewhat tortured relationship with loyalty
- 19:08programs. I dabbled in them at the start
- 19:11of my travel journalism career and then decided that they were
- 19:14not right for me and since then have been on record as a loyalty
- 19:19program and points skeptic. And why are you skeptical?
- 19:22What's your concern? You know, I think that loyalty
- 19:25programs are good for some people.
- 19:28If you are a frequent flyer, as the name implies, then you
- 19:32should probably be participating in a frequent flyer or frequent
- 19:35stayer program. But for the rest of us, they
- 19:38really are marketing programs that are meant to get you to
- 19:41spend more money and to spend money mindlessly on that
- 19:45particular product, whether it's an airline ticket or a hotel
- 19:48room. And I think that on balance,
- 19:50that's bad for customers. So you're saying rewards cloud
- 19:53your judgement when it comes to finding the best price for
- 19:56flights and hotel rooms? Exactly.
- 19:58It short circuits your common sense.
- 20:00So you say, hey, I've, I'm participating in Hilton or Delta
- 20:05or American Airlines. So you start making decisions
- 20:07based on how many points you can get.
- 20:09And where really starts to get crazy is when you have these
- 20:13credit cards where you get one point per every dollar spent.
- 20:16And that's when you start spending a lot more money that
- 20:19you probably wouldn't normally be spending.
- 20:22That's where it gets into crazy territory where you know people
- 20:25are spending a lot to get the points to get the miles and then
- 20:29maybe ending up with a huge balance on their credit card
- 20:32that they can't pay off. Or you get that promotional
- 20:34offer, 70,000 miles, and you sign up for the card and then
- 20:37you realize you only get them if you spend $3000 in the first six
- 20:41months. You find yourself with a clock
- 20:43ticking down, so you go out and buy stuff you wouldn't
- 20:45ordinarily buy because you want those miles.
- 20:48Oh, Herb, we could spend hours talking about loyalty programs,
- 20:52but I'm not going to bore you. But certainly, yes, that's one
- 20:55of the gotchas there is that you get these offers and you think,
- 20:58oh, I'm going to fly somewhere for free.
- 21:01But there's always a catch. And it's like Las Vegas, the
- 21:03house always wins. These programs are created to
- 21:07benefit the airlines and the shareholders.
- 21:10They're not there necessarily to benefit you.
- 21:13So how do you feel about airlines changing the rules when
- 21:15it comes to how miles are accumulated or how many are
- 21:18needed for an upgrade? I don't feel very good about it,
- 21:21to put it mildly. If you want some light reading,
- 21:24you should read the the program agreement for your loyalty
- 21:27program. It tells you that the company
- 21:29can change its rules at any time and for any reason.
- 21:34It'll also tell you that the points don't belong to you, they
- 21:37belong to the company, and that they can confiscate them or
- 21:41close your account for any reason.
- 21:43They don't even need to tell you why.
- 21:45So these are just some of the absurd rules that we agree to
- 21:48when we're participating in a program.
- 21:50If you have any doubts about whether these programs are good
- 21:53for you, read the program agreement that you signed onto
- 21:57when you became a loyal customer and you'll you'll realize very
- 22:01quickly that you're not the beneficiary necessarily.
- 22:04And there are some benefits to an airline credit card.
- 22:06They can provide some nice perks if you fly enough to justify the
- 22:09annual fee, such as free check bags reimbursing you for the
- 22:12cost of applying for TSA pre-check.
- 22:15Some offer companion fares. Yeah.
- 22:17I mean, I don't necessarily buy into the marketing language
- 22:20where they they say, for example, you get a free check
- 22:22bag. I think that you're paying, you
- 22:24know, an annual fee to have the card and that that's one of the
- 22:28benefits of having it. But they're not giving away free
- 22:31check bags necessarily. But yes, you can get some
- 22:34benefits from it if you're going to fly, you know, Alaska
- 22:37Airlines is a good example. Alaska is one of the better
- 22:39airlines, and their loyalty program is one of the least
- 22:42offensive in my mind. If you're going to, you know,
- 22:45fly a lot on Alaska Airlines, Yeah, good idea to participate
- 22:48in its loyalty program. Read the fine print carefully on
- 22:51the credit card because, you know, the cards.
- 22:53That's a totally different animal.
- 22:55You know, you've got the APR you've got to worry about and
- 22:57the annual fee, and it may be a good deal for you and it may
- 23:01not. I mean you, you may get a better
- 23:02deal with your credit union, your bank.
- 23:04So don't automatically assume that just because you can
- 23:06collect miles that it's going to be a good deal for you.
- 23:09We want to remind listeners that you shouldn't even consider a
- 23:12rewards card unless you pay your bill off in full each month.
- 23:15Otherwise you're going to lose money because of the interest.
- 23:18Yet if you can't pay it off, do not spend it because that's when
- 23:22the credit card companies and the airlines, our hotels, really
- 23:26start to do very well. When you've got a balance that
- 23:29hasn't been paid off and the interest starts to accrue,
- 23:32that's just madness. For those who do pay the balance
- 23:35in full each month, Checkbook recommends a rewards card with
- 23:38no annual fee that pays cash back.
- 23:41We feel that money is always better than points you may not
- 23:43be able to use. Would you agree?
- 23:45The problem with points is that the goal posts keep getting
- 23:49moved. So if you can get a flight for
- 23:5225,030 thousand points today, there's no guarantee.
- 23:55Guarantee that in a year's time or two years time, you're going
- 23:58to be able to get the same flight for the same amount of
- 24:00points. In fact, most airlines have
- 24:02already started going to more of a dynamic system where it's
- 24:04based on the demand and you may have to spend a whole lot more.
- 24:08So no, money is always better than points for sure.
- 24:11And by the way, I have a rewards credit card with the airline I
- 24:14travel most often. I have frequent flyer programs
- 24:17with the rest. I don't ever get enough miles to
- 24:20really do anything. But what I do is I give them a
- 24:22charity at the end of the year, like Make a Wish.
- 24:24They can really use them. It's not tax deductible, but it
- 24:26certainly helps out organizations that really need
- 24:28the points or miles. If you travel that much, you
- 24:31should be collecting miles just kind of like as a byproduct of
- 24:34your travels. Whether you use them or not is
- 24:37really up to you. If it makes sense, you should.
- 24:39What you shouldn't do, and I know a lot of people will, they
- 24:42won't have enough miles, so they'll end up buying more miles
- 24:46so that they can get a free ticket.
- 24:47And I'm using free and air quotes.
- 24:49That's also madness. You don't want to be doing that.
- 24:52Only you know, redeem your points if you're going to get
- 24:55something for and if not, I like your idea of donating the
- 24:58points. So where are you off to next?
- 25:01Stockholm, Sweden is my next stop.
- 25:03So Chris, how do people find you on the web?
- 25:05My website is Elliott advocacy.org, so it's ELLIO,
- 25:10TT2L's 2T's advocacy.org. I have a team of people there
- 25:14who help for free. We have a nonprofit
- 25:16organization. We help people when they have
- 25:18consumer problems. You can also read my stories
- 25:20every day on the Elliott Report, which is just elliott.org,
- 25:24Elliot, tt.org. Always great to talk to you and
- 25:28safe travels my friend. OK, thanks.
- 25:30Before we go, here are some other consumer PD episodes that
- 25:33might be of interest #62 the travel show.
- 25:36That's where we talked to Chris #50 finding a credit card that's
- 25:39right for you at #41 finding the best hotel rates.
- 25:44And with that, we've arrived at our gate.
- 25:46We hope you'll rate this episode and follow us on Apple Podcast,
- 25:49Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 25:52Remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 25:55Another way you can support this show is to follow us on Consumer
- 25:58Pedia on Facebook and Instagram and My Consumer Pedia on X,
- 26:03formerly Twitter. I'm Herb Weisbaum.
- 26:05Thanks for listening. Consumer Pedia is a public
- 26:08service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 26:11helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 26:14You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 26:16and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 26:20unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 26:23seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 26:26Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 26:31Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 26:34To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 26:36checkbook.org/consumerpedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 26:40we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 26:43the bottom of the show notes to make a small contribution each
- 26:45month. Consumerpedia.
- 26:48Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.